ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ธ.ค. 2020
- PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to to.pbs.org/DonateEons
↓ More info below ↓
Figuring out what this creature’s face actually looked like would take paleontologists years. But understanding this weird animal can help us shine a light on at least one way for ecosystems to bounce back from even the worst mass extinction.
Thanks to Ceri Thomas (nixillustration.com) for the many excellent Triassic reptile illustrations (both Atopodentatus and Henodus) featured in this episode!
And thanks to Xiao-Chun Wu, Nick Fraser, and Shixue Hu for providing photos for this video!
Finally, thanks to Joschua Knüppe (www.deviantart.com/hyrotrioskjan) (the thumbnail illustration!), Julio Lacerda ( / juliotheartist , Jaime Headden (www.deviantart.com/qilong), and Dmitry Bogdanov for their wonderful paleoart as well.
Both Atopodentatus papers discussed in this video:
Cheng, L., Chen, X., Shang, Q. et al. 2014. A new marine reptile from the Triassic of China, with a highly specialized feeding adaptation. Naturwissenschaften 101, 251-259 DO1: 10.1007/s00114-014-1148-4
Chun, L., Rieppel, O., Long, C. & Fraser, N.C. 2016. The earliest herbivorous marine reptile and its remarkable jaw apparatus. Science Advances 2(5): e1501659 DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.1501659
And on the paper on the Luoping biota:
Hu, S., Zhang, Q., Chen, Z.Q., Zhou, C., Lu, T. Xie, T., Wen, W., Huang, J. & Benton, M.J. 2010. The Luoping biota: exceptional preservation, and new evidence on the Triassic recovery from end-Permian mass extinction. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 278: 2274-2282 doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2010.2235
Produced in collaboration with PBS Digital Studios: / pbsdigitalstudios
Super special thanks to the following Patreon patrons for helping make Eons possible:
Simon read, Reco Lee, Sean C. Kennedy, Eric Roberto Rodriguez, Charles Copley, Hillary Ryde-Collins, Facts Dinosaurs, Frida, YaBoiSam36, Matthew Donnelly, Yu Mei, Colleen Troussel, Dan Ritter, faxo, Gary Walker, Amanda Straw, Stephanie Tan, Anthony Callaghan, Minyuan Li, Ben Cooper, Leonid, Robert Noah, Matt Parker, Heathe Kyle Yeakley, Jerrit Erickson, Jack Arbuckle, Anton Bryl, MissyElliottSmith, Zachary Spencer, Stefan Weber, Andrey, Ilya Murashov, Larry Wilson, Merri Snaidman, Gabriel Cortez, Marcus Lejon, Robert Arévalo, Todd Dittman, Betsy Radley, Laura Sanborn, PS, Philip Slingerland, John Vanek, Eric Vonk, Henrik Peteri, Jon Monteiro, James Bording, Miles Chaston, Michael McClellan, Jeff Graham, Maria Humphrey, Daisuke Goto, Gregory Kintz, Chandler Bass, Tsee Lee, Robert Hill
If you'd like to support the channel, head over to / eons and pledge for some cool rewards!
Want to follow Eons elsewhere on the internet?
Facebook - / eonsshow
Twitter - / eonsshow
Instagram - / eonsshow
References: docs.google.com/document/d/1n... - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
"Yo this thing has a zip mouth"
Atopodentatus: 0 0
. .
___________________
Merp face
😐
Why the long face
This "thing" beats is the tully monster.
0. 0
______________
4:46 So that's what you get when you combine an axolotl, a turtle, and a loaf of bread.
So that's why I immediately loved this creature!
Him
And a harmonica.
@@raptorfae.6645 iiti
maybe a platypus too
If it’s face had been fully discovered in the early 2000’s it totally would have been a supporting character in Ice Age. It would have been a kid favorite!
Yall just making stuff up now. Earth is a plane
@@galvanizedgnome and I am king of England
@@galvanizedgnome nah bro it's a velociraptor
@@galvanizedgnome Isn't it a submarine?
@@galvanizedgnome Wrong. It’s a helicopter
"So you either die a fossil or live long enough to see yourself in another mass extinction event
" _Atopo𝗗𝗲𝗻𝘁atus to the Pterosaur.
Good lord, that is a deep cut
Most of species had not even succeeded to produce fossiles.
You leave a fossils behind then after many reincarnations...find yourself again...🤣😂🤣😂🤣
"Remember that name you all had for me when was in the triassic ocean, what was it paleontologists?"
"...."
"Say it!"
"Atopodentatus."
