Curado DC VS Tatula ELITE LONG CAST frog BATTLE... SHOCK WINNER???
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 พ.ย. 2021
- I put the Shimano Curado DC and the Daiwa Tatula Elite Long Cast through their long awaited rematch! This time with a frog and braid!
DAIWA, SHIMANO, ABU GARCIA, LEWS, KASTKING, QUANTUM, 13 FISHING, CURADO, CITICA, CASITAS, CAENAN, CHRONARCH, METANIUM, ALDEBARAN, ANTARES, CALAIS, STELLA, CONQUEST, SUSTAIN, STRADIC, EXSENCE, STEEZ, ZILLION, TATULA, FUEGO, ALPHAS, REVO, CONCEPT Z, MGX, LUCKY CRAFT, MEGABASS, EVERGREEN, JACKALL, DEPS, IMA, G LOOMIS, MAJOR CRAFT, MGL, NRX, CRUCIAL, SV, PISCIFUN, BLACK MAX, BASS RISE, RYOGA, BANTAM, ADRENA, GLORIOUS, ULTIMA, EXIST, BALLISTIC, FREAMS, TRUMP, SCORPION, XF 50, BAIT FINESSE, HAIBO, STEED, EXIST, ICAST, SLX, TRANX, POISON, SENSILITE, ZEPHYR, GOOGAN, OKUMA, HAKAI, CAIUS - กีฬา
I’m both a shimano and daiwa fan. I must say, you are too much of a shimano fan for me to take your advice. Every video and often in the comments you seem to talk bad about “daiwa fanboys.” Makes you seem a bit bais toward shimano. Shimanos may actually be better better but your advice means nothing to me
I do like his videos, they are informative but his tests never convinced me buy one reel over the other. I do own both brands, including 13 fishing and abu, so i buy what i like and not to mention that in actual fishing i barely see advantages as im boat fisherman. Btw its hilarious and kinda disturbing the way he acts when arguing with so called daiwa fans.
@@aurelianobuendia5360 because he is noob and distance maniac 😂
Would rather a daiwa for consistency over what… an extra 5-6ft from a Shimano? 😂
@@JoeyBasstard baitcaster is all abt accuracy and easy of use. If he so addicted to distance i will suggest to use spinning reel instead.
His videos are about all there is in this format to watch, but yeah I don’t pay much attention to the nonsense comments lol
I sold a Curado DC to buy 2 Tatulas. Don't regret it one bit. Amazing reels. I am now the happy owner of a Shimano Scorpion DC as well as several Tatulas so I have no strong preference, but I feel it's worth noting the overrun at 3:15, 3:50 and 4:07. You had significant overrun on the Curado to get near the same distance and neglected to mention it. You also didn't show the "Extreme distance" setting, only the Scorpion. I suspect that is because it had significantly worse overrun/backlashing with the brakes near off. Not an unbiased review. So to say "Easily Beat" is not a fair or unbiased assessment either. I enjoy your content, but don't provoke fanboys if you're going to be one as well.
As always….a Shimano commercial. Good to see that there are some other guys recognizing it. As always….it‘s the money to be made, that counts with his comparisons.
@@arnemueller2112 I don't think it has anything to do with all that. He just likes what he likes. But to call it an unbiased or fair comparison is a bit of a stretch.
You need to watch again. Those were not "overruns" they were backlashes where I didnt stop the spool after the frog already hit the ground. And yes I showed the "Extreme distance" casts because if you paid attention to where I show the the cast measurements at the end of each cast,(which is exactly why I do it) they were longer and there was zero overrun. This was not a "review" it was a cast battle. And yes, the Tatula Elite was EASILY beaten.. AGAIN. I suggest you come with facts next time you "attempt" to challenge my results and try to look smart on the internet because Ill shred you every time kid.
@@arnemueller2112 as always, fanboys can only cry but cant prove my results wrong :)
@@THEREELTEST You're insistent I'm a fan boy, it's your fall back defense. But it's inaccurate.
Have the Shimano Fanboys ever tried a Daiwa tatula Elite? I will say Shimano curado is a tried-and-true reel 100%. But I will also say that Daiwa tatula Elite is one awesome overall reel. Neither one of them can you say anything real bad about. At this point in technology you're literally just arguing about the brand name and not the actual equipment any longer
Most shimano fanboys always arguing about that the daiwa didnt show anything new... same tws, same magnetic break in all model, same frame...so they are just renaming a tatula with lighter spool or with the sv system and other "features". And thats why Daiwa is blamed by them. Kinda right but in my opinion a tatula is better looking and more comfortable...(yep im daiwa fan) but It would be good if they really release a new reel and not just the ordinary tatula...
