This is one of the best analysis about pink diamond ,i sea a lot of youtubers that demonize her,and take her action as malicious when put in context clerly show that she just try to save the earth but didn't realize how much her action will hurt others That why for me you are one of the best analisys channel
"Spoiler" During a podcast with the creator of Steven Universe CN randomly started playing scenes from future episodes in the background without planning. They showed a fully animated scene of Yellow and Blue on their knees in front of the crystal gem temple talking to Steven. Blue was wiping away tears and yellow had a concentrating face. A frustrated Bismuth was there on Steven's half destroyed porch and Pearl, Garnet, and Amethyst were there looking shocked. As this had its artwork fully finished this was most likely from the "summer" episodes.
They say everyone deals with grief differently and I can see it with the Diamonds. Blue is sad and, as you said, feels somewhat responsible for what happened to Pink. While Yellow (seemingly) hides her own grief behind sternness and hostility
It seems like Blue and Yellow were Parents and Pink was their daughter. Like when Pink was throwing a tantrum about not having a Colony,Yellow acted like the more stern parent and said No but Blue seems like she'd be the Parent that spoils their child at least thats how I interpret it
The way Blue still thinks of Earth as Pink's world may means she will be the first to agree that it is Steven's world, and to leave Earth alone, under his care.
Irene Kamal Well if you notice when blue was talking to Greg she wasn't crying anymore. Then when she took Greg into her hands, the screen shows Steven still having tears in his eyes.
Blue Dimond and yellow Dimond are two opposite extremes. I believe this will shape the course of what's to come. Even though she had selfish motivations, pink diamond's Rebellion was necessary. The question I'd like to put forth is if someone does something good even if it is for a selfish reason does that make it good or bad. I know that might be a simplistic way of looking at it but it gets my point across.
most if not all good action come from selfish motives. just look at capitalisim. most of all good thing we have, advance medicine, phones, computers, TV, cars, massive food supply. a simple man eats better then a king did 400 years ago. all of those were made out of selfish desires for profit and wealth.
Lucas Martinez I completely agree. I'm not suggesting rose quartz was a overtly bad person. I have heard a lot of people Express that sentiment which completely baffles me.
roiking2749 It is refreshing to see someone express capitalism as a vehicle to channel selfish self-interest into a force for greater good. Sure it has its flaws, but as Winston Churchill pointed out of democracy, it may be the worst, but it is better than anything else. And I agree that Rose/Pink saw something of value in organic life and her subordinates as more than just automatons. Hence her revolution.
1:25 Okay I just want to say something about this. This is Blue Diamond before the “shattering” of Pink Diamond. She looked different, and resembles her mural depiction here. One of the major differences between her mural depiction and her current appearance is her hair. However, in this shot you can see that her hair isn’t white and connected near her neck area. It would look more like her mural here. I think that while grieving over the death of PD, her appearance changed. Grief took its toll on BD, and she hasn’t been the same. This all makes sense, but what doesn’t is her gem shape. In this shot her gem shape looks WAYYYYY different than it does now. That might just be a continuity error (and if it is it really bugs me), but maybe she changed it for some reason after the loss of Pink? I’m really not sure, but I hope it gets explained. Edit: I was thinking about this, and maybe Garnet just got the gem shape/cut of Blue Diamond wrong in this flashback? She isn’t exactly a reliable source, and she hasn’t seen Blue Diamond in a long time. It could just be that Garnet got a little mixed up or something.
Yeah, I'm thinking so too. The Moon's flashback shows the dynamic between the three Diamonds. Look, Pink standing like a scolded child, Blue leaning toward her and Yellow standing with her back straight and toward Pink. I believe, and will until proven otherwise, that it was that Moon conversation that cracked poor Blue, I mean, it was the moment when she basically told her little sister that no harm can fall upon her from Rose Quartz and wham, shortly after Pink was "shattered". Considering Gem's great memory capabilities... I bet she's often playing it in her head.
This was the sort of thing .Pink diamond wanted this to happen .The whole of gem culture needed to change to stop the war and it worked . Not as she had hoped but still. But the corruption beam caught her unaware .
So I have a few things I just wanna dump here, I'm sorry •No one was responsible for shattering pink diamond, greg is the real suspect here😂 •Pink was living two different lives, she changed her appearance and her name to be free from everything •I was confused about how pink was able to switch from pink to being rose the rebel and still be able to take care of her colony and make it believable that Rose Quartz was a different gem but then I thought that pearl probably shape shifted to look like rose and play the role as the rebel gem? •Steven is technically pink diamond because he has her gem but I think he's his own person and the diamonds need to understand that Ok sorry bye
Great stuff. I'm with you save for one point. Yellow doesn't feel responsible for the shattering because by then she'd figured out that it was staged, and that Pink was their enemy. However that also means she would believe that she White and Yellow unintentionally corrupted Pink anyway in the diamond attack.
I just tracked her other channel and it lists New Zealand, and now I listen to her again, I can hear it, and that also answers why I hear bits that sound Australian - the two accents are quite similar, but differ in some areas, including vowels. (And I say that from an Australian perspective.) I still think her Rs sound odd, even compared to other New Zealand accents I have heard, but maybe she comes from a different area, like the South Island instead of the North, where Auckland and Wellington are.
