Is Onward Andy's Imagination!? | Pixar Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2019
- In today’s episode Ben takes a look at Pixar’s brand new fantasy world found in Onward and discusses the parallels between Ian and Andy. Is it possible that this whole world has actually be created by the ever imaginative Andy?!
Could Onward Break the Pixar Theory?
• Could Onward BREAK The...
The COMPLETE Pixar Theory:
• The COMPLETE Pixar Theory
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
What do you guys think?! Is Onward going to be Andy's Imagination!?
This theory is so out of the box. Its must be right
SuperCarlinBrothers haven't watched the vid yet but ye because they're doing a dad quest but like Andy's dad, he probs got polio......
I think so! This theory actually makes quite a lot of sense
Prolly
SuperCarlinBrothers my new cannon
Close but sorry no
It’s Andy’s D&D campaign in college
Sheena Attwood headcanon
OMG yes!
YES YES YES I HAD THE SAME THOUGHT
That’s epic!
I can live with this, but is a personal side quest or else there would be 2-3 more characters involved
Pixar: **Breaks theory**
Pixar Theorist: **This**
Pixar: Mission failed, we'll get em next time
ok
It's so true they will never beat us!
Lov it
Pixae: We've been backstabbed, we've been tricked, and we might of even been bamboozled.
no no no... its
Pixar: Finally we broke the theory.
Carlin Bros: Hold my coffee!
Dude imagine if the end credits scene is Andy sitting back from a computer or drawing table and sighing, 'there, finally done!' And it turns out Onwards was made by him
I was thinking the exact same thing 😂
K-Chan Kougashima I hope it Will be true
K-Chan Kougashima Theorists would SCREECH
OMG I would love that
No
Onward writers: Boss, we broke the Pixar Theory
Pixar: Per-
SCB: Nope
What was "per" before it got interrupted? Perhaps?
@Snaketooth 09 Perfect
Marcus the Person @
thumbs up
Andy becomes a creative writing major and writes Onward
Yes! I'm not the only one who thought of this!
I was gonna say this too! Lol. #HeadcanonAccepted
Thats why he went to collage ah
Exactly! It makes total sense that he would study writing bc he's so creative- this could be his first book out of school!
Exactly! Scrolling through the comments I was kind of surprised to not see anyone point out that smartphones didn't exist when Andy was a kid, so this must be adult Andy. I was thinking he could have become a writer after university and wrote this.
What if Onward is a book written by Andy after college?😱
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees!
Now we're asking the real questions!
It's the film adaptation, released in theaters in Pixar's universe
He is daydreaming in collage
Maybe having Onward and Toy Story character equivalents...
You know, if TH-cam ever goes bust, have you guys considered being lawyers? I swear you can argue anything! Loved this theory
Sadie B they could probably convince me that 2=3
Carlin law
J and Ben as lawyers
This is why the robber was an arsonist
Judge: Nothing was burned down
EXACTLY!!!!!
I know!
These guys could give anybody 10-life
Pixar: *includes minor detail in film
How Pixar sees it: That has absolutely no meaning at all
How SCB sees it: WRITE THAT DOWN! WRITE THAT DOWN! IT MEANS -EVERYTHING!-
Non Pixar theorists: you can't make a theory out of one teaser trailer
Ben: hold my super Carlin coffee
"Hold me super carlin coffee" 😂🤣😂🤣
😂
Yep, can't make this stuff up, you just can't.
Me: **Sees title**
Me: Well, this title doesn’t make any sense at all but I’m 99.9% sure that after watching the video I will be thoroughly convinced and completely on board with this theory.
Me: _how do they do it!?_
That's me every single time!
Same my friend it like they saw the movie already
This is me every time I watch their videos
Same
Like a jedi mind trick
Onward is Pixar's story on the super carlin brothers as elves.
yes
wait... reach for the sky means put your hand up? I thought it WAS words of encouragement
Katie Romo bruh
Really? I thought it was a well known phrase.
Katie Romo same
😂😂😂😂😂 Me Too!
Pixar: *releases trailer*
Carlin Brothers: MOM GET THE CAMERA
"We've got to spend the next 5 hours pausing and analysing each frame!"
Pixar: Includes minor detail
Carlin Brothers: Write that down! Write that down!
@@smartaleckduck4135 Lol!
@@smartaleckduck4135 Someone else: It means nothing!
Carlin Brothers: Exactly it means nothing...yet!
@@sarahglover3286 It means nothing by SYMBOLIZING the concept of "nothing".
