Javed Akhtar's candid conversations are always a pleasure to listen to. Whatever topic he discusses, he speaks openly, without hiding his understanding or knowledge. From his religious or non-religious beliefs to his career in the film industry, relationships, failures, and successes-he shares his insights without holding back. His words resonate deeply, and perhaps there’s no other poet in modern India like him, who not only masters the art of Urdu poetry but also engages thoughtfully in discussions on various subjects.
A child born in a Muslim family is a Muslim. No point in pretending that Muslims are made and not born. This is so about any religion. It is a different thing if you believe in the Supreme Being or not.
There is nothing like Atheist Muslim,its either Atheist or Muslim. Unlike Other religion A muslim is muslim by belief and Karma and not by Name and surname
यह धार्मिक नहीं है , नास्तिक है , लेकिन जब मरते है तो कहां दफन होते है , मैं तो वहीं रहता हु जहां यह लोग रहते है , जब कैफ़ी आज़मी मरे तो कहां दफन हुए ,
There is nothing like a religious person... Either you are a human or a dumb human.... Any religion is the worst thing happened to humankind...it only divides ppl... All the countries relatively religious are the one suffering... All the countries which mostly dnt give much importance to religion and even if they do then it's within their homes...are the countries which are developed and all religious 3rd world countries dream to go to the countries which are not religious and have better life..this is brutal fact..if ppl come out of their god fearing mindset and accept all other humans as humans only and don't differentiate or discriminate or hurt then everything will be ok..
I was a liberal for a major portion of my life,but when i saw the debate between Sam.Harris and Ben Afleck a few years back, i realised that we are all in favour of stopping discrimination against minorities, empowering women and we all believe that dignity is a fundamental right of evey individual, however whenever it comes to implementing the same is muslim majority countries all liberals turn a blind eye.
well we can see that in India what is happening to minorities.. just one hindu nation and see what is the result imagine 57 hindu nations and what they will do. by the way out of 57 muslim countries how many are at unrest apart from those having oil? sati, gandhari, draupadi etc wale hume batayege women empowerment😂😂😂
I am an 'Atheist Theist' I believe and disbelieve in God at the same time 😅 After all, people in the entertainment industry are there to entertain us 😂
@@mohdyasir9023 Clearly you have no understanding what atheism is..... It doesn't have any culture.... Its a position of denying the superior being bcoz lack of evidence.
@@mohdyasir9023 you clearly don't know what atheism stands for..... Atheism is denying a proposition of theists due to lack of evidence for it. Hence, atheists don't have specific pre-defined /pre-determined culture.
@knightspygaming1287 there is no such thing as cultural mulslim or atheist Muslim. Being Muslim has nothing to do with culture. There are 2 billion Muslims belonging from almost every culture. These are coping mechanisms of atheist coming from Christian, Hindu or other religious backgrounds. Religious people of these backgrounds might have bowed down to this ideological hypocrisy. Muslims won't.
Listening to Sir Javed at 2 am ..and couldn't sleep without saying words of appreciation to one of the best soul that India has ... respect to you sir ...so much to learn from you everytime...hope god give u more life with abundance good health nad mind ❤
I love Javed Akhtar's intellect. I am aure the whole world, knowingly or unknowingly, is intellectually moving towards the same path which Javed Akhtar has taken.
You come across people who say things that you want to hear, and that person becomes intellectual. 'Atheist Muslim' is oxymoron. It's the belief that makes one a Muslim; you don’t become Muslim by just being born to Muslim parents. Those saying one can be culturally Muslim and be an Atheist by belief need to know that Islam is not a culture. It's a religion with certain necessary beliefs; you reject or leave that belief, and you are automatically out of its fold. Its like saying I am an 'Atheist Theist'. You can't and disbelieve in God at the same time. Logical impossibility!!!
@@mohdyasir9023 one of the very real problems is that muslims have a right to kill other muslims for officially leaving their religion, as apostasy is a crime as instantiated by all four schools of Islamic Jurisprudence. so if you were an atheist but born in a Muslim family, you would have to claim some Islamic identity or you would be cast out of the family or killed. There are many such cases in Islamic communities. In other communities also, but more so in Islam
theres no such thing as an atheist muslim. Its an oxymoron. Youre either a muslim or you are an apostate. Islam is black and white and the quran is absolutely clear on what makes a true muslim. People like Javed only serve to provide a cover to deflect attention away from the true atrocious and supremacist, exclusionary doctrine of islam as found in its primary sources, which is the quran and life of muhammad.
@@mohdyasir9023Exactly. What such pseudo atheist ex-muslims mean to say is, 'Though we don't practice the hate and violence against non-muslims as prescribed in Isl@m but we won't inspire & influence our future generations if they want to practice hateful concepts like JIH@D through our S@T@NIC CU£T of HAT€, £IES, D€ATH & P€RV€RSIONS. 🙏 🙏
@@mohdyasir9023AbsoFlutely. What such pseudo atheist ex-muslims mean to say is, 'Though we don't practice the hate and violence against non-muslims as prescribed in Isl@m but we won't inspire & influence our future generations if they want to practice hateful concepts like JIH@D through our S@T@NIC CU£T of HAT€, £IES, D€ATH & P€RV€RSIONS. 🙏 🙏
Every religion teaches us the discipline of life and the importance of family structure, guiding us on how to live with certain actions and principles. We must be careful not to hurt the feelings of religious people, as it goes against humanity and can hurt many individuals' pride and beliefs. I respect all religions and even those who are atheists. It’s essential to give respect and receive respect in return. HUMANITY IS GREAT!
It's quite obvious... Family circles, culture, good habits are gonna be part of the muscle memory. Even though u don't believe in the faith u were born in it will b not possible for u to share a Pepperoni pizza with me, and I will respect that
Ovais, that is a perfectly reasonable place to be in for any individual. For outsiders, the most important issue is not any "faith" itself but one's stand on faith-related human aspects - be they conflicts between individuals or conflicts between groups. That's where the tension between faith and non faith exists and is the hardest to manage..
When I get some free time, I like watching public intellectuals, especially those who share a similar background, like ex-Muslims who are now atheists. Because of this, TH-cam has started suggesting me a lot of videos of Javed Akhtar. I’ve been listening to him for a while now, and every time, I feel amazed by his way of telling stories. I remember watching him on Zee Classic’s program back in the day and being impressed even then. Javed Akhtar would probably never imagine that someone from a small, remote village in the Karakoram Mountains would become such a big fan of his rational approach. But here I am, in the middle of these towering mountains, never getting tired of listening to him again and again. His thoughts and words are always so powerful, and they leave me thinking every time.
No, it isn't. There are Atheist Jews, Atheist Hindus, Atheist Christians and so on. People who identify with the culture of their upbringing but do not believe in the theology. This is quite common in the world. You need to look at the world, and look past the narrow and simplistic narratives found in the hyper religious politics of India.
Not it is not. Atheism is not a religion. People can be born in a Muslim family and be atheist. There are several. Same with Hindus, Christians and people of other faiths. There is nothing duplicitous here. There is no conspiracy against you. Calm down.
'Atheist Muslim' is oxymoron. It's the belief that makes one a Muslim; you don’t become Muslim by just being born to Muslim parents. Those saying one can be culturally Muslim and be an Atheist by belief need to know that Islam is not a culture. It's a religion with certain necessary beliefs; you reject or leave that belief, and you are automatically out of its fold. Its like saying I am an 'Atheist Theist'. Logical impossibility!!
