Big props for mentioning ELOY - they have produced so many albums, always stable Prog from Western Germany. We father has tought to love them, as well as early Genesis and ELP. Now I am even much deeper into Prog, admiring all those wonderful tunes.
Hasta ahora, de lo poco que conozco, mi top personal es: 1- Pink Floyd 2- King Crimson 3- Genesis 4- Tool 5- Kansas 6- Yes 7- Alux Nahual 8- The Moody Blues Es muy probable que a medida vaya escuchando más bandas mi top pueda ir variando
El top 4 está muy bien, pero van deer graff y gentle giant por debajo de Kansas??? Y faltan las bandas italianas como PFM, Le orme o Banco, Gong, Gnidrolog, Soft machine...y los holandeses de Focus!
@@angeltorres8745, obviamente! Pero sólo expresé mi parecer, de acuerdo a mis gustos. Y el video está de acuerdo al criterio de quién lo hizo... todo es subjetivo
King crimsom es innovador en todas sus etapas, sin bajones de calidad, algo que ni Pink Floyd pudo lograr. Y Génesis en su mejor momento teóricamente fue el mejor en cuanto a nivel compositivo, escucha firth of fifth (se me complica el nombre por favor que alguien me corrija) esa introducción de piano a nivel compositivo es lo mejor que se a creado en el progresivo. Y Pink Floyd es el mas emotivo en sus canciones y conceptos. Para mi estan bien enumerados en la lista King crimsom primero Genesis segundo Pink Floyd tercero Algo ademas es que king crimsom hizo la mejor cancion de la historia que es starless algo que suma puntos
Bands like Aphrodite's child,focus,supertramp,curved air,moody blues are missing, but king crimson deserves 1st place, the only competitor who can beat him is pink floyd.
Me ha alegrado mucho que en el ranking aparezca UK,una banda muy olvidada,compuesta por John Wetton Eddy Jobson y Terry Bozzio.Aqui en España los vi en un programa de TV,llamado Pop-grama por 1980 o 81.Compre su disco en directo Night After Night hace unos 40 años.Aun tengo el vinilo,off course.
Would've loved some more diversity, not only English/American bands. In my opinion italian bands Premiata Forneria Marconi and Banco del Mutuo Soccorso deserve to be here. Edit: I see Eloy is here, my bad. Still, RPI deserves a spot 😁
Rush has little to do with Yes or Genesis. They made prog albums like Hemispheres or Farewell but most of their discography has nothing to do with progressive rock.
The Beach Boys and a few other American Bands mix the flour as well as add the sugar to the recipe. The Beatles have bake the cake and forgot about it. The Moody Blues had eaten the cake. After they eaten the cake, the Moody Blues share the recipe.
i dont quite get the point of dropping pink floyd moody blues and curved air, what is progressive in there? why not Savoy Brown Humble pie and Pearls before swine then? gordon lightfoot? because they have a style?
L'ultima Non la conosco le altre Ok!!!!! Mi piacciono tutte!!!!!! Però potevano anche starci es CURVED AIR, STRAWBS, SOFT MACHINE,HENRY COW,EGG, GONG, HATFIELD & THE NORTH, NATIONAL HEALTH, PROCOL HARUM, MOODY BLUES, FOCUS, EKSEPTION, TRAFFIC, COMUS, DRAGON, TRIUMVIRAT, FAMILY, ASIA,CATAPILLA MARSUPILAMI etc !!!!!!!! Poi vogliamo dare anche uno sguardo a CASA nostra??? PFM BANCO DEL MUTUO SOCCORSO, ORME, AREA, OSANNA, DELIRIUM, BALLETTO DI BRONZO, ROVESCIO DELLA MEDAGLIA, QUELLA VECCHIA LOCANDA, LOCANDA DELLE FATE, ALPHATAURUS, CIRCUS 2000, NEW TROLLS, GOBLIN,TRIP, MAXOPHONE, ALLUMINOGENI, ACQUA FRAGILE, BUON VECCHIO CHARLIE, SEMIRAMIS, MUSEO ROSENBACH, JET, APOTEOSI, JUMBO, PERIGEO, ARTI & MESTIERI, NAPOLI CENTRALE, DEDALUS, CERVELLO, METAMORFOSI etc anche NOI abbiamo avuto delle progressive rock bands di gran livello!!!!!!!
