Well.....that is about as good a performance of Beethoven’s 2nd Symphony as I think I’ve ever heard! No wonder the audience was so swept away at the end. What a privilege to have been there for this event!
Ich bewunderte die Hörner schon in der Sechsten! Die spielen wunderbar auf ihren Naturhörnern! So schön muss es erst einmal einer am Doppelhorn spielen! Chapeau!
@@hanneloreerdmann198Who cares if it doesn’t hinder her playing. Maybe it helps her get into the music. Besides, this isn’t a dance recital. Close your eyes and listen to the music.
Prächtig, einmaliger Sound, ein Orchester wie keins, hervorragende Leitung!! Ein Genuss für die Ohren, vor allem die Flötistin im Larghetto. Bravo, Bravo! Gratuliere HR Symphonie Orchester!
Spettacolare la CODA del primo movimento, staccata con un tempo più veloce a seguito del climax ... mi sono venuti i brividi. ho 64 anni e la seconda di beethoven l'avrò sentita 1000 volte, ma mai coma in questo caso mi ha detto qualcosa di nuovo.
This is one of my favorite Beethoven symphonies, with its rollicking, good-natured first movement with its visions of the 7th, to the many moods and gentle, affecting beauty of the second movement that bring the 6th to mind, to the jolly 'scherzo', and then the rhythmical quirks and misplaced accents of the wonderful finale, precursors of the humorous 8th. I've always thought that the 2nd was an underrated work, and that it approaches the greatness of the 3rd more than I've heard it said. In any case, the performance and interpretation here is as good as I've ever heard, and that's quite an accomplishment!
YOU GOTTA' BE A MUSIC TEACHER. EXPERTS ARE SO FAR BEYOND OTHER MORTALS. I WATCH 'CHOPPED' & HEAR THE JUDGES CRITIQUE THE FOOD IN WAYS I NEVER IMAGINED. AND OF COURSE WHAT YOU'RE SAYING MOST PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND, JUST SCRATCH OUR HEADS. I WILL REMEMBER TO SAY 'I LOVE THE ROLLICKING & JOLLY PARTS OF BEETHOVEN'S 2ND' & THEY'LL THINK I'M SO EDUCATED, HAHAHAHAHA.
I see what you mean... there was a segment in the Adagio that definitely reminded me of the third, which is my favourite... though I guess we will see in around 32 minutes if that will continue to be
Oh, auch diese Sinfonie ist mir sehr vertraut. Mein Vater war großer Beethoven-Fan und ich bin ihm dankbar, dass er mir als Kind die klassische Musik näher brachte. Hier gefällt mir die Stelle 3.55 Bis 4.15 und die Wiederholung 9.44 bis 10.02 besonders gut. Das ist so lange her, dass ich das gehört habe, wahrscheinlich mehr als 50 Jahre.
Die beiden Solostellen in E und dann in A sind gefürchtet bei Hornisten. Die beiden stellen das am Naturhorn hin als wäre es das Selbstverstädlichste auf der Welt. Danke das macht Freude zuzuhören. Bravissimo! 👍👍📯📯
I love their playing in the 4th movement. To me Beethoven Dvorak and Brahms were the best symphonic composers of the 19th century, in that order(sorry Brahms lover). In the 4th movement around 28:36 and repeated at 31:13 there is a brief passage that reminds me so much of Dvorak. A Dvorak “flavour “ so to speak. Obviously Dvorak must have played this symphony when he was a viola player in a Czech orchestra. Great composers are musical sponges, so being a lover of Dvorak symphonies I couldn’t help but notice this.
SOME OF THE GUYS IN THE ORCHESTRA ARE SO HANDSOME, THE CONDUCTOR ALSO. I CLICKED ON THIS JUST TO SEE THE CONDUCTOR, HIS PHYSICAL APPEAL. NOT ASHAMED. LOVE BEETHOVEN ALSO & CLASSICAL IS MY FAVE.
This is quickly becoming one of my favorite TH-cam channels. Haven't come across a bad performance yet! (although, to be honest, I'm not usually that critical anyway--it's just great to have this much beautiful music available in a single click)
Auf das schaue ich nicht. Ich will schließlich nicht Robotern beim Spielen zuschauen, sondern Menschen. Aber die Optik ist mit sowieso ziemlich egal. Musik ist zum Hören und nicht zum Schauen.
Gut balancierte und perfekt synchronisierte Leistung dieser jugendlichen Sinfonie vom kompakten Orchester. Die Töne zweier Hörner sind besonders eindrucksvoll.