I don't know about that... Steven is learning, so he will eventually learn responsibility. Was Rose able to? It seems not, but being half-human may make Steven more able to understand the things Rose couldn't.
I have a theory about pink diamond / roses plan to cure corruption. It's not fully formed but I'm still working on it. I believe Steven being hybrid of both gem and human is the key. I also believe the answer as to how this will come about is hidden within the locked chest. That's as far as I've gotten on the theory so far.
Brandon Powell I... Hope it's not the case because, unless like you said, it's related to Steven (Wich I doubt 😕), why waited to show the crystal gem what was the cure when she could have done it already?
Claire Aquos Stevens power are connected to his emotions and state of mind. Perhaps he has to fully understand and accept who and what he is in order for it to work. Rose was obviously very secretive and she would have no reason to tell the other gems about it since it is Stevens task to take on. The theory isn't air tight and I'm not 100 percent convinced of it myself. it's still a fun idea to entertain none the less.
Brandon Powell What I mean is how does Rose knew that Steven powers would be a little differents from hers? I know she kept many secrets but unless there is a other gem hybride, I don't think she knew what would happen to Steven...
(Sorry for my bad english) You know, I have a theory that Blue and Yellow Diamond could'nt actually take her away from her colony: The only one who could to that was "White" Diamond, but when Pink tries to talk to her, she said exacly what we heard in the story of Garnet when "Rose" tries to convice "Pink" to save the organic life on earth... You get what I mean? So, since she could'nt argue with her, she believes that she would listen to Blue and Yellow, but "Blue and Yellow don't Care they never have" (That's probably what Pearl was trying to Say: That Yellow and Blue could argue with White) . So, she tries to be to finds excuse to get rid of the earth and it end up with Pink faking her death. Also, that makes me believe that White Diamond will the opposite of Pink: A person who think about the survival of the gem species (Because try to protect the organic life and let the gem being themself is basecly being against making gems... After all, gems are made, not born). So yeah, in other words, White Diamond should be a gray character who only wants to protect the gems species but the way she does this (Like destroy the gem who are consider defective) is questionable.
Anyone that has older and/or younger siblings understands Pink. I have older and younger siblings and I was once the child demanding my own room and things my older siblings had like backpacks and lunchboxes or ‘cool’ games/toys and when it was my turn to get the ‘cool’ stuff my younger siblings wanted them too. Pink wanted to be like her Mothers (if Stevonnie dreaming Yellow up as her Mom is anything to go by) and I know I wanted to be like my Mom when I was younger and she had a different idea of what things would be like if she had her own colony. She probably thought if she had one she would get respect from YD and maybe BD, kinda like if you have certain clothes and school gear you’re cool at school (I know I was proud of my LLBean backpack even though it only had one big zipper and wasn’t as cool as the other LLBean backpacks at school because I still had one).
Very interesting video. I feel so bad for Blue Diamond, she’s going through so much; and it all happened because Pink wanted to abandon her duties. She didn’t even consider how her actions could affect others. I understand why she rebelled, and I know she had good intentions, but she certainly approached it the wrong way. Excellent comentary.
this idea needs to die... it is just such a misrepresentation of the fact that its a joke. she was never running from any "duties" heck she took on being a double agent which would have been far more work then what she normal do. she then went on to fight a war against a much larger force. she didn'r abandon her duties she saw they were unfit to be done and active worked to undermine a evil system
She wanted to run her colony HER way. The Diamonds refused. She was not getting satisfaction working within the system, so she created her alter-ego to change it from without. That is not abandoning her responsibilities, that is rejecting rigid top-down authoritarianism(ie despotism and dictatorship).
Claire Aquos I did some research, I think she's supposed to represent Virgin Mary (since many virgin mary paintings have the same dark blue scarf and such) But those sad eyes with the dark bottom lashes look very familiar to a famous painting. I don't know what.
Wow, This is really bad. I'm happy that i was right about rose being pink Diamond, but with all the episodes we've been through? Suddenly rose is turning all Heinous
Tetagonic Well, like Rebecca said, the revelation will make question the crystal gem identity... Also, it could bring more backstory on the diamond and maybe more knowledge about the gems in generale...
Both Pink and Blue Diamond were very close and they love each other like sisters or Mother and daughter. That's why Pink was very important not just for the Diamonds but also to Blue as well.
Dave102693 I know, I was just saying that I hope we see a real one unbubbled. For all we know a real rose quartz could act completely different from the one we thought we new which was really Pink Dimand.
Anyone else think that Pink Diamond regrets the stunt she pulled? When Steven thought he was crying Blue Diamond's tears, he was actually crying Pink's tears? Maybe as rash and impulsive Pink was, she probably didn't think about the about the consequences and how all of this would've affected her sisters. She probably didn't think about how much pain she would've caused because of her absence. As she said in the video, Pink never thought about the negative consequences of her actions.
