honestly, this is the first "pro reviews cheap flutes" video that doesn't just say "yeah just go and buy a $1000 flute instead" as if anyone looking at an under $100 flute even HAS the money to buy a yamaha It really made it seem like the only way you can even get your feet wet on the flute is if you have a grand just lying around for an instrument you're not even sure you like playing, and it's very discouraging. I really appreciate you actually talking about these flutes as serious options. ...on a completely different note, the Mendini sounded much better lol
Thanks so much! I totally get that many people don't have a lot of money to spend on flutes. I have definitely been there before. However, we can always try to make the best of what we have. I tried to take this philosophy when working on this series. If under $100 is the only option, you can still play the flute and get a decent sound.
He had more upper register issues with the Glory so pick the Mendini. I bought a Mendini Sax and it wasn't very good. A better test would be for an intermediate player to try it. Having a pro play a cheap flute is not a realistic test.
Yes! Thanks so much for the video. Sometimes I kinda tired of hearing that don't buy cheap flute if someone is serious about learning it. So, poor people don't deserve to play flute?! Yet, to me, apart form the tone quality, maybe the response of the flute also matters and sometimes even more to beginners.
At the same time, it’s nice to see that these instruments *can* make an acceptable sound. I’ve gone for a second hand TJ 10XE at the ~$200 price point; partly because I suspect I could get the $200 back for it if playing isn’t for me. But it’s really nice to see that even a sub-$100 flute can sound really quite beautiful in the hands of a pro.
I’m learning to play the Flute and I wanted a Flute that was good but cheap since I don’t have the money right now to buy a thousand dollar flute. So watching the three videos really helped me. I was considering buying the Glory flute but changed my mind when I heard the Mendini Flute. I’m trying to learn the flute so I could join my high school marching band so I wanted to get the one with a better tone. And the Mendini also had an open hole version.
Am going to be the odd one out here and say that while the Mendini sounded more refined and polished, I preferred the sound of the Glory. It was cooler-toned to me, a little more haunting. But you played both beautifully, thank you for this very helpful video!
This makes my day! My hope for this video is that people would be able to come to their own conclusions from the side-by-side play test. It's great that you don't agree with the other commenters because tone quality (and music in general) are so subjective and just come down to personal preference in the end. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for making this video! We’re putting together a teacher band at our elementary school that includes teachers that used to play instruments and are interested in playing again to perform for our students. I loved that I was able to see and hear a real review of these instruments!
Thank you! I am a band teacher and am learning the basics of every instrument I can get my hands on, so I wasn't looking for something amazing necessarily so seeing that these instruments are capable of making pretty good characteristic tone is exactly what I needed to see. Thank you so much Lance!
First I preferred the Mandini. After a while I thought the Glory was better in the low register. After listening a little more I will prefer the Mandini. It is amazing that it is possible to produce such flutes for the low price.
Mendini Hands down. The tone s richer. 4 years in HS band 2nd chair. The band always tuned to my C. Now at 55 I want to play again for my "smokers" lines, my lung capacity, my mental well-being and a self improvement challenge. This time I hope to make 1st chair!
Thank you so much for this review! When I was in jr. high, I was in marching band and played the clarinet. In the last few weeks, I keep getting the feeling that I am to pick up the flute and learn it proficiently. I have watched both your Mendini and Glory reviews separately and even had my husband listen to you play both. I am looking to make my flute purchase by the end of this week (12/10/2023) and honestly, both have a great, distinct tone. Glory is definitely more stable but warmer while Medini has a really amazing sound that you would hear a flutist playing in an orchestra. Both also seem to come with their own set of pros and cons.
I agree with the comment that Gabe C. had a few months back. I really appreciate the efforts you've gone to in order to actually review the flutes for what they are - which is bargain basement beginner flutes. Too many of the self-styled experts/teachers/players just point their finger at the instrument they're *cough* reviewing, and dump all over it. You obviously put a lot of thought into the true use points of these flutes, and tailored the review for that. Will they replace a hand crafted Muramatsu "James Galway" special? No. But both of the flutes you reviewed will certainly get someone through their first year of Junior High (Middle School) band, or even just some re-education. Really, they sound no worse than my Gemeinhardt. How instruments have changed in 40 years. Over the years, I've lost track of how many little bottles of oil I used on my instruments, how many screws were adjusted back and forth (or replaced), the head joint crown, and so forth - I definitely put my vote towards a video on "Basic things to look at on your flute". As well as what you _shouldn't_ do yourself, such as glue the screw heads in place. Or expect that any glue on a pad will be anything more than a 'get me through the night' fix.
Definitely Mendini for me! I was shocked at the sound of that one altogether. The Glory one to me sounds a bit airy even after the adjustments you made. I had to help one of my niece's friends with her flute 'not working'. I would warn to check for anything sticking that shouldn't be as well as springs that are out of place or not even there. My niece's friend's flute all had just a couple loose screws and one screw that was tightened a bit too much on the D#/Eb right pinky key where it was barely moving freely. All in all, Mendini by Cecilio has improved since I first heard of the brand. Would I use it if I was a professional flutist? NO! The brand now has become a good brand as an 'intro to flute' type of brand.
