I’m from Pakistan 🇵🇰. I don’t know why our Pakistani Politicians want Kasmir. What ever we have, we are enable to keep it maintained. Actually, Kashmir is profitable business for our Army and Politicians. Being Pakistani, I think Kasmiris are much happier and free with India. Stay happy and move forward. Civilians are victims of Militancy , we Pakistanis knows better.
U understood what 99% of brainwashed kashmiri muslims of India do not understand. Its simply an islamic brainwashing as usual. Look at comment section u wont find any Indian muslim supporting Shah Faezels decision
Yes, when most of the people of both countries will understand this then the most of the problem between India and Pakistan will solve.... Let's hope for the best
Definition - Genocide is the intentional destruction of a people in whole or in part. Deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.@@brahm-ahamasmi
I liked it when @Shah Faisal said that now the Government of India works like a corporate and a file has to move forward no matter what, nobody can hold it for long and do corrupt practices. It functions like a clock work. That's so nice to hear.❤❤❤
6:39 PM 02 March 2019 Shah Faesal tweets: A Nobel Peace Prize to @ImranKhanPTI could drastically change the way Pakistan operates in the South Asia region. IK has already "raised the bar" for leadership in the region and the Prize could encourage him to further nurture the India-Pak relation. He deserves the prize. ISI ki funding se political career shuru karne ki achi koshish thi but sir ko pata nhi tha k Modi-Shah kal k paida nhi hue hain. I personally hate BJP government for reinstating people like him in services, God knows what such opportunists will do next time they get an opportunity.
Highly appreciate, Mr Shah, to have understood his responsibility towards his family, Jammu And Kashmir, India, Islam and Humanity. No one is 100 % perfect in this life but the one who mends his ways during the journey of life ,is always successful. Your words are honest and will continue motivating youth not only of JK but of the entire nation. Jai Hind.⚘⚘🌻🌻🌹🌹
Such an Excellent conversation .. Mr Faesal has a guts to say what he feels like from governance to Hindu and Islamic culture to root problem in Kashmir.. Just Loved this Man... Everybody should watch this ..
This was an outstanding podcast. Interviewer asked thoughtful questions and Dr. Faesal did not deflect any question and elaborated on his views. While Dr. Faesal was speaking the interviewer did not interrupt him and allowed him to continue his trail of thoughts. This is how good podcasts are made. Dr. Faesal is a role model because no one can question his abilities and yet he admits his mistakes and willing to share his learnings openly. What a man. Thank you Vaad team for doing this. Hopefully you will invite him again
Sir, I am from Pune, Maharashtra. I am so happy after watching your interview and views. We will make our nation great. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻. Kashmiris are our brothers and sisters.
Whole India needs a person who said something else before and says something else now? Why you people don't think deeper? He has come to podcast to get blind followers like you.
This is the Man to whom I love to listen. I message him about wular lake condition in 2018 & he replied and he met me the very next day on Delhi Airport. Love You Dr.Shah Faesal From Maharashtra
Mr.Shah Faisal free and frank conversation was very refreshing. It’s difficult to find a Muslim Scholar to talk freely on Islam. He can contribute in educating the youth about true Islam. To openly admit the shortcomings in Islam and measures to overcome them is really wonderful. Looking forward to hearing him on another occasion.
'True Islam' is slipper slope. Instead, we better have 'Indian Islam' - not even that - Kashmiri Islam, Gujarathi Islam, Bohara Islam etc. Such local identities help to define a version that is original, local and co-exists with everyone else. 'Global true Islam' will only lead to Caliphate dream sooner or later.
Shah Faisal is speaking from the heart Being an intelligent and upright person he is presenting the true picture of ground realities of the Kashmir He has excellent knowledge of the fabrics of kashmiri society.
Kashmir society is nothing without kashmiri pandit ; if kashmiri pandit did not settle than kashmiri muslims has no right to talk about kashmiri culture
Kashmiri pandit were living in kashmir before islam ever come to India; due to islam kashmiri pandit had to face massive genocide and exodus ; all temples in kashmir is destroyed
He is reconstructing the impression. You must see the interview he gave to UK media. He was out politics and he was only harming the india. He cant be trusted
IAS Topper himself realised this late in his life….. Very difficult for common people to understand this in depth… Understanding India is not easy and is not everyone’s ☕️
IAS topper, That too from Kashmir itself, that too someone who lost his father to terror. It indeed is not an easy and straightforward problem to solve.
He did not realised late..... He tried to become ultimate opportunist.... milk the situation and become political leader. He knew exactly that he was slowly creating the image of cult leader in the eyes of kashmiris, the leader with separatist views which later would win him the post of chief minister of the state(the ultimate power). But Modi govt threw the cold water on his plans and instead he was trapped in his own plan. Now you are seeing the modified version of him(mind you he is still the same with separatist view). He will show his true colours again the minute modi govt will be thrown out of the power.
Burden of true knowledge and disillusionment of popular activism is an antidote for status quo maintained by UN who upholds under the pressure of absolute aggressors. India is free of Article 370, and it took over 70 years, tells us about efficiency of upholders of democracy.
Dr. Faesal when topped UPSC, i heard his interview in DD National. He has come a long way since then. Its great to know that he accepted his wrong believes for Article 370 and 35A openly in public forum. It require some guts to say that. I am sure he will contribute a lot to build new india. Good work by team Samvaad!!
@tushargoyal554 Intentions are there....Glass is at least half full.....That too will happen.....Only Modi will do.....there are parties out there who are swearing to bring back 370 forget about Kashmiri Pandit rehabilitation.
@@Shri_Ji__ I don't find any real life benefits other than rhetorics. IAS topper isn't doesn't make a person God, stop worshipping humans and start worshipping Sri Ramchandraji.
He changed sides after seeing strict actions by government in Kashmir ...Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!! And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
@@tushar4506 Did he ever said that he regrets his past decisions or apologize for his actions ... Did he ever shown Sympathy for Kashmiri Hidus..... If not then .You're just delusional without "Shatru-Bodh" . ... Because of people like you ... they will betray us again and again... And we will always be doomed to repeat history ..
When he talked about what his father used to say " India badi great nation hai, isase takrana mat" it gave me goosebumps. Also my eyes were filled up with tears simultaneously ❤❤❤❤❤ My heartfelt condolences to Shah's father. May he get a place in Jannat .
I'm from Jammu. I'd very honest, I used to hate Shah Faisal, now i'm a big fan of him. What an intellectual and well informed and well read mind. Huge Respect Faisal. :)
इससे बढ़िया संवाद कश्मीर के बारे में मैने कभी नही सुना। फैजल साहब ने जब इस्तीफा दिया था मुझे बहुत दुख हुआ था। उनके वापस आने से बहुत खुशी हुई। बहुत सी नई बाते पता चली, खास तौर पर जो उन्होंने कहा कि आज कश्मीरी स्कूलों में अधूरी पढ़ाई कराई जा रही है। मुस्लिम सूफियों को ऋषि बोला जाता था। काश कश्मीर फिर पहले जैसा माहौल तैयार हो और फिर से वहां पहले जैसी रौनक लौट आए।
THANK YOU Shah Faesal for insight of J&K. Just hope every Pakistani watch this program and learn from actual people who suffered and survived last 35 years of terrorism in J&K.
