Thanks for the video. The stupid showrunner thought it was ok to kill off Melendez for shock value. Well the S4 ratings are gonna shock him. I watched for Claire, Melendez and Andrews. Not putting myself in a position to be hurt again. Yes it is fiction, but with so much darkness in the world, fiction is my great escape. RIPmelendez #melendaire.
Yes it will be interesting to see how the ratings will do. Not wishing death to the show but I need writers to wrote more character driven than plot point which seems to be popular in recent years
They haven't even kissed yet .... 😭😭 such a long beautiful passionate lovestory and such a meaningless unfair ending.... sad....😢 The video is brilliant !! 👍👍👏👏👏
My heart is hurting so much, I absolutely loved Neil. His character development from season 1 to 3 was amazing, why did the writers do him like that? He and Claire deserved better. Melendez deserved better. I don't think I can ever watch the show the same again. (Thank you so much for this video
I’m gonna miss them so much They were my lifeline for three years. I don’t know what I’m going to do without him, without *them*. I just know I won’t be whole for a long time. This video was so lovely. Thank you for it.
The way he cradles her face after they exchange "I love you's," though--a dagger to the heart! 😩😭They had so many great moments and I will never get over them. Never. This was a beautiful video, thank you! xx
I’m still hoping that they bring him back, I don’t want to get my hopes up but I’m so disappointed that they would start to give us this ship and then pull it away! Absolutely heart breaking. I’m also mad that Claire has to detail with this too, she’s been through enough 💞 Beautiful video by the way!! Amazing work 🥰
You guys, I had intended to do this video and happily wait for Season 4 to see what it brings us. But, well, you know it looks like it didn't turn out the way I would have liked. I should be used to this as lately I have had several ships like this. But it hits fresh everytime. I was going to wait til my emotions settled but since I had already started the video, I needed to finish it and then distance myself from the show for a bit. As of now, I will not be back to watch Season 4. I didn't feel like they needed to kill the character off. I read the interview with the writer and NG. I have seen so many takes on that interview but my take was the writers felt they needed something shocking(disguised as telling a realistic story) and informed Nick it would be him shortly after the new year. Now there is alot that happened in between about their choice but there it is. Gotta say, this one hurt alot. There is so much I would have settled for besides this....so much. Anyway, unless it is miraculously fixed, I have watched the last of the show because honestly, if they did this to him, they will do it to another. And yeah, I don't need that. No problem if anybody continues to watch. I actually have started reading more now as I said I would do. But I will contiue to do videos for other ships and maybe revisit Melendaire so be expecting that. Thankful for all the comments and discussions always.
JenJi I’m so hurt, I actually cried. I agree with your whole statement they didn’t have to kill him off, they could have did something else anything else. It was a good show but now I have no reason to watch. Thank you for your videos, I will continue to watch them. Do you watch New Amsterdam the ship on there is Sharpwin. Well take care.
This was a beautiful video I am def devastated I have shipped them since the first episode when he winked at her. I wish I could say it was bittersweet but it’s actually just bitter. His first scene was with her and his last. Their chemistry was undeniable and I always saw it. He didn’t want to leave. They would have made a beautiful on screen romance. Very sad. I like Shaun but have no interest in watching the show anymore. I will continue to watch your videos. Thank you very beautiful
I watched 1 fucking episode 3 minutes ago.. immediately shipped them both and wanted to watch some fanfic edits. I DID NOT COME HERE TO FIND OUT HE DIES WTF NOOO! GREAT! MY SHIP SUNK BEFORE IT EVEN SET SAIL!! I don't think I'm gonna watch it anymore.
Rachel I’m so sorry! It was pretty devastating for us all.I wouldn’t watch either if I found out before I even got started good. You could watch a bunch of fan vids and get all their moments anyway.
I am very sad and disappointed with what they did. Sometimes I wonder: if they were going to kill him, why did they create a deeper relationship between him and Claire? I will not watch the fourth season, I will not make it. Not without him. But I am very grateful for the moments of the two and for the wonderful videos I watched here too. I hated the end of the season, and all I have left is to cry and cry. But thank you for this video. Its amazing! I'm going to miss the videos and Melendaire too. ❤😔
@@JenJiJ316 agree i wanted to see them go further with each other the writers let us down in not having this they let them have great moments then gave us this ending
Not just for Claire, I actually really liked Dr.Melendez's character as a whole. He was a surgeon who thought outside the box, supported his residents even if it meant taking risks. That's what Good Doctors do, Shaun isn't the only one who deserves that title. And Claire did not deserve this, after all the pain she went through, she was finally coming out of it and was able to admit to her feelings. She deserves better. Even if they want to make it look real, how do they expect a character as sensitive as hers to deal with two deaths of people she loved?
I started CRYING as a baby as soon as the music started. Believe me i am in psysical pain after yesterday and i will never be able to watch this without feeling pain, i can't believe he is truly gone expecially in this was, expecially now that he knew she loved him back. The show will never be the same without him and for sure i won't watch it
Thank you for this. I waited 3 seasons for something to happen between them, and finally there is just this horrible end. Claire don't deserve this. But when I see this video, I realize that the story that there was between Claire and Melendez is the most romantic of all the good doctor series. Let Melendez die is just a stupid idea, and it's useless to keep watching. The production broke our hearts, the audience will drop and it will be fair.