Toy Story: Endgame - reveals that the Pixar Universe was created by Andy and his infinity stones
maybe the marvel cinematic universe takes place in the pixar universe with your theory
I thing they're infinity luxo balls
@@livandmaddieftwrobloxnoobs8518 it also means the Kingdom hearts universe crosses over with The MCU
@@khalidbrown743 heck at this rate, star wars is looking to cross over with the mcu as well
@@livandmaddieftwrobloxnoobs8518 At this rate It'll be everyone but Waluigi
Seamus Gorman: Onward breaks the Pixar theory.
Super Carlin Brothers: Hold my coffee
Lol
Pixar: "We WILL make a movie that breaks the 'Pixar Theory'."
SuperCarlinBrothers: "Nope."
SCB Never
Plot Twist: The movie ends with Steve Jobs reading from a storybook.
My heart????
Rith Trelin ???
But....how?
Steve jobs is dead
Rith Trelin But then- you find out morgen freeman was reading it to Steve jobs
Pixar theory: *exists*
Onward: *I’m about to ruin this man’s whole career*
Super Carlin Brothers: *no, I don’t think you will*
Me: It’s illegal
*uno reverse card*
О, привет Ёжик, тебя тоже в Пиксар запихнуть
@@damired
Did you say "Oh hello Hedgehog, you, too, in Piksar shove"?
Snaketooth 09
I said «Oh, hi, Chico, do you want to get into Pixar?»
Cause the first commentator’s nick and photo is a cartoon’s character Chico (Ёжик) from Kikoriki (Смешарики)
Pixar's Onward is actually the alternate reality from which the rest of the Pixar Universe draws its magic.
Mr. HoneyComb ouuuuu great theory
That’s actually a pretty good idea!
The magic has to come from somewhere, correct? These seemingly magical occurrences in the Pixar Universe have to draw their magic from someplace, and what better place then a realm of pure magic?
I believe as more magic is used on the behalf of our world, the more the magical world becomes like ours.
And that’s why there isn’t as much magic maybe? Cause earth is taking it?
Mr. HoneyComb no I don’t think so. I think the witch in Brave took it
@@justsomeotherguy5679 hmmm
If it’s a character’s imagination, it could be Boo. Maybe inspired by some of the fantastical monsters she saw when she was a toddler.
You have a point...
There's a theory that boo is the witch from brave. She could have been inspired by the magic from brave and the technology from monster Inc. She could have even met Andy through time travel. Who knows?
@@satishdange3849 I think this is the focal point of the pixar theory
"Do I have a defective imagination?"
You? NOOOOOO
He only has a TH-cam channel dedicated to using his imagination for creating theories out of nothing. But yeahhh, I can totally see that he has no imagination at all 🤷♂️
Klee Films 😂😂
@@ChiyouFootballTrainingAcademy ...will I have to do it? Or do you know what im gonna have to do...*sigh* r/woooosh
@@lhmw2288 you should do that to yourself 🤦♂️
What if Onward is a novel that Andy has written or is writing
Yes! Exactly what I thought
Wow! I'm glad to see I'm not the only one thinking this! It makes so much sense and really works!
If he went off to college to do English, that would definitely make sense.
Skylandsdefender 03 that’s exactly what I thought... maybe at the end it’ll show Andy going to a publishing company when he’s out from college? 🧐
@@Pendragon-zw6jl That or he went in for one major, and then switched to English because he believed had more creative liberty that way.
Pixar: *breathes*
Fans: OMG IT’S ANOTHER CLUE
This single theory proves the Pixar theory can never be broken. Every new world and story that Pixar creates can be dismissed as being in someone imagination
DanyDud 3 the Pixar UNIVERSE
Well they were able to make a decent connection if there is no connection then maybe not
Pixar: let’s break the Pixar theory!
SCB: hold my coffee
YES
I left a SuperCarlin Brothers video to watch this SuperCarlin Brothers video.
*_IRONY 100_*
Before I saw the second part of this comment, I thought you left this video. I the said, THAT IS A SIN MY DEAR FRIEND!!!
Well. Good for you.
"do I have a defective imagination?"
you made up this whole theory. no, you do not have a deflective imagination.
main character: Peter Parker/Tom Holland/Spiderman
main character's brother: Peter Quill/Chris Pratt/Starlord
A tale of two peters
@@SpacePrincessPuppet which code names start with "S" and one has star in his name. lol.
