WATCH THIS before you buy diamond stones for tool/knife sharpening!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- How they are made, how to spot a good one, what you need to know about the junk.
Diamond stone I recommend►
Trend 300/1000 grit stone: amzn.to/2nBdaq5
Trend lapping fluid: amzn.to/2nknjF8
Trend Tool & Bit cleaner: amzn.to/2dZkJl3
Trend Kit/C (for router bits, forstner bits, etc.): amzn.to/2nhNLi7
Video about sharpening router bits: • How to sharpen your ow...
Video about sharpening forstner bits: • Fast & Easy Forstner B...
(We may benefit financially if you use the above affiliate links.)
HELP KEEP OUR VIDEOS FREE! Please support those who support us by visiting their websites and having a quick look around-
Trend: www.trend-uk.com/en/US/ - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Diamond stone I recommend►
Trend 300/1000 grit stone: amzn.to/2nBdaq5
Trend lapping fluid: amzn.to/2nknjF8
Trend Tool & Bit cleaner: amzn.to/2dZkJl3
Trend Kit/C (for router bits, forstner bits, etc.): amzn.to/2nhNLi7
Video about sharpening router bits: th-cam.com/video/o4AtrNXR5Iw/w-d-xo.html
Video about sharpening forstner bits: th-cam.com/video/rLoEulA4mM8/w-d-xo.html
(We may benefit financially if you use the above affiliate links.)
HELP KEEP OUR VIDEOS FREE! Please support those who support us by visiting their websites and having a quick look around-
Trend: www.trend-uk.com/en/US/
I just looked at the stone on Amazon. It has a lot of bad reviews. People are saying that it is not flat, has bubbles under the glued-on diamond sheet, sections of diamond sheet peeling off, etc.
@@LucidDreamer54321 And the vast majority of others (94%) are saying the opposite. That's how Amazon reviews work. Everyone that has an issue leaves a poor review, but only a small percentage of those with positive experiences leave one because most people have better things to do than write reviews on Amazon. It skews reality, but it is what it is... All I can tell you is my personal experience and let you make your own decision :)
I use specially prepared water as a sharpening stone lubricant including for Diamond Stones. I add HoneRite Gold anti-corrosion (makes the water rust-proof) additive, added to distilled water, resulting in a suitable sharpening lubricant that prevents rust on both the Diamond Stone and the tool being sharpened.
Is there any none Amazon stones you can recommend?
@@jasons.9389 www.acmetools.com/shop/tools/trend-u*dws-cp8-fc
No annoying loud music, incredibly thorough and comprehensive information. I love your channel!
What a pleasure to watch/listen to a knowledgeable professional, who has prepared an excellent script, and presents it so clearly - with NO distracting background music, no "hey Yo - whats up TH-cam". This is as good as teaching gets. Not just an advertisement to entice clicking of affiliate links - just good, solid, dependable information. Well done!
Good advice on stopping at 1k then stropping.
I go to 200k (Yes, really), but I essentially only do that as a ritual at this point - the process is relaxing to me. It's cool to see how sharp you can really get something, and the mirror edges are really nice as well. But, I'll be the first to confirm... I've taken a knife to that level of sharpness, cut up all the cardboard boxes for my weekly trash haul, and already been back to a point where even shaving is a struggle. It's cool, but it doesn't last.
Personally i love sharpening my knives, chilling out listening to music. It's relaxing 😁
This is the common sense channel. Quite simply the best I've seen so far. There's no superfluous rubbish- it's straight to the point. Excellent advice. You're well up on every subject you advise on.
I was brought up on oilstones, but am considering the diamond stone option. Thank you for your sharing your knowledge.
Greetings from France.
Atoma is the best and lasts the longest, tried all of them, at least for all kind of knives. For polish Ing i use higher grit japanese Water stones, suehiro, shapton and my favourite: naniwa chosera.
Depending on the usecase of the knife, i go up to 3k-8k and strop them a few times on the rough leather side up after that. If i want to get a toothy edge, i strop one side of the edge a few times over a 3k stone or a leather with a 4k diamond compound.
I fixed and regrinded a ton of knives on my 400 grit atoma, after wearing in, it doesnt seem to be as aggressive to the touch of my finger as new, as soon as i put a blade on it, it still cuts a lot faster than any other stone.
