Great review thank you. At the end of the day when I pull out a tool from my wave, other tools come out and bunch up with it. With this Swiss tool, each tool comes out smoothly and by itself. The craftsmanship cannot be compared! Victorinox all the way. I still have my SAK from 30 years ago! 👍
Your review is way better for me than most other reviewers because a) we are watching a person who actually uses these tools as part of their profession describing the pros and cons of each tool from his personal experience, and b) you are articulating it so well. That's really cool. As for the ratchet that you said you don't have here, I have it. And, to me, an amateur home user, it looks very well machined, and very well built. But I would have LOVED to hear your take on it, especially from using it - including bits about how much torque it can take etc.
Very true user review...I have both the tools leatherman wave and Victorinox spirit x...both were my edc once for over 3 years ecah as a marine technician in India...I still prefer to carry t spirit over t leatherman wave for same reasons. Thank you 😊
Yeah I often thought that myself, but a mid-size like the Juice...but with both handles being 93mm alox Vics, but it would also be cool to have a Squirt size version with 58mm alox as handles. Very disappointed with my Squirt, especially the scissors which are terrible, and it's now been relegated to ''gentleman's carry'' for days when I'm very unlikely to need it as I prefer my Nextool Mini as a mini (5th pocket) carry if I might actually need to cut or screw anything that day. I saw a Juice S2 recently in a shop here in London which I almost bought as they're almost impossible to find but I'm glad I didn't, the guy dropped the price to £80 but I've just looked online and seen I can get a Spirit X for that so it's a no-brainer.
Thanks for this thorough review. I own and use A spirit X for more than 10 years and to my personnal use I prefer it over the Leatherman Wave. Sturdier, more stainless, better finitions, and the tools are really usable. The philips screwdriver for example is a real 3D one, with reach and torque, unless the tiny and usuable one on the Wave. Same with the flat screwdriver. I own a very old Supertool Leatherman (over 20 years old) and it is really unbreakable. I've seen so many broken pliers on Leatherman Multitool, so many broken blade. Leatherman has a serious problem with the quality check control with their products. You cannot apply so much torque on the bit holder or it will fail. Leatherman nowaday use a too brittle steel and if you force it it will break. Victorinox steel is softer, It will bend but it won't break. Thus blades have to be sharpen more often, and cutting pliers are no so great with very hard wire.
On thing on that . Although it does have softer steel and you do have to sharpen more often . It sharpens easier , and takes little to no skill . A set of porcelain crock sticks is all you need . Or a strop , for that matter if you never let it get to dull . So there's that .
@@ronnietarnacke5153 That's true but tbh if you carry a Spirit X I doubt if the butterknife on it will be the only blade you carry. I reckon most people would carry it together with a dedicated folder of choice.
Good review as usual, thank you. The main gripe I have with this multitool is the nail-shredding nail nicks used to open the tools. Oh, I know some of you have nails like claw hammers, and can't understand why I find this a problem. But this is about my nails, not yours! If you are trying to open the tools after being out in the rain, or after watersports or swimming when your nails are very soft, you will tear your nails very easily. All the tools are locking, and don't use slip joint locking, so why does Victorinox use bear trap springs just to keep the tools closed?
In Germany and many other European countries you aren't allowed to carry one handed opening knives wich have a locking mechanism. So nearly all Leatherman tools are forbidden to carry except the Rebar, Super Tool 300 or Crunch. That beeing said you may realize why Victorinox didn't implement one handed features to their multitools.
@@appleztooranges It is a shame the leatherman's offered are poor quality. If they were more premium more would purchase them. All leatherman has to do is make the knife Not Locking and below 3inchs in the uk.
@@TheCoomer it’s not leatherman or the U.S’s problem you have a totalitarian government that lets criminals have knives and not the law abiding citizens. Leatherman isn’t going to downgrade our products just to go along with your strict laws. Get a grip.
@@Mikey-ym6ok Lol I agree that our knife laws are ridiculous in the UK and at the end of the day no self-respecting roadman is going to juke anyone with a Leatherman anyway lol the weapon of choice for those scumbags is a cheap kitchen knife from a Poundshop or stolen from their mum's kitchen draw. However it's business sense to make products which can be sold in overseas markets. In any case I carry a Rebar which has a locking blade but in a pouch with bike repair tools so in the very unlikely event I am searched I think I could argue that it constitutes ''valid reason''. Hell I even ride around central London with 6in lethal sharp fixed blades in my bag, completely legally, as I'm a part time restaurant chef and don't want anyone else using them while I'm not at work.
Got it today. I’m in love. Could almost be my favorite multitool! Almost. I love the meat cleaver knife on it, love the scissors, and love the package opener. I say it could be but it’s missing a pocket clip like the Leatherman wave and surge. It’s also missing one handed opening knives. I still think wave/surge is best overall multitool edc that I won’t leave house without. This tool I’ll put in my house for use or in my truck
I use the hook on my Swisschamp to help me pull bank line tighter, lift heavy stuff where my only handle is wire/twine, or to lift my steel bottle out of the fire by the wire bale. Super handy tool for sure
As always , EXCELLENT REVIEW! I see a lot of people trying to compare Victorinox VS Leatherman. Both brands are serious and professional. We need to remember the environment and regulations in USA are not the same in Europe. Ex. Environmental talking just most talking about wood and trees for hinking in Europe most of the forest had soft/medium hardness wood. Is why brand like Gransfors make Axe with low hardness AND Victorinox do not need a very hard steel but they have a lot of humidity so the need for anticorrosion is a 'must' . About regulations as we know, one hand open knife is illegal in most of European Countries. Here in USA he had Hard wood or Very hard wood that is why the pattern of the saw is more aggressive..... Regulations allow one open hand knife and most common and practical steel in USA range from 420-440 A,B and C. Leatherman will not add a lower steel hardness since is cheaper to replace tools than knifes. The warranty is 25 straight and is a supreme no questions ask warranty. Making blades apply more time and labor. Instead of tools. Victorinox give a lifetime warranty where honestly ...... I really believe a radio of 10:1 vs Leatherman in claims. Based kn forums and blogs. The Spirit and Swisstool are lighter and slimmers. Compact and with 1 tool engaged option which I find very comfortable. The pliers are for general use. . . Spirit pliers don't open like the Wave BUT what can you do with a full open Wave? Is just ridiculous uncomfortable tight a bolt with a full open mouth, so Spirit is more realistic of what the size reach? This are a few thoughts only. Nothing nto.do with the magnificent review from TX Crib Tool. Ben, please do more reviews. You have a lot of fanbase because of the professional way you make this stuff. Respectfully, MB
That was very well stated. I think we often forget here in the USA that we are not subject to the knife laws of other counties, which can be quite restrictive. That is really a shame that some of those laws are so strict. When it comes to Victorinox, they hold some clear advantages over Leatherman, of course the same holds true the other way around. I think both companies make quality products. I wish some of the other manufacturers would up their game to more closely compete with both of these companies. Thank you very much for taking the time to watch and for your well thought out comments.
I gave one of this for my father in law He has a small farm in the Brazilian countryside and uses this thinf evey single day in the last 7 years. He never had one single problem.
