Bangladesh: Why Pakistan Should Apologize? | Dr. Mehdi Hassan | Doosri Taraf Say

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ต.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 94

  • @ferdousahmed3264
    @ferdousahmed3264 3 ปีที่แล้ว +16

    As a Bangladeshi, and a son of freedom fighter, I must say thank you for acknowledging the mistakes pakistan's leaders have made. Its true pakistan's military raped our mothers, sisters and killed millions of Bangali people. Our rivers were full of blood and we can ever never forget what has happened to us and how we fought against pakistan's military to win our freedom. But we still say, thank you for finally talking about this in your Media. So pakistani people know how your government treated others. Anyways, Joy Bangladesh, thank you.

    • @tamzidsmind9806
      @tamzidsmind9806 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩

    • @bye.9715
      @bye.9715 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      yes yes 😍😍😍

    • @drerfan
      @drerfan 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Respect your thoughts and agree to what you said. Just wanted to add that tens of thousands of biharis were mercilessly killed by mukti bahnis and their blood also went unnoticed. So let’s forget the past and live peacefully atleast amongst the people, if not governments. I have so many friends from Bangladesh, I was born there and migrated after the war, still have close bindings with Bengali families and friends and love to speak the language I learnt in my childhood, including the famous song “Amar moner phuldani te raakho tomar mon” 😊💐

    • @ferdousahmed3264
      @ferdousahmed3264 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@drerfan Yes, Biharies were part of RAZAKAR Bahini, Which Pakistani Military Created, they raped and killed many Hindu and Muslim families. Pakistani Military used them and gave them false hope during the WAR and after the WAR abandon them. We know the history very well, and most of our family members those saw the 1971 war, are still alive. However, when I speak with my Pakistani friends, they know nothing of this, because your great government in Pakistan has its FAKE PRIDE, Pakistan do not teach their children their shameful act in history. Pakistan's government do not want people to know how your military rapped and killed millions of people, instead they show their False Pride. Mr. Syed Tell the truth, and teach Pakistani people the geocide their military committed. Anyway, sir, please do not misunderstand me, I do not want to offend you or Pakistan, I really like Pakistan, I think it is a beautiful country and it also has some good innocent people, however truth be told. Thank you Sir. By the way, I like Mr. Imran Khan, he is the best. Hehehe....
      "Amar moner phuldani te raakho tomar mon", beautiful Sir. Joy Bangla!!!

    • @drerfan
      @drerfan 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Dear Firdaus, since both of us would stay obsessed with our point of view that we have witnessed respectively, so there won’t be any benefit of this debate. It won’t take us anywhere. Stay blessed and prosper in life.
      I anyway, seriously hope and wish to see my birthplace once again and feel the fragrance in the air while roaming around the streets of Mohammadpur Nurjahan road.

  • @MZKJKGB
    @MZKJKGB 3 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Truth always prevails.

  • @nishadahmed8823
    @nishadahmed8823 3 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    6:12 Sheikh Mujibur Rahman sahb😍😍

  • @atensari
    @atensari 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Why India should not called a Terrorist State for supporting Non-State elements!

  • @thediversity6203
    @thediversity6203 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Our politicians have destroyed Pakistan

  • @anonymus3236
    @anonymus3236 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Thank you for the honest admission of the genocide committed.
    It was the Bengalees who helped create East and West Pakistan. The Bengalees were discriminated against economically, socially from the beginning. Please don't take my word for it, the truth is everywhere on the internet. Would recommend one of your own, Dr. Taimur Rahman’s 5 part video on “East Pakistan to Bangladesh” on TH-cam, and also Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy, a handful of people from Pakistan who recognize the truth. “Kaale bhookhe Bangali”, “Do ta-ke ki ladki” and this is going on as we speak.
    As for the Biharis:
    1. They worked as informants for the Pak army with the hope that one day they would be able to call West Pakistan their home.
    2. Once again, this group was betrayed by Pakistan, which has till this day declined to hold any talks with Bangladesh on this topic.
    3. In spite of their betrayal of the Bengalees, they are not only surviving but thriving in Bangladesh with their business and other ways of earning their living.
    What conclusion would any rational human being draw from these facts? Is saying sorry so very difficult, subhan'Allah?

  • @TheSakr289
    @TheSakr289 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Bravo Dr. Sahab.... Thank you for revealing the truth.