Truly, a great performance. I admire the hr-Sinfonieorchester! The orchestra is great, but I am not sure about Orozco-Estrada? He is mainly concerned about precision, for him that means above all: rhythm. This is just my amateur opinion: This kind of precision works great with Beethovens Early Symphonies, the first and the second. But last night I heard Orozco-Estrada conducting the Ninth (not with the hr-Sinfonieorchester, it was with the Concentus Musicus, an ensemble founded by Harnoncourt and the Arnold-Schoenberg Chor). And I'm going to listen to his performance with the hr-sinfonieorchester as well, but the record I heard last night was so disappointing. On the other side: Orozco-Estrada conducting Rachmaninovs Sinfonische Tänze was wonderful... Maybe the Ninth is something he had to fail with.
Excellent performance. But I'm curious how Orozco-Estrada chose the mix of performance practices he's using. The violins, violas, and cellos are playing without vibrato, as would have been the practice in the late 18th-early 19th century, and this gives a nice, light classical sound. But the double basses are using full vibrato. At least, the principal bass player is; I'm not sure about the others. The brass--horns and trumpets---are using period valveless instruments, but the reeds and flutes are using modern instruments. It works very nicely, and I guess that in the end, that's all that matters.
A esa gran lista de las sinfonías 3, 5, 6, 7 y 9 de Beethoven, de hecho deben incluirse la 1 y la 2. La primera desde el inicio ya nos depara lo que será la gran obra sinfónica de Ludwig con ese comienzo disonante y distinto a los demás clásicos. La segunda es un anticipo a la Eroica, totalmente alegre, no da respiro, ya innovaba con esa festividad, y eso ya era casi romanticismo.
Is it possible that music is processed and recollected in a different part of the brain than other experiences? For instance, even though it has been at least ten years since I last heard this piece, I remembered it almost note for note. It is the same with me for even more complex works by Mahler and Bartok, for instance. Could it be only with those pieces I like? This fascinates me obviously, and I would love to hear from anyone who has had similar experiences.
I think there must be something like that. I remember almost note by note, harmony by harmony most of the pieces I heard in the past and which I'm fond of. I think I could conduct many of them (actually I do that at home when nobody is looking!). I did it once in the presence of somenone that happened to be a friend and a viola in a symphonic orchestra when I got carried away by a stupendous recording of the Prokofiev 6th and to my surprise, when finished, he told me that I could do a better job then many conductorsa he had worked with. Of course I couldn't as I don't even have a theoretical music education and can hardly read music. But it did lift my spirits!
I believe that that flautist was a featured soloist in another part of that evening's live performance. Hence the camera's attention to her playing and the a fancier formal dress for her compared to the other women's attire in the orchestra.
In my view, just as the even numbered Star Trek films are better than the odd numbered ones, it's the odd numbered Beethoven symphonies that outshine the even ones. That said, this performance of his 2nd puts it at the top of that class for me.
![[베토벤 교향곡 완전정복] - 교향곡 2번](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UNOaqEc-LcI/mqdefault.jpg)
Orozco-Estrada brings such freshness to old, time honored music.
Well.....that is about as good a performance of Beethoven’s 2nd Symphony as I think I’ve ever heard! No wonder the audience was so swept away at the end. What a privilege to have been there for this event!
Danke!
Jede der 9 Symphonien ist so wunderschön sie anzuhören!
This channel has been the soundtrack of my lockdown. Thank you so much
Ich bewunderte die Hörner schon in der Sechsten! Die spielen wunderbar auf ihren Naturhörnern! So schön muss es erst einmal einer am Doppelhorn spielen! Chapeau!
Wunderbar gespielt, macht mir viel Freude. Beethoven war aber auch ein begnadeter Komponist. Phantastisch.
Muy hermosa música, muy talentosos Orquesta sinfónica, muchísimas Gracias. La música es Sanidad del Alma, La música más Hermosa del mundo.
Das ist meine Lieblingssimfonie. Eine gute Auffuhrung! Danke!
Speechless, especially the flute and horn players are just awesome!
Besonders das übertriebene Gestikulieren der blonden Flötistin ist unerträglich. Kommt sich wohl wichtig vor.... oh ja....
@@hanneloreerdmann198Who cares if it doesn’t hinder her playing. Maybe it helps her get into the music. Besides, this isn’t a dance recital. Close your eyes and listen to the music.
Prächtig, einmaliger Sound, ein Orchester wie keins, hervorragende Leitung!!
Ein Genuss für die Ohren, vor allem die Flötistin im Larghetto.
