The amount of tragedy Obi Wan has had to deal with (yet still uphold his values throughout his life) is crazy. This felt like a lot of the best bits of animated/live action bought together, was great! Huge props to the creators!
Legendary Right! Restored The Clone War's deleted scene, Added Matt Lanter and James Arnold Taylor voices along Hayden and Ewan, And Adding The Nick Gillard Extra Disarm Move And Reverse grip from The fight that was taken out!☯️⚔️🔥🌋
The new and extended scenes you see in this animation were adapted from the original 'Revenge of the Sith' shooting script, the novelization of the movie, and several assorted deleted scenes and movie stills in an attempt to make the Mustafar duel as complete as possible. Some creative license was used in the camera angles and character movements. And Anakin's mid-air lightsaber "hand swap", originally performed by Hayden Christensen for his duel with Count Dooku (but later deleted), was also adapted for this sequence.
When you talked about how sometimes animation can express things better than live action, I couldn't agree more. It made me think of this exact moment: 12:28 after Anakin screams "I hate you!", you can literally feel the despair from Obi-Wan. He looks like hes tearing up, you can visibly tell that his world has come crumbling down around him and will never be the same. He lost his brother forever.
The start is from an unfinished scene from the CW. Its great they not only adapted the duel into CW style animation but slightly tweaked it as well. If interested for more fan films I'd recommend Wingman by Michaels basement
5:55 + 7:51 some of the "new" or different scenes are from the Episode III deleted scenes from their fight cause there was a lot of footage that was changed and cut from everything that was filmed for their fight 6:11 also, I think this here is from the Episode III novelization
I loved how they added the move of Anakin letting go of his lightsaber and catching it under Obi-Wan's guard from the deleted Dooku fight choreography that resurfaced last year.
This is easily the best fan made Starwars project to date!! I was waiting for this since 4 years ago but ever since the Clone Wars movie came out in 2008, I always wondered what the Obi wan vs Anakin fight would be like in Clone wars form.
Hope you and Tom have a great 2024 and much love from Canada. Also I would love to see you react to "For the Empire" season 1 and 2 full version by AFK someday in the future.
Ahsoka is getting a season two just confirmed,, Mando and Grogu are getting a film supposedly.. I don't think they're doing a Mando season four.. who knows..
honestly, this was masterfully done.... and makes me wonder a fully animated revenge of the Sith film be like with the clone wars finale.... the ultimate revenge of the Sith so to speak.... could you imagine it? always great to see ya!! and happy first video of 2024!!! ^_^
I watched all clone wars and rebels late last year and that was one of the best things ever because wow it added to much more to my love for star wars. And you are 10000% correct animation is art form on its own that can convey some things that other mediums cannot. Projects like Arcane really elevated what animation is capable of.
This is my first time seeing this and it was awesome I loved how the first scene was from an unaired episode of The Clone Wars and even though the animation was a little stuttery I still loved it however I still like Hayden's delivery of the line I hate you a lot more than in this fan film
WHOOOO!!!!!! The Queenof Naboo herself finally posted, it felt like a lifetime since I watched a Catherine video, but yet here I am! Wishing you a speedy recovery, Cat. This definitely hits so much harder than ever in the CW format.
THIS is the emotional impact George intended. Yes, others have had intense reactions to the original (and without having seen Clone Wars), but others like me that connected more with the Clone Wars characters, this hit harder. Something crazy that I didn’t expect was I had a flashback to little Anakin from Ep 1 while Anakin was burning, making me think that “was this all worth it? Robbing this man’s entire life from him since he was an innocent boy? Look where it ended up.”
If you're looking for more tributes to react to, I would highly suggest looking at the ones made by SWFT if you haven't seen them already. He has at least 3 Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker tributes, one for Ahsoka, one for Obi-Wan, as well as the Rebellion, the Empire, and one for all the Dark Side characters. There's really no words to explain how incredible they are. P.S. Happy New Year Cat!!! Here's hoping you have a great 2024🎉🎊
I always forget how much Anakin is the aggressor in his lightsaber duels even when he and Obi-Wan are just training, but on defense more when he's Vader because then he lets his opponents make a fool of themselves. Except for in Rogue One of course.
This is a great reaction I totally agree with everything you said at the end about how under appreciated animation can be for raw emotional scenes like this.
