Kashmiri IAS Officer Shah Faesel Reacts to Article 370 | Dostcast
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ค. 2024
- IAS Shah Faesal is the 2009 topper of the UPSC civil services exam, the first Kashmiri to do so. He has since gone on to briefly become a politician and a niche public figure. In this episode, he talks about:
-The effects of the abrogation of Article 370
-The link between Bangladesh’s independence and terrorism in Kashmir
-His faith in evidence-based policy making
You can follow him on his socials:
Twitter: / shahfaesal
Timestamps
0:00 - Intro
1:39 - Faesal is a Fulbright scholar
5:32 - Lessons from Kennedy School of government
7:00 - The magic of evidence-based decision making
12:05 - Running experiments in policy-making
15:10 - Failure needs to be socially accepted
20:47 - Flattery is ingrained in Indian society
24:07 - What made him leave his service?
26:20 - Is the Lolab Valley really that beautiful?
29:18 - Growing up during the start of terrorism in Kashmir
33:05 - Interference in Kashmir is fundamental to Pakistan’s policy
40:45 - People don’t know the history of article 370
50:15 - A glimpse of post-article 370 abrogation Kashmir
58:00 - Kashmir’s destiny was decided in ‘47
1:01:47 - Why do people oppose the abrogation of Article 370?
1:06:40 - Does Faesal feel like he’s obligated to talk about Kashmir?
1:11:35 - How is working in a ministry different from administering a district?
1:12:14 - Formal education needs to focus on philosophy
1:16:22 - The importance of good mentors
1:18:46 - UPSC is a test of mental fortitude
1:26:45 - Conclusion
Listen to the audio version of the full podcasts at -
Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/70vrbHe...
Google Podcast - podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
Apple Podcast - podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast...
==
This is the official channel for Dostcast, a podcast by Vinamre Kasanaa.
Connect with me
Instagram: / vinamrekasanaa
Twitter: / vinamrekasanaa
Dostcast on Instagram: / dostcast
Dostcast on Facebook: / dostcast
Dostcast on Snapchat: / dostcast
==
Contact Us
For business inquiries: dostcast@egiplay.com
==
#Dostcast
Visit: propodcaster.co and get access to Pro Podcaster Tools and start your podcasting journey right now.
The fact that he accepts flaws in his own prior understandings and shows flexibility in his views backed by logic and reason really impresses me. It's such a delight. A really good person. Need more of them.
It's the mark of a person with a 'growth mindset'. What doesn't accept new just because of being 'new' will become stale.
He still owes to people from whom he collected money in the name of making his own party'
@@golden8519 please elaborate.
6:39 PM 02 March 2019
Shah Faesal tweets:
A Nobel Peace Prize to @ImranKhanPTI could drastically change the way Pakistan operates in the South Asia region.
IK has already "raised the bar" for leadership in the region and the Prize could encourage him to further nurture the India-Pak relation.
He deserves the prize.
ISI ki funding se political career shuru karne ki achi koshish thi but sir ko pata nhi tha k Modi-Shah kal k paida nhi hue hain.
I personally hate BJP government for reinstating people like him in services, God knows what such opportunists will do next time they get an opportunity.
When Bharatiy went out they didn't have ReLigion, they had Sanatan Dharma. ReLigion was invented much later (10s of thousands of years later) in Mideast by Romans 1600 years back to divide and enslave natives by hijacking Jewish theology and inventing last Prophet called Jesus/Yeshu. Romans started new gang/legion members by giving them plum postings in their court and as tax collectors. They gave license to their gang members to keep Jews and others as slaves. These house slaves joined Christianity gang and soon became themselves masters of slaves. To make Mideasterners not revert back to Jewishness, Romans had to infuse hate among gang members for everything native, so they made fake stories of Jews as killer of Jesus. Once the gangsters got completely rootless by cutting of Jewish roots they could be programmed with hate for all those who were not gang members. Thus the distant Europeans were labeled as heathens & pagans. Brutalized Mideasterners were used as cannon fodder by Romans to attack Europe, enslave the natives of Europe, wipe out their proud history and create an evil enslaving Roman empire.
200 years later Arabs started copying Romans, that's why Ummaids' gang could not be distinguished from Christianity and their Kibla was in Northern Jordan. This new gang was competing with older gang Christianity and so had to give more evil licences like keeping sex-slaves and keeping 80% of loot and only giving 20% to Khalifa (Godfather of the desert highway bandits' gang/legion). So all kinds of cruel, crooks & criminals joined this gang called Islam.
Persians were exhausted by constant warfare with Roman brutes and their gang, and when this new gangsters attacked them in mere 18 years Persia was completely Islamized. Islamic brutes after capturing Persian ruling seat, made a law that no Kaffir can own any property, that included wife, children, cattles and farms. Persians to keep their language and culture created a sub-gang with in Islam which we call today Shia. They used division in MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi's family and murderous fights to be khalifa. They used Khalifa politics, so there's a word called ShiaSat.
Bharat became weak because of pacifist strain of extreme Boudh & Jain. Ashoka weakened defences of Bharat. Even then, MohMadden Arabs, Turks & Iranians didn't succeed to establish MohMadden rule in Afghanistan and Eastern Iran till 13th century. Remember MohMad Bin Kasim raided Sindh Sindh & looted MoolSthan/Multan almost 700 years before. So Dharmic natives beat MohMaddens almost 60 times in those 700 years and defended the mother land. The mistake Bharatiy did was - not smashing this bandits' gang and freeing Iran, Iraq and Syria and even Arabia. One cannot coexist as neighbor with these gangsters who hate everything native and Dharmic.
