I know exactly what you mean! To me that is why Beethoven is number one. For that exact reason! The more you hear it the more it develops in your mind. I’m 61 and have been listening to classical since I was a kid, especially LVB.
Beethoven wrote this piece to appreciate how napoleon supported the French revolution and brought down the monarchy. But later napoleon crowns himself emperor imagine how pissed Beethoven would have been
Unless mistaken, I believe it's TH-cam that inserts ads and not the orchestra. (Again, and in my experience, there are lower chances of ads coming up if you're active, i.e. if your keyboard or your mouse are periodically in action, rather than if you're watching with your hands off the laptop/PC.)
Message à Google quand vous traduisez les musiciens so great = géniaux ou le chef so awesome = génial non ! les premiers sont talentueux, grands etc, le second est merveilleux, formidable, etc Mais le génie, c'est Beethoven !
Very nice performance, but for my taste first movement is too fast, like I’ve listened it in 1,25 speed. There are too many things in the first movement you should be savored, with fast tempo it all just lost. Just my opinion. Orchestra plays wonderfully!👏👏👏
The more I listen this fabulous orchestra the more I don't change it neither BP nor LSO. Andrés Orozco-Estrada and this great group of musicians make my life. And during this pandemic time they have demonstrated they are all excellent soloist.
I've "discovered" Beethoven more extensively at this late point in my life, and it seems to me that he was the genuine pioneer of 19th-century music, really paving the way for Schubert, Schumann and Brahms. And Orozco-Estrada, Norrington and other modern conductors have found out how to brush the cobwebs away from this genial musician and his music. It is a pleasure to hear (and see) them at work. A real public service. Many thanks! JAT
@@katrinat.3032 I already have "The Creatures..." in a recording by Roger Norrington/London Classical Players. I know how Beethoven can express himself in shorter contexts...Coriolan,
Fun Fact: After scratching Napoleon's name off the manuscript, Beethoven considered renaming the symphony EROTICA, but settled for EROICA due to misspelling.
I love the energy and elegance that has been put into the interpretation. I think that's part of what Beethoven wanted to capture with the symphony, especially the 1st movement!
According to some music critics, this is the greatest symphony ever written. I always thought 5, 7, and 9 were utterly fantastic, but I'm listening to this again with a new curiosity to determine what drove music critics to evaluate it higher than his other symphonies, especially#9. It indeed is a very pleasing musical production. Every time I hear Andrés Orozco-Estrada direct a symphony. I know it will be high quality. He certainly did not let me down with this wonderful performance. Thank you, Andrés Orozco-Estrada, for this wonderful performance.
The 3rd is considered special because it showed how much more was possible than had come before. It is probably more common to say it is the most important symphony than to say it is the best, but it is indeed great and the others paths that the 3rd introduced.
I think this performance was unnecessarily subdued. Orchestra is top-notch but I am afraid the rendition does not live up to the image of the revolution where many bloody heads were rolling.
@@EnginAtik its subjective, but I think this was one of the compositions that Beethoven produced that helped move classical music into the romantic period. There definitely is some political overtones associated with the composition as Beethoven increasingly disliked Napoleon for proclaiming himself as an Emperor just in time for the battle of the three Emperors at Austerlitz.
@@paulescudero9973 I agree. This symphony was probably a revolution in and of itself in its premiere. I just remember it being more to the point with sharper edges from the recordings I remember from my chilldhood.
I heard nuances in this performance that I had never heard before, and I’ve been listening to this for almost 50 years, both live and on recordings. Stellar performance.
Me encanta Beethoven, me encanta esta versión de su Eroica, el director y la pasión con q el grupo de profesionales ejecutan esta gloriosa música. Gracias mil❤
For many many years I listened to the Bohm interpretation as the ultimate one. It was slow but incredibly powerful. I couldn't find any that would come close. This has just surpassed it. The density, the richness, the absolute mastery in the minute creation of pure power, or might, or energy, is unbelievable. For the first time in my life classical music made me cry.
I love Beethoven. Beethoven's best symphony, Certainly one of the best performances of this symphony. Beautiful performance. I love this orchestra. These people are good. Bravo to everyone! Thanks a bunch
Wunderschoen. Ich lebte einige Monate in Frankfurt und fuhr mit der U-Bahn immer an der Alte Oper Haltestelle vorbei. Wusste immer dass es dort wunderbare Musik gab, hatte aber nie die Zeit ein Konzert zu besuchen. Beethoven hat die Geschichte der Musik mit diesem Stueck veraendert. Tolle Darbietung, Andres!
La música hace poesía pero sólo el corazón es poeta, gracias artistas del mundo, por alimentar nuestra alma con la música, como si fuera el pan nuestro y sagrado de cada día, con la música que no está para mostrar lo visible, sino para hacer visible lo que está más allá del mundo. Hernan navarrete rojas. Un humilde samurai
At my Santiago Chile and his Philhamomic and his Synphonic Orquestras I have never seen this kind of horns. A great conducter and amagnificent orchedtra.
Why does Beethoven's music always make me wanna cry out tears of happiness amidst my anxiety...? Thank you, Beethoven, for giving us consolation by speaking out human beings' innermost feelings.
@@sorim1967 I am disappointed by your reply. What is your hierarchy? How do you LVB felt insulted? Your comment insulted me!! Music is a form of art to be appreciated, such appreication is influenced by many factors of those who appreciate it. You do not know my factors and how can you make such a judgement. Please examin your intentions before making such comments.
