I bought the Kindle 2021 (non-signature edition) per recommendations from you and other TH-cam Channels and have not regretted it. It’s a wonderful device that has all the things I want in an e-reader. I agree that wireless charging and even the auto-brightness is just gimmicky. I wouldn’t use them. As for the storage I don’t have any audiobooks, manga, or comics. Just about 50 books downloaded and there’s plenty of space. Thank you telling me that around 2,500 books downloaded I might go over the 8 gig limit. I can’t imagine I would keep that many on the device and even if I did that’s what Amazon cloud is for. Great review! I simply adore your videos about the books you read and try to watch your new videos when I can. Have a good day Sir.
Did you pay to have the adverts removed ? Does your device also refresh for no reason like the signature model ? If your answer is “ yes “ to both these questions, then I’d rather stick on to my 7th gen paperwhite model, and buy a clip on blue light filter ( I wear glasses ), for night reading. As for extra space on the device, I just have to delete some old books - but we can also rely on Amazon cloud for more space. In my opinion, these new paper whites are not worth the money paid for them. I’m waiting for the model that will easily convert a book to the bionic font for rapid reading. The money I saved to get the new paperwhite will now be spent on that great bread machine I’ve been eyeing for a while !
@@patnathan5013 hello. No I did not have to pay to remove Ads. I bought the Kindle Paperwhite Kids Edition during a flash sale on Amazon. Kids edition has no ads, double the warranty and comes with cover. It’s the same Paperwhite as the non-signature edition just with a kids UI that you can turn off. Better deal overall. No mine never had refreshed unexpectedly or rebooted except to install a firmware update.
I have two Paperwhites. I’ve never had any automatic reboots. The Paperwhite is phenomenal, the battery is great, easy to carry in a purse so convenient !
the battery life is absolutely incredible. even if you notice it's getting low, you can still read for a bit before it runs out, compared to phones or tablets where after it gets to 10% you have a little over an hour before it turns off, if you don't really use it. instead, if you want to read and you notice the battery is low, you can probably read normally until you're home or you can charge it for an hour. best thing ever
Tha advantage of using the kindle signature for audio books is that battery life. When traveling, the phone us in constant use. I use the kindle for my books AND audio books. Especially when I am down the beach or in the woods for multiple days and do not have a power supply that i do not carry.
@@CriminOllyBlog Honestly, I did not realize the ease of monitoring your device and removing books that you do not want to take with you. Had I understood that it would be so easy and I would still retain the books, I would have looked more at other deals. I might have found the Kid's bundle before buying the Kindle, and that is the best deal out there. It is the same price as the regular Kindle, but with a 2-year hassle-free warranty and a cover (the black is ok) (I included this information even though it is repeated in other posts for other readers of the Post. I know CrimiOlly is aware of this information already)
Interesting. I don't know that I've noted the poor battery life with my Oasis. I'll have to pay more attention. Weirdly enough, I notice the tiny extra bit of screen size of the Oasis over the Paperwhite (.2") and it feels like a major deal for me. At the same time, I like the warmer hand-feel of the Paperwhite over the metal of the Oasis, although I live in Minnesota, so perhaps my Oasis just naturally colder much of the year!
I wonder why it reboots. I suspect it's updating the software automatically. Does it reboot on its own on [AIRPLANE] mode? The downsides to it for me are: 1. I actually wish it were smaller! 2. Side buttons would be good (like the Nook). 3. Try going back on a big book more than 10 pages and it's a chore. This is part of why I am still not fully vested on e-readers.
I don't think it is updates as seems to be happening too often for that (and I would expect some sort of a notification when it did an update). I like the size, but equally I would LOVE a pocket sized e-ink device that I could read on. I think there are a few options out there but need to look into it more.
I want to buy one of these on Prime day tomorrow. I went to a local store to check them out. I love the way the Oasis feels in the hand. It is so balanced plus the buttons. However the Oasis screen had a lot of ghosting, like screen burn in, and the contrast didn't seem as good as the Paperwhite. The blacks on the Paperwhite looked darker while the Oasis screen looked washed out. They had them in some sort of demo mode so I couldn't play with brightness settings and the store lighting was very bright. Still not sure which to get.
If you read a lot and don't want to have to charge it every day then I would definitely recommend the Oasis. I don't feel there is much to choose between the screens tbh. Agree that the design of the Oasis is great though.
I've had the Signature Edition since launch, replacing my elderly Oasis and can only say good things about it. Unlike you, I use the wireless charging exclusively - I just plonk it on the wireless charger and pick it up later on, there's no fiddling with cords or plugs (even say that, USB-C is a huge leap over the old micro-USB plugs). In terms of hand-feel, I use one of the Kindle cases because it has the front flap that protects the screen when I chuck it in a bag etc. The case (cork) also gives me a bit more security in terms of holding the device. I've never once had mine spontaneously reboot - I'm wondering whether yours is down to a problem with your device. Another plus side to the latest Kindles is the speed of the processors - the Oasis I had before was almost unbearably slow in terms of navigating the interface where the Signature edition is so much more responsive.
Yeah I’ve got a case for mine now for when I travel. I do like the fact it switches the device on when you open it. Also completely agree about the processor power. Makes using the device much more pleasant
I still have free, old model - has the keyboard. It’s a bit limiting but I’ve only read 2 or 3 books on it. Your advice is welcome though as I’m considering a newer model.
I recently got a regular Paperwhite. It did not cost me anything as I ‘purchased’ it using my Telco’s reward points :). The last Kindle I bought was a 4th edition purchased in either 2011 or 2012. For the last few years I have been reading eBooks using my iPad. I am enjoying books more on the Kindle as using my iPad meant I was often distracted. I am still on to my first book on my new Kindle but it is Shogun so it is a long book.