Whether Shah Faisal was honest then or now doesn't matter much. What matters is what a person of his position says in public. From that perspective, this interview is a landmark interview. 👍
It takes courage to be this honest to ourselves and to the world.... Today I understands him better... Don't know why but I was contemplating about my life and my inner self while listening to the sir.... I just loved this podcast and will watch it again....
Sir,kudos to your maturity, thoughts and acceptance. I have seen a lot of people but they never accept their mistakes. You are an inspiration for the younger generation.
I have lived in Srinagar for 3+ years, had several Kashmiri youths including few Pandits working with me. I was surprised to listen how they hated terrorists and were utterly helpless.
We are really happy to listen to a real Kashmiri indian saying the truth. He is a precious jewel Modi- Shah recognised and reinstated in the government. Thanks to you for the interview.
He changed sides after seeing strick actions by government in Kashmir ... Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!! And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
Once I was so disappointed in him and this day I lay all my reverence for this gentleman. Spectacular explanation of a complex issues. Godspeed to you Dr Faesal.
He changed sides after seeing strick actions by government in Kashmir ... Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!! And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
अर्थ शुचिता जीवन की सबसे बड़ी शुचिता है। ईमानदारी को मूल्य के रूप में स्वीकार करने के लिए अभिनंदन। यह मूल्य जिसके पास हो, उसका आत्मा पतित नहीं होता है। बधाई, शाह जी।
@@VikashKumar-st3qx You are lucky in being born on the correct side he was born in the wrong environment, i Salute him for being able to introspect and correct his path. Not many people can do it. I doubt you and i could do it.
@@deepakthirdreich wheather he has corrected or lying that is different point of discussion. But we as a nation had incured the losses because of this man. I request you to watch hi UK media interview then you wipl get his real face. "Values never changes"
Faesal Saab, I am from Jammu and working in delhi. I also belongs to minority from Jammu. I can understand from the core of my heart what you are talking about. I loved your sincerity. But I would love to have more comments from my Kashmiri brethren 🙏
I am from Barmer Rajasthan. Invite Dr. Faisal again. I have a mindset about this man due to some pre 370 statement of him that he was also part of separatist ecosystem. After this podcast he successfully vanished this out of mine. My vicinity also shares a border with Pakistan and facing similar drugs problems. May his insights of Kashmir can help about similar problems. Also how social media radicalisation can be controlled.
Impressive! I'm truly impressed by how gracefully he acknowledges and rectifies his mistakes. A person of remarkable talent with engaging, knowledgeable conversations. Left me inspired and eager to reconnect.
Thanks for being honest , Mr Faisal . I met with you at CP New Delhi after you left IAS and aspired for politics. I told you that you Can’t change the situation of Kashmir without India and Indians. I am happy that you realised it soon. - Abhinav Chhimwal
I'm from Maharashtra.. Shah Faisal is my inspiration for civil services, but when he opposed 370 revocation and formed JKPM for it, I was heavily disappointed, even my friends were taunting me for he being my inspiration. When he came to realise reality and changed his thoughts with introspection, he again has become my favourite! Kudos to you Shah sir! ❤
Liked the conversation very much in a relaxed and pleasant way. Excited to hear more about upbringing and life in general in Kashmir specifically for you before and after the horror of nineties. Also life and philosophy.
He is just another one. Just like Bittu. If he is one change. Ask the bitter truth, like why Kashmir Hindus genocide happened in Kashmir? Why he still now not able to understand the sufferings of Hindu?
पूरा संवाद बहुत ही रोचक व सुलझा हुआ है। भगवान से प्रार्थना है कि कश्मीर के लोगों को ये तथ्य जल्दी से जल्दी समझ में आ जाएं, जिससे वे अपनी ज़िंदगी को खुशहाल बनाने व देश को आगे बढ़ाने में सहायक बन पाएं।
Sir maine aapki soch ko Salam karta hn aapki baaten sun k meri aankhe khul gai aur apke papa मास्टर जी को मैं अपने दिल से सैल्यूट करता हूं जिनकी शिक्षा से आप इतने अच्छे विचारवान बने है । आप जैसे लोगों की वजह से आपके विचारों से ही कश्मीर एक बार जरूर भारत का सिरमोर बनेगा।
Mr. Shah Faesal sir, I am highly impressed and deeply motivated by witnessing your personality. It takes a tremendous amount of courage to accept one's wrong-doings, amend them and have the determination to walk on the right path. You are a torch-bearer to not only Kashmiri youth but the youth of our India. The sense of clarity and the values of Kashmiriyat which are instilled in you, I pray that the same set of knowledge gets imbibed in us. Wishing you the best of luck in all your future endeavors and may god watch over you always. Thanks a lot for being a part of this podcast. Expecting you again soon!
Respect to Shah Faesal. What an awesome comeback... In fact he is very lucky as life seldom gives back both together to anyone, a second chance as well as people at top who can understand. Very nice podcast
He is 200% honest. Listening to him is like listening to a spiritual person. I really liked the part where he confessed that he wanted to be detained and where he called multiple people and they thought he was calling them for his family. He is 100% transparent !!! Never seen anyone like him 🙏🙏
डॉ. शाह फैसल सच मे सच्चे दार्शनिक है। एक बात तो तय है इस साक्षात्कार को जो भी सुनना प्रारंभ करेगा वो बीच मे छोड़ कर बिल्कुल भी नही जाएगा। आप इस देश की तरक्की में जो योगदान दे रहे हो वो एक दिन जरूर रंग लायेगा। मैं तो आपकी स्वतंत्र सोच को देखकर बड़ा खुश हुआ हूं।
Fantastic man...truly travelled a long distance in his life. Whoever let him come back to IAS after his stint with politics, did the best job...such people will be bringing so much positivity in that part of the world.
It's so satisfying to hear such honest conversation, from such a person, who has been an inspiration to many in this country. Not only as a Govt. Officer, but as a human being, he was able to acknowledge his mistakes, and move on in life, which needs a lot of guts. What an enlightening conversation. Waiting to listen more from him
One of the best, open, genuine and thoughtful and insightful conversations i thought. As a person who has been on all sides of the case, he was so convincing and comprehensive in many ways about it.
Very honest and Frank views about the situation of Kashmir and the people of Kashmir expressed by Mr.Shah Fesal....as an Indian we are proud of such a knowledgeable person being in service of nation. Very intricately he explained the past and present of Kashmir. All the Best sir.
Hmm ! But it's also a fact that many of us now can understand what is being said n not said . And how it is being said . But koi nei! Mara mara kahte kahte hi Rama Rama hoga . Aur koi rasta hai inn green * on ke paas ?
He is clever about what politicians do he was ex upsc then started career in a political career then all of sudden 370 removed now he is acting like being innocent bechara ban Raha hai clever fox
Why are there only 90 thousand-ish views for this ? This deserves to be spread and shared with every living person who has any view on Kashmir across the globe. Absolutely outstanding questions and even better answers. The nuance and depth of the answers are just breathtaking. This is what Kashmir and Kashmiris need more of !
Iam from Kashmir and always had a very sad feeling that my motherland is suffering from some kind of metastatic carcinoma with no cure or hope of getting better.With this podcast after long time i saw a bit of hope for my motherland .Thanks for everything
Oo you have found hope after watching this man's podcast , sry I should not even comment here because the cops are authorised to track social media freely , rest you understand dear.