*Theory debunkers:* Onward is our lord and savior
*Pixar Theorists:* hold my butterbeer
rofl
Hold my carlin brother coffee
@@netashtein7165 It's called SuperCarlinBrothers coffee!
I prefer Butterbeer in it!
Butterbeer
Heheheheheheheheheh
I thought the Cars franchise debunked it already. There's absolutely no way that particular universe fits with the rest unless it's a series of films the Toy Story chars would watch or it's all in the imagination of one of the existing characters.
But how did the mermaid get into the plastic pool?
Probably lifted into it by someone else. There are probably carers who help out, or maybe she lives with someone whose species has adapted to life on land.
Like in the original Charmed when dry her tail became legs
Maybe they have feet on land but tails in water?
Maybe they moved the pool into the water and the mermaid swam in, then they moved the pool into the backyard.
I love how there are five interesting and somewhat plausible replies to someone pointing out plot holes in less than an hour
Barley could actually represent Andy, while Ian is Molly. Molly would also have to cope with not having a dad. And Barley's van would represent Andy's play style, molding things together, using water guns as actual guns, and bringing different concepts together. So maybe Onward is inside Molly's head as she thinks about how Andy helped her growing up without a dad.
Theory: Andy is a writing major and Onward is the story he writes as his final for his Creative Writing class. (It makes a lot more sense for him to purposefully put in symbolism as a young adult, especially to write a coming of age story)
Onward is Andy’s imagination in college when he is introduced to D&D
And DMT
zarah cross what’s d&d
@@maxbennett7652 Dungeons and Dragons, the most popular table-top role playing game of all time.
It's just Andy's imagination in college playing dnd. Which explains why the technology is a bit more advance In this movie than toy story 1 and its fantasy theme compared to to his other imagination for western or sci fi. He grew sound by the same things other nerds grew up with. Would it be so hard to believe that Andy creative imagination led him to dnd. The movie plot even sounds like a dnd campaign.
oh dude you solved it.
what you wanna bet at the end of onward it will show a scene of a college-aged andy sitting behind a DM screen
Yeah but what if its Andy and Molly?? Andy is telling her a story or something??
That's way more likely than Andy looking up to his toys.
Or even more likely, Andy telling his kids a story
@SuperCarlinBrothers - Can we please get a ♥️ on this?
That theory explains the older brother being a sort of father figure. What if Andy sees himself as the older brother in the story and he has to be a father figure to Molly.
Colin F or maybe Andy is really a father now! On toy story 4 we may see that
When I was younger my little sister and I would too "take characters of all walks of life and spin them to one cohesive tale," but our stories weren't "There it is. That makes sense." We'd actually create different dimensions for it to make sense. 😂 I am not saying we are Andy and our toys come to life, I am just saying that such statement gave me nostalgia.
What if it's just two bothers that are playing a d&d type game that their dad use to played with them?
!!! This!
Robin Channel but who would it be that could also tie into this cinematic universe?
Maybe the two kids are the kids of the dead geri
Oh my gosh if Ben and Jay cosplayed the brothers😂
His name is Jonathan and The shorter version is just J
I WOULD DIE!!!!!! I NEED THAT NOW!!!!
OmG yEs
Omg yasssssss
A truly great Halloween idea too!
its probably Andy playing Dungeons & Dragons in college.
Makes sense. Dark Elves, an adventure, and frickin gnomes
I am 9 years old and I know what Dungeons & Dragons is
He would be a great dm
@@Arnet1974 whhaatt?
NOT TO MENTION ONE OF THE CREATORS OF THIS ARE FROM....
*TOY STORY*
Dude, They're both from pixar. Of course they have the same creators.
So what I'm hearing is that Andy would make a great DM
So it seems
Next Time on SuperCarlinBrothers: Did Andy create the Pixar Theory?
* Pixar makes new movies *
Theroies: *Y E S*
Theory: Andy Davis studies to become an animator and makes the movie onward :) #AndyWorks4Pixar
Carlin brothers: Andy has no dad
Pixar: *Releases film with Andy’s dad the literal next day*
What?
What??
Andy's dad where?
What???
I need an explanation asap
Pixar: Finally, we did it... we broke the Pixar Theory!!! Mwahahahaha!!!
Carlin bros: Here, hold my coffee!
I thought Cars broke the theory
That's Awesome!
Why would they want to break it? It's probably gotten them a ton of free publicity. They should be paying all the TH-camrs that talked about it. I've watched movies just so I could watch the theory vidoes about them.
