There are no WRONG notes!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ม.ค. 2023
- Download transcriptions at georgecolliermusic.com. Check out the Discord!: / discord
Original video: • wait for it I promise ...
Piece: Unholy
Performed by: Stacey Ryan
Transcribed by: BA
faq:
Q: how are you related to jacob collier? / A: i'm not, we just have the same last name
Q: how do you transcribe? / A: i use musescore for notation and 'Transcribe!' for beat marking, slowing down etc
Q: do you have perfect pitch? / A: no
Q: where can i suggest videos? / A: / discord
Q: what music do you listen to? A: open.spotify.com/playlist/0zP...
Q: why are some videos not transcribed by you? / A: sometimes other people submit transcriptions, most are commissioned from others who can do a better job than i can. i want to make sure you see the best transcriptions possible! - เพลง
Gosh dang it, enharmonics. Seeing Db and C# in the same chord just doesn't sit well with me, especially since the key signature is Db. I guess that goes along with the atmosphere and theme of the song.
if there's Db and C# in the same chord then it is just wrong/typo :)
Let's keep the swearing down to a minimum please
@zildjian (no im not the real thing) Watch yo' profamity. 👀
@zildjian (no im not the real thing) s tier comment
@@Pheminon1 fl*ppin h*ll
I can imagine a large number of music theory professors fainting or having a bit of a tantrum at this 😅
I’m having a tantrum at the inconsistent grouping of the quavers let alone the accidentals
@@dyskordia_ what do you mean?
@@tobiaskuchar only Beats 1 and 3 in a bar of 4/4 should be separated and sometimes 3 and 4 are separate
@@dyskordia_ that's a very dumb rule. Even then it's only broken in the second bar. The separation should be based on phrasing (or the distance between the notes if they are very far apart) in my opinion.
@@tobiaskuchar not in music theories opinion. And then it gets subjective on where the phrasing is
She played us by taking complex chords, and then starting with the most dissonant relationships first. She still has the correct and most important chords and notes in there so it is still the song we all know.
Definitely agree with the title. It's called dissonance, doesn't mean that it's a wrong note
The title says there are no wrong notes. Did you see a wrong note?
@@MaxxMcGeePrivate Did you misread the part where I said I agree with the title?
@@kevinsundelin8639 Oh yes I did! Hah, sorry
@@MaxxMcGeePrivate No worries, it happens
@@loganloftin7570 really had to ruin a perfectly fine reply section
C A T
🐱
Ah this is Stacey Ryan and she sure knows what she is doing. I would love to see more of her on this page!
I understand but it sounds trash in my opinion
@@davidardelean2832 that’s fine. Music is subjective
I don't know what all the fuss with notes is about but it sounds very unusual and very good!
it does sound unholy lol
unholy, but surely otherworldly
Some parallel 7ths. It's fair game in harmony. She did a good job with it.
do you know how these songs work who have literally 2 major chords just rivaling each other (in this case C# and D) and in enemy from imagine dragons its F# and G? thats not how i learned it in school where we just had I, IV, V, I
@@andrejk401 That’s just “II I” chord progression in Phrygian (with “I” being majorized, as it’s common in styles like flamenco)
@@jorge.iglesias but both D and C# are major chords in this song. Or what do you mean with majorized?
@@andrejk401 The chords that you describe can be understood as II I in a Phrygian scale. In C# Phrygian, II = D major and I = C# minor (but it’s common to “majorize” it, I mean, make it C# major). Sorry if I’m not explaining correctly, I’m not that fluent in English 😅
@@jorge.iglesias Nah that's too complicated to me😅. I am actually really interested in music theory. I want to know the bounders of chord progressions but I don't know where to learn that. I am only at 11 grade😅 you know anything online to learn something like that?
Yes, I sense that Jacob collier is helping inspire this type of crazy harmonizing and I’m here for it:) (Yes it’s been done before, but collier is bringing it to the younger crowd)
He's helping people make bad sounding music?