JenJi they want credibility but they kill melendez and not Vera. It's so stupid. Not credible. They wanted to create a dramatic love story, like Titanic, (the water that starts to rise with Shaun and Vera made me think of that too) but there was not even a single kiss! it's like ron would die in the last episode before kissing Hermione, while they love each other from the start. it's just foolish. They will soon realize their mistakes. (i am french sorry if you didn't understand)
No... I refuse to believe it. And I don't even watch the show yet...maybe I never will after this. I always checked their scenes and I was so sure that they would be my new favorite ship if I start watching the show. It's sooo unfair...and this video made me cry. I'm so sad now... :( But thank you for making this epic vid.
Thank you. Yeah I would hold off on the watch. In fact, they went a whole season pretty much where there wasnt a whole bunch of movement for them. So you kind of felt like it was their time now. And then this... 😔
I am Brazilian and a watch to series, I really are very sad about the death of Melendez, I cried a lot, because there was no sense in his death, he was one of the protagonists and was expecting a lot in his appearance next seasons, I believe that the audience for Good Doctor will drop death bill for this character, as well as another series that I watched called The walkind Dead, I suffered a lot with the death of many characters that were protagonists of series and on account said the audience has lowered a lot. In the end, I thought it unnecessary for them to have killed Melendez, but I will continue watching the series to see what will happen in the coming seasons. I loved your video JenJi, you are very talented. Stay in the peace and God bless you.
Aww thank you so much! Eu concordo com Melendez. Não foi necessário. Eu não vou continuar assistindo. Eu simplesmente não consigo lidar com o que eles o mataram. Também não assisti The Walking Dead desde sempre, mas eles tiveram muitas mortes de favoritos por lá.
Am I the only one here who thinks he's not dead? I mean, we didn't SEE him died, and there's no flatline, it's possible that Claire cried in Lim's arms cause she thinks there's no hope left. Plus, I doubt Shaun even know about his condition, he didn't got his goodbyes. I'm not saying that suddenly he can help him or something but, there's still hope. Yeah the actor has done an exit interview, but maybe that's because they want us to think that he's dead so they can give us a heart attack next season. Just a theory tho.
I shipped them in the beginning but after I saw him with Dr.Lim I liked him when he was with her. Although I do like how their relationship was very pure .
Thanks for this JenJi. I won't be watching season 4 either. I feel totally betrayed and abused by the producers. The writers ran out of ideas and decided to kill off my Melendaire ship before it even set sail. That was so messed up. I guess they thought it was a 'clever' twist but they took it too far.. I will be watching compilations like this over and over until I get over it.
It hurts seeing how many of us are really hurt by this situation. Still, I'm happy that so many of us are united by the same feelings, it makes me feel better. We must not give up on him and insist with bringing him back to the writers. Don't care how, shows have brought characters to life before, so.. I guess I'm gonna hold on to that hope. Try to do that on every network tagging thr writers and letting them know please!
Welp, it physically hurts. and idk what to do with my life now. Literally since the first time Claire flirted with Neil I was waiting for them to get together, and now that they have, he's dead. Besides that, he was a favourite character, and I haven't cried this much since Season 3 of GoT. Also, the creators said they killed him off because they knew it would have an emotional impact. First off, fuck them all, second off, this is bullshit, Melendez was the backbone of TGD. Whoever replaces his character in S4 better not fuck up the story.
If he's replaced we could grow to like him which makes it even worse, because we won't have any reason to hate him or not to want him there. I WANT MELENDEZ. NO ONE ELSE
Never i had been this much dissapointed about a show.lets wait and see how next season ratings gonna shock writers.atleast try and compebsate now.bring him back.pls shaun bring us a miracle
Amazing video! This song is heartbreaking, but I love it! Melendez first scene was with Claire and his last one too :( I can't believe he's gone, it was outrageous, unacceptable and anticlimatic! Only 3 doctor came to say goodbye to one of their own, I expected more commotion at the hospital, and the way Lim and Melendez walked out of that room talking about getting drinks and not even covering Melendez body... Seems like he was asleep not dead. Not to mention that didn't seem like they tried a lot of things to save him! We never saw him coding or being intubated! Maybe they had an idea between his last scene with Claire (at night) and the morning final scene. Also, Lim was talking about getting drinks with Claire! WTF! Almost seemed like they were laughing! If Melendez is gone that was really bad writing. I guess we'll have to wait.... Just can't wrap my head around the ideia that they would kill such a beloved character if Nicholas Gonzalez didn't ask to leave (what he did not).
All of what you said.... Like every word!! All this went through my head as well. It was weird and badly done. It seemed rushed not that I needed it to be dragged out. But it was rushed and they tried nothing. 😒
@@JenJiJ316 the way Lim and Claire walked out of that room** I was nervous when I wrote it haha Yeah, they tried to fit a lot of things into one episode... Didn't work out at all
Thank you for the video. Every time I watch such kind of videos about Melendaire I can't stop crying. Killing him off is a creative decision? Never. It's cruel. It's bullshit. I love Shaun and Lea, but this couple needs to be put along with a normal couple to see the differences and difficulties that they have in life. That's why Melendaire is so appropriate and matches the frame. Now they ruined everything. There is also a biased view on Claire as a color woman, and it's not good at all if they steal every good things from her life. This is a TV show, not real life. For me, I need to watch something that could balance my life because life is harsh enough that I don't need david shore teaching me how harsh it is. Poor him. A pig, he is!
they could really rewrite the whole ending for the beginning of season 4. Like Claire was daydreaming during the surgery and created a whole alternative ending she snaps out of it saves him and they fall in love. PERIOD. I dislike this show now I’m upset
For me the most senseless thing was why they chose to kill him off, that's why I am ot even bothering to sign petitions to bring him back or anything like that. I will only watch S3 and that's it, I love Claire with all my heart and this is not about what they did to Melendaire but more about of how the producers, writers, directors are deciding to manage the show, because if you feel like killing a character simply because it will cause a major impact I think you shouldn't be producing a show like the Good doctor, you should something else. So good The good Doctor t was a gud ride
I agree with all you said. Sadly we are in a time of shock value. Also, a show used to be about what the audience connected with and wanted. But now it's a case of what the writers think is best.
