Why violence is escalating in the West Bank
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ย. 2024
- Use code tldrnews at the link below to get an exclusive 60% off an annual Incogni plan: incogni.com/tl...
This video explains the new US sanctions on a battalion of the IDF and explore what’s going on with this parallel conflict in the West Bank.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahE...
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk...
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
How do you sanction just a single unit of an army?
When you want to pretend you're doing any damage to someone 😂.
Pretty easily. You can sanction individual people.
@@archockencanto1645 90% pretend; 10% sending a warning that sanctions are not off limits
Like the exchange of fire with Iran. Not really intended to cause damage, but more to send a message what is on the table.
Better question: why only a single unit? Normally the US has no problems with punishing whole countries even when it means the normal people have to suffer
@@karimabidi8312 they said something about an american citizen dying in their custody. Which is why they specifically are being sanctioned
The fact that Israel considers this "sanction" beyond the pale while at the same time the USA is just now giving Israel an additional $15B in military aid shows a strange view of things for both sides.
US is giving 26 billion USD to israel and sanctions one unit. Don't you think they just give money dedicated for other units to this one now that you are paying for the rest of the army?
I know its stupid, how can they physically stop the idf supplying the unit American weapons?
From my understanding, it's likely different parts of the government doing this
The aid bill was a compromise between Republicans and the government as they were stonewalling Ukraine aid, by mixing like 4 different aid bills into one session, called "logrolling", to force through Ukraine aid by bundling it with other policies the opposition wanted passed, see how the same bill also includes Taiwan aid, when initially the Ukraine, Taiwan and Israel bill were all separate before
While I'd guess the investigations and sanctions are not being carried out by the legislative branch
@Larsino2000 we don’t provide military aid to Palestine or Hamas…
@@0oShwavyo0 he meant food. He is advocating man made famine.
@@Storming360you think we should be feeding terrorists?
Sure they sanction the settlers but what you didn't mention is how often they roll them back not long after, its all for show.
How often is that?? Considering that in 20 years the number of settlers increased by 3-4 times
It's a token sanction
Sanction only Harms settlers who want to leave to USA in future or US companies. That is why most companies are in west bank are commodities, it's like when China grows cotton in Xinjiang, then sends the cotton to guanzhao for it be become threads and then there the clothing is made and sold to rest of the world.
It is their land they can do what they want with it.
@@jerrymiller9039put people have been living there for around 1k years straight. Also the first owners of the land were canaittes, guess who are the lineage of canaittes (it was the Palestinians)
Netenyahu saying someone else's actions are a moral low is like Boris Johnson calling someone else a liar
Lol
😂😂
It's all a matter of perspective, brotha
Well you can say that as you have never lied.
Yes having armed settlers create a bunch of settlements within another countries territory and bully the local population tends to create tensions…
Well there are no settlements in Gaza but the outcome isn't different. Maybe it's just an excuse for terrorism ?
What can you expect from the Jew.
@@eranhasid7630 The West Bank is a separate region of Palestine. That's like if Canada was illegally building settlements in New England and then saying "There's no settlements in Florida!!'
@@eranhasid7630 what is your argument here exactly? Gaza is controlled by a pro-war govt, the west bank on the other hand. Had decided to lay down arms and try and work for peace with the zionists. This is a product of israeli greed and zionist extremism, to suggest otherwise is incomprehensible to me
@@noahjohnson935 But the attacks come from Florida. So my arguement is pretty valid. Then again Lebanon is a sovereign country but attacks came from Lebanon too. Again maybe it’s just an excuse for terrorism ?
Moral low is having a unit that commites warcrimes
"Did you behead an entire square of arabs? Have poke in the chest for that!"
"How dare you? That is a moral low!"
2024 politics in a nutshell 🤡
It's only a war crime if a white man commits it
Israel have a unit that commits war crimes
Hamas have its entire army commitic the worst warcrimes against them ever since the holocaust.
Yeah... no, I still support Israel.
True Hamas is a moral low
@@PhilipLaSnailthe Israel army commits war crimes
Imagine being so brutal that even the US kindly asks you to reconsider your actions.
Israel is not so brutal is just that the world is hypocrite
Or hell even India saying you should tone it down with the anti-muslim stuff
@@שמעוןאייזנברג-צ3כ If the entire world is hypocritical, that's bad for Israel. It's very unlikely 8 billion people are going to change their ways. Far more like 7 million Israelis will be forced to change their ways to confirm to the world's hypocrisy. Seems like if you are Israel, you would listen to the world merely for your survival. Hypocrisy or anything means very little if it's the overwhelming opinion of those around you.
@@שמעוןאייזנברג-צ3כ Yes we aren't the baddies. The world is Khamass.
@@שמעוןאייזנברג-צ3כ ever wondered why you were kicked out of 100 countries before.
Illegal settlements tend to do that
Arab illegal colinial settlers must leave and go back to Arabia. This is Jewish land, and Israel's land according to the international law uti possedetis juris
@@davidcooks2379those Arabs are living there for more than 2000 years. The Israelis are living there for less than 80 years
It is illegal only if Israel does it
No such thing as an illegal settlement only winners and losers
@@2loaves388 Try to settle land you don't own and see how that goes.
Meanwhile France and UK sitting in the corner trying to pretend that this wasn't all their fault.
As the famous song goes, we didn't start the fire. It was hardly a land of peace, democracy, self-determination and religious freedom before, during or after the British, French and Ottoman empires arrived on the scene.
@@ricequackers You never laid eyes on a history book about the matter, did you? Educate yourself⸺that sort of confident ignorance has no place in modern society. Britain literally helped them smuggle weapons in and train their armed militia while using brutal repression to stop the Palestinians from doing anything of the sort. Then they sponsored the UN to give 55% of the land to 17% of the people, almost half of which had arrived in the last 30 years.
And by the way, I wonder if you'd say the same thing if someone had done that to Europe, one of the most violent places on Earth by that time.
