This video is awesome. You did an incredible job explaining the differences between each bike. I don’t know much of anything about mountain biking but have been looking into buying a Scott Aspect or Specialized Rockhopper recently and this video was so informative. Amazing.
I bought an elite last week, it will arrive next Thursday. I just watched your video and confirmed that my choice was the best. Congratulations on the review! thanks!
Thanks for the video. Your thorough comparison reviews are very helpful and greatly appreciated. I've been keeping my eye out for an MTB but the reviews usually, only focus on the top tier option out of the respective lineups.
Exactly the info I was looking for since I'm trying to decode the Specialized lineup myself right now. One techwriting suggestion that can put your content at the top of the heap: in the chart, eliminate all duplicate phrases, merging the cells so that for instance, you have a row called Front Suspension and there are only two cells with just the single words: coil or air. I don't dispute the value of the XCR/M distinctions but that's what the video is for, not the chart. Thanks for saving me lots of time!
thanks for this technical review, very interesting. I own the Rockhopper Elite and I am very satisfied with this quality bike. I use it in moutain trails and it does the job
Awesome video. Between the graphics, text, and narration, you really set the bar for this kind of thing. I was paying attention to the gear ratio of the models with just one sprocket up front vs. the models with two front sprockets. Sounds like the 1Xs are 30-to-11 at their highest speed setting whereas the 2Xs are 36-to-11. On a long, straight-and-level road, would a rider feel like he was missing out on the opportunity to ride faster with these 1X set-ups? I really like the simplicity of 1 sprocket up front.
Definitely limits top achievable speed on flat road. You can upgrade though for a bigger chainring but that's going to have its costs. Frame has to be designed to accept a front deraileur.
Thanks for the great overview! I got the Elite last summer and agree that it's a better deal than the Expert. I was holding out for a Specialized Chisel because I thought I needed the thru axles and tapered head tube but it was just not worth the price increase. Also for the kind of moderate riding I do (mostly bike path with occasional dirt and gravel) I really didn't need those features. I did find that the 30 tooth front ring was too small and I would spin out while pedaling even slight downhills. It cost me about $150 to upgrade to a 34T front ring because I also had to upgrade the bottom bracket and cranks. I also spent another $35 to raise the front handle bars because I wanted a more upright ride. So I ended up paying about the same price as the Expert but got exactly the right bike for me. I think the increase from 40T to 51T in the rear may be overkill -- for me at least -- since I have never needed to use the largest 2 or 3 gears, but for serious cross country riders it may be worth it.
You’re welcome! Sounds like you got a good setup going there so I’m happy to hear it worked out for you. And yeah the big cassette isn’t for anyone but it’s nice to have as an option and I’ve personally benefitted from it a lot
In the same situation as yourself. Love the Chisel but hard to justify the extra $$ over the Elite. After looking at this comparison, I'm not sold on the Sram drivetrain and derailier compared to Deore. In Australia Specialized have the Elite for $1,300 compared to $2,300 for the Chisel. A big difference in price for the moderate levels of riding I do.
Great video. I bought a 2022 Expert for $1,500 retail. The SRAM SX derailleur is junk. It broke on me within 2 months. I ended up getting a SRAM GX derailleur and GX shifter. I also got a PNW dropper post added. The bike is great now. If I could do it all over, I would have a trusted bike shop fit me for a frame and build me a bike. Maybe next time. This was my first mtb purchase.
Just got from first ride bought a rockhopper sport in blue few hours ago love it ill do a fork upgrade in a few months i ride alot of wheelies and jump little bit dontrails but have to seive to Memphis Tennessee about 40 mins away ❤❤❤❤
I originally was going to go for a Base, I thought there wasn't much of a difference between models, but now your video has helped me lean more towards buying a Sport. I'd say the extra 100 is worth it!
I went into my local shop looking for a hybrid. (Mostly road). Ended up ordering the Rockhopper Sport. They’re putting hybrid tires on for me. Really excited about it after seeing the reviews and doing the research. Admittedly should’ve done this before ordering but it looks like I didn’t make a mistake.
Thanks for the info, and for the great presentation…you’re really good at this! Is it worth it to upgrade from the Sport’s XCM to a fork with lockout if I’m mostly going to be riding on the road? I’ve been using an older 2010 Hard Rock with a fork that doesn’t lock out and I’ve just been tightening it to the max…seems to work fine, but I’m aware that I’m very slow by most road biker’s standards, haha. Just wondering if it’s worth the money, time and effort. Thanks again and have a good one!
Thank you! And I’d say anything is better if you’re coming from the 2010 bike, so you could probably do fine with the XCM and tighten the preload like you said. Having a lockout is pretty nice since it really makes that fork solid for the SR Suntour spring loaded forks so you’re more efficient, which helps on newer mountain bikes since we now have the wider handlebars and wider tires that make it slower. Getting an air fork with a lockout would be the best since you would lose a good amount of weight which helps for riding on the road. I’d say to just ride the bike out and if you start to feel slow then that could be a good upgrade. If you are mainly riding on the road though you could swap out the tires to thinner gravel style tires and that would also make you faster, but I understand if that’s not your ideal option
Love your videos. They are nice bikes. Back in 2020 I had to settled for a Rockhopper (Base) mainly because of the pandemic which made it impossible to shop around. Not a a bad model, but I quickly upgraded the fork to a Judy which made a huge difference. With their price increases I was hoping they'd give better components from the get go.
Thank you! And yeah, the Rockhoppers are cool but dang they are expensive now. But then again, all bikes increased in price so relatively it makes more sense. Still hard to see that happen though
Thank you for the breakdown. I really appreciate it. I have a Rockhopper 2019 Acid Green color and pretty much changed all the components on it from handlebars, stem, BB, rims, tubeless tires down to drivetrain 3x8s to a 1x12s Shimano SLX and dropper post I love the bike. I'll be purchasing the 2022 Rockhopper Sport for my wife.