This Ishtaq Jihadi should read the primary source, for that he has to learn Sanskrit but MohMadism knocks off frontal lobes of the brain and fills it with hate, thus MohMadden brain is reptilian brain. It cannot learn or create, at best it will whine & cry - no wonder rootless parasite Al Baqis are good at Shero Shayari in foreign Arabi & Farsi words which even they themselves don't understand. Al Baki anthem is also not understandable to any Paki but they sing loudly just as Ayyate of Koran, the slave manual.
What Mughal brought and gave to India is preserved by this Mughal princess www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2424410/The-Mughal-emperor-ancestor-Sultana-Begum-forced-live-slum-washes-street-struggles-feed-children.html
Maratha Peshwa who ruled till Afghan border produce en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narendra_Karmarkar
Youngest Bell Labs fellow who deserved a Noble Prize
As a Kashmiri Pandit i must say this was a really sound conversation. Worthy one.
We need such talented,balanced,self made guys in politics. They inspire. They by sheer presence,motivate , they are self made. Nepotism is a curse. Always talk of my parents,my family. Thats so boring
Being from Jammu. I am really enlightened by this wonderful conversation. we need more people like him
U r from Jammu??? Really.... U don't know about this person. He is a known Jihadi. Our Government is stupid, they have taken him back as IAS, this privilege is not for any hindu. Search about him.
So soon you people get carried away.. Without knowing about the person and his doings.
@@sbanj I agree with you but what to do when there is no honest leader for Dogras. His conversation was good but if he is playing a game like other kashmiri M Leaders then fate awaits him.
When Bharatiy went out they didn't have ReLigion, they had Sanatan Dharma. ReLigion was invented much later (10s of thousands of years later) in Mideast by Romans 1600 years back to divide and enslave natives by hijacking Jewish theology and inventing last Prophet called Jesus/Yeshu. Romans started new gang/legion members by giving them plum postings in their court and as tax collectors. They gave license to their gang members to keep Jews and others as slaves. These house slaves joined Christianity gang and soon became themselves masters of slaves. To make Mideasterners not revert back to Jewishness, Romans had to infuse hate among gang members for everything native, so they made fake stories of Jews as killer of Jesus. Once the gangsters got completely rootless by cutting of Jewish roots they could be programmed with hate for all those who were not gang members. Thus the distant Europeans were labeled as heathens & pagans. Brutalized Mideasterners were used as cannon fodder by Romans to attack Europe, enslave the natives of Europe, wipe out their proud history and create an evil enslaving Roman empire.
200 years later Arabs started copying Romans, that's why Ummaids' gang could not be distinguished from Christianity and their Kibla was in Northern Jordan. This new gang was competing with older gang Christianity and so had to give more evil licences like keeping sex-slaves and keeping 80% of loot and only giving 20% to Khalifa (Godfather of the desert highway bandits' gang/legion). So all kinds of cruel, crooks & criminals joined this gang called Islam.
Persians were exhausted by constant warfare with Roman brutes and their gang, and when this new gangsters attacked them in mere 18 years Persia was completely Islamized. Islamic brutes after capturing Persian ruling seat, made a law that no Kaffir can own any property, that included wife, children, cattles and farms. Persians to keep their language and culture created a sub-gang with in Islam which we call today Shia. They used division in MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi's family and murderous fights to be khalifa. They used Khalifa politics, so there's a word called ShiaSat.
Bharat became weak because of pacifist strain of extreme Boudh & Jain. Ashoka weakened defences of Bharat. Even then, MohMadden Arabs, Turks & Iranians didn't succeed to establish MohMadden rule in Afghanistan and Eastern Iran till 13th century. Remember MohMad Bin Kasim raided Sindh Sindh & looted MoolSthan/Multan almost 700 years before. So Dharmic natives beat MohMaddens almost 60 times in those 700 years and defended the mother land. The mistake Bharatiy did was - not smashing this bandits' gang and freeing Iran, Iraq and Syria and even Arabia. One cannot coexist as neighbor with these gangsters who hate everything native and Dharmic.
This Ishtaq Jihadi should read the primary source, for that he has to learn Sanskrit but MohMadism knocks off frontal lobes of the brain and fills it with hate, thus MohMadden brain is reptilian brain. It cannot learn or create, at best it will whine & cry - no wonder rootless parasite Al Baqis are good at Shero Shayari in foreign Arabi & Farsi words which even they themselves don't understand. Al Baki anthem is also not understandable to any Paki but they sing loudly just as Ayyate of Koran, the slave manual.
What Mughal brought and gave to India is preserved by this Mughal princess www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2424410/The-Mughal-emperor-ancestor-Sultana-Begum-forced-live-slum-washes-street-struggles-feed-children.html
Maratha Peshwa who ruled till Afghan border produce en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narendra_Karmarkar
Youngest Bell Labs fellow who deserved a Noble Prize
Wait for the day when your own country will label him as ISI agent
I was in Srinagar a few days back and at 4 AM i was woken up by a sound which i initially thought was someone singing. On paying attention, i realized it was Azaan from a nearby Mosque. Believe me, it was musical. And it definately had a spiritual feel to it, even though i could not understand a word of what was being said. It was the best Azaan i have heard in my life.