@@qc6265 what about this sounds bad
Everything to me. But music is subjective.
@@qc6265 Guess ur just boring
@@TheRoboticFerret I take it you listen to this 6 times a day since it sounds so good to you?
There are no wrong notes, some are just more right than others. "Thelonious Monk"
Phrygian dominant - the scale that keeps on giving.
After all these years I have found my talent: singing the first layer of wrong notes.
I must be used to spicy music. That sound fantastic to me!
Damn this is so good
yoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo instrument maniac!!!!1!!
this scratches a part of my brain i did not know needed scratching
Truly fascinating! Yes, truly fascinating!
she is performing soo superior. Fantastic.
Heard this and thought immediately: The first four notes are exactly the same as Pokemon's St. Anne Theme
This sounds sooo beautiful!
Love it!
just a noobish music lover passing by, maybe someone will be able to explain to me something. During the 5th part, i felt like the notes about to be added in the last part were already present in a way, like suggested by all the previous layers combined. Sorry for the poor musical vocabulary, but it felt amazing to hear! Music is life :)
its okay! you dont need to get a degree in music to enjoy music. its just dissonance lol
@@perpetually_healing thank you for the answer, didn't know that was a property of dissonance. I was asking about a more thorough and precise answer about this mechanism, though, that it why I asked on this chat^^
the 5th part is just the melody line but down an octave
@@briansagram6875 thank you, but stil not what i was asking, maybe i need to rephrase my question (english not being my native language doesn't help..) What i needed an explanation for (and when i say "explanation", i mean more than a short sentence in the style "It's just that", I'm not versed in music theory but not completely ignorant either, and I'm here to learn^^) What I asked for is: How the accumulation of harmonic layers is able , when it reaches a certain point, to suggest another layer which isn' t technically there?and i'm sure the more layers you add, the stronger the phenomenon gets. Like a game we play sometimes, where someone have to guess a word. you can answer questions to help but never directly, and the person finds it by "silouetting", if i may say it that way. Am i making any sense?
And please, anyone, if you fancy answer me, do it thoroughly, with a proper lecture, like i was your equal, I would appreciate a lot and make my best to understand and digest your answer. Don't hesitate to be technical, I'm hungry^^
@@lhidalgo7243 Sometimes, when the voices are perfectly in tune, their harmonics can be interpreted in our brain as more notes than are actually sung. Pretty sure Adam Neely has a video on it.
I had the same impression, but i think here it's more to do with knowing the song beforehand, so as soon as the harmony became full enough, i could imagine the original melody.
Edit: I also think it might be the opposite of implied harmony. A melody usually implies certain harmonies and here we are maybe just automatically extrapolating it from the voiceleading between chords.
space jam dvd
Scotty doesn't know Scotty doesn't know Scotty doesn't know
So don't tell him...
Very creative!
the last measure should have a 4:3 polyrhythm instead of unison quarter note triplets
1st, 3rd, and 4th voices have the quarter note triplet
2nd, 5th, and 6th voices have the expected eighth note-eighth note-quarter note like the original melody
Yeah, it's so sad that people who transcribe such complex harmonies have problems with basic rhythm.
I was looking for this exact comment
@@csermenyizsombor burn
@@csermenyizsombor we don’t all have expert musical education dude
Damn....incredible. Reminds me of the Bulgarian Voices.
Incredible, it sounds fantastic
Thanks George Collier for introducting me to this amazingly talented artist. Now I wanna see her collab with Jacob Collier
She’s amazing
The difference between playing wrong notes and jazz is the confidence.
This is remarkable
I mean ... WTF ! This is crazy perfect .
One shouldn't be afraid to use a little double-flats, darling!
Stacy Ryan is sooo good. Omg. Check her actual music out if you haven’t already.
Plz we are talking about Stacey Ryan of course there are no wrong notes
Wonderful
The melody makes me feel like I were in Arabian robe riding camel in the desert
St. Ryan is a beast! 🎶✍🎹🎙👄👏💯🔥
The similar video she did for "American Boy" is even better, at least to my taste.
it all makes sense when you put the bass in
Slaps so hard
Holy crap, that's awesome.
