How accurate is GREY’S ANATOMY? Real life DOCTOR reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 มิ.ย. 2024
- I compare my real life experience as a doctor to Meredith Grey's to see how accurate the first episode of Grey’s Anatomy is. I’ll talk about the medicine, the hospital and share some of my insights.
Its been fun revisiting Scrubs, House MD and discovering The Good Doctor, The Resident, ER and now Grey’s Anatomy!
For concise #1minutemedicine check out my Instagram:
Insta: / drhopesicknotes
Else:
Twitter: / drhopesicknotes
FB: / drhopesicknotes
Clips used under fair use (education and review).
Grey’s Anatomy footage
By ABC
Production; Shondaland, The Mark Gordon Company, Touchstone Television, ABC Studios
Distributor ; Buena Vista Television, Disney-ABC Domestic Television
Scrubs footage owned by Buena Vista Television (2001-07)
Disney-ABC Domestic Television (2007-10).
Scrubs Intro
• Scrubs Intro
All House clips owned by Fox; Heel and Toe Films, Shore Z Productions, and Bad Hat Harry Productions in association with Universal Media Studios for Fox.
House clip
Available here:
• House - Pilot
Song 'Escapists' by The AutoDisko
Song 'First Day' by Huma-Huma
Song 'See you Soon’ by Otis McDonald
Song ‘Foundation’ by Vibe Tracks
Song ‘New Land’ by ALBIS
Song ‘Finding Me’ by Eveningland
#doctorreacts #doctorwatches #greysanatomy - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
By popular demand I take my first look at Grey’s Anatomy! I can't believe it's 13 years old?! That's right I'm giving very up to date content on this channel :)
I had a fun time talking about the medicine and sharing some similar experiences of mine that appeared in the episode. Hope you enjoy. Comment below if you remember where you were when you first watched this one...
its 13 years old?!?!
I just checked the date it first aired. And it's EXACTLY 13 years to do the day! Spooky.
Dr Hope's Sick Notes you should review the Canadian medical drama saving hope
You should review Chicago Med
Yay so stoked you finally watched!
Funny that every doctor I have seen review this episode has brought up the 2 fingers in the rectal exam, lol.
When he talks about George and then says. "it's weird you guys already know what happen to these characters." THE FEELS. George is too good for us.
Still remember when he wrote 007 on Meredith's palm 😭😭.
Omg 😭 That’s too much
😭😭😭 George!!!
And now Im crying 😢😭😭
George’s death killed me
I’m looking forward to the day where GA and Supernatural make a crossover and bring 007 back 😏
''I don't know why I'm telling you this, it's not like you're going to do it at home'' you won me with this xD
It's good advice
I was searching for this comment😂😂😂
Honey said she wanna try something new in bed 🤷♂️
I was a little hesitant to watch this video because I love Grey's Anatomy, and even I know there are quite a bit of mistakes in it, but you explains things so nicely without necessarily mocking them. That and you're cute to boot =D
I'm glad you've said this (not the cute bit the not mocking shows!). My thoughts are that firstly these shows are super important for getting people interested in medical professions and secondly so much work goes into creating a show like this and therefore should be evaluated in the context that they're set out to be a drama not to revise med schools exams off.
Justin Chang Yeah! He's the first med professional I've seen speak about this show respectfully
Completely agree!
“ trouser too short guy “ 😂😂🤣🤣
Stone Roses I was just going to say that’s not really an insult as it just kinda pretty stupid & in my opinion seriously reaching.. so if that’s the worse they can say about him then I would feel pretty damn good about myself lol
I have temporal lobe epilepsy; dimentia, hallucinations, seizures are all a part of my life. It was strangely calming hearing you talking about it. My diagnosis with Temporal Lobe Epilepsy was a disability that ultimately made me have to drop out of medical school. I grew up from a very young age with a passion for medicine, surgery, and have always had a specific fascination with the brain and smaller neural systems of the body. That's a lot of backstory for just explaining that I did not expect to find your review of Grey's Anatomy of all things to be so touching. Anyway thank you for your videos, they're fantastic.
literally everybody dies - sums up grey's anatomy
Sal Varsey only 4 of the original people (seasons 1-3) are left. Meredith, Miranda, Alex, and Webber😭
Cedra AlKarri season 3 I think is when they were second years and I think a few people(at least one) stayed. I may be thinking of the 3rd group(I’m pretty sure I am)
In America the number one job with the largest rate of suicide are physicians, and yet all those people died in various dramatic ways, and I just had a hard time accepting that, the statistical probability of all of those horrible things happening to a small group of very attractive doctors, and only one of them is of Asian descent, not one Indian guy? Not one impacted bowel? I just stopped watching when Sandra Oh wasn't on it as often as she used to be, I have a major crush on her.