Auch auf dem Heimkino: überwältigend gut. Danke an alle Künstler und den Helfern und Technikern bei dem Konzert. An Beethoven sowieso, was für eine gewaltige Musik.
Wonderfully done. So cool to see natural horns as well. I've played this symphony, and I can tell you from the inside that it is nowhere near as easy as this band makes it seem!
I am very impressed by this conductor. I haven't experienced his work before. His choice of tempi and the way he respects the architecture of the symphony are superb.
I video della Sinfonieorhester sono i migliori. Finalmente possiamo seguire la musica in modo "sinfonico" passo passo dietro le formazioni orchestrali. Grazie
I've bought several LPs and CdDs of this, my favorite Beethoven, over the years. None is better and few are as good as this marvelous orchestra's playing here. Everyone involved in this orchestra onstage and off is wonderful. Bravissimi a tutti!
It is wonderful to see individual orchestra members up very close, almost impossible in the auditorium. In some ways it is better than being in the audience. I would pay for a subscription to online concerts,even after the philharmonic reopens
Also. If you want info of (the current i don't they keep records of pass musicians) if you look at their website you can find the orchestras current members name and biography
Esse primeiro movimento muito me lembra o "Tour de Force" da 5ª Sinfonia em Dó Menor. Essa é a Sinfonia que Beethoven dedicou a Napoleão Bonaparte, mas quando soube que ele auto se havia coroado imperador ficou furioso e riscou a dedicatória de tal modo que rasgou a partitura original. É, sem dúvida, uma Sinfonia esplendorosa! A regência do maestro Andrés Orozco está sublime, inflamada de paixão e concentração absoluta à frente da orquestra, cujos músicos, por sinal, muito bem vestidos se mostaram dedicados a uma interpretação uníssona e à altura do gênio de Beethoven! À parte a apresentação da orquestra, um detalhe técnico me chamou a atenção: as tomadas de câmera foram perfeitas onde todos os músicos e instrumentos tiveram a sua relevância por igual, em ângulos onde toda a excelência da orquestra e sua magistral apresentação se fez presente. Meus parabéns!
Beethoven's best symphny! That 2nd movement is simply unsurpassed in beauty and emotion and did not fail to give me the shivers listening to it again... My favourite of ALL symphonies ever composed.
I first heard the Eroica at age 4 from an old record of my grandfather’s. Even today 60 years later, I can still hear every note in my mind. Permanently implanted in my brain.
I love how classical music makes me have so many feelings. My heart will start beating really fast, I will feel happy, then sad, then be in awe of the beauty of it. ❤❤❤
This performance has left me speechless! Every movement and musical nuance was carefully planned and executed. The orchestra finds the soul of this piece and brings it to light. From start to finish it was a joy to watch this performance. Bravo tutti!
Beethoven would have appreciated this performance of his favorite symphony (before he wrote his Fifth). Hats off to the French horn players using non-valve horns (Richard Strauss's father would have applauded for them, too). Bravo!
Desde hace tiempo sigo la trayectoria de Andrés Orozco-Estrada y no deja de asombrarme. Su grabación del Stabat Mater de Rossini era excepcional. La integral de las 9 sinfonías de Beethoven fue muy, muy buena, con el acierto de incluir a Carlo Colombara en la novena. Pero esta versión de la tercera es lo mejor del ciclo 2016. Una fuerza incontenible, sutilezas increíbles y un acierto en la velocidad del segundo movimiento, al que muchos directores imprimen una velocidad que desvirtúa el sentido. ¡Bravo maestro Orozco-Estrada!
Andres brought up so many layers among the instruments that was not that obvious from other recordings. Indeed, Beethoven's complicated thoughts are more evident in this rendition. In a simple word, 'fire' is the essence of Beethoven's music. Andres took it to another level. Well done!!
@Alex Tejada I had been listening to Beethoven since I was 15. I have many CD collections of Beethoven 9 symphonies as an audiophile. This would tell you if I am that easily impressed by any music.If you don't understand, how can you make a cause and effect relationship? Please check your intention when you comment on Asian. Beethoven understood humanity and would bring all races together in his music rather than isolating once race against another.
When the pandemic is not over yet, this incredible performance brings consolation. The adagio is beyond perfection! HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie conducted by Orozco-Estrada is truly outstanding. Thank you, viel Danke. Muchas gracias!!
And when the pandemic is gone you are always welcome to see, hear and feel them yourself if it is in the "Alte Oper" the place where this one is recorded, or more casual open-air at the "Weseler Werft" veranstaltungen.meinestadt.de/frankfurt-am-main/location-detail/2032203
I once told my late mother (I POINTED TOWARD HEAVEN ) saying Beathoven is up there we are down here ! I regardless of how many years go by will always feel he was&is the greatest composer who ever walked the face of this earth ! How a man who happened to lose his hearing could ever write so many masterpieces of music l will never know ,! Did he get the works. From God?
@@katrinat.3032 I am always waiting for new releases on TH-cam from this amazing group of musicians and everything they do is masterfully executed regardless of the composer. Whether it be sibelius or schubert, bruckner or beethoven, and mahler. The videographer is among the best always pointing the camera at the right group of instruments following the peice to its conclusion.
Beautiful performance! The orchestra and Orozco-Estrada were, as usual, at their best. Loved the use of the old instruments. Many thanks, and the best to all of you!
Wau! Que puedo decir, por más de cincuenta años he estado disfrutando las Sinfonias de Beethoven; para mi ha sido como mi alimento, para aumentar mi espiritu; Sus obras son un elogio a la humanidad y pertenecerá por tiempos inmemoriales hasta que el hombre pierda su carácter humanitario.