And it was in INDIAN SIDE OF KASHMIR WHERE MUSLIMS ARE PERSECUTED ACCORDING TO PAKISTAN.
For a real Indian, India resides in our heart. And by virtue of being proud Indian i feel myself as rightfully at home in Kashmir, as much in kanyakumari.
😂
Musalman manhooz log hain. They believe in jihad not secularism. They believe in ummah not India. They're the worst people in the world.
For a Muslim, religion supersedes all other identities and obligations.
@@garygeorge-wi7co they're killing their neighbors and friends
When Bharatiy went out they didn't have ReLigion, they had Sanatan Dharma. ReLigion was invented much later (10s of thousands of years later) in Mideast by Romans 1600 years back to divide and enslave natives by hijacking Jewish theology and inventing last Prophet called Jesus/Yeshu. Romans started new gang/legion members by giving them plum postings in their court and as tax collectors. They gave license to their gang members to keep Jews and others as slaves. These house slaves joined Christianity gang and soon became themselves masters of slaves. To make Mideasterners not revert back to Jewishness, Romans had to infuse hate among gang members for everything native, so they made fake stories of Jews as killer of Jesus. Once the gangsters got completely rootless by cutting of Jewish roots they could be programmed with hate for all those who were not gang members. Thus the distant Europeans were labeled as heathens & pagans. Brutalized Mideasterners were used as cannon fodder by Romans to attack Europe, enslave the natives of Europe, wipe out their proud history and create an evil enslaving Roman empire.
200 years later Arabs started copying Romans, that's why Ummaids' gang could not be distinguished from Christianity and their Kibla was in Northern Jordan. This new gang was competing with older gang Christianity and so had to give more evil licences like keeping sex-slaves and keeping 80% of loot and only giving 20% to Khalifa (Godfather of the desert highway bandits' gang/legion). So all kinds of cruel, crooks & criminals joined this gang called Islam.
Persians were exhausted by constant warfare with Roman brutes and their gang, and when this new gangsters attacked them in mere 18 years Persia was completely Islamized. Islamic brutes after capturing Persian ruling seat, made a law that no Kaffir can own any property, that included wife, children, cattles and farms. Persians to keep their language and culture created a sub-gang with in Islam which we call today Shia. They used division in MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi's family and murderous fights to be khalifa. They used Khalifa politics, so there's a word called ShiaSat.
Bharat became weak because of pacifist strain of extreme Boudh & Jain. Ashoka weakened defences of Bharat. Even then, MohMadden Arabs, Turks & Iranians didn't succeed to establish MohMadden rule in Afghanistan and Eastern Iran till 13th century. Remember MohMad Bin Kasim raided Sindh Sindh & looted MoolSthan/Multan almost 700 years before. So Dharmic natives beat MohMaddens almost 60 times in those 700 years and defended the mother land. The mistake Bharatiy did was - not smashing this bandits' gang and freeing Iran, Iraq and Syria and even Arabia. One cannot coexist as neighbor with these gangsters who hate everything native and Dharmic.
This Ishtaq Jihadi should read the primary source, for that he has to learn Sanskrit but MohMadism knocks off frontal lobes of the brain and fills it with hate, thus MohMadden brain is reptilian brain. It cannot learn or create, at best it will whine & cry - no wonder rootless parasite Al Baqis are good at Shero Shayari in foreign Arabi & Farsi words which even they themselves don't understand. Al Baki anthem is also not understandable to any Paki but they sing loudly just as Ayyate of Koran, the slave manual.
What Mughal brought and gave to India is preserved by this Mughal princess www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2424410/The-Mughal-emperor-ancestor-Sultana-Begum-forced-live-slum-washes-street-struggles-feed-children.html
Maratha Peshwa who ruled till Afghan border produce en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narendra_Karmarkar
Youngest Bell Labs fellow who deserved a Noble Prize
Huge respect to Shah Faesal sir. As a resident of Jammu division of Jammu & Kashmir I am first time watching a prominent kashmiri person speaking with such clear facts and ideas as it requires alot of courage to speak such true facts about kashmir by a kashmiri himself and it surely shows that our kashmir has changed and will keep on growing further if more and more kashmiri youth also understand your idea and quit radicalism. Jai Hind🇮🇳
6:39 PM 02 March 2019
Shah Faesal tweets:
A Nobel Peace Prize to @ImranKhanPTI could drastically change the way Pakistan operates in the South Asia region.
IK has already "raised the bar" for leadership in the region and the Prize could encourage him to further nurture the India-Pak relation.
He deserves the prize.
ISI ki funding se political career shuru karne ki achi koshish thi but sir ko pata nhi tha k Modi-Shah kal k paida nhi hue hain.
I personally hate BJP government for reinstating people like him in services, God knows what such opportunists will do next time they get an opportunity.
@@Tughlaq-pv4nt we cannot say anything about that acts of him may be he was lying then and may be he is lying now. May be he was playing the role of double agent then in favour of us and be may be he is playing a double agent role now against us. But i am sure that our govt and intelligence agencies are not dumb to ignore such acts of him and reinstate him as a IAS officer again. So, in my view his chances of being a radical or pro seperatist is very low.