I disagree. why are you taking the literal meaning of the word.. it no longer means that alone. it also applies to someone who is simply born in that faith and has nothing todo with it like Javed akhter. there are many muslims who worship their ego, babas, dargah. by your definition they won't be muslim anymore then
@salmansyed5837 what do you mean 'It no longer means that alone ' ? Should words have some meaning or one can make a meaning of their own? How will we communicate if we make language subjective? So if you tell me that you are a Muslim, what's the next question I should ask is, do you believe in God? 😀 Can we agree that being a Muslim is religious identity and once you decide to leave that religion why can't you just identity as your new identity? Why can't Javed Sb. just say that he is an Atheist. If a Christian converts to Islam, how should he identity himself.., A "Christian Muslim'? What you have said about dargah and all is a different matter. Those people believe in God and Prophets and consider themselves follower of the Religion..., whether they are doing it correctly or wrongly is a different discussion.
@@mohdyasir9023 words have multiple meanings. Richard Dawkins calls himself a cultural Christian so does Javed ab. Muslim can be person simply born in the faith
@@mohdyasir9023 yes there is a limit. We don’t randomly give meaning to words they evolve over decades. Muslims literally means submitting to god but it no longer means that alone in today’s time. It can mean a religious group , a cultural group etc. I am aware of fanatic atheist never heard cultural atheist.
The "cult" in fact does not love death more than the other loves life. He is making that up. They just believe that achieving martyrdom (shahada) - AKA freedom fighters and innocent women and children being butchered - is the best way to die because it’s for a true cause. It's honestly fucked up that he's making this argument because he is absolving the criminals of all their crimes and blaming the victims for their religious beliefs.
lett me break it down in simple words, if an extremist from another religion wants to burn down every muslim's house, Javed Akhtar saying, 'I'm not Muslim, I'm an atheist,' wouldn't save him. They wouldn't care, they'd burn his house down regardless. Islam is a part of his identity that he can't just dissociate from. And he’s fully aware of the paradox so you’re not exactly offering any intellectual breakthrough by pointing it out.
Atheist Muslim is an Oxymoron. A Muslim is someone who believes in Towhid and Khatm-e-Nabuwat. Javed Akhtar is not a Muslim no matter what he calls himself
@@Jay-b5b8y LOL you can't be a atheist Muslims since Islam has death penalty for apotasy. Hindus or Jews can be atheists within their traditions since their traditions do allow for non belief and there is a strong cultural aspect to it.
@@Jay-b5b8y He's right though..... Not all Religious ideologies/identities are the same or have the same fundamentals...... Hinduism is comprised of a very diverse set of ideas & beliefs that even include Agnostic & Atheist schools of thought while Jew is very much an Ethnic identity along with being a Religious identity..... Hence, one could definitely claim to be a Atheist Hindu or an Atheist Jew but when it comes to being a Muslim, one has to adhere to a very specific core ideology & being a Muslim isn't considered to be an Ethnic identity either.... The 1st condition to be a Muslim is to believe on 'Allah' & accept him as the one & only true 'God'. Because of such reasons, the term 'Atheist Muslim' is indeed an Oxymoron.
After watching this interview, I realized that Javed Akhtar lacking knowledge beyond writing social stories and poetry. He mentioned that Hajj and Eid existed before Islam, which is incorrect and misleading. It’s surprising that he didn’t provide more logical or informed answers, especially on matters of faith,.
Bro, you can totally be an Atheist Hindu because Hinduism doesn't really have a strict, structured definition. It's not like Islam, which is a consistent monotheistic faith. Dhruv Rathee, for example, calls himself an Atheist Hindu. He doesn't believe in God but still follows Hindu traditions."
I love you Javed Akhtar. Live long! You are opening up minds. Keep speaking. I love you and Shabana so much. May Allah swt protect you both eternally and all of your true loved ones along with us. Duas upon duas for your soul. I love you. Sincerely, Madiha
For all great intellectuals writing comments should know its humanity which is superior to all relegion.. During pandemics & other great disasters its humanity that supersedes everything..while in peace we have frivolous issues to discuss.. Be kind to everyone & the world will change.
@@afb123 Yes it is. In Hadith Sahih Bukhari (52:260) - it clearly States "...The Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' " Also in many Sharia ruled Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia Afghanistan Iran apostasy laws exist, where leaving religion is punishable by death. So it's not me, but you who should be educated about your religion, which invokes death upon free will
@@afb123It is an offence punishable with death. If you leave your religion and be vocal about it and point out mistakes in Islam, it is punishable with death.
@@afb123 No in several Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia Iran Afghanistan has apostasy law where leaving Islam is punishable by death. Either you don't know this or just doing Taqiya
HINDUISM - is Universal in Spirituality, has Diversity in Divinity ,promotes Unity in Humanity & Nature. WHAT IS SPECIAL ABOUT BEING A HINDU ? - By Francois Gautier. 1) Believe in God ! - Aastik - Accepted 2) Don't believe in God ! - You're accepted as Nastik 3) You want to worship idols - please go ahead. You are a murti pujak. 4) You don't want to worship idols - no problem. You can focus on Nirguna Brahman. 5) You want to criticize something in our religion. Come forward. We are logical. Nyaya, Tarka etc. are core Hindu schools. 6) You want to accept beliefs as it is. Most welcome. Please go ahead with it. 7) You want to start your journey by reading Bhagavad Gita - Sure ! 8) You want to start your journey by reading Upanishads - Go ahead. 9) You want to start your journey by reading Purana - Be my guest. 10) You just don't like reading Puranas or other books. No problem my dear. Go by Bhakti tradition . ( bhakti- devotion) 11) You don't like idea of Bhakti ! No problem. Do your Karma. Be a karmayogi. 12) You want to enjoy life. Very good. No problem at all. This is Charvaka Philosophy. 13) You want to abstain from all the enjoyment of life & find God - jai ho ! Be a Sadhu, an ascetic ! 14) You don't like the concept of God. You believe in Nature only - Welcome. (Trees are our friends and Prakriti or nature is worthy of worship). 15) You believe in one God or Supreme Energy. Superb! Follow Advaita philosophy 16) You want a Guru. Go ahead. Receive gyaan. 17) You don't want a Guru.. Help yourself ! Meditate, Study ! 18) You believe in Female energy ! Shakti is worshiped. 19) You believe that every human being is equal. Yeah! You're awesome, come on let's celebrate Hinduism! "Vasudhaiva kutumbakam" (the world is a family) 20) You don't have time to celebrate the festival. Don't worry. One more festival is coming! There are multiple festivals every single day of the year. 21) You are a working person. Don't have time for religion. Its okay. You will still be a Hindu. 22) You like to go to temples. Devotion is loved. 23) You don't like to go to temples - no problem. You are still a Hindu! 24) You know that Hinduism is a way of life, with considerable freedom. 25) You believe that everything has God in it. So you worship your mother, father, guru, tree, River, Prani-matra, Earth, Universe! 26) And If you don't believe that everything has GOD in it - No problems. Respect your viewpoint. 27) "Sarve jana sukhino bhavantu " (May you all live happily) You represent this! You're free to choose, my dear Hindu! This is exactly the essence of Hinduism, all inclusive .. That is why it has withstood the test of time in spite of repeated onslaught both from within and outside, and assimilated every good aspects from everything . That is why it is eternal !!! There is a saying in Rigveda , the first book ever known to mankind which depicts the Hinduism philosophy in a Nutshell -" Ano bhadrah Krathavo Yanthu Vishwathah"- Let the knowledge come to us from every direction.