Phantastische Performance von Dirigent und Orchester. Beethovens dritte sehr gefühlvoll und einfühlsam interpretiert. Ludwig hätte seine Freude daran gehabt. Ich war damals in der Alten Oper dabei und es ist immer wieder ein Genuss diese Aufzeichnung zu sehen und zu hören.
Symphony No.3 The ‘Eroica’ is always a pleasure to listen to with the talented conductor and the wonderful orchestra. Each movement is a delight to listen to. Who could ask anything more than perfection!!!! .... Beethoven never lets us down he gives us such great music to enjoy 😊 in the future.
Es ist eine Freude, die hohe Motivation jedes einzelnen Musikers zu sehen. So wird aus Beethovens Meisterwerk mit diesem genialen Dirigenten ein akustisches Abbild geschaffen, das dem Hörer unvergesslich bleibt
Is anyone wondering how the second movement is beautiful !!!!!!!!! Now i realize that Beethoven is the real transition from classical to romantic music .
That's because it's in C minor key and his works in this tonality have been said to be powerful and emotive, evoking dark and stormy sentiments. Also check his Piano Sonatas Nos. 5, 8 and 32, Symphony No. 5 or the Coriolan Overture.
his facial expressions & body movements are so in step with what they have to do, great guidance - As he recovers composure during the much-needed break see the sweat running down his face 15:26 & thereafter 2 minutes
Before the start of the second movement, it looked like he went into deep meditation or prayer. This conductor feels the music in his entire body ! It’s wonderful to watch
Mi sinfonía preferida en manos de un maestro de tanta categoría. Gracias por dirigirla con tanta pasión y profesionalidad. Un orgullo sentir tu hispanidad.
Con mucho respeto y humildad digo esto: casi el cien por ciento de las personas que hacen comentarios sobre la interpretacion de la Musica de el Señor Beethoven puedo observar y decir que, ni conocen a Beethoven y menos su Musica. Comentarios vasios, superfluos, que no dicen nada. Cuando uno habla, comenta u opina sobre cualquier materia debe de tener conocimiento y cierto dominio sobre esta. Pero, como decía mi abuelita: "La ignorancia es atrevida"
So oft ich kann, höre u. sehe ich mir die EROICA ab - nur diese, weil ein excellenter Dirigent das großartige Orchester führt!! Können und Passion - Beethoven freut sich bestimmt!
Wow in my lifetime I've heard several versions of this sublime symphony.I place this second only to that of the great Karajan.The sincerity and dedication of the director and every team member shine through.The March Funebre literally gave me goosebumps.Bravo.Can't wait to hear more of this great orchestra.
@@foveauxbear Thank you. It's good that those who disagree with remarks made here post their opinions. I've never understood the adulation Mr Karajan enjoys. I grew up with concerts and recordings by Fritz Reiner and George Szell and still find their recordings more interesting and rewarding than those by Mr Karajan. Still, we're dealing with taste here, and It's not easy convince people that they have tin ears.
@@tserkoslavjanskij Yes : the performance of Beethoven's music by Karajan is great, but it is no "pure Beethoven" it is more "Beethoven by Karajan". It is a phenomen that occurs with many great performers (I think of Glenn Gould, Lang Lang ,Pavarotti and many others ) who take fabulous compositions and turn them into... something else...
Hr with Manfred Honeck are superb! And Orozco-Estrada is clearly one of the top rank of conductors. One can tell by the response of the orchestra members.
My GOD. The minute-long passage from 21:30 - 22:40 delivers the most mind-blowingly euphoric high you’ll ever get from music. This stuff oughta be illegal.
Not the most, because music is so much than this and in Beethoven himself it is found more moments like this. And in other composers there are a lot of moments like this and better.
@@kerencanelo8580 I would agree. It was a bit of hyperbole, but it’s a great passage that gives me goosebumps every time I hear it. Off the top of my head, I’d say the final couple minutes of Mahler’s Resurrection Symphony are the most exhilarating and emotionally intense moments of any music I’ve ever heard. 8th is great too.
Een van de mooiste uitvoeringen ooit gehoord van mijn lievelingssymphonie. Met gevoel gespeeld. Elk instrument krijgt de plaats die het toebehoort. Musici, dirigent, geluidstechnici , de cameramensen, kortom iedereen die aan deze opname heeft meegewerkt , BEDANKT. Het publiek wil ik niet vergeten, hun aandacht heeft het orkest geïnspireerd.
This rendition of the Finale is the most satisfying I've ever heard. For many reasons - counterpoint, phrasing, dynamics, balance, second violins, period instruments and no vibrato, superb solos, and a sense of roundness of the whole simphony...
He escuchado varias veces esta interpretación, en distintos momentos; bajo la dirección de Orozco-Estrada y me sigue pareciendo verdaderamente intensa, fluida, aguerrida y sutil. Encuentro finalmente una catarsis en tiempo y color. Cada interpretación es única, es una obra magistral que no hay que santificar, hay que disfrutarla en sus distintas interpretaciones. Siempre y cuando sean dignas de ser escuchadas.
I love this symphony. As a Beethoven lover, it’s in my top 3 Beethoven symphonies along with the ninth and fifth symphonies. As a pianist, I find it harder to play the piano transcription of this symphony than that of his fifth symphony. And as a composer, this is the piece that inspired me to compose symphonies. My first symphony that has been planned for several years now and is now being composed has a lot of inspiration from this symphony, from the general narrative of a hero battling against an enemy and coming out victorious to the presence of a funeral movement to the start of the introduction with fortissimo chords alternating with a bit of quiet melody. That said, one of the biggest differences is the time signature of the first movement. Beethoven uses a 3/4 time signature with hemiola passages that feel like 2/4. I just straight up use a 2/4 time signature and the first theme at least will definitely be a march.