@@ashu21 sure hurts
Honestly for the Triassic this is just normal now
You could say the same for the Cambrian and Miocene
@@raptorfae.6645 really earth is just weird in general
@@neB282 yeh,but have you ever read books like after man,a zoology of the future? As weird as life in the past got there's no way in hell we know how it'll be in the future...
Weirder is cooler for me :P
@@Fede_99 if there was no weird there would be no uniqueness therefore no coolness so yeah weird is the best
1:14 "It turns out switching from eating other animals to eating plants is a harder transition than you might think."
Giant pandas: Nah, we just stayed on the mountain at the same altitude even though it was getting cold and the other animals ran away to where it was warm so we just started eating bamboo.
And we all know how well giant pandas are doing evolutionarily right now
@@samuelmelcher333 But you gotta admit, they look like they're having fun.
They kinda survive on aesthetics nowadays
@@samuelmelcher333 One of them mastered Kung Fu, so that’s a pretty impressive evolutionary advantage
I know it was easy for me. Never been healthier.
It's so weird not hearing Steve's name when they list the eontologists
Yeah, it still feels wrong that they aren't mentioned at the end.
I wonder what happened to Steve, i hope he's okay
Hope he's ok, he hasn't been mentioned for quite some time
I'm sure he's fine, he probably just stopped paying the $150 a month it takes to get your name in the end credits.
Covid Economy got Steve. Poor guy. Hope he bounces back.
Imagine having a time machine and going back to the triassic. There has to be species that didn't get preserved and absolutely strange
All my life I have fantasized about how wondrous it would be to safely time travel!
Imagine appearing infront of a predator...
Instantly regret...
@@justabby4528 Not as bad as being if front of Joe
@@Hugo-yz1vb mama?
Fossil records makes up like less than 1% of all species alive, some things we simply don’t even know what they could even look like, anything living in jungles is effectively impossible to fossilize
The Triassic presents us another evolutionary weirdo.
As if our own feet are normal in any way.
@@tsopmocful1958 our feet are indeed terribly strange
@@tsopmocful1958 We’ve strayed too far from monke
@@Odinsday we must reject hooman and return to monke
@@AbbacchiosJuicyTits hmmm Monke
Was about to sleep, but nope-eons is life.
Same!
Not me it’s only 6:45pm
There is no sleep. There is only Eons.
Who goes to sleep at 4:00 pm?
@@neB282 some people are in different time zones and some people take naps
Steve! Our Eontologist Steve, bless his soul, where did he go?
Idk
Please come back!!
I miss the closure "and Steve!" so much
Unfortunately they had to scale back their contributions to the patreon, presumably because of the current pandemic and its economic toll.
ALL HAIL STEVE!!
Imagine how wrong some of our ideas must be about these animals. I mean, just take a hippo's skeleton. If you looked at it you'd imagine some monster from Star Wars, when in reality it's just a chonky water horse. Just think about how wrong a lot of our reconstructions might be without the actual soft tissue giving us a solid clue. Perhaps the Triassic creatures weren't half as weird.
I think of that often. Bones can only show so much. The face of a moose is kinda odd but you wouldn't know it from the skull. Think of a horse and its skull, would it look different if we had no known images or living species? How about a soft shell turtle or even better an owl. The owl looks like any other raptor sans feathers but its feathers give it a unique look. The Neanderthals look like primitive cave people bc the artist think of them that way but we really dont know what they look like.
@@olliefoxx7165 That is actually a miss representation of how the scientist reconstruct fossils. The moose would have its face, also for the horse and even hippos, guiven complete enough fossils. If the feathers of the Owl preserve, we surly could reconstruct its look to a certain degree (even its color now days).
Now with Neanderthals it's a very different story because they are our closest relative. We even could interbreed with them, and have their complete genome, so the best face we have of past species is actually the Neanderthal. We only need our modern forensic reconstructions techniques and genomic analysis to do it
Elephant skulls used to be thought as Cyclop heads in ancient Greece
I agree with shadowmax. Over the years, 'reconstruction' of muscle tissue based on fossils has evolved tremendously, also thanks to modern day scan techniques (e.g. for bone density and texture) and 3D computer drawing programs.
+MrMezmerized I still think it would be hard to tell what sort of muscular or cartilaginous growths there were on some creatures. An elephant, for example. A trunk is such a weird thing, and if we didn't have living elephants then it's possible our reconstructions of mammoths and such might end up having no trunks.