Hi I got a kinda theory maybe you wanna look at . I noticed that the gem Personalities are matched to the spiritual stone meanings but also I tried picking up and trying to learn tarot again . I kinda Noticed that pd kinda looks like a Harlequin which is sometimes used as pic of the number 0 card . It means a start of a journey and compare the fool to a new born baby going threw life . And blue diamond looks a lot like the empress card. Which mean motherhood . Yd reminds me of the chariot card which mean willpower and Determination. I thinking pd story might be the major arcana cards story , of the fool going threw life meeting each card and changing and because more wiser. It’s just a thought hope you take a look at it .
Fictional Crystals, if the Diamonds and Lapis, and Peridot and Greg, find out about Rose and Pink both being the same one being, what would their reactions be? How would Lapis view Steven? What would Yellow and Blue think about Rose/Pink and Steven, and the Crystal Gems?
People talk about how Rose was an established threat for years before Pink Diamond’s “shattering”. However, the one question no one seems to be asking is: how the heck did Pearl go from pale pink hair to her current pale orange hair? We know Gems can change the colors of their clothing, as the Amethysts and Jaspers in the human zoo wear blue uniforms, but Pearl in her mindscape has very obvious _pink_ hair, and in Garnet’s storybook style, Pearl is almost always depicted as having a teal color. Its strange, no?
Im an amythest as well. You must be born in February 💜 I dont know much about what garnet ilor the others. But very cool your mind went there too ♒ I immediately referenced the show's characters with birthstones, chakras, and zodiac natures/elements .
OMG GUYS BLUE DIAMOND DIDNT USE HER POWERS TO MAKE STEVEN CRY! IT WAS ROSE/PINK'S EMOTIONS THROUGH STEVEN! PINK/ROSE FELT SORRY ABOUT MAKING BLUE SO SAD! SHE FELT THAT SHE WAS TERRIBLY LYING TO HER, WANTED TO TELL THE TRUTH, BUT COULDENT TELL HER BECAUSE OF HER NEW LIFE!
Honestly I'm still confused as to why yellow diamond showed up as a human (with the hair and everything) when stevonia was pink. Why is she completely yellow now? 😭😭
well this is in fact something that goes on a lot in REAL life. Older siblings for what ever reason have a very narcsissitic streak sometimes. And yellow and blue are huge NARCS... they wanted to go about their buisness but didnt really want anything to do with pink. So eventually she felt as a lot of younger siblings subjected to this feel. I dont mean anything to them all they care about is what THEY want I might as well not be here they WILL Be HAPPIER if im gone. Sadly in real life .. we cant stage our death's like pink did.. Suicides and deaths often result from this.. as do many runaways. blue and yellow acted like a couple of narc bitches and so pink decided to run. of course being the narcs they are.. yellow and blue couldnt accept that their treatment of their younger sibling caused this. Of course they were "perfect" so how could they be at fault? It was easier to start a war than admit they hurt her.
Blue Diamond at least seems to understand herself that she played a role in what went down when she mournfully says "I should've done more." Don't know if Yellow Diamond feels the same way, but then again she seems to be the type to bottle up her grief more then anything (to maintain her "perfect" image as a Diamond).
Since Rose is pink diamond I have a theory. Jasper was angry about that shattering So Jasper cared about Rose so she should hate Pearl because she changed to Rose and pink diamond wanted to get herself shattered because she said " I can't exactly shatter myself" then pearl shattered her. Then there's my theory. 😄
seriously I wonder if pink is cruel as the other diamonds there will be no rebellion at all ! without rose, pearl won't be rebel, garnet won't exist, amethyst will become one of the off color in homeworld and steven don't exist🤔
Yep. And why she only looked sad when Blue Zircon finally worked through the logic that Yellow herself had worked through some time before (Still had to poof her for opening the can of worms, but not in anger). Also why she blew up at Green Zircon for acting like a desirable outcome had just happened. One of those, "Oh you are just too stupid to live" moments.
jajwritersblock, I don't think she figured out around then. I think she got suspicious about it during the trial, look at her reaction to Steven showing his gem.
if she did yellow probably would be like, "see I told you you weren't ready." and take the colony from pink. i also had a thought of why didn't pink just declare Independence from home-world, but then i realized if she actually committed mutiny as a diamond and piss home-world off, they would literally blow up earth with pink on it.
ya. a gem war but with pd as pd. only the cluster can instantly harm the earth. we haven't seen anything that says home world can destroy the earth instantly. i mean now they mite have something but back then no way.
then pd and her army will try and stop it. aka war. pd being rose doesn't change the story for me. mostly because im not sure what a colony means. is it really something you can abandon? is it like a house full of children? can they take the colony back? i really don't like not knowing things like this in the show.
abandoning a colony probably would be seen as an sign of weakness for the diamonds and thus wouldn't allow it to happen, even if they have to take it from her/make her out to be a villain. But if there was a guerrilla war specifically against pink, like in the shows timeline, then the other diamonds cant just wipe them out since they might end up attacking pink and her army. Also I don't think pink on her own in this alt timeline would have the resources to stop a full blown invasion/attempt to destroy the earth, since she didn't even have an army until she got Earth. I feel like part of the idea with the actual war was that pink would ask to barrow solders from the other diamonds, then rose would try converting them to Cristal gems. But these are all shots in the dark, I bet pearl is going to give us a lot of answers the next episode.