I first heard this when I was 13. I'm 73 now and it sounds as wonderful as the first time I ever heard it!
I was about 14. My favorite Symphony, when I started understanding musicality and how to perform with others
I know exactly what you mean! To me that is why Beethoven is number one. For that exact reason! The more you hear it the more it develops in your mind. I’m 61 and have been listening to classical since I was a kid, especially LVB.
I'm hearing it today for the first time.
Beethoven wrote this piece to appreciate how napoleon supported the French revolution and brought down the monarchy. But later napoleon crowns himself emperor
imagine how pissed Beethoven would have been
he was so pissed that he supposedly crossed out the dedication angrily on the original partition.
Well, he wouldn't be the first or only person in history to feel let down by a politician...
@@anthtan LOL
Shut up.
@@leonardoiglesias2394 I wasn't talking.
I have come to the point where watching these professionals is as enjoyable as the music itself. Wow. These folks are GOOD.
Thank you for not putting ads in the middle of the piece! Much appreciated.
Sponsored by the German public!
Agreed!
Unless mistaken, I believe it's TH-cam that inserts ads and not the orchestra.
(Again, and in my experience, there are lower chances of ads coming up if you're active, i.e. if your keyboard or your mouse are periodically in action, rather than if you're watching with your hands off the laptop/PC.)
Cancel Netflix and get TH-cam premium
@@chew76 Nah, just use AdBlock haha
The tempo is fantastic. I love this recording so much. The wind players, timpanist, so great. Maestro Estrada is so awesome!
You dont like the strings?????
@@leonardoiglesias2394 lol of course! I absolutely do! :) sorry,, didnt mean to leave them out. Do u have a favorite?
Message à Google
quand vous traduisez les musiciens so great = géniaux
ou le chef so awesome = génial
non !
les premiers sont talentueux, grands etc, le second est merveilleux, formidable, etc
Mais le génie, c'est Beethoven !
Very nice performance, but for my taste first movement is too fast, like I’ve listened it in 1,25 speed. There are too many things in the first movement you should be savored, with fast tempo it all just lost. Just my opinion. Orchestra plays wonderfully!👏👏👏
@@BogdanDekhtiaruk
Very true, as with Brahm's 4th which is often played much too fast.
The more I listen this fabulous orchestra the more I don't change it neither BP nor LSO. Andrés Orozco-Estrada and this great group of musicians make my life. And during this pandemic time they have demonstrated they are all excellent soloist.
For my taste, this is the best orchestra around.
I’m glad I live in the era of recordings 😊
Eroica… The Symphony of Symphonies. A magnificent performance. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I've "discovered" Beethoven more extensively at this late point in my life, and it seems to me that he was the genuine pioneer of 19th-century music, really paving the way for Schubert, Schumann and Brahms. And Orozco-Estrada, Norrington and other modern conductors have found out how to brush the cobwebs away from this genial musician and his music. It is a pleasure to hear (and see) them at work. A real public service. Many thanks! JAT
May I suggest Beethoven’s creatures of Prometheus
@@katrinat.3032 I already have "The Creatures..." in a recording by Roger Norrington/London Classical Players. I know how Beethoven can express himself in shorter contexts...Coriolan,
A poll of modern composers, conductors, and concert artists ranked the Eroica as the greatest of all symphonies ever written.
When this conductor and orchestra come together, magic happens.
what is magic
@@opticalreticlebruh
It sounds very enthusiastic, so heroic, beautiful, and at the same time very gentle.
Can’t get enough of this. It’s infused with energy. I love how he focuses his applause on the orchestra❤️ He seems humble. He’s a great conductor!
You mean, Klemperer, Karajan, Solti and Kleiber were humble….?
@@leonardoiglesias2394 No I was talking about this conductor
So was I.
@@leonardoiglesias2394 Karajan humble 🤣
ㅣ
Love this orchestra! Love the vintage brass! Love this conductor! Love Ludwig!
To be honest, I don't know the difference in tone, the vintage horn, but it's classy and nice to look at.
Makes me feel like the world can be a pretty great place when I see and hear this wonderful performance! Good stuff!
Yes! In Haiti they love this piece!
Yes I love Beethoven! His music transports you
Fun Fact: After scratching Napoleon's name off the manuscript, Beethoven considered renaming the symphony EROTICA, but settled for EROICA due to misspelling.
Lmao
You would've gotten me if I didn't know the etymology for the German word eroica
I love the energy and elegance that has been put into the interpretation. I think that's part of what Beethoven wanted to capture with the symphony, especially the 1st movement!
According to some music critics, this is the greatest symphony ever written. I always thought 5, 7, and 9 were utterly fantastic, but I'm listening to this again with a new curiosity to determine what drove music critics to evaluate it higher than his other symphonies, especially#9. It indeed is a very pleasing musical production. Every time I hear Andrés Orozco-Estrada direct a symphony. I know it will be high quality. He certainly did not let me down with this wonderful performance. Thank you, Andrés Orozco-Estrada, for this wonderful performance.
The 3rd is considered special because it showed how much more was possible than had come before. It is probably more common to say it is the most important symphony than to say it is the best, but it is indeed great and the others paths that the 3rd introduced.
I think this performance was unnecessarily subdued. Orchestra is top-notch but I am afraid the rendition does not live up to the image of the revolution where many bloody heads were rolling.