  • @rudroofficial6739
    @rudroofficial6739 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Thank You sir ❤️
    Love from Bangladesh ❤️

  • @sabihahmad1084
    @sabihahmad1084 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Sheikh Mujib had the full right not to agree with any discussion before the start of the assembly. Bhutto can request but cannot demand. Unfortunately we learned nothing from this experience. As he said we need to continue to apologize with people of BD for our wrong doing.
    Allah apnader kay shob shomai hashi khushi rakhen. Ameen.

  • @futuredok
    @futuredok 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Bangladesh will never have good relations with Pakistan until your country issues a formal apology for the heinous crimes they committed against my people. We Bangalis will never forget and will definitely not forgive your pakistani government for the way they treated bengali people during times of east pakistan. Separating from Pakistan and becoming Bangladesh is the best thing that could have happened to my people. Your people laughed and treated my people like scum with your superiority complex and racism. Now look at us, we are only 50 years old as a country and we are far more prosperous in every way compared to Pakistan. Allah always rewards the humble and honest people and punishes the evildoers on Earth. Tell your people and your government to issue formal apology or there will NEVER be a relationship with pakistan EVER.

    • @drerfan
      @drerfan 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      I totally disagree to this. I have so many good friends from Bangladesh as I too was born there. The army regime didn’t do good in east Pakistan but in turn Bengalis also killed thousands of innocent biharis who were living there peacefully and were good friends with Bengalis. During March 1971, my grandparents helped and saved lots of Bengalis in their home. There is no need to beat about the bush.

    • @drerfan
      @drerfan 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      If an apology is required then it should be from both sides to the descents of those who were killed without a reason. Both, Bengalis and non Bengalis and Biharis. Apology is not needed for governments. It’s needed for those who suffered and were killed.

    • @nitashakhan3959
      @nitashakhan3959 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@drerfan you r right..Apology should be from both sides..because not only bangalis were killed but non bagalis were also killed by bangalis..

    • @TZovro
      @TZovro 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@nitashakhan3959We never will apologize unnecessarily. What if you don't apologize? Will we die? You are surrounded by hostile neighbours, but we have no enemy because our foreign policy is balanced. You need us, but we don't need you. So keep stalling like you did in 1971, we know how that ended. lol

  • @নীলআকাশেরনীচে-থ৫প
    @নীলআকাশেরনীচে-থ৫প 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman did a good performance for Bangladesh.

  • @AbaseenPodcast
    @AbaseenPodcast 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Sir, what is the best Urdu book on East Pakistan tragedy? I want to narrate it on my podcast .

    • @drerfan
      @drerfan 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      I suggest you that consider the Urdu translation of “I witness to surrender” titled “Main ne Dhaka dubte dekha”.

  • @ArifurRahmanArif
    @ArifurRahmanArif ปีที่แล้ว

    Just state one reason why Bangladeshi people shouldn't hate pakistan..!!?
    it is true that, we don't have any issue with pakistani common people..
    but, we have a lots of issue with Pakistani government.. and "the government is, by the people, for the people, of the people"..
    until or unless pakistani government makes any official apology for the dreadful genocide of 1971..
    Listen, we Bangalis are the Real Pakistan at 1947.
    we are the majority on the pakistan movement, not todays NaaPaakistanis..
    but, they treated us as colony, racially demoralized us, and therefore forced us to be separated..
    they officially declared rape to bangali women.. killed us like bugs.. damn.. words are very few to describe those descrimination, and brutality..
    still they blame other nations.,!!??
    They are the most Barbaric nation exist on earth, we admire that..
    but, the matter of fact, still some of us, 'somehow' supports or show love over pakistanis.. blah blah.. WTF..!!..
    How can we emotional Bangladeshis be fooled again and again by listening to the sweet words of those limelighting wicked?
    We know very well, What they did from '1952 Language Movement' to 1971?
    They murdered our millions of people in a ruthless manner, raped our mothers sisters.
    Can they return my ancestral blood?
    If Trudeau can apologise for the atrocities in Canada, there is no reason why any Pakistani leader shouldn't be able to apologise for the past atrocities of previous leaders.?!
    As a concept within Islam, this is a sign of a truthful leader,
    Pakistan should publicly apologize for the massacre in 1971.. otherwise there is no chance for any kind of relation building..
    "Atleast Pakistan should teach their Kids the real history,
    Atleast let pakistani people know what was happened in 1971 ??
    The truth shall reveal"..
    if anyone have the guts (balls) watch this documentary of 1971..
    🇧🇩 জয় বাংলা।
    m.th-cam.com/video/HQlpkB0jM5Q/w-d-xo.html&bpctr=1580756347

    • @AmmaraAziz804
      @AmmaraAziz804 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Hum Pakistanio ko maaf kr dena

  • @arafatislam2611
    @arafatislam2611 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    wow like wow! still you guyz think India misguided us to make Bangladesh.
    this attitude is the main reason for the bad condition of Pakistan, pakistan is a failed state. Bangladesh has considered an economical force in the world by the grace of Allah.
    3:58

    • @carsickjax5040
      @carsickjax5040 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Please put all your trust in India as India will be there for you. India promises it loves Bangladeshis. 😄😏

    • @arafatislam2611
      @arafatislam2611 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@carsickjax5040 we had to use someone, to get what we wanted. Right?
      Joy bangla.

