History of Pakistan 1947 we cannot live with hindus 1953 we cannot live with ahmedis 1971 we cannot live with Bengalis 1980s we cannot live with shia 1990s we cannot live with muhajirs 2000s we cannot live with pashtoons 2020s labbek labbek labbek sabke sar tan se juda
*Pakistani confession* :- 1) 1947 - We can't live without Britain. 2) 1955- 2011- we can't live without USA. 3) 2011 to 2030- we can't live without China. *** 2022*** :- *we can't live without loans from IMF, WB, ADB, US, Russia, CHINA, UZBEKISTAN, SAUDI, UAE, REMITTANCE etc etc n etc* ...
Accidentally came across to this video, trust me, I as a British Indian, I have total respect for Dr. Prof. Hoodbhoy, may God bless him with lots of happiness and good health. He is one of the best brains that our common civilization has ever produced.🙏🙏🙏
Cannot believe how honest this interview is!! What a wonderful and wise person Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy is! Wish we had more such strong and inspiring voices on both sides of the border. Hope India and Pakistan will come together in our lifetimes. That is the only solution to many of our problems and challenges.
In 1947 my Guru Maharaj told some one that time will come in your life time that there will not be any nation called Pakistan, on this earth. His words will certainly come true. Pakistan will vanish due to its efforts to grab Kashmir. 😂😂😂😂😂
This video will have 90% Indian🇮🇳 viewership. And you will understand why Indian is progressing in every field. Who Indians follow.Even when an Educated 🎓 freethinker Pakistani talks Indian will always follow and listen. Gyan jaha se vhi aye lelo...
Indians love truth and no propaganda . We r open society and love every side of story . We don't see things with religious viewpoint . I don't thing Prof is saying anything wrong . All he is saying is the facts . In Pakistan wrong history is taught since last 70/ 80 years . This can't be reversed now as many generation r raised on hatred and malice which has in every Pakistanis blood .
@♜telegram@AbbHaidar whats about everyone participation in voting day with nota vote also (none of the above) candidate i select to be my representative in parliament.
Such a great Interview 👍 i am going to WhatsApp this to my children, so they can Learn something and be a better person for Pakistan. Thank you Pervaiz Hoodbhaye sahib.
Saeed bhai ...its necessary for every Pakistani citizen to make his other citizens in Pakistan to understand the real situation like reflected in this interview. I wish your children the best of luck to educate themselves and bring your land to a respectful platform which it definitely deserves. This cannot be done unless you come out of Religion and serve humanity as Humans and not Muslims or Hindus or christians.
Pakistan ka masla Islam hai. Christianity, Islam, Marxism and fiat currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism asks followers to cut roots - hate everything native, destroy native organic Dharma/spirituality, give up native languages. These gangs/legions (Christianity, Islam, Marxism..) are by design anti-national. Rootless parasites can't form a nation. Rootless parasites are good cannon fodder for building evil empires for 1 Male Khalifa, 1 BriShit Queen, Neo East India Company from USA, 1 Politburo honcho like Mao.
Respect Abbas for his professional approach for self improvement and Respect to Dr. for his analysis of the ground realities that he has so honestly communciated.
Salute this man, I see Pakistani they don't talk facts but this man is great. Pure Fact, knowledge. Pakistan has to remove dual citizenship and Hindu hatred.
JINNAH WANTED TO BE THE PM OF UNITED INDIA, BUT NEHRU BY CONTRAST WANTED TO BE THE PM MAYBE OF A TRUNCATED INDIA. BUT NEHRU AND GANDHI GAVE MONEY, ARMS, AMMUNITION AND OTHER DEFENCE EQUIPMENT ETC TO PAKISTAN ONLY TO BE USED AGAINST INDIA. WITHOUT THE SUPPORT OF NEHRU AND GANDHI PAKISTAN WOULD NOT HAVE SURVIVED EVEN ONE WEEK.
@@vedicchant9981 pakistan barbad hi identity crisis ki wajah se hua invaders ko konsa country apna hero maanta hai bhai ottoman empire me jo arabo ke Saath julm kiya kya arab turks ko apna hero maante hai
Totally disagree on Dual nationals. What Dual nationality Nawaz, Zardari, Musharraf etc have? Nirav Modi had duel? Single deprive the ordinary people, It don’t effect corrupt people , they have money & can move any where. Every Indian/Chinese person I see in USA have given up citizen ships for USA. So if I have given up Indian citizen ship them why I care about India? I have dual and care about both countries like your both parents.
I am surprised to see so many comments from induans as compared to Pakistanis. That says it all about our conditions. Each word of Sir Hoodbhoy is worth listening and implementing. Thanks for such a good program
Sohail, I was wondering the same, I asked my Pakistani friends ..who works with me none of them have even heard his name,shocking!!! You guys need voices like his there is one where he talks to students a few years ago 👌👌 such a gem
@@ohboeeboee agreed. I always had a dream that this region of sub continent prospers just like US Canada or Australia. The people from sub continent are making difference in these regions
It appears that most Pakistanis don't even want to watch programs that tell them the truth, even if the truth be ugly. They're so fed up of bad news they'd rather watch somebody who promises to lift them out of the morass they're in, and when that _masiha_ fails, it is on to the next one who makes the same promises all over again. And so Army -> Nawaz Sharif -> Army -> Niazi, etc.
Agree to the point of view of doctor that Kashmir people remained neglected for a very long time. Its main reason was that article 370 and 35A only bound central government to release enough money for Jammu and Kashmir state, even more than any bigger state of India. But,it did not permit central government to monitor and audit veracity of expenditure made during any financial year, similar to same exercise being carried out in other states. This flaw and deficiency made three families of the state who ruled the state for most part of last 75 years free to loot and plunder money as per their whims and fancies with accountability and answerability to none. Most part of money went on buying of properties by these three families all over India and all over the world. Discreetly, Hurriyat and terrorists were also given this developmental money to sustain their anti state activities. There was ordinance passed by state assembly that whosoever becomes chief ministerof the state once, is entitled to occupy government accommodation till he is alive and he will be entitled to get all privelages and perks, those of a chief minister till he is alive.After abrogation of article 370 and 35A, four number of former chief ministers were forced to vacate government accommodations as they lost the self implemented privelage, moment central government rules were enforced after abrogation of 370 and 35A.There are several such instances where public money was looted and plundered by politicians as they enjoyed status of answerability to none and thus poor public suffered. As on date lots of developmental works are underway. Village panchayats which never got money in the past have been getting enough money to execute local projects as per their necessity and convenience.
So well explained. The Muslim League began and ended with Mohammad Ali Jinnah. It is sad the army, in spite of their education and modern outlook, could not hold Pakistan together. This is what happens in a theocratic state. Jinnah may have been secular, but there were no others who shared his beliefs.
The imperialist was the British Raj, but the All India Muslim League directed their struggle against Hindus only. The same attitude can be seen in the national character of Pakistan. Hate for India forms the basis of Pakistan's foreign policy. Patriotism in Pakistan is with reference to India only.
Army is the only secular force left in Pakistan. Easy to blame the Army but they're not the actual problem. The real problem is the ideology of Pakistan.
Gaand phatne pe inn munafiqo ko barabar sab logic samajhne lagta hai.....jab tak so called kafiro ko Maar rahe hote hai tab tak sab thik hota hai tab sab logic ghas char e chala jata hai......looking at Pakistani society it is proved that evil things can't prosper in this world and karma will hit back these hypocritical barbaric people
Prof Saheb has ignored the adverse impact of the poison of hatered towards Hindus and India which has been injected since 1947, strengthened by Madrassa Education. Unless it is tackled in a focused manner, one fails to see any future for Pakistan and it's citizens.
Ashram Education Results = RSS Ashram Education Results = bajrang dal Aahram Education Results = Shiv sena. Beta we are watching Traitors with open eyes..
RSS and BJP are doing to India what Radical Mullahs and establishments has done to Pakistan. So instead of enjoying by watching Pakistan In this situation you guys should focus on your own country.
Every country requires fearless freethinkers like Dr. Parvez. I use to listen his physics lectures. Even today's India needs open discussions like this in civil circles. Just a Food for Thought. 🤔🤔🤔
In India, Jawaharlal Nehru has been openly criticized and made fun off, many times, in public gatherings. And no one objected to it. It has already happened in India.
@@TheMonk7423 It's not about whether it has happened previously or not. It is a continuous process. We should keep questioning organizations, laid down systems and people who make decisions.
Abbas sahib. The tragic part is that not more than 25% Pakistanis watch this intellectual and insightful debate. 75% Indians are always curious to know.