@@EnginAtik its subjective, but I think this was one of the compositions that Beethoven produced that helped move classical music into the romantic period. There definitely is some political overtones associated with the composition as Beethoven increasingly disliked Napoleon for proclaiming himself as an Emperor just in time for the battle of the three Emperors at Austerlitz.
@@paulescudero9973 I agree. This symphony was probably a revolution in and of itself in its premiere. I just remember it being more to the point with sharper edges from the recordings I remember from my chilldhood.
It's the most superb version I ever heard. Perfect tempo, beautiful instrumentation, and fantastic counterpoints throughout each movement.
I know! This performance is awesome!! There is something about the energy and how ‘clean’ they play❤️
I heard nuances in this performance that I had never heard before, and I’ve been listening to this for almost 50 years, both live and on recordings. Stellar performance.
I see Orozco-Estrada is having the recognition he deserves.
Großartig! Vielen Dank Ludwig v. Beethoven - und allen Interpreten!
hdm
Beethoven, uber alles
Me encanta Beethoven, me encanta esta versión de su Eroica, el director y la pasión con q el grupo de profesionales ejecutan esta gloriosa música. Gracias mil❤
For many many years I listened to the Bohm interpretation as the ultimate one. It was slow but incredibly powerful. I couldn't find any that would come close. This has just surpassed it. The density, the richness, the absolute mastery in the minute creation of pure power, or might, or energy, is unbelievable.
For the first time in my life classical music made me cry.
Great camera work. Puts you right in among the players and you realise how each individual is contributing to the overall superb performance.
Esecuzione magnifica.grande orchestra come il direttore.archi e legni perfetti.un grande applauso.
Unbelievably perfect intonation during the entire 3rd, here. Beautiful beyond belief.
너는 욕망 이 있느냐 질문이라면 베토벤의 영웅이라고 대답할거이다
대답할것이다
The Greatness and gracefulness of Beethoven’s music is profound and immeasurable and infinity
I love Beethoven. Beethoven's best symphony, Certainly one of the best performances of this symphony. Beautiful performance. I love this orchestra. These people are good. Bravo to everyone! Thanks a bunch
Wunderschoen. Ich lebte einige Monate in Frankfurt und fuhr mit der U-Bahn immer an der Alte Oper Haltestelle vorbei. Wusste immer dass es dort wunderbare Musik gab, hatte aber nie die Zeit ein Konzert zu besuchen. Beethoven hat die Geschichte der Musik mit diesem Stueck veraendert. Tolle Darbietung, Andres!
Andere Städte haben auch Musik, einfach mal anhören!
Awesome! Beethoven is divine! This symphony would be called “Bonaparte” if Napoleon hadn’t crownded himself as emperor…respect from 🇧🇷
La música hace poesía pero sólo el corazón es poeta, gracias artistas del mundo, por alimentar nuestra alma con la música, como si fuera el pan nuestro y sagrado de cada día, con la música que no está para mostrar lo visible, sino para hacer visible lo que está más allá del mundo. Hernan navarrete rojas. Un humilde samurai
Marvellous to use the old horns...sounds quite different.
Excellent. The tempo is really perfect.
the other way is the one that is different
Watch the players' right hands' subtile movements as they tune the pitches.
Yeah I am thoroughly impressed by that! I played double horn (valved of course) and there's no way I could equal these masters!
At my Santiago Chile and his Philhamomic and his Synphonic Orquestras I have never seen this kind of horns. A great conducter and amagnificent orchedtra.
@@1udwi6 AAaaaaa@aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa##q
This orchestra is so wonderful. One and done! No splicing, no re-doing. They do it right the first time, every time. Gruendlichkeit.
The best part is that the
conductor really gives
his all with any
orchestra ❤
Congrats to the conductor, the orchestra and all those involved in this marvelous performance, from the philippines.
Why does Beethoven's music always make me wanna cry out tears of happiness amidst my anxiety...? Thank you, Beethoven, for giving us consolation by speaking out human beings' innermost feelings.
Simple, it's the greatest. Except, maybe for John Sebastian.
Because understands human emotions
Hegel's "unhappy consciousness".
because he summons our deepest emotions, being the great genius.
The Eroica is the symphony of symphonies.
Perfect definition !
The 3rd is my favorite since 1997. It's a close runner-up to the 9th for me. But the 3rd will always be my Beethoven love.
This rendition escalated the 3rd to a postion much higher than than before. Beethoven 5th and 9th is only higher in my hierarchy.
@@davekwan2694 Beethoven 5th higher? Are you serious? Beethoven himself would have felt very very insulted.
@@sorim1967 I am disappointed by your reply. What is your hierarchy? How do you LVB felt insulted? Your comment insulted me!! Music is a form of art to be appreciated, such appreication is influenced by many factors of those who appreciate it. You do not know my factors and how can you make such a judgement. Please examin your intentions before making such comments.
Bravo! I love this orchestra and all its conductors, especially, Orozco-Estrada.
Muchas gracias Maestro Orozco por las maravillosas sinfonías que nos ofrece. Mi admiración a usted y a toda su orquesta.
Absolutely perfect. Congratulations to the HR FRANKFURT sinfonie and Andrés Orozco-Estrada.
Auch auf dem Heimkino: überwältigend gut. Danke an alle Künstler und den Helfern und Technikern bei dem Konzert. An Beethoven sowieso, was für eine gewaltige Musik.
Wow. Just wow. This is perhaps the greatest rendition of one of the greatest pieces of music ever written. Thank you.