I like diamond plates only, if it has to be fast, i need to fix something deep, reprofiling or i need a very toothy edge, otherwise i prefer proper whetstones. The edge of a diamond sharpened tool isnt the same as sharpend on a whetstone.
I'm a hobbyist knife maker, I have set of DMT brand stones with the yellow plastic backing like you show. You call them cheap and sub par, (they cost around $75 per stone) but I've used them for a decade now. Sharpened many hundreds of knives using water... with no problems. 🤷♂️
But if/when they ever wear out, I might try a "Trend" brand. Looks like they cost around $20 more. Not sure I'd bother with fancy fluids though. That seems like a real pain, IMO.
I've had a good experience with my DMT "duosharp" plates as well... I keep thinking the fine/extra fine must be "done for" but I'll give it one last try.... and it just keeps on cutting. Really good experience with them so far.
DMT makes the more expensive type as well.
He is correct in describing " serviceable sharpness" I however am one of those who find joy in the art of creating an edge worthy of superlatives. Learning everything I can in the pursuit of the perfect edge... Necessary? Probably not. But there's nothing wrong with the pursuit of perfection.
I'm with you on this. I enjoy sharpening, but I don't love it. I DO love the satisfaction of getting a great edge, and then using it. I work a lot in white pine which I find requires steeper bevel angles, and faultless edges, as sharp as I can get them. So: "Serviceable sharpness" is relative to what you are doing.
If you are a sharpening nut, you need to take up shaving with a straight razor😂
I’ve always found peace in the search for the best edge.
I've watched three very different views on this: Stumpy, Paul Sellars, and Rob Cosman, and I somehow agree with them all. As a carpenter, I was quite content with a sort and hard Arkansas, which got my chisels sharp enough to shave with (but the ones I have are a bit small for a plane iron). A Trend diamond plate has been really good, and easy to use. But I did ultimately spring for a Shapton 16000 grit, as well. It's probably overkill for most jobs, but for the final finish with a smoothing plane, I think it's worth the expense and effort. So, 1000 for dimensioning, 16000 (and resharpen frequently ) for finish.
A similar thought process has me starting to think my Lie-Nielsen #4 1/2 might have been a reasonable expense, but maybe I don't need to go quite so deluxe for a #7...
This was one of the best, most concise explanations that I have yet to see. Thanks so much.
@@AJNoon LOL, only when you are a pedant.
This comment is the best I’ve yet to see! Lol read 📚
Thank you so much for making this video. I tried the cheap diamond stones and thought I just sucked at sharpening because of how difficult it was to get the chisels razor sharp on diamond stones. I saw this and bought ones which had the electro process described, now I'm a weirdo who enjoys sharpening and I'm gonna get near all the sharp objects!
Love this video. A comment, recent reviews of cheap double-sided diamond plates show that the coarse sides are contaminated with larger diamond particles, which make them coarse at the end of the day
Excellent advice without any time-wasting nonsense, Thank you Stumpy Nubs!
Thank you so much for this! I've been trying to make heads or tails of this sharpening "stone" jungle. This is perfect for me.
I used the Trend lubricant but found it no better than the rubbing alcohol I have used for years. And yes, lubricating makes a great difference.
Thanks James. I have been struggling with all the "expert" advice that is out there. This was clear and easy to understand. You have answered more than one of my questions on this topic. The UP thanks you, eh.
Awesome video! Thank you for bringing clarity to sharpening. This is the best lesson and sharpening I’ve seen in 30 years.
What an excellent, informative, well-presented video. Even concisely summarised at the end!
Well done and thank you.
Thanks again for your great explaination of using the diamond stone and undertanding the details.. I really enjoyed meeting you and talking to you at the TREND booth at the NOVI, MI WOODWORKING SHOW. As always, great information....
This is great. Answers all the questions I ever had about these stones. Thanks!
I have had 3 diamond stones (400, 800, 1200) similar to the yellow plastic one that was shown in the video for almost 20 years. I epoxied each of them to a flat smooth piece of 3/4" granite that were off-cuts from a kitchen renovation I did. I cut each piece of granite the size of the diamond plates (about 2 1/4" x 6") & then epoxied them to the top. The result is a very flat solid set of diamond sharpening stones that have lasted for a couple decades so far. I also applied grip tape, used on stair treads or skateboards, to the bottom of each stone so they stay in place while using them.