@@MrIrshadashrafi 😂😂😂 acha. Jada indian communist media dekhe tum. Basic difference between india and pakistan is religion. Pakistan is a reflection of islam and india is of Hinduism
When a piece of land gets separated because of religion, why is there a futile debate about what Mr Jinnah wanted as the governance model for the separated piece of land. One of prominent columnist T.V.R.Shenoy wrote about Israel, the only democracy between Gujarat (India) and Gambia.
mr.abbas.islam and democracy are two different and opposite ideology.islam does not give any freedom like discussion,research,speak or anything.islamic rules regulations are like a close and shut window.no progressive and healthy ideology.after Jia ul haq,Pakistan faced a tight and hard islamic fundamentalism.all this do not suit democracy.mulla maulvi and coorupt politicians + military dominance ruined this beautiful land.
What is balanced in Professor’s views about India? I saw the comments from Indians and except for a couple of them , can’t see how they call his views balanced. I don’t care what his views are about Pakistan. His views on India are not balanced or correct.
Actual problem with Pakistan was that unlike India, none of their leaders( like Quaid, state CM, ministers etc) has actually been gone to prison in independence movement. In India such leaders could be found till 1970 all over.
Correct, while Congress and other leaders were fighing for independence against British ( and went to jails), Jinnah and Muslim league only fought for partition and make Pakistan and never went to jail. So they never really struggled for a long period like the leaders who stayed with India.
Unlike IN mythologies - where we have self-sacrificing leaders like Bheeshma and truthful ones like Yudishtar, etc. - there are no role models of honest and self-sacrificing leaders in the Muslim mythology. Their Phrophet (PBUH) - advocates telling lies. He said that God has given him special permission to have 11 wives, etc. Everyone wants to be the leader (the cause of Shia Sunni fasaad) and all of them were uniformly selfish. Then it all boils down to tribalism. No role models in history or mythology - no real life examples. IN is lucky to have a string of multiple role models - both ancient and modern. Muslims only have one - which is their prophet. That is why they cannot tolerate any fault found against him. Islam, imho, is more of a death cult than a religion. Hence Muslim countries suffer. Similarly - no jail time by PK freedom fighters - no vision - no passion and no intensity to do the right thing. They got their country for free without any major pains or scarifies. How much do you think they will value it and how hard will they work for it?
Sir people's of Pakistan know everything but have no power to change because power lies somewhere else. Dr. Hoodbouy is great intellectual and asset of Pakistan. He is 100% right.
Keep it Up! Love from Pakistan ! I may disagree with him on some points but we should keep on listening people like him becz people like him are only hope left for changing Pakistanis rather than foolish anchors who have million subscribers!
People of kashmir dont want to give kashmir to India. Pakistan is a shithole with thousands of issues, but lets not pretend that the indians are the good guys in the kashmir issue specifically. Yall are basically on the verge of a genocide of kashmiris comparable to what isrealis are doing to the palestinans
In spite of all Hoodbhoy intentionally fall short of speaking on the condition of PoK residents. He spoke of Indian side Kashmir. But he would never speak that his army treats Kashmiri worse than animal. There is no university, no good college, no infrastructure no airport there. But he would not speak on that.
totally agree with you ... There was is and always will be a two way respect between Army and politicians ..... his tone was quite harsh towards our Army for sure
You are wrong and have false information about Kashmir . You just compare Indian Kashmir with Pakistani occupied Kashmir . You will know the difference . Certain Kashmiri leaders were blackmailing New Delhi . By making Kashmir from a state into union territory, India fought back Pakistani exported terrorists and blackmailing by local leaders .
@@ajiasacademy8789 nobody here was talking about kashmir my dude. Also you guys are treating kashmiris like animals locking them up in their house with no contact to the outside world, kidnapping their people, etc. No sane kashmiri supports the crimes against humanity that you guys are doing. You don’t need to be blinded by nationalism to love your country. I am pakistani and I love my people, but I am not afraid to admit that my country is a shit hole. First step is to admit your wrongdoings if you want solutions
@@lolololllll You are being misinformed . Kashmiris are getting all kinds of freedom and economic prosperity . Their per capita income is higher than the per capita income of UP , Bihar and northern India . If you compare with POK , you will find Indian part of Kashmir is far ahead in terms of infrastructure , literacy or economic growth. Pakistan did not abide by UN resolution . It didn’t withdraw its forces from Pakistan occupied Kashmir , Gilgit and Baltistan to conduct plebiscite as mandated by UN . Pakistan invaded India four times to dismember it and every time , it had to eat humble pie . Now , Pakistan is on the brink of dismemberment. Its elite is brazenly corrupt and insensitive to masses . Its military has eaten major chunks of its resources . Pakistan has been waging proxy war in Kashmir for 30 years by exporting terrorists into valley . Pakistan must change from ideological state to normal state .. It must dismantle nexus of zamindars and military . And leave aside anti India tirade if it wants to have a prosper and peaceful Pakistan. Now , India has embarked upon great power status in the world .
پرویز صاحب کا ایک ایک حروف بہت قمیتی ہے یہ بات چیت انہوں نے کہی سب سچ پر مبنی ہے حیدرعلی بھائی ہماری قوم کو ان سب باتوں پر غور کرنا چاہئے اور اپنے حقوق لینے چاہئے
Seeing and hearing Parvez Hoodbhoi after a long time, always a pleasure and lessons to learn, thanks Abbas Haider, you do have a class and you bring people of undeniable, talent, strength dignity and intellect on your platform.
Salute to Hoodbhoy, watching him from my childhood. It’s so hard for Intellectual people to be surrounded by sea of Illiterates , specially So called educated.
Without Kashmir issue, there would be no issue between Pakistan and India. If you want to save this region as a whole, solve the issue of Kashmir. India can become a developed country but it had to live with same neighbors. You can't change your neighbors. Neither can you afford another Afghanistan on your borders. Common Pakistanis never hated Indian people.
@@imranahmad7871 That is a lie. Kashmir is not the cause, it is a symptom. Pakistan doesn't want Bangladesh back, which was once a part of Pakistan, yet wants Kashmir, which never was. Why? Because India has Kashmir, but doesn't want Bangladesh either. The aim is to start the breakup of India. From India's point of view, Kashmir is a pain, but the obsession with it is absolutely killing Pakistan. So, let Pakistan obsess itself to death over Kashmir.
@@imranahmad7871 sorry sir,. Jinnah divided india even when kashmir problem was not there. Problem is with all Islamic countries and it'is no democracy or Badshahat or military 🪖 dictatorship in almost all Islamic countries as they can not coexist with any body or any other religions.
Every Pakistani should listen to this excellent interview. Such meaningful and factual programs are not frequently broadcasted on TV. Although Pakistanis are deceived by false history and rulers, but in the last few years, due to the efforts of notables like Hodbhai, a lot of awareness has been created. The young generation of Pakistan is awakening. They do not have feelings of enmity towards India and want friendly relations. They want to establish a society like Turkey or even more developed, not like Saudi Arabia. Now educated youth is getting rid of religious and linguistic differences . The voices of people like HoodBhai are being heard seriously. Although there are so many religious extremists but they are loosing support of society day by day. Pakistan is changing progressively.
Beleive it or not, India wants a developed and peaceful Pakistan. After getting a homeland of the muslims Pakistan should have no problem with India. Pakistan should treat India as any other nation just like the Arab countries treat India.
Sir, I am proud to be a foot soldier 🪖 of the army of rationalist, science 🔭🧪, technology, critical Thinking people,of South Asia 🌏 whose commander in chief at present is Dr Parvez Houdboy,. In 2000, india had President APJ Kalam, who was a scientific advisor to Prime minister Vajpayee.
India opted secularism, constitution, democracy and finally nation state as in develop democracy of west. Where many people of underdeveloped countries people preferred to go. But Pakistan was based on hatred, communalism etc. Dr. Abul kalam Azad rightly said Pakistan wouldn't survive for long. Now two nation theories are about fail. The main aim of Pakistan was to disintegrate indian democracy by the west and check Russian expansion. Now India emerged as successful democracy. Thus Pakistan aim of creation has been over. Now Pakistan entered into crisis from where it's not possible to return back. Now the intellectual of Pakistan have to find its right path.
Dear Sir Hoodbhoy, from India I love you. Wish you could be in India for our children. Pakistan does not know your value. Why don't you apply for citizenship like adanan n others
This is the best interview cames from Our Neighborhood... And this kind of TH-camrs and people can make our Neighborhood stable and prosperous, that we can feel safe...