At this point it's like a 50 year old blaming their parents for not having enough ice reams, dude you're an adult yo can't blame them anymore
112 children... imagine if they were Americans or British...
Americans and Brits don't commit jihad...
They do support Jeenocide though@@sagunsingh7415
@sagunsingh7415 neither do children.
@@wiseoldwizardok then, im sure you'll nod and smile if a cop goes all police brutality on your newborn baby and claims its a terrorist
@@mappingshaman5280 except they are
We live in a world where fighting for one's own land is terrorism and snatching someone else's land is pretty good
you set an arbitrary start date for history, is not every muslim nation built on stolen land?
Both can both can be true. Palestine can commit acts of terrorism and Israel can also brutalize Palestine
@@007kingifrit my guy doesn’t not know the difference between religious tolerance and settler colonialism
Tell me how gang rape helps the Palestine cause?
@@definitelynotgreen6698 you're right i literally have no idea which side you think is which......i'm also pro western colonialism i think the uncolonized are monsters
People tend to get mad when you steal their land and their homes.
But But God Gave us this land
Literally Every Time .
Stealing land is literally how every country was formed
Nothing stolen here. Land is not Jewish nor Arab as itself. Arabs tried to eliminate and expell the Jews in , because they opposed the creation of a Jewish state. Fair enough. They lost, but never were able to move on, and they didn't ask for a srate when they were under Jordanian and Egyptian rule, but didn't get citizenship either. So, the Arabs who lived under the British mandate of Palastine, were weponized by the Arab world and UNWRA in the hope of eradicating Israel. The Palastinians are not able to currently build a state, they wish to destroy Israel and that is a different goal entirely.
I'd like to live in peace with Arabs from all of the region, and I don't mind actually accepting a Palastinian state in principle, but there are all the reasons to expect that a Palastinian state would be established with every intention of just fighting forever with Israel. Fuck that, first the Palastinians need to grow up as a people, if they are ones as they claim
And people also get angry when you don't want to share the land and you keep shouting that you're going to destroy your neighbor "from the river to the sea".
@geopolitical23 why you wanna even share ur land bro 😭😭
This is going to end one of two ways:
1. Palestinians leave
2. Israelis leave
Which of these two options do you see realistically happening? History may honor victims, but it is unkind to them. I think the IDF will go first maximum damage/maximum effect until the have achieved their goals, then spend the next 20 years trying to fix their relationship with everyone.
There will be several generations of Jordanians, Egyptians, and Palestinians especially that will never forget this.
If the Nakba (where 15,000 Palestinians were killed over a 2 year period and 750,000 displaced) could still lead to 75 years of resistance, and ultimately 7 October, what do you think displacing 2 million people and killing 40,000 of them (15,000 of whom are children) in 6 months is going to do ?
Israel will never know a moment of rest from here on out
Disagree, everyone can stay where they are, but the Palestinians need to start to condemn and fight terrorism and violence within themselves and accept the existence of the Jewish state, something they've never done and are basic requirements for peace
@kfireven why should they accept a state that is constantly oppressing, starving, imprisoning, and killing them?
@@kfireven will the Israelis condemn and fight the settlers in tbe west bank, and the extreme violence of the IDF, particularly towards children?
Will Israelis accept the existence of the Palestinian state?
"The 'Netzah Yehuda' battalion is an inseparable part of the Israel Defense Forces" - We all agree with that.
I wonder if their culture is incorporated in the IDF as a whole
@@Anon-y4w they are the embodyment of the IDF culture.
The West Bank was never part of modern Israel legally. What you wish for is another matter. And things that happened thousands of years ago gives nobody any right to any land, im afraid.
Since Israel took the West Bank from Jordan, does that mean that Jordan is the rightful owner of the West Bank (even though they relinquished all claims to the land in the nineteen eighties?
@@FarberBob678 Jordan relinquished claims to the land to the PLO
@@nayeemhaider8367 The PLO hadn't even declared independence yet, plus I'd argue that Jordan was an illegal occupier since it had no right to take the West Bank from the land of the British Mandate.
@@FarberBob678should give it back to the Ottoman Empire or Turkey
@@grasshopper8901 My argument is that since Israel is the only country that came out of the British Mandate when it ended, that means that Israel should technically have rights over all the land of the British Mandate. Despite this technical claim, I believe it is best for there to be a two-state-solution where the Palestinians get their own state in part of land of Mandatory Palestine. Just because a country (that does not yet exist) has no technical right to that land does not mean that they should not receive it anyway.
Stealing peoples land tends to cause problems.
The islamists stole many lands across Africa and Asia.
...except Israel does still own the West Bank. You haven't read international law nor what the Oslo Accords actually say.
@@veeaxis3892when does they own it? They’re illegally occupying it in a genocidal war.
Both
States sponsor state terrorism to suppress vulnerable 's voices under the patronage of US
Both
Indian Illegally Occupied Jummu and Kashmir &
Gaza
R Occupied by India & Israel illegally
Indeed
Humanity should wake up Now!!
@@veeaxis3892 Ah yes, military conquest and occupation of a land belonging to peoples who don't identify with your state. Doesn't matter if the Oslo Accords say the territory is Israeli, the OP's point still stands. Israel seized territory belonging to Palestinians and gave it to Israeli settlers, legal or not, it will cause significant issues either way.
Under your logic the irish nationalists had no reason to be upset during the troubles.
Over the years, Israeli security forces have practiced an official policy of using Palestinians as human shields, ordering them to carry out military activities that put their lives in jeopardy. This use of civilians was not an independent initiative by soldiers in the field, but the result of decisions made by senior military officials--- B’Tselem.
The fact that the situation in the west bank is internationally tolerated is absolutely insane, and the consequences of it will haunt generations to come.
When Lincoln declared that the Kansas-Nebraska act was an act of violence, it wasn’t a pro-John Brown statement, although that is how the Southern slave holding class interpreted it.