I haven't played a flute in YEARS and have been wanting to pick it up again, but don't want to invest heavily just yet. Both sound wonderful, and the Glory had the better tone in the lower range, but I really liked the warmth of the Mendini in the upper range. Mid range both were comparable. Thank you. I'll probably purchase the Mendini and start from the almost beginning again!
I got the Mendini for free on Amazon a while back. I thought it was a “throwaway “ unto I saw your review so I took it to a flute repair shop to check things out as much as possible (loose screws, etc) and he was surprised at the sound as well. I think he thought it would have a terrible sound given the price.
Wow! You got it for free?! Amazing! I'm glad that you took the time and effort to get it looked at. Every flute deserves a little TLC sometime and hopefully it can serve some (small) purpose for you now. ❤️
Lance Suzuki yes I did ! For applying for their credit card. The amount off that I received covered the entire price of the Mendini flute. Since I have the Cecilio viola that has served me well I gave the flute a try. I agree with others that the Mendini has the warmer tone. Also... you could play a carrot and make it sound beautiful!😂
I ended up buying a Glory open holed B-foot with all the things. I've had it over a year and I love it. Will I upgrade to a more expensive flute? Probably at some point, definitely if I keep playing. But as it is now, this one suits me well. I keep it out on a stand and that reminds me to practice, it's not hugely expensive so if I have to replace it I can. I pick it up multiple times to practice something. Finger placement. Scales. Or fingering on a piece of music im working on. Just small technical things that I can do when I would otherwise be scrolling aimlessly on my phone. And when I actually have a window where I can practice/play then I can focus on tone and that because some of the brain work has already been done. I have at least 300 hours of play time on it total and everything is holding up well, and as I improve my technique it sounds better almost each time I pick it up. Lol. The B-foot with the gizmo really stabilizes that high C well. Also have taught myself how to make the key adjustments (cause if you learn an instrument you should be able to perform some minor maintenance if you want to keep playing and I got too aggressive with a polishing cloth and popped a couple springs out of place which would have made this impossible to play) . At this point if the repair place won't work on it for a pad change or cork change because it's a "cheap flute" I'll gladly save my repair money and do it myself.
Thanks, Kirk. This is a great idea and it's definitely mulling around in the back of my mind right now. I have a series of exercises that I adapt for beginners to grad students and everyone in between. I'm currently working on editing the sheet music and then I will start thinking about how I can present them as videos. Stay tuned, and thanks for watching!!
Lance Suzuki I’m trying to learn how to play. I’m an adult beginner. You explain things very clearly so I look forward to seeing what you come up with. Certainly a “call and response” or “playalong with you and then without you” in whatever genre you decide would benefit everyone. Thank you so much 😊
Lance Suzuki also an explanation and gradual approach on how each note in the flute is played would be extremely helpful and simple etudes that gradually increase in difficulty would be great as well. Thank you so much!!
My feeling is: Glory - more possibilities for tone color and the general sound is bigger and warmer but it is much less refine and a rougher sound. Mendini - More closed off sound and not many possibilities but it is a clearer and more refine sound. I prefer the glory flute.
I have yet to pick a side yet, as I'm still listening and wishing to pick one that feels right to me But as I listen to you play both of them I realized something while reading comments below The glory does have that almost haunting tone, yet as you play it feels to me like it plays to sort of move around you, to try to become the air on the crowd so to say Where as the mendini is slightly sharper and focused, more of a push into you, like you bumped into someone as you walk by them, it tends to push your focus rather than have this envelope feeling, more of a I'm the focus here eyes on me feeling.... Idk if either description makes much sense, but I feel if I play mendini I would wish to solo play and try to entice and excite listeners like at a rally for a race (maybe nothing that big lol) Where as if I played glory I think I would wish to try to play to the heart and try to show emotion and connection to them, wanting to show it's ok to be there even if your not as focused as mendini or as energetic as a race rally, more like watching a campfire burn with friends around the fire.... I think this video may have me bend to want to get myself a glory, but I'll need more flute research before I finalize it, maybe next time I see your videos (I subscribed to you as you yourself have a more welcome tone that invites those to open up) I'll possibly update you if I ever make a choice and wether I regret or not Thank you for your time and effort and I hope I make my own correct choice for my own possible flute
Thanks, I am planning to get one because I am beginning flute lessons in a few days. I don’t know, I usually have a hard time telling difference but the teacher recommended mendini. But Both are great prices, probably getting mendini
This is great my old flute died a few years back and our music store closed. I’ve been looking for something to just have and it’s the perfect price for dabbling and getting back into it. The mendini sounded beautiful for the price like someone else said, richer fuller tone and better high pitched sounds.
😂 Give yourself more credit! What kind of flute do you play? It's probably all silver tubing...? Trust me, you can tell the difference with the precious metal content. However, I just wanted to show that these cheap flutes actually can sound good with a little TLC!
@@LanceSuzuki actually I just bought a bamboo flute at a thrift store about a month ago and I really like it. I'm still working on consistently producing a clean tone.
Thank you for taking the time to make these videos. Music-making should ideally be open to all, but, sadly, the price of a lot of "student" or "entry-level" orchestral instruments will put them out of reach of many. So, it's nice to see playable sub-$100 instruments getting fair, intelligent reviews.