First of all, thank you for your videos brother, packed with huge amounts of information. Secondly, I believe that wire bender notch is quite useful in the 91mm models. Since those don’t have pliers, I use it to make hooks and loops, or just any bend. Doesn’t really work on anything bigger than let’s say Wire hanger thickness. Not sure it’s use on plier based MTs though.
I disagree about replaceable cutters. Multitools are always going to be a compromise, and we carry them to use when full size dedicated tools are not available. The fact that we are often using them under less than ideal circumstances means it is inevitable that we are going to abuse them sometimes. I like the fact that the whole tool won't be ruined if I end up having to cut something I shouldn't. The replaceable cutters mean that you can get yourself out of a bind without doing permanent damage to the tool. Having said that, I do wonder if the overall design is weaker, since some metal has to be removed in order to accommodate the replaceable cutters.
I have the original Spirit. Great tool, and great quality. That chisel is wonderful. I do not like the scissors. Seems like too much length wasted for the handle and too little used for cutting edges. They cut like SAK scissors, though. The wire-cutters I do not like. I prefer the Rebar's. And the awl is good enough, but others are better, Pioneer, Rebar, Surge. The price was much lower but it was doubled a while back. Still an amazing tool. Another excellent review, Ben. Thanks.
One of my best friends told me something similar. He said I have a way of making the complicated understandable. I’d never really thought about it before, but maybe he’s right. At any rate, I greatly appreciate the compliment.
@@txtoolcrib I'd say that's correct, but it's more. You reveal the obvious. You identify hidden issues which, when revealed, seem glaringly obvious; but are 'missed' by many people (myself included). I very much base my purchasing decisions on your assessment / analysis. I value it greatly; keep it up
Very thorough review. I’ve owned both the Leatherman Wave and the Victorinox Spirit X and greatly prefer the Spirit X for ease of use. The “negatives” you highlight have never caused me any problems. Just FYI, I prefer the original Wave to the so-called new & improved version.
Thank you sir. The good thing is, there is pretty much something for everyone on the market these days. Though I would like to see some more specialized models myself from all the manufacturers.
TX Tool Crib I cannot speak to what specialization the military may need in a “belt carry” tool, but my Spirit X fits my needs in those other categories. I would hate to see these go the way of knives where everybody needs/wants their specialized knife to cut stuff. Gadget heads need to remember it is the mechanic, not the wrench, that gets the job done.
Not that anyone is asking but I just got a Sprit X and I have a Leatherman Surge, ST300, ST200 a Wave, Rebar, Charge TTI-Which I hate the pliers, and a Wingman. I have watched toomany videos on the swisstools and spirit's that I decided to see what all the hype was about. Well, I am gonna say for now, I prefer the Leatherman Line but I can see the love and respect for the Swisstool Sprit X and others in their line. First off the sheath is fantastic on the Spitit. One of my complaints with Leatherman is their sheaths and country of origin along with the lack of ability to put a sleeve on their issues sheaths for their removable bit driver for the rebar and ST300. I feel Leatherman still holds the crown for Multi tools but that is only my opinion. Different multi tools for all us fools. Anyway the lock up and smoothness of the tools on the swisstool spirit is amazing and very precise. The smoothness of the pliers back and forth are very stiff but should smooth out. The chisel is cool as hell and TX tool crib is the best multi tool reviewer on the planet. His review is spot on. He keeps it real and pulls no punches. Also the handles collapse on mine quite easily when fully extended, if I were trying to get a wide grip they could collapse which I am surprised at from what I heard about the spirit x. Overall I think they need a pocket clip on the spirit x in this day and age. Well that is all for now I think I will stay with Leatherman and give this a try also. I will use the swisstool spirit in my rotation and give my opinion later. As I stare at it tonight I have to admit it’s a beautiful tool in and out of its case. Now I’m going to have to get the swisstool just to compare. Multi tool rabbit hole.
The Wire cutting blade tool looks great. On the V wire stripper I just put my thumb on the wire and pull with my original Super Tool. I like this Spirit X. Looking to perhaps upgrade.
I've been watching a lot of your videos lately, and you do some really great reviews. One thing, though, is how you often point out Leatherman's replaceable wire cutters as being 154CM. If you check their site, you'll notice they no longer call out the specific steel used in them, and if you check the Q&A on the page for the replacement cutters, you'll find a Leatherman rep referring to them being made from 440C. Not sure exactly when they made the change, but I think it's been a few years.
Outstanding quality, not sure about its usability. As much as I love Victorinox pocket knives, I can't make my mind on one of their multitools. This being said, I would like to see a video comparing a Leatherman Free P* and a Victorinox Spirit *. Keep up your excellent work!
I definitely intend to compare this tool to the Wave+, FREE P4, and Rebar. Those are the three multi tools that I think most closely compare to the functionality of the Spirit X.
@@txtoolcrib I believe that comparing Leatherman against each other is somewhat redundant. Comparing similar multitools of different manufacturers, showing the best (and the worst) of each would make this exercise more appropriate.
I was a carpenter for over 20 years. In 1998 l lost my original leatherman super tool in the crawl space of a house. I replaced it with a Victornox Swiss tool. The Swiss tool is amazing, I used it every day. Leatherman are very good but Victornox is better. Although, Leatherman has a better sheath. Now l own Leatherman Wave, Surge and Super tool 300 and Victornox Swiss tool. Victornox is still the best.
I’m surprised you did not make a point of talking about the fit and finish vs Leatherman. I’ve owned every Leatherman like you and never thought much about the Swisstool. Once I bought one though it was such a crazy feeling. Day and night the fit and finish of the swisstool was better. Every charge and wave I have owned has had one tool that had play. Sometimes it was the knife sometimes the file etc.. and even when you notify Leatherman, say your knife has a bunch of play brand new, they will swap you and then the new tool will have a rock solid knife but then the saw or file will have lots of play. I love Leatherman but the standards on what leaves the factory are less than victorinox. It only takes a having the two tools side by side to figure that out.
Great review. Love that you talked about and explained every tool. I have the spirit plus ratchet version. Not sure if your versions tools are in the same order or not. If I open my can opener between half and 3/4, with my wire cutter open on the other side, then close the handles together. You will find that sweet spot and it will strip wires with ease. Hope that makes sense. Lol. It is time consuming to open up two tools though.
28:28 Why would one need a separate folder if one carries the Spirit XC? What does a point on a knife do that the blade on the XC can't ? Genuinely curious. I have been able to use the blade on the XC to puncture things like plastic covers etc.
I'm looking into buying a multitool to carry on the road with me as a truck driver. my toss up is between this with the ratchet set, and the wave+ or surge with extension and bit set. Which one would you recommend? I'm in the PNW
My personal opinion is going to be that the Surge would be the best fit for you. Though it does not have all of the same functionality as the SwissTool Spirit X, it is a far more capable multi tool. Being from the PNW is a consideration. Higher humidity levels will certainly effect multi tools if they go long periods without use, they can develop surface rust. I still believe that you would be better off going with a larger multi tool. For that reason, I think you should also consider the Victorinox SwissTool or SwissTool X. Both of those tools are much more robust than the SwissTool Spirit models. Another consideration is that knife blades on the Surge and Wave+ models can be opened even with a gloved hand, the same can not be said for Victorinox models. In the end, I would say that the Leatherman Surge is far and away the best choice. I say that because, considering your profession, you are likely be a hard use application. I think the Surge will be the most beneficial to you. I would just take care to properly maintain the tool with a light coating of a good quality knife oil to minimize the chances of surface rust buildup.