I am very much impressed with Mr Shah Faesal's views on Islam Sir .I am a retired surgeon, I want to have some personal communication with him, but I think it is not possible, hence I wish you more podcasts with him in future.thanking you .🙏🙏
It is absolutely delightful to listen to Shah Faisal 2.0 - he is a walking proof how enlightenment and knowledge helps one accept the prevailing truths and reconcile with one's notions implanted wrongly or by wrong people. Hope he continues to talk on various podcasts and s able to catalyse the changes necessary for the growth, development, prosperity and peace of JnK. May Maa Sharda Shakti bless him with joys, courage, great ideas ...Jai Hind @ Vaad - thanks for your brilliant work bhai.
खुद की गलती स्वीकार कराना ऑर आगे चलना ए दिखणे मे बहोत सिंपल हैं लेकीन ये बहोत असान नही होता.Thous who have high morals only they can do it. Very happy that you have accepted it.
Shah Faesal denies the Kashmiri genocide. He uses the words "exodus", "migration" "jaana pada". He also skirts around the question of Islam being the cause of most of the problems there. An attempt to press harder should have been done.
Change after experimenting life is always worth sharing.......it is a long journey of tests and examinations......time alone will uncover the mystery of future. Shah Faisal has a big task ahead....hope he shows up commitment strong enough to deliver at the right time......!
Wonderful conversation! Mr Shah Faesal you are an Icon of India! This kind of positivity is what we need ! Please come back on podcast for more such vaad samvaad !
Very very interactive discussion . Got to know another perspective on Kashmir issue. Listening to Shah Faesal gave us hope that our Kashmir has bright future , just like the rest of India .
Excellent conversation.... I feel extremely proud as an Indian ki Shah Faisal jaisa bright star hum duniya ko uphaardiya hai..... really a bright star who can flourish in any subject of his choice in any corner of the world....may God bless him, may you reach your true potential 🙏
Shah Faesal thanks for sharing your U Turn.. many of us have our own U Turns which is bold to accept as it reflects we have a strong quality which is to reflect and analyse the impact we have through this life. You had yours you understood you accepted and you have the ability to talk about it. Many of us would die a million deaths to even talk of it due to public shame and fear of being isolated. But being able to talk and giving your experience and process to come to terms with it gives many the courage to do it. Your thoughts are so clear reflecting true thought given to it.
Shah Faisal is a blessed man with an extraordinary honesty. He has long way to go and has a great calling waiting for him. Intelligence - honesty - humility is a great human combination.
शाह फैसल द्वारा दिए गए इस इंटरव्यू में हमें कुछ चीजों की जानकारी विशिष्ट तरीके से मिलती है | 370 के बाद में किस प्रकार से कश्मीर के हालात बदल गए और साथ ही किस प्रकार से पाकिस्तान ने यहां पर इस्लाम के नाम पर चरम पथ को फैलाया...... यह बात बहुत ताकतवर शाह फैसल को बना देती है कि उनमें अपनी गलती स्वीकार करने की एक जबरदस्त ताकत है इस इंटरव्यू के बाद में कह सकता हूं शाह फैसल एक शानदार व्यक्तित्व के धनी है वैसे लोग भारत सरकार में होना हम सभी लोगों के लिए सौभाग्य की बात है..... शाह फैसल जैसे पक्के ईमान वाला शायद ही अरब मुल्क में मिले...we love u bro❤😍... मैं तो व्यक्तिगत रूप से चाहूंगा आप जैसे व्यक्ति आगे चलकर पॉलिटिक्स में जरूर जाए
This is an Extremely candid discussion. Mr.Shah Faesal is a true intellectual and espoused various problems encountered by Kashmir. Delighted to hear a genuine conversation that is loaded with philosophical and inner reflection revelations. On the whole It is an inspiring and organised podcast Thank you Shahji. Wish you share your wealth of knowledge with many more aspiring young minds
Very nice interview. He is an IAS officer and undoubtedly knowledgeable. Might be, by this conversation, when it will reach to large audience, people who are misguided will realise to make an U turn to work for the Nation, to know the notion of nationality.
I did not know Shah Faesal's father was killed by LET millitants, very sad that he had to go through this. And I feel very proud that people like him are still there in the nation, who inspite of their hardships become the best in what they do. Please bring him again :)
It wud have been a lot of international media coverage if his fatther was killed by Indian army and u wud have known it right at that time and the news wud have echoed again and again
I like the integrity of Shah Faisal. It takes genuine courage to accept mistakes. I think as a nation, we should forgive him for his mistakes. This time, if he does anything in good faith or joins politics post retirement, i will vote/support him. I wish he leads kashmiri as an intellectual in future. Now he is a true son of India & may be he can serve our nation better. ❤
1:02:02 ❤❤❤ This qtn is what you came for His answer to the question of- future of religion in kashmir was Basically- kashmir's sense of islam isn't that radical, it's closer to Hinduism. My opinion is, he has a hope that islam of kashmir will tone down, and become less vicious with koshish of the government, therby, a day when pandits can return and everything canngo hand in hand. Reality is that, there is islam can't accept anyone if it's majority. And that's the sad reality. While he has a good heart, he's slightly impractical.
I straddle both liberal and Hindutva worlds. My honest opinion is that Liberals don't understand institutional Islam and Hindutva does not understand Muslim modernity. Faesal feels like a Muslim modernist, he wants to create a post Kemalist vision of Islamic society. While the Turks had no history to fall back upon, he realises that Kashmir has a pre-Islamic high culture. I will gauge him on how successful he is in developing and propagating it. Only then can we have a fair assessment.
@@kanhaibhatt913 unki sanskriti thi par unki high culture nahi thi. Aaj ke daur me tribal religions aur woh bhi warrior/headhunting/ethno/terra centric religion ka khaas application nahi raha. Unka religion shayad tengrism raha hoga jo khud Mongolia me bohot Kam ho gaya hai(most Mongols are Buddhist today). Wapis jaane ka utna hi use hai jitna ek Hindu Indra ya Kuber ki Aaj direct Pooja kare. Hinduism has moved beyond its philosophical roots. Hum shayad iklote hai Jo unki reference Aaj bhi karte hai.
@@rutvikrs mai Anatolian logon ki baat kar raha hun. Turkey ke log Turk abhi abhi bane. Woh pehle Byzantine the, uske pehle Roman, uske pehle Greek, uske pehle Lydian.
Very few who can understand the deepness of his conversation.i was very negative about this officer but he opened my eyes.he cleared my alk doubts which I had .I am a nationalist.i got great transparesy.great podcast.👍👍👏👏❣️
Once my project manager told me “if you want to be successful, you should fail earlier in your life. If you dont fail, cost of failure will be too much at later stages and that you can’t handle because you didn’t learn earlier”
A truely agree......as I left job because I need a break and want to regain myself.And currently because of tough market it is getting difficulty to get job. But inside Im solid because it's a phase of life and it shall pass......but society scavenge on your unemployment that adds on more when you are married too..😂
I had been an IAS aspirant and watched Mr.faisals videos before starting preparation. I was so impressed by him and admired him like a God. I followed him on FB but offlately, his continuous negative biased opinions disheartened me so much that I unfollwed him. It even changed my perception about a particular community, that they can not be Nationalist. Today again i am quite impressed by his personality. Sir you have great intellect, please stay positive and true to your country.