Mr. Abbas Haider thanks to invited Dr. Hoodbhoy for valuable & true information. Hope you also invite Mr. Altaf Hussain MQM, Leader in your upcoming interviews. Regards
*10 Biggest Blinders made by Pakistan since Independence* Formation of a country on the basis of religion is the biggest mistake made by the founders of Pakistan. Second mistake was the name coined for the new country as Pakistan. There is Afghanistan for Afghans. There is China for Chinese people. There is Kazakhstan for Kazaki people. But there are on group or race called Pak or Pakis. The Sidhi, Baloch, Punjabi , Pushto and Bengali have their own language, culture, dresses and food habit. Tying them as a nation in the name of religion was not possible from the beginning. During united India , the revenue collection from East Bengal was less than that of West Bengal. The provinces like NWFP and Balochistan had very negligible revenue. The Sindh and Punjab provinces used have better revenue. But the revenue collection was better in Hindu and Sikh dominated areas in Punjab. In case of Sindh the revenue collection was better in cities like Karachi and Hyderabad . After formation of Pakistan there was crisis of revenue from the beginning. Pakistan had ambition to capture as much area as possible after partition. So it formed a huge Army to recapture the entire India. The cost of raising and managing such Army was enormous. Pakistan crumbled to manage such a huge Army. The next problem for Pakistan was lack of democracy and respect for its leaders. Mohammad Ali Jinha could not get an ambulance during his last days to be shifted to the hospital. His PM Liyakat Alli khan tried his level best to stop all medical facilities to Jinha. He died under very difficult condition. Martial Law by Army Generals also ruined the civil and democratic institutions of Pakistan. From its inception Pakistan tried to survive on anti India slogans. Pakistan developed its ambition to capture Indian territory by any means. Jammu and Kashmir became the survival syndrome of Pakistan. Pakistan did not bother to improve its economy, agriculture, industries , education and health care. It depended on donations from Arab countries, USA, China and Turkey. It used all the donations to build its Armed Forces. USA supported Pakistan and helped with advanced weapon systems. In 1947 Pak Army attacked Jammu and Kashmir and occupied 35% of the state. In 1965 Pakistan attacked J and K to capture it from India. It lost badly in the war. It lost some territory in Azad Kashmir and Punjab. There was repression in east Pakistan on Bengali Muslims. Muzibur Rhaman the leader of Awami league was arrested and there was war with India in 1971. Bangladesh was liberated and Muzibur Rahman became the PM of Bangladesh. Zulfiqar Alli Bhutto the PM of Pakistan signed the Shimla Agreement. India returned all the prisoner of war to Pakistan. Pakistan started its nuclear bomb programme with the help of China. Zia ul Haque became the Army Chief of Pakistan and arrested PM Bhutto. Then he was charged with corruption and anti national activities. Bhutto was hanged in Pakistan. Zia ul Haque became the martial law dictator and started the doctrine of thousand cuts to India through terror activities. He sponsored terror activities in Punjab for Khalistan. Pakistan became a terror state with the help of USA and Saudi Arab. Kashmir also came under terror activities. Zia ul Haque died in a plane crash. Democracy returned to Pakistan. But it was suffocated by Army again. Pak Army sabotaged all peace process with India including the Lahore Bus Journey by PM of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee. Then there was Kargil attack by Pakistan. It lost the Kargil war. In between Pakistan also tested atomic weapons. It threatened India on any small issue to nuke . Terrorism was sponsored by Pak army to damage India through Jihad in Kashmir. Pakistan sponsored dreaded terror groups in the name of Islam and Jihad. Pak PM Benazir Bhutto was eliminated by some terror group after her arrival in Pakistan. PM Nawaz Shariff was arrested and put in jail for some scandal. President Asif Zardari was arrested and put in jail. Army placed a puppet Government in Islamabad. Terror groups ruled Pakistan with Army. Balochistan be came next victim of exploitation by Pakistan. Pakistan leased out some land from Gilgit to China. It started its terror hub in Muzafrabad. India faced terror problems from Pakistan. But Pakistan suffered badly in economic front. Now Pakistan is a failed state. It has no money to survive. Count down has started for the collapse of Pakistan. It is a matter of time before the theocratic state and terror state of Pakistan collapse completely. *SuNaLa* !As I Live I Learn!
nope, Israel also made on the basis of religion and many other countries also. Pakistan means land for Muslims - so nothing wrong with that. You are wrong about the size of the army - Pakistani is not responsible for Indian Muslims not moving to Pakistan yet and that is the reason you feel the size of the army is big. Pakistan didn't create that army it was inherited. There are many countries where there is no democracy and they are doing great. Agree that Pakistan should be grateful to India for giving them land but they are anti-India for no reason. Pakistan was not created for democracy, industries, education, and health care, so they have achieved their target. Pakistan was created to become a terror state. Pakistan is not collasping anyway as of now. No idea what you are talking about, you have not mentioned any blunders but their achievements. You have also blamed Pakistan for the things that Indian Muslims have done.
One of the biggest mistake of Pakistan and the basis of all root problem is that Pakistani are suffering from identity crisis. The Muslim community of Pakistan never accept Hindu community as their ancestors. आप लोगो ने हिंदू समाज के लोगों को अपना दूशमन बना दिया और अपने बच्चों को हिन्दू समाज के प्रति नफरत सिखाया | अपने हिन्दू धर्म के लोगों को अपना पूर्वज कभी भी नही स्विकारा |
excellent work sir . One if the most Honesty interviews with great narratives, we should pray that all the predictions that Prof. Pervaiz indicated will come true. Ameen
6:24 India has 22 official languages. 38 languages are under consideration. According to Press Trust of India - More than 19,500 languages or dialects are spoken in India as mother tongues, according to the latest analysis of a census released.
Not really. He has himself said before: his concern is for the Pakistani _people_ not Pakistan the country. He says something similar in this video also:"Pakistan will break, so what? The Pakistani people will remain."
This is an amazing interview with important lessons for India and many countries in the west also. It is, however, conducted in highly literate and scholarly Urdu, which limits its accessibility. It is highly desirable that it be made available with subtitles in Hindi and/or English.
The gentleman is speaking truth living in Pakistan You can imagine his courage . Unfortunately, One thing I m dead sure is that Pakistan is about to finish now. Artificial things don't last longer.
Breakup Pakistan into its constituent nations. Punjab, Sindh, Balochisthan etc. Make their own language and culture as the centerpiece of their existence. Individually, they might prosper.
@@tallatmumtazmir3267 well no. India is a civilizational state, unlike the artifical entity called Pakistan. The pull of all indian nation towards each other is too strong, by their 5000+ year old tradition and cultures. Democracy is making is stronger only. Just think, Punjabi or Sindhi are Indian languages. Nothing to do with Islam or Arabic or Persian or Turki civilization. Even Urdu is Indian language, nothing to do with Pakistan. Or Bengali. Indian and Hindu languages if you want to claim it. The reason Bangladesh is making progress is because they have no conflict with their Indian roots. Once Pakistan is dissolved peacefully, Sindh or Punjab will be similar to Bangladesh. Pakistan is an ideology. Not a state or a civilization or even a country
Brilliant discussion on extremely important subjects! Dr Hoodbhoy, aapko salute hai 🙏...a learned man, not afraid to speak the truth! I wish you were living in India... Respect 🙏 🇮🇳
Hoodboy sab Musulaman kabhi sudharenge nahi,kyunki there is too much racism like fight between Shia and Sunni and barlvi and deobandi,alhabis etc.How can you expect a kaum to improve when they don't trust their bethern or neighbour s
first time i am hearing such an honest interpretation of the stark reality .... pakistanis must remove the blindfold and where they are arrived after 70 years of independence . frankly it seems a impossible task to get Pakistan back on track as a successful state...
Is India any better? Watch parvez hood bai criticise from top to bottom but I can assure you the police will not come to arrest him or bulldoze his house like India.
@@HaidarAsmari , friend, dont get me wrong here but your comments adds more weightage to what my inference which is based on Dr Parvej's candid comments. unfortunately, u represent the voice of your country .... a voice which remains totally disconnected from reality , totally ignorant of the deep hole your beloved country has been digging itself into where there will be no one willing to bail out your country any more, whether its the world bank or IMF or the Saudis or Turkey or the main benefactor china. High time , you all set aside all your age old complex about india and realise the truth that india is heading to become the third largest economy and you are heading towards bankruptcy.... there is no malice here as these are ground realities which frankly should scare the shit our of every pakistani. rather than waste your time on the age old kashmir issue look at constructive measures to improve your economy . Come to your senses that the Bengalis of East Pakistan have a much stronger economy than West Pakistan and is steady pulling way increasing the gap in the GDP and per capita,. Come to your senses that when India was relatively weak in the 60s & 70s you could do nothing and now when the world considers India a rising power , do you seriously think u will get kashmir back. Is it not high time the aam admi in pakistan realises its army has been taking all in sundry for a ride by playing the war card either with india or baluchisthan or the pakisthani taliban in order to force a budget for the armed forces which your government clearly cannot afford. If you remove your sunglasses and carry out a reality check by being brutally honest with yourself , you will see that your army is struggling fighting off baluchis , talibans, other radical groups on your western front and you dont require your army on the eastern front because let me tell you something and i am not being arrogant but being brutally honest when i say .... India will never attack your country ... infact india of today gives a monkeys to what your govt or your press has to say ... Please try to understand that India has moved on with its own life and its high time you guys do the same and concentrate in nation building for a change
Pakistanis should start getting ready for partition of Pakistan in four parts. There is no hope even after that. Most Pakistanis will live like Somalians or Sudanes.