Only, I just ordered the KPW SE and before doing so, I asked customer service at Amazon if I could charge it with the adapter. Just like charging the standard Mandel. They told me yes. But I didn’t see on the video a actual outlet on the device to do so. Is it wireless charging only? Or can I actually plug directly into the device to charge it? I’m waiting for it to arrive.
For me the Oasis wins hands down! Why? First and foremost, the ergonomic grip cannot be beat for ease of holding. It’s a pleasure to hold which is enhanced by the autorotate feature allowing you to change hands and still enjoy the ergonomic grip. And then there’s the page turn buttons 😊. Regarding battery life: I leave mine in airplane mode most of the time and it helps a lot. Though the truth is, I usually plug it in daily just like my phone so it’s not a big deal. For those who don’t like the “coldness” or slipperiness of the back, I’d suggest buying a kindle skin. It adds some grip but doesn’t increase weight like a case. When I take it out and about, I put it in a Kindle sleeve.
I did like the design of the Oasis quite a bit. I had the first gen as well and I thought what they did with that and the charging cover was pretty great. If the 3rd gen had a similar design I’d have been a lot happier with it.
My problems are the random reboots, it takes multiple taps (2-3x) before an ebook downloads, no ePub book covers in the library, power button on the bottom, and frequent slowdowns when navigating through the UI. Another issue I have is the Paperwhite will download multiple copies of the same ebook. I don't understand why. I have the Kindle Paperwhite Signature Edition. I love the last Kindle Oasis released, but the battery life is horrible. My Oasis drains in 1 day. I wish the Kindle Oasis had USB Type C, better battery life and a rubberized back for grip. It could have a 7.8" screen as well. I have over 6K ebooks on my Kindle Paperwhite Signature Edition. 6,369 ebooks last check. I love horror books!!!
I’ve not had the issue of multiple copies of a book being downloaded. Agree that having the power button at the bottom is a terrible design choice though. If they can fix the battery life I’d buy a 7.8” rubberised Oasis with USBC in a heartbeat! And I thought I had a lot of books!!!!
The long battery life sounds like a good thing. I know with my phone, which is where I read my ebooks, if I read even a couple hours a day without using my phone for anything else, it's low on battery already, lol. It's a pity the light adapting doesn't really work well. Though I guess each kind of Kindle has a certain audience that loves them.
I've owned several Kindle Fires. The first one died because something went weird with the power cord. The one I replaced that with got shattered and my poltergeist later decided to pick it up and try to break it in half. I wish I'd been able to get that on film or at least SEE it, because I heard it happening. I'd left it in a padded envelope on my bed, and I went to the bathroom, and I heard this "'pop pop pop" sound coming from my room. When I came back I found it on my bed, out of the envelope where I'd left it. It was bent and the casing was partially popped open, but no one was in the room at the time! I replaced it with another Kindle Fire. The first one got a shattered screen, which Amazon replaced. Then the replacement got a big scratch across the screen; I have no doubts it was the poltergeist that caused both, but I told Amazon it came out of the package that way! So they took it back and replaced it again. AMAZON'S CUSTOMER SERVICE IS FUCKING AMAZING. I've kept an eagle eye on my most recent, but it's still been bent (light leak and one pixel out!) and the poltergeist got hold of it and broke the power cord. It broke my headphones at the same time; funny enough, that's the last time the poltergeist came into my room. Now it just throws stuff at my bedroom door and writes me nasty messages--might even be a different poltergeist. Anyway, I love my Kindle Fire. I use it for reading, but also for watching TH-cam and Netflix when I don't feel like setting up my laptop and want to watch something bigger than my phone! And one more time for those in the back, Amazon's customer service is BOMB. They are awesome!
Yeah that is one thing they’re great at. I suspect part of the reason they’re so good on their devices is that they want people to own them so they can sell them books and movies and so on. Sorry you’ve had such bad luck with your Fires though!
I bought the 8g kindle pw just couldn't justify the other features . And the 32gb was the only real reason that would have made me buy the signature . I've only got 250 book on mine so a couple thousand left to fill it . I also have a kobo clara hd to fill as well. If I ever get to the stage of running out of space I'll delete books I've already read . And I've had a couple random reboots as well .
Excellent review of the Signature and your round up comments on the different kindles at the end. Thank you. I have a Paperwhite 7th edition plus an Oasis 9th ed 8gb. I have posted (at amazons cost) my Oasis to Amazon under there trade up offer. I will receive £60 for the Oasis together with 20% discount on a new Kindle. I did not use the Oasis much in fact it stayed at home, I preferred to take the 7th edition with me on my travels. it is smaller and fits very comfortably into jacket pocket or inside pocket. the Oasis I found would not fit into pockets easily. The battery on the 7 lasted much longer than the oasis. In conclusion the new 8gb Paperwhite will suit my needs perfectly, pocketable and I don't need the wireless charging or the auto back light function. I was leaning towards the Signature but your excellent comments made me realise that the entry level is the way to go, plus I can spend the money I will save on more ebooks. David
Thanks so much for the comparison and your view on the Kindle Paperwhite. I was tempted, but ultimately stuck with my 2018 Paperwhite as I didn't see enough improvements to want me to upgrade. When they come out with a color eInk display though - then I'll reconsider :)
Yeah I am definitely intrigued to see what the next big innovation is. Although I’m not sure I actually have a real need for a colour screen as all I do is read text on mine.
@@CriminOllyBlog Yes, That is the intent, but it is a great idea for adults. It often goes on sale for less than the cost of a regular Paperwhite, and it has that fantastic warranty. That warranty is worth a bit of cash. The only difference between the models (of the standard paperwhite and the kid's paperwhite) is that the kid's version comes with a FEW pre-installed apps or discounts for some kid's books that Amazon wants to promote. AND they can be deleted. So for the EXACT SAME PRICE, you get a no-questions warranty on breakage for any reason, a case (the black one is very adult-looking). It is a Must Buy for anyone that does not need the Signature edition. I bought the signature edition for the extra storage for audio books but had I found the "kids" bundle, I would have bought that and simply monitored the number of audio books on my device.