My goodness!!! This guy is gem of knowledge. I am glad the future of India is in such bright hands. Also, it requires a spine of steel to accept things in public as a public servant. I must accept I was wrong about him few years back. And I set to correct my view of him.
@@tushargoyal554 With due respect, I, myself is an IITian who work in rural areas for the upliftment of education on personal basis by leaving corporate job some years back. I do recognize someone who are high degree of National pride within his heart. I can see a high degree of Integrity in him. I wish more and more such youth come forward for Bhárat and help it reach the past spiritual and material glories.
@@nahopyga There's no need to brag about IIT. I'm however not from IIT but working in one of the top companies in the world which is also normal, I don't brag about it. National pride without any recognition is useless. The upper-castes are treated like Jews here and I don't want to leave my job for corrupt Indian state that doesn't treat me with dignity.
@@tushargoyal554 Yet you bragged. The mobile that you used to told about your views on caste system is part of the technology we built for the world. And it's okay to brag when it's helping my nation go forward. Also, I belong from upper caste, didn't blame the system just entered one of the pioneer institute with shere effort. Don't use your victim card narrative to paint everything same.
@@nahopyga Had to else you'd keep flexing your IIT tag. Mobiles phones! Okay, completely irrelevant thing. Anyways, who are 'we' here? Did you or India build it? Lol, I'm playing victim? Damn, no! It's the low-castes who play victim all the time and Indian state is helping them by demonizing upper-castes and snatching away resources. To be very honest, your entire comment was filled with irrelevant rhetorics. Why should I contribute to the country that has given me nothing but hate?
Before I started I was of a different opinion about Mr. Faesal, but after 2 minutes into the podcast, had me stuck to view it complete. Very Candid and humble replies. A person who accepts his mistakes openheartedly is a great human being. God Bless you Faesal and may you give your best to our great Nation...
Great conversation by Shah. Excellent feeling to hear an enlightened concept taking shape and assimilate back to the realm of Advaita origins and and part of hindusthan as always had been. ❤❤
Kudos to Vaad team, for this extremely well conducted podcast of Shah Faesal. Also Huge Respect to Kashmiri Shah Faesal for his enlightening views. It has completely changed my view of Shah Faesal. Kudos to GOI for reinstating Shah Faesal I am sure he will do more to impress his views on J&K in future. Bharat needs more Kashmiri's like Shah Faesal. Congratulations to VAAD team for pulling off this brilliant podcast and a pure from the heart podcast by a Kashmiri Shah Faesal.
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( มะมะมะหมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4noyAoMa7bQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m from Pakistan 🇵🇰. I don’t know why our Pakistani Politicians want Kasmir. What ever we have, we are enable to keep it maintained.
Actually, Kashmir is profitable business for our Army and Politicians.
Being Pakistani, I think Kasmiris are much happier and free with India. Stay happy and move forward.
Civilians are victims of Militancy , we Pakistanis knows better.
U understood what 99% of brainwashed kashmiri muslims of India do not understand. Its simply an islamic brainwashing as usual. Look at comment section u wont find any Indian muslim supporting Shah Faezels decision
Yes, when most of the people of both countries will understand this then the most of the problem between India and Pakistan will solve.... Let's hope for the best
The problem starts when you refuse to speak the truth and solutiion begins when you start speaking the truth fearlessly.
Salaam hai aap jo sach keh paye..
@@rp19488 It’s true
It's NOT the exodus of Pandits, it's genocide. Great conversation!
the genocide thing is a psyop . it was not a genocide an exodus it was
Genocide ka definition pata hai? How many Pandits have lost their lives over what time period? Genocide is a myth created by RSS.
Inko ko bhi maulana ki dimag se halala marne ki hi thi.
Definition - Genocide is the intentional destruction of a people in whole or in part. Deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.@@brahm-ahamasmi
@@brahm-ahamasmisale itne joote pdenge na Mohammad k dalle 🤬🤬🤬🤬 katve genocide ko jhoot bolta h
I liked it when @Shah Faisal said that now the Government of India works like a corporate and a file has to move forward no matter what, nobody can hold it for long and do corrupt practices. It functions like a clock work. That's so nice to hear.❤❤❤
6:39 PM 02 March 2019
Shah Faesal tweets:
A Nobel Peace Prize to @ImranKhanPTI could drastically change the way Pakistan operates in the South Asia region.
IK has already "raised the bar" for leadership in the region and the Prize could encourage him to further nurture the India-Pak relation.
He deserves the prize.
ISI ki funding se political career shuru karne ki achi koshish thi but sir ko pata nhi tha k Modi-Shah kal k paida nhi hue hain.
I personally hate BJP government for reinstating people like him in services, God knows what such opportunists will do next time they get an opportunity.
@@Tughlaq-pv4ntshi kaha bro , isko kabhi maaf nhi karna tha
He knows how to flatter fatso
Highly appreciate, Mr Shah, to have understood his responsibility towards his family, Jammu And Kashmir, India, Islam and Humanity. No one is 100 % perfect in this life but the one who mends his ways during the journey of life ,is always successful. Your words are honest and will continue motivating youth not only of JK but of the entire nation. Jai Hind.⚘⚘🌻🌻🌹🌹
Such an Excellent conversation .. Mr Faesal has a guts to say what he feels like from governance to Hindu and Islamic culture to root problem in Kashmir.. Just Loved this Man... Everybody should watch this ..
This was an outstanding podcast. Interviewer asked thoughtful questions and Dr. Faesal did not deflect any question and elaborated on his views. While Dr. Faesal was speaking the interviewer did not interrupt him and allowed him to continue his trail of thoughts. This is how good podcasts are made. Dr. Faesal is a role model because no one can question his abilities and yet he admits his mistakes and willing to share his learnings openly. What a man. Thank you Vaad team for doing this. Hopefully you will invite him again
Hi Mr Professor Chaitanya, how are you
Agree
Dr Fasel is doing Al-taque
Well said indeed 👏🏼
Sir, I am from Pune, Maharashtra. I am so happy after watching your interview and views. We will make our nation great. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻. Kashmiris are our brothers and sisters.
We always accepted kashmiris as our sisters and brothers but they never accept the same thing
Wise words by wise man . Absolutely enjoyed the conversation throughout the time. Not only Kashmir but whole india needs this kind of leadership.
Whole India needs a person who said something else before and says something else now? Why you people don't think deeper? He has come to podcast to get blind followers like you.
"India" is the spelling
@@pkmitrabotanydada Tera Bernard shaw lagtavhai😅
This is the Man to whom I love to listen.
I message him about wular lake condition in 2018 & he replied and he met me the very next day on Delhi Airport.
Love You Dr.Shah Faesal From Maharashtra
Just wonderful discussion ❤
Mr.Shah Faisal free and frank conversation was very refreshing. It’s difficult to find a Muslim Scholar to talk freely on Islam. He can contribute in educating the youth about true Islam. To openly admit the shortcomings in Islam and measures to overcome them is really wonderful. Looking forward to hearing him on another occasion.
