- 42
- 437 336
Creed and Culture
United Kingdom
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 11 ส.ค. 2021
Diving deep to address cultural chaos.
This TH-cam channel is a companion to my Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/
I teach religion and philosophy at Eton College. Before Eton, I completed a doctorate at Oxford University.
I’m particularly interested in religious faith, contemporary culture, and the link between the two.
All views expressed are mine or my guests, not those of my employer. The page’s visuals are the work of my talented wife.
This TH-cam channel is a companion to my Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/
I teach religion and philosophy at Eton College. Before Eton, I completed a doctorate at Oxford University.
I’m particularly interested in religious faith, contemporary culture, and the link between the two.
All views expressed are mine or my guests, not those of my employer. The page’s visuals are the work of my talented wife.
The Genesis of Gender | Dr Abigail Favale | EP47
Abigail is a writer whose work lies at the intersection of Catholic theology, literature, and women’s studies. She is a Professor at the University of Notre Dame.
Disagree with Abigail? Let us know in the comments!
Abigail on Twitter: x.com/FavaleAbs
Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/
Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin
Instagram: thecreedandculturepodcast
Spotify: shorturl.at/bxTUY
Apple Podcasts: shorturl.at/nrv13
Edited by Aleksandr Popov.
Disagree with Abigail? Let us know in the comments!
Abigail on Twitter: x.com/FavaleAbs
Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/
Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin
Instagram: thecreedandculturepodcast
Spotify: shorturl.at/bxTUY
Apple Podcasts: shorturl.at/nrv13
Edited by Aleksandr Popov.
มุมมอง: 4 059
วีดีโอ
Evidence for God | Prof Richard Swinburne | EP46
มุมมอง 12Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Richard Swinburne is Emeritus Professor of Philosophy at the University of Oxford. He is widely considered one of the greatest Christian philosophers of the last thousand years. Luke and Richard Swinburne discuss evidence for God and the problem of suffering. Disagree with Richard? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin Insta...
Understanding Christendom | Dr Jon Balserak | EP45
มุมมอง 1632 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr Jon Balserak is a visiting lecturer at the University of Illinois in Chicago. He teaches courses on religion and history. Luke and Jon discuss the period of European history known as Christendom. Disagree with Jon? Let us know in the comments! Jon's Twitter: x.com/Jon_Balserak Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin Instagram: thecreedand...
Making Faith Magnetic | Dr Daniel Strange | EP44
มุมมอง 4K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr Daniel Strange is an author and Director of Crosslands Forum, a centre for cultural engagement and mission. Luke and Daniel discuss his recent book Making Faith Magnetic. Daniel outlines five themes which he thinks all humans are drawn to. He then links them to the Christian faith. Disagree with Daniel? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's Twitter: ...
Towards A Post-Woke World | Dr Eric Kaufmann | EP43
มุมมอง 1.8K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr Eric Kaufmann is Professor of Politics at the University of Buckingham. Luke and Eric discuss his understanding of woke, whether words are violence, what a post-woke world might look like, what to expect under a Labour government in the UK, and Eric's new centre for exploring heterodox ideas. Disagree with Eric? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's ...
The Air We Breathe | Glen Scrivener | EP42
มุมมอง 7K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
Glen Scrivener is an author, speaker, and Anglican pastor. He joins Luke for a fascinating discussion about his book The Air We Breathe. Disagree with Glen? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin Instagram: thecreedandculturepodcast Spotify: shorturl.at/bxTUY Apple Podcasts: shorturl.at/nrv13 Edited by Aleksand...
Enlightenment Ideals Aren't Working | Jonathan Pageau | EP41
มุมมอง 61K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
Jonathan Pageau is a French Canadian icon carver, public speaker and TH-camr exploring the symbolic patterns that underlie our experience of the world. Luke and Jonathan discuss Jonathan's disagreements with James Lindsay on issues like the enlightenment and the place of religion in society. Disagree with Jonathan? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's ...