Too come in contention this is pretty much blue diamond's responsibility of being her fault in the first place. pink diamond recruiting back to the diamonds only asking them to back off a little bit just for her to save the human life form beings on HER colony of her own existence. the first off, blue diamond Complaining of too many amounts of organics, then their cites were too hard to dismantle. of the way her personality was now, looks nothing the same how it is in present of pink diamond's shattered is today. this is much of blue diamond's fault after the way she treated her of not doing what she wanted even though she's a dam diamond after all in the first time of place happen. so as pretty much, yellow diamond didn't even do anything, she just stood back and let blue diamond responded to her. after her shattering, she's been crying for years of pink diamond was shatter. of conclusion blue diamond wouldn't of been emotinal grieving all these years of heartbreaking if she would just let pink diamond save those innocent humans beings on her colony. so yes I agree this theory, blue diamond complaining and nagging of pink diamond's objects forms of human life is what intentionally is what exactly made pink diamond terminated her self with along a little help pearl as rose quartz.
Technically it is Blue Diamond’s fault because she and Yellow Diamond and White Diamond killed Pink Diamond, Rose Quartz, when they took revenge after Pink’s supposed death. Sorry if this comment was annoying or wrong in what’s fact.
Fictional Crystals, I’d love too make you a new intro and new art *for free* and once you receive you can decide if you want too use it or not, if you have Instagram I can message you privately about this.
It’s funny that when Greg and blue diamond met, they were grieving about the same person.
Not really that funny since pink and rose are gone.😢
This is one of the best analysis about pink diamond ,i sea a lot of youtubers that demonize her,and take her action as malicious when put in context clerly show that she just try to save the earth but didn't realize how much her action will hurt others
That why for me you are one of the best analisys channel
it is nice to a YT Steven universe analisys channel make sense for once
dexdrako i know,right?
under garden also checked Lea C. Vid about pink she also looked at pink in anoyher perspective i guarantee u her video is satisfying
Clarence Viduya thank you
under garden yw
Poor Blue :(
I'm curious to see how she's going to react when she learns the truth... I can tell Yellow will be extremely angry
Unfortunately this was leaked.
Joshua Skidds what do you mean?
"Spoiler" During a podcast with the creator of Steven Universe CN randomly started playing scenes from future episodes in the background without planning. They showed a fully animated scene of Yellow and Blue on their knees in front of the crystal gem temple talking to Steven. Blue was wiping away tears and yellow had a concentrating face. A frustrated Bismuth was there on Steven's half destroyed porch and Pearl, Garnet, and Amethyst were there looking shocked. As this had its artwork fully finished this was most likely from the "summer" episodes.
Joshua Skidds huh. Cant wait for that episode
"Spoiler" th-cam.com/video/AEk4CP2sFEw/w-d-xo.html
Blue has always been my favorite diamond. For a lot of reasons. It's hard not to want to take care of her everytime she appears onscreen.
They say everyone deals with grief differently and I can see it with the Diamonds.
Blue is sad and, as you said, feels somewhat responsible for what happened to Pink. While Yellow (seemingly) hides her own grief behind sternness and hostility
Why does this hurts so much? Poor Blue :,(
Imagine this
Steven: Rose was Pink Diamond!
White Diamond chuckles.
WD: I know.
a person oh lol XD
if anyone would secretly know, it would be her.
also who wants to bet that white is planing/doing something that's going make blue and yellow switch sides?
I would die laughing 😂
It seems like Blue and Yellow were Parents and Pink was their daughter. Like when Pink was throwing a tantrum about not having a Colony,Yellow acted like the more stern parent and said No but Blue seems like she'd be the Parent that spoils their child at least thats how I interpret it
What would white be? the grandmother.
Does not make sense
@@galewallblanco8184 a overly controlling parent
Blue should've recognized Pink's voice when Pink as Rose Quartz attacked her
The way Blue still thinks of Earth as Pink's world may means she will be the first to agree that it is Steven's world, and to leave Earth alone, under his care.
When Steven sees Blue Diamond in Korea do you think he was really crying Blue’s tears or maybe... pink diamond’s?
Irene Kamal Well if you notice when blue was talking to Greg she wasn't crying anymore. Then when she took Greg into her hands, the screen shows Steven still having tears in his eyes.
Blue Dimond and yellow Dimond are two opposite extremes. I believe this will shape the course of what's to come. Even though she had selfish motivations, pink diamond's Rebellion was necessary. The question I'd like to put forth is if someone does something good even if it is for a selfish reason does that make it good or bad. I know that might be a simplistic way of looking at it but it gets my point across.
most if not all good action come from selfish motives. just look at capitalisim. most of all good thing we have, advance medicine, phones, computers, TV, cars, massive food supply. a simple man eats better then a king did 400 years ago. all of those were made out of selfish desires for profit and wealth.
roiking2740 Very good point. Happy to hear your thoughts on the matter.