I have used them often over the years & still use them regularly for almost all my sharpening tasks (depending on the tool, axe, knife or chisel etc) & I have always used a solution of windex & water or simple green. I rinse them in hot water after each use, occasionally I'll use a brush as well (finger nail brush or vegetable brush) while rinsing & then let them air dry on their sides. I have never had a problem with them rusting or delaminating & they still cut just fine.
I have a set of ceramic stones made with man-made sapphires ..I bought them 33 years ago back in 1985 when I bought my registered Trapline ..Now I'm 64 and its time to hang up my snowshoes and sell the line ...
Then stones were in my log cabin when she burnt to the ground ..
They survived it just fine ..the intense heat didn't seem to bother them ..
And yes I've always used vim to clean them and wash them off ..no problem what so ever ...
How much do you want for them?
@@johnnycake020 my thoughts exactly lol
I want them!!!
Bidding war ensues!!
SO...the Trend products are not absolutely essential? LOL! I think he would not be happy with this...
Cheers for sharing your knowledge in such a straight forward and easy to get the gist of life lessons you have learned.
Thanks from an Australian Shed Dweller.
I will spend a whole day of blistfull zen I find sharpening very relaxing and stress relieving!
This just showed up on my home page. Great organization and presentation. Especially appreciated your recap at the end with key takeaway points.
Thanks, I have watched lots of sharpening videos and tried all types of sharpeners. Your video has reassured me that one stone can do it all. Marvellous!
Hi
Thank you for posting this video. Got my Trend from Amazon and today was my first chance to try diamond stone on some hand planes and I was very impressed with the results. The process of sharpening took less than all the things I tried in the past and I don't have to worry about need to flatining me stone etc.
So thank you again and will keep watching your videos.
Something more important to protecting your diamond stones than oil and water: Avoid high pressure on the stone. If you bear down too hard, say 20 pounds on something like a narrow chisel, you could get 1000 PSI at the point of contact, causing damage to the stone. Remember, when the contact area goes down, the PSI goes up!
Diamond stones are a man's best friend.
Beautifully done video, most comprehensive I've seen on the topic. Thank you!
I I love sharpening my kitchen knives! I find it rewarding and relaxing🤔
I am genuinely astounded at the quantity of idiotic and spiteful comments. Personally I really enjoy your videos mate, I always learn some useful tidbits and your style of presentation is concise, clear and light hearted. Keep up the awesome work Mr Nubs! PS, please do more videos where you discuss the construction and style of period furniture, they are fascinating and your passion for woodworking really shines in those videos.
Wuauuu! You have managed in a single video to clarify all doubts regarding the diamond stones. Thanks so much, your channel is really useful and full of knowledge.
Glad I came across this before I purchased my first plates. You probably saved me a lot of cash in the long run. Thanks so much.
Thanks heaps very interesting and I agree whole heartedly re "excessive" sharpness.
A lot of people whining about him calling some of us "lunatics" and so... relax, people. I think he is being sarcastic referring to himself, too.
No, I don’t think he was referring to himself at all. He said he believes people like that should be kept away from sharp objects, calls them lunatics, and refers to the practice of sharpening as mind numbing. 0:22
After viewing this video sometime ago, I purchased a Trend Diamond stone. I use it all the time and it is everything that you said about it. Thank you and best wishes.
Thanks for the explanation.
This explains some of the issues I have had with my diamond stones.
I'm a weirdo, love to sharpen my blades, I find it relaxing.
Same
Me too.
You can shave with my shovels!
I too admit to being a sharpening weirdo/geek but if it’s only as sharp as a scalpel, it’s just not sharp enough! And yes I did eat paste in kindergarten.
Brilliant video as usual! Thanks. Can't understand why some folks take exception at a light hearted presentation done so informatively
I used a coarse (Harbor Freight) diamond plate to level a stone, I've been using the stone for 60 years.
Thanks! I'm completely new to this because sharpening is actually pretty relaxing and helps me sort my thoughts.