DEBATE HIGHLIGHT | Is Christianity Progressive? Chalke vs Robinson
มุมมอง 1.7K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is a short clip from a longer debate on the channel. Steve Chalke is a pastor, writer, and founder of Oasis Trust. Calvin Robinson is a priest, former GB News broadcaster, and now Lotus Eaters contributor. Disagree with Steve or Calvin? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Facebook: thecreedandculturepodcast Instagram: thecreed...
Liberalism, Christian Nationalism, and Problems in Universities | Professor Stanley Hauerwas | EP40
มุมมอง 4.1K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
Professor Stanley Hauerwas is one of the most influential theologians of the last century. He was dubbed 'the best theologian in America' by Time Magazine in 2001. He joins Luke for a wide-ranging discussion about liberalism, Christian nationalism, and universities. Disagree with Prof Hauerwas? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Facebook: thecr...
The Substitution Hypothesis | Dr Peter Boghossian | EP39
มุมมอง 16K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr Peter Boghossian is a writer, speaker, and podcast host. He taught philosophy at Portland State University for ten years before resigning in 2021, citing an illiberal academic atmosphere on campus. Along with James Lindsay and Helen Pluckrose, he undertook the famous grievance studies hoax, which arguably demonstrated the low academic standards of some university disciplines. Peter and Luke ...
Democracy and the Legacy of Christendom | Professor Oliver O'Donovan | EP38
มุมมอง 4.6K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Dr Oliver O'Donovan is one of the greatest living Christian theologians. For many years he held posts at Oxford University and Edinburgh University. Luke and Oliver discuss the challenges of democracy, the legacy of Christendom, and the task of accommodating multiple worldviews within one society. Disagree with Dr O'Donovan? Let us know in the TH-cam comments! Facebook: thecreedand...
DEBATE | Is Christianity Progressive? | Chalke vs Robinson | EP37
มุมมอง 62K7 หลายเดือนก่อน
Steve Chalke is a pastor, writer, and founder of Oasis Trust. Calvin Robinson is a priest, former GB News broadcaster, and now Lotus Eaters contributor. Disagree with Steve or Calvin? Let us know in the comments! Luke's Substack: drlukemartin.substack.com/ Luke's Twitter: x.com/luke_s_martin Instagram: thecreedandculturepodcast Spotify: shorturl.at/bxTUY Apple Podcasts: shorturl....
Understanding this Strange New World | Dr Carl Trueman | EP36
มุมมอง 1.2K7 หลายเดือนก่อน
Carl Trueman is Professor of Biblical and Religious Studies at Grove City College. Luke and Carl discuss his book Strange New World: How Thinkers and Activists Redefined Identity and Sparked the Sexual Revolution. Disagree with Dr Trueman? Let us know in the YT comments! Facebook: thecreedandculturepodcast Instagram: thecreedandculturepodcast Twitter: cre...
Reinvigorating the West | John Anderson | EP35
มุมมอง 12K8 หลายเดือนก่อน
John Anderson served as Deputy Prime Minister of Australia for 6 years between 1999 and 2005 under John Howard. He is now a cultural commentator with a very large online following. Luke and John discuss the attraction of the Christian worldview at our current cultural moment; the political arrangements we might aim at; the possibility of reinvigorating Western societies; and much more! facebook...
Communism has come to the West | Dr James Lindsay | EP34
มุมมอง 98K8 หลายเดือนก่อน
For the first time in public, Dr James Lindsay explains precisely how he thinks the radical progressive 'woke' movement which is sweeping through western institutions could lead our societies to a very dark place. The discussion finishes on a note of optimism, as James is encouraged by the growing pushback to the movement. Disagree? Let us know in the TH-cam comments! Dr James Lindsay is a writ...