Great video. Ive just watched the first few minutes, and Ill save this video to watch it afterwork. I have a rockhopper 2016 I want a New one. This is great, dont know if I chamge to another rockhopper or a Trek Marlyn. 🤔🤔🤔
Thank you for making such informative videos, I am learning a lot as I know very little about the components and their differences. I have also watched your marlin comparison video and wondered if you had an opinion on the best HT that is around $1,200 or less (models that are a few years old are fine too if you think going for a used 2021 or something would be better.) Or if any cheaper FS would be a better value in that price range.
Thank you too for watching! And if you’re starting out, bikes like the new gen 3 trek marlins are all really good. I love the trek roscoe which is a higher end trek hardtail and amazing for trail riding, they retail a bit higher but can probably get them used for around that price. The roscoe 6 should be around that price point. They recently got updated though so I’m talking about the 2023 or newer frame versions with 29” wheels, not the older frames that use 27.5” wheels with plus size tires.
Thank you for this breakdown, it was very helpful. I have a Rockhopper Comp 29. I love it but am looking to upgrade. Do you think the Roscoe 7 would be a good upgrade from the Rockhopper Comp 29? Or would I be better off with a Fuse Comp 29?
No problem! Glad it helped. And the fuse and the roscoe are both great upgrades from the rockhopper and you’ll notice a difference for sure. I haven’t looked at the fuse too much for this year but taking a quick look at the specs, it seems very similar to the roscoe 7. I like the shimano deore drivetrain on the roscoe more than the sram NX drivetrain on the fuse since I think the deore is more reliable and durable, but neither is a bad option
I'm not a down hiller, I bought a rock hopper simply because it was down in price from £799, to £640, and I just had a gifthorse which generated £370 toward the cost. So... I actually only paid£270. What a bargain. Ok, so my one, has black matt text on a dark battleship blue satin. It's very subtle, and doesn't attract attention. What a great ride. Ive had mine a year, and I really looked after it, it's immaculate. It rides really well, at slow, (walking speed), its solid, and I have the large size, but im only 5' 7" . I did cut about an inch off each side of the handlebars, for me, they were too wide, and I still think a few more millimetres could go. The saddle was fine, but I changed it for an, ' Ego ', and slouching forward, in the neanderthal position, just annoys me, so, from, ' Halfords ', I bought an adjustable riser set at max for a more upright position. I would recomend it, but only from a town, road, and gravel track experience. It is a big, long, wide bike, but cool.👍😊
Thank you 🙏 You helped me to choose the bike I need. I bought the Elite and I am very satisfied with. The only problem I have with the Elite is the front hidraulic brake it makes a huge noise when I brake, hopefully after changing the pads will be less noisy. But it's really a great bike I love it. Thanks 👍
You’re welcome! And noisy brakes can be a result of dust or debris getting into the pads and rotor. Cleaning the brake rotor itself with alcohol usually helps, as well as sanding down the pads a bit if you have the tools to do so
Yes, for some reason I had the feeling to buy the Elite. Then I saw this video and then decided to buy the Elite. So far I am really happy with it. I use the bike in the forest road, nothing extreme, only fitness and cruising.
I bought a comp around the same time as you. Holding up good so far. Taken off some 2 foot drops and lots of uphill. Im out of shape but it seems easy to go up hill
YOU are My HERO. I was just thinking - I need a g.d. spreadsheet to figure out which Rockhopper to buy my kid! You must think just like me! HOWEVER I have to say that I bought a Rockhopper COMP for my older son 6 months ago and it was different than what you list in this video - It has an air fork (store guy said they switched that up this year on the Comp) and I am 99% sure it was a 1x10 drivetrain, not 1x9. Sigh.... It's a constantly moving target. They make TOO many variations, They make no attempt to explain or rank the tiers on their website, and they do change many of the components every year so nothing stays the same. GRRRRRRR Now I'm looking for my younger son, and the store guy explained there are 3 versions of Rockhopper in a small frame - but I have no idea which of these 5 you covered are equal to those 3 he mentioned. And I can't verify what is on which version unless I go to the store again and examine each one. And I know that Specialized will never put a chart like this on their website, because they are constantly changing things due to supply or annual updates and it would never be accurate. Bottom line - Be Warned! If you are looking to buy you MUST spend hours researching, verifying, and know which year bike you are looking at vs what is in stock at the store, to understand what you are getting. It's not even a fun experience 😞
Appreciate your comment!! Yeah these days it's pretty crazy to try and get an accurate spec list, they change things from country to country and sometimes even locally the bikes could be different like you mentioned. At the end of the day the parts shouldn't be tooo different, but I have seen companies spec lower quality parts sometimes and customers may not know the difference which is sucky
Great video and info 🙌. I bought a base model in lockdown/2020 as it was the only xxl I could find . You've convinced me the elite is for me but are they available in xxl as only base model here in UK seems available, thanks.
That's so nice of you! But no worries, I'm happy to create the videos and I'm grateful that they are helping you out. Thank you for watching and supporting the channel!
Here we are in 2024 and several of the Rockhopper models are not available. My girlfriends RH Comp 29 was lost in a house fire. Tried to replace it with the same and it is not available in medium. Not in the local shop, the Specialized website or the consumer website.
Thank you so much for your explanation. Exactly what I was looking for. Straight to the point, clear, with a personal opinion, and without a lot of "it depends what you want". Regarding your choice for Elite, nowadays they are on sale in all other models (maybe because of your video they didn't include Elite on sale). So, in this scenario that Expert is 999 rather than Elite that still 1,150 you would say that Expert would be your choice, right? Or is there anything you didn't like on Expert model? Thank you again.
You're welcome! The Elite and Expert are pretty much the same bike besides the brakes and drivetrain. I'm fine with either pf the brakes, but I personally prefer the shimano drivetrain on the elite over the sram drivetrain on the expert. Although the expert has a wider gear range and the drivetrain itself is technically more expensive, I don't like the quality of it as much. It's a tough decision, but get the elite if you value a higher quality drivetrain that will be more reliable, or get the expert if you value a wider range of gearing options, and are fine with potentially upgrading the rear derailleur.
@Talalipop MTB total newbie here, I am about to buy the expert as my 1st real bike and was concerned on the derailer on the expert. So I can just upgrade the derailer with the Shimano later and how much would those be? I really like the expert blue color. But I'm willing to get the elite so I don't have to switch later. This will be mostly hauling my kids around paved roads with occasional dirt trails that are not too intense. Thank you.