When Bharatiy went out they didn't have ReLigion, they had Sanatan Dharma. ReLigion was invented much later (10s of thousands of years later) in Mideast by Romans 1600 years back to divide and enslave natives by hijacking Jewish theology and inventing last Prophet called Jesus/Yeshu. Romans started new gang/legion members by giving them plum postings in their court and as tax collectors. They gave license to their gang members to keep Jews and others as slaves. These house slaves joined Christianity gang and soon became themselves masters of slaves. To make Mideasterners not revert back to Jewishness, Romans had to infuse hate among gang members for everything native, so they made fake stories of Jews as killer of Jesus. Once the gangsters got completely rootless by cutting of Jewish roots they could be programmed with hate for all those who were not gang members. Thus the distant Europeans were labeled as heathens & pagans. Brutalized Mideasterners were used as cannon fodder by Romans to attack Europe, enslave the natives of Europe, wipe out their proud history and create an evil enslaving Roman empire.
200 years later Arabs started copying Romans, that's why Ummaids' gang could not be distinguished from Christianity and their Kibla was in Northern Jordan. This new gang was competing with older gang Christianity and so had to give more evil licences like keeping sex-slaves and keeping 80% of loot and only giving 20% to Khalifa (Godfather of the desert highway bandits' gang/legion). So all kinds of cruel, crooks & criminals joined this gang called Islam.
Persians were exhausted by constant warfare with Roman brutes and their gang, and when this new gangsters attacked them in mere 18 years Persia was completely Islamized. Islamic brutes after capturing Persian ruling seat, made a law that no Kaffir can own any property, that included wife, children, cattles and farms. Persians to keep their language and culture created a sub-gang with in Islam which we call today Shia. They used division in MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi's family and murderous fights to be khalifa. They used Khalifa politics, so there's a word called ShiaSat.
Bharat became weak because of pacifist strain of extreme Boudh & Jain. Ashoka weakened defences of Bharat. Even then, MohMadden Arabs, Turks & Iranians didn't succeed to establish MohMadden rule in Afghanistan and Eastern Iran till 13th century. Remember MohMad Bin Kasim raided Sindh Sindh & looted MoolSthan/Multan almost 700 years before. So Dharmic natives beat MohMaddens almost 60 times in those 700 years and defended the mother land. The mistake Bharatiy did was - not smashing this bandits' gang and freeing Iran, Iraq and Syria and even Arabia. One cannot coexist as neighbor with these gangsters who hate everything native and Dharmic.
This Ishtaq Jihadi should read the primary source, for that he has to learn Sanskrit but MohMadism knocks off frontal lobes of the brain and fills it with hate, thus MohMadden brain is reptilian brain. It cannot learn or create, at best it will whine & cry - no wonder rootless parasite Al Baqis are good at Shero Shayari in foreign Arabi & Farsi words which even they themselves don't understand. Al Baki anthem is also not understandable to any Paki but they sing loudly just as Ayyate of Koran, the slave manual.
What Mughal brought and gave to India is preserved by this Mughal princess www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2424410/The-Mughal-emperor-ancestor-Sultana-Begum-forced-live-slum-washes-street-struggles-feed-children.html
Maratha Peshwa who ruled till Afghan border produce en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narendra_Karmarkar
Youngest Bell Labs fellow who deserved a Noble Prize
@@raghavkhajuria4149 yeah maybe they have reinstated him so that he can be closely monitored, one has to keep one's friends close and enemy closer.
Beacuse these words suits you that's why it looks good for you ,if these things don't suit you,then your reply would be different
As a kashmiri Muslim I would say iam ab indian and I have not asked any time that iam not Indian even anyone from my family had never.we are Indians 🖤🇮🇳
It feels good to see kashmiri youths to join mainstream🎉
as a kashmiri youth i can say you are not a kashmiri. a kashmiri will.never forget the civilian killing,whole village raped,pallets,Kidnapping all done by indian army and agencies. you are not a kashmiri keep your propaganda to you self
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai Hind....
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳. You are part of India and we all are proud of our culture and diversity... Jai Hind ....
One of the greatest podcast to listen to,if you are in a dilemma. It opens your mind like 200 books merged in one and a half hour.
Agree
*hour
lol
Musalman manhooz log hain.
These people are the ones who killed their Hindu and Sikh friends and neighbors. Repugnant people
We need more and more people like him. He humbly admits past mistakes. he is true to his roots
Shah Faisal spoke so eloquently. It is amazing how clairvoyant he is at such a young age. God bless you. You are a true role model for millions of Kashmiri children. Need more people like you to spread positivity and take pride in the their Civilization. 💕
अरे chutya he's an opportunist. He can't beat govt, so he joined them
What an interview - what an honesty of Shah Faisal. Thanks to you both. Lots of learning at age 79 from Shah. Kind regards.
For a better India.
Every community should learn that relationship requires sacrifice.
That is true for Hindu, muslim and every other communities.
Rationality is defined as applying a skeptical attitude to perception of things in life.
It denotes accepting nothing at face value.
Observation, experimentation and verification are the keystones of Rationality.
In everyday life, it means adopting a scientific approach towards looking at everything, religion and religious scriptures being the most prominent among them.
Rationality was emphasised by intellectuals over the years across different societies.