Hoodbhoy didn't explain why India is responsible for Kashmir problem. He has a brain fade that Maharaja of Kashmir had signed the deed of accession to merge with India and Pakistan were the aggressor just as they captured the hapless Balochistan which declared by Britishers as a Sovereign entity. So much for a unbiased intellectual huhh!!
The only Physicist and Mathematician Academic in the world who blatantly expresses his knowledge on Sociology and Political Science. He had already said many years ago that Pakistan will be in great danger in every aspect . Now current situation proves that Dr. Hoodbhoy was Right . ✅ Happy to see you again sir . Thanks Abbas bhai also 🙏 😊
Jinah was a man without any principles, either good or bad. He had no qualms about running away with his friend's immature daughter. He thus deceived both her and his friend. He did not follow islam also. He consumed pork, drank liquor and rarely offered namaz. He was only concerned about himself so he used Islam for his own selfish end and created Pakistan to become it's head to remain a figure in history. He died early without setting any framework for Pakistan. He did not even considered it a priority. So he is primarily responsible for the subsequent mess in Pakistan. Let Pakistanis realise this and forget Kashmir and concentrate on development and move ahead.
Regards to Abbas Haider for bringing this great intellectual on his channel. We may differ on certain points with Hoodbouy sahib, but it is always pleasure to hear him. He has a great following in India for his straightforward views.
Every country has an Army, in Pakistan Army has a country. And aap critical kyun nahin hai? Sirf 2 din ke liye majhab chod dijiye, logic aa jayega...let me ask you, are you God fearing or God loving man. 1 or 2 , and why that? Religion or Army will not allow the soldiers to apply mind👍
Nice to know that some sensible people like dR.parveez , abbaas hamid and lots more well meaning people of Pakistan who are hidden there in Pakistan and who can Bring a positive change Allah help them
George Washington also gave no road map for his new country USA, like Muhammad Ali Jinnah, but his colleagues in struggle decided to go for democracy and capitalism.
Sir i don't concur with you over the statement that if Kashmir problem wasn't there you could have been better, we also had buy we grew, the problem is Islamic radicals taking over of Pakistan they would have done that if not Kashmir they would find any other reason
No hope as long as you have Sharifs, Imran Khan Niazi, judiciary, Army, and ordinary Pakistanis fighting each other but considering China a brother! China, that hates Islam to the point of outlawing it, yet you think China is a brother! China will gobble up Pakistan soon. End of the road now.
A 7th century book that is full of faulty assumptions has been assumed to be the perfect book and 99% of your countrymen live according to it, then you still have to ask what went wrong? If you want to see your future look to the country on your west! We will be proud to take Dr Hoodbhoy as a citizen of India!!
History of Pakistan
1947 we cannot live with hindus
1953 we cannot live with ahmedis
1971 we cannot live with Bengalis
1980s we cannot live with shia
1990s we cannot live with muhajirs
2000s we cannot live with pashtoons
2020s labbek labbek labbek sabke sar tan se juda
So true...
*Pakistani confession* :-
1) 1947 - We can't live without Britain.
2) 1955- 2011- we can't live without USA.
3) 2011 to 2030- we can't live without China.
*** 2022*** :-
*we can't live without loans from IMF, WB, ADB, US, Russia, CHINA, UZBEKISTAN, SAUDI, UAE, REMITTANCE etc etc n etc* ...
We cannot survive in India’s neighbourhood.
Al qaida, taaliban, ttp, bla ko bhool gaye
Nooo it's not really the case
The host Mr. Abbas Haidar deserves a credit for conducting a marvelous interview. It's an art to raise both the right and good questions.
Beshak 🤟
X?zxZZZX
X?
he's really a decent host
Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy is a living legend. He is a rare gem in a coal yard. Unfortunately Pakistanis don't listen to people like Sir Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.
Pakistan’s core problem remains flat earth 🌎
For them IK is their saviour.
Strange people
On same hand
Imran khan riaz
Has millions listening to him
Who bullshitting 24x7
He is a lying legend.
Super
Accidentally came across to this video, trust me, I as a British Indian, I have total respect for Dr. Prof. Hoodbhoy, may God bless him with lots of happiness and good health. He is one of the best brains that our common civilization has ever produced.🙏🙏🙏
Cannot believe how honest this interview is!! What a wonderful and wise person Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy is! Wish we had more such strong and inspiring voices on both sides of the border. Hope India and Pakistan will come together in our lifetimes. That is the only solution to many of our problems and challenges.
He has been saying this for last 40 years or more but no one is listening to him.. he is an outlier in Pakistan
In 1947 my Guru Maharaj told some one that time will come in your life time that there will not be any nation called Pakistan, on this earth. His words will certainly come true. Pakistan will vanish due to its efforts to grab Kashmir. 😂😂😂😂😂
You cut the part of your body when it is rotten, let’s save what we have pakistan is damaged to a point of no return
Yeh Indiana's kyun gaand rkh ry Pakistaanio k l pr
This video will have 90% Indian🇮🇳 viewership. And you will understand why Indian is progressing in every field. Who Indians follow.Even when an Educated 🎓 freethinker Pakistani talks Indian will always follow and listen. Gyan jaha se vhi aye lelo...
Very true.
Theres always going to be more indians in videos that criticize pakistan whether it’s intellectual or blatant ignorance. Isn’t it your pastime?
@@lolololllll I have already explained it. Indians are always keen to learn but when someone speaks blatant lie Indians always gonna respond to it.
Indians love truth and no propaganda . We r open society and love every side of story . We don't see things with religious viewpoint . I don't thing Prof is saying anything wrong . All he is saying is the facts .
In Pakistan wrong history is taught since last 70/ 80 years .
This can't be reversed now as many generation r raised on hatred and malice which has in every Pakistanis blood .
@@ashwwal3409 really? no propaganda and only the truth lol? Is the aryan migration real or fake?
What an amazing person Professor Pervez Hoodbhoy is I have seen him a few times in QAU 👍👍👍
@♜telegram@AbbHaidar whats about everyone participation in voting day with nota vote also (none of the above) candidate i select to be my representative in parliament.
Andhon me kana raja hai.
Such a great Interview 👍 i am going to WhatsApp this to my children, so they can Learn something and be a better person for Pakistan. Thank you Pervaiz Hoodbhaye sahib.
Don't spoil the future of your children.
Amazing that people like you still exist in Pakistan! 👏
@@PS-ej2xn you must send tlp videos to your kids for their better future
Saeed bhai ...its necessary for every Pakistani citizen to make his other citizens in Pakistan to understand the real situation like reflected in this interview. I wish your children the best of luck to educate themselves and bring your land to a respectful platform which it definitely deserves. This cannot be done unless you come out of Religion and serve humanity as Humans and not Muslims or Hindus or christians.
Pakistan ka masla Islam hai. Christianity, Islam, Marxism and fiat currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism asks followers to cut roots - hate everything native, destroy native organic Dharma/spirituality, give up native languages. These gangs/legions (Christianity, Islam, Marxism..) are by design anti-national. Rootless parasites can't form a nation. Rootless parasites are good cannon fodder for building evil empires for 1 Male Khalifa, 1 BriShit Queen, Neo East India Company from USA, 1 Politburo honcho like Mao.
It is always a pleasure listening Dr. Parvez Hoodbhoy.
Respect Abbas for his professional approach for self improvement and Respect to Dr. for his analysis of the ground realities that he has so honestly communciated.
Dr. Hoodbhoy is one of the few rational thinkers in a theocratic society.
Yes he is rational thinker, but it context to 🇮🇳 he starts doing proppoganda
@@priyankawaykole8781 the comment is to be read in Pakistani context...for India he is no better than a jehadi islamist bigot.
He is considered a traitor in paxtan 😂😂
@@honeysingh-jd8mp lol he is creation of same fauz he is giving lecture on....in paxtan everything ugly bad disgust is by fauz only.