@@TalalipopMTB Thank you for answer me back. I ended up purchasing the Expert due to the sale price of 999. If SRAM drivetrain break, I hope doesn't cost more than 150 that was the difference between both models. 🚲
I think you are the perfect candidate to do a good video series on building a CYC 5,000 watt 72 volt 50 mph bike build. Little bits and pieces of info are out there and some ok video builds using cyc electric moto kits but I think you should think about doing a really good detailed info series on these kit builds. Strong hard tail frame and gearing with a great front fork.. Large open frame space with space to put a huge triangle battery .. Starting with a bike and why you chose that bike.. You would need to learn about the CYC system and what you have to install before taking on the job.. Would be fun to see someone with your knowledge build the ultimate 50 mph ebike 😁
My wife is an advanced rider and she was looking for a cheap gravel bike and something that could act as a fast XC bike. We got her a 22 Elite and she was a little skeptical but ended up really liking it. Cheaper than a set of wheels we were looking at for her other bike and she ended up riding all the time and enjoying what us really pretty cheap speed and simplicity. Takes you back to a simpler time in riding and honestly, she was shredding pretty hard on it. I agree the Elite is a better choice than the expert, the Deore drivetrain actually performs really well. The blue actually is a really good looking color too…
8:18 We just purchased in the US a 2022 rockhopper sport 29 small and ours came with 28 spoke rims with presta valves. Not sure if they changed out the 29s for this upgraded wheel as you mentioned it should have the 32 spoke with a Schrader valve. Great video of the comparison. Also do you know if all the cranks use the same square taper?
Yes they use the same cheap square taper crankset on every bike model in the rockhopper lineup. Kind of ridiculous considering how much the top-of-the-line model costs. These bikes really are overpriced for what they are
The expert was on sale for 1000 US dollars and I still chose the elite for 1,150$. All I know is that the elite rides like nothing I’ve ever had before. Did blues and yellows toady it’s just works that’s all I can say wondering what that sram is all about and how it feels. Chimano is pretty darn good
Really, they're both great bikes, if you had bought the expert it would've been a good idea to buy a GX derailleur and shifter, and chain upgrade. Once that's done the expert becomes an incredible bike without that crap SX derailleur. So another 250, at least. I would suggest a dropper post, one up is good with 150 mm travel for a large or XL. The dropper post is an incredible upgrade.
@@alidabirnia2882 valid point. Just didn’t want to start upgrading so quick to make it better. I will get a dropper post for sure , I did change the pedals already enjoying it very much. I don’t have any buyers remorse that’s for sure.
@@xk964264 I wouldn't either, that's a sick bike, I'd be happy with either one and I've only heard good things about the the shimano groupset and disc brakes that come with the elite.
Nothing like finding the best comparison video out there AFTER ordering one haha. Thankfully for me, I ordered the Elite for my wife so I think I did good! Especially since the Elite is currently on sale from Specialized (and apparently retailers too) for USD$950! Question for you: You mentioned the rear derailleur that gets dented up too easily (I think it was the 12 speed one)...the other ones are more resistant to damage? And what do people who have that 12 speed one? Replace it every year? Or are there other ones they can upgrade to? And must they also upgrade the shifter too? Thanks!
Hahaha thank you! The elite is definitely a great bike. Yeah that SX Eagle derailleur is just made from lower quality parts like mainly plastic components that tend to bend more easily. The other ones are more resistant in my experience, but the much lower end ones on the rockhopper and comp won’t be too great either but you get what you pay for in those cases and they work fine enough. For the 12 speed derailleur I’d recommend just riding it out until it breaks or bends beyond repair and then replace it with a NX Eagle derailleur or GX eagle which is more expensive but would last a lot longer
Great vid and thanks for the in depth review. My question for you - you mention that all rockhoppers with the same wheel size use the exact same frame, how is that possible when the dimensions are all different? I ordered an XL 29er and the top tube is too high so I am returning it for a large frame with a lower top tube. Doesn't that mean the frames are different? Thanks!
Thank you too! And my bad, I meant that all the 29 inch wheel rockhoppers in a certain frame size will have the same frame, while the 27.5 rockhoppers have a different one. So a medium 29” rockhopper comp or elite or expert will have the same frame, while a medium 27.5” rockhopper comp or elite or expert will have the same frame.
Ive added a air shock and suspension seatpost to my 29". Its the cheaper version but im not one of those people that need to spend thousands on bikes as i get enjoyment riding. And ive converted mine to mid drive 750w bafang electric and add a taller handlebar stem as i hate leaning forward as it hurts my neck and shoulders. The brakes are great but mineral oil ones would be better. Since convertibg it ive added over a thousand kilometers in a few months but im doing more now the weather has improved. I have a giant and marin 29 ebikes ive made and i love all 3. And i never had to spend $11k+ here in australia as thats what a specialized emtb costs
Thanks for great overview. I could see specialized has reduced prices and now comp costs $713, expert $1049 and elite $1150. which one do you suggest after the price change. This would really help me.
I would personally buy the comp to get a good bike and save money. If a better bike matters more to you or if you do want to keep the bike and ride for a long time, the expert is awesome and would give you a pretty good deal since it’s even less than the elite for a better bike.
Yeah the elite is definitely better if you consider the retail prices in my opinion. But if you get the expert for $100 less than the elite, the decision becomes tougher. You’re right that I prefer the elite and I guess “better bike” wasn’t the best terminology. The expert is more expensive and I don’t believe this sale will last forever, as I’ve seen the rockhopper bikes go on sale in the past and then jump back up to retail. So if I were to buy between the elite and expert right now, I’d probably get the expert and when prices jump up again I could more easily sell the expert or trade it in for a higher profit since it’s a more expensive bike according to specialized. Overall, I’d get the expert over the elite in this case since you save $100 and still get a really good bike. The SX drivetrain is mainly hindered by the derailleur, which can be upgraded to an NX Eagle derailleur in the future. But the expert does give you a 12 speed, and since specialized considers the expert to be a higher end bike than the elite, it has a higher value.