@@txtoolcrib I opted to try the Swiss Tool X due to the rust resistance, the price point to get the extras I wanted, and the warranty. I may pick up the surge in the future.
The only reason I haven’t bought one of these is because I really don’t use multi tools like I used to when I used to get greasy. Now I tend to carry a Victorinox Cadet on/off the clock. On the clock I add to that a Knipex belt pouch with a 125mm pliers wrench, 150mm Cobra plier and a 180mm pliers wrench. This is the best review I’ve seen on this tool and maybe I can find an excuse to pick one up. I don’t think it’s a Wave beater but it’s a damn nice tool. The accessories are super cool too.
It’s probably the only multi tool out there in my book that will compete with the Wave/Charge platform in my opinion. The FREE series was supposed to be a multi tool that could challenge the Wave, it doesn’t from my perspective. I really like the Spirit X. I just like the Wave a bit more. Thanks for watching.
TX Tool Crib I just rewatched this. I think I’ve decided on this vs a Rebar. Might as well try something new and I love my Cadet. Can’t thank you enough for making well informed reviews of multi-tools!
@@txtoolcrib Just got my Spirit. Haven't had a chance to put it through the paces, that will take some time. Initial impressions are: WOW! I'm not sure if this is a tool or jewelry. Your description of smoothness cannot be underlined enough. Very impressed. Someone ought to send one of these to SOG.
@@JimLBon Vicotrinox SpiritX is far better than the Leatherman Wave.Wave has only 1 advantage the 1 hand opening blade,while on everything else,Spirit X wins. (I didn't mention the pocket clip,because both come as an extra part to buy,with the only difference,that the Leatherman is made by Leatherman)
Man I don't really need another multitool but I've seen these going for £80 online (that's about $110) which is the same price as a new Juice S2 I saw in a shop the other day and nearly bought, but I'm glad I didn't although I could have probably resold it for a profit. This can be made completely UK legal by dremeling the blade of the ''butter knife'' on it until it has no edge whatsoever, at which point it becomes a spatula. So I think I'm going to buy one next month. Carried with a good slipjoint like a Manly Wasp S90V or Spyderco UKPK this becomes a top-notch EDC combo.
I considered gettimg this for sometime. One of the biggest disadvantages for me is that they are riveted and thus not user-serviceable. Being able to maintain and clean a tool properly is one paramount for me. Otherwise, this would've been perfect as it comes with a handy set of tools.
Like any Victorinox you can just wash this in hot soapy water, in fact you could probably even put this through a dishwasher if you wanted. Unlike Leatherman you don't have to worry about rust.
@@imperfectango what were you doing with the tool? I've had my Surge for 3 years and never had anything fail in normal use. I did warrenty it, but only because it fell down an elevator shaft and broke the blade, but the tool was still able to open up and the rest of the tools could still be accessed
I wish Victorinox would take the Leatherman ratchet as a challenge, come up with their version AND incorporate it into a multitool. Now that would cool.
After using the spirt x for a faucet sprayer nozzle replacement I found out the spirit x does not open as wide for pliers as the wave which is disappointing. Still a great tool but it in no way opens wide enough in the pliers to do basic bolts like the wave or charge series. It seems to be made for smaller screws and I wish the pliers opened wider. That is my only criticism.
Hey TX TC thanks for another informative and entertaining vid on the SwissTool Spirit X. You mentioned that the Leatherman 154CM replaceable plier cutting jaw blades is a big plus. Consider the following scenario of what happens when the cutting blades are damaged. Do earlier versions without replaceable blades under warranty get replacement plier head repairs? In the case of 154CM replaceable jaw blades do LM consider it as wear and tear item and make them purchasable, not cheap either? That is place them outside warranty and at the owner's expense? If the answers are Yes, Yes & Yes then the marketing of these fantastic 154CM jaws is maybe not all that wonderful and perhaps even disingenuous. In my LM MT holdings there’s at least one that has significantly damaged 154CM blade inserts. My experience, from a durability standpoint, is that the inserted blades are not necessarily stronger and more resilient than integral plier head cutters. Oh BTW, I have indeed damaged cutters on a SwissTool Spirit. The result had the pliers binding which was a giant PITA and effectively rendered the STS lame until fixed. Ironically, I used the tip of a diamond file from a LM Charge TTi and some patience to remove the deformation that had immobilised the STS’s plier head. All peachy keen now.
Perhaps correctly HTed AISI D2 would work better and maybe better cutting blade profiles might add durability. In any event they should be better performing as my experience was insert blade damage occurred from not cutting any especially hard materials. That is of course unless and up front cynically, that LM are marketingly good with the 154CM cool blade steel reputation, that it's not the best performance engineering choice, that the RRP replacement price is high and that it's no long covered by warranty. Alternatively maybe the replacement blades are subcontracted and the quality could be better. I guess one thing is obvious. This LM customer is not happy about that aspect of the product.
First of all, thank you and thanks for watching. When it comes to the 154CM cutters, I personally think it was a good move on Leatherman’s part to incorporate them from a business perspective. I would imagine that a lot of the warranty issues on their multi tools were due to damage to their cutters. I have never personally damaged regular or replaceable cutters on any of my multi tools. I don’t know if they replace the cutters under warranty. Let’s just say that they do. Now let’s just use the Surge as a warranty example. It is far cheaper to replace the cutter which has a manufacturing price of under $5 I’m sure, as opposed to the entire tool. I would guess the cost of manufacturing on the Surge to be in $60 range, give or take. From a business perspective, that makes good financial sense. At the end of the day, they are a business and their goal is to turn a profit. All that being said, I think the cutters are definitely better than the older plier heads were.
You make a good point. I think the reason that they don’t use a D2 is because it is more susceptible to rusting than the 154CM is. I don’t have any first hand knowledge of that, just making an educated guess.
heywoodf heywoodf only a few months late! I was looking into some stainless steels for work, & actually found the closest analog to the cold working tool steels used in cutters would be a low-alloy, finely grained steel like AEB-L, or 12c27. D2 has a really high carbide content, making it far more brittle. 154cm isn't an ideal choice, but it makes sense given the domestic supply & LM's familiarity w/ it. I've only had 1 issue damaging the cutters, and it was 100% on me, (on a scissor lift all day, cut some a fair bit of unexpected of 8 awg w/ my Surge!) I fixed it w/ it's own file , but the replaceable inserts are nice. Victorinox makes beautiful, world class tools, but I'd only do that w/ a Surge.
My new SwissTool Spirit MX has a little bit of lateral plier play. Close to 1mm of play measured at the plier tips. Does anyone else have this problem? Looking at some SwissTool forums, it seems that a little bit of plier play is expected and normal.
I just got this Swiss tool spirit x. I was testing it out making some hardwood shavings like I usually do with my multi tools and the blade chipped. Do you think this is normal.I’m deciding whether to return it , have it repaired or exchanged. Victorinox said it was not made for carving but that they would repair it or exchange it. Thanks
I understand what you are saying about the blade being short but you can't have the bent arms for easy pliers application and a longer blade. The handle won't accommodate it unite you want a bend in your knife too.
