Hello sir What is your opinion about Kuzmina's work especially with regards to her take on similarities between Vedic pottery and Andronovo(Fedorovo) pottery and similarities house construction of vedic and andronovo cultures In chapter 5 of her book named "Origin of Indo-iranians" specifically in pages 80 to 84 she explains pottery similarities In chapter 4 she explains about house constructions What she says regarding similarities in ceramics is true? Can you please give your opinion So please consider answering this I will be waiting for your reply If possible give your opinion in a video
I have published one article dealing with the chapter of this book of hers (in Russian). It (her book) is very weak. It has almost nothing to say about the real evidence of the putative steppe 'Aryan' incursion into India in the bronze age. In fact this chapter is her confession of her inability to trace archaeologically and anthropologically the migration from the steppe region to India.
@@Indo-European_Studies can you please elobrate on this or possibly make a video in English to educate intrested people like me I really want to know your arguments If not possible atleast provide a link to your Russian article so that I may look into any ways to translate it
@@vturn2247 Семененко А.А. О предполагаемой миграции андроновцев в Индию из Евразийской степи и Средней Азии во II тыс. до нашей эры // Научные ведомости Белгородского государственного университета. Серия: История. Политология. Экономика. Информатика. - № 13 (132). - 2012. - Выпуск 23. - С. 5-10. ( www.academia.edu/13003418/ ) On the putative Andronovan migration into India from Eurasian steppe and Central Asia in the II millennium B.C.
@@vturn2247 the best thing is to translate this huge discussion: AIT versus OIT: дискуссия на "Генофонд.рф" (составление, корректура, редактирование, предисловие, сноски и приложения Семененко А.А.) / А.А. Семененко, И.А. Тоноян-Беляев, Е.В. Балановская, О.П. Балановский, Я.В. Васильков, В.В. Запорожченко, Л.С. Клейн, А.Г. Козинцев, С.В. Кулланда, В.А. Новоженов. - Воронеж: На правах рукописи, 2015. - 846 с. - ISBN 978-5-9907439-0-8. ( www.academia.edu/17214310/ )
Hello sir
What is your opinion about Kuzmina's work especially with regards to her take on similarities between Vedic pottery and Andronovo(Fedorovo) pottery and similarities house construction of vedic and andronovo cultures
In chapter 5 of her book named "Origin of Indo-iranians" specifically in pages 80 to 84 she explains pottery similarities
In chapter 4 she explains about house constructions
What she says regarding similarities in ceramics is true?
Can you please give your opinion
So please consider answering this
I will be waiting for your reply
If possible give your opinion in a video
I have published one article dealing with the chapter of this book of hers (in Russian).
It (her book) is very weak.
It has almost nothing to say about the real evidence of the putative steppe 'Aryan' incursion into India in the bronze age.
In fact this chapter is her confession of her inability to trace archaeologically and anthropologically the migration from the steppe region to India.
@@Indo-European_Studies can you please elobrate on this or possibly make a video in English to educate intrested people like me
I really want to know your arguments
If not possible atleast provide a link to your Russian article so that I may look into any ways to translate it
@@Indo-European_Studies sir
Have you seen my request?
@@vturn2247 Семененко А.А. О предполагаемой миграции андроновцев в Индию из Евразийской степи и Средней Азии во II тыс. до нашей эры // Научные ведомости Белгородского государственного университета. Серия: История. Политология. Экономика. Информатика. - № 13 (132). - 2012. - Выпуск 23. - С. 5-10.
( www.academia.edu/13003418/ )
On the putative Andronovan migration into India from Eurasian steppe and Central Asia in the II millennium B.C.
@@vturn2247 the best thing is to translate this huge discussion: AIT versus OIT: дискуссия на "Генофонд.рф" (составление, корректура, редактирование, предисловие, сноски и приложения Семененко А.А.) / А.А. Семененко, И.А. Тоноян-Беляев, Е.В. Балановская, О.П. Балановский, Я.В. Васильков, В.В. Запорожченко, Л.С. Клейн, А.Г. Козинцев, С.В. Кулланда, В.А. Новоженов. - Воронеж: На правах рукописи, 2015. - 846 с. - ISBN 978-5-9907439-0-8.
( www.academia.edu/17214310/ )