By The Way... that coffee is CarlinBrothersCoffee
@@aidanbarnes4290 look at the carlin bros vids on the pixar theory, they fit in the cars too =)
SCB: "what if onward is part of andy's imagination?"
MatPat: "WHAT IF TOY STORY FOUR WILL BE A MOVIE OF TOYS FIGHTING HUMANS AND STARTING A WAR?!?!"
Edit: Good lord! 332 likes?
When you read this it will probably be more, but imagine 332 people in your room. It is quite a lot.
Pixar version of Small Soldiers?
Hheheehe yes
IRIS Corporation the two best movie theorists channels on the Internet. Sure, MartPat is has more far fetched theories, but they still work perfectly.
And I love both theories💗😂
I hope that’s Toy Story Five
me going into this video: nahh not gonna buy this....
Also me after video: HOW DO YOU MAKE THESE CRAZY THEORIES BELIEVABLE??
Comments be like:
33% D and D
33% Andy became an animator
33% I'm about to ruin this man's career/ Hold my coffee
Sooooo where’s the 1% tho?
What?
And the last 1% is % comments.
The last 1 percent is Disproving this theory.
Or maybe Andy has gone to college and has studied media/animation and he has created the story of onward
I LIKE THIS
This is a good one
Pixar: at the end it will be a story book
Theories: *this*
Pixar: there getting close
What if the ending of onward shows out of the world, Andy closes a book with a title “Onward” and Andy sais, “ Finally finished making it”
What if this is from Andy’s imagination while he’s in college? His huge imagination could be a way to make himself feel at home and deal with homesickness. What if one day Andy decided to write a story based on fantasy and his own life?
What if it’s boo she’s young and she saw monsters what if she thinks everything exists now??
Edit:I ain’t think it was going to be this popular 😭💙
kiarra carter that’s pretty good
Oooooohhhhh I like this idea. Kudos this is a good one!
Ben should comment on this comment
No
It's obviously a dnd game Andy's playing in his dorm
“100% sure this movie isn’t going to be tear jerky at all for us.”
This man speaks the words of lies.
Or Andy could have just wanted an older brother so he imagined he had one. I know being the oldest, I used to do that a lot.
Advice from me: don’t get an older brother it stinks
The plot of Onward is giving me serious Fullmetal Alchemist vibes already and it scares me
Maybe while Boo was time traveling she went on one of the star liners .and that's the planet were she learned Magic. . And the witch leaked that world
anna klum same
Anna Klum
It does for too
As long as no girls turn into dogs.
I will except only two things number
1 t it's in it's own universe
2 the twist is it was actually a dungeon & dragons campaign
y e s
i stan the second one XD
accept*
Your Grammer Sucks episode 118 right here
Disney/Pixar: ~never considered any of this~
Also D/P: ~rapidly taking notes~
I definitely see the two characters being Andy and maybe a brother he always wanted but never had. The lack of a brother and father figure could drive a child to be more drawn to objects where he could create a world of his own
Squidward, we don't need a television. Not as long as we have our *rainbow intensifies* imagination!
Avery The Cuban-American What’s that? 🤣
It's SPONGE BOB SQUARE PANTS!! 😁😂
M Terry I truly don’t know how you can be on the internet and not get a SpongeBob reference. Especially that one.
@@anonymousunknown7388 go back to the stone age
In Incredibles two, jack Jack supposedly went to another dimension, what if
What if that is where onward takes place
ZAP ANIMATIONS
Andy’s bed actually casts a shadow, of you look closer.
Two moons right there in the room!!
Ben: “When was the last time your fantasy story included local infrastructure?”
Me: D&D my friend, D&D
Always wanted an older brother but was stuck with a younger sister. So he can live this in his imagination
I'm an older brother, trust me, if you had one you'd hate him.
Unknown User i have an older brother and i agree but it’s getting better now😂😂
ANGRY CANADIAN I feel ya
@@marleyrose8634 same same saaaame
J: Chris Pratt
Ben: Tom Holland
Tyler: am I a joke to you?
Hey 👋 super Carlin Brothers I have a question that you can make into a video.
Who is the richest person in the Pixar universe?
Please answer this question because I am dying to know.
Whoever owns Buy and Large.
Isn't it obvious who the richest man in the Pixar universe is, unless your meaning before the events of the Incredibles, which is probably 1972 sience the begining takes place in 1947, it's the CEO of BNL
Edna mode. (just a guess lol)
That guy who ran Buy n Large or Syndrome
BnL probz or Syndrome, I think SCB made a video about Syndrome being rich. I forgo or The Devons. Maybe Edna? Is Big Hero 6 Pixar? I would've said Fred but I don't think so.