Without a doubt, this is my #1 favorite Star Wars fan film. The Obi-Wan vs Anakin duel on Mustafar from ROTS is my #1 favorite lightsaber duel in the entire franchise, so seeing it in TCW animation was a dream come true. I really enjoyed seeing your reaction to this, Cat. Happy New Year!
the mistake of "new" Star Wars that they don't understand lightsabers, in the new trilogy, it looks like Kylo used a real sword, it looks like the blade has weight to it. well it doesn't. in the animated stuff they always could do stuff look fast is the only thing that has any weight is the hilt.
The amount of tragedy Obi Wan has had to deal with (yet still uphold his values throughout his life) is crazy. This felt like a lot of the best bits of animated/live action bought together, was great! Huge props to the creators!
Dave filoni needs to hire this guy for animation
I've been waiting for this since the teaser trailer dropped 3 years ago. SUPER worth the wait!
Me too
Same!!!! I watched it when it came out!!!
Legendary Right! Restored The Clone War's deleted scene, Added Matt Lanter and James Arnold Taylor voices along Hayden and Ewan, And Adding The Nick Gillard Extra Disarm Move And Reverse grip from The fight that was taken out!☯️⚔️🔥🌋
The new and extended scenes you see in this animation were adapted from the original 'Revenge of the Sith' shooting script, the novelization of the movie, and several assorted deleted scenes and movie stills in an attempt to make the Mustafar duel as complete as possible. Some creative license was used in the camera angles and character movements. And Anakin's mid-air lightsaber "hand swap", originally performed by Hayden Christensen for his duel with Count Dooku (but later deleted), was also adapted for this sequence.
When you talked about how sometimes animation can express things better than live action, I couldn't agree more. It made me think of this exact moment:
12:28 after Anakin screams "I hate you!", you can literally feel the despair from Obi-Wan. He looks like hes tearing up, you can visibly tell that his world has come crumbling down around him and will never be the same.
He lost his brother forever.
And his reaction to the burning.
Star wars the clone wars season 6 battle of the heroes in the dvd.
The start is from an unfinished scene from the CW.
Its great they not only adapted the duel into CW style animation but slightly tweaked it as well.
If interested for more fan films I'd recommend Wingman by Michaels basement
Best Star Wars remake ever!
5:55 + 7:51 some of the "new" or different scenes are from the Episode III deleted scenes from their fight cause there was a lot of footage that was changed and cut from everything that was filmed for their fight
6:11 also, I think this here is from the Episode III novelization
I can't get enough of people reacting to this incredible fan animation!
I kinda wanna see more iconic SW fight scenes remade into the CW style
I loved how they added the move of Anakin letting go of his lightsaber and catching it under Obi-Wan's guard from the deleted Dooku fight choreography that resurfaced last year.
"Padme Help" in a raspy voice just before the masks covers his face... its very faint...
This is easily the best fan made Starwars project to date!! I was waiting for this since 4 years ago but ever since the Clone Wars movie came out in 2008, I always wondered what the Obi wan vs Anakin fight would be like in Clone wars form.
I got chills watching this is actually same of episode three revenge of the sith
This thing is better than the whole sequel trilogy 😹
Obviously
And even better than the entire Clone Wars series
lol no
Hope you and Tom have a great 2024 and much love from Canada. Also I would love to see you react to "For the Empire" season 1 and 2 full version by AFK someday in the future.
I wish I had the talent to make something like this .
Hi Catherine happy new year 🎉
Ahsoka is getting a season two just confirmed,, Mando and Grogu are getting a film supposedly.. I don't think they're doing a Mando season four.. who knows..
honestly, this was masterfully done.... and makes me wonder a fully animated revenge of the Sith film be like with the clone wars finale.... the ultimate revenge of the Sith so to speak.... could you imagine it?
always great to see ya!!
and happy first video of 2024!!! ^_^
I've seen this so many times and I still can't believe how good it turned out. So worth the wait. Thank you for taking our requests.
I cry no matter how many times I’ve seen this scene
Seeing animated Anakin and Obi-Wan fight really hits different.
I watched all clone wars and rebels late last year and that was one of the best things ever because wow it added to much more to my love for star wars. And you are 10000% correct animation is art form on its own that can convey some things that other mediums cannot. Projects like Arcane really elevated what animation is capable of.
Happy new year! Thanks for taking the time to react to this! Was looking forward to your reaction!
You're right this just hits differently. Hands down TCW is some of the best Star Wars period.
Good soldiers follow orders.