In India that approach was emphasised by intellectuals like Raja Ram Mohun Roy, D.K Karve, Dr B.R.Ambedkar etc.
But while Bharat is moving ahead, a section of Bharatiya society continues to lag behind, both in their outlook and perception- Muslim citizens of our country.
Problem with Muslim citizens
Majority of Indians are not against anybody and do not favour discriminatory behaviour towards their fellow citizens.
But we cannot help but witness the problematic behaviour of our Muslim neighbours.
They are problematic because of many reasons-
Trust-The arrest of a renowned doctor Dr Adnan Ali Sarkar in a terror case in Pune by the NIA may create a fear psychosis in the minds of ordinary people.
What kind of fear psychosis?
The fear of trusting their Muslim neighbours too much lest they may backstab them under any circumstance.
Secondly, their extreme religiosity. Yes, you heard it right.
The constitution of India guarantees the right to freedom of religion under Article 25 but our Muslim brethren have taken this way too seriously.
Most of them are willing to do anything in the name of their religion, they don’t even mind proselytizing and killing their non-Muslim neighbours for religion’s sake.
Their religious fanaticism is a real problem.
Lastly, their refusal to assimilate themselves with the rest of Bharat.
India is a salad bowl when it comes to ethnicity, unity in diversity is our strength.
Unfortunately, our fellow Muslim citizens don’t seem to think that way.
The ‘you-know-who’ community refuse to sing the national anthem- Vande Mataram, refuse to chant Bharat Mata ki Jai etc.
They too don’t accept that their ethno-religious roots are the same.
They were all Hindus and not Arabs.
This fact of common lineage was confirmed by Jawaharlal Nehru in The Discovery of India.
Can they earn back the lost trust?
Given their questionable track record, it is hard for them to be trusted again.
But they can earn back the trust. How?
First of all, adopt a rational mindset, do not blindly follow your religion.
Religion is not the solution to a good life, it is an ephemeral panacea at best.
Science is the way forward.
Secondly, question your identity, who you are? What are your roots?
Adopt a rationalistic mindset and be skeptical of your religion and religious scriptures.
Question yourself this-as a modern 21st century man or woman can we blindly follow a way of life that existed in the 7th century?
Lastly, accept your Sanatan roots, jettison your Middle Eastern loyalties and learn to revel in the festivities of other religions.
Only then can you become a true Indian.
That is why there is a need of rationality for Muslims of Bharat.
Forget Muslims they never change
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 you must have different defination for the majority. There's a wide contrast between what you said and what you actually wanna said. You said, "science is the way forward", later you said Santan roots ...
@@tremendous11 what so called contrast are you claiming about?
And also what's your perceptions of majority?
@@tremendous11 Sanatan roots means the ancestral roots of every Indian irrespective of his religion. What it has to do with science ?? Seems like u are heavily offended by the word sanatan 😅.
Being from jammu kashmir, its great to see someone speaking sensible.
Now I know why he topped UPSC now ....he is a GEM...of India....we will be fortunate to have him as our leader ......very well read...and educated....
I would never have believed this side of Kashmir if not for this talk. Thanks to you both for making this possible.
As a Kashmiri pandit I hated him most...but today I m proud of him.
@susmitrapandita3489 are Kashmir Pandit able to return back to their home? Is there any chance of that because I heard some people are going back and build again their own house which was there before
@@analyticsbyram we still don't feel safe in Kashmir. What we suffered we don't want our kids go through same. Govt is working to settle down kashmiri pandits in the valley but only a few very few will return.
@@sumitrapandita3489 Okay. Hope atleast you will get back your land and do make buildings and start business there instead of staying there. Because Tourism is booming and gonna be more later on. If you guys can build something for the sake of your business there, instead of going there with whole family. That would be atleast give you guys little bit of happiness.
I really hope more & more people return to valley to their own place. Because Apna Mitti jaisa kuchh cheez nhi h.
Jai Hind. May god be with you and your family.
Native should not keep giving up their territory, "veer bhogya vasundhara" , kashmiri hindu population should re organise and should work on their own ghetto, and collectively spent atleast one month or two months in their own land. Or it's lost forever, your home, your history, the land that fed your hundred generation will be gone in one generation.
yes, because today he gave his bridle in hands of terroristic regume.
Removal of Temporary Article 370 through due constitutional parliamentary procedure has been one of the biggest historical achievement of Modi Government.
@@numaanqnsure there is a problem when people get influenced by the wrong narrative.... believe me it's going to be very positive for the future of kashmiri people and its future ❤generation..❤
@@nanireddy9018Said by non Kashmiri
@@endofworld200says a cult religion member
@@aditya_gupta says a fake religion follower
@@endofworld200so what if he is not kashmiri does it even matter we r indian first then comes the state
Hello to Shah Faesal from Dubai. Loved the interview, being a fellow Kashmiri myself a couple of years younger I’m really impressed with your thought process..
Unfortunately I only got to live in Kashmir for the first 6 years of my life. After migration I’ve heard my grandfather say the same things you spoke about Kashmiri people having lost their identity.
Having left India years back myself, I really admire your spirit of going back and giving back to the community. It’s true, money doesn’t bring meaning to life. The impact one has on society can bring all the meaning to one’s life. I hope one day there is unending peace in Kashmir and KP’s will return. I hope for the enlightenment of the masses. Thank you for the work you are doing.