Keep in mind that an act of selfishness isn't necessarily an evil one. If that weren't true, we'd all be bad people.
Lucas Martinez I completely agree. I'm not suggesting rose quartz was a overtly bad person. I have heard a lot of people Express that sentiment which completely baffles me.
roiking2749 It is refreshing to see someone express capitalism as a vehicle to channel selfish self-interest into a force for greater good. Sure it has its flaws, but as Winston Churchill pointed out of democracy, it may be the worst, but it is better than anything else.
And I agree that Rose/Pink saw something of value in organic life and her subordinates as more than just automatons. Hence her revolution.
"Pink Diamond's shattering didn't break Pink Diamond
It *broke* Blue Diamond."
That got me.
1:25 Okay I just want to say something about this. This is Blue Diamond before the “shattering” of Pink Diamond. She looked different, and resembles her mural depiction here. One of the major differences between her mural depiction and her current appearance is her hair. However, in this shot you can see that her hair isn’t white and connected near her neck area. It would look more like her mural here. I think that while grieving over the death of PD, her appearance changed. Grief took its toll on BD, and she hasn’t been the same. This all makes sense, but what doesn’t is her gem shape. In this shot her gem shape looks WAYYYYY different than it does now. That might just be a continuity error (and if it is it really bugs me), but maybe she changed it for some reason after the loss of Pink? I’m really not sure, but I hope it gets explained.
Edit: I was thinking about this, and maybe Garnet just got the gem shape/cut of Blue Diamond wrong in this flashback? She isn’t exactly a reliable source, and she hasn’t seen Blue Diamond in a long time. It could just be that Garnet got a little mixed up or something.
Yeah, I'm thinking so too. The Moon's flashback shows the dynamic between the three Diamonds. Look, Pink standing like a scolded child, Blue leaning toward her and Yellow standing with her back straight and toward Pink. I believe, and will until proven otherwise, that it was that Moon conversation that cracked poor Blue, I mean, it was the moment when she basically told her little sister that no harm can fall upon her from Rose Quartz and wham, shortly after Pink was "shattered". Considering Gem's great memory capabilities... I bet she's often playing it in her head.
This was the sort of thing .Pink diamond wanted this to happen .The whole of gem culture needed to change to stop the war and it worked . Not as she had hoped but still. But the corruption beam caught her unaware .
Pink Diamond always mentions Blue and Yellow. But does she even know if White Diamond exists? And maybe vice versa?
Fuzzy Paws Have you forgot the corromption part? White was there
Claire Aquos
You mean corruption? I didn't think of that.
Fuzzy Paws Yes...
Maybe she had very little to do with White. Blue and Yellow were the ones raising her while White was dealing with other things.
We need more information. We don't even know what Blue and Yellow's relationships with White Diamond are like yet.
I've been in that place of blue, tough place 😢
Anyway keep these videos rolling 😁
Great analysis of Blue Diamond!
So I have a few things I just wanna dump here, I'm sorry
•No one was responsible for shattering pink diamond, greg is the real suspect here😂
•Pink was living two different lives, she changed her appearance and her name to be free from everything
•I was confused about how pink was able to switch from pink to being rose the rebel and still be able to take care of her colony and make it believable that Rose Quartz was a different gem but then I thought that pearl probably shape shifted to look like rose and play the role as the rebel gem?
•Steven is technically pink diamond because he has her gem but I think he's his own person and the diamonds need to understand that
Ok sorry bye
I have the same questions about how they managed the double life period.
Agreed.
Great stuff. I'm with you save for one point. Yellow doesn't feel responsible for the shattering because by then she'd figured out that it was staged, and that Pink was their enemy. However that also means she would believe that she White and Yellow unintentionally corrupted Pink anyway in the diamond attack.
I love your accent!
And she sounds serious
Chidiebere Uchime
She sounds like an aristocrat, honestly.
I find it confusing, because I hear bits in it that sound Australian but other parts that don't.
Mimi Sardinia she sounds aussie to me.
I just tracked her other channel and it lists New Zealand, and now I listen to her again, I can hear it, and that also answers why I hear bits that sound Australian - the two accents are quite similar, but differ in some areas, including vowels. (And I say that from an Australian perspective.)
I still think her Rs sound odd, even compared to other New Zealand accents I have heard, but maybe she comes from a different area, like the South Island instead of the North, where Auckland and Wellington are.
This just proves that Pink knew nothing about her family, she thought she knew how they would react but at the end she knew nothing.
You could literally cuss me out and I would still be mesmerized by the voice
It's weird that the diamonds were just trying to be good parents, but paid the price.
Pink Diamond doesn’t even know how to be responsible.
I don't know about that... Steven is learning, so he will eventually learn responsibility. Was Rose able to? It seems not, but being half-human may make Steven more able to understand the things Rose couldn't.
Mimi Sardinia he was curious to know the truth about Gem stuff
And he has more ability to be sympathetic than Rose does, so he is going to be a better Pink Diamond than she was.
