In future( should happen sooner to take on the competition) when MG comes out with a bigger battery, they should ensure that it fits in the existing model as well, then they can have the sales chart sky rocketing.
One thing after being an auto enthusiast for so many years.... Zig wheels have always been interesting true to it's DNA... Not biased to any brand... Putting the facts to the face rather than polishing... All thro these yrs ther hav been so many new auto blogs and even more the old auto review channels feel a bit biased today... This is completely my opinion and always feel the trust when watching this channel... Moreover you cover the more practical bits of an every day driver and tech bits as well.... Today other channels try too hard with all making it too much not covering the basic objective of making a review... Thanks a lot zig wheels ❤
Wrong. It's reliability. Nobody wants to become an awara kutta in an open road with their family due to unknown battery and BMS failure with 80-90% battery still left 😂😂😂.
Booked Mid variant Windsor EV from Ghaziabad, dealer giving delivery in mid Feb 2025 and asking to shift from Mid variant to base model as life time warranty on battery will not be applicable after 31st dec 2024. Please suggest if this is right or wrong. Should i go with base model or wait for mid variant till feb 2025
Sir, I will pay for battery and I will take car for finance - in that case what they will say? - when they say payfull ......or get loan for car and battery .......or loan for battery........ then why not pay for battery and loan for vehicle ? like instead of BaaS i want to go VaaS(vehicle as a service)
@@utubefreak7167 Then I can escape from the trap - when they can decide and finance a single product as two product... then what I am claiming is also correct.... customer will also say get lost when their T&C (Hidden) is understood - or They will buy the whole vehicle - say bye bye to BaaS
@@utubefreak7167 Do you know - if you choose pay per kms use(Vidyut scheme) - you have to pay a security deposit amount - go and ask the dealer - then you will say the same to them
@@utubefreak7167 the same tf you got triggered (using tf)🤣 - Baas is already there in south east asian countries as "swap" - ather is also provides lease program which includes BaaS and VaaS(in a different way) - they(MG) were not able to bring the SWAP- instead they bring BaaS.. they finance by spliting a single vehicle in to two. I am asking for vehicle to get financed and battery to get bought by me. Root cause is them (the company) - I am already educated Mr. utube"freak"7167.
Without a bigger battery and being such a huge car it does not qualify for family car or highway car... Better they could have brought a small car with this battery pack..... It might be a good choice for corporate executives travel within city or to bring expats from Airport to the office within city... They would love it....
There is too much of build up for this car from many channels I really doubt its credibility. More influencing for this car. This is not so radical design.
Removable battery are the best with the finance options and fixed sunroof are really bonus as safety... Certainty a big market disruptive....Tatas and Mahindra too should offer such options... otherwise we will soon see more Chinese cars on our road ❤.
1. 38KW -220 Range 2. No physical buttons 3. Computer touch screen -not works properly 4. No spare wheel 5. Limited servicing centers 6. Over priced 7. Front view -0 8. Difficult to drive 9. No speed 10. Ac not working properly 11. High maintenance 12. 200range
This is an almost perfect ev. Battery as service works so well with swap. By giving modular batteries, can't ruleout MG's swap ambitious. But FWD doesn't work with swap. Take for eg 1000s of Nio swap stations. They are all designed for RWD vehicles. RWD would have also liberated a larger frunk. 3 row seating is a miss too. Without a spare wheel that space should have been allocated for the 3rd row occupants footwell. EV and its elimination of the gear-selector needs to be celebrated by reintroducing the good old 60/40 front row seats not a skateboard.
Imp things missing Button controls, auto boot Long route highway driving is not an option... Poor ac...garmi mein papad ban jayega 55 kwh -60 kwh battery options missing
Tata tiago 12lakh ki padti hai with very cheap range like 170km...esliye ye car must buy product ho skti h with 9.9lakhs rs with BAAs program. Thousand times better than tiago i guess.
@@krishnasahu2294 ok. The way I see it is that it costs 11 lakhs in China and 13 lakhs with battery in India. With 80% indigenous parts. Why should there be any premium at all? With the whole world turning away from BEVs, it seems very myopic to be a late adaptor and learn lessons even later. Good luck to all who buy, especially since the battery and the bms may be sourced indigenously and who hasn't heard of HV critical error these days. Mr Jindal is a shrewd businessman and he was on the carbon credits bandwagon years ago. I am merely saying that buyers have to be shrewd too.
Except for bigger size and big screen It didn't get anything right. Punch gets your 10 percent more range due to its less weight Punch si better to drive in cranked up spaces Glass roof consumes more power in hot summer Safety wise the unconventional design will get less crash rating The main purpose of buying Windsor is spacious rear passnger comfort. But the rear suspension is worst. They didn't tune it well. So a whole miss from rear side.