In the same way, correctly declaring Israeli’s policy in the West Bank an act of terrorism isn’t a pro-Hamas statement, but that is how it will be interpreted by many people
Maybe. But I think you’ll find a huge group of people like myself who understand Israel’s attack on Hamas and their supporters in Gaza (76% of the population support the October 7th attacks), even while thinking Israel needs to show more care, stop using dumb bombs when claiming they’re all precision and allow humanitarian corridors when it doesn’t interfere with their operation. So basically qualified support for Israel defending itself. At the same time, we loathe Netanyahu and would be happy to see the violent, supremacist settlers and their supporters in some parts of the IDF stopped.
It’s strange that the majority is the governments of the free world kinda hold this position, don’t you think? Or is that because of the ‘Israel lobby?’ Sounds like an antisemitic position to me - those pesky Jews, manipulating the gentile democratic, nay aryan, governments! Ok, that’s probably not what you think but I’ve come across several ‘anti-racist’ lefties who think that way.
Our governments cock up a lot but maybe this is one of those other times, when they have all the information. And that’s why they support Israel in Gaza while opposing the settlements on the West Bank?
This is not a simple conflict. It has been going on since the attack on Khybar and the rejections of Mohammad as a prophet by the Jewish elders in 7th or 8th Century Arabia.
Not to mention his dream of a visit to Jerusalem on then back of a winged donkey. I’m not poking fun at these beliefs, Judaism and Christianity have equally absurd stories people believe to be true. But this is what we’re dealing with -
God gave the land to one tribe while the same god, almost, gave the land to someone else. And war has results. My grandfather left Europe in the 30s, a refugee from Fascism. Does that make me a refugee too? Should I attack whomever lives in the estate he once had, claiming it as mine?
No. Best stay out of the whole thing. It can only be made worse by starry eyed interference and believing one side bad, the other good. And when the ‘bad’ side is Jewish people, well. That just stinks.
wtf was kansas nebraska act?
@@windowslogo3577 the Kansas Nebraska act overturned the Missouri Compromise which prohibited slavery above 36th parallel.
@@julianmorriscoyou might condemn Netanyahu and Israeli’s settler policy, but Netanyahu was elected by Israel and the settler policy has been going on for decades. The Palestinians have not been given any reason to think peacefully resisting occupation would result in anything but their expulsion of themselves and annexation of their lands.
@@julianmorriscothe conflict goes back to the 1920s when Britain refused to rescind the Balfour declaration.
A lebensraum in the east...
well they are infact entitled to living space. especially since islam stole all the land to begin with
It's ironic how close to Nazis the state of Israel has become.
“Other war” is a crazy way to say illegal settlements
Hasbara 101:
1.We haven't heard reports of deaths ,will check into it
2 .The people were killed but by a faulty Palestinian bomb/rocket
3.ok we killed them but they were terrorist
4.okay they were civilians,but used as human shield
5.okay there were no fighters in the area so it was our mistake,but we kill civilians by accident,they do it on purpose
6.ok we kill far more civilians than they do , but look how terrible other countries are
7.why are you talking about Israel? Are you kind of anti Semite?
Adam Johannes, secretary,cardiff stop the war coalition
8. It's bad if others want ethno-state...
100%
Netanyahu calling the US immoral sure is an example of the pot calling the kettle black.
no, israel is not doing anything immoral. this is a normal war, its sad but that's how war is
Nope its not a normal war recognised country its a terror organisations and the foghting isn't happening in country its happening in an enclave which is Gaza all the time compared to open air prison and detaimend zone by all kinds of international bodies from all kinds of places, again not a normal war.Mostly civilia casualties and right now evem famon and mass starvations. Israel is definitely doing something immoral right now,by every human standard imaginable.
War crimes are crimes because they are not normal. And anyway war is immoral
This caption feels like it could be re-used every other month and each year.
And it would still be very fitting.
It feels like it could be reused from the beginning of time
@@jacrispy1150nah mostly since 1947.
@lordmiraak8991 Didn't the West Bank have a period of peace for like 20 years under Jordanian rule though (which they didn't declare independence there interestingly enough)?
@@zjzr08 yeah, they didnt declare independence there because it was always a temporary thing until the full palestinian issue could be solved. That time never came. But the issue isnt really independence, the issue is the apartheid. It is the displacement and the violence done against the civilian population.
@lordmiraak8991 Most of the violence are from Palestinians who attack against Israelis though (although yes, the issue of settlements is always murky, debates if the West Bank can't be taken by a defensive war or not, etc., plus agreement from the Camp David Accords about security in the region) which I think is fair, like even if they are illegally occupying the land, should they just lay down there and be killed?
To add even if it is temporary, they still should've declared independence because 1.) It affirms Jordan being occupiers 2.) Actually starting building international relations with other countries 3.) Just like with Taiwan or Korea, it isn't impossible for them to reuinte with the other land, even if it is improbable.
Correct me if I’m wrong,
If the battalion gets its weapons and supply from the IDF and the US still sells weapons to the IDF, what the fuck does the sanctioning do?
Nothing, just so the Americans act like they are doing something
how bout some sanctions on Israel for occupying in general?
Please correct my assumption if it is wrong. But you believe all of Israel is occupation, correct?
@@sfp2290 correct
Stealing land tends to cause that
By that logic Germany would have rights to a good chunk of Poland. They lost the war they started, they lost the land. That's how it works.
they didn't steal land learn history
th-cam.com/video/XNf40sBcvKk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=mflHwARzBaUsomju
This is a good video to prove why the Israeli people ; have always existed whether they are either Jews or Muslims but no state of Palestine has existed. Jews and Muslims can coexist like that have for hundreds of years. I made sure this video was as unbiased as it can possibly be. People talk about Israel being genocidal to Muslims but Arab countries have done the same thing to Jew all over the Middle East and Africa
It’s cute you think Palestine didn’t attack them before then.
@@JohnJaggerJack you wanna convince me how a gang of armed poles and european immigrants won a land standing on piles of corpses...?