I know the vid is over a year old, but has anyone tried the 1/4" Rebar bit adapter on the phillips driver? Could it maybe be made to work without hurting its ability to drive screws too severely?
Weak point is the pivot, after some use there is play in the handles. Using the philips driver is very irritating when the handles keep moving in your hand.
My personal favorite as an EDC is definitely the Surge. I use it regularly on construction sites, and it fits my needs the best. If I didn’t work construction, I would probably be looking more at the Charge+, Wave+, or SwissTool Spirit X as my edc. I do like a number of smaller multi tools as well.
Great review. How long have you had this tool? I notice your pliers are mounted the other way around to the older one, with the file/screwdriver being on the side that pivots.
I've never had a SwissTool or ST Spirit in hand but I question your claim that the tools are not one hand opening. If they are smooth and easy to deploy, as you said, it seems that you should be able to pinch the tool at the nail nick and pull up allowing the weight of the MT to deploy the tool. Maybe a slight wrist flick is needed. Have you tried that?
@@greekveteran2715 actually, I’ve been able to open all the tools on my spirit model one handed. While it may not be as simple as on a wave, it’s very possible to open a Swisstool with one hand
I've noticed that the spirit and ratchet set , seem to only available as a set with the one with the serrated butter blade . Not with the spirit x , with the regular blade . Is that the one you have?
I really don't mind the steal and I'm knife guy I have S30V. M390, S90exe and I have used Leatherman Skeletool cx and knife is good really good but all other stuff and biggest problem rusting and that is not normal rusting with time that is crazy rusting in 2 weaks players have spots of rust . I cudent believe it. And Victorinox Spirit MX is every thing I want and sheat is wery good also packet clip is ok so I cary Spirit on the belt or in the pocket . To mee best multi tool I ever have.
Have you seen felix immlers new video on the victorinox can openers? He was able to open a can in 10 seconds with that style. Might put a bug in your head about the eagle claw style can openers though haha!
I actually did happen across that video. Pretty impressive how fast he opened that can. I still like the eagle claw style from Leatherman better. The reason is that I use it as a fingernail cleaner on the job quite often, and it is a very good can opener in it’s own right.
@@txtoolcrib I've used both and don't have a preference either way, but I don't use them as finger picks because I find that gross lol. It's like using something to dig dirt out of your fingernails and then using the same tool to open your food container. I just use a blade or something else that doesn't involve food prep for that (even though it's probably a moot point since they're all on the same multitool anyway and germs are gonna spread no matter what lol) I almost always have my victorinox nail clip on me for that specific purpose anyway.
i broke a spirit x but it was my fault. i was working on a old house an i was lazy didn't feel like going to get my craw bar so i was using my pliers to try to pry a loose board up. i guess i pulled at an angle too hard and the damn head snapped.
You have to keep in mind where the tool is made. In the European Union it is illegal to carry a one handed operation knife or multi tool. You have to have a reason why you are carrying such a tool or knife, but I still love there quality and precision. One of my everyday EDC.
TX Tool Crib Yes they would be able since it’s a tool that would be viable for there profession. I live in the U.S. I love your reviews and very descriptive.
Pete Lopez I like the Swisstools a lot. I think Victorinox makes some high quality multi tools, I just wish they made more, and more diverse models. I certainly understand the knife laws that other countries are forced to contend with as well. Fortunately we don’t have to worry about that problem here in the US. For that reason, I personally greatly prefer the one hand accessible blades on Leatherman Surge, Wave, and Charge tools.
I thought I am the only one know this in the planet, no one ever been say one word about it, I was just felt not right when I first time trying the Scissor, wth until then I know ppl do make left handed scissor, can I, can I say it’s unbelievable!!! love my Spirt x still.
You have to remember swiss tools are a softer medal for that reason I wont buy one and if you look on ebay the swiss tools are going for almost 200 bucks! I'll stick with the charge tti or surge
@@txtoolcrib I just don't really like all the curves, the blades often seem unconventional, and pointless. Even if they work well, I mean that they have flourishes that don't effect performance
Fast forward to 2023 and you have the one handed blade option for the spirit X.
Great review thank you. At the end of the day when I pull out a tool from my wave, other tools come out and bunch up with it. With this Swiss tool, each tool comes out smoothly and by itself. The craftsmanship cannot be compared! Victorinox all the way. I still have my SAK from 30 years ago! 👍
Your review is way better for me than most other reviewers because
a) we are watching a person who actually uses these tools as part of their profession describing the pros and cons of each tool from his personal experience, and
b) you are articulating it so well. That's really cool.
As for the ratchet that you said you don't have here, I have it. And, to me, an amateur home user, it looks very well machined, and very well built. But I would have LOVED to hear your take on it, especially from using it - including bits about how much torque it can take etc.
Thank you very much, I really appreciate it. I need to get that ratchet, it would be interesting to see how well it holds up.
Very true user review...I have both the tools leatherman wave and Victorinox spirit x...both were my edc once for over 3 years ecah as a marine technician in India...I still prefer to carry t spirit over t leatherman wave for same reasons. Thank you 😊
I would love Victorinox to make a 'Mini' version of this. Like the Leatherman Squirt. It would become the ultimate EDC
Yeah I often thought that myself, but a mid-size like the Juice...but with both handles being 93mm alox Vics, but it would also be cool to have a Squirt size version with 58mm alox as handles. Very disappointed with my Squirt, especially the scissors which are terrible, and it's now been relegated to ''gentleman's carry'' for days when I'm very unlikely to need it as I prefer my Nextool Mini as a mini (5th pocket) carry if I might actually need to cut or screw anything that day. I saw a Juice S2 recently in a shop here in London which I almost bought as they're almost impossible to find but I'm glad I didn't, the guy dropped the price to £80 but I've just looked online and seen I can get a Spirit X for that so it's a no-brainer.
Thanks for this thorough review. I own and use A spirit X for more than 10 years and to my personnal use I prefer it over the Leatherman Wave. Sturdier, more stainless, better finitions, and the tools are really usable. The philips screwdriver for example is a real 3D one, with reach and torque, unless the tiny and usuable one on the Wave. Same with the flat screwdriver. I own a very old Supertool Leatherman (over 20 years old) and it is really unbreakable. I've seen so many broken pliers on Leatherman Multitool, so many broken blade. Leatherman has a serious problem with the quality check control with their products. You cannot apply so much torque on the bit holder or it will fail. Leatherman nowaday use a too brittle steel and if you force it it will break. Victorinox steel is softer, It will bend but it won't break. Thus blades have to be sharpen more often, and cutting pliers are no so great with very hard wire.
Good observations, all of which I can agree with.
On thing on that . Although it does have softer steel and you do have to sharpen more often . It sharpens easier , and takes little to no skill . A set of porcelain crock sticks is all you need . Or a strop , for that matter if you never let it get to dull . So there's that .
@@ronnietarnacke5153 That's true but tbh if you carry a Spirit X I doubt if the butterknife on it will be the only blade you carry. I reckon most people would carry it together with a dedicated folder of choice.