Is the 21st Century Working for Women? | Lois McLatchie Miller | EP33
มุมมอง 6K8 หลายเดือนก่อน
Is the 21st Century Working for Women? | Lois McLatchie Miller | EP33
DEBATE | Should We Resist DEI? | Orr vs Benson | EP32
มุมมอง 6K9 หลายเดือนก่อน
DEBATE | Should We Resist DEI? | Orr vs Benson | EP32
A Holistic Response to Cultural Decline | Dr Iain McGilchrist | EP31
มุมมอง 18K9 หลายเดือนก่อน
A Holistic Response to Cultural Decline | Dr Iain McGilchrist | EP31
Fired for a Tweet | Dr Aaron Edwards | EP30
มุมมอง 1.4K10 หลายเดือนก่อน
Fired for a Tweet | Dr Aaron Edwards | EP30
What Do Men Want? | Dr Nina Power | EP29
มุมมอง 4.2K10 หลายเดือนก่อน
What Do Men Want? | Dr Nina Power | EP29
Is an Atheist + Christian Coalition Possible? | Paul Vander Klay | EP28
มุมมอง 4.3K11 หลายเดือนก่อน
Is an Atheist Christian Coalition Possible? | Paul Vander Klay | EP28
Finding Healing and Purpose in the Christian Faith | Rev Pat Allerton | EP27
มุมมอง 4.6K11 หลายเดือนก่อน
Finding Healing and Purpose in the Christian Faith | Rev Pat Allerton | EP27
Rebirth of Belief in God | Justin Brierley | EP26
มุมมอง 1.2Kปีที่แล้ว
Rebirth of Belief in God | Justin Brierley | EP26
Intolerance will become persecution | Rev Calvin Robinson
มุมมอง 6Kปีที่แล้ว
Intolerance will become persecution | Rev Calvin Robinson
The Case for Free Speech | Toby Young | EP25
มุมมอง 1.2Kปีที่แล้ว
The Case for Free Speech | Toby Young | EP25
Generous Orthodoxy, Identity Politics, and Authentic Living | Dr Graham Tomlin | EP24
มุมมอง 1.7Kปีที่แล้ว
Generous Orthodoxy, Identity Politics, and Authentic Living | Dr Graham Tomlin | EP24
What on Earth is Heaven? | Dr Jim Paul | EP23
มุมมอง 848ปีที่แล้ว
What on Earth is Heaven? | Dr Jim Paul | EP23
The Revolution has Happened | Peter Hitchens | EP22
มุมมอง 12Kปีที่แล้ว
The Revolution has Happened | Peter Hitchens | EP22
What is Western Civilisation? | Rev Calvin Robinson
มุมมอง 904ปีที่แล้ว
What is Western Civilisation? | Rev Calvin Robinson
Discussion NOT Cancellation! | Katharine Birbalsingh
มุมมอง 289ปีที่แล้ว
Discussion NOT Cancellation! | Katharine Birbalsingh
Mr Chalke prefers Paul’s words over The Word
Very informative ❤
Here, here Calvin! 😊
Calvin, God bless you!
Thank you Calvin for standing up for the truth! There are many of us in Singapore who are in total agreement with you! Praise God for you!
👌🏿
Sir I have a lengthy response perhaps too long for this format is there some other platform I might use to communicate. ?
Rejecting your god because of suffering is the only conclusion a rational being could draw. There is a god, however.
Thanks for contributing.
Christian Nationalism is Satanic
Take your unbiblical attire off, Mr. Robinson and get out on the streets with the Gospel of Christ. There are no celebrities in my King James Bible book of the Acts of the Apostles. I see the catholic imagery is prominent in the backdrop.
Lord have Mercy. We need about a thousand great Priest's like Pastor Robinson.
"Christianity is our best bet". I don't care what's the most useful for upholding enlightenment ideals, i want to know what's true.
If the Bible was 100 % clear then no two Christians would disagree over a verse, or instructions 🤔....so either humans are disobedient and fit the Bible to what suits them or the bible is unclear and changeable....
Good conversation
Thanks!
no it is not progressive
Quick question. Does one need evidence of God? Next what's the problem about suffering? Finally for now. Is it important or essential for "Christian " belief in Jesus that you hold on to the position that Jesus was an actual Person. and that the gospel narratives are factual and actual from "Immaculate conception to Bodily ascension into heaven. Thank you .