Bravo, Bravo! Gratuliere HR Symphonie Orchester!
Spettacolare la CODA del primo movimento, staccata con un tempo più veloce a seguito del climax ... mi sono venuti i brividi. ho 64 anni e la seconda di beethoven l'avrò sentita 1000 volte, ma mai coma in questo caso mi ha detto qualcosa di nuovo.
sono perfettamente d'accordo la migliore in assoluto
Cool.
Bravo! Fine musicians, fine orchestra, brilliant conductor!
Thank you for such beautiful music! Citizens of Frankfurt are blessed!
Beautifully played! Bravo !
I would say Citizens of the whole world!
This is one of my favorite Beethoven symphonies, with its rollicking, good-natured first movement with its visions of the 7th, to the many moods and gentle, affecting beauty of the second movement that bring the 6th to mind, to the jolly 'scherzo', and then the rhythmical quirks and misplaced accents of the wonderful finale, precursors of the humorous 8th. I've always thought that the 2nd was an underrated work, and that it approaches the greatness of the 3rd more than I've heard it said. In any case, the performance and interpretation here is as good as I've ever heard, and that's quite an accomplishment!
YOU GOTTA' BE A MUSIC TEACHER. EXPERTS ARE SO FAR BEYOND OTHER MORTALS. I WATCH 'CHOPPED' & HEAR THE JUDGES CRITIQUE THE FOOD IN WAYS I NEVER IMAGINED. AND OF COURSE WHAT YOU'RE SAYING MOST PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND, JUST SCRATCH OUR HEADS. I WILL REMEMBER TO SAY 'I LOVE THE ROLLICKING & JOLLY PARTS OF BEETHOVEN'S 2ND' & THEY'LL THINK I'M SO EDUCATED, HAHAHAHAHA.
@@GuruRasaVonWerder I understand: You don't understand. Understand?
@@ronaldbwoodall2628 STAY HAPPY SON
I see what you mean... there was a segment in the Adagio that definitely reminded me of the third, which is my favourite... though I guess we will see in around 32 minutes if that will continue to be
@@GuruRasaVonWerder Kellie... much appreciate your detailed analysis. It adds much to our seeing the bigger picture .
Oh, auch diese Sinfonie ist mir sehr vertraut. Mein Vater war großer Beethoven-Fan und ich bin ihm dankbar, dass er mir als Kind die klassische Musik näher brachte. Hier gefällt mir die Stelle 3.55 Bis 4.15 und die Wiederholung 9.44 bis 10.02 besonders gut. Das ist so lange her, dass ich das gehört habe, wahrscheinlich mehr als 50 Jahre.
Loving that natural horn. Yet more colors, and those overtones - BRAVO!!
I just love the harmoniousness and coordination of human beings
Die beiden Solostellen in E und dann in A sind gefürchtet bei Hornisten. Die beiden stellen das am Naturhorn hin als wäre es das Selbstverstädlichste auf der Welt. Danke das macht Freude zuzuhören. Bravissimo! 👍👍📯📯
Gibt es die Entscheidung für Naturhörner oft in Orchestern mit "modernen" Instrumenten? Auch die Trompeten sind ehr historisch.
@@petatap3737 die haben aber hier nicht die gefürchtete Stelle...😁
Purely amazing. The music makes you feel so "wealthy" or serious.
Was mich fasziniert ist der Grandioser Klang dieses Orchestra unter Maestro Estrada. Finest Beethoven.
Splendida esecuzione!!!! Andrés Orozco-Estrada è UN DIRETTORE impareggiabile.
I love their playing in the 4th movement.
To me Beethoven Dvorak and Brahms were the best symphonic composers of the 19th century, in that order(sorry Brahms lover).
In the 4th movement around 28:36 and repeated at 31:13 there is a brief passage that reminds me so much of Dvorak. A Dvorak “flavour “ so to speak.
Obviously Dvorak must have played this symphony when he was a viola player in a Czech orchestra.
Great composers are musical sponges, so being a lover of Dvorak symphonies I couldn’t help but notice this.
Bitte wer sind diesmal die tollen Naturhornisten?
Das hr-Sinf.Orch. dürfte gesegnet sein mit wunderbaren Hornisten! 📯📯👍😎
Hi, Johann!
That’s our Michael Armbruster and Marc Gruber!
Hoeren Sie mal Armbruster am Anfang Bruckner's Vierte!
Just a breathtaking, wonderful performance! Congratulations Andres and hr-Sinfonieorchester!!!!!