@@TalalipopMTB Okay, thanks heaps Sir. Here in Aus, the expert is still $300 more than the Elite. I'm about to pull the trigger on the Elite, based on your video, but became unsure from the above comment. I'll stick to the Elite I think, as I'm not sure if I'll need the 12th gear.
@@TalalipopMTB great vid, really helped me decide. given the new prices, are there other brands with comparable specs to the comp or elite you can recommend?
I wonder what's the difference in top speed on the road is between the sport (double crank in front with 36 highest) and the comp (30 highest) in the highest gear, anybody knows for example how much rpm you have to do with the comp to go for example 19 miles/hour = 30 km/u with the comp
A 29 tire covers a little more than 7 feet per revolution. The Sport has a top gear of 36/11 or 3.27 turns of the wheel for 1 turn of the pedals, roughly 23 feet. 23 x 60 rpm x 60 minutes per hour ÷ 5280 feet per mile is 15.68 mph. The Comp has a top speed of 30/11 or 2.72 roughly 19 feet. It's speed would be 12.95 mph at 60 rpm.
I bought a 2023 Rockhopper from the original owner who used it 4 months, he upgraded the fork and pedals. I went over to try it out, the front large sprocket was bent, so from the $500 asking went to an offer of $350, which was accepted. The week before I checked out new ones and wasn’t impressed with the prices. Facebook marketplace is a great source for used bikes, if you’re patient and not lured by a scammer. I look closely at the pictures, for the neighborhood, garage and other clues to verify it’s legit or not. Also talking to the owner, and asking plenty of questions will filter out fakes too. A side note, pictures of the bike I bought were posted later by a fake poster, which was reported. Thieves never sleep 😡
Just bought brandnew rockhopper sport few hours ago went for a good ride will do a fork upgrade other than that for me I ride wheelies a lot and jump do trails just don't have many around my area unless I drive to Memphis Tennessee ❤❤
If people just find one local and not pay ANY MONEY ahead of time hopefully they won't get scammed, I just bought a new rockhopper sport a few hours ago I will do a fork upgrade in a few months but other than that it does what I wanted to do I love it❤❤❤❤
I bought an second hand elite and the wheelset doesn’t have tubeless tape. After watching this vídeo I was hopping just to change valves and add tubeless sealent…
Just ordered an Expert for £674, there are deals out there on the 2023 range right now. It replaces a 10yr old Rockhopper Comp which I've really enjoyed over the years.
This made my life much easier. Thanks for all the research and work u put in
You’re welcome! Glad it helped :)
This video is awesome. You did an incredible job explaining the differences between each bike. I don’t know much of anything about mountain biking but have been looking into buying a Scott Aspect or Specialized Rockhopper recently and this video was so informative. Amazing.
Thank you for watching! Glad it helped you out :D
I just bought a brand new rockhopper sport a few hours ago I lost my trek Roscoe 8 about 4 months ago but I love it hopefully you found you something
I bought an elite last week, it will arrive next Thursday. I just watched your video and confirmed that my choice was the best. Congratulations on the review! thanks!
Awesome!! Thank you for watching :D
Thanks for helping a noob getting into cycling learn a lot about bikes!
Haha no worries!
Thanks for the video. Your thorough comparison reviews are very helpful and greatly appreciated.
I've been keeping my eye out for an MTB but the reviews usually, only focus on the top tier option out of the respective lineups.
You’re welcome!! Glad they help out :)
I needed a commuter that could handle the unmaintained roads where i live. Thank you for making .e feel so much more confident about my purchase!
You’re welcome! Hope you enjoy it!!
What did you get and are you happy with the purchase?
Exactly the info I was looking for since I'm trying to decode the Specialized lineup myself right now. One techwriting suggestion that can put your content at the top of the heap: in the chart, eliminate all duplicate phrases, merging the cells so that for instance, you have a row called Front Suspension and there are only two cells with just the single words: coil or air. I don't dispute the value of the XCR/M distinctions but that's what the video is for, not the chart. Thanks for saving me lots of time!
Planning to buy the specialized rockhopper elite 29 in May. 😎🇺🇸
I just bought mine! Will have it in a week or so!
@@venictos How does the Rockhopper Elite ride mate?! Does it have issues with it's speeds skipping gears etc like the Sport model?
@greekveteran2715 I haven't had any issues with it skipping gears. It rides nicely but then again I've only ridden it a few times on terrain.
@@venictos Thank you very much! I really appreciate it, I'm getting one on Monday!! Thanks again!
Love this video that helps me a lot as a beginner.
Glad it helped!
Man I wished I saw this before I bought mine! I bought the entry-level Rockhopper, but now I am leaning towards selling mine and buying the Elite 💚💚
Great review and channel. thanks for the detailed and well explained information.
thanks for this technical review, very interesting. I own the Rockhopper Elite and I am very satisfied with this quality bike. I use it in moutain trails and it does the job
You’re welcome! The elite is definitely a great bike!
Awesome video. Between the graphics, text, and narration, you really set the bar for this kind of thing.
I was paying attention to the gear ratio of the models with just one sprocket up front vs. the models with two front sprockets. Sounds like the 1Xs are 30-to-11 at their highest speed setting whereas the 2Xs are 36-to-11. On a long, straight-and-level road, would a rider feel like he was missing out on the opportunity to ride faster with these 1X set-ups? I really like the simplicity of 1 sprocket up front.
Definitely limits top achievable speed on flat road. You can upgrade though for a bigger chainring but that's going to have its costs. Frame has to be designed to accept a front deraileur.
Thanks for the great overview! I got the Elite last summer and agree that it's a better deal than the Expert. I was holding out for a Specialized Chisel because I thought I needed the thru axles and tapered head tube but it was just not worth the price increase. Also for the kind of moderate riding I do (mostly bike path with occasional dirt and gravel) I really didn't need those features. I did find that the 30 tooth front ring was too small and I would spin out while pedaling even slight downhills. It cost me about $150 to upgrade to a 34T front ring because I also had to upgrade the bottom bracket and cranks. I also spent another $35 to raise the front handle bars because I wanted a more upright ride. So I ended up paying about the same price as the Expert but got exactly the right bike for me. I think the increase from 40T to 51T in the rear may be overkill -- for me at least -- since I have never needed to use the largest 2 or 3 gears, but for serious cross country riders it may be worth it.