I have a theory about pink diamond / roses plan to cure corruption. It's not fully formed but I'm still working on it. I believe Steven being hybrid of both gem and human is the key. I also believe the answer as to how this will come about is hidden within the locked chest. That's as far as I've gotten on the theory so far.
Brandon Powell I... Hope it's not the case because, unless like you said, it's related to Steven (Wich I doubt 😕), why waited to show the crystal gem what was the cure when she could have done it already?
Claire Aquos Stevens power are connected to his emotions and state of mind. Perhaps he has to fully understand and accept who and what he is in order for it to work. Rose was obviously very secretive and she would have no reason to tell the other gems about it since it is Stevens task to take on. The theory isn't air tight and I'm not 100 percent convinced of it myself. it's still a fun idea to entertain none the less.
Brandon Powell What I mean is how does Rose knew that Steven powers would be a little differents from hers? I know she kept many secrets but unless there is a other gem hybride, I don't think she knew what would happen to Steven...
Claire Aquos Perhaps it has something to do with what she valued most about Humanity. And that is human's ability to change and adapt.
(Sorry for my bad english)
You know, I have a theory that Blue and Yellow Diamond could'nt actually take her away from her colony: The only one who could to that was "White" Diamond, but when Pink tries to talk to her, she said exacly what we heard in the story of Garnet when "Rose" tries to convice "Pink" to save the organic life on earth... You get what I mean?
So, since she could'nt argue with her, she believes that she would listen to Blue and Yellow, but "Blue and Yellow don't Care they never have" (That's probably what Pearl was trying to Say: That Yellow and Blue could argue with White) .
So, she tries to be to finds excuse to get rid of the earth and it end up with Pink faking her death.
Also, that makes me believe that White Diamond will the opposite of Pink: A person who think about the survival of the gem species (Because try to protect the organic life and let the gem being themself is basecly being against making gems... After all, gems are made, not born).
So yeah, in other words, White Diamond should be a gray character who only wants to protect the gems species but the way she does this (Like destroy the gem who are consider defective) is questionable.
Your English is GREAT!
Claire Aquos So is your theory
Im Original Thanks 😊
I agree. Garnet's story was true, but it was White rather than "pink" that Rose was talking to.
And I agree your used of English was perfect.
Anyone that has older and/or younger siblings understands Pink. I have older and younger siblings and I was once the child demanding my own room and things my older siblings had like backpacks and lunchboxes or ‘cool’ games/toys and when it was my turn to get the ‘cool’ stuff my younger siblings wanted them too.
Pink wanted to be like her Mothers (if Stevonnie dreaming Yellow up as her Mom is anything to go by) and I know I wanted to be like my Mom when I was younger and she had a different idea of what things would be like if she had her own colony. She probably thought if she had one she would get respect from YD and maybe BD, kinda like if you have certain clothes and school gear you’re cool at school (I know I was proud of my LLBean backpack even though it only had one big zipper and wasn’t as cool as the other LLBean backpacks at school because I still had one).
Very interesting video. I feel so bad for Blue Diamond, she’s going through so much; and it all happened because Pink wanted to abandon her duties. She didn’t even consider how her actions could affect others. I understand why she rebelled, and I know she had good intentions, but she certainly approached it the wrong way. Excellent comentary.
this idea needs to die... it is just such a misrepresentation of the fact that its a joke. she was never running from any "duties" heck she took on being a double agent which would have been far more work then what she normal do. she then went on to fight a war against a much larger force.
she didn'r abandon her duties she saw they were unfit to be done and active worked to undermine a evil system
She wanted to run her colony HER way. The Diamonds refused. She was not getting satisfaction working within the system, so she created her alter-ego to change it from without. That is not abandoning her responsibilities, that is rejecting rigid top-down authoritarianism(ie despotism and dictatorship).
You are aware that blue diamond is a fascist dictator right?
Exactly blue feels responsible for what happened to her sister pink
This video has some super scary suggestions for other videos...
"The shattering of Pink diamond did not break Pink diamond, it broke Blue Diamond" true🤔
I kinda feel blue diamond resembles a famous painting. I can't find out which. Gotta go research.
Meow nover Mona Lisa?
Claire Aquos I did some research, I think she's supposed to represent Virgin Mary (since many virgin mary paintings have the same dark blue scarf and such)
But those sad eyes with the dark bottom lashes look very familiar to a famous painting. I don't know what.
Meow nover Oh ok
Wow, This is really bad. I'm happy that i was right about rose being pink Diamond, but with all the episodes we've been through? Suddenly rose is turning all Heinous
Tetagonic Well, like Rebecca said, the revelation will make question the crystal gem identity... Also, it could bring more backstory on the diamond and maybe more knowledge about the gems in generale...
Guys-
What if blue diamond tried to shatter herself after pink’s shattering?
That’s why she looks different in the answer
Both Pink and Blue Diamond were very close and they love each other like sisters or Mother and daughter. That's why Pink was very important not just for the Diamonds but also to Blue as well.
I think your voice sounds like Lapis.
You just made that up did you
Chibi Lancelot no , actually ...
lapissed No, sorry.
Kamil Aliev That's only my opinion, you are free to disagree.