Same with us, really. Look at how many non-bony growths and weird special adaptations we have. No other animal has feet like ours, and it may be hard for another sentient species to accurately reconstruct that for a dead humanity. Look at our noses, and our ears. Hell, look at our gonads, those certainly won't survive to fossilize. On the minor end, they may misrepresent how much hair we have, too much or too little. They may only get a miraculous specimen of human hair patterns from a balding man's corpse and conclude we all looked this way since birth since male pattern balding is itself an a weird and unique phenomenon. Likewise, they may never know it existed because it wasn't preserved.
Maybe I'm just being a skeptic but I doubt we're being portrayed as anything but earless, noseless ape monsters, presumably ones who use their long fear hands to grasp tree branches while we swoop down and haul up a fresh kill with our forelimbs unless some remnants of human culture and depictions of us and our society manage to survive that long.
Actually, perhaps the Voyager is our best hope of being reconstructed, as it shows a man and woman, and that we come from earth. Granted they may think we were nudists, but it proves we were sentient and on the edge of spacefaring, if only they can find it out there in space.
It's official: George Lucas has a time machine. That's how the Star Wars animals were "designed", he just went back in time and reproduced what he saw.
did man discover the circle or create it?
Reproduced
Hummmm
or maybe Spielberg shared with him Paul's notes...
I've also been convinced for some time he also capitalized on a big time score with special effects.
Without computer capabilities, I doubt Star Wars would have gone anywhere.
Well this is why it says before the opening crawl... "Along time ago, in a galaxy far far away..."
The end of the Permian: they’re just never going to let us forget, are they?
I feel like there should be bumper stickers for The Great Dying 😁
I'll buy one if you make it.
"I survived the great dying and all I got was this t-shirt". Applies to 2020 as well.
P-Tr: never forget.
Written across the outline of a gorganopsid? Or perhaps a trilobite?
@@Roboprogs both
Where did you come from?
Where did you go?
Where did you come from, weird teeth joe??
loving that pfp
The Khat
Every single Eons host is just fantastic at what they do.
Strangest Teeth, Atopodentatus v. Helicoprion. FIGHT
mozasaurs?
Edestus !
Nothing really strange about Helicoprion's teeth. It was their jaws that were weird AF.
Insert obligatory british teeth joke here
Dude parasuars have a block of teeth in the middle of their mouth that their tongue wrapped around like a tumbler using it's tongue to push plants towards the middle of it's mouth back and forth I'd say that's another under the rader jaw weirdos
This is one of the greatest channels ever. Thank you PBS Eons for providing us with so many quality videos.
This video literally taught me energy through a food chain in seconds while my science teacher be taking three weeks.
Don't underestimate how much you needed your teachers instruction to understand the brief overview.
Ask permission to send your teacher a link. Maybe...just maybe...it will be an excuse for the entire class to watch TH-cam during school.
Atopodentatus immediately became one of my favorite prehistoric animals when I first learned about it. This creature's appearance is so fascinating, which is saying a lot considering what the early Triassic has to offer.
I may riot in the continued absence of our beloved Steve
The original Two-Face.
Because I'm Batman
The origins of batman was never found
No. As she eventually (kinda) explained "two faces" was click bait.
Someone has to say what PBS can't
@@Tachyon1457 pog
"Can we have platypus?"
"We have platypus at home"
The platypus at home:
😆😆
Watching the beginning of this felt like when you're trying to keep yourself from telling your friend about the upcoming plot twist being a fan of Atopodentatus myself.
Yessss the former zipper-faced flipper friend
They call him zipper, zipper, faster than lighting!
NES ADDICT what?
@@cg-rezi7597 you tube flipper tv intro.
Tongue twister!
Former friend? What happened?
It kinda looks like a platypus?? >. >
Triassic is just so weird I can't be surprised any more
There are two things I really want to learn about right now: how did sharks turn into rays? My other question stems from your video discussing the Mesozoic marine revolution; Are there any niches that have gone away? Like ammonite or trilobite specialist perhaps?
Could you do an episode on taxonomy, phylogeny, and the tree of life, along with an explanation of when animals are considered two different species. And an episode on leviathan melviliai.
Aron Ra here on you tube has a 50 part series on that exact thing.
You expect that to be covered in one episode?!
@@LuinTathren no, I need lots of episodes. On everything.
that would be awesome!
@@larryscarr1929 Aron Ra can't get beyond his crusade to inform on anything.
This species is The Literal 🅱iological and Existential animal representation of the depiction known as *Bruh*
The DORUK I think I lost a couple of brain cells reading this
not as much as Bruh-chiosaurus.
@@MrDerek-km6xw *Perfect!*
True my dudes
Bruh chain
Every time I watch an eons video I am reminded how crazy and amazing our world is... Evolution is actually amazing.
