ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
the most satisfying tiktok harmony
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2022
- Download transcriptions at georgecollierm... and check out the Discord!: / discord
Original video: • Talking To The Moon - ...
Performed by: CJ Capital ( / @cjcapital )
faq:
Q: how are you related to jacob collier? / A: i'm not, we just have the same last name
Q: how do you transcribe? / A: i use musescore for notation and 'Transcribe!' for beat marking, slowing down etc
Q: do you have perfect pitch? / A: no
Q: where can i suggest videos? / A: / discord
Q: what music do you listen to? A: open.spotify.c...
Q: why are some videos not transcribed by you? / A: sometimes other people submit transcriptions, most are commissioned from others who can do a better job than i can. i want to make sure you see the best transcriptions possible!
i like to imagine what this wouldve sounded like *without* pitch correction 😂 No way can I deny how great this sounds, but also imagine the dissonance + clashing overtones from 5 unedited tracks
I couldn't stop thinking about that exact thing
What autotune?
@@DerekHartley If you cannot hear it, I am sorry to say that you will need to work on your ear if you ever want to mix/master music
@@alechamblin7679 you’re right but you don’t have to be an ass about it
I think writing crunch like this is only really effective when the music is done without Melodyne. All the life of the chord is removed when you compress and tune it artificially.
…ah yes… those parallel fifths we were told ‘never’ to use in composition!!
Stunning harmonies here!! Very pleasing to the ear…
Theory class be like
Hahaha, they're a cool technique if not overused. :)
Parallel 5ths and 4ths are only verboten in 18th century harmony. Game on!
Tbh music theory is a scam
They were not supposed to be used because they dont sound very much like seperate voices in counterpoint of the classical and baroque Era. Nobody is saying that they cant sound good in a different context.
I would love to see a choir perform this. It's also an excellent warm up song
Oh, that's a great idea. I'll definitely steal it for that. Also good exercise in intonation.
700th like
Now I have the music I'll get back to you in a couple of weeks when my choir class gives it a shot.
@@bluefletcherfish Yessssss! Send a link when you do please
We used this as a warmup in mine! Sounded insane
To this day, some people say he's still talking to the moon.
That's rough buddy
I understood that reference
@@danielf3623
I see what u did there
Others say she didn't want him to get to her to begin with
holy shit ur here
I'd love to hear the raw vocals of this arrangement with like a group choir that'd be nuts if done well
sounds autotuned, so raw might be a little less satisfying
Fun fact: everything you’ve ever heard on the radio has had some form of pitch correction. Give this guy some slack, he’s still an excellent singer and it would sound really off if everything wasn’t exact.
They used pitch correction in the 60's?
@@bertilow actually they did pitch correct songs! by speeding up or slowing down parts of tracks, they could produce an effect like a primitive autotune. so yes. yes they did. they also used other effects to mask a singer if they were off pitch :)
@@katiakitty In every hit song?
@@bertilow that wasn't what you asked! I suggest googling for your answers. maybe start with "what does 'moving goalposts' mean?" (please note. I am done with this conversation now. just in case you expect a reply past this point)
@@katiakitty i expect a reply past this point.
Love the composition, not in love with how robotic it all sounds due to whatever autotune/pitch correction he used.
Just see it as synthy sound design instead of pitch correction. If you see it as a artistic choice it's much more bearable.
@@jessevandendoren Ehhhhhh I actually don't agree, but that is super subjective.
@@MightyManotaur22 You don’t have to agree lol. Some people are boomers about auto tune, others don’t get the hang up.
@@thomasharris9059 Not liking autotune does not make you a boomer, lol. If we're using this specific example, this composition and the style of the song are in direct opposition to a more synthetic sound. In my opinion. You can can't just dismiss all criticism of autotune as "oh well they're just old" or "they don't get it."