@@AL-lh2ht there was no israel to start a war with.. just armed illegal immigrants who got kicked out from 100 countries(i wonder why?)
War? Don't you mean genocide?
No, if Israel wanted to the entire palestinian population would drop to 0 within a single day.
@@kostas0352 not what genocide means, the Serbs killed “only” 40 thousand people at serbonitza, but it was still declared a genocide, and the leaders persecuted at Den Haag. Intent is the main driver and the intent was undoubtedly there on the Israeli side. Your point again?
@@jackrenders8937 if israel's point is to what? the settled area are agreed to by the oslo accords which was enacted by the PA? would you call azerbajani settlements in ngorno karabakh illegal too? or is it genocide as well? israel is not comitting genocide in the west bank since settlements are not genocidal, there are conflicts between the settlers and the palestinians of course, but they are mostly unorganized local people.
@@princecommander5757 I have little to no knowledge when it comes to Azerbaijan or Armenia, The fact is Settlements are Illegal and Immoral and IDF has proven they or elements of them has genocidal intent.
@@jackrenders8937 you're both wrong, genocide isn't a number. genocide is an intention. and israel just isn't trying to wipe them out. if they WERE trying. then he is right....they would be dead by now.
and that's the definition of genocide....its about intent. and israel just doesn't have that intent.
The west bank must be free!
It’s Israel forever
@@khlapsIsraelis:The West bank is for ISRAEL!!!!.
Also israelis:Why do you palestineans hate us.
Offende by everything,Ashamed of nothing.
@@khlaps Squatter.
Real life squatters are Islamic, they squat here, there, everywhere, on the toilets, water everywhere, splish splash splosh
@@khlapsBetter with Jews than with Islamic groups, these left-wing people think that these people are tolerant, which is great absurd.
Remember guys, the conflict didn’t start October 7th 🇵🇸💔
I agree but I feel like this conflict started both in the past and October 7. The conflict is complicated.
It started before 1948 when Arabs invaded the Holy Land
@@Juan-qu4oj Ah yes, the Muslims invaded the Jewish holyland... held by Christian European empires?
@@ahmedharajli189 that’s exactly what they did. I’m tired of hearing about Israeli “settler colonialism” when the whole Middle East and North Africa are Arab due to Arab settler colonialism. The Arabs deserve no sympathy and should go back to Arabia.
@@xY1Bc56dEf90l it's not that complicated... a side has the biggest arsenal in the world and unwavering support from colonial countries, the other has stones from their recently demolished houses.
Where does the US get the Ukraine and Israeli aid money from… considering the country is essentially (almost) broke?
From Taxes
It is not broke.
Why did you name this “other war”? It’s an occupation, so war feels a little misleading
The resolution would be so easy for the US... They have the power to do it. Israel is dependent on their billions of dollars and weapons.
Not realy .
Israel is dependent on us for somme munitions .
So withdrawing israel support means more casualties due to less acurate munitons .
@@roeci6 Are you kidding? Israel is heavily dependent on the support of the US. Thats why they spend so much for PR in the US.
Without them, they wouldnt behave like they do.
@@roeci6 such a bs. Sanctions against Israel like those against russia and there would be peace after less than a week
@@billcarson818 Rather than dependent on money (let's face it, Israel has more GDP per capita than most of EU countries), they are far more dependent on unconditional US support in diplomacy, as well as most of US based media.
Look at UN security council votes. Recently on votes concerning Israel/Palestine US is the only country left that is still supporting Israel no matter what. Even Brits are often abstaining.
If one day US change its stance towards Israel and stopped their support it's pretty easy to imagine Israel suddenly losing their only remaining international credibility and Netanyahu's regime could collapse practically overnight. Precisely why Israel lobbyists are doing their best to prevent this very thing from happening.
As an Israeli, we are not.
But we obviously prefer them on our side than the terrorist's...
Calling an illegal occupation a war is beyond disingenuous
If Canada or Mexico were evicting Americans off their land and building houses on US soil, you'd see a lot of Americans calling that an act of war.
The solution to this stupid conflict:
1) one democratic state
2) two religio-ethnic states
Any other solution will lead to escalated wars.
We have one life on this earth, these relentless wars are just dumb.
It is a slap for those who say it had started in 7 October
2023
It all started with the Arab league's failed invasion in 1948. You reap what you sow.
Aren't Hamas and PA rivals, I'm pretty sure the current conflict, while related, is mostly independent IMO.
Hitler and Netanyahu behave the same.
It's not an another war. It is the same war from Israel against Palestina with the same purpose (they prefer to wipe them out), but there is less media attention for this part of the war.
A unit specifically for radical xionists is crazy lol
It's not a unit, it is the whole Israeli Army
It’s the whole Israeli government at this stage. Israel has been consistently moving right for decades. We’re at the far-end of that spectrum now.
Tnx for the love and support 🇮🇱❤
What is the point of sanctions when US is giving Aid in billions. What we need is justice.
What's the individual incentive for moving to the West Bank? I get that the government is attempting to suppress the Palestinians, but why, as a family/individual, would you risk moving somewhere so dangerous and contentious?
Great episode guys.
Lies. Judea and Samaria are not occupied, they are Israel sovereign territory
🤓
@@davidcooks2379not according to international law
@@davidcooks2379cope
I think having a separate Palestine state is absurd at this point. Israel's gotta take over the West Bank and allow everyone there to become citizens with equal rights. 80 years is a ridiculous amount of time for it to stay separate yet controlled.
Lool an ethnoreligious fascist state that calls them animals??
However, 75% of Palestinian Arabs support Hamas, according to their own polls.
So the majority of Palestinian Arabs should be given the opportunity to emigrate and those that do not should be expelled. The peaceful, anti-terrorism minority can stay. Full annexation of Judaea & Samaria and Gaza. Equal rights for all. The end.
@@Daniel-jv1ku emigrate where its their country
Allow everyone with equal rights😂 what a joke
Remember Israel only occuppied the West Bank since 67 which is around 60 years...just to be clear they weren't the first occupiers there.