Just a warning, he can definitely make these sound better than you probably can. I have not tried these but recently upgraded from a Nuvo to Geminhardt and the Gemeinhardt is much easier to play in tune consistently. Someone who has been playing for a long time will compensate for intonation problems. For the record I still like my Nuvo because it is lighter, can get wet, and unbreakable. Playing the Gemeinhardt has helped my tone on both though because my embrasure seems to settle in the correct position easier and I can transfer that to the Nuvo. All that said I'm sure these 70$ flutes are probably as good as multiple hundred dollar flutes 20 years ago.
You're definitely right that there is some skill involved. However, in this experiment, my playing is the constant and the flutes are the variables. I am not treating these flutes any differently than I would a $700, $7000 or $20,000 flute. You will have to take my word that I didn't make any crazy adjustments for intonation or tone above anything that I would do on a fine instrument.
This is a great review!! I appreciate you taking the time to do this video. I am definitely TeamMendini. The sound was consistent throughout the range of the instrument. The Mendini has a nice, warm tone. The Mendini did seem to struggle just a tiny bit in the high register. Although the Mendini sounded the best. I was listening with noise canceling headphones. Thank you so much 😊
My first flute was a Mendini, it was actually good for a beginner but after a year or two, it sort of fell apart and wasn't matching my skill level anymore (if that makes sense). I don't remember the exact problem but I think it had some loose screws so the keys were falling apart- I managed to fix it myself but it kept unscrewing over time. I took the whole thing apart after I got a new one :p
these videos really helped my decision. the mendini sounded better, but for my needs i think i will choose to get a glory. it was really cool to hear them side by side.
Thank you for these videos. They are really helping me in my effort to purchase a flute for my 4th grade granddaughter to use at school. However, I wish on this last video that you would have compared the Glory to the Mendini before you made the adjustments that you said made the Mendini sound better as there is no way I would be able to make any adjustments to a flute. In any case, I don’t think there is enough of a difference for it to matter. But I will buy the Glory because you didn’t have to adjust it as much to make it sound that good. Thanks again!
The flute was my first instrument at 13 years old, haven't touched it since probably about 15. Im 28 now and just chose the Mendini because of this video. You're never too late to learn an instrument.
Honestly, these are not bad at all. I was listening but not watching the screen and forgot I was listening to cheap flutes. I have a semi-professional flute, but I'd definitely get one of these as a backup or for questionable playing conditions.
Now that the Mendini is around the price of $110; do you believe that the flute is still one of the best on the market for this price point or do you believe there is another flute around this price range that does better?
The mendini has a warmer, tighter sound, which is lovely in its own right. The glory, however, has a more airy and playful vibe. In my opinion, it's like comparing singing styles, right? For more traditional/folk pieces I would choose the glory. For something a little more modern and refined, the mendini might better lend to the result one might want.
Hi, I just bought an open hole Glory flute. I used to play but haven't played in years. I'm wondering if you have any experience with the open hole version of Glory's line? This video is now 2 years old, so I'll understand if you don't see this comment. My mom's flute was an Armstrong open hole with a silver head but I don't have it anymore 💔
The Mendini sounds remarkably good for the price, especially considering the quality of some of the other instruments they make. Your playing makes one wonder why anyone would spend more than $100 on a flute.
the Mendini def has a more vibrant lower register. I can hear the harmonics better with the mendini but the glory is a little brighter which will probably sound better to blend in elementary and middle school band.
hi, lance! just wondering, is it true that instruments with gloves included on amazon scams? my band teacher said that "on amazon, you should never buy an instrument on amazon if it has gloves included. its most likely a scam." do yo thin thats true or not? thanks!
Unfortunately not yet! I hope to get to that in the next few months. I can't afford to buy all the cheap flutes and piccolos...even though they're cheap, it still adds up!
After listening to your play, I bought Glory since the low registers are good for me. I like the flute. Thanks. Can you post some pieces of music by Kenny G? Such as Forever in Love or Going Home.
I've watched many comparisons of different flute brands - mostly of higher-priced models, and I don't think the tone quality of any of those were as good as the ones that Lance just demonstrated, but that is probably because of the player, not the instrument. I am a flute player. I liked both of the flutes, but, again, that's probably because Lance was playing them. Hey Lance, do you give online lessons?
Thanks so much! Yes, there is a bit of skill involved in playing these instruments. However, I try to be as neutral as possible when testing. I hope that it's helpful to know that they are capable of producing good sounds. Yes, I do give online lessons, btw. Please check out my website at www.lancesuzuki.com/flute-lessons/virtual
@@LanceSuzuki Thank you so much for replying to my comment! I feel blessed to know that such a famous person is willing to take the time to communicate with me! I'll definitely check out your website. Thanks again!
This is helpful, i was wanting to just buy a cheaper flute for outside concerts, i have better flutes, but want one for outside, i like the Mendini i think
I`m not a flutist, but I preferred the mendini for Its clear and richer sound, Even though they sound almost the same. The glory lacks a little bit fines specially in the high notes.