Good review as usual, thank you.
The main gripe I have with this multitool is the nail-shredding nail nicks used to open the tools. Oh, I know some of you have nails like claw hammers, and can't understand why I find this a problem. But this is about my nails, not yours!
If you are trying to open the tools after being out in the rain, or after watersports or swimming when your nails are very soft, you will tear your nails very easily.
All the tools are locking, and don't use slip joint locking, so why does Victorinox use bear trap springs just to keep the tools closed?
In Germany and many other European countries you aren't allowed to carry one handed opening knives wich have a locking mechanism. So nearly all Leatherman tools are forbidden to carry except the Rebar, Super Tool 300 or Crunch. That beeing said you may realize why Victorinox didn't implement one handed features to their multitools.
That’s why Leatherman came out with the curl and bond this year. Seemed like a downgrade from rebar and wave but for countries like this it works
Fully understandable, but damages for the NA and other countries’ market
@@appleztooranges It is a shame the leatherman's offered are poor quality. If they were more premium more would purchase them. All leatherman has to do is make the knife Not Locking and below 3inchs in the uk.
@@TheCoomer it’s not leatherman or the U.S’s problem you have a totalitarian government that lets criminals have knives and not the law abiding citizens. Leatherman isn’t going to downgrade our products just to go along with your strict laws. Get a grip.
@@Mikey-ym6ok Lol I agree that our knife laws are ridiculous in the UK and at the end of the day no self-respecting roadman is going to juke anyone with a Leatherman anyway lol the weapon of choice for those scumbags is a cheap kitchen knife from a Poundshop or stolen from their mum's kitchen draw. However it's business sense to make products which can be sold in overseas markets. In any case I carry a Rebar which has a locking blade but in a pouch with bike repair tools so in the very unlikely event I am searched I think I could argue that it constitutes ''valid reason''. Hell I even ride around central London with 6in lethal sharp fixed blades in my bag, completely legally, as I'm a part time restaurant chef and don't want anyone else using them while I'm not at work.
Got it today. I’m in love. Could almost be my favorite multitool! Almost. I love the meat cleaver knife on it, love the scissors, and love the package opener. I say it could be but it’s missing a pocket clip like the Leatherman wave and surge. It’s also missing one handed opening knives. I still think wave/surge is best overall multitool edc that I won’t leave house without. This tool I’ll put in my house for use or in my truck
I use the hook on my Swisschamp to help me pull bank line tighter, lift heavy stuff where my only handle is wire/twine, or to lift my steel bottle out of the fire by the wire bale. Super handy tool for sure
It can also be used to tighten shoe laces . Especially on roller or ice skates . Unless the laces are real thick .
As always , EXCELLENT REVIEW!
I see a lot of people trying to compare Victorinox VS Leatherman. Both brands are serious and professional.
We need to remember the environment and regulations in USA are not the same in Europe.
Ex.
Environmental talking just most talking about wood and trees for hinking in Europe most of the forest had soft/medium hardness wood. Is why brand like Gransfors make Axe with low hardness AND Victorinox do not need a very hard steel but they have a lot of humidity so the need for anticorrosion is a 'must' .
About regulations as we know, one hand open knife is illegal in most of European Countries.
Here in USA he had Hard wood or Very hard wood that is why the pattern of the saw is more aggressive.....
Regulations allow one open hand knife and most common and practical steel in USA range from 420-440 A,B and C.
Leatherman will not add a lower steel hardness since is cheaper to replace tools than knifes. The warranty is 25 straight and is a supreme no questions ask warranty. Making blades apply more time and labor. Instead of tools.
Victorinox give a lifetime warranty where honestly ...... I really believe a radio of 10:1 vs Leatherman in claims. Based kn forums and blogs.
The Spirit and Swisstool are lighter and slimmers. Compact and with 1 tool engaged option which I find very comfortable. The pliers are for general use. . . Spirit pliers don't open like the Wave BUT what can you do with a full open Wave? Is just ridiculous uncomfortable tight a bolt with a full open mouth, so Spirit is more realistic of what the size reach?
This are a few thoughts only. Nothing nto.do with the magnificent review from TX Crib Tool.
Ben, please do more reviews. You have a lot of fanbase because of the professional way you make this stuff.
Respectfully,
MB
That was very well stated. I think we often forget here in the USA that we are not subject to the knife laws of other counties, which can be quite restrictive. That is really a shame that some of those laws are so strict. When it comes to Victorinox, they hold some clear advantages over Leatherman, of course the same holds true the other way around. I think both companies make quality products. I wish some of the other manufacturers would up their game to more closely compete with both of these companies. Thank you very much for taking the time to watch and for your well thought out comments.
I gave one of this for my father in law He has a small farm in the Brazilian countryside and uses this thinf evey single day in the last 7 years. He never had one single problem.
First of all, thank you for your videos brother, packed with huge amounts of information. Secondly, I believe that wire bender notch is quite useful in the 91mm models. Since those don’t have pliers, I use it to make hooks and loops, or just any bend. Doesn’t really work on anything bigger than let’s say Wire hanger thickness. Not sure it’s use on plier based MTs though.
I really appreciate that. Thank you for taking the time to watch.
Thank you for the wonderful content and a special thanks for not having an annoying intro 👍🏻
I disagree about replaceable cutters. Multitools are always going to be a compromise, and we carry them to use when full size dedicated tools are not available.
The fact that we are often using them under less than ideal circumstances means it is inevitable that we are going to abuse them sometimes.
I like the fact that the whole tool won't be ruined if I end up having to cut something I shouldn't.
The replaceable cutters mean that you can get yourself out of a bind without doing permanent damage to the tool.
Having said that, I do wonder if the overall design is weaker, since some metal has to be removed in order to accommodate the replaceable cutters.
I have the original Spirit. Great tool, and great quality. That chisel is wonderful.
I do not like the scissors. Seems like too much length wasted for the handle and too little used for cutting edges. They cut like SAK scissors, though.
The wire-cutters I do not like. I prefer the Rebar's.
And the awl is good enough, but others are better, Pioneer, Rebar, Surge.
The price was much lower but it was doubled a while back. Still an amazing tool.
Another excellent review, Ben. Thanks.
Thank you. I happen to agree with everything you just stated.
Once again; an excellent review ..... You're a teacher by nature; exceptional communicator
One of my best friends told me something similar. He said I have a way of making the complicated understandable. I’d never really thought about it before, but maybe he’s right. At any rate, I greatly appreciate the compliment.
@@txtoolcrib I'd say that's correct, but it's more. You reveal the obvious. You identify hidden issues which, when revealed, seem glaringly obvious; but are 'missed' by many people (myself included). I very much base my purchasing decisions on your assessment / analysis. I value it greatly; keep it up
Very thorough review. I’ve owned both the Leatherman Wave and the Victorinox Spirit X and greatly prefer the Spirit X for ease of use. The “negatives” you highlight have never caused me any problems. Just FYI, I prefer the original Wave to the so-called new & improved version.
Thank you sir. The good thing is, there is pretty much something for everyone on the market these days. Though I would like to see some more specialized models myself from all the manufacturers.
TX Tool Crib Interesting. What do you mean by “specialized” models?
