Even though I like this scene, I can't help but feel like it's a waste because it's one of my favourite scenes in the books. I don't remember exactly how it was worded, but Qorin asked Jon to do what he has to do. They leave Jon to it. Jon reflects on justice and what his father would have done and decides to let her go. He then comes back and Qorin easily figures out that Jon didn't kill her and they say something along the lines of: "So you didn't kill her" "I know you asked me to do so but..." "I didn't ask you to kill her. I asked you to do what you had to do. You decided to let her go, and now I know more about you. I need to know my men to command them best. Now I know that you won't obey something that goes against your sense of justice" "And if I did kill her?" "Then she would have been dead and I would still know more about you" Of course I probably butchered it, but it's a truly fantastic scene, and making it about Jon wanting to kill her her but being physically incapable to do it kind of loses its charm (although it's the direction they wanted to take with Jon: someone who only obeys honor and does the right thing like Ned)
Great writing never survives the TV writers room sadly, they either think the audience are too stupid to understand the original writing or they have some inflated sense that they know better than the author. Another great example was the recent Shogun adaptation, lots of scenes were butchered when they could have just been done word for word.
Ughhh I really wish it was in the show. This whole series of scenes w Ygritte and Jon and Halfhand were a little confusing in the show theees alot of missing context
What is the name of this series? You producers need to start putting out a better clue then some margin letters or numbers. You do want people to buy the stuff don't you.
Qhorin Halfhand.. actually is Ser Arthur Dayne. Ned didn't kill him, he sent him to the wall under an oath of secrecy. That is why Qhorin protects Jon and mentors him. He was the best fighter North of the wall and easily bests every soldier of the nights watch
Qhorin was pretty dumb here. He should have easily recognized how attractive she was, even for a wildling, and he left the newbie virgin to deal with her, who has obviously never done this to a woman before, either. It boggles the mind. He knew how dangerous the situation was, and he just abandoned them there without making sure it was done.
@@based-ys9um Point of their comment went over your head eh? I'll break it down for you. The show at this point still followed the books, where she wasn't attractive. So OP point about Qhorin being dumb is wrong. The writers at this point weren't going deviate from the show.
@@YoctoporyThey were on horses and going towards Mance anyway, so she wouldn't reach them or pose a threat. He left Jon and said to do what he thinks is best. Then talks to him about it, to figure out what kind of man he is. Later on they are surrounded by wildlings and their horses tire out/die out. Since Qhorin knew of Jons interaction and how he could be super honorable is partly why he could come up with the desperate, last minute plan of making the wildlings believe Jon was a traitor of the crows/turn cloak, trusting Jon wouldn't ever forget his vows. It was experience and improvisation from Qhorin while getting to know his new recruit. In the show he's just stupid and trusting and gets fooled and also the plan feels weird and unnecessary.
Holy, I hadnt seen the actor for Qhorin up to this point but they cast him perfectly. A terrifying man who'd look right at home on the field of battle or on some farmland.
The Half Hand was playing the long game. In the book he knew that Jon wouldn't kill her and that Ygritte would lead the wildlings to them. That was a hell of a man.
This is the once-great HBO series Game of Thrones, from the book series by GRR Martin, "A Song of Ice and Fire." I blv it's 2nd season, but cld b wrong on that part.
They didn’t question at all why Jon would want to do it himself and then are just like okay we’ll see ya later buddy! 🚶♂️🚶I’m not gonna watch but I’ll just leave u alone with this lady ok
I dont think i noticed at the time this first aired, and I may be misremembering, but its ironic that here they talk about the Wildings killing Qorin if they got the chance, but later we see they in fact did take him prisoner, albeit only to have Jon kill him to stay alive.
Back when GOT was good, and the chemistry is real between them , obviously has they are married now , Kit's and Emilia's chemistry felt like 2 relatives at a family dinner who really dont care about each other but are faking being nice to each other
This scene has much more sense in the books. Jon has a choice - let her go or kill her. He decides not to kill her and take her as prisoner and bring to the Qhorin. What’s the point of it if he just said that they can’t spare a man to guard her and they don’t have food
Jon Snow Targaryan'sibling is Daenyrus? First cousin Snow's mother is sister to Daenyrus' fat;er. The asassinated by his Right Hand Jamie Lannister yet this is th÷ actor's true wife off set? Hope this madness does not become accepted.
![Best Of Ygritte || Ygritte Being Iconic For 9 Minutes And 57 Seconds [Game Of Thrones]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CLHvLI-AXaI/mqdefault.jpg)
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Even though I like this scene, I can't help but feel like it's a waste because it's one of my favourite scenes in the books. I don't remember exactly how it was worded, but Qorin asked Jon to do what he has to do. They leave Jon to it. Jon reflects on justice and what his father would have done and decides to let her go. He then comes back and Qorin easily figures out that Jon didn't kill her and they say something along the lines of:
"So you didn't kill her"
"I know you asked me to do so but..."
"I didn't ask you to kill her. I asked you to do what you had to do. You decided to let her go, and now I know more about you. I need to know my men to command them best. Now I know that you won't obey something that goes against your sense of justice"
"And if I did kill her?"