That's what is called "bina sar pair ka" Hinduism is so shallow you think? Today's Hindus are so scared or desperate to make Hinduism inclusive bcz they arevafraid they are a minority religion (globally)
Please change the title an atheist is the opposite word of the word muslim....Muslim means a person who believes in Islam and Islam believes in Only one Allah who is supreme ...where as a person who shed this belief and became a non believer is called 'Murtadd' and not atheist Muslim..
Have utmost respect to javed. As like Javed , I am an Atheist, culturally Hindu, intellectually scientist, ethically buddhist, ethnically Tamil Dravidian.
Christmas’s origin is the pagan winter solstice festival in many parts of Europe which was turned to a Christian festival. But it was Pope Julius 1 that linked the day with Jesus’s birth. So basically church leaders in their christianisation project just co-opted existing pagan festivals. Another example is Easter from the pagan festival of Eostre, goddess of fertility.
The moment I see Javed Saab I go CLICK, immediately! Always learning something astonishing new. Thank you Barkha Mam🙏 Greeeting from South America, Suriname
Javed ji, you are the most lovable atheist. There is so much to learn from you -especially, your positive attitude and appreciation of this life. Also, the examples of words and language you gave are so fasinating.
lett me break it down in simple words, if an extremist from another religion wants to burn down every muslim's house, Javed Akhtar saying, 'I'm not Muslim, I'm an atheist,' wouldn't save him. They wouldn't care, they'd burn his house down regardless. Islam is a part of his identity that he can't just dissociate from. And he’s fully aware of the paradox so you’re not exactly offering any intellectual breakthrough by pointing it out.
I found it unprofessional on the interviewer’s part that when Javed Sahib started talking about his past struggles with hunger and got emotional, it was fine up to that point as it reflected genuine feelings. However, he continued sniffling later in the interview and even asked for a tissue. This could have been edited out; what was the point of keeping it in the interview? Were they trying to increase ratings by showing that they didn’t edit out any parts to keep it "authentic"? They likely edited out many other parts, but here it was unnecessary to keep showing his visible distress repeatedly. It would have been sufficient to hear his story up to the point he shared his emotions. But continuing to show the sniffling, the teary eyes, and then making a big deal out of it felt to me like an unprofessional and unnecessary attempt to boost ratings.
I found it both amusing and intellectually intriguing when he identified as an Atheist Muslim. The term itself is a fine example of irony-akin to someone labeling themselves a 'Communist Capitalist' or a 'Rightist Leftist.' A Muslim, by definition, is one who submits their will to the Almighty God, while an atheist fundamentally rejects the existence of any deity. This juxtaposition of opposing beliefs makes the term not only ironic but a fascinating paradox of identity and belief. Anyone foolish enough to call themselves an 'Atheist Muslim' is only revealing their ignorance of Islam's truth. This label disrespects Islam's essence by mixing it with beliefs that deny Allah, showing a shallow understanding of what it truly means to submit to the Almighty.
@@spritualist6519 Hindus accept that there are various paths of reaching good all that matters are good karma , even good karma of an atheist is accept by Hindu faith . Whereas a Muslim accepts people who pray only their good , all others are kafirs , and you know what is the punishment for kafirs? Right
@@VictimHood-qv1hx Unless you can prove that your ancestors emerged from Africa as Hindus, calling others converts does not mean anything. Perhaps in your sub-culture (the group you refer to as "us") you think it is an insult?
@@sharaddhadiwan5968Perhaps they moved there from North India. No Bengali Muslim across two countries speaks Urdu. One set split their country rather than speak Urdu.
@@botheredbewildered5646 I am not talking about Bengali Muslims. I am specifically talking about Maharashtra Muslims and I know these muslims are there in Maharashtra from ages. Still they prefer to talk in Urdu. And they specially say that our mother tongue is Urdu.
Great interview. Few points that I want to remember 1) Urdu is not a langauge of muslim, it's for eevryone. Note that hawa, asman, dost, dushman are Persian words and balti is a Portuguese word. 2) a person can be atheist by mind and religious culture. Like atheist hindu or atheist muslim etc
for all the bozos in the chat trying to be religious professors.let me clarify that there is a thing called cultural Jews(most atheist Jewish celebrities),cultural Christians (atheist Richard Dawkins),and cultural Muslims(atheist javed akhtar) and he is true hajj and eid are old festivals starting from Abraham himself
Hi! This video doesn’t offer HD options like 1080p, 1440p, or 2160p. Higher resolutions would really enhance the viewing experience for a lot of us. Could you let the team know that HD and 4K options would be appreciated?
I always think about culture, religion and society and their evolution with regards to each other, and I also thought in line with Javed Sahab's perspective on festivals but after this interview I have much more clarity on my thoughts. He is a legend I always admire his talks and only could wish to have such conversations with him on such societal topics personally, but a man could dream.
I don’t take objection to this “Atheist Muslim” tag unlike a lot of people in the comments section. Islam is beyond a belief system it’s also a culture. He’s culturally a Muslim, he doesn’t believe in God, but he feels as though he’s part of the community.
There is no such thing. Being muslim means submitting your will to God. Being an athiest is not believing in God. Its like saying I am a non veg vegetarian.
Bhai Log! Muslim means one who submits to Allah. According to Javed Sahib, I am the believer of God and at the same I am not the believer of God. From Quran: Chapter No.2, Verse No. 208 "O you who have believed, ENTER INTO ISLAM COMPLETELY [and perfectly] and do not follow the footsteps of Satan. Indeed, he is to you a clear enemy". Culture will also consistent with Islam. Jis ka do dil chahta bolta hai.
What a lovely interview - Ms Dutt. Kudos to you. Excellent questions. You really drew him out. I always learn something whenever I listen to Javed Akhtar. I love to listen to his elaborate, thoughtful, rational arguments on any topic.
@@Ninanina_2018 Of course, but he would know more about Sikhism than me who isn't a Sikh or ex-Sikh. If I want to know disadvantages of Sikhism, I can talk to ex-Sikh.
@@TheKurze1 Bhagat was in foreign rule...didnt had any constitutional right as citizen... ... Chale argument karne😂 And if we go by your point of view kasab becomes revolutionary 😅
But how could you celebrate eid without namaz . Because without namaz, there is no ritual. And only kurbani, you can call it a ritual. So you made kurbani without namaz.
यह धार्मिक नहीं है , नास्तिक है , लेकिन जब मरते है तो कहां दफन होते है , मैं तो वहीं रहता हु जहां यह लोग रहते है , जब कैफ़ी आज़मी मरे तो कहां दफन हुए ,
Chillout guys! Atheist Muslim means that a person is culturally a Muslim but not in practicality. For instance if you say Assalamoalaikum to Javed Sahab, he will reply you back saying Walaikumassalam. That's what an Atheist Muslim or Culturally Muslim is!
Religion is not only about social conditioning. This man has not bothered to read the Quran(translation). Some of the passages or surahs are very moving. He would have come to know the truth. Atheist muslim is oxymoron!!