I own the Punch EV and it's been a fantastic experience. What it loses to Windsor in terms of Space is gained back in terms of Safety, Range, Ride quality, Footprint and Toughness to go anywhere. Ofcourse Windsor is good VFM, but horses for courses.
It has 190+ range at 90 speed ..wtf ..who will buy this..those 40000 booked customers will regret after 6 months...after 6 months in olx ..good codition windsor available for sale at 6-8 lakh 😂😂
Punch ev the best and the best of all , why ? What’s the reason anybody shocked at the budget of 13.80 lakh it gives the good music system , ground clearance , traffic mainly a car which is small , good long range , and no petrol no diesel just enjoy , 🇮🇳 made . 😎, not mg Windsor omg it’s just a toy for indian road bumping in the road , sound inside , low quality , more over small humps it keep shaaaaaaking 😂
I have taken test Drive for both Punch and Windsor. I will tell you this, Punch is just typical average Tata car. Poor interior, horrible sitting, a lot of body roll. Where as in Windsor I got incredible comfort (I have ankylosing spondylitis, so for me sitting comfort is most important), back seats are also very comfortable, rich interior. Also they are giving lifetime warranty on battery. There is absolutely no comparison between Punch and Windsor. After taking test drive of several cars, I booked Windsor yesterday. After getting the feel of Windsor there is no way any sane person will go for Punch.
Dont like the range ...reduce claimed range by atleast 25 percent in day to day travel The ranges claimed by all evs are under optimal conditions of echo mode Highway par kon 70..80 ke beech chalata hai..250 ki range ayegi iski normal conditions me...gadi innova jitni wide hai ..bahut bulky hai City drive is not going to be easy with bumber ti bumper traffic
@@ZenoSamaOmniKing Which "foreign" country? And what are the tax rates on cars there? Is it like the 28% GST+ 20% Cess tax on ex showroom price plus road tax, registration tax plus 18% GST on insurance in India?
@@ZenoSamaOmniKing you said "then only car will survive". As if it's the companies that are causing the price inflation. You could've just said India needs lower tax.
I think this could be a a game changer...the cabin is a clinical brilliance.
200km range ..its bullshit
Can't be, when you have better options like curvv ev with real world range of atleast 360 km and the newly launched be6e.
In future( should happen sooner to take on the competition) when MG comes out with a bigger battery, they should ensure that it fits in the existing model as well, then they can have the sales chart sky rocketing.
One thing after being an auto enthusiast for so many years.... Zig wheels have always been interesting true to it's DNA... Not biased to any brand... Putting the facts to the face rather than polishing... All thro these yrs ther hav been so many new auto blogs and even more the old auto review channels feel a bit biased today... This is completely my opinion and always feel the trust when watching this channel... Moreover you cover the more practical bits of an every day driver and tech bits as well.... Today other channels try too hard with all making it too much not covering the basic objective of making a review... Thanks a lot zig wheels ❤
Thank you so much! Your kind words mean the world to all of us at ZigWheels!
How could they not understand that Indian buyer's single largest concern with EVs is RANGE !!!
you are right .... when I put the same comment - people do not agree
Its price as well, no one will buy 500 range car for 25 lakhs as well.
@@Imperial791 Then need to engineer for low cost - any way they are collecting premium for the technology - then why not.?
@@sprakashaiht they did thats why you are getting 4.3 meter vehicle with a 38 kwh battery pack with loads of features for only 13.50 lakhs,
Wrong. It's reliability. Nobody wants to become an awara kutta in an open road with their family due to unknown battery and BMS failure with 80-90% battery still left 😂😂😂.
Putting aside everything and all problems with the car, this is THE most BEAUTIFUL car in this segment in India right now! ❤
This review is so factual and covers all the required info for one to make a decision
I have the zs ev for 2/3 years
I like it enough to want to get this beauty also
So if the touchscreen gets screwed, you get screwed, unlike Tata or Mahindra evs
Fixed sun roof is big big and very big plus point for this car 👌🏻
Yes 👍...
Great review
But if the wheels were not static it can confuse the driver when mapping so that’s why perhaps …speaking of 3d mapping
Can anyone throw light for exchange for scrapping an old car? Is MG giving any additional discount for the same with a scrapping certificate
I'm surprised by MG's work for Indian market, cause they are taking risks and winning the game
ahead of any brand in India.
This is failure
For the price being I think it'll attract a lot of buyers. From look seats seems too much soft and the design will hurt for long drives.
Range 190-200km
I'd love to buy one but I'm in Australia.
In BAAS, How the Finance will get to know per month Kms consumption. how they will fetch the real time data and bill gets generated
is mg afterservice is best..??
is mg ev cars are reliable..??
is mg ev car battery are safe??