You made them both sound amazing .! Not sure how either would sound in my hands 😖. I have subbed to your channel and look forward to seeing more from you. I’m a beginner (adult), teaching myself and finding it very enjoyable but also a little frustrating lol. I liked the tone of the Mendini better
Lance Suzuki I’ve only had my flute since approx March this year, it’s a second hand Trevor James 10x something, can’t remember without looking, and I’m finding it hard to slur between low and high registers? If that makes sense, the notes aren’t clean, and I end up pushing too much air through, I think,to reach the higher note as it gets a lot louder, lol!. Like I say I’m a complete novice really, and an impatient one as I just want to be able to play something. I have found some Gariboldi flute exercises here on TH-cam that I practice with, but other than my original first Tune a day book, I don’t know where to go from there. 🤷♀️. Also I need to learn the theory side of music too . I just love messing around with it, I’ve always wanted to play flute and it’s my one regret in life. Could you give me any advice on practice pieces/books to get or exactly what I should be practicing please? Thank you 🙏
If we are able to get a used Student Bundy or Gemeinhardt for the same price as the cheap Amazon one, which is preferred? They say the Bundy and Gemeinhardt 2SP are in "Good" condition. Are used, older branded ones better than new cheaper ones? Thank you.
Hi Gina, This is an excellent question. However, there isn’t really a good answer because it really depends on the actual instrument. I would not buy Bundy (even though my first flute was a Bundy). Gemeinhardt could be okay depending on how old it is and the condition. Regardless, those flutes are not necessarily made for resale. I would make sure there is a decent return policy before you order. I hope that helps. Thanks for watching. Lance
Hi Gina, This is an excellent question. However, there isn’t really a good answer because it really depends on the actual instrument. I would not buy Bundy (even though my first flute was a Bundy). Gemeinhardt could be okay depending on how old it is and the condition. Regardless, those flutes are not necessarily made for resale. I would make sure there is a decent return policy before you order. I hope that helps. Thanks for watching. Lance
@@LanceSuzuki thank you! Great to know. Do you know anything about this Jean Paul flute on Amazon: www.amazon.com/dp/B07W22TRNM/ref=twister_B07WJZ964R?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1
I have a Buescher from the 1980s and it’s not the best flute. But it’s still playable now whereas I bet these Amazon flutes won’t be usable in 35 years.
Yes sir mendini is much good than glory it sounds very well. And I also think that there is an airy sound in the glory which is very minute but seems like making sound in mendini is too much easy and no airy sound is there. Preferably the Mendini flute is the better choice.
@@LanceSuzuki no kidding darn thing near doubled 😅 Wonder if my salary will ever double lol But trurh is most likely it's due to the insane increase in shipping. A 40 foot container to the US from china used to cost between 1500 to 3000 USD. It has reached 18k-22K I mean even if its due to increase in fuel prices (which doubled) shouldnt the price just double instead of this monstrous increase? Crazy world we live in
![Glory Flute Unboxing & Review [Cheapest Amazon Flute (2020) Tested by Pro Flutist]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eN2AcSeLx5o/mqdefault.jpg)
![Glory Flute Unboxing & Review [Cheapest Amazon Flute (2020) Tested by Pro Flutist]](/img/tr.png)
![Mendini Flute Review & Unboxing [Budget Flute from Amazon Tested by Pro Flutist]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jqKYyiznCGU/mqdefault.jpg)
honestly, this is the first "pro reviews cheap flutes" video that doesn't just say "yeah just go and buy a $1000 flute instead" as if anyone looking at an under $100 flute even HAS the money to buy a yamaha
It really made it seem like the only way you can even get your feet wet on the flute is if you have a grand just lying around for an instrument you're not even sure you like playing, and it's very discouraging.
I really appreciate you actually talking about these flutes as serious options.
...on a completely different note, the Mendini sounded much better lol
Thanks so much! I totally get that many people don't have a lot of money to spend on flutes. I have definitely been there before. However, we can always try to make the best of what we have. I tried to take this philosophy when working on this series. If under $100 is the only option, you can still play the flute and get a decent sound.
Ive heard eastar is good
He had more upper register issues with the Glory so pick the Mendini. I bought a Mendini Sax and it wasn't very good. A better test would be for an intermediate player to try it. Having a pro play a cheap flute is not a realistic test.
Yes! Thanks so much for the video. Sometimes I kinda tired of hearing that don't buy cheap flute if someone is serious about learning it. So, poor people don't deserve to play flute?! Yet, to me, apart form the tone quality, maybe the response of the flute also matters and sometimes even more to beginners.
At the same time, it’s nice to see that these instruments *can* make an acceptable sound.
I’ve gone for a second hand TJ 10XE at the ~$200 price point; partly because I suspect I could get the $200 back for it if playing isn’t for me. But it’s really nice to see that even a sub-$100 flute can sound really quite beautiful in the hands of a pro.
I preferred the Mendini. It sounded warmer and fuller to my ears.
Hey Mikhail! Yes, I agree. It was also more enjoyable to play. Thanks for watching!
same
I’m learning to play the Flute and I wanted a Flute that was good but cheap since I don’t have the money right now to buy a thousand dollar flute. So watching the three videos really helped me. I was considering buying the Glory flute but changed my mind when I heard the Mendini Flute. I’m trying to learn the flute so I could join my high school marching band so I wanted to get the one with a better tone. And the Mendini also had an open hole version.
Am going to be the odd one out here and say that while the Mendini sounded more refined and polished, I preferred the sound of the Glory. It was cooler-toned to me, a little more haunting. But you played both beautifully, thank you for this very helpful video!
This makes my day! My hope for this video is that people would be able to come to their own conclusions from the side-by-side play test. It's great that you don't agree with the other commenters because tone quality (and music in general) are so subjective and just come down to personal preference in the end. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for making this video! We’re putting together a teacher band at our elementary school that includes teachers that used to play instruments and are interested in playing again to perform for our students. I loved that I was able to see and hear a real review of these instruments!