Y hay más(aceptando el kraut rock también como música progresiva).Gravy Trains,Agitación Free,Eela Craig,Variations,Tangerine Dream,Can,Faust,Cluster,Popol Vuh,Birth Control,Nektar,Gong-Davied Allen,Magma,Nucleus,Wallanstein,Fermata,Tako,Imán,etc. Pero la selección de los 20 grupos y solistas que propones es muy buena,sin duda.Saludos.
Tercera y última reseña de grupos Mr.Juleson,porque lo poco agrada y lo mucho cansa.Premiata Forneria Marconi,Focus,Embryo,Ted Nugent & The Amboy Dukes,Black Sheep,Indian Sumer,Tear Gas,Satín Whale,King Ping Meh,Dragón,The Trip,Ash Ra Tempel.Incluso podríamos incluir también a Iron Butterfly.Cosas de Uriah Heep,como la suite Salisbury o canciones como Shadows of grief.De Led Zeppelin The rain song o No quarter.No olvidar a los pioneros Moody Blues y Procol Harum.Y aquí lo dejo Mr.Juleson.Un saludo cordial.
Permítame,Juleson,poner correctamente el nombre a 3 de las bandas mencionadas:Gravy Train,Agitation Free e Indian Sumer.Los 2 primeros fueron cosas del algoritmo y el tercero error mío.Ok.
Finalizó.Se me quedaron en el tintero gente diversa como Steve Hillage,Family,Spyro Gira,Brainticket,Mainhorse,Jerónimo,Toad y hay más,pero concluyó ya aquí.
1 Hot Rats- zappa 2 Thick as a brick -tull 3 Bundles-Soft Machine 4Larks tongues in aspic-Crimson 5Close to the edge-Yes 6Physical Graffiti-Led 7Three Friends-Gentle Giant 8South Saturn Delta-Hendrix 9Meddle-Pink Floyd 10Third-Soft Machine 11Waka Jawaka-Zappa 12Are you experience-Hendrix 13 Heavy Horses-Tull 14In the court of the crimson-king-crimson 15Presence-Led 16Going for the one-Yes 17The soft Parade-the doors 18Construção-Chico 19O clube da esquina-Milton 20Alagbon close-Fela Kuti
The debate has gone on for 50 years. What is prog rock in comparison to pure rock music. Agree with most of the list but some groups are not prog rockers. Plus no Porcupine Tree
Zappa/Mothers is top 5 at worst. 1. Genesis 2. Pink Floyd (only prog album, so no Piper etc) 3. Zappa/Mothers (only prog albums, otherwise a clear winner) 4. Yes 5. Gentle Giant 6. Jethro Tull 7. King Crimson The rest are all much worse (but by no means bad), be it Camel, Rush or Van Der Graaf.
Big props for mentioning ELOY - they have produced so many albums, always stable Prog from Western Germany. We father has tought to love them, as well as early Genesis and ELP. Now I am even much deeper into Prog, admiring all those wonderful tunes.
Finally someone put camel in the list
- Gennesis
- Pink Floyd
- Yes
- Jethro Tull
- Moody Blues
- Barclay James Harvest
I would’ve put Rush and Gentle Giant higher, but a great list overall.
Wishbone Ash released an excellent all instrumental album called Noveau Calls back in the 80's
Great list❣️ Short and Effective as it should, well done 🤗
Can we please get the names of the songs featured in the video?
Do you not consider Porcupine Tree a prog band or do you not find them good or influential? Thanks for the video!
Big exclusion!
Hasta ahora, de lo poco que conozco, mi top personal es:
1- Pink Floyd
2- King Crimson
3- Genesis
4- Tool
5- Kansas
6- Yes
7- Alux Nahual
8- The Moody Blues
Es muy probable que a medida vaya escuchando más bandas mi top pueda ir variando
Очень рекомендую ещё Emerson, Lake & Palmer 👍🏻
Особенно первые 4 альбома.