Short answer: israeli colonisation
An Israeli here, H O W - A R E - W E - C O L O N I Z I N G - O U R - O W N - H O M E L A N D ? ? ?
AND HALF OF US HERE ARE FROM NORTH AFRICA AND THE MIDDLE EAST.
@@PhilipLaSnail well majority of countries dont recognise the west bank as israeli land and origins are irrelevant to the fact that the settlements are illegal under International law.
Israel didn't exist before a bunch of Europeans colonised Arab land after the second world war. Israel is not a final solution, it's an abomination @PhilipLaSnail
@@cgt3704 Most Israelis don't justify the settlements, neither do I.
But I thought you meant the entire sovereign land of Israel, sorry.
@@PhilipLaSnail well the video was about the west bank, but i understand the confusion
why do you neglect the violence of palestinians against jewish settlers in the west bank? how many incidents of that? does the un count?
Settlers? Or invaders seeking to displace them?
@@shafsteryellow indigenous people returning to their homeland (laterally called Judea - land of the jews) you mean?
@@shafsteryellow not invaders just natives reclaiming theeir holyland against the meccan invaders
@@theimmortalemperor3605 wrong. How can Poles and Ukrainians be natives 😂
@@shafsteryellow
Arabs are native to Arabia, Jews are native to Judea.
So why are there Arabs in Judea?
"War" that is a funny way to say genocide
Population increasing tho
@@blazer9547a genocide is still happening, even though the birth rate might be a bit higher than the death rate.
@@Ian-en2sqit's a shitty genocide then...
@@Ian-en2sq There is no effort to wipe out the populace or the ethnic culture, and there is no effort to expunge Palestinians from the area. No definition of genocide is being met.
@@blazer9547 so there's also never was a genocide against Armenian's and jews?
The Palestinians have been in full control of Gaza since late 2005 or early 2006, they have never established or made moves to establish a Palestinian State despite having 100% control of Gaza for 18-19 years.
As an Israeli, I'm against the expansion of settlements in the West Bank and pro-two states. I'm also against Netanyahu and his radical government. That being said, after October 7th, with rising support for Hamas in the West Bank, I've got to say I'm against a Palestinian state with the current Palestinian mentality. Jihad is not the way to peace; Israel can't afford another October 7th attack from the West Bank. Radical terrorism is not the way; it will only increase the suffering of both sides. Most Israelis don't want land, we just want to have a safe and quiet life for the Jewish people.
🤮
Appreciate you speaking up. However, as you know, settlements have been going on for decades. That’s the main reason, as an American, I do not support Israel in its current form. It is blatant aggression and erodes any hope of a peaceful solution.
What is you opinion on the current genocide happening in Gaza ? Is that teh way to have peace ? Would you consider that as any other thing than terrorism ? Have you seen any of the motives behind the October attack beyond what is said by national/western media ? Were you aware of the slow genocide that has been occuring even before the attacks, and how Netneyahu's government has been reducing all sorts of ressources going into Gaza ?
What if the Palestinian state is unable to build an army or host military bases from foreign countries?
What of the Netanyahou government do you oppose? Do you oppose settlements in Gaza ? Do you oppose the further displacement of Palestinians? Do you oppose the killing of 15,000 children in 6 months? Do you support a Palestinian state?
If no to any of these questions, it seems you line up pretty well with Netanyahou and his government. I'd like to be proven otherwise. I don't want to think that all Israelis support and like Netanyahou, but poll After poll consistently demonstrated that most Israelis support most Netanyahou policies, even if they don't support the man himself.
Because of Netanyahu's grandiose and violent plans. The US is no less of a bad actor. 2022 the US knew what IDF was, but since it is a reflection of the lack of values within those in power in the US... all good, fits our self-serving manipulative motives of power and profit.
Us israel so bad , other guys so good .
Maybe look at the history of the other guys?
Like assad , casualties we see in gaza are lower then the first day when assad targeted his civillians .
Sins 2004 90% of asyran population is gone.
Syria is named after them , lived there for over 1000 od years , no free syrie?(he is ally of palestine)
Hezbolla , holds lebanon hostage .
Only 15 out of 125 seats in parlement but holds the country hostage with an army 2 times the size of the nations army .
Lebanon used to have a 60% christian majority , now it's maybd 30% .
Maybe hezbolla should stop ocupying lebanon ?
Instead of pointing fingers .
@@roeci6
Assad who get support from the west and Israel?
And the Hezbollah isn't a government
@@karimabidi8312 israel fights against asad just like us sponsers groupins against asad ...
Russia and iran back assad , how badly can you be informed .
About hezbolla not being the goverment , that's my point .
They only have 15 seats but practically rule the country (well act in a way that makes it so thag others can't rule ) and behave in ways that bring violence to lebanon .
@@roeci6
I wanted to write "got", not get. Israel supported Assad and his father, they also supported apartheid in south africa and the north African dictators
@@roeci6 Yes mostly true, both of those countries and Israel and the US. Apply the logic to ALL not just some. It is universal, but manipulative governments and individuals don't want you to believe that of them. They say they are different but are the same. Both parties can be just as bad, calling out those parties is not indicative of supporting another party to do the same... that is the manipulation.
The war in one of the most war torn areas in the world is seeing more war? I’m shocked, shocked!
Well not that shocked.
Well it's shocking considering one side justifies everything by saying hamas and that side doesn't have hamas .
Your tax money at work
I was against the illegal settlements in the West Bank. After looking into it, i still don't fully agree, still think it's illegal, but i finally understand the deep religious meaning the land has for the settlers. Muslims are often accommodated for their religion worldwide, not sure why Jews shouldn't receive the same....there are 1.8 Billion Muslims worldwide with multiple countries that share the same language, religion, and ethnic customs....there are 19 million Jewish people worldwide with one claim to a homeland.
TLDR : when you say "112 children were killed" how about telling how many of them engaged with live fire with soldiers prior to that? most of that number is affiliated to armed terrorists organization but you wouldn't want to show that now would you? you lie by this omission
Why lie?