@@MightyManotaur22 k
I don't care that it's tuned pretty hard, its sounds very nice still
Melodyne is one helluva invention
Melodyne is much more transparent than this lol I think he used some auto tune plug in
@NPC 2428 You can force it with melodyne to sound like this if you tune it perfectly AND take all the natural dynamics out. Don't remember the proper term but you know smooth out the squigly line in each note to be completely flat. It sounds almost as awful as autotune.
@NPC 2428 It can to over tuned T-Pain -sound if you want it to but for that there is autotune. But autotune can't do the smooth and natural sound that melodyne does so overall Melodyne 100, Autotune 0 😄
It doesn't matter if this guy is "cheating" with auto tune. Music is music. The purpose is to create something that can be enjoyed by many, and this guy accomplishes just that
How do you know that that is what the purpose of music is?
@@PaulMurrayCanberra Some people create music for our enjoyment, some do it for money, others do it to express how they feel. Music can be created with many different goals in mind. In Richboi's perspective, music is created for people to enjoy.
@@PaulMurrayCanberra yeah as the other guy said, it's rlly up to the individual, For me that's what it's for, but you're free to have any opinions that you feel are right with you
@@PaulMurrayCanberra ok 🤓
Who the fuck said anything about cheating? The problem with pitch correction is that the artifacts sound like absolute shit
I don’t understand how harmonies work I just really enjoy the sound of them :)
it's like chord but with voice in simple terms :)
That's the most important thing. I work with plenty of producers who don't know shit about music theory yet can drop beautiful jazz and neo soul piano like it's nothing. Your ear is all you need
Very subtle vocal editing here that makes it sound very very nice, good subtle reverb and tuning here on this mans part. Good singing on top of it.
Thanks for posting! Appreciate the support, means a lot :)
Yay, found you through this comment (though it is also in the descripition).
Thanks for creating a wonderful moment:
Your voice in my ears, a cool summer night's breeze and a starry sky = a happy contend heart and calmness for my soul.
Love from a small town in Germany
Youre awesome dude!!!
your compositions/arrangements are beautiful!! everytime i listen to the “you” part i feel like im ascending
keep it up
You sound indcredible!
Yep, because the one thing I love about vocal harmony is how robotic and strictly conforming to 12-TET algorithmic perfection it is.
😂😂
Umm, how about assessing its quality based off of compositional merit? This is not vocal harmony in the traditional sense, it’s an auto tuned voice that works/feels more like a synth. We know this. Isn’t this obvious? It is its own instrument. It’d be like calling the game of whiffle ball a “bad game” on the grounds that there’s not real baseballs being used. No shit, it was designed that way.
Ha imagine complaining that something using 12-TET
🤓
@@augurofnyarlathotep5051 there's a reason choirs don't use it dude.
@@nuberiffic imagine complaining about someone using common practice musical theory for their music
And liking their own comment
🤓
why is everyone piling on this guy, but no one made fun of the girl from the last one (take me to new york one) who used the same effects. This happened with the last guy. Is it a gender thing? like actually, the comments on her video were so positive, these two guys will never hear the end of over laying effects. If you dislike the artificiality, that's fine, but please be consistent.
Legit crying right now this is so beautiful
We did this is choir as a warmup and oh my god did it sound insane
Parallel 5ths, my theory teacher would have none of this 😂
Yeah so uncomfortable lol
Parallel 5ths in of themselves don't really bother me. Power chord voicings basically require them. They only become an issue to me when in a vocal or string arrangement, where the sound is very pure, so they draw way more attention to themselves. They're also surprisingly difficult to sing, because it becomes hard to hear your own voice separately from the voice above you, so try not to use them for 4-part vocals especially!
Parallel fifths are fine. We're not living the 18th century and neither do people write music in that style anymore really. If you like the sound then go ham and use all the parallel everythings you want!
i believe you are my most visited TH-cam channel at the moment:)
Jacob collier barely beat him
@@Calebthecreator so true
@@Calebthecreator I think if you take this guy off a drug called “pitch correction” Jacob collier would smash him
Remember, it’s not just the pitch that’s important, but also the timing as well. Melodyne is good for both. 😂
I just saw this the other day, now you do a transcription! Thank you!