Staci Wiley if you still have crush on sandra oh, watch killing eve.. shes the lead on that drama..
I got a better one
Litteraly everyone has syhpillis
Seizures are scary! The old daycare I worked in the other teacher went on break. I was left alone with 10 infants. Most were sleeping. One woke up and just didn’t look right at all. His lip was trembling he looked EXHAUSTED. I knew something wasn’t right so I kept a careful eye on him. Seconds later he was seizing. Happened multiple times with him and me together. Never scared me any less!
I swear you can run a paid show teaching medicine - paid
like John Green has crash course you can have your own website teaching medicine ......that would be so cool
Loved this! I watched Grey's ages ago and all of House. Lumbar punctures turn up so much in House!
That cauliflower demonstration was fantastic and genius
I am taking anatomy currently and I didn't really understand about the meninges entirely and your demonstration about it really helped me understand!
Thank you so much, I know how much the show means to people so was slightly nervous giving my thoughts!
‘I don’t know what happens to them’ cuts to George 😭😭😭
in real life I think Meredith would have PTSD with everythinh thats happened to her0
Kay Cee She does have PTSD.
I have it, and that's after one murdered best friend during an argument with his ex boyfriend, having to clean up your own friend's murder so his sister wouldn't have to see the blood or the crushed lampshades, it was so stressful, I have lost a lot of people to overdoses and suicides throughout the years, and I loved them and it hurt, but losing my favorite person in the world in such a violent and pointless way...I remember the phone call, the coroner, the questions, having to clean up, make sure the cats were taken out in carriers with me, organizing the memorial, paying for every little thing including arguing over the cost of a small vase they basically glue onto the stone monument where he's interred, and then sleeping for days after it was officially over, I don't think I spoke one word for a year. I made gestures, and wrote things down but my voice just didn't work, I was diagnosed with PTSD, and really there isn't much you can do to make it better other than helping other people as best you can. It's been two years and I can talk, but I prefer to type. I actually used TH-cam as a starting point to communicate with others, because they were strangers, who didn't know me.
She does
she does, more than 1 eps
I was told that's what I have for years, only recently I learned I have "complex PTSD". I have my social work diploma & +15 yrs experience (ptsd came first) & Im just learning the difference. Hang in there, fellow ptsd pals, & be good to yourselves- HUGS🤗
I've just discovered your channel... I am LOVING this :) And I especially appreciated the bit with the cauliflower!
Just saw you on Dr Mike. SO Im very late to your channel, but im certainly going to binge watch. You're very in depth and provide lots of education on the parts of the brain, your hospital dynamics and your experiences. Love it❣
I'm Canadian so its very interesting to see the similarities in your National Health Service and ours and the drastic differences too.
George! Damn I miss the first season if greys
daAnder71 wow thank you sooooooooo much! very needed how else could people understand what I was talking about! You saved my life.
when he mention that someone’s gonna do it in the on call room.... i died laughing bc it’s so true 😂
I'm not a medical professional, but I work at a dementia unit (Food handling and cleaning). It's really heartbreaking to see, and every day to hear someone begging you to take them home. It can be very rewarding though. Just remember that they are people, people with the same wants and needs as you. Much love from Canada. Your videos are both entertaining and educational.
I feel like I don’t see too many real doctors breaking down the medical mysteries in Grey’s so this was really cool to watch! I’m a huge Grey’s fan so I’d love to see you do more episodes. :)
Loved this video!!! I want you to know that I will study medicine next year here in Argentina and these videos really inspire me!! You are great, keep doing this amazing content.
Saw Grey's and I have never clicked so fast!!!
You're really good at explaining stuff!
But in relation to a non keyhole position,this WAS back in 2005 so would really have been done?
Oh god you just pulled out the cauliflower as I'm typing this! 😂
Definitely subscribing!
Ps you might enjou scenes from the later seasons when the residents and attendings are doing insane research and innovative surgical techniques!
Thanks! Yeh from what I can find around 2005 was about the year that most became keyhole, so actually entirely possible that open is realistic for the time.
Been waiting for the review of Grey's! Loved the video! Your explanations of complex things in medicine, things I and I assume quite a lot of people don't know but are interested in, is simple and easy to understand and it makes me want to know more!
One of my new favorite channels. Like your enthusiasm. Keep up the good work!