'True Islam' is slipper slope. Instead, we better have 'Indian Islam' - not even that - Kashmiri Islam, Gujarathi Islam, Bohara Islam etc. Such local identities help to define a version that is original, local and co-exists with everyone else.
'Global true Islam' will only lead to Caliphate dream sooner or later.
No body speak short coming in others.
All Credit Goes to Modi Government who made it Possible from a Stone Pelting to Giving Pen 🖋 in the Hand of Youngsters.
💯 willingness to take tough decisions. Imagine what the risk factors were? Could have been political suicide.
But he became IAS topper in congress era.
Shah Faisal is speaking from the heart Being an intelligent and upright person he is presenting the true picture of ground realities of the Kashmir He has excellent knowledge of the fabrics of kashmiri society.
Kashmir society is nothing without kashmiri pandit ; if kashmiri pandit did not settle than kashmiri muslims has no right to talk about kashmiri culture
Kashmiri pandit were living in kashmir before islam ever come to India; due to islam kashmiri pandit had to face massive genocide and exodus ; all temples in kashmir is destroyed
He is reconstructing the impression. You must see the interview he gave to UK media. He was out politics and he was only harming the india.
He cant be trusted
Saanmp hain ye ...
abhi bhi tumsbko shatrubodh nhi h
@@leaderofmassexactly. Very disappointed he called this snake
IAS Topper himself realised this late in his life….. Very difficult for common people to understand this in depth… Understanding India is not easy and is not everyone’s ☕️
Great 👍👌 ok
IAS topper, That too from Kashmir itself, that too someone who lost his father to terror. It indeed is not an easy and straightforward problem to solve.
Kahani kuch or h samjho😅😅😅😅jo sun rhe ho wo pura sachai nhi h
He did not realised late..... He tried to become ultimate opportunist.... milk the situation and become political leader. He knew exactly that he was slowly creating the image of cult leader in the eyes of kashmiris, the leader with separatist views which later would win him the post of chief minister of the state(the ultimate power). But Modi govt threw the cold water on his plans and instead he was trapped in his own plan. Now you are seeing the modified version of him(mind you he is still the same with separatist view). He will show his true colours again the minute modi govt will be thrown out of the power.
Burden of true knowledge and disillusionment of popular activism is an antidote for status quo maintained by UN who upholds under the pressure of absolute aggressors. India is free of Article 370, and it took over 70 years, tells us about efficiency of upholders of democracy.
Dr. Faesal when topped UPSC, i heard his interview in DD National. He has come a long way since then.
Its great to know that he accepted his wrong believes for Article 370 and 35A openly in public forum. It require some guts to say that. I am sure he will contribute a lot to build new india.
Good work by team Samvaad!!
Best ever podcast in ur channel Shah faesal ❣️
Modi has made it possible, and most importantly, Kashmiri people have shown great will to leave the dark past behind . ..😊
When will Modi resettle Kashmiri Hindus, rebuild Hindu temples and change demographics of the valley?
@tushargoyal554 Intentions are there....Glass is at least half full.....That too will happen.....Only Modi will do.....there are parties out there who are swearing to bring back 370 forget about Kashmiri Pandit rehabilitation.
@@Shri_Ji__ What's the benefit of removing 370?
@tushargoyal554 An IAS topper from Kashmir is iterating its benefit.....i cannot add anything more....Please rewatch the video. Peace
@@Shri_Ji__ I don't find any real life benefits other than rhetorics. IAS topper isn't doesn't make a person God, stop worshipping humans and start worshipping Sri Ramchandraji.
Thanks faesal sir for choosing to be an IAS. This country needs officers like you.
He changed sides after seeing strict actions by government in Kashmir ...Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!!
And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
@@abhishek_singh9what do you want us yo do ? Cancel him for life? Atleast he's trying to give a good message to Kashmiris
@@abhishek_singh9they are in pressure of government, please if u fully don't accept kashmiri then why we want Kashmir 😊
@@tushar4506 Did he ever said that he regrets his past decisions or apologize for his actions ... Did he ever shown Sympathy for Kashmiri Hidus..... If not then .You're just delusional without "Shatru-Bodh" . ... Because of people like you ... they will betray us again and again... And we will always be doomed to repeat history ..
@@abhishek_singh9or else Modi sent him to beds with tukde tukde gang ...
When he talked about what his father used to say " India badi great nation hai, isase takrana mat" it gave me goosebumps. Also my eyes were filled up with tears simultaneously ❤❤❤❤❤ My heartfelt condolences to Shah's father. May he get a place in Jannat .
same feeling!
same feeling!
Bhai tum Hindu ho
Tum apne concepts kyu badal dete ho kisi Muslim k liye baat karte hue
Jannat, Allah ka kya logic hai ?
@@Nationalist04 bhai muslman ko swarag me entry nhi milti 😢
Ye Jannat kya hota hai..behn k loude
I'm from Jammu. I'd very honest, I used to hate Shah Faisal, now i'm a big fan of him. What an intellectual and well informed and well read mind. Huge Respect Faisal. :)
इससे बढ़िया संवाद कश्मीर के बारे में मैने कभी नही सुना। फैजल साहब ने जब इस्तीफा दिया था मुझे बहुत दुख हुआ था। उनके वापस आने से बहुत खुशी हुई। बहुत सी नई बाते पता चली, खास तौर पर जो उन्होंने कहा कि आज कश्मीरी स्कूलों में अधूरी पढ़ाई कराई जा रही है। मुस्लिम सूफियों को ऋषि बोला जाता था। काश कश्मीर फिर पहले जैसा माहौल तैयार हो और फिर से वहां पहले जैसी रौनक लौट आए।
THANK YOU Shah Faesal for insight of J&K. Just hope every Pakistani watch this program and learn from actual people who suffered and survived last 35 years of terrorism in J&K.
Whether Shah Faisal was honest then or now doesn't matter much. What matters is what a person of his position says in public. From that perspective, this interview is a landmark interview. 👍
Just Imagine the gut it takes to openly accept and move on from the things as they are.. heavily enlightening.. ❤❤
It takes courage to be this honest to ourselves and to the world.... Today I understands him better... Don't know why but I was contemplating about my life and my inner self while listening to the sir.... I just loved this podcast and will watch it again....
Sir,kudos to your maturity, thoughts and acceptance.
I have seen a lot of people but they never accept their mistakes.
You are an inspiration for the younger generation.
I personally believe every Indian brother and sister must watch this podcast.
Thank you Vaad and thank you Shah Faesal Bhai. 🙏
I have lived in Srinagar for 3+ years, had several Kashmiri youths including few Pandits working with me. I was surprised to listen how they hated terrorists and were utterly helpless.
Most muslims support terrorists
If they would have hated terrorists, the Hindus would never have to leave the valley. Stop romanticizing things and smell the coffee.
Kashmiris hate terrorist Indian army
Stop this fake propaganda.
@@theinfotube4078 Why? How do you know it's fake?
We are really happy to listen to a real Kashmiri indian saying the truth. He is a precious jewel Modi- Shah recognised and reinstated in the government. Thanks to you for the interview.
He changed sides after seeing strick actions by government in Kashmir ... Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!!
And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
Very excellent podcast.. eye opening n insightful especially for every Indian muslim youths ❤❤❤
Once I was so disappointed in him and this day I lay all my reverence for this gentleman. Spectacular explanation of a complex issues. Godspeed to you Dr Faesal.