    • @raju.ca71
      @raju.ca71 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @jason camel have your country raised voice against Myanmar? More than 1 million Rohingyas have fled from Myanmar and we are giving them shelter & food.Did your country do something fot them?Bangladesh Army train Palestinians & make them true soldiers. Does your country do in the same way?What did your country for Uighurs? Tell me?Your Puppet govt. Can't survive without China's help that's why they haven't raised any words against chinese govt..We always suppot Kashmiris.We want them to be Independent and make a country by their own.Because they are not safe to both India & Pakistan.They are safe to them only.

    • @jubairabdullah3133
      @jubairabdullah3133 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@carsickjax5040 Bangladesh ain't really relying on any individual power... we collaborate with any state where both countries are benefited. Of course, India will not get a penny more than it deserves. we don't intend to harm anybody... we focus on economic growth and your visit to Bangladesh.

    • @TheSoulja99boy
      @TheSoulja99boy 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @Pa Jeet Did you type this after visiting Heera Mandi?

  • @ashiqurrahman7091
    @ashiqurrahman7091 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Lots of love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

  • @jamaldin7000
    @jamaldin7000 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Durst farmaya aap ne

  • @PakArchive
    @PakArchive 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    ‏80 ہزار ریپ کیسز۔۔۔
    اور جب ہمارے وڈے افسران کو کوئی بتاتا تھا کے آپکے بندے وہاں عورتوں کی عزتیں لوٹ رہے ہیں تو وہ کہتے تھے
    " کیا اب اتنے سے کام کے لیئے وہ لوگ میدان جنگ چھوڑ کے اتنا دور واپس گھروں کو آئیں"
    ہم مانیں یا نا مانیں یہ ہماری تاریخ کے سیاح ترین بابوب میں سے اک ہے۔

    • @mdrummankhan8269
      @mdrummankhan8269 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      What are you saying

    • @mdrummankhan8269
      @mdrummankhan8269 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      তোরা বাঙালির উপর অত্যাচার করছ,

    • @masudurrahman9566
      @masudurrahman9566 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@mdrummankhan8269 ঠিক মত লেখা পড়া করে ইংরেজী লেখতে এস, এই সব উল্টা পাল্টা লেখা লেখ

  • @namanpandey4021
    @namanpandey4021 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Learned Nd to point interview

  • @daudkamran2391
    @daudkamran2391 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Nice sir

  • @AhsanShah-xm6vp
    @AhsanShah-xm6vp 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    What is the name of host?

  • @sadiamufti8890
    @sadiamufti8890 3 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Maafi mangein ya na mangein, mulk ke halaat bta rhe hein ke bheek zaroor maange ge.

  • @dr.saadatfaruq9882
    @dr.saadatfaruq9882 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    بابا یو ایس اے نے فیصلہ کر لیا گیا تھا کہ پاکستان توڑنا ہے۔ مذہب اہم ہے مگر جمہوریت کے کئی رخ ہیں۔ ہمیں سب سے معافی مانگتے رہنا چاہیے ۔ اللہ سے۔ انسانوں سے اور قوموں سے۔اس طرح ہمارے دانشوروں کی تسلی ہو گی۔ زندہ قومیں آگے بڑھتی ہیں۔ ماضی سے دیکھتی ہیں ۔

  • @shorif566
    @shorif566 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    🇧🇩🙏🇵🇰😰😰😰

  • @tahirnaveed370
    @tahirnaveed370 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Mehdi hassan banglades us dour gia he nahian adhar bath ki bakta hi

  • @alishah2883
    @alishah2883 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    RABBUL izzat aapko Foundamentelist mullahs se mahfooz rakkhe

  • @sarwaralam3977
    @sarwaralam3977 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    No apology until Bengalis also apologize for killing innocent West Pakistani and Bihari civilians. Bengalis never complained they were forbidden to join British army. 45 thousand Pak Army had great numerical and geographical disadvantages against India and Mukti Bahini goons. This idiot Dr Mehdi is giving numbers of killings but no proof. He also did not mention Agartala conspiracy.