How much auto tune do you want?
This guy: yes.
how about, yes
I want a version of this with the instruments too now.
no
Originally, I was thinking it’s not good that computer programs were used to make this sound better. Then I realized that I don’t actually care, because I’ve given nothing to the person who made it other than a couple minutes, and those couple minutes sounded nice. So… auto tune away!
Beautiful harmony to this song!!😍
Finally got that George Collier recognition!
i remember watching this back when it had like 3k views while this song was trending and stuff! good to see CJ getting the recognition he deserves!
I know that is is heavily auto tuned but why can’t all of tik too be like this. This is beautiful 😢
I would to do this with other people!! In a open area, for reverb or something.
I like it-reminds me of kind of an R&B-style Eric Whitacre
This is a perfect example of blatant overuse of autotune. (Harmony is dope tho, would love to hear it without all the autotune)
This is? All you here in youtube doing harmonies are blatant overuses of autotune or similar.
It is a shame that people rely so much on autotune, not using it can be really time consuming when I record harmonies for fun at home it usually takes over 100 recordings until I'm satisfied but it does make for a much more interesting sound in my opinion
@@tristanrowan5105 "not using it can be really time consuming" this is the whole reason why autotune exists. In this time of tiktok and viral trends being able to create content quickly is key to remaining relevant or catching the right momentum.
@@EricBenjamin518 what he means is that one is more impressive but time consuming, although he still enjoys how the auto tune sounds
Often autotune can be quite useful, such as clearing up background reverb, making sure melodies line up and getting everything perfect
PERFECT， love how he arrange this !
honestly that is just so cool, amazing voicing
this is the kind of video where i realize after the vid that ive been holding my breath the whole time
I’m literally 2 seconds in and I’m already very impressed!!!
I would love a full version of this, it’s so entrancing!
Bunch of snobs whining about pitch correction lol. Cool music is cool music regardless of tools used in the process, and I think this sounds dope. Any effect or trick can be used poorly, drum quantization can suck the life out of something for example, but edited drums done well for the right song only enhance the core performance
1:24 finally satisfaction. Was waiting for that
way to go son - i saved that one to favorites
Maybe it's just my taste but I don't understand everyone complaining about the dissonance in the harmony? Major 2nds are my jam
@NPC 2428 from 1d ago:
"don't love the dissonance. sometimes it works in a nice crunchy way in these tiktok harmonies, but here it feels forced and bad"
I dig the renaissance vibe of the perfect 5ths in parts 1 and 2
It had so much potential to be a thicc raw harmony but hes gotta quit autotune. his voice is great and doesnt need it
You have no idea how this sounded before auto tune to say that. There are some people with great tambre and not so great tuning out there.
@@iurigrang idk I just think a human voice is sound is very beautiful. Even if his voice isn't good, I think I'd still rather hear him than Wall-E. Wall-E is great but I don't want to hear him sing.
@@roboticunclephil I honestly dont doubt it. Im not a singer or audio engineer or anything. I'm probably wrong, but isn't that what the TH-cam comments were made for?... speaking out my ass? I just play stringed instruments and a lil brass. I know that the human voice is naturally beautiful. That's it.
The most satisfying TikTok harmony in the... room.
Depending on the room.
Ooh, that crunchy pedal as the Bass II moves in and out of it.
It's 12:02. Just me and you. And seven other dudes, around you on the dance floor.
My first theory teacher taught me to write Bass and Soprano first, so seeing a harmonization stacked from bass up feels wrong to me.
can't get over those parallel fifts.
Cannot believe. I am so surprised and wondering at the greatness of your talent.
that was more beautiful than i thought it would he
This video makes me so happy every time I listen. ❤
was wating for him to beat box and finally start rappin
This is funny 😂😂
The quint parallels though
I love how it gets more and more dissonant until it resolves into this beauty
What dissonance? This is all diatonic.
@@andybaldman I'm not great with music theory, but for example, if you had a chord with the root and the seventh, there would be some dissonance, yet both are diatonic, right ? Please let me know if I'm wrong.