First Time, I listened a sensible voice from Kashmir, who is Kashmiri himself.
So proud to see him as an Indian from Kashmir whose curtains from his eyes has gone and understanding that we all better together. His words will go far away and echo for dacades in the valley of Kashmir and millions of people's attitude towards us will change. As I have been always saying, we are one no matter what.
Indian from Kashmir? Whole pakistan is ours.
I don't know about Kashmir but Jammu has Suffered enormously after the Abrogation of Article 370 and the irony is we supported its Abrogation. Crime Rate is so high now , Infrastructure is in tatters , roads condition in cities are worse than Himalayan roads let alone villages . Jobs Creations is next to zero . Jammu and its 10 Districts have suffered the most . Neither we got our separate state nor any development
From being petitioner challenging abrogation of article 370 to accepting the change and speaking about it and taking back the petition, it can be trusted the change is real. Good to see he looks happy and satisfied. Kudos to Shah Faesal.
I have been listening shah faesal right from that time when he got selected as an ias in 2011.....he is a huge inspiration
One of the best interviews that i have listened so far. The words that like most was "rise above from smaller identities and look at larger identity as an Indian." Appreciate the work that IAS Shah Faesal sir is doing for the country and for the fellow Kashmiris to motivate and make them understand that they are part of larger civilizational history.
Mr Faesal proves that he is not only a topper in Studies but also in real life. Hats off to him. Great future awaits him and our country is fortunate to have such an young visionary administrator. A gem of a person, Mr Faesal will be the star of stars to countless youngsters.
What a delight to watch this eye opening interview!
Shah Faesal is one of the reasons I still have hope for the nation. Perspectives can change. :)
I want him to be future CM of J&K❤
No local wants lol
Wow, I didn't knew there were people like Faezal exist in kashmir .... I'm impressed 👏 👍👍
Only now he is humble should have seen him a few years ago. He was trouble .
@@baljitkler9947 He had resigned from his position, it was very easy for the government to get rid of him but the government reinstated his services. Long story short, he is a bright guy (AIR 1 in UPSC is no joke) and deserves to be given a second chance. If he can utilize his intellect positively, he can do a lot of good for himself and the state. Also it is understable what he mentioned that after his exposure to various cultures in india he realized that his culture is not unique, india is full of unique cultures. Let's hope for the best, we need bright people in India 🇮🇳 🙏 😀
@@afterburner2828 Sure we need bright people like him but he should help in some way the young in Kashmir to have open mind and the parents as well . The world is far ahead of them they live to word of the mulanas . I am happy that he realise loved the way he presented himself at the interview.
He was opposing article 370 removal started political party and failed
Now he is seeing development 🤣
@@pratik.8156 he's very suspicious, i don't buy anything he says
He has accumulated so much wisdom for the whole country to benefit from.
this man is gem of India, he got very mesmerizing personality,we need leader like him,he should not be limited to kashmir
People not just from kashmir state but from all over India should listen him between 29 min to 1hr 10 min.
Indeed a good episode watched till date.
PS:- watch this episode with 2x will save your time.
As a Kashmiri i can say he speaks facts. he did some mistakes but he is young and a has high potential to bring changes in J&K
Neer ho cxur dalè sind cxur dalla
@@cnopyAbe dalle bhag ja yaha se bhikharistan
@@cnopy nerr ladnav benni miltants att.
@@cnopy chup dalle beharri
@@cnopy halala ki gndi paidash 😂
This man is an exemplary example of what education can do to oneself. 👏👏
Good education is a remedy to most social/religious acrimonies.
He is an outlier , not an average .
As a cultural secretary u have been doing a grate work in emphasizing Kashmiri culture and it's relationship with Indian civilization....and you word that you embrace Indian identity beyond any other identity....we need people like you to connect back our kashmiri families back to us
Kudos for bringing him here. So much to learn from him. We need to add some sophistication into the minds of Indian youth for true progress..
I am glad that young Kashmiris have such an erudite and articulate role model to emulate.... I am very hopeful that his legacy will steer many of them to success and excellence
So wonderful and realistic details of Kashmir presented by Mr Shah. He is very neutral in his delivery of his views. I have not seen such a polished officer who is fairl to all.
Thank you for this podcast. It really touched me from 1hr 9min to 1 hr 13 min..he said as an proud Indian everything is so pure .
Applaud for his honesty with his conscience and with the nation.
I never knew of Mr Shah Faisal and every minute of listening to his composed talk was a joy! This podcast must reach every citizen and esp Muslims of this country. And I just recalled Mr Farooq Abdhullah’s banter in parliament couple of days back. Never to believe such politicians who battered J&K all these years.
Woww. Thank you for doing this podcast, Sir. I graduated as your contemporary and have always been influenced by your thoughts since I was in college. Hearing you today makes me so thrilled and certain that our country is on the right track. Thank you so much for everything 🙇♂️
was quite astonished to see a kashmir muslim accepting his roots and speaking bitter truths which needs to be talked about. respect
I am from Tamilnadu Though I watched few of his interviews earlier. Listened with full attention unusually my mind got focused today. It is Highly informative well explained. I came across about him for years continuedly. so bit easy to relate and understand. Valuable message to youngsters throughout India. Good to watch and thanks for such a special podcast to both of you. This is Best one I watched.