El top 4 está muy bien, pero van deer graff y gentle giant por debajo de Kansas??? Y faltan las bandas italianas como PFM, Le orme o Banco, Gong, Gnidrolog, Soft machine...y los holandeses de Focus!
Son solo 20, no pueden estar todas las que tú quieres.
@@angeltorres8745, obviamente! Pero sólo expresé mi parecer, de acuerdo a mis gustos. Y el video está de acuerdo al criterio de quién lo hizo... todo es subjetivo
Italian bands suck
@@martinbarrios7920 porqué son tontos. kansas no existe seriamente. VdgG and Gentle giant es arte clasica.
Yes is #1
Excellent your selection. But I would include No 21 Focus from the Netherlands
Good list, I can think of a few more that I personally love, but if I did a list it would be more than 20.
Frank Zappa, such a great band
He was a one man band. Ok, not really.
King crimsom es innovador en todas sus etapas, sin bajones de calidad, algo que ni Pink Floyd pudo lograr.
Y Génesis en su mejor momento teóricamente fue el mejor en cuanto a nivel compositivo, escucha firth of fifth (se me complica el nombre por favor que alguien me corrija) esa introducción de piano a nivel compositivo es lo mejor que se a creado en el progresivo.
Y Pink Floyd es el mas emotivo en sus canciones y conceptos.
Para mi estan bien enumerados en la lista
King crimsom primero
Genesis segundo
Pink Floyd tercero
Algo ademas es que king crimsom hizo la mejor cancion de la historia que es starless algo que suma puntos
Interesting selection. Could do with a bit longer on each band. I don't necessarily agree with the order but nobody else would either
Bands like Aphrodite's child,focus,supertramp,curved air,moody blues are missing, but king crimson deserves 1st place, the only competitor who can beat him is pink floyd.
Agreed
you mean the first supertramp
Very good ! Banco , PFM, Triumvirate missing , but oh well
excelente elecciòn
My top 20:
1) King Crimson (1)
2) Pink Floyd (3)
3) Genesis (2)
4) Yes (4)
5) Camel (5)
6) Emerson Lake & Palmer (6)
7) Kansas (9)
8) Jethro Tull (7)
9) Rush (8)
10) Marillion (14)
11) Van Der Graaf Generator (12)
12) Alan Parsons Project (15)
13) Moody Blues
14) Porcupine Tree
15) Eloy (11)
16) Caravan (18)
17) Gentle Giant (10)
18) IQ
19) Premiata Forneria Marconi
20) Tool
Honorable mentions:
Renaissence (19)
UK (17)
Focus
Procol Harum
Banco dil Mutuo Socorso
Mahavishnu Orchestra?
And the group Saga???
Me ha alegrado mucho que en el ranking aparezca UK,una banda muy olvidada,compuesta por John Wetton Eddy Jobson y Terry Bozzio.Aqui en España los vi en un programa de TV,llamado Pop-grama por 1980 o 81.Compre su disco en directo Night After Night hace unos 40 años.Aun tengo el vinilo,off course.
El Top-7 es modélico.Exacto.
gentle giant? gong? magma? can? pfm? soft machine?
colosseum I and II? nope nothing rien nada.
still not convinced that PF is P.
Would've loved some more diversity, not only English/American bands. In my opinion italian bands Premiata Forneria Marconi and Banco del Mutuo Soccorso deserve to be here.
Edit: I see Eloy is here, my bad. Still, RPI deserves a spot 😁
Genesis, Yes, ELP in that order. Nursery Cryme the greatest prog album ever created.
Foxtrot.
Kayak , Strawbs , COLOSSEUM , HATFIELD at North , Supertramp,
@@pietrostronati1667 hatfield and the north yes, amazing!
@@pietrostronati1667 supertramp only the first album, to me.
1. Yes
2. Emerson, Lake and Palmer
3. Pink Floyd
4. Renaissance
5. Jethro Tull
6. Moody Blues
7. Genesis
8. Rush
9. Alan Parsons
10. King Crimson
Where is Uriah Heep???