Source for your claim?
Isreal's other... OCCUPATION 🤦🏻♂️😂
They’ve decided not to sanction them ..
There is no parallel conflict. The situation in Gaza and the West Bank have been linked from the very beginning.
No sanctions will be imposed. Trust me!
It's not a war, it's Apartheid.
It doesnt matter, "do you condemn hamas?"
But do you?
I condemn Issac Newton
Cowards 5:48
Children are very scary, they can shoot the football at them by accident, are you antisemitic?
Meanwhile most of the WCs was done by their Air Force. 👀
A ethnostate committing systematic ethnic cleansing to achieve lebensraum, who does that remind you of?
In Germany you can get in prison when you say the truth like that...
The zionists are much more effective than "them". If "they" got the USA to give them unlimited political, financial and millitary support during ww2 the allies wouldve been finished.
@@karimabidi8312 If the shoe fits...
A common approach in the Middle East?
Without more hints, I can't tell if you're talking about Israel or Palestine...
Yet, we are sending military air to Israel...
It's Judea and Samari... Not the west bank.
I found an ancient map mentions Judea and samaria...
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartography_of_Palestine
West Bank
@@Ahmed-oq3ug Can't change history just because it is convenient to you..
I'm happy to see one sane comment here.
Population transfer (excluding a peaceful minority) and full annexation NOW!
@@hishamalaker491 Never heard of such a place...
Israel should have just annexed the WB.
There's no Palestinian state, it was never declared apart of one because the Palestinians never declared a state in 1948 and opted to try for genocide instead going for independence rather than accepting the partition.
Jordan annexed it in the 1950s, they didn't give it to the Palestinians. Israel took it in the Six Day War and should have incorporated it properly. It's too strategically valuable to give away to the Anti-Semitic PA (They have a Martys fund and their leader has a PHD in holocaust denial).
Any attempt of independence for Palestinian independence with the PLO/PA has been denied every time with the Palestinians getting up to 98% of what they want in the latest attempt at the start of the 2000s.
But they go on about wanting to kill all the Jews and kicking them back to the sea (hence River to the Sea, (Israel will be free).
Settlements are necessary for Israeli Territorial security. End of.
They just need to stop imposing a military government in the region and move to an actual civilian one.
Edit: Anyone saying that Jews are European colonialists barely understands that Jews are actually from the Levant and have lived in Israel for thousands of years. And most Jews in Israel aren't Ashkenazi (Which are still genetically Semitic, not Khazars or the like), they're Mizarhim Jews that left Arab countries upon being kicked out in the late 1940s/early fifties
Such a bs. Palestine has a more than 2000 years old history, Israel doesn't even have 80 years history😂😂😂
You are alien to the land called Palestine. You are European colonist.
@@karimabidi8312
The previous comment got deleted when I was trying to edit it.
Syria Palestina was the name given to the province of Judea after the third Jewish revolt against Rome in order to crush the presence of the Jews as much as possible after such a devastating conflict for the region and the problems the Jews caused for Rome.
The Region thereafter was always considered part of Syria/whatever Damascus province existed in the time period of control (Such as under the Ayyubids or Ottomans).
But Jews always persisted there and maintained their culture, whereas a Palestinian national consciousness only begins to grow in the 1930s in response to the various British commissions about what to do with the mandate. Before that and still even then, it was mostly considered apart of the wider Arab Pan-Nationalism movement by the Arabs themselves (Al-Husseini literally says this and the Egyptians used the PLO for that wider aim until the Camp David Accords that made peace between Israel and Egypt).
Both a Israeli state and a Palestinian state movements have existed for about 90 years, but the Jewish identity which Israel is there for (as the only Jewish state in the world) is ancient. And the Jews always pray towards Jerusalem and pray to be in Israel when they engage in prayers.
Isreal will never do that becagse they dont want Palestinians becominubg the majority in elections. Uf they annex ut they gave to guve them voting rights.
@@karimabidi8312 there is no evidence a place called palestine ever existed
Us and Israel wants you to believe this fake rivelry. While also passing 200 bajillion dollars to fund the setteler project. Nice😀
Weird timing to punish a division for something that happened last year, and the men responsible have already been dismissed.
It's a show to divert criticism.
This vid is highly 1sided and dose not say the complete story.
There is always 2 sides to the story.
Nazis and jews were 2 sides too.
But one side had brutal arsenal with radical people the other were stripped of every right and have only stones from their recently demolished homes.
Why are Gene tests Iligal in Israel ? what were the Gene test results of the Palestinians living in Gaza ? Is Jew a religion or a nationality/etnicity ? If it is a nationality and an etnicity ? if it is an Etnicity or nationality is a Jew still a Jew wenn he changes religion ?
An Israeli here, It is legal. (Why people think it isn't?)
Fun fact you even have to do a DNA test to prove that you are Jewish before you are doing an Alyiah to prove that you are a jew as you are claiming to be.
And yeah, jews can change their religon and still be Jewish ethnically.
Jewish is not our nationality but we call ourselves Israelis, many Israelis are Muslim, Christian Druz and many of them serves the IDF, many of them are patriotic and many of them love being Israeli.
(The only difference is that arabs don't have to serve in the army but many of them volunteer to)
Is obtaining a DNA test prohibited in Israel? If so, what are the reasons behind this legal restriction? Yes, it is indeed illegal to get a DNA test in Israel without a court order or a doctor's prescription [3]. This restriction is imposed by the Israeli government under the Genetic Information Law.
@@PhilipLaSnail One correction: law of return stipulates at least claiming not being adherent of some other religion. Which is quite original and by modern standards somewhat discriminatory.
@@tarik1163 "The government uses these measures to protect the public so that insurance companies, private parties, et cetera won't misuse the private information for personal gain, as well as the national implications these tests could hold or affect with Israel being a government recognized Jewish-state."
-The Jerusalem post.