Chibi Lancelot Hell no where did you get that idea
I love your theories and I was wondering if you could make a video about voltron season 6 predictions?
I hope we see a real rose quartz soon, maybe we will get a episode about Steven going back to the zoo.
Diana Shaw they are bubbled in PD's room at the Zoo.
Dave102693 I know, I was just saying that I hope we see a real one unbubbled. For all we know a real rose quartz could act completely different from the one we thought we new which was really Pink Dimand.
Before PD's death, BD was fierce like YD but after PD's death, BD became _calm_
Poor Blue, if only she knew the truth. All those millenia of wasted tears and unnecessary mourning...
Pink said that yellow and blue didn't care, but boy she looked at it wrong
Your character looks like I human versions of blue diamond
Blue diamon has been grieving the death Pink diamond but little she know that she's still alive.
Anyone else think that Pink Diamond regrets the stunt she pulled? When Steven thought he was crying Blue Diamond's tears, he was actually crying Pink's tears? Maybe as rash and impulsive Pink was, she probably didn't think about the about the consequences and how all of this would've affected her sisters. She probably didn't think about how much pain she would've caused because of her absence. As she said in the video, Pink never thought about the negative consequences of her actions.
are the images at 1:50 supposed to be yellow and blue(cuz of the hood) >_>
Oh gosh, early, so much pressure to say something clever....
Um
Thomas Walder garnet is a fusion!
What a twist!
is that an Amythest pun or...
"early"
"so much pressure"
Hi I got a kinda theory maybe you wanna look at . I noticed that the gem Personalities are matched to the spiritual stone meanings but also I tried picking up and trying to learn tarot again . I kinda Noticed that pd kinda looks like a Harlequin which is sometimes used as pic of the number 0 card . It means a start of a journey and compare the fool to a new born baby going threw life . And blue diamond looks a lot like the empress card. Which mean motherhood . Yd reminds me of the chariot card which mean willpower and Determination. I thinking pd story might be the major arcana cards story , of the fool going threw life meeting each card and changing and because more wiser. It’s just a thought hope you take a look at it .
Ok. Jesus. Im crying cause of this theory.
Just like a mother mourning over a child...
Fictional Crystals, if the Diamonds and Lapis, and Peridot and Greg, find out about Rose and Pink both being the same one being, what would their reactions be? How would Lapis view Steven? What would Yellow and Blue think about Rose/Pink and Steven, and the Crystal Gems?
I'm on time!
Your voice sounded like a voice program like loquendo??? So uncanny.
People talk about how Rose was an established threat for years before Pink Diamond’s “shattering”. However, the one question no one seems to be asking is: how the heck did Pearl go from pale pink hair to her current pale orange hair? We know Gems can change the colors of their clothing, as the Amethysts and Jaspers in the human zoo wear blue uniforms, but Pearl in her mindscape has very obvious _pink_ hair, and in Garnet’s storybook style, Pearl is almost always depicted as having a teal color. Its strange, no?
Im an amythest as well. You must be born in February 💜 I dont know much about what garnet ilor the others. But very cool your mind went there too ♒ I immediately referenced the show's characters with birthstones, chakras, and zodiac natures/elements .
Oh! If Steven could show them the truth! [...] He does have the right gem for it... if he can flip it back.
Any theories why blue’s accent was so prominent this time?
i think it's just cuz she wasn't speaking as softly as she normally does
OMG GUYS BLUE DIAMOND DIDNT USE HER POWERS TO MAKE STEVEN CRY! IT WAS ROSE/PINK'S EMOTIONS THROUGH STEVEN! PINK/ROSE FELT SORRY ABOUT MAKING BLUE SO SAD! SHE FELT THAT SHE WAS TERRIBLY LYING TO HER, WANTED TO TELL THE TRUTH, BUT COULDENT TELL HER BECAUSE OF HER NEW LIFE!
Blue diamond is my fav villain and character because well i feel similar to her always a mess X3
On point.
Honestly I'm still confused as to why yellow diamond showed up as a human (with the hair and everything) when stevonia was pink. Why is she completely yellow now? 😭😭
well this is in fact something that goes on a lot in REAL life.
Older siblings for what ever reason have a very narcsissitic streak sometimes.
And yellow and blue are huge NARCS... they wanted to go about their buisness but didnt really want anything to do with pink.
So eventually she felt as a lot of younger siblings subjected to this feel.
I dont mean anything to them
all they care about is what THEY want
I might as well not be here
they WILL Be HAPPIER if im gone.
Sadly in real life .. we cant stage our death's like pink did..
Suicides and deaths often result from this.. as do many runaways.
blue and yellow acted like a couple of narc bitches and so pink decided to run.
of course being the narcs they are.. yellow and blue couldnt accept that their treatment of their younger
sibling caused this.
Of course they were "perfect" so how could they be at fault?
It was easier to start a war than admit they hurt her.
Blue Diamond at least seems to understand herself that she played a role in what went down when she mournfully says "I should've done more." Don't know if Yellow Diamond feels the same way, but then again she seems to be the type to bottle up her grief more then anything (to maintain her "perfect" image as a Diamond).