I don't get it. Why did they do that? It was too emotional for me. First of all I was crying and then I was angry asf.I don't know what now. I don't wanna watch it anymore. Or might watch it just for Claire.... This edit is so amazing! Thanks for that.
I didn' know the couple neither did show but You Tube suggested me some videos about them and I loved it! I loved the chemistry between them so much so I was about to start watching " Good Doctor", but now there is no point :( I am very sad.
Is there any possibility that maybe Claire and Shaun got hurt and all of this was some kinda of coma dreams.. And Melendez still alive??.. I want hope.. Can't handle this.. 😢😢
At the moment I see Lea fall into the ground because of the earthquake i immediately thought it was a Shaun's dream it seemed unrealistic the way people reacted
What pisses me off is the fact that David Shore And Daniel Dae Kim went all season long getting everyone's especially Melendaire fans hopes up of thinking that they were going to put Neil and Claire together if they NEVER had any intentions on making them a fuckin couple that's what's pissing me off here! I completely understand there's other characters on the show and it's not just based around Nicholas's character or on Claire and Melendez but what was the point of having them grow closer and spending all that time together and building a relationship if they were just planning on killing off Melendez? I don't understand. Cause in my opinion if they NEVER had any intentions on making them a fuckin couple then they should've just kept their relationship completely on a platonic level and had not even went down that road because all it accomplished was piss me the fuck off excuse my french. Now has far as that bullshit article I read I just found it complete bullshit and completely comical because Limlendez fan's are making these stupid ass assumptions and are coming up with these ridiculous theories like Neil wasn't really in love with Claire and he only said I love you to her because he was on his death bed give me a damn break! No one put a gun to Neil's head and made him say I love you to Claire he did that all on his own, if he honestly didn't love Claire or had no romantic feelings for her than he didn't even have to respond or acknowledge that she even told him she loved him he could've ignored it but instead decided to say I love you to Claire. Even Claire wasn't sure when she blurted out I love you to Neil if he even felt the same way about her but took a risk and told him anyways because she wanted him to know. And Limlendez's theory on how Neil still has feelings for Audrey because he made the statement I could spend a life time drinking whiskey with you, really? You got he still had feelings for her off that one statement? I honestly wanted to laugh my ass off! Just because he made that statement to Audrey doesn't necessarily mean that he meant it romantically or that it meant that he still had feelings for her how people came up with that ridiculous concept is beyond me, he could've easily meant having a glass of whiskey with her has a friend, I swear people read way to into shit. Not to mention Limlendez fans must really NOT pay attention very well because Neil told Shaun in another episode that he was completely over Audrey and Jessica so where they got this ridiculous concept that Neil's still into Audrey is beyond me. And here's another thing if Neil honestly was "Supposedly" So in love with Audrey which he NEVER was in love with her but ok he had every opportunity to tell her he loved her and didn't instead decided to say I love you to Claire. And same thing applies to Audrey has well if she was so in love with Neil she also had every opportunity to tell him she loved him when they were together saying their goodbyes and didn't and this is the couple that is "Supposedly" so in love with each other? Give me a break. Plus, here's another ridiculous theory from Limlendez fans they claim he's NOT in love with Claire because when she goes to say something to him he cuts her off and says DON'T! We all know the reason he really did that was because he wanted Claire to focus on other patients and not just on him and knew there was still a crisis going on in the hospital and knew they needed all the doctors available it had absolutely NOTHING to do with him NOT loving her. We all know the only reason Limlendez fans are making these stupid ass assumptions and saying stupid shit like Neil wasn't really in love with Claire and he only said he loves her because he was on his death bed is because their pissed he didn't end up with Lim and he was in love with Claire and NOT her.
I have also had the thought of I would have rather they even not go there with Melendez if they were going to kill him off. I get so confused as to their reasoning for it all.
Writers literally destroyed my favourite ship ever and I am so pissed off. I feel that I have thrown three years in the garbage waiting for nothing. My only hope is that Neil is not really dead but he experienced the NDE, he went through a tunnel full of light and he came back to life thanks to God. It would be an interesting plot .
I keep thinking that episode after episode they come up with ways in impossible situations to save people. But when it came to Neil, it was like he is going to die and they barely spent time on trying to come up with solutions...just not what the show has been about. Neil, Claire and Shaun were my favorite characters. I felt if one of these left(which obviously Shaun is the show so he wouldn't), I wouldn't be able to watch. And I ship alot of couples but only ship a few couples hard....this was one of them.
@@JenJiJ316 I didn't care about the other characters excepting Neil and Claire. I have followed the show basically for them. The actors really fit in their roles and it seems that they were really in love . If Nicholas was not married I would have shipped him with Antonia in real life too ahhha they make me crazy; however I hope that Melendez really came to life after a NDE experience. It is the only thing that I can imagine.
Yes very sad ending. They had amazing story beautiful chemistry truly the only reason I watched the show I saw it from season 1 so 1, when he winked at her and I have patiently waited for this and then nothing. It sucks they didn’t even get to kiss but I feel their chemistry friendship mutual respect admiration and love spoke volumes it was always in the eyes for them. 😞
@@lynnmartin4896 my dream is that Nicholas and Antonia make a movie together where they kiss wildly, touch everywhere , and fuck as two animals.😄 a fantastic dream for a bisexual like me. We deserve something like that.