All these so called rational pakistani ever talk about terrisam done by pakistani army in Bharat.
Salute this man, I see Pakistani they don't talk facts but this man is great.
Pure Fact, knowledge.
Pakistan has to remove dual citizenship and Hindu hatred.
JINNAH WANTED TO BE THE PM OF UNITED INDIA, BUT NEHRU BY CONTRAST WANTED TO BE THE PM MAYBE OF A TRUNCATED INDIA. BUT NEHRU AND GANDHI GAVE MONEY, ARMS, AMMUNITION AND OTHER DEFENCE EQUIPMENT ETC TO PAKISTAN ONLY TO BE USED AGAINST INDIA. WITHOUT THE SUPPORT OF NEHRU AND GANDHI PAKISTAN WOULD NOT HAVE SURVIVED EVEN ONE WEEK.
Except Hinduism,RSS and Muslims in india he's right about Pakistan
@@vedicchant9981 pakistan barbad hi identity crisis ki wajah se hua invaders ko konsa country apna hero maanta hai bhai ottoman empire me jo arabo ke Saath julm kiya kya arab turks ko apna hero maante hai
@@vedicchant9981 😂😂😂 khatarnak summarise kiya bhai
Totally disagree on Dual nationals. What Dual nationality Nawaz, Zardari, Musharraf etc have? Nirav Modi had duel? Single deprive the ordinary people, It don’t effect corrupt people , they have money & can move any where. Every Indian/Chinese person I see in USA have given up citizen ships for USA. So if I have given up Indian citizen ship them why I care about India? I have dual and care about both countries like your both parents.
I am surprised to see so many comments from induans as compared to Pakistanis. That says it all about our conditions. Each word of Sir Hoodbhoy is worth listening and implementing. Thanks for such a good program
Sohail, I was wondering the same, I asked my Pakistani friends ..who works with me none of them have even heard his name,shocking!!! You guys need voices like his there is one where he talks to students a few years ago 👌👌 such a gem
@@ohboeeboee agreed. I always had a dream that this region of sub continent prospers just like US Canada or Australia. The people from sub continent are making difference in these regions
Indians always lend their ears to hear wise people.
It appears that most Pakistanis don't even want to watch programs that tell them the truth, even if the truth be ugly.
They're so fed up of bad news they'd rather watch somebody who promises to lift them out of the morass they're in, and when that _masiha_ fails, it is on to the next one who makes the same promises all over again.
And so Army -> Nawaz Sharif -> Army -> Niazi, etc.
That is because Pakistan lacks the culture of intellectual debate. Religious extremism has erased this open thinking.
Being an Indian my aim is to learn something from a wise man..!!!
💯
This wise man has been royally f*****d by the Pakistan government but afreen he still blames India for the Kashmir issue
I am Indian...and I too started like this man ...Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Being a Martian, I am trying to learn why Earthlings are so obsessed with religion and fundamentalism that is destroying themselves
Being a Martian, I want to learn all the silly ways of earthlings
Agree to the point of view of doctor that Kashmir people remained neglected for a very long time. Its main reason was that article 370 and 35A only bound central government to release enough money for Jammu and Kashmir state, even more than any bigger state of India. But,it did not permit central government to monitor and audit veracity of expenditure made during any financial year, similar to same exercise being carried out in other states. This flaw and deficiency made three families of the state who ruled the state for most part of last 75 years free to loot and plunder money as per their whims and fancies with accountability and answerability to none. Most part of money went on buying of properties by these three families all over India and all over the world. Discreetly, Hurriyat and terrorists were also given this developmental money to sustain their anti state activities.
There was ordinance passed by state assembly that whosoever becomes chief ministerof the state once, is entitled to occupy government accommodation till he is alive and he will be entitled to get all privelages and perks, those of a chief minister till he is alive.After abrogation of article 370 and 35A, four number of former chief ministers were forced to vacate government accommodations as they lost the self implemented privelage, moment central government rules were enforced after abrogation of 370 and 35A.There are several such instances where public money was looted and plundered by politicians as they enjoyed status of answerability to none and thus poor public suffered.
As on date lots of developmental works are underway. Village panchayats which never got money in the past have been getting enough money to execute local projects as per their necessity and convenience.
Beautifully explained!
Thank you 🙏🇮🇳
So well explained. The Muslim League began and ended with Mohammad Ali Jinnah. It is sad the army, in spite of their education and modern outlook, could not hold Pakistan together. This is what happens in a theocratic state. Jinnah may have been secular, but there were no others who shared his beliefs.
The imperialist was the British Raj, but the All India Muslim League directed their struggle against Hindus only. The same attitude can be seen in the national character of Pakistan. Hate for India forms the basis of Pakistan's foreign policy. Patriotism in Pakistan is with reference to India only.
Their struggle was for partition. What about other parties?
But they will never understand, because they are blinded by islam
Because bigoted hindus wanted to be the next imperialist power against the Muslims.
Maulanas used Islam, concepts of darul harb, battle oi badr analogies etc to
Only Sharia Law Can Save Pakistan.
Inshallah Sharia Kaayam Hoga aur Pakistan Duniya Ki Sabse Badhi Taakat Banega Alhamdulilah
Very rare to see Pakistanis discussing their current state of affairs so accurately and honestly ! Please stay safe from your army !
Army is the only secular force left in Pakistan. Easy to blame the Army but they're not the actual problem. The real problem is the ideology of Pakistan.
Gaand phatne pe inn munafiqo ko barabar sab logic samajhne lagta hai.....jab tak so called kafiro ko Maar rahe hote hai tab tak sab thik hota hai tab sab logic ghas char e chala jata hai......looking at Pakistani society it is proved that evil things can't prosper in this world and karma will hit back these hypocritical barbaric people
He is a fervent supporter of his faith, and has contempt towards India & Hindus.
हर इंडियन यह चाहता है कि पाकिस्तानी जिन समस्याओं में हैं उस से बाहर निकले इंसानियत के नाते हम आपके साथ हैं
@@gujjo9825 jab hoga tab dekh lenge
Prof Saheb has ignored the adverse impact of the poison of hatered towards Hindus and India which has been injected since 1947, strengthened by Madrassa Education. Unless it is tackled in a focused manner, one fails to see any future for Pakistan and it's citizens.
he was brainwashed in his teens.
Ashram Education Results = RSS
Ashram Education Results = bajrang dal
Aahram Education Results = Shiv sena.
Beta we are watching Traitors with open eyes..
This is the real problem.you redress the same.Available with the emancipated people,a rare commodity in Pakistan.
Look at the comment section ..its just shocking..
RSS and BJP are doing to India what Radical Mullahs and establishments has done to Pakistan. So instead of enjoying by watching Pakistan In this situation you guys should focus on your own country.
Every country requires fearless freethinkers like Dr. Parvez. I use to listen his physics lectures. Even today's India needs open discussions like this in civil circles.
Just a Food for Thought. 🤔🤔🤔
In India, Jawaharlal Nehru has been openly criticized and made fun off, many times, in public gatherings. And no one objected to it. It has already happened in India.
@@TheMonk7423 It's not about whether it has happened previously or not. It is a continuous process. We should keep questioning organizations, laid down systems and people who make decisions.
@@karmayogi_satyanveshi I agree.
Yup i agree. 👍
Shastriji was a second prime minister and he was a shining example of honesty. He never changed according to time and circumstances.
Abbas sahib. The tragic part is that not more than 25% Pakistanis watch this intellectual and insightful debate. 75% Indians are always curious to know.
😂Not more than 1% Pakistanis would even consider hoodbhoy worth watching. They consider these people gaddar
Out of 75% Indians 95% are Hindus
Op
Janab Indian bhi Pakistan ki rah par hain ab 25 percent hi curious hai aur 75 percent andh bhakt hai
@@MrIrshadashrafi 😂😂😂 acha. Jada indian communist media dekhe tum.
Basic difference between india and pakistan is religion. Pakistan is a reflection of islam and india is of Hinduism
When a piece of land gets separated because of religion, why is there a futile debate about what Mr Jinnah wanted as the governance model for the separated piece of land. One of prominent columnist T.V.R.Shenoy wrote about Israel, the only democracy between Gujarat (India) and Gambia.
Indian army lives in 1.3 billion indian 💕 hearts.
We Indians are 1.42 billion now !!!
Indian army doesn't have "Pappa-Jones-outlets" and corner plots across country.
@@shyamsundard.r1782 tab bhi ye baat sahi hai.
@@avyay9442 👌🇮🇳❤️💐🙏.