Muslims who have read Quran are fighting war amongst themselves . More Muslims are killed by Muslims in terrorism and all those are who follow Quran completely
What is this concept of atheist muslim? Either an atheist or Muslim... He may have an Muslim name, given by his parents... But belief comes from within..... At the most culturally close to Muslim.. 1st condition to be a Muslim to believe in one God
This man is intellectually a hypocrite of the highest order. I just wonder how Javed Akhtar managed to get an award for "Critical Thinking" from Richard Dawkins, a highly intelligent and a well known Atheist. One can be an ex muslim, an ex Hindu or ex any other faith, but to regard oneself as an Atheist Muslim muslim or an Atheist xian means he or she still has a soft corner fot the faith he belongs to. Jeved Akhtar never speaks, he shuts his trap whenever a hindu hasbeen a victim yet his most Bullshitwood's life falls in danger when a muslim is involved as a victim. In rhat case even Barkha Dutt falls in the same catagory, a wind up merchant that she is. 🇮🇳🕉️🙏
Religion and religious beliefs are personal choices and connect that we hv with the almighty. In every interview, Javed Akhtar highlights that he is an Atheist Muslim. It is his choice to be an atheist, indirectly he is promoting atheism, and that too is also a way of influencing ppl to follow his ideology. If he is able to answer abt the source of his thinking and writing skills then we will talk abt his practices and their authenticity.
every one worships someone, we worship Allah the true god and the atheist worship their hedonism, he is using islam conveniently for his benefit by not disassociating it completely while promoting atheism among muslims, we should push for removal pf javed akhtar as a representative of muslims in india in any talk show, podcast, or debate panel, cant have a murtad representing us
Not all atheists worship hedonism. Hedonism actually promised to Muslims in heaven hoor, wine, lot of strength etc. Actually it is Muslims ultimate goal is hedonism.
He is an expert in Urdu language but doesn’t know the meaning of Muslim. Being atheist and Muslim same time, I just couldn’t understand. If you don’t believe in Allah then how can you be a Muslim. Muslim means submit to Allah. I like his romantic poetry but his thoughts are questionable and not impressive.
Javed is poet and a writer, he is skilled to convey lie to be convinced with a sarcastic smile. When asked about the origin of Eid al- Adha, The Prophet of Islam, Muhammad, is reported to have said, “It is a tradition that has come down to us from Abraham.” The Feast of Sacrifice originates from the historic event when Prophet Abraham was commanded by God in a dream vision to sacrifice his son, Ishmail. This is witnessed by Jews and Christians as it mentioned in Holy books.
Don’t try to sell your show with click baits or cheap headlines. There is no such thing as Atheist Muslim. A person may be an atheist or a Muslim.
I think it means, he/she comes from a Muslim background but now doesn't believe in God.
Just he is living in muslim culture,as a social human being he has to live in society and that comprises culture, kiths, kins, social festivals.
Exactly, well put. Javed Akhtar is an intellectual confused person with a big ego.
Good that people from both sides are trolling him
Bhai tu h kon usko muslim na hone ka certificate dene ka
Wo upar decide hoga na
Allah talla decide karenge
Javed Akhtar's candid conversations are always a pleasure to listen to. Whatever topic he discusses, he speaks openly, without hiding his understanding or knowledge. From his religious or non-religious beliefs to his career in the film industry, relationships, failures, and successes-he shares his insights without holding back. His words resonate deeply, and perhaps there’s no other poet in modern India like him, who not only masters the art of Urdu poetry but also engages thoughtfully in discussions on various subjects.
AN ATHEIST CAN'T BE A MUSLIM
A MUSLIM CAN'T BE AN ATHEIST
He thinks he is a cultural muslim. No belief, only culture.
@@Nep.Prazol
YOU CAN'T BE A MUSLIM BY REJECTING FAITH.
@@abdurrakib1947 he is not a muslim. He just carries the culture. I dont agree with him but its his choice to be what he wants
...lol😂 😂
A child born in a Muslim family is a Muslim. No point in pretending that Muslims are made and not born. This is so about any religion. It is a different thing if you believe in the Supreme Being or not.
There is nothing like Atheist Muslim,its either Atheist or Muslim.
Unlike Other religion A muslim is muslim by belief and Karma and not by Name and surname
Oh shut up. You have missed the point entirely.
@@acidicascetic and whats that ??
यह धार्मिक नहीं है , नास्तिक है , लेकिन जब मरते है तो कहां दफन होते है , मैं तो वहीं रहता हु जहां यह लोग रहते है , जब कैफ़ी आज़मी मरे तो कहां दफन हुए ,
There is nothing like a religious person...
Either you are a human or a dumb human....
Any religion is the worst thing happened to humankind...it only divides ppl...
All the countries relatively religious are the one suffering...
All the countries which mostly dnt give much importance to religion and even if they do then it's within their homes...are the countries which are developed and all religious 3rd world countries dream to go to the countries which are not religious and have better life..this is brutal fact..if ppl come out of their god fearing mindset and accept all other humans as humans only and don't differentiate or discriminate or hurt then everything will be ok..
@@Brijesh_S.D. according to u human religion is survival and evolution.
They its absolutely fine to be cannibals
I was a liberal for a major portion of my life,but when i saw the debate between Sam.Harris and Ben Afleck a few years back, i realised that we are all in favour of stopping discrimination against minorities, empowering women and we all believe that dignity is a fundamental right of evey individual, however whenever it comes to implementing the same is muslim majority countries all liberals turn a blind eye.
Very accurate description
they are neo liberals or illeberals.... they have forgotten liberalism
nailed it
No ass
well we can see that in India what is happening to minorities.. just one hindu nation and see what is the result imagine 57 hindu nations and what they will do. by the way out of 57 muslim countries how many are at unrest apart from those having oil?
sati, gandhari, draupadi etc wale hume batayege women empowerment😂😂😂
I am an 'Atheist Theist'
I believe and disbelieve in God at the same time 😅
After all, people in the entertainment industry are there to entertain us 😂
Please say you didn't understand his position.
Is is cultural Muslim and does not believe in God.
Here muslim refers to his cultural background.
@knightspygaming1287 is there any limit to what all any particular one word could mean?
Can I say that I am a cultural Atheist, but I believe in God?
@@mohdyasir9023 Clearly you have no understanding what atheism is..... It doesn't have any culture.... Its a position of denying the superior being bcoz lack of evidence.
@@mohdyasir9023 you clearly don't know what atheism stands for.....
Atheism is denying a proposition of theists due to lack of evidence for it.
Hence, atheists don't have specific pre-defined /pre-determined culture.
@knightspygaming1287 there is no such thing as cultural mulslim or atheist Muslim.
Being Muslim has nothing to do with culture. There are 2 billion Muslims belonging from almost every culture.
These are coping mechanisms of atheist coming from Christian, Hindu or other religious backgrounds.
Religious people of these backgrounds might have bowed down to this ideological hypocrisy.
Muslims won't.
Listening to Sir Javed at 2 am ..and couldn't sleep without saying words of appreciation to one of the best soul that India has ... respect to you sir ...so much to learn from you everytime...hope god give u more life with abundance good health nad mind ❤
I love Javed Akhtar's intellect. I am aure the whole world, knowingly or unknowingly, is intellectually moving towards the same path which Javed Akhtar has taken.
You come across people who say things that you want to hear, and that person becomes intellectual.
'Atheist Muslim' is oxymoron. It's the belief that makes one a Muslim; you don’t become Muslim by just being born to Muslim parents. Those saying one can be culturally Muslim and be an Atheist by belief need to know that Islam is not a culture. It's a religion with certain necessary beliefs; you reject or leave that belief, and you are automatically out of its fold. Its like saying I am an 'Atheist Theist'.