"Then she would have been dead and I would still know more about you"
Of course I probably butchered it, but it's a truly fantastic scene, and making it about Jon wanting to kill her her but being physically incapable to do it kind of loses its charm (although it's the direction they wanted to take with Jon: someone who only obeys honor and does the right thing like Ned)
Great writing never survives the TV writers room sadly, they either think the audience are too stupid to understand the original writing or they have some inflated sense that they know better than the author. Another great example was the recent Shogun adaptation, lots of scenes were butchered when they could have just been done word for word.
Damn they really did butcher this. Doing it properly wouldn't have taken hardly any extra time.
All of this... aside from physically unable. It was his mind, honour and emotions
No man I think you did great, I’ve been reading the books lately and this seems about right
Ughhh I really wish it was in the show. This whole series of scenes w Ygritte and Jon and Halfhand were a little confusing in the show theees alot of missing context
Jon: I'll do it.
Jon's mind: I'll do her.
😂
@@Sunny08810 🤣
Your comment: Gay
Instead of killing her, he married her in real life.
Truth
He ended up “stabbing”her in real life if you know what I mean lol
Marry, F, or Kill.
Real life for Jon Snow.
Don't blame him
Do you not see her, smart man
You know nothing Mr Halloween87
😂😂
😂😂
"Now I have become season 8 episode 3, the battle of winterfell"
- Johnny Slush
I don't get it
scroll down@@Patrick-zr8tv
In the books Jon intentionally spares her because of something Ned taught him
What did ned teach him?
@@TheIronMax
How to nae nae
😂😂@@MaxMikescrool1
@@TheIronMax iirc something about the gravity of execution, basically if it don’t feel right it ain’t right.
What is the name of this series? You producers need to start putting out a better clue then some margin letters or numbers. You do want people to buy the stuff don't you.
The pair began dating in real life and got married at a castle in 2018.
Aight, I break the circle. I know nothing.
Says Socrates
You're damn right you know nothing. Especially how to spell. You sound like a gen z mouth breather.
She's a cool actress. She made the character unique.
John ended up causing the deaths of all his brothers here
All of the above know nothing…
Qhorin Halfhand.. actually is Ser Arthur Dayne. Ned didn't kill him, he sent him to the wall under an oath of secrecy. That is why Qhorin protects Jon and mentors him. He was the best fighter North of the wall and easily bests every soldier of the nights watch
Finally someone with a brain
Never piss off a redhead!
I 2nd that!
I can confirm.
Ron weasly prove the opposite.
Idk, they are always so nice and intelligent
Top comment told you, Mr.
How is it possible that Jon Snow got the two hottest women on the show
Cuz he’s the bloody king of the north
Fun fact,he is married to her IRL
Have you seen him? Hello?
Missandei?
What are you talking about? He never had anything going with Margaery Tyrell, so I don't know what you mean by that comment
How much I would have loved to see them make it to the end game.❤️🐺
Only one of them had impermeable plot armor 😢
Qhorin was pretty dumb here. He should have easily recognized how attractive she was, even for a wildling, and he left the newbie virgin to deal with her, who has obviously never done this to a woman before, either. It boggles the mind. He knew how dangerous the situation was, and he just abandoned them there without making sure it was done.
He knew exactly what he was doing. He knew Jon wouldn't kill her.
she apparently wasnt attractive in the books.
He was the quickest way to find Mances camp. Maybe there was some strategy, or maybe Kit Harrington said “do we have to kill her?”
@@DGSnowolfit's hard to tell but this is the show 😮
@@based-ys9um Point of their comment went over your head eh? I'll break it down for you.
The show at this point still followed the books, where she wasn't attractive. So OP point about Qhorin being dumb is wrong. The writers at this point weren't going deviate from the show.
Damn i love the sound of her voice
It's a bit too convenient that they just decide to leave the two alone
It was done on purpose in the books.
@@carlbates9110 Really? What does that mean? Did they do it on purpose because they knew he wouldn't kill her?
@@Yoctoporyhe done it on purpose to see what Jon will do and learn something about him
@@Yoctopory He wanted to find out what choice Jon would make if left to himself.
@@YoctoporyThey were on horses and going towards Mance anyway, so she wouldn't reach them or pose a threat. He left Jon and said to do what he thinks is best. Then talks to him about it, to figure out what kind of man he is. Later on they are surrounded by wildlings and their horses tire out/die out. Since Qhorin knew of Jons interaction and how he could be super honorable is partly why he could come up with the desperate, last minute plan of making the wildlings believe Jon was a traitor of the crows/turn cloak, trusting Jon wouldn't ever forget his vows. It was experience and improvisation from Qhorin while getting to know his new recruit. In the show he's just stupid and trusting and gets fooled and also the plan feels weird and unnecessary.
“Do you know who I am, girl?”
“Michael, is that you?”
Holy, I hadnt seen the actor for Qhorin up to this point but they cast him perfectly. A terrifying man who'd look right at home on the field of battle or on some farmland.
