Im a christian. But i agree with this philosopher. Philosophical reasoning has a limit. It cannot be compared to spiritual experience and it should be applied within the framework of divinity.
“Over-reliance on reason.” He has nailed it! I was aversed to philosophical learning coz i saw it as a threat to complete trust in the divine as a Christian, but now i see the coherence. We should rely on reason but not ‘over-rely’! 😮. Surely, there is an infinite power unlimited by reason and that is God. I understand.
This is the problem I had with the catholic church. An overreliance on human reason, even so much that my local priests talk more about Aquinas in their sermons than Jesus. These same arguments for and against using reason as the ultimate way to understand god existed between the Catholic and Orthodox churches. Gregory Palamas vs. Aquinas.
Thanks to Al Ghazali, philosophy became more discussed in academia than before. Remember in ghazalis book he discarded 3 concepts of falasfa but agreed with 17 concepts of falasfa, eventually it's all about progressive studies
Fundamental religious principles are incompatible with reason. Also, why do people keep claiming that they know the “reality of God” because they read writings of people who did not even know that the earth went around the sun?
you might have an opinion today regarding morality. And assume in 50 years science discovers that the solar system has more than 30 planets. would that discount all your opinions? Also there was a strong group of philosophers like beruni who believed earth went around sun
The title of this video diaplays a high level of ignorence on the part of the uploader. Al ghazali had a war on inrrational and abusrdist reasoning that vailed itself as philosophical logic and reason. In fact his aim was to purify philosophy from absurdism and illogic.
He is not against philosophy in the sense of thinking and giving opinion( what you said reverse engineering) he is against opinion/doctrine from the philosopher that against Islam
Im a christian. But i agree with this philosopher. Philosophical reasoning has a limit. It cannot be compared to spiritual experience and it should be applied within the framework of divinity.
“Over-reliance on reason.” He has nailed it! I was aversed to philosophical learning coz i saw it as a threat to complete trust in the divine as a Christian, but now i see the coherence. We should rely on reason but not ‘over-rely’! 😮. Surely, there is an infinite power unlimited by reason and that is God. I understand.
This is the problem I had with the catholic church. An overreliance on human reason, even so much that my local priests talk more about Aquinas in their sermons than Jesus. These same arguments for and against using reason as the ultimate way to understand god existed between the Catholic and Orthodox churches. Gregory Palamas vs. Aquinas.
@@adsffdaaf4170 so you left catholicism
Yeah but christinity is not natural it is based on bible
Islam is natural religion based on Intuition
Thanks to Al Ghazali, philosophy became more discussed in academia than before. Remember in ghazalis book he discarded 3 concepts of falasfa but agreed with 17 concepts of falasfa, eventually it's all about progressive studies
Nice music, I think there was some talking aswell but I couldn't hear well
🫣
some of it is repeated but still was very good and fascinating.
Ye video needs a bit polishing
How about averrouse book critizing this book?
It's on the way.
Philosophy is our reverse engineering process. Its a seriously needed tool.
Fundamental religious principles are incompatible with reason. Also, why do people keep claiming that they know the “reality of God” because they read writings of people who did not even know that the earth went around the sun?
because you have not read the incoherence of the philosophers
@@hamzali84 I have. And, the principle that religion must influence government and be mutually reinforcing is one that I profoundly disagree.
you might have an opinion today regarding morality. And assume in 50 years science discovers that the solar system has more than 30 planets. would that discount all your opinions?
Also there was a strong group of philosophers like beruni who believed earth went around sun
Some points feel repeated a lot which was frustrating to watch
I agree. I'll pay attention to that in the next videos.
I see alghazali defending the ressurection.
Ressurection is Islamic
The title of this video diaplays a high level of ignorence on the part of the uploader.
Al ghazali had a war on inrrational and abusrdist reasoning that vailed itself as philosophical logic and reason.
In fact his aim was to purify philosophy from absurdism and illogic.
If you cant join in their mess, confuse them.
?
he wasnt against philosphy at all
Did you read Ghazali? Yes/No?
He is not against philosophy in the sense of thinking and giving opinion( what you said reverse engineering) he is against opinion/doctrine from the philosopher that against Islam
Is this all just an AI project?
AI tools + A researcher in philosophy and religious studies