Tell us what you like about the piece. The world needs to be informed about your judgement.
@@leonardoiglesias2394 I don’t quite understand why someone would make that comment, but something tells me that any explanation would be lost on you.
Wonderfully done. So cool to see natural horns as well. I've played this symphony, and I can tell you from the inside that it is nowhere near as easy as this band makes it seem!
Just when I think it can't get any better, there it is! wonderful performance.
This must be the best performance of the Eroica I've heard!
I am very impressed by this conductor. I haven't experienced his work before. His choice of tempi and the way he respects the architecture of the symphony are superb.
This symphony is my favorite in all of music. I can relate it to a lot on a personal level. Great performance!
I video della Sinfonieorhester sono i migliori. Finalmente possiamo seguire la musica in modo "sinfonico" passo passo dietro le formazioni orchestrali. Grazie
Concordo pienamente, e il Maestro Orozco è un Gigante !!
@@angelomonticelli5042 absolutely wonderful master, totally agree.
/!😢
I've bought several LPs and CdDs of this, my favorite Beethoven, over the years. None is better and few are as good as this marvelous orchestra's playing here. Everyone involved in this orchestra onstage and off is wonderful. Bravissimi a tutti!
It is wonderful to see individual orchestra members up very close, almost impossible in the auditorium. In some ways it is better than being in the audience. I would pay for a subscription to online concerts,even after the philharmonic reopens
To be up close to a performer is indeed a wonderful gift!
Also. If you want info of (the current i don't they keep records of pass musicians) if you look at their website you can find the orchestras current members name and biography
Esse primeiro movimento muito me lembra o "Tour de Force" da 5ª Sinfonia em Dó Menor. Essa é a Sinfonia que Beethoven dedicou a Napoleão Bonaparte, mas quando soube que ele auto se havia coroado imperador ficou furioso e riscou a dedicatória de tal modo que rasgou a partitura original. É, sem dúvida, uma Sinfonia esplendorosa! A regência do maestro Andrés Orozco está sublime, inflamada de paixão e concentração absoluta à frente da orquestra, cujos músicos, por sinal, muito bem vestidos se mostaram dedicados a uma interpretação uníssona e à altura do gênio de Beethoven! À parte a apresentação da orquestra, um detalhe técnico me chamou a atenção: as tomadas de câmera foram perfeitas onde todos os músicos e instrumentos tiveram a sua relevância por igual, em ângulos onde toda a excelência da orquestra e sua magistral apresentação se fez presente. Meus parabéns!
Beethoven's best symphny! That 2nd movement is simply unsurpassed in beauty and emotion and did not fail to give me the shivers listening to it again... My favourite of ALL symphonies ever composed.
I bet you say that to ALL the girls...
@@donreed Ha-ha, quite funny...
I first heard the Eroica at age 4 from an old record of my grandfather’s. Even today 60 years later, I can still hear every note in my mind. Permanently implanted in my brain.
the best, me too, stupendous
My favourite too.
This orchestra really is the best on TH-cam
I love how classical music makes me have so many feelings. My heart will start beating really fast, I will feel happy, then sad, then be in awe of the beauty of it. ❤❤❤
Wow I see so many comments from the last few days. That proves, Beethoven is timeless
Yes :))). All classical composers will be remembered by us fellow musicians
Oi lá em pop
@@matthewwong944 ,hu
@@matthewwong944 i
Excelente concerto . Bravi a turri!!
Extraordinaria dirección de Andres Orozco, antioqueño. Proximamente director de la Sinfónica de Viena. Aplausos
Love the style of the applause, to all the individuals - well deserved! Bravo, I'm going to listen to this again & again. And dance to it.
This performance has left me speechless! Every movement and musical nuance was carefully planned and executed. The orchestra finds the soul of this piece and brings it to light.
From start to finish it was a joy to watch this performance. Bravo tutti!
you bet!
My God. This orchestra managed to excel in this heroic. Congratulations to the musicians and the conductor.
Beethoven would have appreciated this performance of his favorite symphony (before he wrote his Fifth). Hats off to the French horn players using non-valve horns (Richard Strauss's father would have applauded for them, too). Bravo!
I once read that he made that claim after the 8th. Yes, love that darker sound of the natural horns and natural trumpets.
Desde hace tiempo sigo la trayectoria de Andrés Orozco-Estrada y no deja de asombrarme. Su grabación del Stabat Mater de Rossini era excepcional. La integral de las 9 sinfonías de Beethoven fue muy, muy buena, con el acierto de incluir a Carlo Colombara en la novena. Pero esta versión de la tercera es lo mejor del ciclo 2016. Una fuerza incontenible, sutilezas increíbles y un acierto en la velocidad del segundo movimiento, al que muchos directores imprimen una velocidad que desvirtúa el sentido. ¡Bravo maestro Orozco-Estrada!
También admiro al señor Orozco-Estrada y agradezco que haya jóvenes directores de su excelente habilidad y comprensión.
Que buen director es Orozco, y que preciosa sinfonia
This is the first symphony I listened to 50 years ago.
Andres brought up so many layers among the instruments that was not that obvious from other recordings. Indeed, Beethoven's complicated thoughts are more evident in this rendition. In a simple word, 'fire' is the essence of Beethoven's music. Andres took it to another level. Well done!!
Listen to Pierre Monteux or Georg Solti.