Booked Mid variant Windsor EV from Ghaziabad, dealer giving delivery in mid Feb 2025 and asking to shift from Mid variant to base model as life time warranty on battery will not be applicable after 31st dec 2024. Please suggest if this is right or wrong. Should i go with base model or wait for mid variant till feb 2025
Sir, I will pay for battery and I will take car for finance - in that case what they will say? - when they say payfull ......or get loan for car and battery .......or loan for battery........ then why not pay for battery and loan for vehicle ? like instead of BaaS i want to go VaaS(vehicle as a service)
They’ll say get lost and don’t come back
@@utubefreak7167 Then I can escape from the trap - when they can decide and finance a single product as two product... then what I am claiming is also correct.... customer will also say get lost when their T&C (Hidden) is understood - or They will buy the whole vehicle - say bye bye to BaaS
@@utubefreak7167 Do you know - if you choose pay per kms use(Vidyut scheme) - you have to pay a security deposit amount - go and ask the dealer - then you will say the same to them
@@sprakashaiht why tf are you so triggered? It isn’t like BaaS is a new concept. Get educated
@@utubefreak7167 the same tf you got triggered (using tf)🤣 - Baas is already there in south east asian countries as "swap" - ather is also provides lease program which includes BaaS and VaaS(in a different way) - they(MG) were not able to bring the SWAP- instead they bring BaaS.. they finance by spliting a single vehicle in to two. I am asking for vehicle to get financed and battery to get bought by me. Root cause is them (the company) - I am already educated Mr. utube"freak"7167.
Without a bigger battery and being such a huge car it does not qualify for family car or highway car... Better they could have brought a small car with this battery pack..... It might be a good choice for corporate executives travel within city or to bring expats from Airport to the office within city... They would love it....
Very soon this will be choice of Bangalore EV Cabbies! Perfect receipe for airport and cuty commute!
Everything is good but Range..?
Actually found Windsor EV very impressive 🔥🔥
Like the unique look...very different from other EV's. lifetime warranty on battery thus no hassle of maintenance and Baas 😄😄
Test it in may in rajasthan with ac on...sheekh kabab banega kya...we will see people putting in newspapers in windows for lesser heat...
There is too much of build up for this car from many channels I really doubt its credibility. More influencing for this car. This is not so radical design.
Better than tata products
😂😂, its waste ..just 190km range at 13-14 lakh or 10 lakh + subscription
Removable battery are the best with the finance options and fixed sunroof are really bonus as safety... Certainty a big market disruptive....Tatas and Mahindra too should offer such options... otherwise we will soon see more Chinese cars on our road ❤.
Everything is exceptional for the price but the range. The single biggest deal braker
Good city car. Need another petrol car with this in garage.
1. 38KW -220 Range
2. No physical buttons
3. Computer touch screen -not works properly
4. No spare wheel
5. Limited servicing centers
6. Over priced
7. Front view -0
8. Difficult to drive
9. No speed
10. Ac not working properly
11. High maintenance
12. 200range
@@rajanikanthreddy9823 do you own this car?
Buy an AMT and own the car, no range anxiety, no m monthly payment done to the company
This is an almost perfect ev.
Battery as service works so well with swap. By giving modular batteries, can't ruleout MG's swap ambitious. But FWD doesn't work with swap. Take for eg 1000s of Nio swap stations. They are all designed for RWD vehicles. RWD would have also liberated a larger frunk. 3 row seating is a miss too. Without a spare wheel that space should have been allocated for the 3rd row occupants footwell. EV and its elimination of the gear-selector needs to be celebrated by reintroducing the good old 60/40 front row seats not a skateboard.
Woah! this windsor design really look appealing and range in also good, slowly it's becoming a good option to go😅
Why is no one talking about the super slow touchscreen. A deal breaker for sure!
Need Range test in real road test..
Nexon ev45 vs Windsor ev on real world range and pick up
Everything on the screen which is slow, I like buttons man
MG should swap battery size between zs and Windsor, that would suit better
I thought CUV means " confused utility vehicle" 😂🤣
Taking ev in local (morris)garage is like asking a plumber to fix wifi 😂
Auto gear hai kya
Imp things missing
Button controls, auto boot
Long route highway driving is not an option...
Poor ac...garmi mein papad ban jayega
55 kwh -60 kwh battery options missing
Looks like honda jazz
Tata tiago 12lakh ki padti hai with very cheap range like 170km...esliye ye car must buy product ho skti h with 9.9lakhs rs with BAAs program. Thousand times better than tiago i guess.
AC should have been more powerful
This model similary with Wuling Cloud in Indonesia 😂😂
Cheap Chinese car selling at a premium to perfect fools. Wuling?