In my tests the Tatula elite outcasted the Curado dc with ease and I was a massive shimano fanboy until that happened
Daiwa fanboys are such sensitive snowflakes that they think just because their favorite reel lost a cast battle equates to me calling them junk. Ive never once called the Elite junk
@@thechamplainfisher7854 If thats the case, show us on video
Lol I’ve been arguing with a guy because he said his 2020 metanium doesn’t cast as far as the tatula elite. When I literally spool my friends metanium with ease and he has 15 pound invis x on it
I have the Tatula Elite P/F in an 8 ratio paired with a 7'3" Fast, mag-heavy Dobyns Fury rod. Such a good frogging or heavy cover combo. For anybody wondering the Tatula Elite P/F isn't JUST for pitching and flipping. It's on-par with all my other reels (DC reels included) even with the 65lb Berkley x5 braid I have on it. I definitely wanna try the long cast or the SV 103. Leaning towards the SV just because I've yet to own an SV reel. The Curado 150 MGL is looking fire too though.
Good to know about the P/F model that its not just a 1 trick pony. As far as SV reels? Just take your regular Tatula, then slow the spool down and cut off a few feet of casting distance. I think SV reels are great to learn baitcasters on, but not a brake system to be putting on expensive reels.
@@THEREELTEST Yeah I almost got the long cast elite but I don’t need all that line for frogging plus the long handle helps with the 8 ratio speed. But still it has no problem. I’ve use it for just about everything in my tackle bag. Not quite on par with my scorpion but I’d have no issues putting it on a medium or medium heavy rod for all around use👍🏻
@@blackbirdrc8348 You should do a video review, Ive seen zero reviews on the P/F model, and I know that alot of people assume because its brakes were designed for short distance casts, that it cant be used for long cast techniques
@@THEREELTEST Hmm 🤔 Never gave it much thought. If I can find my head mount for my iPhone maybe I’ll take it out, show how I have my spool tension set (just eliminating side to side play) and make some casts with different baits.
Agreed. The producer is obviously a Shimano fanboy and does not disclose if he actually uses "fair" brake settings in his tests. You can easily have tension turned up just a hair on one lure that makes it not cast as far and definitely not be telling us, all the while optimizing brake settings on his "preferred" lures and still not disclose it. His obvious preference for Shimano is very striking and his mental capacity as indicated by his speech patterns etc.. indivates that he would be susceptible to bias in his actual testing to support his own brand bias.
The gears in the Daiwa are just spectacular! You can just fight the Big Fish over & over! I have tangled with the Big Tarpons, Jack Crevalle, Common Snook, & Peacock Bass with my Tatula's.
Pls suggest me... Daiwa or shimano? Where very strong reel fight big fish?
Flush bearing and polishing I can emptied out any abu and shimano and lews on most lures
Back the spool tension off a little in the Elite. I found the factory setting a little too snug. It made quite a difference. It seems you've tweeked the DC to it's max already.
I like and own both reels, I lean a little more toward the Elite due to the price though.
If you use a 3/4 frog, you can BOMB with the elite. I can cast stupid far with it on setting 1 and 8x braid. You do have to make sure that the line isn't dug into reel at all or you'll spend some time with backlash haha.
That’s what I’m talking about. Heavy line, big rods and heavy lure.
hi, have you seen the new 135 g TSURINOYA DarkWolf KF50S reel with a 6.1 g spool?
Hi can you make a contest between Aldebaran BFS XG and GekkaBijin AIR TW 8.5 PE SPECIAL.
How does the new Curado 150 MGL stack up against the Scorpion MGL? Love my Scorpion MGL so if its just as good or better I'm gonna pull the trigger on the new Curado. Out of all my reels my Scorpion is by far my favorite and best casting. Even over my Curado DC and my gen4 Abu Revo Premier.
That Scorpion MGL is one bad mother... If it wasnt so dang heavy! unsure about how it casts compared to the 150 MGL yet.
Both are the best reel that i have hands down.
both are excellent reels
You try the new curado mgl 150 vs scorpion? Great video
Would like to see the new curado 150mgl versus the Scorpion 150mgl
That might be a possibility but im so behind on videos its not funny
I’ve found that you can cast shimano reels on lower break settings than the Daiwa reels and not have as many issues.
SHIMANO CURADO MGL K 70 or Aby Garcia ROXANI BF8 What's your choice?
A "The Reel Test" review with a shimano winning - suprise...
Ask an other tester/user and it's other way round.
What a surprise... a Daiwa "online marketing" shill shows up lol
@@THEREELTEST You did a little creative "marketing" yourself there with not mentioning the DC's overrun on break setting 2 and not showing brake setting 1 on camera. I'm happy to say I own both and while I tend to lean towards Daiwa for the feel in my hands and twing, I have no strong preference. But don't perpetuate not to if you do.
@@THEREELTEST so everybody who doesn't hate on Daiwa is either a fanboy or is paid by Daiwa? Good that the world works that easy...🤦🏼♂️
Sorry bro, I like your videos and I appreciate the afford but the only fanboy sitting on the table isn't me - I'm just sayin'...
What a surprise, indeed!
@@TimHaunFishing Ive already proved you wrong in your original comment
I have feelings, that you are working for shimano, Rembrandt 🤣😂
wanna be but unfortunately shimano doesnt want him to lol
I absolutely love the control and light weight of my elites. Also they fit in my hand better
I've never had a Daiwa last more than 8 years. I have 2 Shimano Curados I bought in 1996 that I still use constantly. So there's that.