For me he and she are alive happily together, married and with a beatiful kids...1,2 or many as Neil convince Claire to have...and they live their cute story so many time...so many years, they have their forever. And...so much people thinks the same than me...so, I think: If someone keeps their story just like that....so, Melendaire will continue...no matter what.
Just know they won’t be getting a season 5. I never even tuned in to see Sean. I hate Morgan, lim is kinda Irrelevant and park is cool. That’s pretty much it
Can't believe they took Melendez from us. But we can't stop having hope with the " #bringbackmelendez" movement on Twitter, IG, and Facebook. And please sign the petition: chng.it/vk9jrwSqry if you want the lovely Neil Melendez back with us in Season 4, so we can continue to see his character blossom
Oke but like, they said he would be dying of a septic shock, right? But sepsis is treatable... why did they didn’t do anything, or did I miss something?
As far as I know something else had ripped open and bacteria was spreading quickly through his sytem, unfortunately there isn't a cure for that :/ I kept hoping Shaun would come in and devise this miracle plan as he so often does... But no, the creators just wanted shock value.
Sea Bird Yes, but I did so,e reading up on it, because I thought sepsis can be treated. Not in all cases, obviously, but even bad cases can be turned around. You just have to treat the patient, but they didn’t do anything. So I really don’t like how they choose sepsis as his death reason, when medically speaking, he could have been saved. Seems like lazy writing just get it done with.
I will be doing a giveaway in the next week when I hit 1000 subscribers. So if you aren't subscribed, pleaee do for a chance to get a vid of your choice. It will be only open to my subscribers before I launch my giveaway video.
Por que gente???? Pq justo ele? Ninguém nessa serie merece morrer! Muito menos ele! Sacanagem!!! Eu quando vi comecei a chorar! Nunca chorei tanto como de terça feira pra cá! Muito triste mesmo. Estou morta por dentro e fora.
![Melendez + Claire | Isn't it lovely? [3x20]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zhFHSYbuuzk/mqdefault.jpg)
![i won't mind | claire + neil [+1x18]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LzvqxTvlS3Q/mqdefault.jpg)
th-cam.com/channels/bne3geC9yztjed0GGxvAhQ.htmldiscussion?view_as=subscriber
the “you gonna be okay, claire” breaks my heart everytime in million pieces..
Thanks for the video. The stupid showrunner thought it was ok to kill off Melendez for shock value. Well the S4 ratings are gonna shock him. I watched for Claire, Melendez and Andrews. Not putting myself in a position to be hurt again. Yes it is fiction, but with so much darkness in the world, fiction is my great escape. RIPmelendez #melendaire.
Yes it will be interesting to see how the ratings will do. Not wishing death to the show but I need writers to wrote more character driven than plot point which seems to be popular in recent years
They picked a bad time to do this, least i still have New Amsterdam
This was a work of art. Everything hey could have been and never had the chance to be.
They haven't even kissed yet ....
😭😭
such a long beautiful passionate lovestory and such a meaningless unfair ending....
sad....😢
The video is brilliant !!
👍👍👏👏👏
My heart is hurting so much, I absolutely loved Neil. His character development from season 1 to 3 was amazing, why did the writers do him like that? He and Claire deserved better. Melendez deserved better. I don't think I can ever watch the show the same again. (Thank you so much for this video
I'm crying. Just now watched The Good Doctor and these two were the best part of the show...😢 How am I gonna survive with this death...😢
I’m gonna miss them so much
They were my lifeline for three years. I don’t know what I’m going to do without him, without *them*. I just know I won’t be whole for a long time.
This video was so lovely. Thank you for it.
Same. They have affected me the same way. 😢
The way he cradles her face after they exchange "I love you's," though--a dagger to the heart! 😩😭They had so many great moments and I will never get over them. Never. This was a beautiful video, thank you! xx
Oh yes. The face cradle. 😭 Thank you. 😊
They really did us dirty. Still not over this betrayal.
www.change.org/p/the-good-doctor-fans-save-melendez-thegooddoctor?lang=en-US
@@koontzie5423 that's a little extra lol there are more important issues to petition.
Killing Melendez was emotional and unforgettable
Yes totally agree.
👏👏👏
I’m still hoping that they bring him back, I don’t want to get my hopes up but I’m so disappointed that they would start to give us this ship and then pull it away! Absolutely heart breaking. I’m also mad that Claire has to detail with this too, she’s been through enough 💞 Beautiful video by the way!! Amazing work 🥰
You guys, I had intended to do this video and happily wait for Season 4 to see what it brings us. But, well, you know it looks like it didn't turn out the way I would have liked. I should be used to this as lately I have had several ships like this. But it hits fresh everytime. I was going to wait til my emotions settled but since I had already started the video, I needed to finish it and then distance myself from the show for a bit. As of now, I will not be back to watch Season 4. I didn't feel like they needed to kill the character off. I read the interview with the writer and NG. I have seen so many takes on that interview but my take was the writers felt they needed something shocking(disguised as telling a realistic story) and informed Nick it would be him shortly after the new year. Now there is alot that happened in between about their choice but there it is. Gotta say, this one hurt alot.
There is so much I would have settled for besides this....so much. Anyway, unless it is miraculously fixed, I have watched the last of the show because honestly, if they did this to him, they will do it to another. And yeah, I don't need that. No problem if anybody continues to watch. I actually have started reading more now as I said I would do.
But I will contiue to do videos for other ships and maybe revisit Melendaire so be expecting that. Thankful for all the comments and discussions always.
@Girl of Confusion yeah he said there was more left to tell about Neil's story. I am not clear about what exactly happened.