اللٰہ پاک ڈاکٹر صاحب کو سلامت رکھے۔
Balochistan Azad hoga 1 din zaroor hoga
Balochistan zindabad
Long live Balochistan !
mr.abbas.islam and democracy are two different and opposite ideology.islam does not give any freedom like discussion,research,speak or anything.islamic rules regulations are like a close and shut window.no progressive and healthy ideology.after Jia ul haq,Pakistan faced a tight and hard islamic fundamentalism.all this do not suit democracy.mulla maulvi and coorupt politicians + military dominance ruined this beautiful land.
What is balanced in Professor’s views about India? I saw the comments from Indians and except for a couple of them , can’t see how they call his views balanced. I don’t care what his views are about Pakistan. His views on India are not balanced or correct.
Exactly!
Murphy's law: "What has to go wrong will go wrong."
anything that can go wrong will go wrong
who is murphy though? random statements mean nothing. Multiple people said random multiple things.
Actual problem with Pakistan was that unlike India, none of their leaders( like Quaid, state CM, ministers etc) has actually been gone to prison in independence movement. In India such leaders could be found till 1970 all over.
asal problem ISLAAM hai ,, all over world analyse karengay to yahi payengay
Correct, while Congress and other leaders were fighing for independence against British ( and went to jails), Jinnah and Muslim league only fought for partition and make Pakistan and never went to jail. So they never really struggled for a long period like the leaders who stayed with India.
Unlike IN mythologies - where we have self-sacrificing leaders like Bheeshma and truthful ones like Yudishtar, etc. - there are no role models of honest and self-sacrificing leaders in the Muslim mythology.
Their Phrophet (PBUH) - advocates telling lies. He said that God has given him special permission to have 11 wives, etc.
Everyone wants to be the leader (the cause of Shia Sunni fasaad) and all of them were uniformly selfish. Then it all boils down to tribalism.
No role models in history or mythology - no real life examples. IN is lucky to have a string of multiple role models - both ancient and modern. Muslims only have one - which is their prophet. That is why they cannot tolerate any fault found against him. Islam, imho, is more of a death cult than a religion. Hence Muslim countries suffer.
Similarly - no jail time by PK freedom fighters - no vision - no passion and no intensity to do the right thing. They got their country for free without any major pains or scarifies. How much do you think they will value it and how hard will they work for it?
Sir people's of Pakistan know everything but have no power to change because power lies somewhere else. Dr. Hoodbouy is great intellectual and asset of Pakistan. He is 100% right.
Problem of pakistan is:
1. Islam
2. No Upper Castes
3. Army influence
Keep it Up!
Love from Pakistan !
I may disagree with him on some points but we should keep on listening people like him becz people like him are only hope left for changing Pakistanis rather than foolish anchors who have million subscribers!
If Pakistan gives kashmir peacefully
You can save Pakistan
But you won’t
💯
Hahahaha
@@hassanzaheercheema6037 - you "Ha, ha......" is what is called "Gallows Humour". The laugh of a dying man or a dying nation.....
A dying nation...Very near future new Sri Lanka
People of kashmir dont want to give kashmir to India. Pakistan is a shithole with thousands of issues, but lets not pretend that the indians are the good guys in the kashmir issue specifically. Yall are basically on the verge of a genocide of kashmiris comparable to what isrealis are doing to the palestinans
so factual ... Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy ... Hope Pakistani leadership learn something out of this
In spite of all Hoodbhoy intentionally fall short of speaking on the condition of PoK residents. He spoke of Indian side Kashmir. But he would never speak that his army treats Kashmiri worse than animal. There is no university, no good college, no infrastructure no airport there. But he would not speak on that.
Indian Army is disciplined army,We are proud of our army ❤️
Most armies are disciplined. Also don’t say “we”, you don’t represent all indians
totally agree with you ... There was is and always will be a two way respect between Army and politicians ..... his tone was quite harsh towards our Army for sure
You are wrong and have false information about Kashmir . You just compare Indian Kashmir with Pakistani occupied Kashmir . You will know the difference . Certain Kashmiri leaders were blackmailing New Delhi . By making Kashmir from a state into union territory, India fought back Pakistani exported terrorists and blackmailing by local leaders .
@@ajiasacademy8789 nobody here was talking about kashmir my dude. Also you guys are treating kashmiris like animals locking them up in their house with no contact to the outside world, kidnapping their people, etc. No sane kashmiri supports the crimes against humanity that you guys are doing.
You don’t need to be blinded by nationalism to love your country. I am pakistani and I love my people, but I am not afraid to admit that my country is a shit hole. First step is to admit your wrongdoings if you want solutions
@@lolololllll You are being misinformed . Kashmiris are getting all kinds of freedom and economic prosperity . Their per capita income is higher than the per capita income of UP , Bihar and northern India . If you compare with POK , you will find Indian part of Kashmir is far ahead in terms of infrastructure , literacy or economic growth. Pakistan did not abide by UN resolution . It didn’t withdraw its forces from Pakistan occupied Kashmir , Gilgit and Baltistan to conduct plebiscite as mandated by UN . Pakistan invaded India four times to dismember it and every time , it had to eat humble pie . Now , Pakistan is on the brink of dismemberment. Its elite is brazenly corrupt and insensitive to masses . Its military has eaten major chunks of its resources .
Pakistan has been waging proxy war in Kashmir for 30 years by exporting terrorists into valley . Pakistan must change from ideological state to normal state .. It must dismantle nexus of zamindars and military . And leave aside anti India tirade if it wants to have a prosper and peaceful Pakistan. Now , India has embarked upon great power status in the world .
پرویز صاحب کا ایک ایک حروف بہت قمیتی ہے یہ بات چیت انہوں نے کہی سب سچ پر مبنی ہے حیدرعلی بھائی ہماری قوم کو ان سب باتوں پر غور کرنا چاہئے اور اپنے حقوق لینے چاہئے
Abbas Sir there was a representative of an Hindu Bengali from East neighborhood as well....
Action speaks louder than words....
Good teachings....
Even in India, most Muslims don’t demand for banks, schools or other advancement; instead they ask for Madrassa Education or Huj subsidies.
Prof Pervez talks a lot of sense. Pakistan needs a lot more people who think like him!
Military is preoccupied with making money,not fighting enemies.
Seeing and hearing Parvez Hoodbhoi after a long time, always a pleasure and lessons to learn, thanks Abbas Haider, you do have a class and you bring people of undeniable, talent, strength dignity and intellect on your platform.
Difference between india between india and Pakistan is RELIGION. When india majority Hindu hence democracy and other systems
Extremely important analysis and advice to the authorities of Pakistan.
Your guest Mr Hoodby is a gem personality of intellectuals of Pakistan. Really a good person
Salute to Hoodbhoy, watching him from my childhood. It’s so hard for Intellectual people to be surrounded by sea of Illiterates , specially So called educated.
Sir, just for argument sake , even if Pakistan is given entire Kashmir,
Will it improve Pakistan common
People. I think, Not at all.
Bhai kashmir is lingering for so long
Guess who letting it linger
No prize for answering
It's without doubt
Washington DC
Without Kashmir issue, there would be no issue between Pakistan and India. If you want to save this region as a whole, solve the issue of Kashmir. India can become a developed country but it had to live with same neighbors. You can't change your neighbors. Neither can you afford another Afghanistan on your borders. Common Pakistanis never hated Indian people.
@@imranahmad7871
Then why is Pakistan ISI meddling with Punjab and Kerala, Assam, and trying to infiltrate via Nepal?
@@imranahmad7871
That is a lie. Kashmir is not the cause, it is a symptom.
Pakistan doesn't want Bangladesh back, which was once a part of Pakistan, yet wants Kashmir, which never was. Why?
Because India has Kashmir, but doesn't want Bangladesh either. The aim is to start the breakup of India.
From India's point of view, Kashmir is a pain, but the obsession with it is absolutely killing Pakistan. So, let Pakistan obsess itself to death over Kashmir.
@@imranahmad7871 sorry sir,. Jinnah divided india even when kashmir problem was not there.
Problem is with all Islamic countries and it'is no democracy or Badshahat or military 🪖 dictatorship in almost all Islamic countries as they can not coexist with any body or any other religions.
Such a great person Dr.Hoodbhoy
Every Pakistani should listen to this excellent interview. Such meaningful and factual programs are not frequently broadcasted on TV. Although Pakistanis are deceived by false history and rulers, but in the last few years, due to the efforts of notables like Hodbhai, a lot of awareness has been created. The young generation of Pakistan is awakening. They do not have feelings of enmity towards India and want friendly relations. They want to establish a society like Turkey or even more developed, not like Saudi Arabia. Now educated youth is getting rid of religious and linguistic differences . The voices of people like HoodBhai are being heard seriously. Although there are so many religious extremists but they are loosing support of society day by day. Pakistan is changing progressively.