Is rhis model the shimano curado dc 200
Damm... I miss that orange meter. :D
Bro, please also compare the weight, smoothness, break. Those features are as important as long casting.
You should have slid in the new Okuma Hakai in this battle
dont worry, its going to have its "days" on the casting field :)
Can u review the 13 fishing sport a pls
what braid do u use?
Hercules braid from Ebay
They are neck to neck, but I prefer tatula bc it’s way lighter
for that reason I would pick it for walking topwater or jerkbaits over either the Scorpion or Curado
I'm confused how you lost frog if it broke off while casting on land
casting too hard
@@THEREELTEST I get how lures come off; I was confused as to how they lost a lure while casting on land
I think casting technique comes into play to some degree.. My old Zillion JDream bombs frogs significantly farther than my tatula or scorpion dc.
If Im not mistaken your Jdream has a much lighter spool than either?
@@THEREELTEST It's around 11g iirc.
Such a great comparison!
Tatula sv tw or tatula elite best for longcast
I have to say John1:1 is one of my favorites
John was an awesome author. Very poetic.
Traded my DC for a Tatula 100sx with a Tatula rod.
What about the 70 and the 150? Can they beat the Scorpion?
hard to say, the scorpion has a bigger spool. I am going to be doing a 150MGL vs 70MGL video soon
@@THEREELTEST great! Looking forward to it
You need to check your recording level on your mic.
Love the Bible verses!
Prefiro a tatula elite , tem construção melhor e o sistema de freio não dá problema .
Sim, eu digo o mesmo, tenho a Elite pitch and flip e a Curado DC, a Elite tem construção visivelmente mais robusta e bem construída, fora que na Amazônia não sei se a Curado vai voltar inteira.
Lots of arguing in this comment thread. People take their reels seriously. I own both. Like both.
Very good info n tutorials.nice bro.done subscribe.
Yo I love your content but most of all the scriptures at the beginning keep up all the good content. Let's go Buckeyes. God bless you
I just bought a Scorpion MGL for 140 ish on Ebay. Can't wait to get it and not use it until next year 🤣
I get more distance out of my curado DC then my tatula elite
With braid, its an entirely different animal!
Agreed. Settings mean everything. I've gotten over 175 feet with my curado. All about technique. 1 maybe 2 backlash with my curado.
Here’s my thoughts. I personally would not use either of these reels for throwing frogs. The criteria a reel must meet for me to consider frogging with it is:
1. It must have an aluminum frame and gear side plate
2. It must have a dual bearing supported pinion
3. It must have brass gears
This means the list of reels I would use for frogs includes, but is not limited to, the Bantam MGL, Steez A Morethan PE, USDM Zillion SV TW G, 22 Zillion TW HD G. I like a very solid reel when you’re throwing into the thickest of cover
why you guys need a ton of drag?
big braid ?
extra heavy rod ?
@@Noname-wx3ru because you’re throwing into the thickest of mats and need thick coarse like to pull the fish out of it
@@hunterbull7804 oh i see cause normally we in malaysia will go to 20lb maximum when it come to froggy cause here we catch snakehead but snakehead in here is small so we need tiny lure like 4cm frog to get perfect hookset and thats why we not use heavy setup like 40-50 lb braid cause we need to cast tiny lure... sometimes we go on ultralight setup like 6lb braid 1-6lb rod and 1000 reel for frogging 😃
I bought both reels at the same time. I ended up buying 4 more Elites after comparing them mainly due to the DC's weight, and I use alot of heavy FC which to me the Elite excels at. The DC on the right rod however can be magical. I do have to agree with Hunter, I would rather use something more robust for frogging the heavy salad.
Excalty I'm all about light action and bfs. best fight period Haven't touched a spinning setup over 10+ years. But I can understand pros who fishing for $ tho
This guy has some sort of unfair bias towards dawaii...you can easily hear it in his voice doesn't take an expert to know that this guy has a hatred for dawaii
Poor old Daiwa. They just keep coming up short in performance. But they do make some nice looking reels.
I hope you aren't using this video as a metric. It clearly was weighed in the favor of Shimano. See my above comment. I own both. The two best reel companies there are. I just wish this had been a fair comparison.
@@TimHaunFishing youve been easily debunked
They need to swallow their pride and come up with a centrifugal braking system. Even Shimano has better magnetic braking systems than Daiwa
@@THEREELTEST You patting yourself on the back does not equate to "debunking". I've notice your otherwise meticulous scientific theory takes a back seat when it comes to arguing in your own comment section. But to each their own. Your walk is your walk.
@@TimHaunFishing an argument would imply that you actually had a chance. I destroyed your meticulous criticisms easily but not surprisingly, you ignore that
Lets count how many butthurt fanboys show up LOL *UPDATE* Tatula Elite Long Cast lost a cast battle to a much cheaper reel, the Abu Garcia Revo SX on DEBO's Fishing channel! th-cam.com/video/E-crcNdVXNI/w-d-xo.html
From both sides, it's gonna be legendary.
Lol , Daiwa fans set up
I just come to these cast battles to see the Diawa fanboys cry 😂
I already know who wins......
watch the vid, the real winner isnt in the thumbnail lol