"Trousers too short guy" isn't pithy at all... Ur colleagues need a lesson in nicknames.
HAHAHAHA.
metimez300 It was their second choice, after realising 'slightly awkward guy' included most of the male staff.
They should've called him "Mister Wade."
For one, to kind of remove the Doctor role; and two, because you can wade in water when your trousers are too short.
Love this! Thanks for taking the time to explain the medical terms you use. Please do another episode of Grey's.
Your cauliflower demonstration was brilliant. Great work, keep it up! Also, it's called a *season* not a series basically everywhere but the UK lol I always get confused when people talk about series of Dr. Who or QI! I'm like, "you mean the season?! series would be the entire show's length."
Can you do a video on your medical school experience?
Great idea; yes I will
Absolutely loved this video!! You're such a great teacher, the way you described what was going on with the patient, I don't think I'll ever forget it. I'm a Grey's fan and was slyly waiting for this video lol. Also love your AF video too.
Danielle O This have nothing to do with your comment, but my name is Daniella and my family name begin with a "O"... WTF ? x)
Danzignan lool that's a pretty strange coincidence
They actually did an episode where merediths first patient comes back in either season 13 or 14 I think.
yes omg the on call room is so iconic !! please continue watching the show it’s amazing !!
Officially subscribed... Thank you for taking the time off of your busy schedule to do this for us. It might not mean much to some but it means a lot to most. Thank you.
I'm getting a knowledge high right now, omg. Where has this channel been all my life?
Omg I’ve been WAITING for this video for sooo long!! Thank youuu x
LOVE your channel, keep going!
Hi Ed, thank you for providing such an easy & interactive explanation of a subarachnoid haemorrhage - more better than my Anatomy tutors! I also love how you compare your own professional experience to the experiences of these characters. I look forward to watching your other videos! It would be great to see more videos on your medical journey (pre and current)
Yes! Thank you! I’ve been waiting for this video. I love your channel, and I love how you explain everything so clearly. Keep it up please, you are doing amazing! :)
You need to review the pigs episode of Greys, because I always wanted to know from a doctor's point of view if 1. Is it ethical? and 2. Is it realistic? I'll search it up and edit the comment with the season and number of episode in a bit.
Edit: Season 5, episode 6, "Life During Wartime". Former army doctor giving trauma training on live pigs.
It's not ethical, but that is actually how medical training works in military school
I don't know how it works for civilians, but one of my best friends was a military trama surgeon, and has told me that they had to save pigs that they shot. He was a vegan, and it was really tough for him. They'd keep the same pig alive for months, caring for it, saving it again and again, and then having to shoot it, stab it, blow stuff up beside it, etc. After about two months of doing this, he decided to take the poor mark, and mercy kill it.
@@_homewardbound_4149 That's absolutely horrific. Anyone who would torture an animal for months, especially an animal as intelligent as a pig, without being traumatized by it is a sociopath or was turned into one by the military.
Just found out about your channel, and I really enjoy it! Also, just came from watching an episode lol...
Love the content!
I loved this video! I’m a huge fan of Greys and I really loved hearing you share your perspective on it all. So good!
What about doing a UK medical show, Doc Martin. I enjoy watching it on netflix here in the US and have been wondering how acuratly it shows the british system
5 seconds into the video and I already love you! I love how you didn't make fun of the show you're just cool and easy going :) great video. The last bit about dementia kinda made me really sad but I m definitely subscribing
You should make this a series, it was so interesting. A lot of really insane things happen on Grey’s Anatomy and it’s cool to get a perspective from someone like you
Thank you for this great video. I was really looking forward to it because Grey´s is my favorite show and I had fun watching this reaction. It´s awesome that I always learn something new or understand certain medical terms better in the end of your videos. Also the show seems to be more accurate than I originally thought even if it´s more the little things. I would love to see you watching ER because to me (about to do my A-levels so no medical knockledge) it seems pretty accurate. (also sorry for possible mistakes I´m german)
Seriously everytime i watch your videos i get a boost if confidence. As a 4th year med school student i always look at the shows and i get scared from all the quick terminology and the 1 minute diagnosis made
AHHH!! I’ve been waiting.
Very riveting episode. Thank you for especially that last bit about patients with dementia and alzheimer's, so true.
You are a really good teacher, the videos are amazing!
Thank you, I've been wanting to watch a doctor's analysis of this show
First time seeing one of your videos, loved it! Especially the visual aids, I'm a huge loved of anatomy & physiology and it was nice to see if made relatable.