JenJi I’m so hurt, I actually cried. I agree with your whole statement they didn’t have to kill him off, they could have did something else anything else. It was a good show but now I have no reason to watch. Thank you for your videos, I will continue to watch them. Do you watch New Amsterdam the ship on there is Sharpwin. Well take care.
This was a beautiful video I am def devastated I have shipped them since the first episode when he winked at her. I wish I could say it was bittersweet but it’s actually just bitter. His first scene was with her and his last. Their chemistry was undeniable and I always saw it. He didn’t want to leave. They would have made a beautiful on screen romance. Very sad. I like Shaun but have no interest in watching the show anymore. I will continue to watch your videos. Thank you very beautiful
@@cherrisecole7330 New Amsterdam is on my list to watch after I finish The Resident.
JenJi Great you’re going to love it 😊
Goodbye The Good Doctor...I m so done😢 Melendaire had so much potential😭😭😭😭
I watched 1 fucking episode 3 minutes ago.. immediately shipped them both and wanted to watch some fanfic edits. I DID NOT COME HERE TO FIND OUT HE DIES WTF NOOO! GREAT! MY SHIP SUNK BEFORE IT EVEN SET SAIL!!
I don't think I'm gonna watch it anymore.
Rachel I’m so sorry! It was pretty devastating for us all.I wouldn’t watch either if I found out before I even got started good. You could watch a bunch of fan vids and get all their moments anyway.
that’s exactly what happened to me, i was heartbroken i dumped the whole show.
Seems aint alone here
I’m dead ass crying at 1 in the morning
I am very sad and disappointed with what they did. Sometimes I wonder: if they were going to kill him, why did they create a deeper relationship between him and Claire?
I will not watch the fourth season, I will not make it. Not without him. But I am very grateful for the moments of the two and for the wonderful videos I watched here too.
I hated the end of the season, and all I have left is to cry and cry.
But thank you for this video. Its amazing!
I'm going to miss the videos and Melendaire too. ❤😔
Thought this too. I almost would have rather they not went there since they knew they were gonna kill him off.
@@JenJiJ316 agree i wanted to see them go further with each other the writers let us down in not having this they let them have great moments then gave us this ending
@@barbaragrisinger1502 it could have been a great story because he is her boss. 😢
Not just for Claire, I actually really liked Dr.Melendez's character as a whole. He was a surgeon who thought outside the box, supported his residents even if it meant taking risks. That's what Good Doctors do, Shaun isn't the only one who deserves that title.
And Claire did not deserve this, after all the pain she went through, she was finally coming out of it and was able to admit to her feelings. She deserves better. Even if they want to make it look real, how do they expect a character as sensitive as hers to deal with two deaths of people she loved?
After watching that Melendez died, I don't want to continue watching.
My favorite couple of all times and show killed it 😟
I started CRYING as a baby as soon as the music started. Believe me i am in psysical pain after yesterday and i will never be able to watch this without feeling pain, i can't believe he is truly gone expecially in this was, expecially now that he knew she loved him back. The show will never be the same without him and for sure i won't watch it
Me too 💔😭
@@leehneis2032 and now that the actor replyed to my tweet and i found out he hopes his character could come back too i feel Even worst
@@federicamartino1490 ownnn 😭😭😭
@@leehneis2032 yep
@@federicamartino1490 really??
Thank you for this. I waited 3 seasons for something to happen between them, and finally there is just this horrible end. Claire don't deserve this. But when I see this video, I realize that the story that there was between Claire and Melendez is the most romantic of all the good doctor series. Let Melendez die is just a stupid idea, and it's useless to keep watching. The production broke our hearts, the audience will drop and it will be fair.
I agree totally. They had the best chemistry right from the start. ❤️
JenJi they want credibility but they kill melendez and not Vera. It's so stupid. Not credible. They wanted to create a dramatic love story, like Titanic, (the water that starts to rise with Shaun and Vera made me think of that too) but there was not even a single kiss! it's like ron would die in the last episode before kissing Hermione, while they love each other from the start. it's just foolish. They will soon realize their mistakes. (i am french sorry if you didn't understand)
JenJi I hope he will appear in Claire's dreams, or appear as Shaun's brother.
No... I refuse to believe it. And I don't even watch the show yet...maybe I never will after this. I always checked their scenes and I was so sure that they would be my new favorite ship if I start watching the show. It's sooo unfair...and this video made me cry. I'm so sad now... :( But thank you for making this epic vid.
Thank you. Yeah I would hold off on the watch. In fact, they went a whole season pretty much where there wasnt a whole bunch of movement for them. So you kind of felt like it was their time now. And then this... 😔
I can't. My heart can't 😭❤
😭
I am Brazilian and a watch to series, I really are very sad about the death of Melendez, I cried a lot, because there was no sense in his death, he was one of the protagonists and was expecting a lot in his appearance next seasons, I believe that the audience for Good Doctor will drop death bill for this character, as well as another series that I watched called The walkind Dead, I suffered a lot with the death of many characters that were protagonists of series and on account said the audience has lowered a lot.
In the end, I thought it unnecessary for them to have killed Melendez, but I will continue watching the series to see what will happen in the coming seasons. I loved your video JenJi, you are very talented. Stay in the peace and God bless you.
Aww thank you so much! Eu concordo com Melendez. Não foi necessário. Eu não vou continuar assistindo. Eu simplesmente não consigo lidar com o que eles o mataram. Também não assisti The Walking Dead desde sempre, mas eles tiveram muitas mortes de favoritos por lá.