Those geared towards Urban, Bushcraft, Electrical, and Maintenance. Maybe some other specialized tools other than military as well.
TX Tool Crib I cannot speak to what specialization the military may need in a “belt carry” tool, but my Spirit X fits my needs in those other categories.
I would hate to see these go the way of knives where everybody needs/wants their specialized knife to cut stuff.
Gadget heads need to remember it is the mechanic, not the wrench, that gets the job done.
That is true.
Not that anyone is asking but I just got a Sprit X and I have a Leatherman Surge, ST300, ST200 a Wave, Rebar, Charge TTI-Which I hate the pliers, and a Wingman. I have watched toomany videos on the swisstools and spirit's that I decided to see what all the hype was about. Well, I am gonna say for now, I prefer the Leatherman Line but I can see the love and respect for the Swisstool Sprit X and others in their line. First off the sheath is fantastic on the Spitit.
One of my complaints with Leatherman is their sheaths and country of origin along with the lack of ability to put a sleeve on their issues sheaths for their removable bit driver for the rebar and ST300. I feel Leatherman still holds the crown for Multi tools but that is only my opinion. Different multi tools for all us fools. Anyway the lock up and smoothness of the tools on the swisstool spirit is amazing and very precise. The smoothness of the pliers back and forth are very stiff but should smooth out. The chisel is cool as hell and TX tool crib is the best multi tool reviewer on the planet. His review is spot on. He keeps it real and pulls no punches. Also the handles collapse on mine quite easily when fully extended, if I were trying to get a wide grip they could collapse which I am surprised at from what I heard about the spirit x.
Overall I think they need a pocket clip on the spirit x in this day and age. Well that is all for now I think I will stay with Leatherman and give this a try also. I will use the swisstool spirit in my rotation and give my opinion later.
As I stare at it tonight I have to admit it’s a beautiful tool in and out of its case. Now I’m going to have to get the swisstool just to compare. Multi tool rabbit hole.
I think we are of the same mindset, I agree with all of your points.
The Wire cutting blade tool looks great. On the V wire stripper I just put my thumb on the wire and pull with my original Super Tool. I like this Spirit X. Looking to perhaps upgrade.
It is in my top 5 for plier based multi tools for sure.
What do you do when it goes dull?
I've been watching a lot of your videos lately, and you do some really great reviews. One thing, though, is how you often point out Leatherman's replaceable wire cutters as being 154CM. If you check their site, you'll notice they no longer call out the specific steel used in them, and if you check the Q&A on the page for the replacement cutters, you'll find a Leatherman rep referring to them being made from 440C. Not sure exactly when they made the change, but I think it's been a few years.
Noted!
I like the metal saw, I use it for slot cutting stripped out screws/ bolt heads all the time. too many tools miss that feature
The only problem I have with that tools is that if it used often, it will wear out fairly quickly. It works really well though.
After 3 years of heavy use on the saw, how is the teeth of it holding up?
Outstanding quality, not sure about its usability. As much as I love Victorinox pocket knives, I can't make my mind on one of their multitools.
This being said, I would like to see a video comparing a Leatherman Free P* and a Victorinox Spirit *. Keep up your excellent work!
I definitely intend to compare this tool to the Wave+, FREE P4, and Rebar. Those are the three multi tools that I think most closely compare to the functionality of the Spirit X.
@@txtoolcrib I believe that comparing Leatherman against each other is somewhat redundant. Comparing similar multitools of different manufacturers, showing the best (and the worst) of each would make this exercise more appropriate.
I was a carpenter for over 20 years.
In 1998 l lost my original leatherman super tool in the crawl space of a house. I replaced it with a Victornox Swiss tool. The Swiss tool is amazing,
I used it every day. Leatherman are very good but Victornox is better.
Although, Leatherman has a better sheath. Now l own Leatherman Wave,
Surge and Super tool 300 and Victornox Swiss tool. Victornox is still the best.
David Krueger the Swiss certainly know how to make good tools.
I’m surprised you did not make a point of talking about the fit and finish vs Leatherman. I’ve owned every Leatherman like you and never thought much about the Swisstool. Once I bought one though it was such a crazy feeling. Day and night the fit and finish of the swisstool was better. Every charge and wave I have owned has had one tool that had play. Sometimes it was the knife sometimes the file etc.. and even when you notify Leatherman, say your knife has a bunch of play brand new, they will swap you and then the new tool will have a rock solid knife but then the saw or file will have lots of play. I love Leatherman but the standards on what leaves the factory are less than victorinox. It only takes a having the two tools side by side to figure that out.
The best multitool ever made.
My off duty Multitool , my default work multi is the Surge ( with Whia double ended bits ) .
Good choices.
I love your channel!! Ive watched several videos. This review is especially good for me!!
Great review. Love that you talked about and explained every tool. I have the spirit plus ratchet version. Not sure if your versions tools are in the same order or not. If I open my can opener between half and 3/4, with my wire cutter open on the other side, then close the handles together. You will find that sweet spot and it will strip wires with ease. Hope that makes sense. Lol. It is time consuming to open up two tools though.
I'll try to see if that method will work better. Thanks.
The spirit of PST lives in this tool.
Thank you for the review. Very thorough and reality-oriented.
Thank you, I appreciate it.
28:28 Why would one need a separate folder if one carries the Spirit XC? What does a point on a knife do that the blade on the XC can't ? Genuinely curious. I have been able to use the blade on the XC to puncture things like plastic covers etc.
I'm sure you know this by now but where the corkscrew shines is in undoing tight knots and tangles.
I've used that a few times and it's awesome.
Absolutely correct.
I'm looking into buying a multitool to carry on the road with me as a truck driver. my toss up is between this with the ratchet set, and the wave+ or surge with extension and bit set. Which one would you recommend? I'm in the PNW
My personal opinion is going to be that the Surge would be the best fit for you. Though it does not have all of the same functionality as the SwissTool Spirit X, it is a far more capable multi tool. Being from the PNW is a consideration. Higher humidity levels will certainly effect multi tools if they go long periods without use, they can develop surface rust. I still believe that you would be better off going with a larger multi tool. For that reason, I think you should also consider the Victorinox SwissTool or SwissTool X. Both of those tools are much more robust than the SwissTool Spirit models. Another consideration is that knife blades on the Surge and Wave+ models can be opened even with a gloved hand, the same can not be said for Victorinox models. In the end, I would say that the Leatherman Surge is far and away the best choice. I say that because, considering your profession, you are likely be a hard use application. I think the Surge will be the most beneficial to you. I would just take care to properly maintain the tool with a light coating of a good quality knife oil to minimize the chances of surface rust buildup.
@@txtoolcrib I opted to try the Swiss Tool X due to the rust resistance, the price point to get the extras I wanted, and the warranty. I may pick up the surge in the future.
The only reason I haven’t bought one of these is because I really don’t use multi tools like I used to when I used to get greasy. Now I tend to carry a Victorinox Cadet on/off the clock. On the clock I add to that a Knipex belt pouch with a 125mm pliers wrench, 150mm Cobra plier and a 180mm pliers wrench.
This is the best review I’ve seen on this tool and maybe I can find an excuse to pick one up. I don’t think it’s a Wave beater but it’s a damn nice tool. The accessories are super cool too.