I already used water on my diamond plates but they were cheaper ones so I'm fine for the next single double sided one I'll get.
Gonna get that Trend Fluid, wanna keep doing it and I intend to do it right
I sharpen knives for the ladies in my neighborhood. I'm very popular. It blows my mind how dull most people's knives are.
Is your mind all that gets blown?
I'm a lady who sharpens her own knives and hates using other people's dull knives! You are doing a great service to your neighborhood
@@timgreaves9906 he can't Answer right now his minds getting blown
Have to wonder why men are called men but for some reason, women need to be called ladies.
james cannon - because most of us are no longer gentile enough to be referred to as gentlemen.
I always enjoy your Vid's and this one is no exception. As a matter of fact it was rather timely so I'm off to spend my and with your help I will spend much less (in the long run) Mr. Nubbs I hope you have a grand day
Great clarity! Loved that your videos contain no long pauses and backtracks and ums , and ahhhh etc that so many videos contain today. Those types of videos are painful yo watch.Great job! Thanks!
I bought that same 300 grit and 1000 grit diamond steel and been using it for two years and you are absolutely right
I love to sharpen and have used most types of stones and brands over the past 50 years. I have been using the "cheap" yellow DMT product(s) shown in your video since the early 80's and have never had a problem with ANY of them!
Dex Peavy good to know. I wanted to get some stones and if they work they work
Dex Peavy ; Agreed. I don`t do that much sharpening. However I have been using the same DMT "stone" for the last 20 years. Has not changed at all, works the same as the day I bought it. Mine is still red.
That sounds really interesting, could you send a link to the company's website so I can look at this stone you use?
Same here. I bought mine as a set a while back. A base and two dbl sided mesh stones. They have served me well and no more trying to keep all my traditional stones the same flatness. I actually use one of diamond stones to flatten the only traditional stone I still use. Very happy with the set.
My zen is sharpening things. Mirror edge finish with a strop!
Great informative video.
Straight and to the point.
Thanks so much for sharing your knowledge.
Hey, I'm one of those that enjoy my Zen moment sharpening blunt blades, and the five cuts on my hand prove that sometimes I "Zen" out a little too much! But that workshop of yours with all those tools in the background. There is no such thing as too many blades.
I love my mind to be numbed. I love sharpening knives. My favorite is stropping, lol. 😀 So I started stropping while watching your video. A Mora this time
I have a very good EZE Lap diamond plate embedded on a wood base. I sharpen by hand and I hold the stone and knife in my hands when I sharpen. (It's how I learned) The wood base is helpful to keep me from slipping and scratching the blades. It started as a medium grit, but is now medium fine, but then again it is 16 years old. I use water on it as its a stainless metal. I use my diamond first and then finish with a hard Arkansas stone just to polish the edge up. Most of my cutting tools get a working edge or a butcher's edge. A polished edge so sharp you can shave your face with is too sharp for many applications, although I do polish the edges on my leather tools. I make knives for a profitable hobby and have done so for 25 years now. A diamond stone is a necessity for some of the high vanadium steels as they are very wear resistant. I made a knife from D2 tool steel and found sharpening it with a regular stone took way too long and then I found out about diamond stones.
I've sharpened thousands of tools and a friend asked me sharpen a new D2 knife he bought. Using traditionaldiamond
What a fantastic video, informative and to the point. Thank you.
Great video! Learned a lot! Thanks so much for putting in the time to make this.
I also cut gem stones and use numerous diamond laps. A well made lap should be fine with water based lubricants. If a lap rusts it was not plated very well. The nickel plating should be bonded to the steel plate affording protection from rust. Believe me, the volume of lubricant needed for cutting gems, you are not going to be buying tiny bottles of expensive honing fluid. A little liquid dish soap or Simple Green in water is fine. Paul Sellers has been using the same laps for years with nothing more than glass cleaner.
I do concur on not needing more than 1000 mesh. My finest mesh is 1200 for cutting gems. I go straight from that to a Lucite lap charged with aluminum oxide for mirror polishing on gem stones a lot harder than any steel. Charge your strop with white diamond (aluminum oxide ) compound or green compound (chromium oxide). These both come in hard blocks you can rub on your leather for charging.