The play dough and toothpick model is hilarious!
They seem nice in person but I bet they talk about you behind your back to their other friends.
The original big mouth.
I don’t know why I thought you were talking about the hosts
“Two-faced reptile” sounds like a good description for an unpleasant person like that
I’m obsessed with eons pbs 😩😍
Me too because I love animals. 😁👍
Me too
@@MaoRatto To be honest, I actually like both.
That means you have an appetite for knowledge
@@MaoRatto better is subjective, PBS (eons) has better presentation mothlight has a bit more depth, both amazing channels
"The Fossil Has Two Faces," starring Reptilia Streisand.
@@GPrinceps Right now, I've got 42: that's even cooler.
Ooo! Now we’re up to 69! 😈
A two faced herbivore? Must've spilled a lot of tea back in it's day.
Thank you for doing both pronunciations of niche.
and h in herbs 😊 it was a really nice nodd to the otje side of The Pond 🥰
Well, there is only one pronunciation. They have to cater too the American English Garbo lol
@@bradleywayne2788 oh shush with thinking how you say things is “superior” to others if the people saying it are American they say it the way Americans do, Other people say it how they want. pronunciation it’s also not exclusive to where you live so get off your high horse
@@sirsanti8408 No, the people who need to take account of what you say are Americans. The way many Americans speak makes it hard to work out what words they're saying, so this makes communication harder than it needs to be. This is the problem not the solution.
Oh damn, didn't expect to see Henodus in there. It was found near my university! :D
Little known fact that the two faced lizard exists in the modern era, I dated one for several weeks
damnn
LOL ROASTED.
I thought you were about to drop some scientific facts but it was really a sick burn
I see what you did there when you said, "Let's face it." Lol, nice jokes and great delivery. Awesome content as well. Cheers
Atopodentatus is proof that anything we consider common knowledge about a prehistoric animal could potentially become 100% wrong in the future.
proof that all 'scientific facts' are just the *current* observed truths, that can be challenged at any day. We are limited by what we can see, and we can't see everything.
@@deeya There are few or no scientific "facts" as science is constantly changing and updating. However, the more data, the less likely we are wrong.
The original depictions was not considered a fact though. It was just a hypothesis based on limited data
Can't wait until future paleontologists discover that it's all just barn owls.
@@unclekanethetiberiummain1994 Or basking sharks. XD
"This is called niche partitioning or niche partitioning"
you are too kind ;D
I have never heard it pronounced nitch!
Nietzsche partitioning
@@hlvr123 *in kermits voice: "well it depends on what you mean by partitioning..."
@@clickrick 'murica
I remember reading about these in grade 2. They where my favourite marine reptile because of their face. I thought they where ADORABLE
Steve, you're not forgotten. Just putting that out there. 💜
where is he.
@@alucardnolifeking789 They did a vid a little while ago saying steve couldn't contribute anymore. It was a hard time for all. I just knew the time had come to an end when they were like andddd steve lol. Sad.
Very cool and interesting reptile, I wish they were still around in the oceans today
I love it when I learn about a taxon that I never heard about! Though, aetosaurs are still my favorite herbivorous Triassic reptile. Aetosaurs - the "cro-cow-diles."
So genuine question, if we've only found one of a species, how do we know it doesn't have a birth defect?
Total guess, but, with modern wild animals, we would expect one with major deformities to die very young, so an adult would be less likely to have that kind of defect. Add to that the relative rarity of gross deformities in the first place, and it's reasonable to assume, in the absence of other evidence, that a given fossil is probably typical. There's a lot of "probably" in paleontology.
@@Amanda-C. so short response, it's unlikely, shorter response, we don't.
@@TheSucidalpanda Fair.
I love these episodes about the weirdest animals in the mesozoic. The visuals are always on point!
I love Eons! You always make my day when you release another episode! 💗🦖🦕 Thank you for making my day!
I love when PBS eons posts a new video! It shows animals from the past and learning from them! Merry christmas!🦖🦕
🐊
This where the “why the long face” came from
Every time you guys mention "the great dying" it sounds like something taken from the land before time or something
Ikr? I keep on thinking of that everytime they say it
MERRY CHRISTMAS PBS EONS CREW!! Have a very great week and a very happy new year!! Stay warm!🎄✨🎅🏼❤️💚
You guys should do the weird marsupials from Riversleigh in Australia.