You can't and disbelieve in God at the same time.
Logical impossibility!!!
@@mohdyasir9023 one of the very real problems is that muslims have a right to kill other muslims for officially leaving their religion, as apostasy is a crime as instantiated by all four schools of Islamic Jurisprudence. so if you were an atheist but born in a Muslim family, you would have to claim some Islamic identity or you would be cast out of the family or killed. There are many such cases in Islamic communities. In other communities also, but more so in Islam
theres no such thing as an atheist muslim. Its an oxymoron. Youre either a muslim or you are an apostate. Islam is black and white and the quran is absolutely clear on what makes a true muslim. People like Javed only serve to provide a cover to deflect attention away from the true atrocious and supremacist, exclusionary doctrine of islam as found in its primary sources, which is the quran and life of muhammad.
@@mohdyasir9023Exactly. What such pseudo atheist ex-muslims mean to say is, 'Though we don't practice the hate and violence against non-muslims as prescribed in Isl@m but we won't inspire & influence our future generations if they want to practice hateful concepts like JIH@D through our S@T@NIC CU£T of HAT€, £IES, D€ATH & P€RV€RSIONS.
🙏 🙏
@@mohdyasir9023AbsoFlutely. What such pseudo atheist ex-muslims mean to say is, 'Though we don't practice the hate and violence against non-muslims as prescribed in Isl@m but we won't inspire & influence our future generations if they want to practice hateful concepts like JIH@D through our S@T@NIC CU£T of HAT€, £IES, D€ATH & P€RV€RSIONS.
🙏 🙏
Every religion teaches us the discipline of life and the importance of family structure, guiding us on how to live with certain actions and principles. We must be careful not to hurt the feelings of religious people, as it goes against humanity and can hurt many individuals' pride and beliefs.
I respect all religions and even those who are atheists. It’s essential to give respect and receive respect in return. HUMANITY IS GREAT!
I also identify as an atheist Muslim. I don’t believe in Islam but i cannot be disassociated with the society completely either.
It's quite obvious... Family circles, culture, good habits are gonna be part of the muscle memory. Even though u don't believe in the faith u were born in it will b not possible for u to share a Pepperoni pizza with me, and I will respect that
CAn you go to yor nearest mosque and announce in the mike there that you do not believe in Islam ? we will discuss if you survive for a day
Hipocrasi kii siima hoti hai ...by NM
Ovais, that is a perfectly reasonable place to be in for any individual. For outsiders, the most important issue is not any "faith" itself but one's stand on faith-related human aspects - be they conflicts between individuals or conflicts between groups. That's where the tension between faith and non faith exists and is the hardest to manage..
What has pepperoni pizza got todo with religion@@FreddieMurphy746
When I get some free time, I like watching public intellectuals, especially those who share a similar background, like ex-Muslims who are now atheists. Because of this, TH-cam has started suggesting me a lot of videos of Javed Akhtar. I’ve been listening to him for a while now, and every time, I feel amazed by his way of telling stories. I remember watching him on Zee Classic’s program back in the day and being impressed even then.
Javed Akhtar would probably never imagine that someone from a small, remote village in the Karakoram Mountains would become such a big fan of his rational approach. But here I am, in the middle of these towering mountains, never getting tired of listening to him again and again. His thoughts and words are always so powerful, and they leave me thinking every time.
How can anyone be an atheist and a Muslim at the same time? This is a duplicitous description.
Culturally. I am an atheist Hindu. I love my festivals and consider religion as a set of stories.
Atheist is intellectual part, muslim is cultural part.
As like him , I am Atheist Hindu culturally, intellectually scientist, ethical buddhist.
No, it isn't. There are Atheist Jews, Atheist Hindus, Atheist Christians and so on. People who identify with the culture of their upbringing but do not believe in the theology. This is quite common in the world. You need to look at the world, and look past the narrow and simplistic narratives found in the hyper religious politics of India.
Not it is not. Atheism is not a religion. People can be born in a Muslim family and be atheist. There are several. Same with Hindus, Christians and people of other faiths. There is nothing duplicitous here. There is no conspiracy against you. Calm down.
Islam punishes apostates, there is no provision for leaving the belief.
A truly democratic “live and let live” kind of bold person. The interviewer is a seasoned professional and overall a great conversation.
'Atheist Muslim' is oxymoron. It's the belief that makes one a Muslim; you don’t become Muslim by just being born to Muslim parents. Those saying one can be culturally Muslim and be an Atheist by belief need to know that Islam is not a culture. It's a religion with certain necessary beliefs; you reject or leave that belief, and you are automatically out of its fold. Its like saying I am an 'Atheist Theist'. Logical impossibility!!
I disagree. why are you taking the literal meaning of the word.. it no longer means that alone. it also applies to someone who is simply born in that faith and has nothing todo with it like Javed akhter. there are many muslims who worship their ego, babas, dargah. by your definition they won't be muslim anymore then
@salmansyed5837 what do you mean 'It no longer means that alone ' ? Should words have some meaning or one can make a meaning of their own? How will we communicate if we make language subjective?
So if you tell me that you are a Muslim, what's the next question I should ask is, do you believe in God? 😀
Can we agree that being a Muslim is religious identity and once you decide to leave that religion why can't you just identity as your new identity? Why can't Javed Sb. just say that he is an Atheist.
If a Christian converts to Islam, how should he identity himself.., A "Christian Muslim'?
What you have said about dargah and all is a different matter. Those people believe in God and Prophets and consider themselves follower of the Religion..., whether they are doing it correctly or wrongly is a different discussion.
@@mohdyasir9023 words have multiple meanings. Richard Dawkins calls himself a cultural Christian so does Javed ab. Muslim can be person simply born in the faith
@@salmansyed5837 is there any limit to what all any particular one word could mean?
Can I say that I am a cultural Atheist, but I believe in God?
@@mohdyasir9023 yes there is a limit. We don’t randomly give meaning to words they evolve over decades. Muslims literally means submitting to god but it no longer means that alone in today’s time. It can mean a religious group , a cultural group etc. I am aware of fanatic atheist never heard cultural atheist.
Never knew so much of what you said and how you think Javed Sa’ab! Loved it!
Thanks for doing this Barkha! Our young generation and the ones that are going to come would need a reference of history. Lots of love ❤
*"If a cult loves death more than their opponent loves life, why are they complaining about high death count?"*
Such an insensitive comment. Hindus believe in Moksh after death that doesn't mean they love death more than life.
But these Sanghis will nvr understand
You explained ideology of every freedom fighter and every army perfectly. 👏👏
The "cult" in fact does not love death more than the other loves life. He is making that up. They just believe that achieving martyrdom (shahada) - AKA freedom fighters and innocent women and children being butchered - is the best way to die because it’s for a true cause.
It's honestly fucked up that he's making this argument because he is absolving the criminals of all their crimes and blaming the victims for their religious beliefs.
Oxymoron. Hes just atheist.
There are hindus who are also culturally attached to Urdu and muslim culture.
lett me break it down in simple words, if an extremist from another religion wants to burn down every muslim's house, Javed Akhtar saying, 'I'm not Muslim, I'm an atheist,' wouldn't save him. They wouldn't care, they'd burn his house down regardless. Islam is a part of his identity that he can't just dissociate from. And he’s fully aware of the paradox so you’re not exactly offering any intellectual breakthrough by pointing it out.
Javed akhtar your vocabulary inspired me.