Thank you! I am a band teacher and am learning the basics of every instrument I can get my hands on, so I wasn't looking for something amazing necessarily so seeing that these instruments are capable of making pretty good characteristic tone is exactly what I needed to see. Thank you so much Lance!
Great! Thanks so much for the comment!
First I preferred the Mandini. After a while I thought the Glory was better in the low register. After listening a little more I will prefer the Mandini. It is amazing that it is possible to produce such flutes for the low price.
Mendini
Hands down. The tone s richer.
4 years in HS band 2nd chair. The band always tuned to my C. Now at 55 I want to play again for my "smokers" lines, my lung capacity, my mental well-being and a self improvement challenge. This time I hope to make 1st chair!
Thank you so much for this review! When I was in jr. high, I was in marching band and played the clarinet. In the last few weeks, I keep getting the feeling that I am to pick up the flute and learn it proficiently. I have watched both your Mendini and Glory reviews separately and even had my husband listen to you play both. I am looking to make my flute purchase by the end of this week (12/10/2023) and honestly, both have a great, distinct tone. Glory is definitely more stable but warmer while Medini has a really amazing sound that you would hear a flutist playing in an orchestra. Both also seem to come with their own set of pros and cons.
I would like to hear a comparison of the Mendini vs the cheapest Gemeinhardt and Yamaha flutes.
I agree with the comment that Gabe C. had a few months back. I really appreciate the efforts you've gone to in order to actually review the flutes for what they are - which is bargain basement beginner flutes. Too many of the self-styled experts/teachers/players just point their finger at the instrument they're *cough* reviewing, and dump all over it. You obviously put a lot of thought into the true use points of these flutes, and tailored the review for that. Will they replace a hand crafted Muramatsu "James Galway" special? No. But both of the flutes you reviewed will certainly get someone through their first year of Junior High (Middle School) band, or even just some re-education. Really, they sound no worse than my Gemeinhardt. How instruments have changed in 40 years.
Over the years, I've lost track of how many little bottles of oil I used on my instruments, how many screws were adjusted back and forth (or replaced), the head joint crown, and so forth - I definitely put my vote towards a video on "Basic things to look at on your flute". As well as what you _shouldn't_ do yourself, such as glue the screw heads in place. Or expect that any glue on a pad will be anything more than a 'get me through the night' fix.
Thanks, Troy, for your thoughtful comments! That is a wonderful video idea that I will definitely consider!
Definitely Mendini for me! I was shocked at the sound of that one altogether. The Glory one to me sounds a bit airy even after the adjustments you made. I had to help one of my niece's friends with her flute 'not working'. I would warn to check for anything sticking that shouldn't be as well as springs that are out of place or not even there. My niece's friend's flute all had just a couple loose screws and one screw that was tightened a bit too much on the D#/Eb right pinky key where it was barely moving freely. All in all, Mendini by Cecilio has improved since I first heard of the brand. Would I use it if I was a professional flutist? NO! The brand now has become a good brand as an 'intro to flute' type of brand.
I'm actually a bass clarinetist and clarinetist that plays flute off and on. Haha!
It's great to know that they are improving! 👍🏼👍🏼 Thanks for watching!
I'd choose the mandini too, because I prefere the warmer and clearer sound. The lack of quality in both shows most in the high register in my opinion.
I agree high register is where the problem starts for me.
I haven't played a flute in YEARS and have been wanting to pick it up again, but don't want to invest heavily just yet. Both sound wonderful, and the Glory had the better tone in the lower range, but I really liked the warmth of the Mendini in the upper range. Mid range both were comparable. Thank you. I'll probably purchase the Mendini and start from the almost beginning again!
I got the Mendini for free on Amazon a while back. I thought it was a “throwaway “ unto I saw your review so I took it to a flute repair shop to check things out as much as possible (loose screws, etc) and he was surprised at the sound as well. I think he thought it would have a terrible sound given the price.
Wow! You got it for free?! Amazing! I'm glad that you took the time and effort to get it looked at. Every flute deserves a little TLC sometime and hopefully it can serve some (small) purpose for you now. ❤️
Lance Suzuki yes I did ! For applying for their credit card. The amount off that I received covered the entire price of the Mendini flute. Since I have the Cecilio viola that has served me well I gave the flute a try. I agree with others that the Mendini has the warmer tone. Also... you could play a carrot and make it sound beautiful!😂
I ended up buying a Glory open holed B-foot with all the things. I've had it over a year and I love it.
Will I upgrade to a more expensive flute? Probably at some point, definitely if I keep playing.
But as it is now, this one suits me well.
I keep it out on a stand and that reminds me to practice, it's not hugely expensive so if I have to replace it I can.
I pick it up multiple times to practice something. Finger placement. Scales. Or fingering on a piece of music im working on. Just small technical things that I can do when I would otherwise be scrolling aimlessly on my phone.