David Johnston
Yes sir, you are correct. I've worked a lot in gem stones also and it really can be helpful in putting an edge on metal, even had a bit of a side business sharpening knives.
I also agree, but the Trend Diamond stones rust so easily it kind of is disturbing. I have the trend stone but will be switching to the same stones paul sellers uses due to not wanting to spend a few hundred dollars a year on lapping fluid.
You could sub regular car antifreeze for the overly expensive lapping fluid. It provides excellent lubrication and contains corrosion inhibitors. I've used a 50/50 mix in my diamond gem saws for years now. The metal in those saw blades will rust just from looking at them while thinking about water.
You must do a TON of sharpening to go through it that fast!
You've had a stone rust?
FYI, I'm one of those weirdos that love to sharpen their tools and find it a moment of zen. :)
Brian M. Same
Joe Smith yeah plus I feel its kinda nice knowing that your tools are like an extension of who you are and the more time and dedication you put towards them the better results you'll get. I don't know though, could be just me haha
gape Coca: I live by the adage: a sharp tool is a safe tool. Good steel + good sharpening setup = scary sharp blades. My setup uses 2 DMT diamond stones (XX coarse and X coarse) and 1000, 3000, 10K, and 13K grit ceramic stones (Sigma Power Select II). I finish with a leather strop with the green honing compound. That mirror finish makes me happy. I agree with the Samurai Carpenter: learn to free hand sharpen and save the money you would have spent on honing jigs on better equipment. My blades cut through red oak and leave a beautiful smooth finish.
Brian M. That's one hell of a setup you got there, I eventually want to have similar stones. And I bet they would leave a beautiful finish. Keep working hard! And stay safe my friend
The setup is worth it though. It leaves a mirror finish and a very, very sharp blade. If you use O1 or PMV-11's it creates an incredibly sharp edge. I don't recommend creating a micro bevel either since it changes the geometry of the cutting edge. I have zero problems planing red oak and cherry and it leaves a smooth finish.
Guess I'm one of those weirdos who enjoys sharpening. Great video, really helpful discussion about lubricants and why the price difference in diamond stones.
It's such an informative and interesting video that I watched all of it, when in fact I don't have any sharpening to do except my kitchen knives from time to time on an old fashioned two-grit sharpening stone.
Dear Stumpy, I am so sad to hear you are not experiencing the fantastic feeling of Zen tranquility that comes from becoming one with your sharpest edge!
you mean tremor inducing rubbing action
Thats my favorite part of cooking when I get to sharpen all of my cooking knifes!
A necessary evil, but evil nonetheless
go look up Kezuroukai, Planing Competition, if that's not zen, what is?
I use an ammonia free glass cleaner on my diamond plates and wet or dry sandpaper as recommended by Paul Sellers. I get it at Dollar General for $1.00 a bottle. Works great, doesn't cause rust and is cheap.
Same I'm not spending 30 dollars a bottle for that trend stuff
the video guy is using a WATER SOLUBLE blue lapping fluid - in other words, it's 95%+ WATER ....
LMAO
@@shakdidagalimal That's not what wate-soluble means, mate
@@spawniscariot9756 sure thing judas - it's probably over 99% water, you'll buy some though, because so, so dumb.
@@shakdidagalimal Salt is water-soluble, tears aren't ;)
Thanks James! Good info and well timed for my uses too.... I've been wondering about that.
I purchased three diamond sharpening plates and did not use any lubricant. I cleaned the plates after each use but, will buy the Trend oil product that you recommended. I purchased Atoma diamond plates from Japan and they work great. I also purchased arkansas stones, 3M polishing film and water stones because I want to compare each one.
I like sharpening things :( I find it relaxing
ReZ same here!!
I find myself sharpening my tools even when they are razor sharp, it is very satisfying and relaxing. I'm certainly one of the "weirdos" that find it enjoyable
Sounds like you could be spending time sharpening the tools of others in that time when yours are already sharp. I heard it's like 2X up to 8X more satisfying and enjoyable
Thank you for taking the time to make the video. I have definitely learned something.
Just ordered the stone you recommended. Can't wait to try it.
Question: which is better for dressing my grinding wheel, a dressing stone or those "T" shaped dressing tools with diamonds?