@@michaelreed649 and no annoying lock screen ads! The included case cover is not as good as the regular one, which you will need to pay additional 20-30 USD
I don’t recall any random reboots on my Signature Edition. I’ve had about six months too. For the most part, it’s great, though I do miss my Oasis - except the terrible battery life. I do with Amazon would make a 10” Kindle.
There do seem to be a lot more E-ink devices from other manufacturers with larger or smaller screens, as well as colour and so on. I’d be surprised if Amazon doesn’t try something on those lines before too long.
I only own the standard paperwhite and it does reboot at least once every couple of days (that I've seen) my guess would have been some kind of software update but it's happening when I'm scrolling through books looking for something to read?.. So maybe it's a software glitch rather than anything major... And they are cheaply made, I dropped my 1st one from a small height & the screen cracked, my bad and my new one is in a case..
@@CriminOllyBlog I dropped my one from around waist high, no damage except a crack across the top part of the screen making it useless.. For a few extra pound I can't recommend a case enough. & of course it saves the swearing on the train as you look at your ereader that's now fit only for the bin.. 😩
The auto-brightness needs to be “trained”, switch it on and adjust the brightness under different light conditions and the sensors will learn your particular settings. And in regards to your kindle randomly restarting fortnightly, that is not normal, nor have i heard of anyone else having a similar issue and i frequently visit the kindle subreddit.
FYI, CriminOlly is a fantastic name for your channel. You are clearly well read, so I have a question for you. I am about to go camp on the beach for a week. Do you have any suggestions for camping on a beach in isolation? I am thinking deserted island or some such setting. I have "The Island of Doctor Moreau" on my Kindle (yes, I am embarrassed to admit that I have not read it yet), But would like more books for the trip. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Thank you! I actually haven't read The Island of Dr Moreau! I should really fix that. Other ones that spring to mind - 'The Ruins' by Scott Smith, 'The Beach' by Alex Garland, 'Forgotten Island' by David Sodergren. Maybe throw in some Tarzan too? Or some H Rider Haggard if you fancy something more adventure focused.
I use my tablet if I have to read an ebook, but I prefer to read a physical copy. I had a kindle DX at one time, and it was terrible. I got the DX for my sister because of the large screen and text to voice, but it was too difficult for her to use because of her disability. So I ended up trying to use it, but the page turning was way too slow, and before long the battery would not hold a charge. I probably didn't read a complete book on it before disposing of it. $400 CAN wasted. Since I don't enjoy reading with the kindle app on my tablet, I assume a modern kindle would not be much better. A tablet or kindle would be great on the go, but in the summer I don't have a pocket big enough for my 8 in tablet. So I grab a pocket book when I am going somewhere. I did read ebooks on my phone for a while, but then it would take a year or more to read a book, since I would only read it when out somewhere and had to wait around.
I think you’re the first person I know who owned a DX! I’ve always been intrigued by it because it seemed like a bit of a crazy device. I think you’d find page turns and so on much quicker on a newer kindle
Current Kindles are much faster than the DX. Not sure what happened with your battery, but I still use an ereader from 2011 and the battery still lasts at least a week. Reading on a black and white eink screen is different than reading on a phone or tablet. Closer to a printed page. If you are in a store and see a Kindle or a Kobo, I'd suggest at least checking them out to see how they are.
Are you sure you are not accidently knocking the power button with your finger? I've done that many times. And regarding the position of the power button ....
Have been a Kindle Basic version owner for 5 years (1 non front lit, 1 front lit) but now although I still prefer the Kindle Store, I use a Kobo Libra 2 now. Calibre with DeDRM is amazingly useful.
That’s useful! I’ve got Calibre and DeDRM but the one thing I haven’t got sorted is the ability to import files in the new Amazon format (which I forget the name of now)
@@CriminOllyBlog I download using my pc from the Kindle site of books i own and they download in the format i mentioned. Calibre and DeDRM has no problem with those. The only place i find the kfx format is on my Kindle itself if i download with the kindle.
What does Without Kindle Unlimited mean? What does Lockedscreen Ad supported mean? I’m thinking of buying a regular Paperwhite and there are options that I need to choose from.
Hi there. Kindle Unlimited is a subscription service from Amazon that gives you access to free kindle books and audiobooks. The range is limited but there is a lot of good stuff there. You pay a monthly fee but can cancel anytime. You can also add it at any time, so if you’re not sure you want it I would select without for now. Lock Screen ads basically means that when your kindle is not being used Amazon will show ads for books it think you’ll like on the screen (just a static image). It’s not too intrusive but can be a bit annoying.
You must have a lemon Oasis or something. My Oasis lasts about a week and a half in between charges with wifi always on. I read on it at least a couple hours a day.
I found weird that your unite keeps rebooting, I've had Paperwhite 1, 3 & 5 (non signature edition) and some family and friends have had some others too .. never experienced a reset at all, I think your unit is faulty .. make a warranty claim if still can
@@CriminOllyBlog I'm glad to read it was software related so it could get fixed just by wait the update .. great review btw, agree with everything, just the plasticky feel -of course it's there- isn't a deal breaker for me
@@CriminOllyBlog thanks. I tend to just wind mine once per day if not wearing. I was wondering if any excessive wear and tear has been noticed when you have them serviced.
Great review!, As always. Regarding the problem that the Kindle restarts by itself did you try to check if is not an update? It will be good to know if this is the issue. I only see that when I was getting updates so that can be the case... If not it will be good that you speak with Amazon to see if is a problem. I do not have the signature edition so I can compare but with my regular paperwhite I only see that it restart when i get an update.
Don't want to be chiming in here 2 months later, but here we are. I was wondering after getting the Paperwhite myself. Do you sometimes hold it with three fingers on the back and the kindle then resting on your little finger on the bottom. If so the power button could be resting on your little finger from time to time and causing it to reboot. Seen another reviewer saying this was an issue for them due to their little finger placement or power button placement, more like.