And when I actually have a window where I can practice/play then I can focus on tone and that because some of the brain work has already been done. I have at least 300 hours of play time on it total and everything is holding up well, and as I improve my technique it sounds better almost each time I pick it up. Lol. The B-foot with the gizmo really stabilizes that high C well. Also have taught myself how to make the key adjustments (cause if you learn an instrument you should be able to perform some minor maintenance if you want to keep playing and I got too aggressive with a polishing cloth and popped a couple springs out of place which would have made this impossible to play) . At this point if the repair place won't work on it for a pad change or cork change because it's a "cheap flute" I'll gladly save my repair money and do it myself.
I would love to see you create some kind of online or video lesson plan. I’m sure they would be high quality like your reviews 😊
Thanks, Kirk. This is a great idea and it's definitely mulling around in the back of my mind right now. I have a series of exercises that I adapt for beginners to grad students and everyone in between. I'm currently working on editing the sheet music and then I will start thinking about how I can present them as videos. Stay tuned, and thanks for watching!!
Lance Suzuki I’m trying to learn how to play. I’m an adult beginner. You explain things very clearly so I look forward to seeing what you come up with. Certainly a “call and response” or “playalong with you and then without you” in whatever genre you decide would benefit everyone. Thank you so much 😊
Lance Suzuki also an explanation and gradual approach on how each note in the flute is played would be extremely helpful and simple etudes that gradually increase in difficulty would be great as well. Thank you so much!!
These are great suggestions. Keep them coming and thanks!!!
Maybe a lesson plan that focuses on scales and arpeggios and various etudes that utilizes scales and arpeggios
My feeling is:
Glory - more possibilities for tone color and the general sound is bigger and warmer but it is much less refine and a rougher sound.
Mendini - More closed off sound and not many possibilities but it is a clearer and more refine sound. I prefer the glory flute.
Great! Thanks for watching!
I have yet to pick a side yet, as I'm still listening and wishing to pick one that feels right to me
But as I listen to you play both of them I realized something while reading comments below
The glory does have that almost haunting tone, yet as you play it feels to me like it plays to sort of move around you, to try to become the air on the crowd so to say
Where as the mendini is slightly sharper and focused, more of a push into you, like you bumped into someone as you walk by them, it tends to push your focus rather than have this envelope feeling, more of a I'm the focus here eyes on me feeling....
Idk if either description makes much sense, but I feel if I play mendini I would wish to solo play and try to entice and excite listeners like at a rally for a race (maybe nothing that big lol)
Where as if I played glory I think I would wish to try to play to the heart and try to show emotion and connection to them, wanting to show it's ok to be there even if your not as focused as mendini or as energetic as a race rally, more like watching a campfire burn with friends around the fire....
I think this video may have me bend to want to get myself a glory, but I'll need more flute research before I finalize it, maybe next time I see your videos (I subscribed to you as you yourself have a more welcome tone that invites those to open up) I'll possibly update you if I ever make a choice and wether I regret or not
Thank you for your time and effort and I hope I make my own correct choice for my own possible flute
Thanks, I am planning to get one because I am beginning flute lessons in a few days. I don’t know, I usually have a hard time telling difference but the teacher recommended mendini. But Both are great prices, probably getting mendini
This is great my old flute died a few years back and our music store closed. I’ve been looking for something to just have and it’s the perfect price for dabbling and getting back into it. The mendini sounded beautiful for the price like someone else said, richer fuller tone and better high pitched sounds.
Lance- How to make an Amazon piece of 💩 flute sound like a $5000 flute.
Me- How to make a $5000 flute sound like an amazon piece of 💩 flute.
😂 Give yourself more credit! What kind of flute do you play? It's probably all silver tubing...? Trust me, you can tell the difference with the precious metal content. However, I just wanted to show that these cheap flutes actually can sound good with a little TLC!
@@LanceSuzuki actually I just bought a bamboo flute at a thrift store about a month ago and I really like it. I'm still working on consistently producing a clean tone.
Thank you for taking the time to make these videos. Music-making should ideally be open to all, but, sadly, the price of a lot of "student" or "entry-level" orchestral instruments will put them out of reach of many. So, it's nice to see playable sub-$100 instruments getting fair, intelligent reviews.
Thanks a lot! Much appreciated! ❤️
Just a warning, he can definitely make these sound better than you probably can. I have not tried these but recently upgraded from a Nuvo to Geminhardt and the Gemeinhardt is much easier to play in tune consistently. Someone who has been playing for a long time will compensate for intonation problems. For the record I still like my Nuvo because it is lighter, can get wet, and unbreakable. Playing the Gemeinhardt has helped my tone on both though because my embrasure seems to settle in the correct position easier and I can transfer that to the Nuvo. All that said I'm sure these 70$ flutes are probably as good as multiple hundred dollar flutes 20 years ago.
You're definitely right that there is some skill involved. However, in this experiment, my playing is the constant and the flutes are the variables. I am not treating these flutes any differently than I would a $700, $7000 or $20,000 flute. You will have to take my word that I didn't make any crazy adjustments for intonation or tone above anything that I would do on a fine instrument.
Embouchere
This is a great review!! I appreciate you taking the time to do this video. I am definitely TeamMendini. The sound was consistent throughout the range of the instrument. The Mendini has a nice, warm tone. The Mendini did seem to struggle just a tiny bit in the high register. Although the Mendini sounded the best. I was listening with noise canceling headphones. Thank you so much 😊
The Mendini was actually fun for me to play and I think it has some nice tone colors in it.