He is really a good human, an inspiration for UPSC aspirants, bhai please bring him back one more time.
What inspiration you got from him for UPSC? That utter toxic things about country and crawl afterwards to get the job?
He changed sides after seeing strick actions by government in Kashmir ... Before He was in beds with separatists and Shela Rashid's Tukde Tukde gang......!!!!!!!!
And only Hindus can fall for such things.. 😂 He will change side again if government loses grips in Kashmir.
अर्थ शुचिता जीवन की सबसे बड़ी शुचिता है। ईमानदारी को मूल्य के रूप में स्वीकार करने के लिए अभिनंदन। यह मूल्य जिसके पास हो, उसका आत्मा पतित नहीं होता है। बधाई, शाह जी।
You must see the interview he gave to UK media
@@VikashKumar-st3qx You are lucky in being born on the correct side he was born in the wrong environment, i Salute him for being able to introspect and correct his path. Not many people can do it. I doubt you and i could do it.
@@deepakthirdreich wheather he has corrected or lying that is different point of discussion. But we as a nation had incured the losses because of this man. I request you to watch hi UK media interview then you wipl get his real face. "Values never changes"
Faesal Saab, I am from Jammu and working in delhi. I also belongs to minority from Jammu. I can understand from the core of my heart what you are talking about. I loved your sincerity. But I would love to have more comments from my Kashmiri brethren 🙏
I am from kashmiri and this clown is saying all this to impress bjp..
I am from Barmer Rajasthan. Invite Dr. Faisal again.
I have a mindset about this man due to some pre 370 statement of him that he was also part of separatist ecosystem.
After this podcast he successfully vanished this out of mine.
My vicinity also shares a border with Pakistan and facing similar drugs problems.
May his insights of Kashmir can help about similar problems.
Also how social media radicalisation can be controlled.
Wow...this is top class conversation...Faesal Shah is a real example of a well educated person who understands the difference between bad and best.
Awesome interview. He has become a fully transformed person. Nice to see such composed and articulate views of Shah Faesal.
You can't reform these people. He is having some agenda.
Thanks to guest and host ! ..for a wonderful conversation . Conversations like this bridge gaps , remove rhetoric and hope to move together ahead
Yes he knows which way the wind is blowing now so he has adapted. I don't trust Muslim leaders in Kashmir after what they did to Hindus in 1990.
I have watched Shah Faesal's two interviews todays back to back. It was a pleasure listening to him.
Impressive! I'm truly impressed by how gracefully he acknowledges and rectifies his mistakes. A person of remarkable talent with engaging, knowledgeable conversations. Left me inspired and eager to reconnect.
Thanks for being honest , Mr Faisal . I met with you at CP New Delhi after you left IAS and aspired for politics. I told you that you Can’t change the situation of Kashmir without India and Indians. I am happy that you realised it soon.
- Abhinav Chhimwal
I'm from Maharashtra..
Shah Faisal is my inspiration for civil services, but when he opposed 370 revocation and formed JKPM for it, I was heavily disappointed, even my friends were taunting me for he being my inspiration.
When he came to realise reality and changed his thoughts with introspection, he again has become my favourite!
Kudos to you Shah sir! ❤
It just shows how gullible u r
Where are you from?
Modiji ni sarvanchi Akal thekana var aanli ahe ...❤❤❤
Very enlightening discussion. He has matured so much over the period. India is blessed to have him 👍🏻
Liked the conversation very much in a relaxed and pleasant way. Excited to hear more about upbringing and life in general in Kashmir specifically for you before and after the horror of nineties. Also life and philosophy.
He is just another one. Just like Bittu. If he is one change. Ask the bitter truth, like
why Kashmir Hindus genocide happened in Kashmir?
Why he still now not able to understand the sufferings of Hindu?
@@BharathiFromSouthModi doesn't recognize the genocide of Hindus in Kashmir and you want to hear recognition from a mere government officer?
@@tushargoyal554 why Modi, can't you ask? As your mouth stuck with the stone. Are you Moran or acting like stupid
@@aviator9985 Recent govt papers term the genocide of Hindus in Kashmir as 'migration'. Modi is busy in appeasing Muslims just like Congress.
पूरा संवाद बहुत ही रोचक व सुलझा हुआ है।
भगवान से प्रार्थना है कि कश्मीर के लोगों को ये तथ्य जल्दी से जल्दी समझ में आ जाएं,
जिससे वे अपनी ज़िंदगी को खुशहाल बनाने व देश को आगे बढ़ाने में सहायक बन पाएं।
Sir maine aapki soch ko Salam karta hn aapki baaten sun k meri aankhe khul gai aur apke papa मास्टर जी को मैं अपने दिल से सैल्यूट करता हूं जिनकी शिक्षा से आप इतने अच्छे विचारवान बने है ।
आप जैसे लोगों की वजह से आपके विचारों से
ही कश्मीर एक बार जरूर भारत का सिरमोर बनेगा।
Mr. Shah Faesal sir, I am highly impressed and deeply motivated by witnessing your personality. It takes a tremendous amount of courage to accept one's wrong-doings, amend them and have the determination to walk on the right path. You are a torch-bearer to not only Kashmiri youth but the youth of our India. The sense of clarity and the values of Kashmiriyat which are instilled in you, I pray that the same set of knowledge gets imbibed in us. Wishing you the best of luck in all your future endeavors and may god watch over you always. Thanks a lot for being a part of this podcast. Expecting you again soon!
I'm youth, 24 years old. He's not my torch-bearer. Stop simping on snakes like him.
where was Kashmiriyat in 1990 when his people threw Hindus out?
Respect to Shah Faesal. What an awesome comeback... In fact he is very lucky as life seldom gives back both together to anyone, a second chance as well as people at top who can understand. Very nice podcast
He is 200% honest. Listening to him is like listening to a spiritual person. I really liked the part where he confessed that he wanted to be detained and where he called multiple people and they thought he was calling them for his family.
He is 100% transparent !!!
Never seen anyone like him 🙏🙏
डॉ. शाह फैसल सच मे सच्चे दार्शनिक है। एक बात तो तय है इस साक्षात्कार को जो भी सुनना प्रारंभ करेगा वो बीच मे छोड़ कर बिल्कुल भी नही जाएगा। आप इस देश की तरक्की में जो योगदान दे रहे हो वो एक दिन जरूर रंग लायेगा। मैं तो आपकी स्वतंत्र सोच को देखकर बड़ा खुश हुआ हूं।
Fantastic man...truly travelled a long distance in his life. Whoever let him come back to IAS after his stint with politics, did the best job...such people will be bringing so much positivity in that part of the world.
So refreshing to see someone in the public sphere being so vulnerable and candid. 😊
Thanks for great podcasts. Enjoyed the ones with Dr. Niraj Rai, Dr. Meenakshi Jain and of course this one. Keep doing the great work 🙏🙏
Bhai upi kiya Kar.. 40 % percentage youtube rakh lega tera
@@bv6168 Ohh. Didn't know it. Will keep it in mind for next time 👍
@@Beyond_Usual 👍👍
Such a humble and intelligent man.his words are like poetry.thx a lot for the podcast.may kashmir stays calm as his words
It's so satisfying to hear such honest conversation, from such a person, who has been an inspiration to many in this country. Not only as a Govt. Officer, but as a human being, he was able to acknowledge his mistakes, and move on in life, which needs a lot of guts. What an enlightening conversation. Waiting to listen more from him
One of the best, open, genuine and thoughtful and insightful conversations i thought. As a person who has been on all sides of the case, he was so convincing and comprehensive in many ways about it.