@@michaelfeehily2297 I can't say that I have that issue maybe because I always use my kindle with a cover. Since it goes in my purse I use the cover to avoid the device to turn on by itself and to protect it from scratches. Maybe that is why I never touch that button by mistake but I totally understand that someone without any cover can get that. Just to clarify I do not use the big leather covers I always search for the slim ones. But I highly recommend to get one if you carry your device around as I do :)
@@karopi ahhh. I only got this kindle the other day so the cover is in the post. So that's where I was coming from (someone without a cover, yet). By the way, great videos. I've found some horror books I'm looking forward to checking out.
@@michaelfeehily2297 I'm pretty sure it's not that because I think I've had it reboot when it's just sitting on a table. That said, the power button placement is ridiculous!
I always have a question regards PW5&PW5S: Will PW5S slowdown if it’s fully loaded? If I remember correctly, the signature-edition has the same RAM just like a regular KP5, so can it really handle that many files (like use more than 75% of the storages space, especially with e-books not audiobooks) on a device? It’s probably a dumb question but I’m just so curious.
I can't see that being a problem. If I understand how these things work correctly, then RAM is only used for active processes. So RAM usage would be identical regardless of how many books are on the device - as would just be the book you actually have open
@@CriminOllyBlog yes that makes sense. It’s just kindle’s operating system sometimes has the weirdest glitches. I have two Amazon accounts, had recently switched mine old Kindle 8th Gen to a different account and somehow it cannot show book covers while it’s sleeping, so I figured it’s probably cannot been recognize as the Ad-free version for the other account because of whatever. But just the other night, it decided to randomly restored this function and now every book I’m reading will be shown in the display. My KP5 never showed the rebooting problem that many people experienced with theirs, but it tends to freeze from time to time now I have use more that 50% of the storage space. It’s not a major issue because all I need is to close it for a second and then reopen it, everything will be just fine.
8:34 that is absolutely daft, like you say... Like why though? In an eink the light isn't for display it's for seeing, so really shouldn't the algorithm be reversed? The brighter it senses it is the lower the backlight? It's a simple change that'd make so much more sense. If it did that it'd actually be useful
It was your previous review that convinced me that I needed this iteration of the Kindle in my life! I ordered it for my birthday in April, so I've had it a couple months now and I love it! 📚 I love the screen size on the Paperwhite Signature, too! It's a big difference from my previous Kindle Paperwhite (2017? I think...) and it's much snappier. 😬 How odd that yours is randomly rebooting on you! Is it possibly getting software updates when that happens? I don't know if you've done this and I know you didn't ask for advice, 😆 but I would completely shut it down for a few minutes to see if that makes a difference. Who knows...maybe that'll do the trick. 🤓
I bought the Kindle 2021 (non-signature edition) per recommendations from you and other TH-cam Channels and have not regretted it. It’s a wonderful device that has all the things I want in an e-reader. I agree that wireless charging and even the auto-brightness is just gimmicky. I wouldn’t use them. As for the storage I don’t have any audiobooks, manga, or comics. Just about 50 books downloaded and there’s plenty of space.
Thank you telling me that around 2,500 books downloaded I might go over the 8 gig limit. I can’t imagine I would keep that many on the device and even if I did that’s what Amazon cloud is for.
Great review! I simply adore your videos about the books you read and try to watch your new videos when I can.
Have a good day Sir.
Thank you! Great that you're getting on so well with your Paperwhite!
Did you pay to have the adverts removed ? Does your device also refresh for no reason like the signature model ? If your answer is “ yes “ to both these questions, then I’d rather stick on to my 7th gen paperwhite model, and buy a clip on blue light filter ( I wear glasses ), for night reading. As for extra space on the device, I just have to delete some old books - but we can also rely on Amazon cloud for more space. In my opinion, these new paper whites are not worth the money paid for them. I’m waiting for the model that will easily convert a book to the bionic font for rapid reading. The money I saved to get the new paperwhite will now be spent on that great bread machine I’ve been eyeing for a while !
@@patnathan5013 bread makers are pretty cool!
@@patnathan5013 hello. No I did not have to pay to remove Ads. I bought the Kindle Paperwhite Kids Edition during a flash sale on Amazon. Kids edition has no ads, double the warranty and comes with cover.
It’s the same Paperwhite as the non-signature edition just with a kids UI that you can turn off. Better deal overall.
No mine never had refreshed unexpectedly or rebooted except to install a firmware update.
I have two Paperwhites. I’ve never had any automatic reboots. The Paperwhite is phenomenal, the battery is great, easy to carry in a purse so convenient !
I’m reading on mine right now 😊
the battery life is absolutely incredible. even if you notice it's getting low, you can still read for a bit before it runs out, compared to phones or tablets where after it gets to 10% you have a little over an hour before it turns off, if you don't really use it. instead, if you want to read and you notice the battery is low, you can probably read normally until you're home or you can charge it for an hour. best thing ever
Agreed! It's really comforting to know you don't have to rush to the charger!
@@CriminOllyBlog Thanks for the reply I just received my Kindle today from Prime Day. Let the fun begin!
@@von20808 Great! Hope you get many happy hours of reading from it!
I put a pop socket on the back of my Kindle and now it’s WAY more comfortable to hold.
Ah that’s a great tip!
Tha advantage of using the kindle signature for audio books is that battery life.
When traveling, the phone us in constant use.
I use the kindle for my books AND audio books.
Especially when I am down the beach or in the woods for multiple days and do not have a power supply that i do not carry.