@@andybaldman a minor second is dissonant and also diatonic. It doesn’t have to be one or the other
@@jagp135 Agreed. But I don't hear any dissonant minor seconds in this. It all sounds very diatonic.
@@andybaldman a major second is still dissonant. the alto and soprano staves sing a held E, F#, and G# at the same time at the onset of the words "moon" and "you". The G# is also the major 7th of the A major chord being held in the bass staff. Sevenths are still considered dissonant to the western ear, as are minor/major seconds and of course the tritone. The leading tone being held in one of the top voices begs for resolution, creating a harmonic dissonance.
Why are yall so hard pressed about the auto-tune? It sounds so good though.
I was hoping you'd do this one ☺️
lyrics:
"Talking to the moon"
"Trying to get to you"
This is going in my note of "Memorable Lyrics" for when I need inspiration to write something
Interesting to see so many people complaining about autotune. I wonder if the same people show up in the comments when an artist is performing outside and uses reverb.
this person sounds so good! Amazing job on the transcription!!
George great work transcribing that is how you are able to teach us those without perfect pitch about the harmonies.
Calming. Sparks joy.
I didn't realize it was the same guy singing every time. I think the first one was actually baritone but I don't know if it's a technical specific range
Why are people so impressed by this?
Damnit Mane! I knew what it was yet still waited for the beat to drop 😩
Wow. People are so fucking harsh. He tried to create a beautiful melody and succeeded (in my opinion). Even if he used Autotune... maybe he's not at a superb level of vocal excellence yet, should that bar him from creating something nice?
That's what gets me about these anti-Autotune purists. They want to ban anyone who isn't an amazing singer from making music that sounds and feels good.
It’s extremely clear that he used pitch correction, and way too much of it. It ruins the harmony for some people because it sounds so fake and like a midi file rather than a real voice. Pitch correction is extremely normal in music nowadays, but this is overdone. The robotic sound doesn’t fit this harmony
That was beautiful. 🙏🏻
My guy, that was beautiful
That's the most satisfying thing I've ever heard
I don’t have TikTok but I saw a song collaboration thing with a whole bunch of kids singing to a composition called “muffin man” of something like that and it was stunning
Well it is enjoyable, dont care with the technical things. Some people prefer music to enjoy it, and i enjoy it.
Cj Capital, an amazing singer 🤟
The second I saw this, I knew you would do a video with it!
Everytime I see a vocal harmony I couldn't imagine how amazing are Freddie Mercury does it in his works with Queen
50 shades of swag will always hold my heart
the pharalel fifts hurt me... i was trained well in theory
That was beautiful ❤
that G# m7 / C# hits differently
Blueballed me so hard. I was so scared he wouldnt do it
That C#9 😍
Guy does harmony tiktok: FAKE. HE USES AUTOTUNE, SOUNDS LIKE TRASH
Girl does harmony tiktok: OMG SHE’S SO TALENTED!!
oh no... PARALLEL FIFTHS!!!!
i dont understand that these "music producers" know it has autotune where as, people who are actual music producers can't even hear where the autotune is.. lol stop being "cursed with knowledge"
I learned in my music theory class that you should avoid parallel fifths at all costs🤓
this makes me relaxing
When that pedal tone comes in, gamechanger
Yes, China will always get to you
Not big on the off beat “yoooouuuuu”
I like the extended harmonies.
people who complain about autotune or brag about not using it are the big truck guys of the music world. y'all are insecure
Good.
Now I know that that lovely voice will NEVER be achieved without electronic help. Or maybe I'll get that tone if I try very hard
Chills
My choir uses tik tok harmonies for warmups, new one to add to the list lol
He used parallel fifths and nobody died
So this is how you use parallel fifths
Reminds me of 808s and heartbreaks
My girlfriend turned into the moon
That's rough buddy
bro got the beardyman loop
very jacob colllier - esque. love it
O:19 parallel fifths
It peaked in the middle tbh
so cool !!!!