It’s probably the only multi tool out there in my book that will compete with the Wave/Charge platform in my opinion. The FREE series was supposed to be a multi tool that could challenge the Wave, it doesn’t from my perspective. I really like the Spirit X. I just like the Wave a bit more. Thanks for watching.
TX Tool Crib I just rewatched this. I think I’ve decided on this vs a Rebar. Might as well try something new and I love my Cadet. Can’t thank you enough for making well informed reviews of multi-tools!
@@txtoolcrib Just got my Spirit. Haven't had a chance to put it through the paces, that will take some time. Initial impressions are: WOW! I'm not sure if this is a tool or jewelry. Your description of smoothness cannot be underlined enough. Very impressed. Someone ought to send one of these to SOG.
Jim Bonney they are nice.
@@JimLBon Vicotrinox SpiritX is far better than the Leatherman Wave.Wave has only 1 advantage the 1 hand opening blade,while on everything else,Spirit X wins. (I didn't mention the pocket clip,because both come as an extra part to buy,with the only difference,that the Leatherman is made by Leatherman)
Man I don't really need another multitool but I've seen these going for £80 online (that's about $110) which is the same price as a new Juice S2 I saw in a shop the other day and nearly bought, but I'm glad I didn't although I could have probably resold it for a profit. This can be made completely UK legal by dremeling the blade of the ''butter knife'' on it until it has no edge whatsoever, at which point it becomes a spatula. So I think I'm going to buy one next month. Carried with a good slipjoint like a Manly Wasp S90V or Spyderco UKPK this becomes a top-notch EDC combo.
I considered gettimg this for sometime. One of the biggest disadvantages for me is that they are riveted and thus not user-serviceable. Being able to maintain and clean a tool properly is one paramount for me. Otherwise, this would've been perfect as it comes with a handy set of tools.
Like any Victorinox you can just wash this in hot soapy water, in fact you could probably even put this through a dishwasher if you wanted. Unlike Leatherman you don't have to worry about rust.
I think it’s the best in the market
maybe that’s why you have two😄
Lol. It is definitely up there for me too. Not quite at the very top of my list though.
@@txtoolcrib what's the top
Leatherman Surge
I'm trying to find the larger xc pouch. Any ideas?
My default EDC Multitool ! The Surge gets the nod for work . It’s pretty rare to see broken Vic. Plierheads .
And these are nice too!
Thank you so much for the review!!
You’re quite welcome.
I've used a Swisstool for 19 years! Never sent in for warrenty! Victorinox kicks leatherman's ass!!
My one and only Leatherman lasted 2hrs and 4 screws.
@@imperfectango what were you doing with the tool? I've had my Surge for 3 years and never had anything fail in normal use. I did warrenty it, but only because it fell down an elevator shaft and broke the blade, but the tool was still able to open up and the rest of the tools could still be accessed
That chisel chisel :) sold me! Thank you!
M8 I love you videos keep up the fantastic work. Thanks ❤
Very helpful. Thank you.
Which blade do you find more useful, the classic pen blade here or the "butter knife" on the regular Spirit?
The pen blade.
I think you need the eye to make it an Awl as well. Which, as I'm sure you know better then me, allows stitching with leather.
I wish Victorinox would take the Leatherman ratchet as a challenge, come up with their version AND incorporate it into a multitool. Now that would cool.
Does anyone know what steel Victorinox uses for their pliers? I really wish they used harder, more modern steels.
If you close the pliers as hard as you can with your grip, say 5 times, it will loose up and get exactly as your other spirit.
Thanks for that, I'll give it a try.
I got a Winchester which is low budget it works good for my use.
After using the spirt x for a faucet sprayer nozzle replacement I found out the spirit x does not open as wide for pliers as the wave which is disappointing. Still a great tool but it in no way opens wide enough in the pliers to do basic bolts like the wave or charge series. It seems to be made for smaller screws and I wish the pliers opened wider. That is my only criticism.
Hey TX TC thanks for another informative and entertaining vid on the SwissTool Spirit X.
You mentioned that the Leatherman 154CM replaceable plier cutting jaw blades is a big plus. Consider the following scenario of what happens when the cutting blades are damaged.
Do earlier versions without replaceable blades under warranty get replacement plier head repairs? In the case of 154CM replaceable jaw blades do LM consider it as wear and tear item and make them purchasable, not cheap either? That is place them outside warranty and at the owner's expense? If the answers are Yes, Yes & Yes then the marketing of these fantastic 154CM jaws is maybe not all that wonderful and perhaps even disingenuous. In my LM MT holdings there’s at least one that has significantly damaged 154CM blade inserts. My experience, from a durability standpoint, is that the inserted blades are not necessarily stronger and more resilient than integral plier head cutters.
Oh BTW, I have indeed damaged cutters on a SwissTool Spirit. The result had the pliers binding which was a giant PITA and effectively rendered the STS lame until fixed.
Ironically, I used the tip of a diamond file from a LM Charge TTi and some patience to remove the deformation that had immobilised the STS’s plier head.
All peachy keen now.
Perhaps correctly HTed AISI D2 would work better and maybe better cutting blade profiles might add durability. In any event they should be better performing as my experience was insert blade damage occurred from not cutting any especially hard materials. That is of course unless and up front cynically, that LM are marketingly good with the 154CM cool blade steel reputation, that it's not the best performance engineering choice, that the RRP replacement price is high and that it's no long covered by warranty. Alternatively maybe the replacement blades are subcontracted and the quality could be better.
I guess one thing is obvious. This LM customer is not happy about that aspect of the product.
First of all, thank you and thanks for watching. When it comes to the 154CM cutters, I personally think it was a good move on Leatherman’s part to incorporate them from a business perspective. I would imagine that a lot of the warranty issues on their multi tools were due to damage to their cutters. I have never personally damaged regular or replaceable cutters on any of my multi tools. I don’t know if they replace the cutters under warranty. Let’s just say that they do. Now let’s just use the Surge as a warranty example. It is far cheaper to replace the cutter which has a manufacturing price of under $5 I’m sure, as opposed to the entire tool. I would guess the cost of manufacturing on the Surge to be in $60 range, give or take. From a business perspective, that makes good financial sense. At the end of the day, they are a business and their goal is to turn a profit. All that being said, I think the cutters are definitely better than the older plier heads were.
You make a good point. I think the reason that they don’t use a D2 is because it is more susceptible to rusting than the 154CM is. I don’t have any first hand knowledge of that, just making an educated guess.
heywoodf heywoodf only a few months late! I was looking into some stainless steels for work, & actually found the closest analog to the cold working tool steels used in cutters would be a low-alloy, finely grained steel like AEB-L, or 12c27. D2 has a really high carbide content, making it far more brittle. 154cm isn't an ideal choice, but it makes sense given the domestic supply & LM's familiarity w/ it.
I've only had 1 issue damaging the cutters, and it was 100% on me, (on a scissor lift all day, cut some a fair bit of unexpected of 8 awg w/ my Surge!) I fixed it w/ it's own file , but the replaceable inserts are nice.
Victorinox makes beautiful, world class tools, but I'd only do that w/ a Surge.
I'm gonna have to have this
does the wrech attach to the phillips?