BEAUTIFUL!!!! AH MY HEART IS BREAKING!!!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💔
Beautiful I’m in tears, thank you for this video
I can't beleive they did this. Can't get over his death
It was horrible for me. I balled and then balled adding those last scenes in.
@@JenJiJ316 ikr. Can you make more videos of them? I just miss them sooo much. 😭
@@JR-xz4zj Oh I will I'm sure. I just need a bit of a break to process what happened.
They deserved so much better😭💔
Do not give up on them please. Tag the writers on all the networks to make them understand they made a huge mistake. Let's try bringing him back!
Why it's so hurt?! 😭 Beautiful and sad
Am I the only one here who thinks he's not dead? I mean, we didn't SEE him died, and there's no flatline, it's possible that Claire cried in Lim's arms cause she thinks there's no hope left. Plus, I doubt Shaun even know about his condition, he didn't got his goodbyes. I'm not saying that suddenly he can help him or something but, there's still hope. Yeah the actor has done an exit interview, but maybe that's because they want us to think that he's dead so they can give us a heart attack next season. Just a theory tho.
Wow.. If this happens Dennis watch
I pray for that to happen but the actor who play dr Melendez stopped the serie so idk
maybe you're right
we'll see in season 4
i pray for that to happen please we need melendez and we need this relationship pleasee❤️ #bringbackmelendez
Yeah...well...I think that too...We'll see...I hope so much that!! It's necesary!!
I shipped them in the beginning but after I saw him with Dr.Lim I liked him when he was with her. Although I do like how their relationship was very pure .
What a beautiful video!! I hope that Neil be alive in season 4 please...we need to see him and we need to see Melendaire!!
BEAUTIFUL...I'm so sad what happened, this final episode just ripped me apart in so many ways especially with these two. :''( Why did he have to die?!
Oh dear
Such a sad ending...really thought there was more..will miss that picture
Thanks for this JenJi. I won't be watching season 4 either. I feel totally betrayed and abused by the producers. The writers ran out of ideas and decided to kill off my Melendaire ship before it even set sail. That was so messed up. I guess they thought it was a 'clever' twist but they took it too far..
I will be watching compilations like this over and over until I get over it.
You are welcome. 😊
This is such a well made video! It tells Melendez and Claire’s story very well!
Beautiful but so heartbreaking,time is something can't get back that's what makes this even more harder to watch.
It hurts seeing how many of us are really hurt by this situation. Still, I'm happy that so many of us are united by the same feelings, it makes me feel better. We must not give up on him and insist with bringing him back to the writers. Don't care how, shows have brought characters to life before, so.. I guess I'm gonna hold on to that hope. Try to do that on every network tagging thr writers and letting them know please!
Both deserved better 🥺💔
Welp, it physically hurts. and idk what to do with my life now.
Literally since the first time Claire flirted with Neil I was waiting for them to get together, and now that they have, he's dead.
Besides that, he was a favourite character, and I haven't cried this much since Season 3 of GoT.
Also, the creators said they killed him off because they knew it would have an emotional impact. First off, fuck them all, second off, this is bullshit, Melendez was the backbone of TGD.
Whoever replaces his character in S4 better not fuck up the story.
If he's replaced we could grow to like him which makes it even worse, because we won't have any reason to hate him or not to want him there. I WANT MELENDEZ. NO ONE ELSE
@@angelassinging I know RIGHT!?! I don't think I'll ever be 100% okay with the show now that Melendez isn't there anymore
I wanted them to kiss,,, sooooo badly. If I don't see them together in very first episode of next season, I am so done with the show.
Never i had been this much dissapointed about a show.lets wait and see how next season ratings gonna shock writers.atleast try and compebsate now.bring him back.pls shaun bring us a miracle
Moving, It hurts me
Still hurt
Amazing video! This song is heartbreaking, but I love it! Melendez first scene was with Claire and his last one too :(
I can't believe he's gone, it was outrageous, unacceptable and anticlimatic! Only 3 doctor came to say goodbye to one of their own, I expected more commotion at the hospital, and the way Lim and Melendez walked out of that room talking about getting drinks and not even covering Melendez body... Seems like he was asleep not dead. Not to mention that didn't seem like they tried a lot of things to save him! We never saw him coding or being intubated! Maybe they had an idea between his last scene with Claire (at night) and the morning final scene. Also, Lim was talking about getting drinks with Claire! WTF! Almost seemed like they were laughing! If Melendez is gone that was really bad writing.
I guess we'll have to wait.... Just can't wrap my head around the ideia that they would kill such a beloved character if Nicholas Gonzalez didn't ask to leave (what he did not).
All of what you said.... Like every word!! All this went through my head as well. It was weird and badly done. It seemed rushed not that I needed it to be dragged out. But it was rushed and they tried nothing. 😒
@@JenJiJ316 the way Lim and Claire walked out of that room** I was nervous when I wrote it haha
Yeah, they tried to fit a lot of things into one episode... Didn't work out at all
@@amandakassis way too rushed and impersonal on many levels.
Thank you for the video. Every time I watch such kind of videos about Melendaire I can't stop crying. Killing him off is a creative decision? Never. It's cruel. It's bullshit.
I love Shaun and Lea, but this couple needs to be put along with a normal couple to see the differences and difficulties that they have in life. That's why Melendaire is so appropriate and matches the frame.
Now they ruined everything. There is also a biased view on Claire as a color woman, and it's not good at all if they steal every good things from her life.