Me da la impresión que muchas portadas se vieron influenciadas por Un The Court Of The Crimson King. Eso no hace más que alimentar su leyenda
Rush has little to do with Yes or Genesis. They made prog albums like Hemispheres or Farewell but most of their discography has nothing to do with progressive rock.
My personal top 5 has pretty much the same bands
1. Pink Floyd
2. Genesis
3. Yes
4. Jethro Tull
5. King Crimson
I know it’s not the most original 😅
Renaissance lower than Alan Parsons Project or Kansas??? No way!
Yes should be number one. Good list anyway though.
Eloy 🔛🔝
No meu podiun, colocaria em primeiro: Yes, Gênesis, ELP,.
@@clodoaldopereira8754 si los peores.
1 Genesis.
What about jane band from Germany
King Crimson is amazing
Jade Warrior?
The Beach Boys and a few other American Bands mix the flour as well as add the sugar to the recipe.
The Beatles have bake the cake and forgot about it.
The Moody Blues had eaten the cake. After they eaten the cake, the Moody Blues share the recipe.
Frost and Devin Townsend would be here if this were a list including current bands!
i wouldve put elp, gentle giant and van der graaf higher but great list nonetheless
Decent list. RUSH should be top 5 at least.
After genesis and yes i don't care.
@@soothsayerbh1038 beatus ille simplex.
King Crimson absolute The best Aphrodites Child-666 progressive music missing.????
i dont quite get the point of dropping pink floyd moody blues and curved air, what is progressive in there? why not Savoy Brown Humble pie and Pearls before swine then? gordon lightfoot? because they have a style?
is Blodwyn pig prog? no! ok they're the best but not prog! lets stop putting anything in that bag.
L'ultima Non la conosco le altre Ok!!!!! Mi piacciono tutte!!!!!! Però potevano anche starci es CURVED AIR, STRAWBS, SOFT MACHINE,HENRY COW,EGG, GONG, HATFIELD & THE NORTH, NATIONAL HEALTH, PROCOL HARUM, MOODY BLUES, FOCUS, EKSEPTION, TRAFFIC, COMUS, DRAGON, TRIUMVIRAT, FAMILY, ASIA,CATAPILLA MARSUPILAMI etc !!!!!!!! Poi vogliamo dare anche uno sguardo a CASA nostra??? PFM BANCO DEL MUTUO SOCCORSO, ORME, AREA, OSANNA, DELIRIUM, BALLETTO DI BRONZO, ROVESCIO DELLA MEDAGLIA, QUELLA VECCHIA LOCANDA, LOCANDA DELLE FATE, ALPHATAURUS, CIRCUS 2000, NEW TROLLS, GOBLIN,TRIP, MAXOPHONE, ALLUMINOGENI, ACQUA FRAGILE, BUON VECCHIO CHARLIE, SEMIRAMIS, MUSEO ROSENBACH, JET, APOTEOSI, JUMBO, PERIGEO, ARTI & MESTIERI, NAPOLI CENTRALE, DEDALUS, CERVELLO, METAMORFOSI etc anche NOI abbiamo avuto delle progressive rock bands di gran livello!!!!!!!
Faltan algunos.Coloseum,Bent Wind,Gila Steamhammer,Tíbet,Mammut,Jenghiz Khan,Mushroom,Ammon Duul,Henry Cow,Freedom,Strange Fox,Indeksi,Triana,Dalton,Xarhanga,Ex Ovo,etc.etc.
Y hay más(aceptando el kraut rock también como música progresiva).Gravy Trains,Agitación Free,Eela Craig,Variations,Tangerine Dream,Can,Faust,Cluster,Popol Vuh,Birth Control,Nektar,Gong-Davied Allen,Magma,Nucleus,Wallanstein,Fermata,Tako,Imán,etc. Pero la selección de los 20 grupos y solistas que propones es muy buena,sin duda.Saludos.