I watch your videos and feel as if I'm in a face to face conversation. You have a gift for teaching. Truly enjoy your work, thanks.
Omg I’ve been waiting for this one!! Thanks dr hope :)
Love your demonstration of the meninges! Would love to see more of those cool explanations :D thank you!
I loved this! Now I want a complete guide to all of Grey's Anatomy, it's very intresting to see all the little details there are in there. You should definitely do a couple more of these from other seasons
Your visual aids are top notch. Really helps illustrate what happens and how. Your videos are always illuminating and entertaining. Thank you so much for such tope quality content. Cheers
I lowkey enjoy the first (only the first) season of Grey's Anatomy. If someone confronts me in the OR during anesthesia rotations about this I'll deny it to the death.
I enjoyed 1st season and 5 or 6 episodes of the 2nd. Then it became too soapy
Bolt SRNA if you watch the rest of it,it is a really good show...
Bolt SRNA 😂😂😂
I have screenshots of your comment .... I will find you and embarrass you
I liked seasons 1-4. After that I sortive lost interest, but I did catch some of the season 8-9-10 stuff because my grandma used to watch it.
Do ER! Please? My Uncle is a doctor and he says it was one of the more accurate medical dramas. Also, do Chicago Med. My sister could barely handle five minutes because it was so inaccurate
Thank you for this video, and especially sharing the advice you got on dealing with people who have dementia. I'm a nurse in training and work on an internal medicine ward, where we see quite a lot of elderly patients, some of whom inevitably have dementia. I'm thinking and hoping this insight will help me provide more comfort to them. Keep up the great videos!
Please do a review of Chicago Med. I believe it has a good representation of ER docs (I don't work in the healthcare industry, yet) and hospital staff in general
Your videos are so interesting and informative. The cauliflower demonstration was so smart!
I really love your input on these shows. ❤
Great job on the video! I love Greys and I love that you didn't rip it apart.
I've watched every single episode of all 14 Seasons too date and I can honestly say that you Dr Hope will be inspiring more future doctors than all these medical series' combined. Love your channel!
I love watching your content. It's made medicine so much easier to understand. I'd love to see a video on Crohn's or IBD just because so many people have no idea what it is but so many people have it
Agreed! I have Crohn’s Disease and you’re right, A LOT of people have no clue what it is all about or they compare it to IBS...so not the same.
That was a beautiful and simply put way of describing dementia and their emotions. I’m not a doctor but I have interacted with individuals with dementia. Thank you for explaining that emotion of wanting to talk to their mom so beautifully.
Boo Radley Yes, I was touched by that too! My paternal grandmother (the wife and mother of doctors) has dementia, and it is heartbreaking. Especially to see my Dad, who throws himself into taking care of people and at least improving there lives if he can't fix their ailment, sitting there, not able to really do much at all, to not be known by his own mom, it's really disturbing and just endlessly sad. I hope, in time, we find better treatments so people don't have to do this. To have them so fully taken away from you, but still there is a very specific kind of pain. Dr. Hope's way of understanding the meaning underneath the words will help me handle this in the future.
This was my favorite video ever. You know so much about medicine.
Oh yesss, I was hoping you would do this!
I just found your channel and I absolutely love this. As a fan of medical drama I love to see your opinion on them and all the things they exaggerate and get wrong. I just subscribed can't wait for more!
Man, I love your videos. I have absolutely no experience with medicine and generally don’t have much of an interest in the field, however I thoroughly enjoy watching all your videos.
Your videos are fantastic!! I'm so happy I found your channel!!!
Wow! I'm a fan of the show! I'm not in the medical field, so I don't understand much of what happens in the show, but I've paused it and done research sometimes and it's been fun to learn new things, so this video was great! It would be awesome to see you reacting to more episodes! See what it's really like and stuff. I loved this video, the part with the cauliflower was awesome! :)
This just popped up in my suggestions. Definitely worth it.
I really enjoyed your review. Greys anatomy is my favorite tv show! I love hearing from a doctors perspective
i just love how you explain stuff with everyday items! could imagine a whole channel of those 😂
Great video! You're a very good teacher, you helped even this law grad understand the medical stuff ;)
DUDE! I subscribed because you gave that wicked cool demonstration of the hemorrhage.
I think that's awesome!
Incredible. While watching Grey's Anatomy I always thought about what a dorctor would have to say to that. This is so much fun! And also very educational. I didn't mean to learn something while watching. But thanks!! I'm amazed.
From all the Doctors-reaction-videos I watched (somehow all are strictly starting with episode one, hihi) this is definetly my favourite!