This is a TV show, not real life. For me, I need to watch something that could balance my life because life is harsh enough that I don't need david shore teaching me how harsh it is. Poor him. A pig, he is!
they could really rewrite the whole ending for the beginning of season 4. Like Claire was daydreaming during the surgery and created a whole alternative ending she snaps out of it saves him and they fall in love. PERIOD. I dislike this show now I’m upset
bruh i was literally waiting since season 1 for these two to be together and they had to kill him???? bye
For me the most senseless thing was why they chose to kill him off, that's why I am ot even bothering to sign petitions to bring him back or anything like that. I will only watch S3 and that's it, I love Claire with all my heart and this is not about what they did to Melendaire but more about of how the producers, writers, directors are deciding to manage the show, because if you feel like killing a character simply because it will cause a major impact I think you shouldn't be producing a show like the Good doctor, you should something else. So good The good Doctor t was a gud ride
I agree with all you said. Sadly we are in a time of shock value. Also, a show used to be about what the audience connected with and wanted. But now it's a case of what the writers think is best.
@@JenJiJ316 which doesn't make sense at all. They can stay with their show.
Awesome video..as always....loved it❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks so much! 😊
I don't get it. Why did they do that? It was too emotional for me. First of all I was crying and then I was angry asf.I don't know what now. I don't wanna watch it anymore. Or might watch it just for Claire....
This edit is so amazing! Thanks for that.
I understand how you feel. It was way too heartbreaking for me
Thank you. And I was devastated. I love Claire but I can't watch her move on to someone new knowing they never went there with her and Neil.
JenJi I agree!
I am going to fight to #bringbackmelendez whatever it takes
I didn' know the couple neither did show but You Tube suggested me some videos about them and I loved it! I loved the chemistry between them so much so I was about to start watching " Good Doctor", but now there is no point
:( I am very sad.
im crying so fucking hard
Is there any possibility that maybe Claire and Shaun got hurt and all of this was some kinda of coma dreams.. And Melendez still alive??.. I want hope.. Can't handle this.. 😢😢
I hopee 😔😔
At the moment I see Lea fall into the ground because of the earthquake i immediately thought it was a Shaun's dream it seemed unrealistic the way people reacted
Will not be watching either bc I read the interview as well. They didn't need to kill him off.
What pisses me off is the fact that David Shore And Daniel Dae Kim went all season long getting everyone's especially Melendaire fans hopes up of thinking that they were going to put Neil and Claire together if they NEVER had any intentions on making them a fuckin couple that's what's pissing me off here! I completely understand there's other characters on the show and it's not just based around Nicholas's character or on Claire and Melendez but what was the point of having them grow closer and spending all that time together and building a relationship if they were just planning on killing off Melendez? I don't understand. Cause in my opinion if they NEVER had any intentions on making them a fuckin couple then they should've just kept their relationship completely on a platonic level and had not even went down that road because all it accomplished was piss me the fuck off excuse my french. Now has far as that bullshit article I read I just found it complete bullshit and completely comical because Limlendez fan's are making these stupid ass assumptions and are coming up with these ridiculous theories like Neil wasn't really in love with Claire and he only said I love you to her because he was on his death bed give me a damn break! No one put a gun to Neil's head and made him say I love you to Claire he did that all on his own, if he honestly didn't love Claire or had no romantic feelings for her than he didn't even have to respond or acknowledge that she even told him she loved him he could've ignored it but instead decided to say I love you to Claire. Even Claire wasn't sure when she blurted out I love you to Neil if he even felt the same way about her but took a risk and told him anyways because she wanted him to know. And Limlendez's theory on how Neil still has feelings for Audrey because he made the statement I could spend a life time drinking whiskey with you, really? You got he still had feelings for her off that one statement? I honestly wanted to laugh my ass off! Just because he made that statement to Audrey doesn't necessarily mean that he meant it romantically or that it meant that he still had feelings for her how people came up with that ridiculous concept is beyond me, he could've easily meant having a glass of whiskey with her has a friend, I swear people read way to into shit. Not to mention Limlendez fans must really NOT pay attention very well because Neil told Shaun in another episode that he was completely over Audrey and Jessica so where they got this ridiculous concept that Neil's still into Audrey is beyond me. And here's another thing if Neil honestly was "Supposedly" So in love with Audrey which he NEVER was in love with her but ok he had every opportunity to tell her he loved her and didn't instead decided to say I love you to Claire. And same thing applies to Audrey has well if she was so in love with Neil she also had every opportunity to tell him she loved him when they were together saying their goodbyes and didn't and this is the couple that is "Supposedly" so in love with each other? Give me a break. Plus, here's another ridiculous theory from Limlendez fans they claim he's NOT in love with Claire because when she goes to say something to him he cuts her off and says DON'T! We all know the reason he really did that was because he wanted Claire to focus on other patients and not just on him and knew there was still a crisis going on in the hospital and knew they needed all the doctors available it had absolutely NOTHING to do with him NOT loving her. We all know the only reason Limlendez fans are making these stupid ass assumptions and saying stupid shit like Neil wasn't really in love with Claire and he only said he loves her because he was on his death bed is because their pissed he didn't end up with Lim and he was in love with Claire and NOT her.
I have also had the thought of I would have rather they even not go there with Melendez if they were going to kill him off. I get so confused as to their reasoning for it all.
@@JenJiJ316 same. It didn't make any sense
Let's hope he is still alive
Please I can't accept it
As I said to someone before, I need an April's Fool on this one.
yey another Melendaire video where I can complain about the last episode 😃😃
What they did to them was so disrespectful honestly I’m not even gonna watch the show anymore
I'm so mad. They didn't even get them a chance to develop. I hope this doesn't turn out the same as Grey's anatomy
Thank you for making such a beautiful video! ❤
Thank you so much 😊
😭🥺 The vídeo is really good.