Beleive it or not, India wants a developed and peaceful Pakistan. After getting a homeland of the muslims Pakistan should have no problem with India. Pakistan should treat India as any other nation just like the Arab countries treat India.
The ONLY wise man in 22 crore people.
Sir, I am proud to be a foot soldier 🪖 of the army of rationalist, science 🔭🧪, technology, critical
Thinking people,of South Asia 🌏 whose commander in chief at present is Dr Parvez Houdboy,.
In 2000, india had President APJ Kalam, who was a scientific advisor to Prime minister Vajpayee.
When someone in India says says he is a proud rationalist, he usually means he is an Islamist or a Christian bigot pretending to be a rationalist.
Hoodbouy ji is most intelligent person in Pakistan.
From India
🙏🙏🙏
What a categorical statement!
Pray enlighten us how you reach this conclusion?
Which metrics did you use to deduce this?
The host has done a splendid job!
India opted secularism, constitution, democracy and finally nation state as in develop democracy of west. Where many people of underdeveloped countries people preferred to go. But Pakistan was based on hatred, communalism etc. Dr. Abul kalam Azad rightly said Pakistan wouldn't survive for long. Now two nation theories are about fail. The main aim of Pakistan was to disintegrate indian democracy by the west and check Russian expansion. Now India emerged as successful democracy. Thus Pakistan aim of creation has been over. Now Pakistan entered into crisis from where it's not possible to return back. Now the intellectual of Pakistan have to find its right path.
Mr. Prevez is true human beings his analysis 95% correct
Problem is most Pakistanis don’t see this stream, so hardly it will help.
Pakistan really need prople like Dr pervez.
Dear Sir Hoodbhoy, from India I love you. Wish you could be in India for our children. Pakistan does not know your value. Why don't you apply for citizenship like adanan n others
You guys love and respect bold people like Mr Zubir😹
This is the best interview cames from Our Neighborhood... And this kind of TH-camrs and people can make our Neighborhood stable and prosperous, that we can feel safe...
💯👌👌
Mr. Abbas Haider thanks to invited Dr. Hoodbhoy for valuable & true information. Hope you also invite Mr. Altaf Hussain MQM, Leader in your upcoming interviews. Regards
spot on the current situation and real issues of Pakistan. excellent moderation by Haider Abbas.
*10 Biggest Blinders made by Pakistan since Independence*
Formation of a country on the basis of religion is the biggest mistake made by the founders of Pakistan.
Second mistake was the name coined for the new country as Pakistan. There is Afghanistan for Afghans. There is China for Chinese people. There is Kazakhstan for Kazaki people. But there are on group or race called Pak or Pakis. The Sidhi, Baloch, Punjabi , Pushto and Bengali have their own language, culture, dresses and food habit. Tying them as a nation in the name of religion was not possible from the beginning. During united India , the revenue collection from East Bengal was less than that of West Bengal. The provinces like NWFP and Balochistan had very negligible revenue. The Sindh and Punjab provinces used have better revenue. But the revenue collection was better in Hindu and Sikh dominated areas in Punjab. In case of Sindh the revenue collection was better in cities like Karachi and Hyderabad . After formation of Pakistan there was crisis of revenue from the beginning. Pakistan had ambition to capture as much area as possible after partition. So it formed a huge Army to recapture the entire India. The cost of raising and managing such Army was enormous. Pakistan crumbled to manage such a huge Army.
The next problem for Pakistan was lack of democracy and respect for its leaders. Mohammad Ali Jinha could not get an ambulance during his last days to be shifted to the hospital. His PM Liyakat Alli khan tried his level best to stop all medical facilities to Jinha. He died under very difficult condition. Martial Law by Army Generals also ruined the civil and democratic institutions of Pakistan. From its inception Pakistan tried to survive on anti India slogans. Pakistan developed its ambition to capture Indian territory by any means. Jammu and Kashmir became the survival syndrome of Pakistan. Pakistan did not bother to improve its economy, agriculture, industries , education and health care. It depended on donations from Arab countries, USA, China and Turkey. It used all the donations to build its Armed Forces. USA supported Pakistan and helped with advanced weapon systems. In 1947 Pak Army attacked Jammu and Kashmir and occupied 35% of the state. In 1965 Pakistan attacked J and K to capture it from India. It lost badly in the war. It lost some territory in Azad Kashmir and Punjab. There was repression in east Pakistan on Bengali Muslims. Muzibur Rhaman the leader of Awami league was arrested and there was war with India in 1971. Bangladesh was liberated and Muzibur Rahman became the PM of Bangladesh. Zulfiqar Alli Bhutto the PM of Pakistan signed the Shimla Agreement. India returned all the prisoner of war to Pakistan. Pakistan started its nuclear bomb programme with the help of China. Zia ul Haque became the Army Chief of Pakistan and arrested PM Bhutto. Then he was charged with corruption and anti national activities. Bhutto was hanged in Pakistan. Zia ul Haque became the martial law dictator and started the doctrine of thousand cuts to India through terror activities. He sponsored terror activities in Punjab for Khalistan.
Pakistan became a terror state with the help of USA and Saudi Arab. Kashmir also came under terror activities. Zia ul Haque died in a plane crash. Democracy returned to Pakistan. But it was suffocated by Army again. Pak Army sabotaged all peace process with India including the Lahore Bus Journey by PM of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee. Then there was Kargil attack by Pakistan. It lost the Kargil war. In between Pakistan also tested atomic weapons. It threatened India on any small issue to nuke . Terrorism was sponsored by Pak army to damage India through Jihad in Kashmir. Pakistan sponsored dreaded terror groups in the name of Islam and Jihad. Pak PM Benazir Bhutto was eliminated by some terror group after her arrival in Pakistan. PM Nawaz Shariff was arrested and put in jail for some scandal. President Asif Zardari was arrested and put in jail. Army placed a puppet Government in Islamabad. Terror groups ruled Pakistan with Army.
Balochistan be came next victim of exploitation by Pakistan. Pakistan leased out some land from Gilgit to China. It started its terror hub in Muzafrabad. India faced terror problems from Pakistan. But Pakistan suffered badly in economic front. Now Pakistan is a failed state. It has no money to survive. Count down has started for the collapse of Pakistan. It is a matter of time before the theocratic state and terror state of Pakistan collapse completely.
*SuNaLa*
!As I Live I Learn!
nope, Israel also made on the basis of religion and many other countries also. Pakistan means land for Muslims - so nothing wrong with that. You are wrong about the size of the army - Pakistani is not responsible for Indian Muslims not moving to Pakistan yet and that is the reason you feel the size of the army is big. Pakistan didn't create that army it was inherited.
There are many countries where there is no democracy and they are doing great.
Agree that Pakistan should be grateful to India for giving them land but they are anti-India for no reason. Pakistan was not created for democracy, industries, education, and health care, so they have achieved their target. Pakistan was created to become a terror state.
Pakistan is not collasping anyway as of now. No idea what you are talking about, you have not mentioned any blunders but their achievements. You have also blamed Pakistan for the things that Indian Muslims have done.
Thanks to jinnah we have less muzlims in india. Otherwise it would be too much anarchy in india too
Wah shahzady kitab hi likh di 👏👏👏
One of the biggest mistake of Pakistan and the basis of all root problem is that Pakistani are suffering from identity crisis.
The Muslim community of Pakistan never accept Hindu community as their ancestors.
आप लोगो ने हिंदू समाज के लोगों को अपना दूशमन बना दिया और अपने बच्चों को हिन्दू समाज के प्रति नफरत सिखाया | अपने हिन्दू धर्म के लोगों को अपना पूर्वज कभी भी नही स्विकारा |
I think this is an extremely biased view, it has some truth in it of course but it’s mostly hyperbolic
No one can match the genuineness of Abbas Haider
This discussion should be included in our national syllables.
Fearless, enlightened intellectual. Privileged to listen to Mr.Hoodbhoy.
excellent work sir . One if the most Honesty interviews with great narratives, we should pray that all the predictions that Prof. Pervaiz indicated will come true. Ameen
6:24 India has 22 official languages. 38 languages are under consideration.
According to Press Trust of India -
More than 19,500 languages or dialects are spoken in India as mother tongues, according to the latest analysis of a census released.
Parvez Bhai is always my favourite.
- Capt Sudarshan Gupta, Mumbai
First time I have listen to pervez hoodbhay. One thing I can say that he is a true patriot of Pakistan. Wish you all the best sir!
@RK2022 proof please
Not really. He has himself said before: his concern is for the Pakistani _people_ not Pakistan the country. He says something similar in this video also:"Pakistan will break, so what? The Pakistani people will remain."