Thank you very much for doing this!
The brain explanation was so good. Great job on the video!
Best thing about this video is the lecture. Thanks, doc!
tim s I
Enjoyed very much seeing on Dr.Mike's Podcast .... Loving your videos 🙌🏽
Amazing lesson on the Brain.
Dude this was great! But now you have to do an accuracy review of each and every episode of every season haha... please and thank you
OMGosh love the advise on the dementia! Never thought of it that way but that makes soooo much more sense to me now
I’ve seen the pilot of greys a bunch of times and never realised that the patient saying “my heads all full” was a symptom. Great videos man 🙂
I really appreciate how you focus on what they get right rather than going the easy route and just nit-picking the heck out of it.
I am hooked. The clarity on the subarachnoid haemorrhage was crystalline - using bin bags and red tape was inspired. Next the funny bit
I've just discovered your channel and after seeing this video, I suscribed to... I really like the way you explain the different parts of this episode, it's very informative and I hope to see more videos like this, as a medical student, I thank you.👍
omg love your channel! keep up the good work. Also hoping to get into medicine this year
Rewatching this two years later, now I'm a nursing student. On my first clinical placement I was in a surgical ward. A patient on my preceptor's load who was in good health and about to be discharged suddenly started seizing, went into cardiac arrest, and had a MET call. Even though I had nothing to do with the MET code, it's frightening to see as a student, indeed!
This was really interesting. I have been watching Grey's Anatomy since they started and I still love this show. I assumed they would have doctors who help them make it as real as possible, but it's cool to hear an actual doctor's opinion. The demonstration with the cauliflower was great. I totally understood it all. :) P.S. I just found out about the actually existing anatomy book a few weeks ago and it was one of those enlightening "Wow, I had no clue" moments. Haha...
Thank you! One of the reasons I left nursing was the fear and it was good to have that validated. I worked in L&D at a high risk pregnancy unit and was scared most of the time. When bad stuff happens it happens really fast and you don't want to lose baby or the mother. Everybody thinks L&D is such a happy place to work but so much can go wrong and when everybody is already geared up with a high risk mindset it is much less "fun." (I also spent several years caring for Alzheimer's patients and that was far less scary. You just had to be prepared to have the same conversations over and over for 8-12 hours. There also was the advantage that if you had a disagreement about something in 5 minutes it was ancient history and the patient who had resisted something, say bathing, could be approached differently and the bathing done with no problems!)
loved this! I've always wondered what real life doctors think of grey's I'm a huge fan of the show
That is a phenomenal teaching aid. Very well demonstrated.
My 18 month old nephew has quite a bit of seizures. He has Neurostorms which suck because a lot of the time the diazepam (7mg) doesn't work and he'll often have a storm for a day or two. He used to have Infantile Spasms, which to me are terrifying due to the damage to the brain that is happening through such a semi-subtle looking seizure.
Anyway, I'm a new subscriber and I love what you are doing bro. I watched tons of your videos the other night. I love learning about medical subjects so thank you for doing what you're doing.
I love both shows and loved your reviews on both greys and ER. but as a nurse I can def relate to ER more, and even today I still love to watch it.
Greys never focused on nursing characters, so I guess that really why I like ER more as a kid especially 🤣 as it was very much medicine and nursing. Your Sub arach break down was really good .
Hey mate, old-ish subscriber here, though I hardly comment. I am bewildered (and in a good way) by how your channel is growing as of late, please keep up the good work; I am looking forwards to further growth, your content is, daresay nearly one-of-a-kind on this site! Cheers!
Thanks for the comment and all your support.You're right I've been overwhelmed by the response lately, I think I have the dedicated fans of Grey's Anatomy and Scrubs to thank!
I loved how you used visual props to explain the haemorrhage! Great video! 😁
I was so excited to see this 😂 maybe you could do Nurse Jackie in the future!
I loved this video!
I love watching these, I find your input so interesting and refreshing I’d love for you to do Code Black next, it’s a pretty great, not so sure on the accuracy though
Great video! I would love to see another one on a more recent episode of Grey's. Obviously the show being 13 years old they transition quite a bit as surgeons and part of me wants to see your reaction to the characters 'all grown up' so to speak. Also, it would be great to find out if the writers gotten less accurate with the medicine as time has passed, especially since the newer episodes are a little more focused on the actual doctors and not so much on their cases. I could definitely see them throwing medical accuracy out the window for the drama of it all!
YAY! FINALLY! I AM SO EXCITED!😍😂