Great information, thanks for sharing! I think some are giving you a hard time about the lunatic joke because your delivery was flatter than those monocrystaline stones you are raving about!
Fantastic video with awesome information. Not many videos like this on the tube. Thank you!
Very Professional, informative video!! Thank You. Now I know what to buy!
Excellent video... Thanks James! My 2 cents... have had great luck with Windex... dries fast on its own and has very little thickness
Me to, I started with it and never found a reason to change. I contemplated trying Fantastic spray cleaner, bur I worry it could leave a deposit that might get gummy. I've read several times that if you add a couple drops of dish soap to water that works quite well.
I love keeping my tools sharp and in good condition. With diamond it's very quick. I've been using water for years with no problems. I rinse with the hottest water I can get out of my sink, dry with a paper towel and the heat drys any water I've missed. I also do my kitchen knives. I used to do my ceramic knives but I gave them away. I can actually get a better edge on steel. I think the ceramic edge crumbles microscopically even if you sharpen to a relatively coarse angle. Concerning steel tools, you get to know which ones take a really good edge and which are so, so. Even the same brand of high quality tools aren't always uniform in their ability to take and hold a sharp edge. I make pretty good violins and truly sharp tools make a big difference.
I get the feeling the honing fluid is just to make money, been using water in mine and it's fine. Just drying off well and leave it in the open to dry.
You are absolutely correct about the ceramic kitchen knife blades "crumbling". It's why they keep cutting, not because of the hardnessnof the ceramic- The edges on these constantly crumble, giving a ragged saw like edge.
See the microphotographs of this here:
scienceofsharp.wordpress.com/2018/02/24/ceramic-blades/
Excellent advice...straight, simple and to the point...no pun intended 👍👍
For lubricant on my diamond stones I use 1 cap full of Honeright Gold w/ distilled water in a 250ml spray bottle. Plate doesn't rust, it's reasonably priced, thin enough film thickness for 400 and 1200 grit Atoma plate and 250ml is enought for a year of home sharpening and cleaning the stones after use. BTW the 300/400 grit stones also can be used to flatten water stones.
I wish you posted this about a month ago! I just dropped $140.00 on the Norton Water Stone starter kit. Oh, well. I always enjoy your videos.
Water stones will work fine. They just require maintenance, are more messy, and don't drop them. But they will do the job.
Pete Kelly I dropped my money on Sigma Power Select II ceramic stones. They wear fast but evenly and cuts well. I also have a Norton truing stone and a nagura stone. I use diamond stones (DMT) for fixing edges. Diamond stones are awesome, abraded stupid fast (on O1 or PMV-11 it performs brilliantly), and is durable.
I have replied to your comment above.
I've been using my plastic base dmt plates with water for over 10 years, no issues at all. The only one that actually isn't holding up is the 120 mesh stone which is the only one on a solid metal plate.
Yeah, I think the guy is trying to sell the Trend product. The plastic on DMTs and Eze-Laps doesn`t really effect anything, flatness comes from the metal plates glued to the plastic, and if you dry em nothing should rust.
I've used the plastic DuoSharp diamond sharpening stone professionally for over 25yrs with water, it's still going strong with no prob, my mistake was buying the fine/extra fine when i should have bought the middle one, coarse/fine. The extra fine on is too fine for general use.
I have been using the DMT plates for around 7 years now. I have to agree. If anyone follows the link he posted read the reviews, not impressed compared to my DMT set that works fine with water.
There is nothing wrong wit those stones! Stumpy doesn't know what he's talking about, he's just trying to promote the lapping fluid which you dont need!
Here in the future, I'm looking between Trend and DMT, and I'm finding lots of quality issues with the Trend diamond blocks. DMT still seems to have a huge fanbase, along with Atoma. I like Stumpy, but this recommendation is a miss. I'm hopping on the DMT train!
Great introduction to sharpening stone. Thank you 👍🏻
Never too old to keep learning
Perfect guidance thank you 👍
Hi there from Portugal,
Nice info :D
Obrigado(Thanks)
Informative video.But waterstones are the best way and diamond plates to flatten them.
Thanks Stumpy as I just bought on a whim some stones from Harbor freight witch I will now return thanks to you!
Thanks for the info, I have a learned a lot from your videos, keep up the great work and thanks for sharing!