Huh, apparently it is illegal.
uhm, thank you for informing me this.
But everything else I said is still true.
@@useodyseeorbitchute9450 Yeah, Israel is still devided on this issue of if to cancel this law or not.
But remember Israel is an ethnic-state.
We've built our homeland to protect world wide jews, not other minorities.
But you can definitely apply for citizenship if you are an arab or bedouin or druz.
It is not against arabs, it is pro jews.
*the west bank was captured in 1967 (but from Jordan)..... not from the palestinians.
This is NOT a war. It wasn’t called the German - Jewish war either…
the difference is the jews in poland weren't firing rockets into berlin......so that wasn't a war. this is
@@007kingifrit neither do the people in the west bank, so genozide it is
@@007kingifrit The Jews revolted when they were locked up in Ghettos. Or was a violent uprising in self defense for liberty unjustified?
@@007kingifrit read Warsaw uprising.
You don't colonise land then complain about natives
@@laithmughrabi8990 the warsaw uprising was AFTER the germans were holding them in ghettos. gaza was a self governing place that STILL started firing rockets into israel regularly.
your example would only be valid if the rockets were firing from poland in 1938.....
The title cannot be more missleading.
The "West Bank" was captured from Jordan, but they ceded all claims to that territory, so whom is it "occupied" from? "Palestinians" have never been in control of that territory, and just like Catalonia, their independence should be governed by negotiations, not by outside claims. I would have been glad, if Jordan accepted the territory at piece talks, just as Egipt with Gaza. But nobody hates the Palestinians more than people of surrounding Arab nations. Look at all the "rights" they have in their countries of residence. Even in Jordan, where they are population majority.
Good goy, we might not bleed your child now
This is a lot of cope: UN dictates that the West Bank is occupied and settlements are illegal.
‘nobody hates Palestinians more than arab neighbours’ yeah im sure an EGYPTIAN ‘hates’ a Palestinian more than an israeli . Totally 😂 -
And they lack rights because they have refugee status and ate a politically unstable population due to that: pro israelis are more delusional than pro Palestinians because you assume everyone will simply agree with you when you spew stupid shit
The Western allies were offered to accept the jews well its too bad that even in these western countries they didnt accept the Jews, it appears no one likes them, gotta do what I gotta do.
-Austrian painter
Do you see the irony? No one wanted jews either and even when they were accepted people hated them and when the west refused to host the Jews hitler killed them so by your logic everyone of us Palestinians deserve to be killed well if you were to kill us might as well put up a fight, why die in vain? While you kill us and call us terrorists many Palestinians would die knowing at least they resisted up until their inevitable death or expulsion. The Jews do no want to live with us, the ISraeli-arabs are fooled to believe that their state loves them the momment they kick out or kill all gazans they will go for the west bank then for Israeli arabs and the land will be completely cleansed as most US media would excuse it. Austrian never had his own ''AIPAC'' in the US, but even then comparing him to them is not a good thing since he had some degree of honour. I respect the crusaders as enemies because they were honourable, honest and to some extent trustworthy while Israelis while less brutal arent.
I don't know where did you get the claim of arabs hating palestinians, but i it reminds me of people who got kicked out by 100 countries.
Brilliant to see that TLDR stands against debate and shadow deleted comments i made on another account.
I'm disgusted.
That's probably youtube's algorithm automatically deleting comments that violates its guidelines. Try to word your comments appropriately.
context please
Be careful with key words as yt eliminates all post with key words which may imply that you spread heresy...
I love the title, because he has absolutely no clue 😂
I believe in a one state solution in which Israel would annex the West Bank and Gaza and Palestinian people have to assimilate into the Israeli government
How about a one state solution with no religious extremism. A secular state with the equality of all citizens just like in Israel’s self claimed allies?
There was no israel to begin with.
@@cianmcguire5647You do realise that most palestinaens do not want to be a part of israel.
@@Justanormalcat7 Yes, because Israel has no intention of being a secular and democratic state with the equality of all citizens. Would you choose to live in Jim Crow America? My point was that Israel acts and looks nothing like it’s claimed allies in the West, because it is a religious extremist state.
@@Justanormalcat7 that is why in a one state solution you don’t call it Israel or Palestine
I hate how my country (US) supports Israel blindly while the majority of voters want otherwise
Where is the statistic on number of Palestinian attacks on the Israeli settlers? I would hope for parity of information between your statistics. You also don't mention where these statistics are being pulled from and the possible biases in reporting.
If there was such a thing, you will be seeing it on every TV channel with title "beheaded babies and raped women" with an "honest" reporting without evidence.
everybody says occupied west bank, but does anyone know why it was occupied?
Tell me.
@@laithmughrabi8990 I want to know too
the same reason Putin occupied parts of Ukraine
Religion of peace 🤫
Palestinians are way more peaceful than the oppressors
Yeah clearly Judaism is more peaceful…
@@karimabidi8312 I thought they were even less bothering on selecting military targets, just have worse weapons.
@@bababababababa6124 only Christianity is semi decent of the abrahim faith.im atheist btw
Definitely more peaceful have you seen their military Definitely wouldn't hurt a fly@@bababababababa6124
That what happened when you have a group that act above the. Laws
Most of the Westbank should be left for the Palestinians. Israel should abandon all settlements not close to Israeli borders and hand them over to Palestinians which have lost their land, houses and orchards to (illegal) Jewish settlers. The settlements close to the Israeli borders will be subject to an independent international council (so no UN) if they can stay under Israeli law and attached to Israel or have to be handed over to the Palestinians. And Israeli settlers should not be allowed to demolish the settlements and leave them in ruins, like they did when they left Gaza. If they do that, they should pay compensation to the Palestinians who lost their property on the Westbank to settlers.
Settlers build homes and settlements, not taking them from palestinians.
When Israel left Gaza - they didn't destroy anything. Quite the opposite they left Gaza with all what they built. It was the palestinians to destroy all of what Israel builded.
@@y.l7455 you are lying. They did destroy things when they were forced to get out of gaza in 2005.