Knowledge requires evidence. So if one values truth, one *must* require evidence. (Beliefs are things we think we know are true. So evidence isn't optional, if we actually care about truth. Without evidence, we don't know an idea is true, and we'd be thinking we know it's true -- that's what belief is -- and that's self-deception.) Religions often realize they're trying to sucker people into a bad idea, and so they build in concepts like "faith" (which is essentially gullibility; believing without evidence) in order to win more followers.kk I think Jesus probably existed. The claim, _"this historic human existed,"_ is a very weak claim, due to how much evidence we have of tons of humans existing throughout history. Well we don't have many writings about Jesus, but we have very weak evidence. Because that evidence meets/exceeds the strength of the claim, it's reasonable to believe Jesus existed. The problem is, (A) that's where the evidence ends, but (B) there are many other claims about Jesus ranging from faith-healing to resurrection. These claims are *dramatically stronger* and require very strong evidence. Yet just when we needed stronger evidence we instead have basically nothing (just the books making the claims basically). Even worse, those are both things that throughout history we have evidence humans have tricked each other with. Peter Popoff was a faith-healer scammer. Various individuals have either (1) faked their own deaths or (2) impersonated the dead. Also (3) post-death hallucinations are a real thing (thinking you see a person who's dead). These seem like far better explanations to me for what's written in the gospels than to actually believe it all really happened. Also, Swinburne's "evidence of god" here are bad arguments too, just to be clear. They're bad logic (specifically argument from ignorance is a mistake he makes in several points he raises), and so they're not evidence.
I hope you get the answer to your questions…unfortunately they are at the same kind of level as ‘does a car need a starter motor’?
@@michaelcorner6861 . I hope I get a response to my questions, obviously you deem that beneath you. You being so academic and intellectual. Sir I find your attitude extremely arrogant. Shame on you .
@@michaelcorner6861 Ps. EVs don't need a starter motor
Thanks for your questions! You'll actually get some answers to your questions by listening to the episode (Swinburne responds to at least two of them).
Calvin Robertson is a charlatan and a disgrace to Christianty
When pageau says « Christianity is our best bet » he is in fact speaking and thinking in the manner of the Enlightenment, as if religions are merely tools which can be selected rationally on the basis of their practical advantages. But the question is, not which religion is our best bet, but which one is actually true.
If Consciousness is God as they perceive it to be in the East then what is posited here is morals without consciousness. I don’t think so.
3:32 ... so, who is the "Jesus" who have you the new revelations?
It all comes down to secularists wanting to protect LGB rights while wanting Christian influence to fight against the Q and T. The problem is they can't articulate why LGB is ok but Q and T is too far. Christians have a framework of one man and one woman that provides a solid foundation. Once you break that and advocate for LGB then there's no framework or foundation to prevent us from moving to Q and T. If you want to pushback then you have to go all the way and restore the Christian framework because it is the guardrails of liberalism. What we have today is liberalism without Christian guardrails.
The more progressive the church becomes, the smaller it will get.
Progress is being conformed to the will of God, by submitting to His will over our own. Chalke wants to call 'progress' imposing our will over God’s...based on what makes sense to us, which is the very essence of sin.
Chalke constantly interrupts, talking over Robinson. There's a reason for that...he doesn’t want to allow him to form a cohesive argument. Everything Chalke states is based on his own, subjective views...and it constantly changes. Truth is immutable, absolute, objective...that fixed object is God Himself. God doesn’t change...Truth, based on God can't change. What we arbitrarily decide is irrelevant. Robinson's contention that marriage, for example, is clearly defined, from the beginning, and stated just as clearly by Jesus, who just ss clearly stated, ' What God has jkined together, LET NO MAN PUT ASUNDER, literally not strive to separate , dsviate from what God established. Chalke also distorted when Jesus says ' You have heard it said...but I say unto you. .." to mean that God’s commands somehow change with circumstances is completely wrong. Jesus was addressing the Pharisees and their human traditions becoming the standard ...how they reinterpreted what was always what God had said. He corrected the kinds of cha ges tbat Chalke is wanting to impose into the Scriptures .
Thank you so much Calvin for your boldness and courage to speak the TRUTH. When we know the truth, then the truth will set us free….keep up the good work….
Oliver O'Donovan. Gentle. Giant.Genius.
When I first saw Fr. Robinson, I thought he was a Liberal. Boy, I was wrong. And in a very good way. He is a True Christian and I fundamentally agree with him. Here in the USA and in the state where I live, Woke and LGBTQ reigns supreme. Like Fr. Robinson, I agree that Woke and LGBTQ are contrary to God's Plan. Kudos to Fr. Robinson!