Very honest and Frank views about the situation of Kashmir and the people of Kashmir expressed by Mr.Shah Fesal....as an Indian we are proud of such a knowledgeable person being in service of nation. Very intricately he explained the past and present of Kashmir. All the Best sir.
We Hindus are so gullible. It’s a pity. I can’t believe that a IAS topper does not know what exactly 370 is. He is very clever.
Isse adhik to hinduo ki tipniyan padh kar aa raha hai.
Ye I also noticed barrage of compliments in comment section, he is politically motivated.
We are Not gullible.. But dumb.
He knows everything
Hmm ! But it's also a fact that many of us now can understand what is being said n not said . And how it is being said . But koi nei! Mara mara kahte kahte hi Rama Rama hoga . Aur koi rasta hai inn green * on ke paas ?
He is clever about what politicians do he was ex upsc then started career in a political career then all of sudden 370 removed now he is acting like being innocent bechara ban Raha hai clever fox
Why are there only 90 thousand-ish views for this ? This deserves to be spread and shared with every living person who has any view on Kashmir across the globe.
Absolutely outstanding questions and even better answers. The nuance and depth of the answers are just breathtaking. This is what Kashmir and Kashmiris need more of !
He lost elections and then thought IAS wud be better option. Now he can easily penetrate Indian administrative system and leak information.
One of the very few high class and at the same time candid interviews that i have so far gone through. Eagerly waiting for the next episode.Thanks!
Iam from Kashmir and always had a very sad feeling that my motherland is suffering from some kind of metastatic carcinoma with no cure or hope of getting better.With this podcast after long time i saw a bit of hope for my motherland .Thanks for everything
Oo you have found hope after watching this man's podcast , sry I should not even comment here because the cops are authorised to track social media freely , rest you understand dear.
Shah Faesal, What a genuine guy. Maza aa gaya . Thanks Vaad for bringing us this conversation.
I am very much impressed with Mr Shah Faesal's views on Islam Sir .I am a retired surgeon, I want to have some personal communication with him, but I think it is not possible, hence I wish you more podcasts with him in future.thanking you .🙏🙏
His views on i-slam are romanticized - not based on scripture or reality
It is absolutely delightful to listen to Shah Faisal 2.0 - he is a walking proof how enlightenment and knowledge helps one accept the prevailing truths and reconcile with one's notions implanted wrongly or by wrong people. Hope he continues to talk on various podcasts and s able to catalyse the changes necessary for the growth, development, prosperity and peace of JnK. May Maa Sharda Shakti bless him with joys, courage, great ideas ...Jai Hind
@ Vaad - thanks for your brilliant work bhai.
खुद की गलती स्वीकार कराना ऑर आगे चलना ए दिखणे मे बहोत सिंपल हैं लेकीन ये बहोत असान नही होता.Thous who have high morals only they can do it. Very happy that you have accepted it.
FAISAL SIR U R THE INSPIRATION OF YOUTH PARTICULARLY KASHMIRI YOUTH. TAKE UR EVERY DECISIONS RATIONALY.
Shah Faesal denies the Kashmiri genocide. He uses the words "exodus", "migration" "jaana pada". He also skirts around the question of Islam being the cause of most of the problems there. An attempt to press harder should have been done.
One of the best interview I have seen recent times
Although he got his job back due to a Hindu Govt but his has to please his Aka who are islamic extremists
You're just being harsh
Change after experimenting life is always worth sharing.......it is a long journey of tests and examinations......time alone will uncover the mystery of future.
Shah Faisal has a big task ahead....hope he shows up commitment strong enough to deliver at the right time......!
This was such an enriching and deep experience listen to Me Shah Faesal Sir… would love to hear him once more👏👏
Wonderful conversation!
Mr Shah Faesal you are an Icon of India! This kind of positivity is what we need ! Please come back on podcast for more such vaad samvaad !
What an incredible interview!!! Thank you Vaad 🙏
It’s not that often we get to hear firsthand account of locals. Thank you Mr. Faesal 🙏
Very very interactive discussion . Got to know another perspective on Kashmir issue. Listening to Shah Faesal gave us hope that our Kashmir has bright future , just like the rest of India .
Excellent conversation.... I feel extremely proud as an Indian ki Shah Faisal jaisa bright star hum duniya ko uphaardiya hai..... really a bright star who can flourish in any subject of his choice in any corner of the world....may God bless him, may you reach your true potential 🙏
Bas , iniki aisi hi meethi baato me aake katwate hain hindu
What a podcast!
So smooth and non controversial. Would like to hear more from him😊
Shah Faesal thanks for sharing your U Turn.. many of us have our own U Turns which is bold to accept as it reflects we have a strong quality which is to reflect and analyse the impact we have through this life. You had yours you understood you accepted and you have the ability to talk about it. Many of us would die a million deaths to even talk of it due to public shame and fear of being isolated. But being able to talk and giving your experience and process to come to terms with it gives many the courage to do it. Your thoughts are so clear reflecting true thought given to it.
Shah Faisal is a blessed man with an extraordinary honesty. He has long way to go and has a great calling waiting for him. Intelligence - honesty - humility is a great human combination.
Bring him back... This is fantastic stuff!! I never imagined i would see this day...
Badhiya conversation. Always good to listen to perspectives from locals
संवाद से आग्रह है कि ईमानदारी वाले वाक्य की एक अलग क्लिपिंग बनाकर शेयर करें, इसकी समाज को बड़ी आवश्यकता है।
शाह फैसल द्वारा दिए गए इस इंटरव्यू में हमें कुछ चीजों की जानकारी विशिष्ट तरीके से मिलती है | 370 के बाद में किस प्रकार से कश्मीर के हालात बदल गए और साथ ही किस प्रकार से पाकिस्तान ने यहां पर इस्लाम के नाम पर चरम पथ को फैलाया...... यह बात बहुत ताकतवर शाह फैसल को बना देती है कि उनमें अपनी गलती स्वीकार करने की एक जबरदस्त ताकत है इस इंटरव्यू के बाद में कह सकता हूं शाह फैसल एक शानदार व्यक्तित्व के धनी है वैसे लोग भारत सरकार में होना हम सभी लोगों के लिए सौभाग्य की बात है..... शाह फैसल जैसे पक्के ईमान वाला शायद ही अरब मुल्क में मिले...we love u bro❤😍... मैं तो व्यक्तिगत रूप से चाहूंगा आप जैसे व्यक्ति आगे चलकर पॉलिटिक्स में जरूर जाए
This is an Extremely candid discussion. Mr.Shah Faesal is a true intellectual and espoused various problems encountered by Kashmir. Delighted to hear a genuine conversation that is loaded with philosophical and inner reflection revelations. On the whole It is an inspiring and organised podcast
Thank you Shahji. Wish you share your wealth of knowledge with many more aspiring young minds
Very nice interview. He is an IAS officer and undoubtedly knowledgeable. Might be, by this conversation, when it will reach to large audience, people who are misguided will realise to make an U turn to work for the Nation, to know the notion of nationality.