You’re welcome! Sounds like you got a good setup going there so I’m happy to hear it worked out for you. And yeah the big cassette isn’t for anyone but it’s nice to have as an option and I’ve personally benefitted from it a lot
In the same situation as yourself. Love the Chisel but hard to justify the extra $$ over the Elite. After looking at this comparison, I'm not sold on the Sram drivetrain and derailier compared to Deore. In Australia Specialized have the Elite for $1,300 compared to $2,300 for the Chisel. A big difference in price for the moderate levels of riding I do.
Great video. I bought a 2022 Expert for $1,500 retail. The SRAM SX derailleur is junk. It broke on me within 2 months.
I ended up getting a SRAM GX derailleur and GX shifter. I also got a PNW dropper post added. The bike is great now.
If I could do it all over, I would have a trusted bike shop fit me for a frame and build me a bike. Maybe next time. This was my first mtb purchase.
Thanks! And those upgrades are awesome!! Definitely makes that a much better bike for sure.
Thank you for this informative video! I am heading in to buy a Rockhopper Comp!
You're welcome, glad it helped!
Have the RH sport 19 now for a few years. Really like it but looking to upgrade to the RH elite. Your review sealed the deal for me. Thanks.
You mean change your bike or upgrade your own bike parts to reach Elite level ?
@@sACLeFR my days of being elite on any bike are most likely behind me now 👍.
@@bripw 🤣 I meant changing your bike to a new RH or upgrade the one you have ?
@@sACLeFR New bike. Went for the RH elite 29... so far I like. Was debating between a full suspension and hard tail.
Thanks for the video...nice review. A comparison on the weights of the bikes would have been appreciated though.
You’re welcome! And Specialized doesn’t disclose the weights of these bikes on their website otherwise I would’ve included that.
Very helpful video. i am now enlightened more than I had expected. thank you.
Thank you! I’m happy it helped :D
Just got from first ride bought a rockhopper sport in blue few hours ago love it ill do a fork upgrade in a few months i ride alot of wheelies and jump little bit dontrails but have to seive to Memphis Tennessee about 40 mins away ❤❤❤❤
Awesome!!!
Thanks so much for such a detail comparation. Just the video I was looking for
You’re welcome!
I originally was going to go for a Base, I thought there wasn't much of a difference between models, but now your video has helped me lean more towards buying a Sport. I'd say the extra 100 is worth it!
Glad it helped! I agree that the extra $100 is worth it for that model
Rn it’s reduced by 200€, at least in Germany.. maybe in ur place too
@@philippbuuutz9554 The 27.5" model is on sale for me, the others are still normal price I believe
I went into my local shop looking for a hybrid. (Mostly road). Ended up ordering the Rockhopper Sport. They’re putting hybrid tires on for me. Really excited about it after seeing the reviews and doing the research. Admittedly should’ve done this before ordering but it looks like I didn’t make a mistake.
Great video man! Keep up the good work!
Thanks!!
Very exelent compararison ! I love you man !
Thank you!! Appreciate you watching :)
Thanks for the info, and for the great presentation…you’re really good at this! Is it worth it to upgrade from the Sport’s XCM to a fork with lockout if I’m mostly going to be riding on the road? I’ve been using an older 2010 Hard Rock with a fork that doesn’t lock out and I’ve just been tightening it to the max…seems to work fine, but I’m aware that I’m very slow by most road biker’s standards, haha. Just wondering if it’s worth the money, time and effort. Thanks again and have a good one!
Thank you! And I’d say anything is better if you’re coming from the 2010 bike, so you could probably do fine with the XCM and tighten the preload like you said. Having a lockout is pretty nice since it really makes that fork solid for the SR Suntour spring loaded forks so you’re more efficient, which helps on newer mountain bikes since we now have the wider handlebars and wider tires that make it slower. Getting an air fork with a lockout would be the best since you would lose a good amount of weight which helps for riding on the road. I’d say to just ride the bike out and if you start to feel slow then that could be a good upgrade. If you are mainly riding on the road though you could swap out the tires to thinner gravel style tires and that would also make you faster, but I understand if that’s not your ideal option
thanks for the video, have watched this so many times and is very usefull in all aspects
You’re welcome! Glad it helped :D
Thanks, useful
You’re welcome!
Perfect video, exactly what I was looking for!
Glad it helped!
Bought a Rockhopper Comp for $750 last September 2022. Rides great! Wished it came with RockShox instead of SunTour front suspension which is heavy.
Informative and well produced.
Thank you!
Thank you soooooooo much!!! It really helps!!!
Yeah of course!
This is a fantastic comparison I hope you make a couple more
Thanks for the video, it helps a lot
You’re welcome!
Excellent, detailed, and helpful review!
Thanks!!
Thank you, exactly what I needed.
You're welcome!
Thanks for clearing that up! Well done, and informational.
Of course!
Thanks for putting this together. Very handy.
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you gr8 video, will buy the Elite
Glad it helped!
Love your videos. They are nice bikes. Back in 2020 I had to settled for a Rockhopper (Base) mainly because of the pandemic which made it impossible to shop around. Not a a bad model, but I quickly upgraded the fork to a Judy which made a huge difference. With their price increases I was hoping they'd give better components from the get go.
Thank you! And yeah, the Rockhoppers are cool but dang they are expensive now. But then again, all bikes increased in price so relatively it makes more sense. Still hard to see that happen though
Thank you for the breakdown. I really appreciate it. I have a Rockhopper 2019 Acid Green color and pretty much changed all the components on it from handlebars, stem, BB, rims, tubeless tires down to drivetrain 3x8s to a 1x12s Shimano SLX and dropper post I love the bike. I'll be purchasing the 2022 Rockhopper Sport for my wife.
Awesome!! Thank you for watching as well :)
Great review NOW can you do 2024???