Me watching SCB for years, became smarter but questions intelligence and me messing up all of my childhood movies and forgets some details: WAAAAHHHH...
Andy has a moon carved into his bed and that then creates this theory, Love the SuperCarlinBrothers for taking something so small and connecting it to The Pixar Theory
Ben: When was the last time your fantasy story included local infrastructure?
Me: *looks at Shadowrun*
Maybe when Boo was time traveling she went on the star liners that landed on another planet .where she learned Magic .and the witch in brave leaked that world to use
This just shows that nothing can break the Pixar Theory.
I knew you guys would find a way to fit this relatively into the theory. Also that opening thing about being brothers and how far you've come. I've been here since almost the very beginning, and I love seeing where you guys are now. Great job guys.
The houses from onward remind me of the smurfs
You guys can probably convince me that a pile of rocks has meaning.
What if it's Andy senior's imagination, and those are actually his old toys.
ooh i like that idea
I think this is one of the few Pixar-verse Theories that I can actually agree with
What if this is actually Andy’s developed imagination of when he’s older, which is why we see modern day infrastructure. And like we see in coco how his grandmother almost forgot her father until her grandson helps the rest of the family. It’s Andy’s mind trying to remember any memory of his father. What do y’all think ?
Maybe Onward is a book Andy wrote as an adult.
Edit; The characters in Onward are much older and the technology is more advanced that it would be when Andy was young.
I did think that's a problem and why lots of people have commented it's something he wrote either as an adult or at college as when he was growing up smartphones didn't exist as I believe he was born 90's!
What about the movie being called onward? Buzz is a space ranger. He travels onward through space. to infinity and beyond is kind of another way to say let's keep going onward.
the revolution is beginning the infitoy war is coming!!!!! 😂
I feel like Onward is being made as a commentary on our own world and how humans have affected it.
Ben: also I feel like i´ve been playing with my toys wrong, do i have a defective imagination?
me: Ben, we all feel like that when we watch toy story.
Yep
I LOVE YOUR THEORIES! Keep up the great work!
One week from questioning how it fits in, and you already have an answer. You guys work so hard and so quickly.
In the other one they gave a few other suggestions!
Also also, actually actually... when the word "ANDY" is repeatedly said.. it sounds like IAN.
Khaeden Golez not rlly
I like the “it’s Andy’s collage D&D campaign” comments going on
Or, the imagination we are seeing is molly, Andy's younger sister who often played with Andy (seen in toy story 1)
That would mean Andy's got Tom Holland's voice in his imagination!!
Who doesn’t?
He wrote the story, and tom Holland is in the inevitable movie adaptation.
@Xitlalic Chavez Valencia Soon there will literally be no film studio not owned by Disney.
For once, an animated character who wears earphones properly 😂😂😂😂😂
You know the unicorn on his van it's like having a cat or raccoon on a van in our world
Maybe its taking place when Andy is in College and he could be playing/making a MMO RPG game or smthn like that.
just a thought
If the Pixar theory was intentional then it makes every Pixar film a Toy Story spin-off
What if its an animated movie that andy made, after credits scene: ppl congratulating andy for his film
This morning, I was watching Ralph Breaks the Internet and came across a Interesting question. Does Ralph breaks the Internet expand the Pixar Theory to all things Disney?
Hey that's a pretty amazing thought!
How so?
I don’t think it does because I’m pretty sure Ralph breaks the internet is a Disney movie so it would have no effect on the Pixar theory
@@mlbfangirl0746 Pixar is a Disney Property.
Wreck it Ralph is a Disney movie. Why would Wreck it Ralph be able to change the Pixar theory?
Plot Twist: Onward is Andy’s college application to Ringling
Talk about the new pixar movie Soul!
Yeah, I came for this comment!
I literally just realized that they film these videos as if they’re taking to their brother
The channel actually started as a way for the two of them to speak to each other in a creative way
What if when Andy was younger was when the Onward universe was old timey and more traditional, but as he got older and technology advanced around him, he added those components into his universe, therefor modernizing his fantasy
I like to think that the movie would end with Andy as a grown up making this movie at Pixar
what if onward is a D&d
campaign that andy is playing?
What if Andi sometimes thought to him self I wonder what it would be like to have an older brother
Maybe Andy became a Storybook writer and wrote this book.