Your comment , of coarse , was a joke . But using WD-40 is, for sure , not a lapping matter .
**holds nose, ducks and runs!** that one STUNK, my friend... :P ....like WD-40.
Stoooooop lmao
So comprehensive - you answered all the queries that had been buzzing around in my head ever since I first saw diamond stones. I know you were a writer, and have a great deal of woodworking experience, but every time you do a video like this I am so impressed by your abilities as a communicator - and the humour (sic) adds the finishing touch.
(BTW, to whom do I apply to join your fan club ?)
Sonny I do like this and am so glad I have learned from it! I keep on buying stuff and regret it but now I have learned the sharpening I did not always do often well enough. I have learned and the tools are treasured and will not go anywhere while I am able to look after it. Later, God knows! The Young Ones will not have learned unless they learn NOW! Thank You Sir, You are much younger than me but your tool shed is impressive as the SHOW!
I'm kinda shocked at how good that was! Thank you. I'll be going deeper down this rabbit hole...
I bought the Trend 300 / 1000 diamond stone. However, the $5 an ounce Trend honing fluid is off the table for me. My favorite British woodworker considers the value proposition akin to a snake oil selling. He still uses automotive glass cleaner. I hope the two sided Trend stone I just bought lasts. I am still in the breaking in mode. Amazon reviews are mostly good but the negative reviews are flatness issues and diamonds falling off. I hope the Trend warranty is not contingent upon buying and using the Chanel no. 5 priced honing fluid.
Hi James, I just read my above post and it fails to provide my thank you for your thoughtful videos.
Trend lapping fluid is on Amazon for 13.99
Prof10000
A mix of Simple Green and water (50/50 mix) also works well since it provides lubrication but prevents rust. Also works for drilling steel too. Got that one from AskWoodman.
"Are they made from real diamonds?" He says no, then goes on to effectively say yes. Grown diamonds are still real diamonds.
Yeah, they just aren’t restricted by the only company worldwide that can mine them and set exorbitant prices. :p
I think what he means by not real is that they are not naturally occurring diamonds that were mined. They were grown synthetically.
And for industrial applications, they’re better due to having fewer imperfections. The only reason “real” diamonds fetch a premium is b/c of debeers marketing around their mystique.
Well heck. Now the whole video is wrong.
Same story I told my wife.
Extremely informative. Thank you!
I use your expertise quite a bit. I got an old Stanley (rather long, I’ve forgotten the name) plane last year off of EBAY. Flattened the sole starting yesterday using sand paper. OMG. Anyway it’s smooth has a mirror shine. Flattened using a sheet of glass.
That said I do know there’s more to be done and the iron needs sharpening too. So I TH-camd Stumpy - ordering the Trend lube and stone in a few…
Thanks again for well presented, no bs videos.👊
I think Paul Sellers uses windex with his stones. It's in the same category as water, though -- accidentally got a few drops on my band saw table and ended up with a bit of annoying rust to clean off.
He doesn't use Windex. He uses automotive windshield washer fluid. Works for me, just fine, too.
All of the, ahem, solutions, used as alternatives to water are still water based. The reason they will work better, although I'm not sure how much better, is that they all have surfactants (think detergent) that lowers the surface tension. And when you're trying to keep intimate contact between the tool and stone that will matter. Like I said, I don't know if you can perceive it but it will have some impact. That said, I've been using water forever. Maybe I'll try it. And if you want to just a few drops of dishwashing soap per liter should be fine.
When he says he buys 500 ml of glass cleaner he is not talking about windshield washer solvent. 500 ml is about 17 ounces as you would buy in a spray bottle.
Paul Sellers does use window cleaner, but I don't think he uses plates I am pretty sure he uses stones, although I think with the ammonia in glass cleaner it takes the water with it when it flashes off (dries) so no worries of rust, think about when you clean a window and you watch the streaks of moister evaporate in front of your eyes. But this is all guessing, I uses plates and glass cleaner and it works well, no rust in almost 2 years.
you're all wrong. it's not Windex or automotive windshield washer fluid. He uses glass cleaner. not to be confused with window cleaner. And yes he uses diamond plates. Eze Lap plates to be specific
If you are sharpening by hand and not in a jig, the flatness of the stone is negligible. I doubt any of the viewers out there could even measure the difference. I have used the multi layered stones (DMT) for many many years and checked my work on an optical comparator, its nice having a full machine shop at your disposal. The price difference between them (multilayered) and a single piece unit is just not worth it considering the results.