God bless Father Calvin,and raise him up to spread the true word of God
Nice podcast!
Thanks!
Calvin : True man of God.. Chalke: False teacher Any Questions!
Chalke plays the slavery card. ..typical.
Right on Calvin! Bless you brother!
Jesus, Im so grateful to be nowhere near the top of the hierarchy... so happy and grateful to witness God and all His works..
I suspect the broad path has a left and a right lane. Diabolos Road. The object would be to divide Christians into two main groups. Conservative or progressive. Bah. Humbug. Progressives are never progressive enough for the next generation of progressives. The Word of God is preservative, not conservative - indeed it is radical.
Bengali bilieve in fraternity as per history
Wants to go back to Fresh Prince, they all do
He is a fool and blames everything on irrelevant category of communism. He will not be able to argue against something without him comparing it to something else. Pathetic
James has a lot of knowledge, but Jonathan has knowledge and wisdom.
Thank you for speaking the truth .....the church of England should be ashamed in what they are doing. True christians now must stand up and defent the true gospel. We are now living in a pegan world . I agree the intollerance against christians will eventually lead to persecution
Calvin is bang on target. Steve is driven mostly by "his" own opinion, like what 'he' likes, what 'he' thinks and so on. But Calvin rightly bases his decision on The Church (The One True Apostolic and Catholic Church). I'll pray for Steve's conversion. Ave Maria!
James Linsey wants to funnel everything through the funnel of communism which is completely irrelevant. Just more conservative type cowardice
I don't think Joan of arc actually said that she was beyond category, beyond man and woman, "I am". That was the invention of the playwrght.
As a Baptist, we do NOT claim Steve Chalke! I don't know any Baptists who would say those types of things.
Disgusting ignorance of Steve Chalk, who seems to understand nothing of dispensations 😱
Steve Chalk lost, Calvin Robinson speaks Christian standards.
I call it, Walking dead society 🧟♀️ 🧟♂️
I just listened to a talk about the book, this is your brain on parasites, about toxoplasmosis...how it can affect behavior...how cats carry it most. The talk was quite peculiar in the suggestive perspective department about political ideals though...6th grade teacher author? I think...but am aware of ideological disciples are in our skools... 👁 I also know about OG Tavistock, trilateral commission, IALP, and that every org/kult headquarters hiding out in Switzerland should be raided! 😆 I'm just a research nerd...🤓 🤪 😜
Substitution hypothesis sounds similar to Joseph Campbell's ideas in regards to the lack of rituals and rites of passage in modern human society. I believe his claims are that humans have a history of spiritually, and mythology is how our ancestors tried to teach us how to deal with the potential of the fear of the unknown as a natural human...so ritual is a necessity but has been replaced by a hodgepodge of modern ideals with little meaning... He's a tough read, but I loved listening to him speak in the power of myth with Bill Moyers ❤
Reason for James’ strong reaction is that he was brought up by the American fundamentalist baptists… They are cringe even to many Catholics. He did not experience reasonable Orthodoxy or Catholicism.
If Lindsey, who is a smart guy, wants to play the game of pretend where there's only one way of doing christianity, he should never blurbed out the term "reason" ever again. Before him embracing enlightment and liberalism as the solution to the modern western problems, he needs to book himself in a massive therapy to fix his deep seeded religeous traumas. His commentary is just him getting back his issues and it's helping no-one.
You had me until you mentioned Jordan Peterson.
Good to know.
I don’t agree with Calvin’s views on women and how God uses them but I’d admire his integrity and courage. He shines with Gods goodness. Steve Chalk used to but now he just seems so lost. I have no idea what’s happened to him but it’s so sad to see. I remember how influential and inspiring he was back in the eighties. He’s wrong to bless in his church what God has condemned and he’s wrong to put himself above Gods word and think he is more moral and compassionate than God who is the source of all goodness, love and the father of compassion. I hope and pray he finds his way home.
Just found your channel yesterday. Obsessed!
Welcome!