That's a really great point, I hadn't thought of that
@@CriminOllyBlog Honestly, I did not realize the ease of monitoring your device and removing books that you do not want to take with you. Had I understood that it would be so easy and I would still retain the books, I would have looked more at other deals. I might have found the Kid's bundle before buying the Kindle, and that is the best deal out there. It is the same price as the regular Kindle, but with a 2-year hassle-free warranty and a cover (the black is ok)
(I included this information even though it is repeated in other posts for other readers of the Post. I know CrimiOlly is aware of this information already)
Interesting. I don't know that I've noted the poor battery life with my Oasis. I'll have to pay more attention. Weirdly enough, I notice the tiny extra bit of screen size of the Oasis over the Paperwhite (.2") and it feels like a major deal for me. At the same time, I like the warmer hand-feel of the Paperwhite over the metal of the Oasis, although I live in Minnesota, so perhaps my Oasis just naturally colder much of the year!
I haven’t been bothered by the smaller screen at all since moving to the PW. It’s funny how we each have our own priorities when it comes to devices
Thank you, Olly, for another fab video. Happy reading! 📚
Thanks Diane! Happy reading to you too
@@CriminOllyBlog You're welcome. Thank you.
I have the Oasis and the battery long very well.
Thanks for the video. I was wondering what kindle to get for a Father’s Day gift and now I know.
Excellent! Glad it was useful
I wonder why it reboots. I suspect it's updating the software automatically. Does it reboot on its own on [AIRPLANE] mode? The downsides to it for me are:
1. I actually wish it were smaller!
2. Side buttons would be good (like the Nook).
3. Try going back on a big book more than 10 pages and it's a chore.
This is part of why I am still not fully vested on e-readers.
I don't think it is updates as seems to be happening too often for that (and I would expect some sort of a notification when it did an update).
I like the size, but equally I would LOVE a pocket sized e-ink device that I could read on. I think there are a few options out there but need to look into it more.
I want to buy one of these on Prime day tomorrow. I went to a local store to check them out. I love the way the Oasis feels in the hand. It is so balanced plus the buttons. However the Oasis screen had a lot of ghosting, like screen burn in, and the contrast didn't seem as good as the Paperwhite. The blacks on the Paperwhite looked darker while the Oasis screen looked washed out. They had them in some sort of demo mode so I couldn't play with brightness settings and the store lighting was
very bright. Still not sure which to get.
If you read a lot and don't want to have to charge it every day then I would definitely recommend the Oasis. I don't feel there is much to choose between the screens tbh. Agree that the design of the Oasis is great though.
I've had the Signature Edition since launch, replacing my elderly Oasis and can only say good things about it. Unlike you, I use the wireless charging exclusively - I just plonk it on the wireless charger and pick it up later on, there's no fiddling with cords or plugs (even say that, USB-C is a huge leap over the old micro-USB plugs). In terms of hand-feel, I use one of the Kindle cases because it has the front flap that protects the screen when I chuck it in a bag etc. The case (cork) also gives me a bit more security in terms of holding the device. I've never once had mine spontaneously reboot - I'm wondering whether yours is down to a problem with your device. Another plus side to the latest Kindles is the speed of the processors - the Oasis I had before was almost unbearably slow in terms of navigating the interface where the Signature edition is so much more responsive.
Yeah I’ve got a case for mine now for when I travel. I do like the fact it switches the device on when you open it.
Also completely agree about the processor power. Makes using the device much more pleasant
I also struggled getting the battery to last me a day on the Oasis it was awful. I use a bigger font so the bigger screen is better for my situation.
Yeah the battery is terrible
I still have free, old model - has the keyboard. It’s a bit limiting but I’ve only read 2 or 3 books on it. Your advice is welcome though as I’m considering a newer model.
Glad it was helpful!
I recently got a regular Paperwhite. It did not cost me anything as I ‘purchased’ it using my Telco’s reward points :). The last Kindle I bought was a 4th edition purchased in either 2011 or 2012. For the last few years I have been reading eBooks using my iPad. I am enjoying books more on the Kindle as using my iPad meant I was often distracted. I am still on to my first book on my new Kindle but it is Shogun so it is a long book.
Excellent! Glad you're enjoying it! And yes, Shogun will keep you going a while!
Only,
I just ordered the KPW SE and before doing so, I asked customer service at Amazon if I could charge it with the adapter. Just like charging the standard Mandel. They told me yes. But I didn’t see on the video a actual outlet on the device to do so. Is it wireless charging only? Or can I actually plug directly into the device to charge it? I’m waiting for it to arrive.
* please excuse the typos .
Hi - you can charge it by plugging the cable into the device
Thanks for responding. I got it yesterday and it is simply fantastic! Great videos!
@@gregjo3808 Thank you!
For me the Oasis wins hands down! Why? First and foremost, the ergonomic grip cannot be beat for ease of holding. It’s a pleasure to hold which is enhanced by the autorotate feature allowing you to change hands and still enjoy the ergonomic grip. And then there’s the page turn buttons 😊. Regarding battery life: I leave mine in airplane mode most of the time and it helps a lot. Though the truth is, I usually plug it in daily just like my phone so it’s not a big deal. For those who don’t like the “coldness” or slipperiness of the back, I’d suggest buying a kindle skin. It adds some grip but doesn’t increase weight like a case. When I take it out and about, I put it in a Kindle sleeve.
I did like the design of the Oasis quite a bit. I had the first gen as well and I thought what they did with that and the charging cover was pretty great. If the 3rd gen had a similar design I’d have been a lot happier with it.
My paperwhite 2021 sometimes reboot. Always when I’m lying and holding it with the thumb near the Kindle logo. It is a bad contact on the power nutton
Ah that's interesting, it could be that on mine too
@@CriminOllyBlog In my case, I just moved my thumb a few milimeters and voilá, no more reboots! And thanks for the great channel.
@@ricardias1551 I’ll give that a try. And thank you! Glad you’re enjoying it!