Wow really awesome tool!!!
I think so too. Really well made.
@@txtoolcrib yeah😊
My new SwissTool Spirit MX has a little bit of lateral plier play. Close to 1mm of play measured at the plier tips. Does anyone else have this problem? Looking at some SwissTool forums, it seems that a little bit of plier play is expected and normal.
Where did you get the sheath and tool kit? I got the sheath with the spirit x and want to upgrade eventually.
I got them with the Swisstool Spirit CS, but I believe you can buy the seperately.
I just got this Swiss tool spirit x. I was testing it out making some hardwood shavings like I usually do with my multi tools and the blade chipped. Do you think this is normal.I’m deciding whether to return it , have it repaired or exchanged. Victorinox said it was not made for carving but that they would repair it or exchange it. Thanks
That’s definitely not normal, I would send it in for warranty.
I own the tool. 31 minutes of nitpicking. The crate opener tool which u call a wire stripper is a great multi function tool.
I understand what you are saying about the blade being short but you can't have the bent arms for easy pliers application and a longer blade. The handle won't accommodate it unite you want a bend in your knife too.
That is why I prefer the larger framed tools.
I know the vid is over a year old, but has anyone tried the 1/4" Rebar bit adapter on the phillips driver? Could it maybe be made to work without hurting its ability to drive screws too severely?
Weak point is the pivot, after some use there is play in the handles. Using the philips driver is very irritating when the handles keep moving in your hand.
Hi, what is your favourite Multitool!? My guess would be Surge but still just wanted to confirm.
My personal favorite as an EDC is definitely the Surge. I use it regularly on construction sites, and it fits my needs the best. If I didn’t work construction, I would probably be looking more at the Charge+, Wave+, or SwissTool Spirit X as my edc. I do like a number of smaller multi tools as well.
TX Tool Crib what’s the best smaller keychain multi tool that’s durable with pliers ?
Great review. How long have you had this tool? I notice your pliers are mounted the other way around to the older one, with the file/screwdriver being on the side that pivots.
Thank you. I have had this one for about 2 1/2 years I believe.
@@txtoolcrib Thanks for your reply. Did you ever notice how your plier heads were mounted the other way around?
Clint de Santos I have seen that earlier version are indeed reverse pivoted.
I've never had a SwissTool or ST Spirit in hand but I question your claim that the tools are not one hand opening. If they are smooth and easy to deploy, as you said, it seems that you should be able to pinch the tool at the nail nick and pull up allowing the weight of the MT to deploy the tool. Maybe a slight wrist flick is needed. Have you tried that?
It doesn't work, the tools are hold tight in the multitool when in closed position.
@@greekveteran2715 actually, I’ve been able to open all the tools on my spirit model one handed. While it may not be as simple as on a wave, it’s very possible to open a Swisstool with one hand
I have the Victorinox Swiss Army SwissTool Spirit Plus Ratchet because I could and it is the deluxe model.
Good combination.
I've noticed that the spirit and ratchet set , seem to only available as a set with the one with the serrated butter blade . Not with the spirit x , with the regular blade . Is that the one you have?
I assume no wire crimper?
Not on this one I'm afraid.
I just push the screwdrier blade up to trap wire for stripping on the superior wire stripper.
Nice review
Thank you.
I really don't mind the steal and I'm knife guy I have S30V. M390, S90exe and I have used Leatherman Skeletool cx and knife is good really good but all other stuff and biggest problem rusting and that is not normal rusting with time that is crazy rusting in 2 weaks players have spots of rust . I cudent believe it.
And Victorinox Spirit MX is every thing I want and sheat is wery good also packet clip is ok so I cary Spirit on the belt or in the pocket . To mee best multi tool I ever have.
Have you seen felix immlers new video on the victorinox can openers? He was able to open a can in 10 seconds with that style. Might put a bug in your head about the eagle claw style can openers though haha!
I actually did happen across that video. Pretty impressive how fast he opened that can. I still like the eagle claw style from Leatherman better. The reason is that I use it as a fingernail cleaner on the job quite often, and it is a very good can opener in it’s own right.
@@txtoolcrib I've used both and don't have a preference either way, but I don't use them as finger picks because I find that gross lol. It's like using something to dig dirt out of your fingernails and then using the same tool to open your food container. I just use a blade or something else that doesn't involve food prep for that (even though it's probably a moot point since they're all on the same multitool anyway and germs are gonna spread no matter what lol)
I almost always have my victorinox nail clip on me for that specific purpose anyway.
Does anyone know the dimensions of this tool? How wide is it when closed?
Not sure (gave it as a gift), but it was impressively compact. I wish the needle nose was finer, but that’s my only gripe.
This would not exist without Leatherman.
i broke a spirit x but it was my fault. i was working on a old house an i was lazy didn't feel like going to get my craw bar so i was using my pliers to try to pry a loose board up. i guess i pulled at an angle too hard and the damn head snapped.
Thank goodness for warranties. Lol.
I wish that Philips was square, so I could use an adaptor with different screw heads
That would be ideal.
The new Spirit X's have a one handed opening large chromium blade.
Nothing to complain about, but use sorry.
👍👍👍👍👍
Leatherman can't hold a candle to victorinox!
22:39 carefully, the cover is painted!
Is it really? I didn’t know that.
@@txtoolcrib my white pants hurt in one day
3:49 to get to the meat
You have to keep in mind where the tool is made. In the European Union it is illegal to carry a one handed operation knife or multi tool. You have to have a reason why you are carrying such a tool or knife, but I still love there quality and precision. One of my everyday EDC.
Pete Lopez is your profession a legitimate reason? What I mean is, would the average construction worker be permitted to carry a multi tool?
TX Tool Crib Yes they would be able since it’s a tool that would be viable for there profession. I live in the U.S. I love your reviews and very descriptive.
Pete Lopez I like the Swisstools a lot. I think Victorinox makes some high quality multi tools, I just wish they made more, and more diverse models. I certainly understand the knife laws that other countries are forced to contend with as well. Fortunately we don’t have to worry about that problem here in the US. For that reason, I personally greatly prefer the one hand accessible blades on Leatherman Surge, Wave, and Charge tools.
And you forgot to mention: the scissor is a left hand type --> why Victorinox did you do the design in this way ????
I thought I am the only one know this in the planet, no one ever been say one word about it, I was just felt not right when I first time trying the Scissor, wth until then I know ppl do make left handed scissor, can I, can I say it’s unbelievable!!! love my Spirt x still.
The Phillips head screwdriver is way to soft and damages immediately with first use!
Don’t feel bad about thinking Leatherman makes better saws. Even Felix Immler (the SAK guy) agrees.
Oil
They have plenty of lubrication.
Leathermans barely better
You have to remember swiss tools are a softer medal for that reason I wont buy one and if you look on ebay the swiss tools are going for almost 200 bucks! I'll stick with the charge tti or surge
Victorinox tools are ugly!
Why do think that? I feel like they are more streamlined than Leatherman tools personally.
@@txtoolcrib I just don't really like all the curves, the blades often seem unconventional, and pointless. Even if they work well, I mean that they have flourishes that don't effect performance
I can understand that. I personally like the more rugged look of the surge myself.