Thank god...Shah Faisel is brutally honest and ackowledged his past mistakes in his ideology of Kashmir. Its takes courage to ackowledge ones mistakes. This podcast is excellent. Hope lot of kashmiri youth would listen to Shah Faisel. There are great things ahead for India. We finally started rising and we will rightfully take our place in the world and the world has already started to notice our contributions in sciences, astronomy, arts & culture, maths, social media etc. The best is yet to come from India !!!
What a discussion ❤class 👍🏾
One sentence touched my heart. I totally agree with him I am an Indian not only because I am Hindu or live in India but also I am the part of this great Indian Civilization.
He makes you feel why we should be proud Indian🇮🇳
Haven't listened to such a candid and honest interview. Heartiest congratulations.
“YOU NEED TO HAVE VERY GOOD MENTOR.”
So so TRUE
Thank you shah Faesal
👍👍
One of the best interviews of Indian history
Ideology emanates from Identity. Identity is everything. Indian Civilizational Identity which is being tolerant and all inclusive is something which we should relate to.
No, identity emanates from ideology.
@@HsenagNarawseramap it can be both. A small minority of self aware people construct identity from ideology. For the majority identity becomes ideology.
@@iqbalbakht8508not really. The Greeks and megasthenese give extraordinary accounts of "Patlibothra" calling it as the most powerful race and kingdom and the most wealthy of all People in Indian subcontinent.
They are described as mightiest.
Search the word "Patlibothra" - even their cities, forts and palaces are described in extreme grandeur and magnificence.
Shah faisel sir a gem of a person..
Following him since long.
Such a clarity in his thoughts
Watched the whole interview... Awesome analysis on various aspects.
Thanks dostcast for bringing Shah Faisal.❤❤❤
Woww...since long time I wanted to listen Shah Faisal Sir...and I am feeling so much educated just by listening to him.. Thanks for this masterpiece
You are a gentleman, intellectual and a great son to Mother India. I will always admire you for your thoughts and contribution to the nation.
I also go through similar nightmares about examinations...
Shah Faisal talks with a perfect perspective. Great indeed.
जब शाह फैजल ias बना था मैं बहुत inspired था आज खुस हु की मैं इनके जैसा बनना चाहता था
Same here bro!
After getting derailed for some time, he has come on the right track splendidly!
Shah Faesal has evolved so much over time
Great interview. It shows there are good human beings in all religions. India is blessed with so much diversity. Modi had United India and world is seeing it now. Better days for India are yet to come.
Great conversation ! I visited Kashmir recently and there is such feeling of tranquility and anticipation of bright future in the valley !
This man deserves to be the CM of J&K, a state trapped between opportunist Abdullahs and Muftis. Forget the intellectual brilliance he possesses, the kind of clarity this guy has at this age is very rare to see.
I would certainly like to see Shah in future on a cabinet post in the centre.
Bhai can be future PM/President of Bharat.
Optiimist camp for Bharat Civilization, sign of hitaishi(हितैषी)
He is a manifestation of how outside circumstances can be seen objectively as a kid without taking the wrong conclusions from it and becoming entrenched in the narrative pushed by men with guns.
More stories like this should be shown especially to young Kashmiris.
Thanks for bringing him on and thank you sir for your ongoing services to our nation.
This man is amazing.. education is so important to transform India. The correct education
Very insightful discussion Sah Faisal sir jee. You deserved to be upsc topper. You have very deepness in our history and civilization.
Truly engrossing and amazing Podcast. It was indeed entertaining and informative, a delight to hear an eloquent speaker like Shah Faisal, articulating so well , touching a gamut of subjects with utmost honesty. Would definitely look forward to another episode with him .
Faisal I have heard 1st time ro you. You are visionary and great patriot. Salut to you.
I always felt there must be some group of people advising him when he did irrational and illogical criticism after 370 abolition. He accepted here about his error of judgement. Now he has reformed himself for better. He will be a good administrator in times to come.
It's always great pleasure to hear from Shah Faesal.... The way he speaks it's seem like someone is narrating a beautiful story and you keep continue listening without interrupting.....
What an outstanding person you are Mr Shah Faesal . Salute to you ! Truly inspiring
Thank for the Podcase with Shah Faesalji. Following him from long time, from time he topped, time when he joined politics and back to his job. Few things articulated hearing him and felt if the discussion could be longer :). A calmness in his voice, reflect of high intellect level, Someone who access situation as it comes and takes evidence based decision, someone who has seen middle class reality, a forward thinking voice from someone who lived his life in a war turned zone. society needs people like him and I am sure many people across India must be aspiring to go in his path and surely a source of inspiration.
" You don't need to repeat mistakes which people have learnt from "
Thanks for come on social media sir I really appreciate you I was waiting long time for your interview
what a gem..loved it
Very inspiring and thought provoking podcast his knowledge of world history is great ❤
I am glad to see Shah Faesal sir after a long time and the way he accepted flaws in his own understanding. KUDOS! Thanks for the efforts @Dostcast
We. Need more people like him❤..He defined what India is !that too being scarred by the turmoil.
Mesmerized with the Intellect and the clarity of thoughts.
A well read and experienced Individual only can show you the falmbeau in darkest hours.
One of the best till today ❤😊
Amazing depth of thinking of Faesal Bhai. They are the real hope of our civilizational Nation.