My problems are the random reboots, it takes multiple taps (2-3x) before an ebook downloads, no ePub book covers in the library, power button on the bottom, and frequent slowdowns when navigating through the UI. Another issue I have is the Paperwhite will download multiple copies of the same ebook. I don't understand why. I have the Kindle Paperwhite Signature Edition. I love the last Kindle Oasis released, but the battery life is horrible. My Oasis drains in 1 day. I wish the Kindle Oasis had USB Type C, better battery life and a rubberized back for grip. It could have a 7.8" screen as well. I have over 6K ebooks on my Kindle Paperwhite Signature Edition. 6,369 ebooks last check. I love horror books!!!
I’ve not had the issue of multiple copies of a book being downloaded. Agree that having the power button at the bottom is a terrible design choice though.
If they can fix the battery life I’d buy a 7.8” rubberised Oasis with USBC in a heartbeat!
And I thought I had a lot of books!!!!
The long battery life sounds like a good thing. I know with my phone, which is where I read my ebooks, if I read even a couple hours a day without using my phone for anything else, it's low on battery already, lol. It's a pity the light adapting doesn't really work well. Though I guess each kind of Kindle has a certain audience that loves them.
Yeah I think every E-reader has its fans! And yes reading on a phone will kill the battery!
Hi there. I’ve never had a Kindle reboot unexpectedly. And I read a lot as well. 👍
Thanks, Scott! Mine seems to have calmed down a bit now...
I've owned several Kindle Fires. The first one died because something went weird with the power cord. The one I replaced that with got shattered and my poltergeist later decided to pick it up and try to break it in half. I wish I'd been able to get that on film or at least SEE it, because I heard it happening. I'd left it in a padded envelope on my bed, and I went to the bathroom, and I heard this "'pop pop pop" sound coming from my room. When I came back I found it on my bed, out of the envelope where I'd left it. It was bent and the casing was partially popped open, but no one was in the room at the time! I replaced it with another Kindle Fire. The first one got a shattered screen, which Amazon replaced. Then the replacement got a big scratch across the screen; I have no doubts it was the poltergeist that caused both, but I told Amazon it came out of the package that way! So they took it back and replaced it again. AMAZON'S CUSTOMER SERVICE IS FUCKING AMAZING. I've kept an eagle eye on my most recent, but it's still been bent (light leak and one pixel out!) and the poltergeist got hold of it and broke the power cord. It broke my headphones at the same time; funny enough, that's the last time the poltergeist came into my room. Now it just throws stuff at my bedroom door and writes me nasty messages--might even be a different poltergeist. Anyway, I love my Kindle Fire. I use it for reading, but also for watching TH-cam and Netflix when I don't feel like setting up my laptop and want to watch something bigger than my phone! And one more time for those in the back, Amazon's customer service is BOMB. They are awesome!
Yeah that is one thing they’re great at. I suspect part of the reason they’re so good on their devices is that they want people to own them so they can sell them books and movies and so on.
Sorry you’ve had such bad luck with your Fires though!
I bought the 8g kindle pw just couldn't justify the other features .
And the 32gb was the only real reason that would have made me buy the signature .
I've only got 250 book on mine so a couple thousand left to fill it .
I also have a kobo clara hd to fill as well.
If I ever get to the stage of running out of space I'll delete books I've already read .
And I've had a couple random reboots as well .
I think you made the right choice with the 8gb version. Sorry to hear you’re getting reboots too though.
Excellent review of the Signature and your round up comments on the different kindles at the end. Thank you.
I have a Paperwhite 7th edition plus an Oasis 9th ed 8gb. I have posted (at amazons cost) my Oasis to Amazon under there trade up offer. I will receive £60 for the Oasis together with 20% discount on a new Kindle. I did not use the Oasis much in fact it stayed at home, I preferred to take the 7th edition with me on my travels. it is smaller and fits very comfortably into jacket pocket or inside pocket. the Oasis I found would not fit into pockets easily. The battery on the 7 lasted much longer than the oasis.
In conclusion the new 8gb Paperwhite will suit my needs perfectly, pocketable and I don't need the wireless charging or the auto back light function.
I was leaning towards the Signature but your excellent comments made me realise that the entry level is the way to go, plus I can spend the money I will save on more ebooks.
David
Thanks David! Glad you found the review useful. Hope you enjoy the new Kindle!
Thanks so much for the comparison and your view on the Kindle Paperwhite. I was tempted, but ultimately stuck with my 2018 Paperwhite as I didn't see enough improvements to want me to upgrade. When they come out with a color eInk display though - then I'll reconsider :)
Yeah I am definitely intrigued to see what the next big innovation is. Although I’m not sure I actually have a real need for a colour screen as all I do is read text on mine.
Nice review.
The kindle paperwhite kids bundle used to be a good bundle. 2 year, no hassle warranty and a cover ( black is ok).
It often goes on sale.
That's cool! A great way to get kids reading
@@CriminOllyBlog Yes, That is the intent, but it is a great idea for adults. It often goes on sale for less than the cost of a regular Paperwhite, and it has that fantastic warranty. That warranty is worth a bit of cash. The only difference between the models (of the standard paperwhite and the kid's paperwhite) is that the kid's version comes with a FEW pre-installed apps or discounts for some kid's books that Amazon wants to promote. AND they can be deleted.
So for the EXACT SAME PRICE, you get a no-questions warranty on breakage for any reason, a case (the black one is very adult-looking).
It is a Must Buy for anyone that does not need the Signature edition.
I bought the signature edition for the extra storage for audio books but had I found the "kids" bundle, I would have bought that and simply monitored the number of audio books on my device.
@@michaelreed649 and no annoying lock screen ads! The included case cover is not as good as the regular one, which you will need to pay additional 20-30 USD
I don’t recall any random reboots on my Signature Edition. I’ve had about six months too. For the most part, it’s great, though I do miss my Oasis - except the terrible battery life. I do with Amazon would make a 10” Kindle.
There do seem to be a lot more E-ink devices from other manufacturers with larger or smaller screens, as well as colour and so on. I’d be surprised if Amazon doesn’t try something on those lines before too long.