@@ArmageddonIsHere didnt notice that thanks
Incredible conversation. Hats off to you Pervez sb
This is an amazing interview with important lessons for India and many countries in the west also. It is, however, conducted in highly literate and scholarly Urdu, which limits its accessibility. It is highly desirable that it be made available with subtitles in Hindi and/or English.
The gentleman is speaking truth living in Pakistan
You can imagine his courage . Unfortunately,
One thing I m dead sure is that Pakistan is about to finish now. Artificial things don't last longer.
Breakup Pakistan into its constituent nations. Punjab, Sindh, Balochisthan etc.
Make their own language and culture as the centerpiece of their existence.
Individually, they might prosper.
That is against international laws.
@@vinamrasinghai2339 they should sit together and do it, else civil war.
Same is applicable on Indian States. As well.
China will gobble them up, one at a time.
@@tallatmumtazmir3267 well no. India is a civilizational state, unlike the artifical entity called Pakistan. The pull of all indian nation towards each other is too strong, by their 5000+ year old tradition and cultures. Democracy is making is stronger only.
Just think, Punjabi or Sindhi are Indian languages. Nothing to do with Islam or Arabic or Persian or Turki civilization.
Even Urdu is Indian language, nothing to do with Pakistan.
Or Bengali. Indian and Hindu languages if you want to claim it.
The reason Bangladesh is making progress is because they have no conflict with their Indian roots.
Once Pakistan is dissolved peacefully, Sindh or Punjab will be similar to Bangladesh.
Pakistan is an ideology. Not a state or a civilization or even a country
Awesome deep and educated discussion...thankyou 🥰🙏
Paying tax can not be viewed as anti-state . Nobody in the world wants to pay tax. It is the laws/rules of the state which forces people to pay.
Brilliant discussion on extremely important subjects! Dr Hoodbhoy, aapko salute hai 🙏...a learned man, not afraid to speak the truth! I wish you were living in India... Respect 🙏 🇮🇳
Mr Zubir of Alt news is very too, I hope you respect him.
Hoodboy sab Musulaman kabhi sudharenge nahi,kyunki there is too much racism like fight between Shia and Sunni and barlvi and deobandi,alhabis etc.How can you expect a kaum to improve when they don't trust their bethern or neighbour s
Jinnah was Politician not Statesman.
He was a lawyer.
@@vinamrasinghai2339 he was a hooray aspirant as well.... hare krishna
first time i am hearing such an honest interpretation of the stark reality .... pakistanis must remove the blindfold and where they are arrived after 70 years of independence . frankly it seems a impossible task to get Pakistan back on track as a successful state...
Is India any better? Watch parvez hood bai criticise from top to bottom but I can assure you the police will not come to arrest him or bulldoze his house like India.
@@HaidarAsmari , friend, dont get me wrong here but your comments adds more weightage to what my inference which is based on Dr Parvej's candid comments. unfortunately, u represent the voice of your country .... a voice which remains totally disconnected from reality , totally ignorant of the deep hole your beloved country has been digging itself into where there will be no one willing to bail out your country any more, whether its the world bank or IMF or the Saudis or Turkey or the main benefactor china. High time , you all set aside all your age old complex about india and realise the truth that india is heading to become the third largest economy and you are heading towards bankruptcy.... there is no malice here as these are ground realities which frankly should scare the shit our of every pakistani. rather than waste your time on the age old kashmir issue look at constructive measures to improve your economy . Come to your senses that the Bengalis of East Pakistan have a much stronger economy than West Pakistan and is steady pulling way increasing the gap in the GDP and per capita,. Come to your senses that when India was relatively weak in the 60s & 70s you could do nothing and now when the world considers India a rising power , do you seriously think u will get kashmir back. Is it not high time the aam admi in pakistan realises its army has been taking all in sundry for a ride by playing the war card either with india or baluchisthan or the pakisthani taliban in order to force a budget for the armed forces which your government clearly cannot afford. If you remove your sunglasses and carry out a reality check by being brutally honest with yourself , you will see that your army is struggling fighting off baluchis , talibans, other radical groups on your western front and you dont require your army on the eastern front because let me tell you something and i am not being arrogant but being brutally honest when i say .... India will never attack your country ... infact india of today gives a monkeys to what your govt or your press has to say ... Please try to understand that India has moved on with its own life and its high time you guys do the same and concentrate in nation building for a change
Both are intelligent person good talk
Pakistanis should start getting ready for partition of Pakistan in four parts. There is no hope even after that. Most Pakistanis will live like Somalians or Sudanes.
Hoodbhoy didn't explain why India is responsible for Kashmir problem. He has a brain fade that Maharaja of Kashmir had signed the deed of accession to merge with India and Pakistan were the aggressor just as they captured the hapless Balochistan which declared by Britishers as a Sovereign entity. So much for a unbiased intellectual huhh!!
Exactly my point
The only Physicist and Mathematician Academic in the world who blatantly expresses his knowledge on Sociology and Political Science. He had already said many years ago that Pakistan will be in great danger in every aspect . Now current situation proves that Dr. Hoodbhoy was Right . ✅ Happy to see you again sir . Thanks Abbas bhai also 🙏 😊
Haha
Jinah was a man without any principles, either good or bad. He had no qualms about running away with his friend's immature daughter. He thus deceived both her and his friend. He did not follow islam also. He consumed pork, drank liquor and rarely offered namaz. He was only concerned about himself so he used Islam for his own selfish end and created Pakistan to become it's head to remain a figure in history. He died early without setting any framework for Pakistan. He did not even considered it a priority. So he is primarily responsible for the subsequent mess in Pakistan. Let Pakistanis realise this and forget Kashmir and concentrate on development and move ahead.
Calling divisive and greedy Jinnah as secular is beyond laughable.
Hoodbhoy is a good boy for Pakistan. Pakistan should listen to him
Always a pleasure to listen to this program!
Regards to Abbas Haider for bringing this great intellectual on his channel. We may differ on certain points with Hoodbouy sahib, but it is always pleasure to hear him. He has a great following in India for his straightforward views.
Every country has an Army, in Pakistan Army has a country. And aap critical kyun nahin hai? Sirf 2 din ke liye majhab chod dijiye, logic aa jayega...let me ask you, are you God fearing or God loving man. 1 or 2 , and why that? Religion or Army will not allow the soldiers to apply mind👍
Dr. Prof. Parvez Hoodbhoy is a great analyst indeed.
Nice to know that some sensible people like dR.parveez , abbaas hamid and lots more well meaning people of Pakistan who are hidden there in Pakistan and who can
Bring a positive change Allah help them
Sir Words fail me to express my admiration 🙏🇮🇳
We would proud to have Prof sir with us. We will worship him.
The quintessential Hindu hunger for finding love from across the border. Dikkhar hai. Rise above this.
@@nicolasflamel3489 Dosta agar achhai rawan(Pakistan) m bhi ho to ussey sikhna hi hamri sanskriti h....
Watch 35:00
@@mukundbhardwaj5095 Unki acchi lete hi burayi kab aa Jaye pata nhi
Islam aur two nation theory samajo
Most Hindus have a natural instinct of becoming gulam..
He is a science man , who thinks and speaks logically, but how many ppl in Pak would agree with him.
George Washington also gave no road map for his new country USA, like Muhammad Ali Jinnah, but his colleagues in struggle decided to go for democracy and capitalism.
They were not Muslims 😀
Sir,It is impartial analysis of History.surprising fact is that a Physicist has deep sense of history and society.
Sir i don't concur with you over the statement that if Kashmir problem wasn't there you could have been better, we also had buy we grew, the problem is Islamic radicals taking over of Pakistan they would have done that if not Kashmir they would find any other reason
Still hope for pakistan as long as Dr.shaib and people like him excited in our society.
No hope as long as you have Sharifs, Imran Khan Niazi, judiciary, Army, and ordinary Pakistanis fighting each other but considering China a brother!
China, that hates Islam to the point of outlawing it, yet you think China is a brother!
China will gobble up Pakistan soon. End of the road now.
Hats off to this highly intellectual and candid person 👏 .
Real gem
A 7th century book that is full of faulty assumptions has been assumed to be the perfect book and 99% of your countrymen live according to it, then you still have to ask what went wrong? If you want to see your future look to the country on your west! We will be proud to take Dr Hoodbhoy as a citizen of India!!
Where he have options to take US UK EU Canada citizenship why would he choose india fucker!! It’s a third world country at the end
Insan bano
Second World War mae USA or UK ki marrrige hui tou eik child pada huwa jis ka nam Pakistan ha (Usa Pakistan ka father ha or mother UK ha)
Indian army and defence forces and their chiefs stay in the hearts of all indians. Jai Hind