Flatness my be less important with knives, but this video is about woodworking tools. And flatness does make a BIG difference when you are sharpening a hand plane.
Stumpy Nubs then you should be sharpening with a jig. Or having them precision ground by a qualified grind shop. If you are sharpening it by hand you are going to be at a minimum of 5 tenthousandths out, just from going between grits. I doubt you have the set up and proper equipment to even measure that, so it's a moot point.
Been using an Atoma japanese diamond lapping plate for 4 years now. It has an aluminum base with a replaceable pad. Held on by adhesive. Still within 1/10k of an inch. I know your against them but I would give it a try. Best tolerances on the market imo.
Thank you for this valuable ( New to me ) Info !
What brand is that honing guide you've got there?
Trend. One of the links above will also have the stone in a kit with the guide. I got the kit a few years ago. It's my favorite guide.
7:16 "...but wood is an abrasive material and after a couple of stroke your 20000 grit edge is gonna be worn down to that 1000 grit anyway..." ......5 MINUTES STANDING OVATION.
I concur wholeheartedly. I've stumbled across some videos where the great zen honing master is getting all masturbatory over his near mythical Japanese natural waterstones and the magical properties they impart to his steel. Now... every man needs a hobby, and I can see the appeal that sharpening steel to a ludicrous degree might have to the obsessively inclined. I really do. But I work wood for a living. I havn't got the time. Sharp enough will have to do. Been using a set of 3 plastic-based DMT diamond stones with water the last 4 - 5 years. Very pleased with them.
@Dick Fageroni sorry to say this i agree that stropping is the method that is used for ages and it is one of the most effective older techniques out there. But a razor is not to be compared with a chisel or any other woodworking edge. Because of the complete different metal composition...
All edges look like a saw under a microscope, and how coarse the saw teeth are dictates how fast the edge turns dull. So, a finer edge will remain sharp longer. This is also why wood, a material softer than metal, works as an abrasive - because the blade has tiny teeth that gets stuck and bent on the wood.
That said, depending on what you’re doing should dictate how you’re honing. A chef has better use of a 6k stone than a bushcrafter or carpenter
@@AndreasNkleby Most of the times, indeed, a carpenter doesn't need to go above 3000 or 4000. But that's for planing, not finishing surfaces. You can never get a surface as smooth with abrasives as you get with a plane. Some Japanese guys (obviously!) made a video with microscope photos of planed and sanded surfaces. No matter how fine, sandpaper always leaves fibers that are torn but still attached to the surface, and decrease the smoothness. A plane cuts all fibers at the same length (provided it's sharpened by a maniac) and leaves a significantly smoother surface behind. True, the cutting edge won't hold for long - that's why, when you go to such grit, you need to resharpen often.
There are applications where having an extremely sharp steel using a much higher grit than 1k is desired. Not really needed when you are just hacking away.
Based on this recommendation, I just bought the Trend 300/1000 plate. I’ve only sharpened one chisel so far, but it is wicked sharp! I was astonished at how much more sharp it was. I can’t wait to see what it does with my plane irons… Thanks!
This was so helpful. I have just bought brand new chisels and did not want them anywhere near my oil stone which has more peaks and valleys than something with a lot of peaks and valleys!
Diamonds in nickel are in suspension, not in solution. If they were dissolved they wouldn't be diamonds any more.
“Diamonds are the hardest material on Earth.”
Pffftt..... whatever. You should meet my ex. I guarantee her shriveled, black, hardened heart would slice through a diamond like butter.
Lonsdaleite and wurtzite boron nitride are supposedly even harder than diamond, but there is so little that they can't actually measure it.
We must have the same ex...🤔
You must be my ex's second husband in disguise...
My ex and your ex have to be related
@@tikkidaddy you're all related too........and bitter 😂😂😂
I hate having to stop and sharpen. One of my hobbies involves bamboo and my plane iron gets beat up so I sharpen often. You tips are a huge help. Thanks.