Great video. Ive just watched the first few minutes, and Ill save this video to watch it afterwork. I have a rockhopper 2016 I want a New one. This is great, dont know if I chamge to another rockhopper or a Trek Marlyn. 🤔🤔🤔
Thanks! Glad it’s helping :)
@@TalalipopMTB yes bro thank you very much. Its helping.
Hope you do a talon 2023 line up comparison
I’ll look into that!
Hey man was looking to get my first mountain bike. Do you recommend trek marlin 5 or the Rockhopper Sport/ normal rockhopper?
Thank you for making such informative videos, I am learning a lot as I know very little about the components and their differences. I have also watched your marlin comparison video and wondered if you had an opinion on the best HT that is around $1,200 or less (models that are a few years old are fine too if you think going for a used 2021 or something would be better.) Or if any cheaper FS would be a better value in that price range.
Thank you too for watching! And if you’re starting out, bikes like the new gen 3 trek marlins are all really good. I love the trek roscoe which is a higher end trek hardtail and amazing for trail riding, they retail a bit higher but can probably get them used for around that price. The roscoe 6 should be around that price point. They recently got updated though so I’m talking about the 2023 or newer frame versions with 29” wheels, not the older frames that use 27.5” wheels with plus size tires.
Thank you for this breakdown, it was very helpful. I have a Rockhopper Comp 29. I love it but am looking to upgrade. Do you think the Roscoe 7 would be a good upgrade from the Rockhopper Comp 29? Or would I be better off with a Fuse Comp 29?
No problem! Glad it helped. And the fuse and the roscoe are both great upgrades from the rockhopper and you’ll notice a difference for sure. I haven’t looked at the fuse too much for this year but taking a quick look at the specs, it seems very similar to the roscoe 7. I like the shimano deore drivetrain on the roscoe more than the sram NX drivetrain on the fuse since I think the deore is more reliable and durable, but neither is a bad option
I'm not a down hiller, I bought a rock hopper simply because it was down in price from £799, to £640, and I just had a gifthorse which generated £370 toward the cost. So... I actually only paid£270. What a bargain. Ok, so my one, has black matt text on a dark battleship blue satin. It's very subtle, and doesn't attract attention. What a great ride. Ive had mine a year, and I really looked after it, it's immaculate. It rides really well, at slow, (walking speed), its solid, and I have the large size, but im only 5' 7" . I did cut about an inch off each side of the handlebars, for me, they were too wide, and I still think a few more millimetres could go. The saddle was fine, but I changed it for an, ' Ego ', and slouching forward, in the neanderthal position, just annoys me, so, from, ' Halfords ', I bought an adjustable riser set at max for a more upright position. I would recomend it, but only from a town, road, and gravel track experience. It is a big, long, wide bike, but cool.👍😊
Thanks for the review. I'm looking at the Elite and this was a great comparison for me. Sealed the deal. Appreciate it
I got the elite, even with the expert being on sale , makes you wonder why they have the expert on sale,.
I bought a rockhopper elite 29. Hope i like it!
Awesome video - thorough and concise, much appreciated!!
Thank you, glad you liked it!
Thank you 🙏
You helped me to choose the bike I need. I bought the Elite and I am very satisfied with. The only problem I have with the Elite is the front hidraulic brake it makes a huge noise when I brake, hopefully after changing the pads will be less noisy. But it's really a great bike I love it. Thanks 👍
You’re welcome! And noisy brakes can be a result of dust or debris getting into the pads and rotor. Cleaning the brake rotor itself with alcohol usually helps, as well as sanding down the pads a bit if you have the tools to do so
did you get the elite even by knowing that the expert was on sale. ?
Yes, for some reason I had the feeling to buy the Elite. Then I saw this video and then decided to buy the Elite. So far I am really happy with it. I use the bike in the forest road, nothing extreme, only fitness and cruising.
Same got the elite and I’m just happy lol very happy with my choice.
Enjoy your ride 😁
FYI, the Rockhopper Comp comes with a Rockshox Judy fork (NOT the Suntour XCM) according to Specialized website specs.
I bought an Elite for $900 and love it…it’s a beast at climbing…
Just bought a Comp yesterday rides great I’m new to riding so let’s see how she holds up
Awesome!
I bought a comp around the same time as you. Holding up good so far. Taken off some 2 foot drops and lots of uphill. Im out of shape but it seems easy to go up hill
You should do a comparison between the different tiers of the Kona Dew line. Great vid 🤙🏽
Realy good video!
Thank you!!
YOU are My HERO. I was just thinking - I need a g.d. spreadsheet to figure out which Rockhopper to buy my kid! You must think just like me!
HOWEVER I have to say that I bought a Rockhopper COMP for my older son 6 months ago and it was different than what you list in this video - It has an air fork (store guy said they switched that up this year on the Comp) and I am 99% sure it was a 1x10 drivetrain, not 1x9. Sigh.... It's a constantly moving target.
They make TOO many variations, They make no attempt to explain or rank the tiers on their website, and they do change many of the components every year so nothing stays the same. GRRRRRRR
Now I'm looking for my younger son, and the store guy explained there are 3 versions of Rockhopper in a small frame - but I have no idea which of these 5 you covered are equal to those 3 he mentioned. And I can't verify what is on which version unless I go to the store again and examine each one. And I know that Specialized will never put a chart like this on their website, because they are constantly changing things due to supply or annual updates and it would never be accurate.
Bottom line - Be Warned! If you are looking to buy you MUST spend hours researching, verifying, and know which year bike you are looking at vs what is in stock at the store, to understand what you are getting. It's not even a fun experience 😞
Appreciate your comment!! Yeah these days it's pretty crazy to try and get an accurate spec list, they change things from country to country and sometimes even locally the bikes could be different like you mentioned. At the end of the day the parts shouldn't be tooo different, but I have seen companies spec lower quality parts sometimes and customers may not know the difference which is sucky
Great video and info 🙌. I bought a base model in lockdown/2020 as it was the only xxl I could find . You've convinced me the elite is for me but are they available in xxl as only base model here in UK seems available, thanks.
Thank you too!
My brandnew RH sport came with a 1x drivetrain 👍🏻👍🏻also mine has a shimano cues derailleur with clutch
If you’re commuting. Is it worth upgrading to a Rockhopper sport from the entry point one?
thanks a lot for the video, very helpfull
You’re welcome!