My first flute was a Mendini, it was actually good for a beginner but after a year or two, it sort of fell apart and wasn't matching my skill level anymore (if that makes sense). I don't remember the exact problem but I think it had some loose screws so the keys were falling apart- I managed to fix it myself but it kept unscrewing over time. I took the whole thing apart after I got a new one :p
Thanks for the info! What did you end up getting to replace it?
these videos really helped my decision. the mendini sounded better, but for my needs i think i will choose to get a glory. it was really cool to hear them side by side.
Awesome! I hope the flute works out for you!
I purchased the Glory about 3 years ago because it was on sale; However, I preferred the Mendini for sure.
Mendini sounds a little tighter. I ordered a Glory though, and the difference is pretty tiny. Nice review.
Thanks a lot, Travis!
I’m team Mendini, beautiful sound… I bought a mendini before watching this video, this is confirmation that I made the right purchase
This was helpful, thanks! I preferred the sound of the Glory, to my ears.
Great! Thanks for watching!
Thank you so much Im a student who wants to start flute and this has helped me a lot.
Great! I'm so glad it helped!
Thank you for these videos. They are really helping me in my effort to purchase a flute for my 4th grade granddaughter to use at school. However, I wish on this last video that you would have compared the Glory to the Mendini before you made the adjustments that you said made the Mendini sound better as there is no way I would be able to make any adjustments to a flute. In any case, I don’t think there is enough of a difference for it to matter. But I will buy the Glory because you didn’t have to adjust it as much to make it sound that good. Thanks again!
How does the lazarro flute compare to the mendini and glory flutes
Across the range, the Glory was superior to the Mendini. Great demo, you play so nicely, and thanks for posting!
I have zero knowledge about flute. But I’m fascinated about them. And always wanted to be able to how to play.
I will go with mendini.
Great! Let me know how it goes and if I can help in any way.
The flute was my first instrument at 13 years old, haven't touched it since probably about 15. Im 28 now and just chose the Mendini because of this video. You're never too late to learn an instrument.
Try the eastrock flute please
beautiful playing on both thank you for sharing this
Thanks so much, David!
Honestly, these are not bad at all. I was listening but not watching the screen and forgot I was listening to cheap flutes. I have a semi-professional flute, but I'd definitely get one of these as a backup or for questionable playing conditions.
Now that the Mendini is around the price of $110; do you believe that the flute is still one of the best on the market for this price point or do you believe there is another flute around this price range that does better?
The mendini has a warmer, tighter sound, which is lovely in its own right. The glory, however, has a more airy and playful vibe. In my opinion, it's like comparing singing styles, right? For more traditional/folk pieces I would choose the glory. For something a little more modern and refined, the mendini might better lend to the result one might want.
I bought a mendini and it is good so far
I prefer the precision in all the registers of the Mendini. It also sounds less airy.
Hi, I just bought an open hole Glory flute. I used to play but haven't played in years. I'm wondering if you have any experience with the open hole version of Glory's line? This video is now 2 years old, so I'll understand if you don't see this comment. My mom's flute was an Armstrong open hole with a silver head but I don't have it anymore 💔
Unfortunately, I haven't been able to try the open holed one. However, I imagine that it would be similar to the closed hole.
I am in a band and have played for 4 years. I wanted my own flute and this really helped. I like the mending flute!
Great! Have fun playing it in your band!
Hi, what do you thing abaut Nuvo flutes...thank you in advance
Mendini sounded richer. Love your videos and teaching
The Mendini sounds remarkably good for the price, especially considering the quality of some of the other instruments they make.
Your playing makes one wonder why anyone would spend more than $100 on a flute.
the Mendini def has a more vibrant lower register. I can hear the harmonics better with the mendini but the glory is a little brighter which will probably sound better to blend in elementary and middle school band.
Is the third register intonation fine? I have another off brand called muslady and it's rather out of tune up there.
Would you kindly tell me which one is easier and more effortless to play (produce sound)
hi, lance! just wondering, is it true that instruments with gloves included on amazon scams? my band teacher said that "on amazon, you should never buy an instrument on amazon if it has gloves included. its most likely a scam." do yo thin thats true or not?
thanks!
Do you have a video on Amazon piccolos?
Unfortunately not yet! I hope to get to that in the next few months. I can't afford to buy all the cheap flutes and piccolos...even though they're cheap, it still adds up!
After listening to your play, I bought Glory since the low registers are good for me. I like the flute. Thanks. Can you post some pieces of music by Kenny G? Such as Forever in Love or Going Home.
Mendini. Might be nice to have one of these to learn how to work on flutes, since if these get messed up, not a whole lot of money was spent.
Absolutely #TEAMMENDINI its sound is bright and clean
I've watched many comparisons of different flute brands - mostly of higher-priced models, and I don't think the tone quality of any of those were as good as the ones that Lance just demonstrated, but that is probably because of the player, not the instrument. I am a flute player. I liked both of the flutes, but, again, that's probably because Lance was playing them. Hey Lance, do you give online lessons?
Thanks so much! Yes, there is a bit of skill involved in playing these instruments. However, I try to be as neutral as possible when testing. I hope that it's helpful to know that they are capable of producing good sounds. Yes, I do give online lessons, btw. Please check out my website at www.lancesuzuki.com/flute-lessons/virtual
@@LanceSuzuki Thank you so much for replying to my comment! I feel blessed to know that such a famous person is willing to take the time to communicate with me! I'll definitely check out your website. Thanks again!