SOME OF THE GUYS IN THE ORCHESTRA ARE SO HANDSOME, THE CONDUCTOR ALSO. I CLICKED ON THIS JUST TO SEE THE CONDUCTOR, HIS PHYSICAL APPEAL. NOT ASHAMED. LOVE BEETHOVEN ALSO & CLASSICAL IS MY FAVE.
I love it with its 4 movements and with this excellent conductance. Bravo Beethoven. We will not stop thinking of you all the times.
I come here to listen to this almost every day. Stunning!!
Marvelous performance, taut, precise, refined, crisp sound and articulation, excellent balances, lovely!
Let the rich and adventurous fly to Mars; I'd rather stay behind in this planet if only to listen to a performance like this.
This is quickly becoming one of my favorite TH-cam channels. Haven't come across a bad performance yet! (although, to be honest, I'm not usually that critical anyway--it's just great to have this much beautiful music available in a single click)
Same :) Have you listened to Bruch's violin concerto with Hillary Hahn yet?
@@Ivander85 Don't know if I have or not, but I'll definitely add it to my play queue.
@@Ivander85 yeah, right?
Che meraviglia questa sinfonia di Beethoven
World best music symphony my favorite music symphony orchestra world best Beethoven
1.mvt 0:32
2.mvt 12:51
3.mvt 23:46
4.mvt 27:41
I don't like Mahler but i like you
@@kerencanelo8580 you should try Mahler's 2nd
|Great playing. Love the natural horns!
Ausgezeichnet und fabelhaft
Following on the violin score was joyful!
Great performance! Perfect ensemble of the wind section. Thank you!
Herrliche Synchronisation von Körpereinsatz des Dirigenten, des Orchesters und der Musik!
Auf das schaue ich nicht. Ich will schließlich nicht Robotern beim Spielen zuschauen, sondern Menschen.
Aber die Optik ist mit sowieso ziemlich egal.
Musik ist zum Hören und nicht zum Schauen.
Wow. The future of modern performance - bravo!
Bravissimi tutti. Esecuzione perfetta. Direttore sopra la norma. Complimenti
Magnifique interprétation, très belle prise de son, voilà de quoi nous régaler les oreilles ! Avec la prémonition de la 9 ème à 2'15 !
This just made my day! Thanks on all musicians!
You all are the best guys!!!
Bravo vintage horns!! What a treat! Ludwig would appreciate!
Thank you for this work of art: tremendous performance.
1st movement
0:33 begins | 3:39 energetic transition | 5:49 energetic transition | 7:13 wind down | 10:51 wind down |
*2nd movement
12:52 begins | *15:25 moment | 21:25 theme |
3rd movement (gradual combos)
23:47 begins
4th movement
27:42 begins | 32:31 moment | 33:24 ending checkpoint | 33:31 ending
Чудесная музыка! Большое спасибо Франкфуртскому оркестру!
' ll
Schon genial, wie LvB besonders im 4. Satz das saturierte Publikum immer wieder am Einschlafen hindert.
Magnificent. Perfect views of a hard-working orchestra.
Fantastic! Marvelous!
Hermosa sinfonía como todas las de Beethoven. Muy buena interpretación y excelente tarea del director. Bravo 👌💪
very nice speed i like this fast tempo very wonderful art!!!!!
Excellent performance
Love the allegro molto. It has some Mozartian elements combined with typical Beethoven being atypical.
Gut balancierte und perfekt synchronisierte Leistung dieser jugendlichen Sinfonie vom kompakten Orchester. Die Töne zweier Hörner sind besonders eindrucksvoll.
Naturhorn viel anpassender.
@@richardnewnham1417 Vielleicht so. Aber die modernen Hörner klingen noch schön.
@@notaire2 Schoen -- und sicher.
@@richardnewnham1417 Ja, echt sicher.
Humanity at one of its best!
Thank you mr. Conductor!! I use these recordings to study!!!
truly amazing
I love Beethoven.
superbe interpretation...Bravo!
Entusiasmante! momento magico
Extraordinaria interpretación.
Gracias.
Fenomenal, esplendido. Muitos aplausos
❤
Wunderschön!! Vielen Dank!
what a maaaive organ in the back - beautiful!
what great music
Bravo! Bravo!
Merci beaucoup for this.