Every time I see these preserved fossils
I can’t see any details so props
To the people who know what they’re looking at
ok but at 5:42, i couldn’t help but laugh at that still frame. like,, come on. that’s beautiful
Strange but fascinating. Never heard of this animal before. Thank you.
did you have a falling out with Steve? Is Pat Seifert a rebound?
3:23 *unusually intense meditative music starts*
What a weird little thing. I love it!
I am a simple man, I see PBS eons upload, I click.
Merry Christmas to all at
PBS Eons! Love you all ❤️
It's Happy Holidays. You lost the War on Xmas.
@@angryhairpeice you spelled "holiday" wrong 🙄
@@macgonzo Thanks. I'll fix it.
I love these videos. When I get depressed from watching other YT videos about how terrible things are now I come to these and cleanse my brain.
Takes “zip your lips” to a new meaning.
The great dying was literally some bruh casting languish
The Triassic really did produce some 'alien' looking creatures.
Always so excited for your videos! The cadence of speaking, the way they make the material engaging, this speaker is excellent at what they do!
Literally everyone: WHY?
Atopodentatus: I'm just built different
This is getting out of hand
Now there are 2 of them
But they were no match for Droidekas
8:36, thank you for pronouncing niche correctly after doing it how you usually pronounce it. My ears were pleased.
You guys should do a host vs host episodes, where you pick a topic and then compete to pick the best creature to fit that topic, example, cutest burrower, weirdest looking glider, or funniest mating rituals. And the viewers get to vote for the winner. Could be really fun.
So weird and so cool; makes you appreciate this magnificent world of ours
all the marine reptiles are such an amazing mystery. Id like to know more about their detailed looks. like, since they had to evolve past their cold blooded nature, did they outwardly resemble convergent fatty tissue appearance like whales and seals? or were they still scaly and looked totally new and different, like some sort of chubby thick crocodile. The idea of reptiles being big ocean predators seem terrifying, since reptiles are so bloodthirsty and non-empathetic.
Wow, every time I think I've read, heard, seen the weirdest find after the mass extinction event,...what the?
First video where this host didn't use the title of the video as her ending line.. That is definitely a good moment where everything in this video, this channel and our lives comes together in a one-liner
I don't know how I managed to come this far in life without knowing about Aquatic Iguanas, it's strange
Yay my favourite TH-cam series :)
I’m told this was posted 2 min ago ... 30th comment crazy .
Shout out to pbs eons , great stuff . Big history buff , all forms of it . Great show .
I love these representations of art of these certain species but it would be so dynamic and incredible to be able to see them in real life. It would probably change our outlook on these ancient animals and "dinosaurs" if we could see them in life.
Your channel is making my quarantine exciting and educational, thank you!
Love learning about 🌏 and all it’s previous and current awesome inhabitants
Your enthusiasm is contagious, Kallie!
Other people with a time machine: world domination!
Me with a time machine: time to check out all the old weird creatures
This is such an awesome and wholesome channel. I absolutely love your videos! Thank you!!
She’s such a dope host, great content.
Hi! I would like to know more about dinosaur mummies and their soft tissues.
I love all of your videos. They're so educational and informative. Kudos.
Pbs eons should come with a warning label: very addictive 😍!
I love all three the hosts, with a special place in my heart for Kallie😄
I came here while I was watching archer. This is more important.
& arguably funnier! “Eyesuar” 📝😂👍🏻
@@benjaminstowe9017 yeah, very different kinds of humor.
Get the feeling - but loving Archer too! 😃
Why does learning about stuff that I wasn’t alive for make me nostalgic
It's been Eons since I saw such a thoroughly delightful episode!
I love PBS Eons and melodysheep. Absolutely amazing channels one is for evolution and the other for space
Not gonna lie...I miss Steve...I think you should add him back just cause, I mean he did support you for years as far as I can tell...and the show doesn't end right without the usual shout out to Steve...
I think of Steve whenever these episodes end.
I too miss Steve but adding them to the shout-outs without the patreon backing would be a bit weird as others in the shout-out give patreon backing.
Go home Triassic, you're drunk
Blake suffers through the puns
But this gal? RELISHES them
I love it
Was just scrolling through the Eons list & just realized that I have watched everyone of them! So come on you two, get to work and crank out a bunch more! Ha ha ha ha. Just goes to show the quality of your work. Rock On!
WHERE IS STEVEEEEE!
So what’s the weirdest organism in paleontology then?
Tully monster is probably one of the weirdest
I have always liked the earliest forms of life, would be great if you could do an episode with a deeper look at early Triassic species!
You guys astound me! You keep finding the most interesting species! love your vid article. Thank you. Enjoy the holidays and New years.