@Alex Tejada I had been listening to Beethoven since I was 15. I have many CD collections of Beethoven 9 symphonies as an audiophile. This would tell you if I am that easily impressed by any music.If you don't understand, how can you make a cause and effect relationship? Please check your intention when you comment on Asian. Beethoven understood humanity and would bring all races together in his music rather than isolating once race against another.
yes
When the pandemic is not over yet, this incredible performance brings consolation. The adagio is beyond perfection! HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie conducted by Orozco-Estrada is truly outstanding. Thank you, viel Danke. Muchas gracias!!
And when the pandemic is gone you are always welcome to see, hear and feel them yourself if it is in the "Alte Oper" the place where this one is recorded, or more casual open-air at the "Weseler Werft" veranstaltungen.meinestadt.de/frankfurt-am-main/location-detail/2032203
I once told my late mother (I POINTED TOWARD HEAVEN ) saying Beathoven is up there we are down here ! I regardless of how many years go by will always feel he was&is the greatest composer who ever walked the face of this earth ! How a man who happened to lose his hearing could ever write so many masterpieces of music l will never know ,! Did he get the works. From God?
I return to this performance again and again! Simply amazing!
This conductor is phenomenal.
It is wonderful and powerful played
Simply brilliant. I love the way the dirigent applauds the orchestra.
I love that too! You can tell he loves his orchestra ❤️. He gives them all the credit. I just love the energy of this ensemble.
@@katrinat.3032 I am always waiting for new releases on TH-cam from this amazing group of musicians and everything they do is masterfully executed regardless of the composer. Whether it be sibelius or schubert, bruckner or beethoven, and mahler. The videographer is among the best always pointing the camera at the right group of instruments following the peice to its conclusion.
Bravo Maestro! I have listened to this many, many times. This was superb!!! Every note perfect!!!
Welche Freude dass es solche Orchester gibt.Meisterklasse !!!
Superb performance. Great to hear a well disciplined German orchestra play with great precision without the usual schmaltz and sloppiness.
Beautiful performance! The orchestra and Orozco-Estrada were, as usual, at their best. Loved the use of the old instruments.
Many thanks, and the best to all of you!
P
Thank you all of you. great play. Making my Sunday morning jubilant. Daegu, Korea.
Hi Korea!! From USA🙂
Wau! Que puedo decir, por más de cincuenta años he estado disfrutando las Sinfonias de Beethoven; para mi ha sido como mi alimento, para aumentar mi espiritu; Sus obras son un elogio a la humanidad y pertenecerá por tiempos inmemoriales hasta que el hombre pierda su carácter humanitario.
Y que opinas de Auschwitz, Gregorio, que era vigilada atentamente por amantes de Beethoven y de Schubert?
Si llega ese momento prefiero que un holocausto nuclear nos caiga encima a quedarme a ver como se degrada la humanidad😰
I love this. This is the heart and the head and you can see every musician loving this.
Yeee. Do you play any instruments?
Phantastische Performance von Dirigent und Orchester. Beethovens dritte sehr gefühlvoll und einfühlsam interpretiert. Ludwig hätte seine Freude daran gehabt. Ich war damals in der Alten Oper dabei und es ist immer wieder ein Genuss diese Aufzeichnung zu sehen und zu hören.
Symphony No.3 The ‘Eroica’ is always a pleasure to listen to with the talented conductor and the wonderful orchestra. Each movement is a delight to listen to. Who could ask anything more than perfection!!!! .... Beethoven never lets us down he gives us such great music to enjoy 😊 in the future.
Wem sich meine Musik offenbart, der kann nie ganz elend werden. B
The tempos are great, and I love how outrageously harsh the dissonances of the first movement sound in this performance.
Best Eroica recording I have heard!! MAESTRO👏👏👏
Es ist eine Freude, die hohe Motivation jedes einzelnen Musikers zu sehen. So wird aus Beethovens Meisterwerk mit diesem genialen Dirigenten ein akustisches Abbild geschaffen, das dem Hörer unvergesslich bleibt
Is anyone wondering how the second movement is beautiful !!!!!!!!! Now i realize that Beethoven is the real transition from classical to romantic music .
Infact this symphony is often described as the first romantic symphony.
I've always found interesting how he combines the tonal language of classicism with formal principles of romanticism.
@@hjo4104wonderfully put.
That's because it's in C minor key and his works in this tonality have been said to be powerful and emotive, evoking dark and stormy sentiments. Also check his Piano Sonatas Nos. 5, 8 and 32, Symphony No. 5 or the Coriolan Overture.
@@nachito2002x youre not answering the question
his facial expressions & body movements are so in step with what they have to do, great guidance - As he recovers composure during the much-needed break see the sweat running down his face 15:26 & thereafter 2 minutes
Before the start of the second movement, it looked like he went into deep meditation or prayer. This conductor feels the music in his entire body ! It’s wonderful to watch
Wonderful ...a beautiful orchestra and heavenly music
1часть
00:20 ГП
1:07 ПП1
1:24 сдвиг в ПП
1:48 ПП2
6:13 эпизод в разработке
2часть
16:13 начало
20:50 трио
23:38 фугатто в репризе
3часть
32:02 начало
4часть
37:57 1тема
39:10 2тема
40:24 контраданс
難能可貴的演出。超級棒的指揮，演奏，無瑕的錄音！
Mi sinfonía preferida en manos de un maestro de tanta categoría. Gracias por dirigirla con tanta pasión y profesionalidad. Un orgullo sentir tu hispanidad.
wow großen Respekt! Diese traditionellen Blechblasinstrumente sind einfach phänomenal
Ich liebe es einfach euch allen ZUHÖREN und zuzusehen. Was für ein wunderbares Orchester!