Are you still running with that uber racist "arabs like to destroy and israel likes to build" narrative? How does that work in gaza right now? Who's flattening it entirely?
The West Bank was occupied from Jordan, and although Israel offered Jordan the West Bank back, they refused. So it's not really
Its not even the first time they offered it...
That's the thing the West doesn't understand.
Nobody wants the Palestinians to be their problem. Whoever have given a helping hand has only been stung like a snake
Jordan, Egypt, Kuwait, Israel the list is long
@@caniblmolstr452 Then let them be a independent state? Why moan about babysitting someone who doesn't want you there in the first place.
If India offered the United States half of its land, the US would refuse
@@lokensicarius9347 last time they were made independent state they started a war...
Thank you for this information.
Because U.S. aid to Ukraine is finally being approved, could you please update us on what is next for Ukraine?
FREE PALESTINE🍉🍉
FJB
Judea & Samaria are legitimate and legal Israeli land, and the Israeli communities built in them are legitimate as well.
and they're blaming the Palestinians for being violence if you're a settler who got stabbed by the Palestinians remember its your fault for not staying in brooklyn 🤷♂️
It's funny that you don't see the irony in that you deny that Palestinians are violent and right after you say you have no problem with Palestinians stabbing Israelis.
@@zivcalko I Don't have problem with people defending their land correct
@@zivcalko and why the jews became violent at warsaw uprising? I mean the nazis gave them Lebensraum with food, water and medicine, yet they call for the destruction of the 3rd reich, what a genocidal maniacs were they!
Lol 'war'
This channel is biased towards the zios. They repeat the same lies.
just because one side is inferior doesn't make it not a war
@@007kingifrit not if you say it like that no. But the degree of inferiority definitly plays a role. You wouldn't call an ufc world champion beating the shit out of a 10 year old girl a fight, would you? The reality is that palestinians get no funding while Israel receives billion upon billions. Gazans cannot feed themselves. The situation is worse than the example above. It's like dropping 2 nuclear bombs on children. Oh wait.. that is exactly what is happening! Maybe you didnt know that, but Isreal dropped bombs equal to 2 nuclear bombs on the gaza strip.. in 6 months and more babies have been killed in these 6 months in gaza than in all the wars over the past 4 years combined. Still want to call it a war?
@@007kingifrit if you think the degree of inferiority doesn't play a role, youre a fool. A 'fight' between an ufc fighter and a child also doesn't get called a fight right? The power desperity between these groups is even larger than the example above. Instead of sending an ufc fighter, they send bombs. The amount of bombs they fired equals the power of 2 n*clear bombs. More kids and babies have been k*lled in 6 months than in all wars of the last 5 years... combined! The mean age is 18!
@@007kingifrithuman rights violations is not a war my guy
Dude please stop wearing the Chris Chan shirt
Poor muslim arabs, a nation of doctors and engineers won't allow them to jihad in peace.
Step1) colonise arabs and muslims
Step2) complain about arabs and Muslims.
"Conflict"
I would also like to know how many attacks of Palestinians against Israelis there were and how many of the killed Palestinians were during the settler attacks and how many during them attacking Israeli soldiers. Reporting without these facts smells heavily of pushing a specific narrative.
Not even comparable..
Open btselem, it will give you good statistics.
I will never understand why the US is so serious about supporting Israel. What do they even gain from doing all this?
its ridiculous how they kept whining about Terrorism when they themselves terrorize Palestinians on a daily basis, and this is in West Bank where Palestinians don't resist and there's no Hamas, it's almost like Hamas is not their problem, Palestinian people are
Literally just the other day 2 teenage boys were arrested in the West bank because they tried to stab some people.
Literally Bassem Youssef propaganda, Hamas operatives are killed and arrested frequently in the West Bank, they’re trying to bring down the Palestinian Authority
@@owenfautley yet statics and data shows most of the casualties are overwhelmingly Palestinians
@@owenfautley believe me, if it was real they will be gunned down at the moment.
Of course, we COULD have peace in the Middle East tomorrow if the neighboring Arab countries just agreed to accept Palestinian refugees. There are 4.5 million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip combined, and there are 20 million foreign-born residents between Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates alone, but next to none are Palestinian. Just saying...
Or one could just give J some strip of desert in the US...
Why Palestinians should leave their land?
@@Ahmed-oq3ug To have peace in the Middle East. (Did you read what I wrote?)
Gaza was not under Israel military control prior to oct 7. Israel left the strip unilateral.
I used to occupy your house, but I left it and set up cameras and an electrified fence around your house, you are not allowed to leave your house or enter it, nothing is allowed to leave or enter without my permission, even your utilities and services like water, food, and electricity are under my control.
See? Im not occupying you, I promise!!!
@@bonafidemonafide7810 bro excellent explanation
@@bonafidemonafide7810also your other neighbour also doesn't like you and has put up boundaries.
Due to your past misconduct we both have decided that you can't be trusted. All our friends and some of your cousins also agree coz frankly we all agree there is something wrong wit your head
In fact they are allowed to leave it and work in Israel. Hamas exploited this of course.@@bonafidemonafide7810 . When it comes to the fence and all other things: Hamas says on their charta to murder all jews. So it is just absurd to complain about security measures and control of all comodities to this terrorist led shithole.
To add to the first guys reply:
The sea in Gaza belongs to i$ rae li territory. No harbors allowed. No airports allowed. The border crossing between Gaza and Egypt which i$ r ael should have no business in, is also heavily influenced by them.
No hamas there btw...
There is...
@@y.l7455 prove it.
@@y.l7455 no, prove it.
@@lordmiraak8991
Why do you mean by prove it? hamas and the islamic jihad themselves don't hide it.
The battle in Jenin last summer come to mind first, that was fight between the IDF and the islamic jihad.
West bank is israel.
Judea Samaria is israel.
💙🇮🇱💙
Ow the theatre, it's happening, btw stand with Papa Abraham