Thank you for your reactions. Not only gorgeous but you make everyone one happy. Thank for everything. Matthew Biangardi. Cheers
This is my first time seeing this and it was awesome I loved how the first scene was from an unaired episode of The Clone Wars and even though the animation was a little stuttery I still loved it however I still like Hayden's delivery of the line I hate you a lot more than in this fan film
WHOOOO!!!!!!
The Queenof Naboo herself finally posted, it felt like a lifetime since I watched a Catherine video, but yet here I am! Wishing you a speedy recovery, Cat. This definitely hits so much harder than ever in the CW format.
Loved this so much! And when the Padame scene came on I thought about you because it so looked like you and your work.
All I can say is...OMG!!! That blew me away.
THIS is the emotional impact George intended. Yes, others have had intense reactions to the original (and without having seen Clone Wars), but others like me that connected more with the Clone Wars characters, this hit harder.
Something crazy that I didn’t expect was I had a flashback to little Anakin from Ep 1 while Anakin was burning, making me think that “was this all worth it? Robbing this man’s entire life from him since he was an innocent boy? Look where it ended up.”
Feel better, lots of tea!
If you're looking for more tributes to react to, I would highly suggest looking at the ones made by SWFT if you haven't seen them already. He has at least 3 Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker tributes, one for Ahsoka, one for Obi-Wan, as well as the Rebellion, the Empire, and one for all the Dark Side characters. There's really no words to explain how incredible they are.
P.S. Happy New Year Cat!!! Here's hoping you have a great 2024🎉🎊
Cat plays Padme in SWFT film. Trust me she has seen it. Lol
Sorry got cut off. Cat plays Padme in 1. Shards of the Past.
I keep rewatching it because it was done so good.
If you watch and listen carefully, when vaders mask gets put on he says "Padme Help"
I noticed that as well. Was that line in ROTS?
I always forget how much Anakin is the aggressor in his lightsaber duels even when he and Obi-Wan are just training, but on defense more when he's Vader because then he lets his opponents make a fool of themselves. Except for in Rogue One of course.
Now i want that 3 hours CloneWarsFinale + RotS 4K HDR but with full animated style in RotS
Happy new year everyone
This is a great reaction I totally agree with everything you said at the end about how under appreciated animation can be for raw emotional scenes like this.
Great reaction. Clone Wars fan have seen so many episodes of Ani and Obi. I’m definitely more emotionally connected to the animated characters.
Without a doubt, this is my #1 favorite Star Wars fan film. The Obi-Wan vs Anakin duel on Mustafar from ROTS is my #1 favorite lightsaber duel in the entire franchise, so seeing it in TCW animation was a dream come true. I really enjoyed seeing your reaction to this, Cat. Happy New Year!
New sub this is better then all Disney StarWars .
Made by fans
Incorrect
it just hits harder seeing it like this
Seeing this reaction was like...
Even in animation you look like Padmé.
Imagine if Star Wars fans were in charge of Star Wars at Disney. I'd be glad to wait years and years for masterpieces to be released.
We would make a masterpieces in honor George and carry on his legacy and respect him more than Kennedy did
Do you realize that this is simply a copy of an existing film in The Clone Wars style?
Padme already got her funeral animated in clone wars sad to see but it was in tales of the Jedi
15:30 I almost cried when, padme died in revenge of the Sith.
So Good!
Finding your channel is the only good thing about watching SWT
loved the reaction
Hey Cat,
When Star Wars Theory gets Vader: Episode 2 on, are you gonna be back as Padme?
I hope so, you gave episode 1 a lot of its soul :)
Which would you rank higher, Animated ROTS or SC38?
15:00 padma help me
“Don’t you dare show me Padme’s funeral” - watch “Tales of the Jedi” episode 6 :/
Hey friend! GEN1films would love to see your reaction to our latest film “Kestis: A Jedi Survivor Story.”
the mistake of "new" Star Wars that they don't understand lightsabers, in the new trilogy, it looks like Kylo used a real sword, it looks like the blade has weight to it. well it doesn't. in the animated stuff they always could do stuff look fast is the only thing that has any weight is the hilt.
Last time my brother and i fought like this we had dueling sabers we broke them i won are sabers died tho
❤
You look so gorgeous lovely and beautiful Catherine and happy new year sweetheart ❤️ 💖 💗 💕 ♥️
I missed your old intro
Catherine is my baby
I was wondering when you’d react to this
15:54 Tales of the Jedi di already animate that
I've said it before and I'll say it again... that's your man, Padme. It should have been you voicing her lines... just saying!