Wonderful interpretation by Andrés Orozco Estrada!
Con mucho respeto y humildad digo esto: casi el cien por ciento de las personas que hacen comentarios sobre la interpretacion de la Musica de el Señor Beethoven puedo observar y decir que, ni conocen a Beethoven y menos su Musica. Comentarios vasios, superfluos, que no dicen nada. Cuando uno habla, comenta u opina sobre cualquier materia debe de tener conocimiento y cierto dominio sobre esta. Pero, como decía mi abuelita: "La ignorancia es atrevida"
@@hiramroman9093 y en que mundo crees que tu vives, jaja?!
@@hiramroman9093 eso es la Internet mío caro
@@hiramroman9093 Mi gusta enchilada con queso y pollo! Bravo Beethoven!
@@leonardoiglesias2394 just ignore him
So oft ich kann, höre u. sehe ich mir die EROICA ab - nur diese, weil ein excellenter Dirigent das großartige Orchester führt!! Können und Passion - Beethoven freut sich bestimmt!
Wow in my lifetime I've heard several versions of this sublime symphony.I place this second only to that of the great Karajan.The sincerity and dedication of the director and every team member shine through.The March Funebre literally gave me goosebumps.Bravo.Can't wait to hear more of this great orchestra.
Karajan??? you must be joking, the MOST ghastly, self-indulgent-syrup-laden recordings ever made, horrid.
@@foveauxbear Thank you. It's good that those who disagree with remarks made here post their opinions. I've never understood the adulation Mr Karajan enjoys. I grew up with concerts and recordings by Fritz Reiner and George Szell and still find their recordings more interesting and rewarding than those by Mr Karajan. Still, we're dealing with taste here, and It's not easy convince people that they have tin ears.
@@tserkoslavjanskij Yes : the performance of Beethoven's music by Karajan is great, but it is no "pure Beethoven" it is more "Beethoven by Karajan". It is a phenomen that occurs with many great performers (I think of Glenn Gould, Lang Lang ,Pavarotti and many others ) who take fabulous compositions and turn them into... something else...
While studying for the English IELTS exam, I came across a passage about Beethoven Eroica, so I found myself listening to this magnificent melody.
The maestro and his orchestra play Beethoven like no one else! They are the best... and I like Manfred Honeck
Hr with Manfred Honeck are superb! And Orozco-Estrada is clearly one of the top rank of conductors. One can tell by the response of the orchestra members.
My GOD. The minute-long passage from 21:30 - 22:40 delivers the most mind-blowingly euphoric high you’ll ever get from music. This stuff oughta be illegal.
Not the most, because music is so much than this and in Beethoven himself it is found more moments like this. And in other composers there are a lot of moments like this and better.
@@kerencanelo8580 I would agree. It was a bit of hyperbole, but it’s a great passage that gives me goosebumps every time I hear it.
Off the top of my head, I’d say the final couple minutes of Mahler’s Resurrection Symphony are the most exhilarating and emotionally intense moments of any music I’ve ever heard. 8th is great too.
@@JJJRRRJJJ Which eighth do you mean , Beethoven's or Mahler's???
>>>Joel Laykin , Hong Kong , China .
@@IPPF-oo6pe I meant Mahler’s 8th
Great Maestro Andres!
im
@@josiesanseverino3610 im not......... lol
Een van de mooiste uitvoeringen ooit gehoord van mijn lievelingssymphonie. Met gevoel gespeeld. Elk instrument krijgt de plaats die het toebehoort. Musici, dirigent, geluidstechnici , de cameramensen, kortom iedereen die aan deze opname heeft meegewerkt , BEDANKT. Het publiek wil ik niet vergeten, hun aandacht heeft het orkest geïnspireerd.
i mean to say....this must be the greatest masterpiece ever written......and ever will be written.....until the next grand extinction
This rendition of the Finale is the most satisfying I've ever heard. For many reasons - counterpoint, phrasing, dynamics, balance, second violins, period instruments and no vibrato, superb solos, and a sense of roundness of the whole simphony...
counterintuitively, it is amazing what an effect vibrato-less notes in the strings can produce
He escuchado varias veces esta interpretación, en distintos momentos; bajo la dirección de Orozco-Estrada y me sigue pareciendo verdaderamente intensa, fluida, aguerrida y sutil. Encuentro finalmente una catarsis en tiempo y color. Cada interpretación es única, es una obra magistral que no hay que santificar, hay que disfrutarla en sus distintas interpretaciones. Siempre y cuando sean dignas de ser escuchadas.
I love this symphony. As a Beethoven lover, it’s in my top 3 Beethoven symphonies along with the ninth and fifth symphonies. As a pianist, I find it harder to play the piano transcription of this symphony than that of his fifth symphony. And as a composer, this is the piece that inspired me to compose symphonies. My first symphony that has been planned for several years now and is now being composed has a lot of inspiration from this symphony, from the general narrative of a hero battling against an enemy and coming out victorious to the presence of a funeral movement to the start of the introduction with fortissimo chords alternating with a bit of quiet melody. That said, one of the biggest differences is the time signature of the first movement. Beethoven uses a 3/4 time signature with hemiola passages that feel like 2/4. I just straight up use a 2/4 time signature and the first theme at least will definitely be a march.
Fabian Kirchgessner I am for sure proud that I am writing symphonies now.
those hemiolas are so forceful. 7:27
@@caterscarrots3407 wow
Andres Orozco Estrada BRILLIANT.
The confidence and sheer energy of the conductor’s opening is just beyond me. I knew I was in for a treat. Molto bravissimo 🎉