Fascinating.
And to think my music teacher assumed I just wasn’t very good when mashing random keys. Jokes on them now!
This is definetely in C# Phrygian Dominant, meaning you'd have to write it in F# minor key -- it would be much easier to read and understand this way!
I agree, the notation is absolutely horrendous.
amazing
Mommy turned too many effects on for the recording ☹️
nothing wrong with effects if you need them for a certain sound
How does she make a microphone that good sound so low quality lol also very good singing
This is way harder than singing it normally 😂
my brain is so used to regular harmonics, i cant enjoy this
Amazing
The way she tags the girdle #MKIV is amazing
Right off the bat I thought I was having a stroke
All this is beautiful, and I loved it. But… what the fudge WAS daddy up to at the body shop?…
Doing something unholy 😈
Awful counterpoint. Starts bad, gets worse.
goddamnit this is the please dont text me when youre drunk girl
Mommy don’t know 😔
Hey! That's Stacey!
Sounds fantastic to me
It sounds amazing, there’s nothing wrong with it
what I took away from this is that you can make any progression sound all kinds of fucked up by playing onl; the middle notes
*Straight Midsommar Vibe*
Véritablement superbe
Im a simple man, i see stacey ryan, i click
At first I thought this was just someone singing poorly without autotune. I could not have been more wrong.
It’s great
It could be so easier to read, if only C#maj existed...
"mommy don't know dad is gettin hot in the body shop, doing something unholy". Am I wrong? ...sounds a bit... gross... wtf is doing her father?
I was disappointed with the full song from her viral TikTok thing but your posts of Stacey Ryan made sure I should be paying more attention
All I here is
"space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd
space jam dvd"
THIS is something unholy
There's no rules in art, only techniques
So did mommy learn that daddy's getting hot at the body shop doing something unholy?
I like It tbh
I didn't look at it too closely but isn't it just that it's in some form of harmonic minor and you keep having to use more minor seconds awkward note choices to fill a thicker harmony.
There she goes again
Jacob Collier wants to know your location
She used to go to my high school!!!
Tell me if I’m being unfair but I’ve seen one comment with double digit likes talking about the effects when the two he posted with a couple guys doing similar stuff got ripped apart by top comments for using effects to hide voice. I personally don’t mind it but I feel like there’s a double standard of some kind I’d love to have cleared up
There's another word for "no wrong notes" it's called ✨J A Z Z✨
Woah this is the definition of spicy
Why does it feel like I'm listening to my own voice?
Likesito mi jorge collier
I can imagine Kanye sampling this for the first 10 seconds of the song then looping part of it for the rest of the
The note spellings here are all over the place. It would be interesting harmony to analyze, but all the chords are obscured by sharps that should be flats, etc.
Context makes things sounding right or wrong
This physically hurts to listen to, I like it tho
Okay who the hell summoned the Fae
She has such a cool and precise voice. Wonder how much, if any, is edited here.
Isn‘t the „something unholy“ two eigth notes into one quarter note instead of quarter note triplets?
It's definitely all edited unless she's a sextuplet singing family
Nice, was looking forward to a new System of a Down Album!
i was thinking this as well
Yup. Gotta wonder how much ProTools was involved. If not, impressive!
Something about this doesn’t feel right…. But I’m so impressed
Victor Vooten likes it.
George! I see your title and raise you one 'The Shaggs'. Do my 'My Pal Footfoot' and really test your skills.
This is stacey ryan for those who are wondering, please check out her stuff it's stupid good!!
Therapist: Gender Bent Jacob Collier isn't real, she can't hurt you
Gender Bent Jacob Collier:
Db + C# + Ebbb + B## would make a great chord.
why is it in Db? the weird accidentals are screwing with me a bit here
Approved by Max Reger
there are no wrong notes when your cranking your melodyne up to ungodly amounts lol