Atheist Muslim is an Oxymoron. A Muslim is someone who believes in Towhid and Khatm-e-Nabuwat. Javed Akhtar is not a Muslim no matter what he calls himself
His atheist from a muslim background same why am a atheist from a Hindu background, I think you hate him as you can't refute him
@@Jay-b5b8y LOL you can't be a atheist Muslims since Islam has death penalty for apotasy. Hindus or Jews can be atheists within their traditions since their traditions do allow for non belief and there is a strong cultural aspect to it.
"mai musalman hu magar Islam mujhme nahi hai"
He is a born muslim turned Atheist.Is it that hard to understand.
@@Jay-b5b8y He's right though.....
Not all Religious ideologies/identities are the same or have the same fundamentals......
Hinduism is comprised of a very diverse set of ideas & beliefs that even include Agnostic & Atheist schools of thought while Jew is very much an Ethnic identity along with being a Religious identity.....
Hence, one could definitely claim to be a Atheist Hindu or an Atheist Jew but when it comes to being a Muslim, one has to adhere to a very specific core ideology & being a Muslim isn't considered to be an Ethnic identity either....
The 1st condition to be a Muslim is to believe on 'Allah' & accept him as the one & only true 'God'.
Because of such reasons, the term 'Atheist Muslim' is indeed an Oxymoron.
I thoroughly enjoyed this conversation.
But one correction. People from Kerala don't speak Malayali. They are "malayalis" who speak Malayalam.
What an intelligent, witty and a genuine legend.
So what
After watching this interview, I realized that Javed Akhtar lacking knowledge beyond writing social stories and poetry. He mentioned that Hajj and Eid existed before Islam, which is incorrect and misleading. It’s surprising that he didn’t provide more logical or informed answers, especially on matters of faith,.
जावेद अख़्तर से अपेक्षा है कि भाषा को लेकर कुछ detail में बताएं क्योंकि इस बारे में काफी पढ़े लिखे लोग भी ज्यादा नहीं जानते।❤❤
Atheist, Atheist Hota Hai, Na Hindu Na Musalman...Ye Kya Bawasir Title Hai.
Bro, you can totally be an Atheist Hindu because Hinduism doesn't really have a strict, structured definition. It's not like Islam, which is a consistent monotheistic faith. Dhruv Rathee, for example, calls himself an Atheist Hindu. He doesn't believe in God but still follows Hindu traditions."
I love you Javed Akhtar. Live long! You are opening up minds. Keep speaking. I love you and Shabana so much. May Allah swt protect you both eternally and all of your true loved ones along with us. Duas upon duas for your soul. I love you. Sincerely, Madiha
"Atheist Muslim" is an oxymoron.
For all great intellectuals writing comments should know its humanity which is superior to all relegion.. During pandemics & other great disasters its humanity that supersedes everything..while in peace we have frivolous issues to discuss.. Be kind to everyone & the world will change.
@@vinayakpatil5568 yes 🤗
THERE IS NOT POSSIBILITY OF ANY SUCH TERM ATHEIST MUSLIM. HE IS. JUST ATHEIST AND NON MUSLIM. HE SHOULD COLLECT THAT MUCH COURAGE TO SAY IT OPENLY
Atheist Muslim: oxymoron. Sethia gaya hai buddha
When he says atheist Muslim it sounds funny since in Islam apostasy is punishable by death.
No it is not. Please educate yourself.
@@afb123its either death, imprisonment or confiscation of property. Maybe there is a criteria of how the punishments are alloted.
@@afb123 Yes it is. In Hadith
Sahih Bukhari (52:260) - it clearly States "...The Prophet said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "
Also in many Sharia ruled Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia Afghanistan Iran apostasy laws exist, where leaving religion is punishable by death.
So it's not me, but you who should be educated about your religion, which invokes death upon free will
@@afb123It is an offence punishable with death. If you leave your religion and be vocal about it and point out mistakes in Islam, it is punishable with death.
@@afb123 No in several Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia Iran Afghanistan has apostasy law where leaving Islam is punishable by death.
Either you don't know this or just doing Taqiya
HINDUISM - is Universal in Spirituality, has Diversity in Divinity ,promotes Unity in Humanity & Nature.
WHAT IS SPECIAL ABOUT BEING A HINDU ? - By Francois Gautier.
1) Believe in God ! - Aastik - Accepted
2) Don't believe in God ! - You're accepted as Nastik
3) You want to worship idols - please go ahead. You are a murti pujak.
4) You don't want to worship idols - no problem. You can focus on Nirguna Brahman.
5) You want to criticize something in our religion. Come forward. We are logical. Nyaya, Tarka etc. are core Hindu schools.
6) You want to accept beliefs as it is. Most welcome. Please go ahead with it.
7) You want to start your journey by reading Bhagavad Gita - Sure !
8) You want to start your journey by reading Upanishads - Go ahead.
9) You want to start your journey by reading Purana - Be my guest.
10) You just don't like reading Puranas or other books. No problem my dear. Go by Bhakti tradition . ( bhakti- devotion)
11) You don't like idea of Bhakti ! No problem. Do your Karma. Be a karmayogi.
12) You want to enjoy life. Very good. No problem at all. This is Charvaka Philosophy.
13) You want to abstain from all the enjoyment of life & find God - jai ho ! Be a Sadhu, an ascetic !
14) You don't like the concept of God. You believe in Nature only - Welcome. (Trees are our friends and Prakriti or nature is worthy of worship).
15) You believe in one God or Supreme Energy. Superb! Follow Advaita philosophy
16) You want a Guru. Go ahead. Receive gyaan.
17) You don't want a Guru.. Help yourself ! Meditate, Study !
18) You believe in Female energy ! Shakti is worshiped.
19) You believe that every human being is equal. Yeah! You're awesome, come on let's celebrate Hinduism!
"Vasudhaiva kutumbakam" (the world is a family)
20) You don't have time to celebrate the festival.
Don't worry. One more festival is coming! There are multiple festivals every single day of the year.
21) You are a working person. Don't have time for religion. Its okay. You will still be a Hindu.
22) You like to go to temples. Devotion is loved.
23) You don't like to go to temples - no problem. You are still a Hindu!
24) You know that Hinduism is a way of life, with considerable freedom.
25) You believe that everything has God in it. So you worship your mother, father, guru, tree, River, Prani-matra, Earth, Universe!
26) And If you don't believe that everything has GOD in it - No problems. Respect your viewpoint.
27) "Sarve jana sukhino bhavantu " (May you all live happily)
You represent this! You're free to choose, my dear Hindu!
This is exactly the essence of Hinduism, all inclusive .. That is why it has withstood the test of time in spite of repeated onslaught both from within and outside, and assimilated every good aspects from everything . That is why it is eternal !!!
There is a saying in Rigveda , the first book ever known to mankind which depicts the Hinduism philosophy in a Nutshell -" Ano bhadrah Krathavo Yanthu Vishwathah"- Let the knowledge come to us from every direction.
That's what is called "bina sar pair ka" Hinduism is so shallow you think? Today's Hindus are so scared or desperate to make Hinduism inclusive bcz they arevafraid they are a minority religion (globally)
Please change the title an atheist is the opposite word of the word muslim....Muslim means a person who believes in Islam and Islam believes in Only one Allah who is supreme ...where as a person who shed this belief and became a non believer is called 'Murtadd' and not atheist Muslim..
I think there is a difference between Islam and Muslim.