That's not Chinese bro 80% going to be localized and it's JSW MG, Windsor at this pricing has already disrupted the market.
@@krishnasahu2294 ok. The way I see it is that it costs 11 lakhs in China and 13 lakhs with battery in India. With 80% indigenous parts. Why should there be any premium at all? With the whole world turning away from BEVs, it seems very myopic to be a late adaptor and learn lessons even later. Good luck to all who buy, especially since the battery and the bms may be sourced indigenously and who hasn't heard of HV critical error these days. Mr Jindal is a shrewd businessman and he was on the carbon credits bandwagon years ago. I am merely saying that buyers have to be shrewd too.
@anandagoswami7373 Cost of production is cheaper in China plus the taxes on electric cars there is lower too.
When you talk about thigh support, you must mention your height
Looks like Toyota Lucida. and Old Daewoo Matiz
MG knockout Punch
Except for bigger size and big screen
It didn't get anything right.
Punch gets your 10 percent more range due to its less weight
Punch si better to drive in cranked up spaces
Glass roof consumes more power in hot summer
Safety wise the unconventional design will get less crash rating
The main purpose of buying Windsor is spacious rear passnger comfort. But the rear suspension is worst. They didn't tune it well. So a whole miss from rear side.
@@premkuamr6343Punch is the worst car ever…!
Tata punch is a junk car
I own the Punch EV and it's been a fantastic experience. What it loses to Windsor in terms of Space is gained back in terms of Safety, Range, Ride quality, Footprint and Toughness to go anywhere.
Ofcourse Windsor is good VFM, but horses for courses.
@@premkuamr6343 So you are trying to compare an elevated hatchback with a crossover.
It has 190+ range at 90 speed ..wtf ..who will buy this..those 40000 booked customers will regret after 6 months...after 6 months in olx ..good codition windsor available for sale at 6-8 lakh 😂😂
Punch ev the best and the best of all , why ? What’s the reason anybody shocked at the budget of 13.80 lakh it gives the good music system , ground clearance , traffic mainly a car which is small , good long range , and no petrol no diesel just enjoy , 🇮🇳 made . 😎, not mg Windsor omg it’s just a toy for indian road bumping in the road , sound inside , low quality , more over small humps it keep shaaaaaaking 😂
I have taken test Drive for both Punch and Windsor. I will tell you this, Punch is just typical average Tata car. Poor interior, horrible sitting, a lot of body roll.
Where as in Windsor I got incredible comfort (I have ankylosing spondylitis, so for me sitting comfort is most important), back seats are also very comfortable, rich interior. Also they are giving lifetime warranty on battery.
There is absolutely no comparison between Punch and Windsor. After taking test drive of several cars, I booked Windsor yesterday. After getting the feel of Windsor there is no way any sane person will go for Punch.
MG is selling Chinese cars rebranding them....But Teek hai..
Dont like the range ...reduce claimed range by atleast 25 percent in day to day travel
The ranges claimed by all evs are under optimal conditions of echo mode
Highway par kon 70..80 ke beech chalata hai..250 ki range ayegi iski normal conditions me...gadi innova jitni wide hai ..bahut bulky hai
City drive is not going to be easy with bumber ti bumper traffic
It’s pretty easy to drive due to multiple features.
Need real range test
Yah to fiat multiplia jaisa dikh Raha Hai Na, ekadam badsurat
Kitne paise mile peefect batane ko
Ev Range is disappointing!
EVs have fire risk
Its not even a car. Its just a toy
Tata Tiago and punch laughing at corner for this toy car..
This toy car gonna rule the ev sector. Unlimited battery warrenty that's enough. No others can give that offer.
Mahatma Gandhi Windsor.
Why such cartoonish front look?
Windsor
.Look Like Rich Old Man who wear COSTLY Suit, Watch, Shoes ..But .. Can not able to Walk Long.
Looks terrible
indian market needs big suv with 14 lac and approx 600 km range
then only car will survive
You'll get that when you get a big plate of quality mutton biryani at a good restaurant for just Rs50.
@@SPM_SS in foreign u get in 14 lakh rupees only
@@ZenoSamaOmniKing Which "foreign" country? And what are the tax rates on cars there? Is it like the 28% GST+ 20% Cess tax on ex showroom price plus road tax, registration tax plus 18% GST on insurance in India?
@@SPM_SS that's what I'm saying the tax on cars is too much but on ev is 5% only
ev suv big costs 15 lakh as I wanted :)
@@ZenoSamaOmniKing you said "then only car will survive". As if it's the companies that are causing the price inflation. You could've just said India needs lower tax.
Chinese toy car
Worst design of all time