    • @3e372
      @3e372 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      What's with the crocodile tears? You handed weapons to the Biharis to kill Bengali civilians. Don't try to hide history like your illiterate grandpa used to do. And why would you as a Pakistani want an apology for the Biharis when you don't even recognize them as Pakistanis? You used them by handing them weapons to target Bengali civilians and then you betrayed the Biharis in Bangladesh when you lost the war where they lived under harsh conditions. This makes you traitor to the Biharis!!!
      As for West Pakistanis, majority of them weren't even interested to go East Pakistan which is not surprising at all because you looted the earnings of East Pakistan to develop the West. East Pakistan or Bangladesh never had any noticeable minorities of Punjabis or Sindhis 50 years ago and even today. Punjabis and Sindhis did not leave the West Pakistan to the East in large numbers like the Bengalis did towards the West because you exploited the Bengalis. Vast majority of Punjabis and Sindhis stayed in the comfort of their homes while your Punjabi army joined hands with the Biharis to butcher the Bengalis. The only reason you're shedding crocodile tears is because you're too proud and arrogant to admit your faults. You're using the Biharis to play the victim card, not because you care about them. You have no excuse to be live in denial like your grandparents. Today is the age of information so you can't distort history like the previous generation of Pakistanis.

  • @hawkeye123hamid4
    @hawkeye123hamid4 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Who killed Mujeeb Rehman. Should we ask forgiveness for this also?. He was killed by our Bengali brother's. Fact remains archeticts of 1971 disaster met horrible end; whether it was Bhutto,Yayha,Mujeeb,Indra Ghandi etc. We (both sides) need to learn from history and move on.Yes, injustice was done and killing's also.There are no Momin on that side also.See Hazrat what Mukhti did in their stadium by killing unarmed civiliansTell them to seek forgiveness for killing those innocent also. Stop producing guilt like cult.Your face represent a guilt borne syndrome.Rememeber Rule of Engagement:Give Respect by being getting respect not seeking respect.Long live Pakistan and Bangladesh

    • @sabriabir
      @sabriabir 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      Unharmed civilian. No wonder Pakistan is a big shelter for terrorist. Educate yourself.

  • @Hamza-fr1gj
    @Hamza-fr1gj 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Propaganda nothing else. Racist budha blabbering about Punjabis.
    Or yeh chay insan Dhaka University me AK47s kese ai woh nai btaye ga.

  • @tahirnaveed370
    @tahirnaveed370 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Bangladesh should appalogise for massicre of all pakistanies aànd telling lies

  • @saifmalik9501
    @saifmalik9501 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    I agree 99% , nonetheless, impartial reports ref to Sharmila Bhos , killing and rape figures are not correct as stated by the esteemed scholar. Ex President Musharraf sought apologia the past , how many times more apolitical be raised . !!!!!? What about the killings of Urdu speaking and killings/ rapes of West Pakistanis !?
    I think let’s close the past and move forward as none of the characters responsible are alive at the moment. We respect sovereignty of BD and love Bengalies as well

  • @eishahussain7748
    @eishahussain7748 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    بنگلہ دیش کو پا کستان سے معافی مانگنا چاہے ان کی وجہ سے کتنے لوگ آرمی اور بنگالی جو پاکستان سے محبت کرتے وہ شہد کردہے

    • @sabriabir
      @sabriabir 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Bengali never loved Pakistan...23 years with Pakistan was a torcher. We never liked u..we were more liberal secular...u with ur Islamic propaganda destroyed our language, culture. Our culture is different

  • @tahirnaveed370
    @tahirnaveed370 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Bangladesh should appologise from pakistan as bengales started killing army
    Men with out provocation

  • @ziyahaani9838
    @ziyahaani9838 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    This channel is funded from india.

    • @jamilurrahman8468
      @jamilurrahman8468 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ہاہاہاہا

    • @MuhammadMahadiHasan-n7r
      @MuhammadMahadiHasan-n7r 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      you are send from Israel and you are given order to make troubles everywhere !

    • @xtasktaste0
      @xtasktaste0 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @ziya haani That's what you understood from this video? Great learning.

    • @nightwolf728
      @nightwolf728 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@xtasktaste0 hahaha

    • @MuhammadMahadiHasan-n7r
      @MuhammadMahadiHasan-n7r 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@xtasktaste0 😁😁😁