Thanks for this. Looking at 2024's. You should add a "buy me a coffee" link, I'd send you a couple bucks. Thanks again for saving me some time.
That's so nice of you! But no worries, I'm happy to create the videos and I'm grateful that they are helping you out. Thank you for watching and supporting the channel!
Great Video!
Thanks!
I'm very happy with the stock Comp. For slick conditions I will upgrade the peddals. Eventually I will upgrade to airshocks.
Great information!
Thanks!
Thanks for details review 👍
No problem!
Great video. Very helpful!
Thank you!
What a great video, thank you sir.
Welcome! Thank you too for watching
Thannnk you your vidéo is amzing !!
You're welcome!!
What are your thoughts between the Specialized Rockhopper lineup and the GT avalanche lineup. Which would you choose? Thanks
Should do the same style video for the stump jumper
Very informative. Thanks
Welcome!
Here we are in 2024 and several of the Rockhopper models are not available. My girlfriends RH Comp 29 was lost in a house fire. Tried to replace it with the same and it is not available in medium. Not in the local shop, the Specialized website or the consumer website.
Thank you so much for your explanation. Exactly what I was looking for. Straight to the point, clear, with a personal opinion, and without a lot of "it depends what you want". Regarding your choice for Elite, nowadays they are on sale in all other models (maybe because of your video they didn't include Elite on sale). So, in this scenario that Expert is 999 rather than Elite that still 1,150 you would say that Expert would be your choice, right? Or is there anything you didn't like on Expert model? Thank you again.
You're welcome! The Elite and Expert are pretty much the same bike besides the brakes and drivetrain. I'm fine with either pf the brakes, but I personally prefer the shimano drivetrain on the elite over the sram drivetrain on the expert. Although the expert has a wider gear range and the drivetrain itself is technically more expensive, I don't like the quality of it as much. It's a tough decision, but get the elite if you value a higher quality drivetrain that will be more reliable, or get the expert if you value a wider range of gearing options, and are fine with potentially upgrading the rear derailleur.
@Talalipop MTB total newbie here, I am about to buy the expert as my 1st real bike and was concerned on the derailer on the expert. So I can just upgrade the derailer with the Shimano later and how much would those be? I really like the expert blue color. But I'm willing to get the elite so I don't have to switch later. This will be mostly hauling my kids around paved roads with occasional dirt trails that are not too intense. Thank you.
@@TalalipopMTB Thank you for answer me back. I ended up purchasing the Expert due to the sale price of 999. If SRAM drivetrain break, I hope doesn't cost more than 150 that was the difference between both models. 🚲
I think you are the perfect candidate to do a good video series on building a CYC 5,000 watt 72 volt 50 mph bike build. Little bits and pieces of info are out there and some ok video builds using cyc electric moto kits but I think you should think about doing a really good detailed info series on these kit builds. Strong hard tail frame and gearing with a great front fork.. Large open frame space with space to put a huge triangle battery .. Starting with a bike and why you chose that bike.. You would need to learn about the CYC system and what you have to install before taking on the job.. Would be fun to see someone with your knowledge build the ultimate 50 mph ebike 😁
Thank You!
np!
Not the least bit sorry I went with Trek especially after this comparison. Keep up these comparisions.
Thank you!
Hey can you help me choose one for the new models (2024) i want to buy one and i need advice, if you could help me pls do.
Super helpful! thank you
Welcome!
Amazing video!
Thank you!
My wife is an advanced rider and she was looking for a cheap gravel bike and something that could act as a fast XC bike. We got her a 22 Elite and she was a little skeptical but ended up really liking it. Cheaper than a set of wheels we were looking at for her other bike and she ended up riding all the time and enjoying what us really pretty cheap speed and simplicity. Takes you back to a simpler time in riding and honestly, she was shredding pretty hard on it. I agree the Elite is a better choice than the expert, the Deore drivetrain actually performs really well. The blue actually is a really good looking color too…
Nice!! Glad to hear that worked out for her :)
Great Video Thank You 🙏🏼
No problem!
Please, may i ask - since i've got the Expert for mostly city riding. What upgrade is well worth it in this case? 20-30% is easy mounting biking.
8:18 We just purchased in the US a 2022 rockhopper sport 29 small and ours came with 28 spoke rims with presta valves. Not sure if they changed out the 29s for this upgraded wheel as you mentioned it should have the 32 spoke with a Schrader valve. Great video of the comparison. Also do you know if all the cranks use the same square taper?
Yes they use the same cheap square taper crankset on every bike model in the rockhopper lineup. Kind of ridiculous considering how much the top-of-the-line model costs.
These bikes really are overpriced for what they are
The expert was on sale for 1000 US dollars and I still chose the elite for 1,150$. All I know is that the elite rides like nothing I’ve ever had before. Did blues and yellows toady it’s just works that’s all I can say wondering what that sram is all about and how it feels. Chimano is pretty darn good
Really, they're both great bikes, if you had bought the expert it would've been a good idea to buy a GX derailleur and shifter, and chain upgrade. Once that's done the expert becomes an incredible bike without that crap SX derailleur. So another 250, at least. I would suggest a dropper post, one up is good with 150 mm travel for a large or XL. The dropper post is an incredible upgrade.
@@alidabirnia2882 valid point. Just didn’t want to start upgrading so quick to make it better. I will get a dropper post for sure , I did change the pedals already enjoying it very much. I don’t have any buyers remorse that’s for sure.
@@xk964264 I wouldn't either, that's a sick bike, I'd be happy with either one and I've only heard good things about the the shimano groupset and disc brakes that come with the elite.
Nothing like finding the best comparison video out there AFTER ordering one haha. Thankfully for me, I ordered the Elite for my wife so I think I did good! Especially since the Elite is currently on sale from Specialized (and apparently retailers too) for USD$950!
Question for you: You mentioned the rear derailleur that gets dented up too easily (I think it was the 12 speed one)...the other ones are more resistant to damage? And what do people who have that 12 speed one? Replace it every year? Or are there other ones they can upgrade to? And must they also upgrade the shifter too? Thanks!