This is helpful, i was wanting to just buy a cheaper flute for outside concerts, i have better flutes, but want one for outside, i like the Mendini i think
I`m not a flutist, but I preferred the mendini for Its clear and richer sound, Even though they sound almost the same. The glory lacks a little bit fines specially in the high notes.
fantastic sound!
making cheap sounds expensive!
You can make any flute sound beautiful 💜🎶💜🎶
Aww...thanks so much, Julie! ❤️
I wanted a back up flute too...I like the Mendini because it has a richer tone. Thank you for your post. 🙏 #TEAMMENDINI
Great!
You made them both sound amazing .! Not sure how either would sound in my hands 😖. I have subbed to your channel and look forward to seeing more from you. I’m a beginner (adult), teaching myself and finding it very enjoyable but also a little frustrating lol. I liked the tone of the Mendini better
What concepts/skills are you finding the most challenging right now?
Lance Suzuki I’ve only had my flute since approx March this year, it’s a second hand Trevor James 10x something, can’t remember without looking, and I’m finding it hard to slur between low and high registers? If that makes sense, the notes aren’t clean, and I end up pushing too much air through, I think,to reach the higher note as it gets a lot louder, lol!. Like I say I’m a complete novice really, and an impatient one as I just want to be able to play something. I have found some Gariboldi flute exercises here on TH-cam that I practice with, but other than my original first Tune a day book, I don’t know where to go from there. 🤷♀️. Also I need to learn the theory side of music too . I just love messing around with it, I’ve always wanted to play flute and it’s my one regret in life. Could you give me any advice on practice pieces/books to get or exactly what I should be practicing please? Thank you 🙏
@@tootles7568 Are you still playing? Try the Trevor Wye books! :)
If we are able to get a used Student Bundy or Gemeinhardt for the same price as the cheap Amazon one, which is preferred? They say the Bundy and Gemeinhardt 2SP are in "Good" condition. Are used, older branded ones better than new cheaper ones? Thank you.
Hi Gina,
This is an excellent question. However, there isn’t really a good answer because it really depends on the actual instrument. I would not buy Bundy (even though my first flute was a Bundy). Gemeinhardt could be okay depending on how old it is and the condition. Regardless, those flutes are not necessarily made for resale. I would make sure there is a decent return policy before you order. I hope that helps. Thanks for watching.
Lance
Hi Gina,
This is an excellent question. However, there isn’t really a good answer because it really depends on the actual instrument. I would not buy Bundy (even though my first flute was a Bundy). Gemeinhardt could be okay depending on how old it is and the condition. Regardless, those flutes are not necessarily made for resale. I would make sure there is a decent return policy before you order. I hope that helps. Thanks for watching.
Lance
@@LanceSuzuki thank you! Great to know. Do you know anything about this Jean Paul flute on Amazon: www.amazon.com/dp/B07W22TRNM/ref=twister_B07WJZ964R?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1
I have a Buescher from the 1980s and it’s not the best flute. But it’s still playable now whereas I bet these Amazon flutes won’t be usable in 35 years.
I love your flute videos
Thanks, Christie! ❤️
Stopped on second piece, confirmed Mendini.
mendini sounds fuller and richer. do they have an open hole mendini?
Yes, the open holed Mendini is here: amzn.to/3vdmOQc
Can you please do a review on Amazon Piccolos?
Yes, I definitely want to do piccolos in the future!
Joe Kinchicken 😐
I prefer the Mendini for overall sound quality.
Yes sir mendini is much good than glory it sounds very well.
And I also think that there is an airy sound in the glory which is very minute but seems like making sound in mendini is too much easy and no airy sound is there.
Preferably the Mendini flute is the better choice.
A Good flute player can produce a good sound on any Instrument.
This is true to some extent. The player makes a huge difference but can only do so much for the flute. Thanks for watching, Sven!
Went with the mendini because im allergic to the nickel in the glory one ha
Great video !
Thanks so much!
Early. Ima be the first to like!
The flutes are equally good 👍
What is the best flute to buy under $200?
I haven’t yet gotten to the $100-200 range. However, in the below $100 range, I think the Mendini is a good buy.
I liked the mendini
I am.team u. I love the way u play♡ I just love the flute♡ Thanks
Aww. Thanks so much, Amber!! ❤️
Mendini!
I am with #TeamLanceSuzuki
❤️❤️
Yes, the Mendini is the better one.
👍
Thought Mendini was more glorious :-)
Team mendini
Glory sounds richer and fuller
#teammendini!
Thanks a lot! #Mendini
Wow the Mendini is 130 now, and here I was just about to buy it. This sucks.
Wow! Inflation!! Sorry to hear that.
@@LanceSuzuki no kidding darn thing near doubled 😅
Wonder if my salary will ever double lol
But trurh is most likely it's due to the insane increase in shipping. A 40 foot container to the US from china used to cost between 1500 to 3000 USD. It has reached 18k-22K
I mean even if its due to increase in fuel prices (which doubled) shouldnt the price just double instead of this monstrous increase?
Crazy world we live in
mendini
Mendini
Mendine sounds better.
#TeamMendini
Poor Glory hasn't gotten any votes! However, I agree with you.
a Glory Hole Flute 🤣
Mending was my favorite!
It’s 100% a great flute for the price!