Mulhid
Have utmost respect to javed. As like Javed , I am an Atheist, culturally Hindu, intellectually scientist, ethically buddhist, ethnically Tamil Dravidian.
And how is it you are ethnically a Tamil Dravidian? 😂😂😂
Genes?? Language?? Culture??
You are ethnically a Tamil Indian/South Indian.
Ayyo, so many 😂
Bro you described all the different vegetables 🥗 in sambhar 😅😅😅
Ha ha, except mentally and sexually you have said all "-ally" here 😅
What a joker 😂
you're like sankar jati. Na ghar ka na ghat ka.
Christmas’s origin is the pagan winter solstice festival in many parts of Europe which was turned to a Christian festival. But it was Pope Julius 1 that linked the day with Jesus’s birth. So basically church leaders in their christianisation project just co-opted existing pagan festivals. Another example is Easter from the pagan festival of Eostre, goddess of fertility.
surprisingly I agree to all of his points
Brilliant conversation expressions. Thanks a lot Berkha.Excelent indeed
The moment I see Javed Saab I go CLICK, immediately!
Always learning something astonishing new.
Thank you Barkha Mam🙏
Greeeting from South America, Suriname
Atheist love for Islam, can't leave it.
Javed ji, you are the most lovable atheist. There is so much to learn from you -especially, your positive attitude and appreciation of this life. Also, the examples of words and language you gave are so fasinating.
Enlightening , as always Javed Sahab🙏
Atheist "MUSLIM"😂😂😂
I am a non veg vegetarian.
lett me break it down in simple words, if an extremist from another religion wants to burn down every muslim's house, Javed Akhtar saying, 'I'm not Muslim, I'm an atheist,' wouldn't save him. They wouldn't care, they'd burn his house down regardless. Islam is a part of his identity that he can't just dissociate from. And he’s fully aware of the paradox so you’re not exactly offering any intellectual breakthrough by pointing it out.
I found it unprofessional on the interviewer’s part that when Javed Sahib started talking about his past struggles with hunger and got emotional, it was fine up to that point as it reflected genuine feelings. However, he continued sniffling later in the interview and even asked for a tissue. This could have been edited out; what was the point of keeping it in the interview? Were they trying to increase ratings by showing that they didn’t edit out any parts to keep it "authentic"? They likely edited out many other parts, but here it was unnecessary to keep showing his visible distress repeatedly. It would have been sufficient to hear his story up to the point he shared his emotions. But continuing to show the sniffling, the teary eyes, and then making a big deal out of it felt to me like an unprofessional and unnecessary attempt to boost ratings.
I found it both amusing and intellectually intriguing when he identified as an Atheist Muslim. The term itself is a fine example of irony-akin to someone labeling themselves a 'Communist Capitalist' or a 'Rightist Leftist.' A Muslim, by definition, is one who submits their will to the Almighty God, while an atheist fundamentally rejects the existence of any deity. This juxtaposition of opposing beliefs makes the term not only ironic but a fascinating paradox of identity and belief.
Anyone foolish enough to call themselves an 'Atheist Muslim' is only revealing their ignorance of Islam's truth. This label disrespects Islam's essence by mixing it with beliefs that deny Allah, showing a shallow understanding of what it truly means to submit to the Almighty.
This person says one line I AM A ATHEIST MUSLIM , and then he continues attacking Hindu faith like a proper radicalised Muslim .
He also attacks muslim clerics and their activities.
@@spritualist6519 Hindus accept that there are various paths of reaching good all that matters are good karma , even good karma of an atheist is accept by Hindu faith . Whereas a Muslim accepts people who pray only their good , all others are kafirs , and you know what is the punishment for kafirs? Right
He is not attacking. You are feeling insecure.
@@okeng71487 a converted Hindu person cannot make us insecure.
@@VictimHood-qv1hx Unless you can prove that your ancestors emerged from Africa as Hindus, calling others converts does not mean anything. Perhaps in your sub-culture (the group you refer to as "us") you think it is an insult?
But in Maharashtra, Muslims don't speak Marathi, they speak Urdu.
You been to rural Maharashtra? Go to nanded, solpur, satara, kolhapur the Marathi Muslims speaks Marathi even at home
@@samip3124 I stay in Rural Maharashtra and I have so many Muslim friends from my childhood. But they all speak in Urdu.
No relation between Mahabharata writer ved vyas and krishn
@@sharaddhadiwan5968Perhaps they moved there from North India. No Bengali Muslim across two countries speaks Urdu. One set split their country rather than speak Urdu.
@@botheredbewildered5646 I am not talking about Bengali Muslims. I am specifically talking about Maharashtra Muslims and I know these muslims are there in Maharashtra from ages. Still they prefer to talk in Urdu. And they specially say that our mother tongue is Urdu.
Great interview. Few points that I want to remember
1) Urdu is not a langauge of muslim, it's for eevryone. Note that hawa, asman, dost, dushman are Persian words and balti is a Portuguese word.
2) a person can be atheist by mind and religious culture. Like atheist hindu or atheist muslim etc
A Muslim can't be an atheist. Case is shut.
@@Jkjeetkr8t8 thik bhai, tujhe nahi samajh aya to chup kar
Madam an Atheist is an Atheist... you cannot categorise further with any religion leave alone being Muslim. Kindly don't oversell your headline
He is not muslim neither atheist he is just getting old😂😂
Muslim atheist 😂😂😂😂😂😂 wtf , he is biggest hypocrite
He's such an intelligent man. One of the most brilliant minds of Bollywood. I have many of the same views as Akhtar. Love all his interviews.
And still he call himself an atheist Muslim 😂😂😂
The level of idiotic blabbering 😂
Exmuslim Sahil Uncensored and Zafar Heretics ko suno...Sab clear hi jayega❤❤.
@@bhaiyajipranam YASIR NADEEM AL WAJIDI
ABUZAR RESPONDS
ELAINA ALI
ZAID PATEL
DAWAHWISE
AAMIR HAQ
@@abdurrakib1947 In sabko hi to sunke momino ka bacha hua iman bhi khatam ho jata hai
for all the bozos in the chat trying to be religious professors.let me clarify that there is a thing called cultural Jews(most atheist Jewish celebrities),cultural Christians (atheist Richard Dawkins),and cultural Muslims(atheist javed akhtar)
and he is true hajj and eid are old festivals starting from Abraham himself
He expressed his mind out nicely
He's a muslim atheist - the man is clearly lost.
When was this Recorded ? And why there isn't any option for 1080p, 1440p and 2160p ?
Some please let Barkha's team know that HD and 4k are a thing !!
Hi! This video doesn’t offer HD options like 1080p, 1440p, or 2160p. Higher resolutions would really enhance the viewing experience for a lot of us. Could you let the team know that HD and 4K options would be appreciated?
@@SaimonRaj this is actually from a 7 month old interview
I always think about culture, religion and society and their evolution with regards to each other, and I also thought in line with Javed Sahab's perspective on festivals but after this interview I have much more clarity on my thoughts. He is a legend I always admire his talks and only could wish to have such conversations with him on such societal topics personally, but a man could dream.
I don’t take objection to this “Atheist Muslim” tag unlike a lot of people in the comments section. Islam is beyond a belief system it’s also a culture. He’s culturally a Muslim, he doesn’t believe in God, but he feels as though he’s part of the community.
Half knowledge of science makes you an atheist and complete knowledge of science makes you a believer
Being an atheist Muslim is better than being a believer but it still means your sympathies ultimately lie with Muslims above others.