I only own the standard paperwhite and it does reboot at least once every couple of days (that I've seen) my guess would have been some kind of software update but it's happening when I'm scrolling through books looking for something to read?.. So maybe it's a software glitch rather than anything major...
And they are cheaply made, I dropped my 1st one from a small height & the screen cracked, my bad and my new one is in a case..
Yeah I still haven’t got a case for mine but now that I’m commuting again I think I probably need to
@@CriminOllyBlog I dropped my one from around waist high, no damage except a crack across the top part of the screen making it useless..
For a few extra pound I can't recommend a case enough.
& of course it saves the swearing on the train as you look at your ereader that's now fit only for the bin.. 😩
@@gerarddonohoe5806 you’ve convinced me!
I have kindle on my phone and it suits me fine.
Why would I need a $140 kindle when I got one for free?
If you’re happy with using your phone that’s great!
The auto-brightness needs to be “trained”, switch it on and adjust the brightness under different light conditions and the sensors will learn your particular settings. And in regards to your kindle randomly restarting fortnightly, that is not normal, nor have i heard of anyone else having a similar issue and i frequently visit the kindle subreddit.
Ah that’s interesting, I didn’t know that about the auto brightness, thank you!
FYI, CriminOlly is a fantastic name for your channel.
You are clearly well read, so I have a question for you.
I am about to go camp on the beach for a week. Do you have any suggestions for camping on a beach in isolation?
I am thinking deserted island or some such setting.
I have "The Island of Doctor Moreau" on my Kindle (yes, I am embarrassed to admit that I have not read it yet), But would like more books for the trip.
Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Thank you! I actually haven't read The Island of Dr Moreau! I should really fix that.
Other ones that spring to mind - 'The Ruins' by Scott Smith, 'The Beach' by Alex Garland, 'Forgotten Island' by David Sodergren. Maybe throw in some Tarzan too? Or some H Rider Haggard if you fancy something more adventure focused.
I have the original Oasis and it has crashed in the middle of reading a book recently. It never happened before. I suspect it is a software issue.
Ah that's interesting! It does suggest it's software related so hopefully they can fix it.
I use my tablet if I have to read an ebook, but I prefer to read a physical copy. I had a kindle DX at one time, and it was terrible. I got the DX for my sister because of the large screen and text to voice, but it was too difficult for her to use because of her disability. So I ended up trying to use it, but the page turning was way too slow, and before long the battery would not hold a charge. I probably didn't read a complete book on it before disposing of it. $400 CAN wasted. Since I don't enjoy reading with the kindle app on my tablet, I assume a modern kindle would not be much better. A tablet or kindle would be great on the go, but in the summer I don't have a pocket big enough for my 8 in tablet. So I grab a pocket book when I am going somewhere. I did read ebooks on my phone for a while, but then it would take a year or more to read a book, since I would only read it when out somewhere and had to wait around.
I think you’re the first person I know who owned a DX! I’ve always been intrigued by it because it seemed like a bit of a crazy device. I think you’d find page turns and so on much quicker on a newer kindle
Current Kindles are much faster than the DX. Not sure what happened with your battery, but I still use an ereader from 2011 and the battery still lasts at least a week.
Reading on a black and white eink screen is different than reading on a phone or tablet. Closer to a printed page. If you are in a store and see a Kindle or a Kobo, I'd suggest at least checking them out to see how they are.
Thanks!
CriminOlly
Are you sure you are not accidently knocking the power button with your finger? I've done that many times. And regarding the position of the power button ....
It’s definitely possible!
I think that the reboot problem has been solve. Can someone confirm this please?
It hasn't happened to me for a little while, so hopefully it has!
Have been a Kindle Basic version owner for 5 years (1 non front lit, 1 front lit) but now although I still prefer the Kindle Store, I use a Kobo Libra 2 now. Calibre with DeDRM is amazingly useful.
That’s useful! I’ve got Calibre and DeDRM but the one thing I haven’t got sorted is the ability to import files in the new Amazon format (which I forget the name of now)
@@CriminOllyBlog Do you mean azw3? And happy to help if I can but not sure what you mean of what the problem is. 🙃
@@CDubya.82 just checked and it’s called KFX I think. The guide I used told me to download a KFX plug in as well but doesn’t seem to have worked
@@CriminOllyBlog I download using my pc from the Kindle site of books i own and they download in the format i mentioned. Calibre and DeDRM has no problem with those. The only place i find the kfx format is on my Kindle itself if i download with the kindle.
@@CDubya.82 ah that’s helpful! Thank you I’ll give that a try!
What does Without Kindle Unlimited mean?
What does Lockedscreen
Ad supported mean? I’m thinking of buying a regular Paperwhite and there are options that I need to choose from.
Hi there. Kindle Unlimited is a subscription service from Amazon that gives you access to free kindle books and audiobooks. The range is limited but there is a lot of good stuff there. You pay a monthly fee but can cancel anytime. You can also add it at any time, so if you’re not sure you want it I would select without for now.
Lock Screen ads basically means that when your kindle is not being used Amazon will show ads for books it think you’ll like on the screen (just a static image). It’s not too intrusive but can be a bit annoying.
@@CriminOllyBlog Now I understand. Thank you for explaining it to me.
You must have a lemon Oasis or something. My Oasis lasts about a week and a half in between charges with wifi always on. I read on it at least a couple hours a day.
Weird - I have had 2 of them and the battery life was identical
I found weird that your unite keeps rebooting, I've had Paperwhite 1, 3 & 5 (non signature edition) and some family and friends have had some others too .. never experienced a reset at all, I think your unit is faulty .. make a warranty claim if still can
It hasn’t done it for a while now so I’m hoping it was a software related issue which has been patched
@@CriminOllyBlog I'm glad to read it was software related so it could get fixed just by wait the update .. great review btw, agree with everything, just the plasticky feel -of course it's there- isn't a deal breaker for me
@@luisvazquez6633 thank you! Yeah the plastic is a bit disappointing, but a case helps a lot!