I did not know Shah Faesal's father was killed by LET millitants, very sad that he had to go through this. And I feel very proud that people like him are still there in the nation, who inspite of their hardships become the best in what they do. Please bring him again :)
It wud have been a lot of international media coverage if his fatther was killed by Indian army and u wud have known it right at that time and the news wud have echoed again and again
Fantastic podcast; Dr. Shah Faesal has earned my respect back….
Don't be in trap of Al Taqiaya
One of the great conversations I heard and will love to hear him again!
I like the integrity of Shah Faisal.
It takes genuine courage to accept mistakes. I think as a nation, we should forgive him for his mistakes.
This time, if he does anything in good faith or joins politics post retirement, i will vote/support him. I wish he leads kashmiri as an intellectual in future.
Now he is a true son of India & may be he can serve our nation better.
❤
1:02:02 ❤❤❤
This qtn is what you came for
His answer to the question of- future of religion in kashmir was
Basically- kashmir's sense of islam isn't that radical, it's closer to Hinduism.
My opinion is, he has a hope that islam of kashmir will tone down, and become less vicious with koshish of the government, therby, a day when pandits can return and everything canngo hand in hand.
Reality is that, there is islam can't accept anyone if it's majority.
And that's the sad reality.
While he has a good heart, he's slightly impractical.
I straddle both liberal and Hindutva worlds. My honest opinion is that Liberals don't understand institutional Islam and Hindutva does not understand Muslim modernity.
Faesal feels like a Muslim modernist, he wants to create a post Kemalist vision of Islamic society. While the Turks had no history to fall back upon, he realises that Kashmir has a pre-Islamic high culture.
I will gauge him on how successful he is in developing and propagating it. Only then can we have a fair assessment.
@@rutvikrs Turkish log keval Turkikarit Anatolians hain. Ottoman sultanat ke pehle bhi unki ek sanskriti thi aur uske pehle bhi sainkdon varshon se unke yahaan sanskriti rahi hai. Woh chahe toh use dobaara laa sakte hain.
@@kanhaibhatt913 unki sanskriti thi par unki high culture nahi thi. Aaj ke daur me tribal religions aur woh bhi warrior/headhunting/ethno/terra centric religion ka khaas application nahi raha. Unka religion shayad tengrism raha hoga jo khud Mongolia me bohot Kam ho gaya hai(most Mongols are Buddhist today).
Wapis jaane ka utna hi use hai jitna ek Hindu Indra ya Kuber ki Aaj direct Pooja kare. Hinduism has moved beyond its philosophical roots. Hum shayad iklote hai Jo unki reference Aaj bhi karte hai.
@@rutvikrs mai Anatolian logon ki baat kar raha hun. Turkey ke log Turk abhi abhi bane. Woh pehle Byzantine the, uske pehle Roman, uske pehle Greek, uske pehle Lydian.
@@kanhaibhatt913 toh baat kahi aur chali gayi, topic pe nahi rahi
Very few who can understand the deepness of his conversation.i was very negative about this officer but he opened my eyes.he cleared my alk doubts which I had .I am a nationalist.i got great transparesy.great podcast.👍👍👏👏❣️
Once my project manager told me “if you want to be successful, you should fail earlier in your life. If you dont fail, cost of failure will be too much at later stages and that you can’t handle because you didn’t learn earlier”
Excellent Excellent
A truely agree......as I left job because I need a break and want to regain myself.And currently because of tough market it is getting difficulty to get job. But inside Im solid because it's a phase of life and it shall pass......but society scavenge on your unemployment that adds on more when you are married too..😂
Great, 👍👍👍
Kya khoob kahi 👏
I had been an IAS aspirant and watched Mr.faisals videos before starting preparation. I was so impressed by him and admired him like a God. I followed him on FB but offlately, his continuous negative biased opinions disheartened me so much that I unfollwed him. It even changed my perception about a particular community, that they can not be Nationalist.
Today again i am quite impressed by his personality. Sir you have great intellect, please stay positive and true to your country.
I am from JK. I feel Shah speak from his heart ❤️. Accepting ur mistakes is a big thing which hardly our politicians do..
My goodness!!! This guy is gem of knowledge. I am glad the future of India is in such bright hands.
Also, it requires a spine of steel to accept things in public as a public servant. I must accept I was wrong about him few years back. And I set to correct my view of him.
Nation requires paltus like him? God bless you and your country.
@@tushargoyal554 With due respect, I, myself is an IITian who work in rural areas for the upliftment of education on personal basis by leaving corporate job some years back. I do recognize someone who are high degree of National pride within his heart. I can see a high degree of Integrity in him.
I wish more and more such youth come forward for Bhárat and help it reach the past spiritual and material glories.
@@nahopyga There's no need to brag about IIT. I'm however not from IIT but working in one of the top companies in the world which is also normal, I don't brag about it.
National pride without any recognition is useless. The upper-castes are treated like Jews here and I don't want to leave my job for corrupt Indian state that doesn't treat me with dignity.
@@tushargoyal554 Yet you bragged.
The mobile that you used to told about your views on caste system is part of the technology we built for the world.
And it's okay to brag when it's helping my nation go forward. Also, I belong from upper caste, didn't blame the system just entered one of the pioneer institute with shere effort.
Don't use your victim card narrative to paint everything same.
@@nahopyga Had to else you'd keep flexing your IIT tag.
Mobiles phones! Okay, completely irrelevant thing. Anyways, who are 'we' here? Did you or India build it?
Lol, I'm playing victim? Damn, no! It's the low-castes who play victim all the time and Indian state is helping them by demonizing upper-castes and snatching away resources.
To be very honest, your entire comment was filled with irrelevant rhetorics. Why should I contribute to the country that has given me nothing but hate?
Excellent, very informative and motivational conversation...thanks.
Kudos to you Sir for very informative discussion 🎉🎉 Salute! Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Vande Matram!
Before I started I was of a different opinion about Mr. Faesal, but after 2 minutes into the podcast, had me stuck to view it complete. Very Candid and humble replies. A person who accepts his mistakes openheartedly is a great human being. God Bless you Faesal and may you give your best to our great Nation...
Such an inspiring conversation. ...eagerly waiting for his next interview 😊
Great conversation by Shah. Excellent feeling to hear an enlightened concept taking shape and assimilate back to the realm of Advaita origins and and part of hindusthan as always had been. ❤❤
Kudos to Vaad team, for this extremely well conducted podcast of Shah Faesal. Also Huge Respect to Kashmiri Shah Faesal for his enlightening views. It has completely changed my view of Shah Faesal. Kudos to GOI for reinstating Shah Faesal I am sure he will do more to impress his views on J&K in future. Bharat needs more Kashmiri's like Shah Faesal.
Congratulations to VAAD team for pulling off this brilliant podcast and a pure from the heart podcast by a Kashmiri Shah Faesal.
Shah Faesal absolutely Great 👍 👌 ❤absolutely wonderful podcast, I will love to see him again, thanks again Jai Hind 🙏🙏💐💐
Thank you Faisal. You cleared a lot of things.
Great to have you on our side..