Hahaha thank you! The elite is definitely a great bike. Yeah that SX Eagle derailleur is just made from lower quality parts like mainly plastic components that tend to bend more easily. The other ones are more resistant in my experience, but the much lower end ones on the rockhopper and comp won’t be too great either but you get what you pay for in those cases and they work fine enough. For the 12 speed derailleur I’d recommend just riding it out until it breaks or bends beyond repair and then replace it with a NX Eagle derailleur or GX eagle which is more expensive but would last a lot longer
Great vid and thanks for the in depth review. My question for you - you mention that all rockhoppers with the same wheel size use the exact same frame, how is that possible when the dimensions are all different? I ordered an XL 29er and the top tube is too high so I am returning it for a large frame with a lower top tube. Doesn't that mean the frames are different?
Thanks!
Thank you too! And my bad, I meant that all the 29 inch wheel rockhoppers in a certain frame size will have the same frame, while the 27.5 rockhoppers have a different one. So a medium 29” rockhopper comp or elite or expert will have the same frame, while a medium 27.5” rockhopper comp or elite or expert will have the same frame.
Ive added a air shock and suspension seatpost to my 29". Its the cheaper version but im not one of those people that need to spend thousands on bikes as i get enjoyment riding. And ive converted mine to mid drive 750w bafang electric and add a taller handlebar stem as i hate leaning forward as it hurts my neck and shoulders. The brakes are great but mineral oil ones would be better. Since convertibg it ive added over a thousand kilometers in a few months but im doing more now the weather has improved. I have a giant and marin 29 ebikes ive made and i love all 3. And i never had to spend $11k+ here in australia as thats what a specialized emtb costs
Great video
Thanks!
Thanks for great overview. I could see specialized has reduced prices and now comp costs $713, expert $1049 and elite $1150. which one do you suggest after the price change. This would really help me.
I would personally buy the comp to get a good bike and save money. If a better bike matters more to you or if you do want to keep the bike and ride for a long time, the expert is awesome and would give you a pretty good deal since it’s even less than the elite for a better bike.
@@TalalipopMTB What makes the expert better? From watching your video I thought the Elite seemed to be the better bike, with the shimano drivetrain.
Yeah the elite is definitely better if you consider the retail prices in my opinion. But if you get the expert for $100 less than the elite, the decision becomes tougher. You’re right that I prefer the elite and I guess “better bike” wasn’t the best terminology. The expert is more expensive and I don’t believe this sale will last forever, as I’ve seen the rockhopper bikes go on sale in the past and then jump back up to retail. So if I were to buy between the elite and expert right now, I’d probably get the expert and when prices jump up again I could more easily sell the expert or trade it in for a higher profit since it’s a more expensive bike according to specialized.
Overall, I’d get the expert over the elite in this case since you save $100 and still get a really good bike. The SX drivetrain is mainly hindered by the derailleur, which can be upgraded to an NX Eagle derailleur in the future. But the expert does give you a 12 speed, and since specialized considers the expert to be a higher end bike than the elite, it has a higher value.
@@TalalipopMTB Okay, thanks heaps Sir. Here in Aus, the expert is still $300 more than the Elite. I'm about to pull the trigger on the Elite, based on your video, but became unsure from the above comment. I'll stick to the Elite I think, as I'm not sure if I'll need the 12th gear.
@@TalalipopMTB great vid, really helped me decide. given the new prices, are there other brands with comparable specs to the comp or elite you can recommend?
is quick release quick teft too?
Specialized has had 2 months in a row sale. The base is 488 and the Rockshox Judy can be found at 174, which the main upgrade to do.
RockShox Judy is a horrible fork don't buy it
I wonder what's the difference in top speed on the road is between the sport (double crank in front with 36 highest) and the comp (30 highest) in the highest gear, anybody knows for example how much rpm you have to do with the comp to go for example 19 miles/hour = 30 km/u with the comp
A 29 tire covers a little more than 7 feet per revolution. The Sport has a top gear of 36/11 or 3.27 turns of the wheel for 1 turn of the pedals, roughly 23 feet. 23 x 60 rpm x 60 minutes per hour ÷ 5280 feet per mile is 15.68 mph. The Comp has a top speed of 30/11 or 2.72 roughly 19 feet. It's speed would be 12.95 mph at 60 rpm.
I bought a 2023 Rockhopper from the original owner who used it 4 months, he upgraded the fork and pedals. I went over to try it out, the front large sprocket was bent, so from the $500 asking went to an offer of $350, which was accepted. The week before I checked out new ones and wasn’t impressed with the prices. Facebook marketplace is a great source for used bikes, if you’re patient and not lured by a scammer. I look closely at the pictures, for the neighborhood, garage and other clues to verify it’s legit or not. Also talking to the owner, and asking plenty of questions will filter out fakes too. A side note, pictures of the bike I bought were posted later by a fake poster, which was reported. Thieves never sleep 😡
Just bought brandnew rockhopper sport few hours ago went for a good ride will do a fork upgrade other than that for me I ride wheelies a lot and jump do trails just don't have many around my area unless I drive to Memphis Tennessee ❤❤
If people just find one local and not pay ANY MONEY ahead of time hopefully they won't get scammed, I just bought a new rockhopper sport a few hours ago I will do a fork upgrade in a few months but other than that it does what I wanted to do I love it❤❤❤❤
That's concerning. What is the scam? Is it getting mugged? Just asking as I'm currently shopping for a bike on Facebook
Charl south Africa Thank You really apriciate video
You're welcome!
My Hart is in 2 places between Specialized Rockhoper and Trek Marlin 5
I bought an second hand elite and the wheelset doesn’t have tubeless tape. After watching this vídeo I was hopping just to change valves and add tubeless sealent…
Thank you
Welcome!
Can you completely internally route a dropper post in this?! Please answer jesus i cant find the answer
Just ordered an Expert for £674, there are deals out there on the 2023 range right now. It replaces a 10yr old Rockhopper Comp which I've really enjoyed over the years.
Where from?
@@balancejedi162 It was from Tredz, only one colour was at that price & they've sold out now.
@@paulstevenson3877 Ahhh ok thanks anyway