Thank you Silvia!
Writers literally destroyed my favourite ship ever and I am so pissed off. I feel that I have thrown three years in the garbage waiting for nothing. My only hope is that Neil is not really dead but he experienced the NDE, he went through a tunnel full of light and he came back to life thanks to God. It would be an interesting plot .
I keep thinking that episode after episode they come up with ways in impossible situations to save people. But when it came to Neil, it was like he is going to die and they barely spent time on trying to come up with solutions...just not what the show has been about. Neil, Claire and Shaun were my favorite characters. I felt if one of these left(which obviously Shaun is the show so he wouldn't), I wouldn't be able to watch.
And I ship alot of couples but only ship a few couples hard....this was one of them.
@@JenJiJ316 I didn't care about the other characters excepting Neil and Claire. I have followed the show basically for them. The actors really fit in their roles and it seems that they were really in love . If Nicholas was not married I would have shipped him with Antonia in real life too ahhha they make me crazy; however I hope that Melendez really came to life after a NDE experience. It is the only thing that I can imagine.
Yes very sad ending. They had amazing story beautiful chemistry truly the only reason I watched the show I saw it from season 1 so 1, when he winked at her and I have patiently waited for this and then nothing. It sucks they didn’t even get to kiss but I feel their chemistry friendship mutual respect admiration and love spoke volumes it was always in the eyes for them. 😞
@@lynnmartin4896 my dream is that Nicholas and Antonia make a movie together where they kiss wildly, touch everywhere , and fuck as two animals.😄 a fantastic dream for a bisexual like me. We deserve something like that.
Love them😭❤❤❤#melendaire
It was heartbreaking to watch
Yes it was. One reason I didn't put more of it at the end...just too much. 😭
Made me cry
HE IS ALIVE!!!MORAN POST it💜
So he is coming back ??
I really hope so💔
For me he and she are alive happily together, married and with a beatiful kids...1,2 or many as Neil convince Claire to have...and they live their cute story so many time...so many years, they have their forever. And...so much people thinks the same than me...so, I think: If someone keeps their story just like that....so, Melendaire will continue...no matter what.
Just know they won’t be getting a season 5. I never even tuned in to see Sean. I hate Morgan, lim is kinda Irrelevant and park is cool. That’s pretty much it
Yeah.
Não me conformo 😢😢😢😢
Somos dois😭😭😭😭
We are 3
Can't believe they took Melendez from us. But we can't stop having hope with the " #bringbackmelendez" movement on Twitter, IG, and Facebook. And please sign the petition: chng.it/vk9jrwSqry if you want the lovely Neil Melendez back with us in Season 4, so we can continue to see his character blossom
Amazing melendaire video can you do a video of them to if the world was ending by jp saxe and Julian Michaels
Oke but like, they said he would be dying of a septic shock, right? But sepsis is treatable... why did they didn’t do anything, or did I miss something?
Exactly...well according to them his shit was leaking rather quickly. Does septic shock even kill someone that fast?
As far as I know something else had ripped open and bacteria was spreading quickly through his sytem, unfortunately there isn't a cure for that :/
I kept hoping Shaun would come in and devise this miracle plan as he so often does... But no, the creators just wanted shock value.
Sea Bird Yes, but I did so,e reading up on it, because I thought sepsis can be treated. Not in all cases, obviously, but even bad cases can be turned around. You just have to treat the patient, but they didn’t do anything. So I really don’t like how they choose sepsis as his death reason, when medically speaking, he could have been saved. Seems like lazy writing just get it done with.
What's up name of the song you used 😭😭😭😭
This is a really great video
Thank you so much!
Melendez was the nicest,sweetest, funniest, handsomist, best character in the whole show.why did you kill him?Not fair.
What kind of bullshit is this. Did they really kill him? What the hell !!!! Are the writers that stupid !!
Nice
💔
I can't believe you guys killed him off. Can't anyone be happy on your show? Not watching anymore.
Happiness seems not to be what writers want to write. And I definitely need more happiness.
Cami Hayes me too
What episode in 1:46? Please
Hellen Rodrigues season exactly 3, and episode 9 or 10
Episode 9 ,it's called incomplete
😭😭😭😭😭😭
Amazing video,hope he didn't die maybe we will see in season 4
Thank you! Nothing wrong with hope. 😊
No me dolio....
😭
You deserve to be happy 🦉
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
Je sur désolé pour mon docteur préféré il sans vait ????? Pauvre Claire😢😢😢😢😘
Oui, il était aussi l'un de mes préférés 😭
Great 💕💕💕💕💕💕
Thank you😊
A Time For Us
Can u please make a video of Claire and Neal using Taylor Swift's Enchanted? Thank you :)
I will be doing a giveaway in the next week when I hit 1000 subscribers. So if you aren't subscribed, pleaee do for a chance to get a vid of your choice. It will be only open to my subscribers before I launch my giveaway video.
Muita sacanagem matar ele. Não assisto mais
Sim, eu também não estou assistindo.
Esse era o meu casal favorito ♥️
@@kakau5032 Eu entendo completamente. Eu os amava muito.
Por que gente???? Pq justo ele? Ninguém nessa serie merece morrer! Muito menos ele! Sacanagem!!! Eu quando vi comecei a chorar! Nunca chorei tanto como de terça feira pra cá! Muito triste mesmo. Estou morta por dentro e fora.
Ele morreu?
Worst final ever!
Eu não acredito que ele vai morrer
Rosangela Bras Eu gostaria de acreditar que ele também não morreu.
You guys are sooo toxic, I’m sure it was a difficult decision to do that in the recent episode
😭😭😭😭😭😭