There is no such thing. Being muslim means submitting your will to God. Being an athiest is not believing in God. Its like saying I am a non veg vegetarian.
Bhai Log! Muslim means one who submits to Allah.
According to Javed Sahib, I am the believer of God and at the same I am not the believer of God.
From Quran: Chapter No.2, Verse No. 208
"O you who have believed, ENTER INTO ISLAM COMPLETELY [and perfectly] and do not follow the footsteps of Satan. Indeed, he is to you a clear enemy".
Culture will also consistent with Islam.
Jis ka do dil chahta bolta hai.
may be your nani didnt want your nana's hard earned money to get wasted on you. 😂😂 11:00
What a lovely interview - Ms Dutt. Kudos to you. Excellent questions. You really drew him out. I always learn something whenever I listen to Javed Akhtar. I love to listen to his elaborate, thoughtful, rational arguments on any topic.
May Allah guide him
@@abdulsaud4551 Guided out of silliness.
Atheist ex sikh🙋
Just say athiest, ex sikh lagana zaroori nahi. Sikhs have nothing to do with you, you are not Sikh so their name should not be attached to you.
@@Ninanina_2018 Why?? Once you divorce, your ex remains your ex. Who are you to suggest otherwise?
@@chetan_naik but you don't define your self by your ex now do you? Or do you define your relationship status as 'noorie's ex' or 'priyas ex'.
@@Ninanina_2018 Of course, but he would know more about Sikhism than me who isn't a Sikh or ex-Sikh. If I want to know disadvantages of Sikhism, I can talk to ex-Sikh.
Old interview re-uploaded
Audio Quality can be improved
Comment section where both hindu and Muslim are agree😂😂😂😂
"Hindu God has created all Hindus, and Muslim Allah has created all Muslims. Then, are atheists created by a mistake of God?"
Truly a Rationalist...
There is no thing such as Athiest Muslim. Haram and Halal can't be same.
There is nothing like Atheist Muslim, either you would be muslim Or not a Muslim... Atheist etc
*"Losing a war you started is called Defeat, not Genocide!"*
Was Bhagat Singh a terrorist?
@@TheKurze1 Bhagat was in foreign rule...didnt had any constitutional right as citizen...
...
Chale argument karne😂
And if we go by your point of view kasab becomes revolutionary 😅
@@Yashcky_read history.Israel is an artificially created state on the Arab land. Israelis are mostly of European origin. Netanyahu is Polish migrant.
@@cameoindia4425 same as Pakistan
@@saikatbaug1937 not at all. Pakistanis were Indian before 1947 but most Israelis were European or American before 1948.
I admire his thoughts...Javed Saab has always taught me great insights.
But how could you celebrate eid without namaz . Because without namaz, there is no ritual. And only kurbani, you can call it a ritual. So you made kurbani without namaz.
यह धार्मिक नहीं है , नास्तिक है , लेकिन जब मरते है तो कहां दफन होते है , मैं तो वहीं रहता हु जहां यह लोग रहते है , जब कैफ़ी आज़मी मरे तो कहां दफन हुए ,
Chillout guys! Atheist Muslim means that a person is culturally a Muslim but not in practicality. For instance if you say Assalamoalaikum to Javed Sahab, he will reply you back saying Walaikumassalam. That's what an Atheist Muslim or Culturally Muslim is!
Religion is not only about social conditioning. This man has not bothered to read the Quran(translation). Some of the passages or surahs are very moving. He would have come to know the truth. Atheist muslim is oxymoron!!
Muslims who have read Quran are fighting war amongst themselves . More Muslims are killed by Muslims in terrorism and all those are who follow Quran completely
What is this concept of atheist muslim? Either an atheist or Muslim... He may have an Muslim name, given by his parents... But belief comes from within..... At the most culturally close to Muslim..
1st condition to be a Muslim to believe in one God
1st condition for any faith is to be an idiot. Congrats you passed.
They have turned muslim into an ethnicity lol
Like how jews are catagorised.
In response to terror attacks,
*Govt of Bharat* : "We strongly condemn ..."
*Govt of Israel* : "Happy Diwali!" 💥
He is such a rational thinker.
Too too am a bacon and beef loving vegan
This man is intellectually a hypocrite of the highest order. I just wonder how Javed Akhtar managed to get an award for "Critical Thinking" from Richard Dawkins, a highly intelligent and a well known Atheist.
One can be an ex muslim, an ex Hindu or ex any other faith, but to regard oneself as an Atheist Muslim muslim or an Atheist xian means he or she still has a soft corner fot the faith he belongs to. Jeved Akhtar never speaks, he shuts his trap whenever a hindu hasbeen a victim yet his most Bullshitwood's life falls in danger when a muslim is involved as a victim. In rhat case even Barkha Dutt falls in the same catagory, a wind up merchant that she is. 🇮🇳🕉️🙏
Love you Javed Akhtar!
Religion and religious beliefs are personal choices and connect that we hv with the almighty. In every interview, Javed Akhtar highlights that he is an Atheist Muslim. It is his choice to be an atheist, indirectly he is promoting atheism, and that too is also a way of influencing ppl to follow his ideology. If he is able to answer abt the source of his thinking and writing skills then we will talk abt his practices and their authenticity.
It is good to pramote atheism... because religion is a shit and nonsense thing...
Following any faith is one’s personal affair but marketing same personal benefits is not correct. One should be stand for justice rationally.
He can be be both
every one worships someone, we worship Allah the true god and the atheist worship their hedonism, he is using islam conveniently for his benefit by not disassociating it completely while promoting atheism among muslims, we should push for removal pf javed akhtar as a representative of muslims in india in any talk show, podcast, or debate panel, cant have a murtad representing us
Not all atheists worship hedonism. Hedonism actually promised to Muslims in heaven hoor, wine, lot of strength etc. Actually it is Muslims ultimate goal is hedonism.
"Atheist Muslim"
Wah 👏👏👏👏👏
The term " Atheist muslim" does mean anything.
Long intro is annoying but the video is worth a while 🌹🙏
Excellent Interview. Great answer on Animal as well.
"I am an Atheist mulsim!" Bro manages to save his precious victim card!😂
When did he act like victims.
If he is athiest he cannot be muslim nor hindu nor any other relegion. Athiest beleive God does not axist.
The irrepressible Javed saheb. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
He is an expert in Urdu language but doesn’t know the meaning of Muslim. Being atheist and Muslim same time, I just couldn’t understand. If you don’t believe in Allah then how can you be a Muslim. Muslim means submit to Allah. I like his romantic poetry but his thoughts are questionable and not impressive.
Only if she stops using her English in her Hindi…… choose one language for God’s sake !!
Javed is poet and a writer, he is skilled to convey lie to be convinced with a sarcastic smile.
When asked about the origin of Eid al- Adha, The Prophet of Islam, Muhammad, is reported to have said, “It is a tradition that has come down to us from Abraham.” The Feast of Sacrifice originates from the historic event when Prophet Abraham was commanded by God in a dream vision to sacrifice his son, Ishmail.
This is witnessed by Jews and Christians as it mentioned in Holy books.
*"Human shields dying in a war you started is called Collateral Damage, not Genocide!"*
what if that war was started because of ur ghettoization of the population?
"Old Wine "Better with Time .. I would like to be like him when I Age . Respect 🙏
if he's an atheist, I'm the fairy godmother
No you're a moron. He's the most prominent atheist of India. A beacon for all atheists in India.