Thank you so so so much Faesal sir. It's soothing to the eyes to see you after so much time. It's even more soothing to the ears to listen to ur wise words.
U r a gem for the planet Earth
What an amazing podcast! So happy to see an educated Kashmiri who is proud of our civilisational history! Beautiful conversation ❤ proud that we have officers and politicians like Shah Faesal sir! Jai hind 🇮🇳
There is no shortage of educated Kashmiris.Farukh Abdulla,Omar Abdullah, and all those spokespersons on kashmir on TV are all educated. But their narrative is Jihadi and separatist..Shah Faisal appears to be an open minded person ...how he continues to evolve will be interesting to see.
@@pinkikaushik517 I haven't followed him much except that he is an IAS topper.I drew my conclusions based on his responses in the podcast.Maybe he has evolved from his previous position.Time will tell because the truth does come out.I haven't invested so much capital on him that I will be shocked if he shows a separatist mindset.
@@pinkikaushik517 What you are saying may not be wrong,but all listeners are only making one point that hopefully he has changed his stance,because others in Kashmir too have changed.As far as minority restoration is something that is not going to happen in the near future. Right now ending separatism ,terrorism ,ushering peace and integrating Kashmir emotionally with India is a priority.
Wonderful interview. Shah Faizal, what a clarity and vision you brought to the Kashmiri people in particular and to all Indians in general. It will have a tremendous impact on all of them to move forward and look ahead. So much progress and happiness ahead for them but the narrow-minded, visionless cowardly politicians were only directing them to the path of self-destruction. God has been kind that they have not been successful. Salute to you.
What an educational podcast, thanks to Shah Faesal . This was incredible. I feel bad on how Kashmir was alienated and misguided. I'm truly optimistic in its future after the abbrogation of Art 370. May the valley bloom and turn into paradise in its truest sense. Thanks for the podcast.
I am from Jammu. Don't have these experiences which he described because we didn't have Terrorism in Jammu, of course because we have Hindu majority Demography. But we have experienced all the blow backs which state have suffered because of radicalization and Rising Terrorism. We, Dogras, tried our best to bring and maintain conditions which was beneficial for our state including supporting the " Abrogation of 370" and Today, I can say that we are at much better position.
I am Proud Indian, Jai Hind.
Really ? Are you not seeing Sarore Toll Plaza incident ? Have you even seen the conditions of Roads all over Jammu ? Have you seen the JKSSB debacle ?
Jammu was a Muslim majority area. After 1947 massacres of Muslims it became a Hindu majority area.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1947_Jammu_massacres
@@bhadwamodi8294
If Hindus massacre Jammu Muslims, how come kashmiri Muslims didn't retaliate ?
Wikipedia can be written by anyone, it's not an authentic source.
@@bhadwamodi8294that's fake news
The most profound and deep understanding on this topic! Hats off ❤
Need such interviews to be spread across the youth of present day Kashmir. Great work...
A true role model for India.
Thoughtful and intellectual discussion. Kudos to both of you 👏
What a brilliant podcast I came across!
Thanks dostcast for this.
Wow he acknowledged Krishna and Geeta as truth, I think he has read the other book and understood that there is always a room for improvement
He read real history then he must learnt about his ancestors hindu religion
Why Hindus get fool so easily. With few sweet good words you drop your defense.
I guess you will never learn unless it gets personal.
Where does he mention it?
Where??
Mr. Faisal, Very happy to listen to you on your change of mind on article 370 and the way you articulated the idea of being a part the larger civilization and our great nation. Please work for the betterment of the nation as a whole and let us all live in peace, harmony and prosperity. Let's consider religion as our a part of our private beliefs.
What a intellectual with such quality of thoughts....really enlightened
What a man shah faisal sir is.....i came to this podcast randomly but it is the best thing i ever seriously ever watch in youtube.....if every indian thinks like this than we were in top of the world soon
Wow. This was amazing. Beyond hearing about Kashmir, this was an enlightening podcast
"Even today if i hear a loud cracker sound or noise, i get palpitations "
Its so true, and unique to every kashmiri.
And who is responsible for that the "Indian state" isn't it!! 👏👏👏
@@samip3124don't be sarcastic on the trauma that Kashmiri have faced.
@@official_tarique.07 that satire was for the people who supported those jehadis ofcourse , you dont need to take everything on yourself
@@samip3124 bhai kya hai yeh. Saare log terrorist nahin aur support bhi nahin karte the. Humanity bhi dikhau kabhi kabhi, itni negative baath karte rahte ho.
@@anmolmonga1933 maine sabko kha terrorist bola 🤔 I just told every Islamist kashmiris ideology towards India so is that hate crime Islamophobia??
This podcast is brilliant. Its so refreshing to see how locals perceive the current situation post removal of Article 370 and the great things it's doing for J&K. It also show the propaganda run by the opposition and the personal agenda they have in dividing J&K from the rest of India.
Great convo enjoyed it thoroughly ❤
He is such a gud orator..
the selection of words &the humbleness in his speech and ya most important the truthfulness without any biasness accepting flaws even at such a position makes him unmatched personally...
@dostcast : One of your best podcast till date. Kudos to Mr. Faisal too for being so open.
Great podcast. An eye opening piece of conversation 😊
Subah ka bhula shyam ko ghar aaye to use bhula nahi kehte..!!😊
We still love you Shah Faesal..!!❤❤ Keep rocking