Pink diamond caused a shitstorm in the SU fandom
I thought the answer took place after pink was shattered
How Will Steven tell the diamonds that pink never got shattered
Yay! Another Theory from Fictional Crystals!
Since Rose is pink diamond I have a theory. Jasper was angry about that shattering
So Jasper cared about Rose so she should hate Pearl because she changed to Rose and pink diamond wanted to get herself shattered because she said " I can't exactly shatter myself" then pearl shattered her. Then there's my theory. 😄
Blue diamond as a Crystal Gem?
I feel bad at jasper
What happened if blue diamond 💎
Reaction if she knows pink to rose to Steven ?🤔
Hmmm what if pink diamond didnt fake her shattering and it was all real and pink wasn’t rose
seriously I wonder if pink is cruel as the other diamonds there will be no rebellion at all ! without rose, pearl won't be rebel, garnet won't exist, amethyst will become one of the off color in homeworld and steven don't exist🤔
What if yellow knew all along
Maybe not all along, but I'm completely convinced she figured it out before That Will be All.
jajwritersblock it would make sense for yellow to want to hurry up the trial before listening to Steven (Rose) defense.
Yep. And why she only looked sad when Blue Zircon finally worked through the logic that Yellow herself had worked through some time before (Still had to poof her for opening the can of worms, but not in anger). Also why she blew up at Green Zircon for acting like a desirable outcome had just happened. One of those, "Oh you are just too stupid to live" moments.
jajwritersblock I am so glad that I'm not the only one who thinks that
jajwritersblock, I don't think she figured out around then. I think she got suspicious about it during the trial, look at her reaction to Steven showing his gem.
why didn't pink diamond just told her gems to stop colonizing?
if she did yellow probably would be like, "see I told you you weren't ready." and take the colony from pink.
i also had a thought of why didn't pink just declare Independence from home-world, but then i realized if she actually committed mutiny as a diamond and piss home-world off, they would literally blow up earth with pink on it.
ya. a gem war but with pd as pd. only the cluster can instantly harm the earth.
we haven't seen anything that says home world can destroy the earth instantly.
i mean now they mite have something but back then no way.
they could of strapped rockets to the moon and push it into the earth
then pd and her army will try and stop it. aka war. pd being rose doesn't change the story for me.
mostly because im not sure what a colony means.
is it really something you can abandon?
is it like a house full of children?
can they take the colony back?
i really don't like not knowing things like this in the show.
abandoning a colony probably would be seen as an sign of weakness for the diamonds and thus wouldn't allow it to happen, even if they have to take it from her/make her out to be a villain. But if there was a guerrilla war specifically against pink, like in the shows timeline, then the other diamonds cant just wipe them out since they might end up attacking pink and her army. Also I don't think pink on her own in this alt timeline would have the resources to stop a full blown invasion/attempt to destroy the earth, since she didn't even have an army until she got Earth. I feel like part of the idea with the actual war was that pink would ask to barrow solders from the other diamonds, then rose would try converting them to Cristal gems. But these are all shots in the dark, I bet pearl is going to give us a lot of answers the next episode.
Too come in contention this is pretty much blue diamond's responsibility of being her fault in the first place. pink diamond recruiting back to the diamonds only asking them to back off a little bit just for her to save the human life form beings on HER colony of her own existence. the first off, blue diamond Complaining of too many amounts of organics, then their cites were too hard to dismantle. of the way her personality was now, looks nothing the same how it is in present of pink diamond's shattered is today. this is much of blue diamond's fault after the way she treated her of not doing what she wanted even though she's a dam diamond after all in the first time of place happen. so as pretty much, yellow diamond didn't even do anything, she just stood back and let blue diamond responded to her. after her shattering, she's been crying for years of pink diamond was shatter. of conclusion blue diamond wouldn't of been emotinal grieving all these years of heartbreaking if she would just let pink diamond save those innocent humans beings on her colony. so yes I agree this theory, blue diamond complaining and nagging of pink diamond's objects forms of human life is what intentionally is what exactly made pink diamond terminated her self with along a little help pearl as rose quartz.
So pink diamond never existed? It was just rose?
Technically it is Blue Diamond’s fault because she and Yellow Diamond and White Diamond killed Pink Diamond, Rose Quartz, when they took revenge after Pink’s supposed death.
Sorry if this comment was annoying or wrong in what’s fact.
Question is pink diamond rose quartz!!!?!?!?!
yeah sorry for the spoilers
No, she's really Steve Urkel
I'm early!
Rose is pink Diamond
Sounds like you say pony than colony
I love Steven universe
Feeling the blues? XD
Fictional Crystals, I’d love too make you a new intro and new art *for free* and once you receive you can decide if you want too use it or not, if you have Instagram I can message you privately about this.
Miss.. You could go into narration or voice acting professionally.
Pink is such a brats. She doesn't know how to be responsibility. Poor blue. :(
We have only see Pink from two memories. There is more to the story.
Peridot SU
I disagree with you. But I have no evidence to back myself up yet.
Rip this channel
#100 like :)