Now they are married, i wonder if he regrets knocking back the chance to do it ... 😂
Do you think Jon ygritted this decision
Highly underrated comment
😅😅😅
😂😂😂
Jon was thinking with the wrong head
No, but I do think you're an idiot.
She assumed the proper position
Then he carried out his orders and went back to the wall to live out his days.
And a few episodes later she climbs him like a tree
Okay how many shorts of GOT im i gonna see 💀
I Loved her too Jon..❤
The Half Hand was playing the long game. In the book he knew that Jon wouldn't kill her and that Ygritte would lead the wildlings to them. That was a hell of a man.
Snow Planing to Save the Princess Life.❤🎉❤
Hey what series is this? I eant to know the name of this. And is the book the same name as this show? I'd appreciate it
This is the once-great HBO series Game of Thrones, from the book series by GRR Martin, "A Song of Ice and Fire." I blv it's 2nd season, but cld b wrong on that part.
They didn’t question at all why Jon would want to do it himself and then are just like okay we’ll see ya later buddy! 🚶♂️🚶I’m not gonna watch but I’ll just leave u alone with this lady ok
"We're deep in their country"
Jon: Id like to be deep in something too 😏
You know nofhing john snow😂😂😂😊
These earlier season were peak
She ticks every box on my "Marry this woman" list
Straight out of the😔James Bond playbook!
I loved her from #first sights
Qorin Halfhand looks like Julien Assange😅😂
He basically pulled a Krillin on android 18
How long should she get pay for devorcing this man.
Wow aloy is far from killing robot Dinosaurs 😮.
She must have lost her Focus. 😊
she is far from her fridge as well it seems
Name of movie or show
This whole time I thought his name was Half-HOUND. Cuz he was such a good tracker...
I swore I just knew something a minute ago....
You know nothing Maul Bro Kaoi
Longclaw is a fine looking sword
Name of movie?
And the rest was history
That's how it looks like when you use your other "brain"
Movie name?
Game of thrones
And suddenly i know nothing
Great show. Too bad they never made a season 7.
I dont think i noticed at the time this first aired, and I may be misremembering, but its ironic that here they talk about the Wildings killing Qorin if they got the chance, but later we see they in fact did take him prisoner, albeit only to have Jon kill him to stay alive.
She bad as hell
You know nothing ccanterod68!
Whats the name of the film please
TV show Game of Thrones
She’s the best part of GOT
... but then he decided not to."
You know nothing Key Uploads 2
I've always liked Downton Abbey
I am this part of the book now good timing. Clash of kings
What is the name of the show?
Remember the station was in 2 halves. Was the romulus side evolution butbthe Remus side bio weapons? This would counter all what you said.
Should've stayed in that cave
wats da tittle of dis movie
What series is this ??
what movie is this ??
TV show Game of Thrones
The show is ' game of throne
He really married her and couldnt kill his wife
Movie?
Back when GOT was good, and the chemistry is real between them , obviously has they are married now , Kit's and Emilia's chemistry felt like 2 relatives at a family dinner who really dont care about each other but are faking being nice to each other
I don't know if I should feel pissed about the fact that Ygritte would definetely be dead here if she didn't have female privilege
well, that's an ass backwards way of looking at things
with all the ignorance of a butt boil
well that's an ass backwards way of looking at things
with all the ignorance of a butt boil
This scene has much more sense in the books. Jon has a choice - let her go or kill her. He decides not to kill her and take her as prisoner and bring to the Qhorin. What’s the point of it if he just said that they can’t spare a man to guard her and they don’t have food
later on she turn over for jon, just like that, but for far more fun and lovely purposes.
Also in real life too
Spoiler alert.. Jon ran her through.
🥳
What is this series called
Im still trying to GAF.
He stabbed her with a different kind of sword, in the show and in real life
And then he married her!
No clue why, but Ygritte was the most attractive woman in the whole show for me. Probably not a common opinion though.
Hollywood bleeding
why would they leave John Snow alone with an enemy?
Story reasons, although the line "don't take too long" could imply some dark stuff.
I'm sorry, guys, what is the title of the movie? It seems like everyone knows it already.
What is the show called
Game of thrones
What's the title please?
TV show Game of Thrones
Jon Snow the traitor who murders his queen lover Daenerys Targarean.
They let her go on purpose?
Marriage material.
اسم فیلم لطفا
How did it happen that he spared her?
She hot. That’s how.
Jon Snow Targaryan'sibling is Daenyrus? First cousin Snow's mother is sister to Daenyrus' fat;er. The asassinated by his Right Hand Jamie Lannister yet this is th÷ actor's true wife off set?
Hope this madness does not become accepted.
Name?
Game of thrones
is this the game of trones
?
Yes
You know nothing ccanterod68
The name of the move
What is this moive name
Qhorin halfhaand was a menace to the wildlings.
"Don't take too long" feels kind of rapey, to me, why not just wait there to make sure Jon would get the job done?
That's a projection and a half. Like "Don't take too long" has been used so many times for murdering people in movies and shows
😂
@@karagravis true
You know nothing astralanreid
I know something
What is this