Resistance and redirection both are helpful in different situations. I value both aspects . As there is no one way to resolve a conflict. There's what works for the individual in a situation.
the upward wrist toe strike looks really weak.. you can do as much katas you want... but you really need to apply everything into a fighting situation. The great old gen Sensei seems to have included alot of movments with hands... just to include it for some illutional reasons. UFC made it all clear when every style did meet each other. Poor fellows with all types of styles where just having there asses handed over. So Bruce was right about better train few things many times, than train many things few times. It also seems that movements are neglected to a point.. in most styles of Karate/Kung Fu. Judo, BJJ and wrestling is effective, and so is kicking and different style of fist fighting... inkluded basic technics in Karate and Kung Fu.
That is very true, especially for sport combat. I am not trying to delve into only self defense as a purpose for practicing martial arts. Forms and kata are mostly misunderstood today. Of course no one can use the sequences performed in the katas, but the same can be said for any techniques. The forms have to be discovered over a period of time to understand how to apply them. My interest is not to try to compare various styles in the proverbial "what style is best for self defense". I will discuss it at some point for sure, but not in the common type of answer we normally see. By the way, have you ever seen someone break 4 boards with a toe strike which takes over 800 pounds of force? Or the same number of boards with a finger strike or one knuckle? Of course that takes years of dedication to accomplish.
@@СергейМанько-ж7л I agree. Did some of that in my youth but decided I did not want messed up hands and fingers, toes. Later realized that with proper tensioning of the body that strength would develop via the katas.
The UFC is a sport with rules, referee, gloves and time outs in a sterile environment against a single opponent of the same size and experience. If people taught chimps to beat each other unconscious it would be outlawed.
Interesting, you train so you don’t need to use kata. That sounds similar to what Bruce Lee said. In one of his movies, where he talked about fighting without having to rely on technique. th-cam.com/video/POnQYx2tTH4/w-d-xo.html
Effective for what? I have only met one MMA guy in his 90's. About 20 or 30 over 100yr old Karate & Kung Fu guys in the last 50yrs. Take from that what you will.
@@MrRourkВы врёте .Продолжительность жизни зависит от генетики.Речь идёт об эффективности единоборства .Современные единоборства эффективнее в разы ..Единоборства это бои ,схватки ,соперничество ,соревнования ...а не формальные ката в каратиских секциях ,бессмысленные набивания неподвижной макивары итд.😊
راءع الكراتيه القديمه راقيه جدا ونستطيع القول انها جمعت كل اساليب فنون الدفاع عن النفس شكرا لمؤسسيها وشكرا للذين اوصلوها لنا
I am enjoying the conversations. I find much that I can also relate to in my 50 years of study.
Thank you. That is great!
Resistance and redirection both are helpful in different situations. I value both aspects . As there is no one way to resolve a conflict. There's what works for the individual in a situation.
We also had in hung gar soft internal forms : sup yin , and tid sin kuen
Too hard or too soft? Sounds similar to Goju-Ryu?
Ah, yes you have seen into it! I will bring that out in future videos.
"subjective opinion here"
Of course, they all are by all of us. That is good, open dialogue to create thought and discussion.
the upward wrist toe strike looks really weak.. you can do as much katas you want... but you really need to apply everything into a fighting situation. The great old gen Sensei seems to have included alot of movments with hands... just to include it for some illutional reasons. UFC made it all clear when every style did meet each other. Poor fellows with all types of styles where just having there asses handed over. So Bruce was right about better train few things many times, than train many things few times. It also seems that movements are neglected to a point.. in most styles of Karate/Kung Fu. Judo, BJJ and wrestling is effective, and so is kicking and different style of fist fighting... inkluded basic technics in Karate and Kung Fu.
That is very true, especially for sport combat. I am not trying to delve into only self defense as a purpose for practicing martial arts. Forms and kata are mostly misunderstood today. Of course no one can use the sequences performed in the katas, but the same can be said for any techniques. The forms have to be discovered over a period of time to understand how to apply them. My interest is not to try to compare various styles in the proverbial "what style is best for self defense". I will discuss it at some point for sure, but not in the common type of answer we normally see. By the way, have you ever seen someone break 4 boards with a toe strike which takes over 800 pounds of force? Or the same number of boards with a finger strike or one knuckle? Of course that takes years of dedication to accomplish.
@@UniversityofKarateА зачем ломать доски ударом пальца 😊.Потратить годы на чепуху ?
@@СергейМанько-ж7л I agree. Did some of that in my youth but decided I did not want messed up hands and fingers, toes. Later realized that with proper tensioning of the body that strength would develop via the katas.
The UFC is a sport with rules, referee, gloves and time outs in a sterile environment against a single opponent of the same size and experience. If people taught chimps to beat each other unconscious it would be outlawed.
Interesting, you train so you don’t need to use kata. That sounds similar to what Bruce Lee said. In one of his movies, where he talked about fighting without having to rely on technique.
th-cam.com/video/POnQYx2tTH4/w-d-xo.html
Yes! Very insight full! I have a video coming that will discuss that.
MMA 3 times a week for 6 months is more effective than 20 years of traditional karate.
😂
You are certainly entitled to you opinion. I consider practicing the martial art a journey that I can participate in for a life time.
Effective for what? I have only met one MMA guy in his 90's. About 20 or 30 over 100yr old Karate & Kung Fu guys in the last 50yrs. Take from that what you will.
@@MrRourkВы врёте .Продолжительность жизни зависит от генетики.Речь идёт об эффективности единоборства .Современные единоборства эффективнее в разы ..Единоборства это бои ,схватки ,соперничество ,соревнования ...а не формальные ката в каратиских секциях ,бессмысленные набивания неподвижной макивары итд.😊
MMA or bbj Mexican jj is fake copy cat, and useless they fight sloppy like a rookie Street fighter sit your weak as down.