Probably should also go for the 32GB one if you read a lot of comic books or manga.
Very true!
I've not had any issues with it rebooting - have you considered contacting Amazon?
I haven’t done that yet, but if it keeps happening I probably will
How are you getting on with your watch winder? I keep getting conflicting opinions, what is yours? Thanks
I’ve got no complaints at all. It’s great to be able to just grab and automatic and wear it without having to worry about setting it.
@@CriminOllyBlog thanks. I tend to just wind mine once per day if not wearing. I was wondering if any excessive wear and tear has been noticed when you have them serviced.
@@Omega-Phil nope, nothing that’s been reported back to me anyway
Great review!, As always. Regarding the problem that the Kindle restarts by itself did you try to check if is not an update? It will be good to know if this is the issue. I only see that when I was getting updates so that can be the case... If not it will be good that you speak with Amazon to see if is a problem. I do not have the signature edition so I can compare but with my regular paperwhite I only see that it restart when i get an update.
Hi thanks for the suggestion. Unfortunately it’s done it multiple times in different versions of the software and not just when it was updating.
Don't want to be chiming in here 2 months later, but here we are. I was wondering after getting the Paperwhite myself. Do you sometimes hold it with three fingers on the back and the kindle then resting on your little finger on the bottom. If so the power button could be resting on your little finger from time to time and causing it to reboot. Seen another reviewer saying this was an issue for them due to their little finger placement or power button placement, more like.
@@michaelfeehily2297 I can't say that I have that issue maybe because I always use my kindle with a cover. Since it goes in my purse I use the cover to avoid the device to turn on by itself and to protect it from scratches. Maybe that is why I never touch that button by mistake but I totally understand that someone without any cover can get that. Just to clarify I do not use the big leather covers I always search for the slim ones. But I highly recommend to get one if you carry your device around as I do :)
@@karopi ahhh. I only got this kindle the other day so the cover is in the post. So that's where I was coming from (someone without a cover, yet).
By the way, great videos. I've found some horror books I'm looking forward to checking out.
@@michaelfeehily2297 I'm pretty sure it's not that because I think I've had it reboot when it's just sitting on a table. That said, the power button placement is ridiculous!
I love my Kindle Fire.
The Fire is an excellent device!
I always have a question regards PW5&PW5S: Will PW5S slowdown if it’s fully loaded? If I remember correctly, the signature-edition has the same RAM just like a regular KP5, so can it really handle that many files (like use more than 75% of the storages space, especially with e-books not audiobooks) on a device? It’s probably a dumb question but I’m just so curious.
I can't see that being a problem. If I understand how these things work correctly, then RAM is only used for active processes. So RAM usage would be identical regardless of how many books are on the device - as would just be the book you actually have open
@@CriminOllyBlog yes that makes sense. It’s just kindle’s operating system sometimes has the weirdest glitches. I have two Amazon accounts, had recently switched mine old Kindle 8th Gen to a different account and somehow it cannot show book covers while it’s sleeping, so I figured it’s probably cannot been recognize as the Ad-free version for the other account because of whatever. But just the other night, it decided to randomly restored this function and now every book I’m reading will be shown in the display. My KP5 never showed the rebooting problem that many people experienced with theirs, but it tends to freeze from time to time now I have use more that 50% of the storage space. It’s not a major issue because all I need is to close it for a second and then reopen it, everything will be just fine.
@@jessicamou Yeah I think I've had weird random glitches with all of my Kindles - cover art not showing, occasional freezes and so on
Is it still rebooting?
It hasn’t done for a while 🤞🏻
@@CriminOllyBlog That's wonderful to hear.
8:34 that is absolutely daft, like you say... Like why though? In an eink the light isn't for display it's for seeing, so really shouldn't the algorithm be reversed? The brighter it senses it is the lower the backlight? It's a simple change that'd make so much more sense. If it did that it'd actually be useful
Yeah completely agree. I really don’t understand it at all
Signature edition has no ad lock screen.
What are you reading now?
Just started The Terror by Dan Simmons 🥶
@@CriminOllyBlog Enjoy your book.
@@dianemorasco thank you! It’s great so far
Ooh a Kindle video! Here come 2k views easy. You are a clever criminal. It is a great review video, I must admit.
Ha! Thanks Michael
I've never had the kindle reboot on its own. So maybe it seems like a defect. Not even with an old kindle, it should not do that.
Thanks, Rod. it does seem to have calmed down a bit with the rebooting now
It was your previous review that convinced me that I needed this iteration of the Kindle in my life! I ordered it for my birthday in April, so I've had it a couple months now and I love it! 📚 I love the screen size on the Paperwhite Signature, too! It's a big difference from my previous Kindle Paperwhite (2017? I think...) and it's much snappier. 😬 How odd that yours is randomly rebooting on you! Is it possibly getting software updates when that happens? I don't know if you've done this and I know you didn't ask for advice, 😆 but I would completely shut it down for a few minutes to see if that makes a difference. Who knows...maybe that'll do the trick. 🤓
Ah brilliant that you’re enjoining it! So pleased! I agree the big screen is great.
I haven’t tried that! Maybe I’ll shut it down overnight
sorry you had bad battery on your oasis, i had an oasis at one point and my battery lasted ages. You might have just gotten a lemon
Maybe - it did seem very bad
Nice Doxa.
👍👍👍👍👍👍
if you get a pink kindle in the mail, send it back or deal with the low men.
Ha ha. I’m a Kobo gal and I still watched this. 😂😂
Thanks MJ 😂
I have a Kobo and two Kindles - just bought the signature on a prime day deal!
@@katxl7 I did too! I’m doing a full comparison video this weekend.
@@katxl7 hope you like it!
This aged badly