Tercera y última reseña de grupos Mr.Juleson,porque lo poco agrada y lo mucho cansa.Premiata Forneria Marconi,Focus,Embryo,Ted Nugent & The Amboy Dukes,Black Sheep,Indian Sumer,Tear Gas,Satín Whale,King Ping Meh,Dragón,The Trip,Ash Ra Tempel.Incluso podríamos incluir también a Iron Butterfly.Cosas de Uriah Heep,como la suite Salisbury o canciones como Shadows of grief.De Led Zeppelin The rain song o No quarter.No olvidar a los pioneros Moody Blues y Procol Harum.Y aquí lo dejo Mr.Juleson.Un saludo cordial.
Permítame,Juleson,poner correctamente el nombre a 3 de las bandas mencionadas:Gravy Train,Agitation Free e Indian Sumer.Los 2 primeros fueron cosas del algoritmo y el tercero error mío.Ok.
Indian Summer.Ahora si.
Finalizó.Se me quedaron en el tintero gente diversa como Steve Hillage,Family,Spyro Gira,Brainticket,Mainhorse,Jerónimo,Toad y hay más,pero concluyó ya aquí.
Tull , Pink Floyd , and Yes top 3 .
King crimson?
Genesis is better than JT
@@brunomantovaneli6076 Imo Genesis was a little too experimental for my taste . Big fan of Peter Gabriel solo stuff .
Why is Kayak always missing?! A very underrated topband from the early 70's that should be in every list!! A hidden treasure.
Yeah, first place is definitely Pink Floyd, they have the number one spot just with Echoes.
you havent listen to enough king crimson then
@@trapitogamer999pro4ive listened to all king crimson. Floyd are still no 1. Because they and the moody blues did it first. Not Itcock
@@doscwolny2221 it doesn't matter who did it First but who did it better it's what matters, also, the First pink floyd records arent prog
1 Hot Rats- zappa
2 Thick as a brick -tull
3 Bundles-Soft Machine
4Larks tongues in aspic-Crimson
5Close to the edge-Yes
6Physical Graffiti-Led
7Three Friends-Gentle Giant
8South Saturn Delta-Hendrix
9Meddle-Pink Floyd
10Third-Soft Machine
11Waka Jawaka-Zappa
12Are you experience-Hendrix
13 Heavy Horses-Tull
14In the court of the crimson-king-crimson
15Presence-Led
16Going for the one-Yes
17The soft Parade-the doors
18Construção-Chico
19O clube da esquina-Milton
20Alagbon close-Fela Kuti
Toto?
🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
Frank Zappa è fusion
What?? 1st place-Pink Floyd
The debate has gone on for 50 years. What is prog rock in comparison to pure rock music. Agree with most of the list but some groups are not prog rockers. Plus no Porcupine Tree
No A.D.2 Or Hawkwind. or can...oh well!
Ne pas mettre Brave en avant pour Marillion... Aie...
Listen my song.. Novel V'lazz
Where are the Italian bands?
Rush should be higher on the list!!!
I just creamed my pantaloons.
Eso es que has escuchado the creaminal record de Rick Wanke Man.
Right selection, wrong order. Should be:
1. Pink Floyd
2. Yes
3. King Crimson
4. Genesis
5. Rush
6. Emerson, Lake and Palmer
7. Camel
8. Jethro Tull
9. Gentle Giant
10. Frank Zappa
why pink floyd and yes higher than king crimson?
Zappa/Mothers is top 5 at worst.
1. Genesis
2. Pink Floyd (only prog album, so no Piper etc)
3. Zappa/Mothers (only prog albums, otherwise a clear winner)
4. Yes
5. Gentle Giant
6. Jethro Tull
7. King Crimson
The rest are all much worse (but by no means bad), be it Camel, Rush or Van Der Graaf.
If you wanna a cure from insomnia look for Pink Floyd recordings.
or better yet Tangerine Dream.
That would be radiohead
I don't think this is the correct top 20
La mejor banda de todas no está .....los jaivas de chile
Yes and Genesis created more brilliant albums than King Crimson
Wrong
@@table7195 King Crimson didn't have a stabile stuff
Wrong²
@@Gabriel-uq6iq go to Wikipedia, dork
@@folker412 that’s what made them unique.
Faltan grupos esenciales y Kansas , por ejemplo , muy sobrevalorado