1st mov 0:32
A 2:16
Allegro 3:03
B 3:57 6:05
C 4:25 6:34
2nd Ending 7:20
D 7:37
Tenuto 7:53
E 8:23
F 9:06
Truly, a great performance. I admire the hr-Sinfonieorchester! The orchestra is great, but I am not sure about Orozco-Estrada? He is mainly concerned about precision, for him that means above all: rhythm. This is just my amateur opinion: This kind of precision works great with Beethovens Early Symphonies, the first and the second. But last night I heard Orozco-Estrada conducting the Ninth (not with the hr-Sinfonieorchester, it was with the Concentus Musicus, an ensemble founded by Harnoncourt and the Arnold-Schoenberg Chor). And I'm going to listen to his performance with the hr-sinfonieorchester as well, but the record I heard last night was so disappointing. On the other side: Orozco-Estrada conducting Rachmaninovs Sinfonische Tänze was wonderful... Maybe the Ninth is something he had to fail with.
Tout simplement splendide !
Excellent performance. But I'm curious how Orozco-Estrada chose the mix of performance practices he's using. The violins, violas, and cellos are playing without vibrato, as would have been the practice in the late 18th-early 19th century, and this gives a nice, light classical sound. But the double basses are using full vibrato. At least, the principal bass player is; I'm not sure about the others. The brass--horns and trumpets---are using period valveless instruments, but the reeds and flutes are using modern instruments. It works very nicely, and I guess that in the end, that's all that matters.
I would make a special trip to Germany just to hear this orchestra perform any of Beethoven’s 9 symphonies
A esa gran lista de las sinfonías 3, 5, 6, 7 y 9 de Beethoven, de hecho deben incluirse la 1 y la 2.
La primera desde el inicio ya nos depara lo que será la gran obra sinfónica de Ludwig con ese comienzo disonante y distinto a los demás clásicos.
La segunda es un anticipo a la Eroica, totalmente alegre, no da respiro, ya innovaba con esa festividad, y eso ya era casi romanticismo.
Куда вы дели 4-ую симфонию? 🙄4-ая гораздо интересней чем многие его симфонии кроме может 5-ой и 6-ой.
BRAVO!
지휘자가 무난히잘한다 지루하지않고 비교적 조용해 즐거히 감상한다
Ele brilha na condução de uma obra vibrante. Beleza Rafa. Bela escolha.
Incrível, bela performance.
Is it possible that music is processed and recollected in a different part of the brain than other experiences? For instance, even though it has been at least ten years since I last heard this piece, I remembered it almost note for note. It is the same with me for even more complex works by Mahler and Bartok, for instance. Could it be only with those pieces I like? This fascinates me obviously, and I would love to hear from anyone who has had similar experiences.
I have the same feeling, but only with pieces I like.
I think there must be something like that. I remember almost note by note, harmony by harmony most of the pieces I heard in the past and which I'm fond of. I think I could conduct many of them (actually I do that at home when nobody is looking!). I did it once in the presence of somenone that happened to be a friend and a viola in a symphonic orchestra when I got carried away by a stupendous recording of the Prokofiev 6th and to my surprise, when finished, he told me that I could do a better job then many conductorsa he had worked with. Of course I couldn't as I don't even have a theoretical music education and can hardly read music. But it did lift my spirits!
I too have experienced this God given phenomenon. The brain is remarkable and still not fully explored by researchers . .
Many thanks!
Obrigado amigos e amigas musicistas!
Incredible.
His second symphony says: Forget the Viennese style, here comes Ludwig van.
Sehr gelungen, auch und gerade ohne die übliche Hektik im Schlusssatz!
A fine orchestra indeed and a great conductor. Wonderful. Only one question. Is the TV director married to the principal flautist ? So dedicated.
I believe that that flautist was a featured soloist in another part of that evening's live performance. Hence the camera's attention to her playing and the a fancier formal dress for her compared to the other women's attire in the orchestra.
Oh Thank your!
Alejandro, the "Concertino" received once, years ago, the blessing hands from Anna Netrebko while singing "Meine Lippen" von Giudita's Lehar.
Flute: Clara Andrada de la Calle
Muy bueno
The best.
Très décevante la disposition des cordes!!
bravo!
In my view, just as the even numbered Star Trek films are better than the odd numbered ones, it's the odd numbered Beethoven symphonies that outshine the even ones. That said, this performance of his 2nd puts it at the top of that class for me.
Me encanta, 😊
아~~ 정말 좋구나...
2:14 is it just me or is this foreshadowing the ninth symphony?
Espetáculo graças
Early symphony has that kind of humor...always 3-4 repeat
Excellent performance. But why does he pause so long between movements? It ends up making one nervous, and it fragments the work.
What kind of horns are those? They don't appear to have valves but aren't like the natural horn used in Baroque music.