@Joe-pc3hs you have a bioessentalist world veiw. If you don't know what that means you don't have the requisite philosophical, sociological, psych, or bio knowledge to participate in conversations about sex, gender, or trans people. I'm begging you and every other random internet troll to just read a single book, Just one book before talking. Stop listening to political pundents say trans people believe and taking their word as gospel, if you're illiterate at least have an open and honest conversation with a trans person before you make claims about their claims.
Meanwhile on Facebook, there's a lot of "moral crusaders" who will lash out regardless of how nice the situation just because she's a trans person. How noble.
So you're just going to ignore the fact that Dylan will be genetically male, not just now but long after he's dead? Dude, DNA is a thing, and it really fu*ks up your whole worldview. Maybe change????
@@justagamethrower you say it. That’s disgusting, man. That’s a human being. And we say “she” because she asks us to. If you want to choose to be a jerk, that’s your legal right, but you should evaluate that choice, because it isn’t a very good one.
Ikr. Like this guy is so dumb and sheep thinkers jus flock to him. He’s like lgbt but NOT lgbt. He’s right wing thinker but NOT EXACTLY like bro ok. Just cut the bs😂
I 100% agree, people were really upset that she got a can with her face on it. And they thought that Bud light was going to start forcing them to buy beer cans with her face, but Bud light literally sends a can with someone's face on it to everyone who joins their marketing campaigns? People will just take any excuse to be bigoted and transphobic. All of this "criticism"comes from bigoted transphobes who just want to complain that trans people exist. They are legitimately disgusted by the fact that a trans person has to do with a beer brand that they identify with. They are so sensitive and triggered that the mere existence of a trans person sends them into a flurry of hatred
So making a mockery of women and using "woman face" and doing days of GIRL hood and not womanhood and taking millions from brand deals as soon as you say you're a woman because you couldn't get clout as a man isn't problematic? I have no issues with trans adults. Dylan is not trans. He is a money hungry attention seeker
@@Nachofleas The entire point of her content was to show her journey of being trans. She is trans, she did not plan to become popular it just happened. If someone came to you because you were making content, and offered you brand deals of course you would take those brand deals because that's how life works. You need money to survive, and if your content is meaningful to trans people going through similar situations as you, and you can make that your full-time job then that's a good thing. You are being transphobic, first of all misgendering someone on purpose is pretty gross. Claiming that just because she makes money off of her content doesn't make her trans makes no sense. Because she was making this content well before she got popular just to share her life and her journey.
Exactly the vast majority of people don’t really about gender. We just care about wtf you produce for society. There’s nothing more annoying that some that’s unproductive to society.
@@rockerdude83 it doesn't bother you that the person you pay rent to is profiting off of your need for housing without contributing anything themselves?
@@Blappyboop do you think ppl are like Marching into women’s houses and saying they’re replacing them? Can you explain to me how they’re replacing cis women if the amount of women in the world doesn’t go down? Who’s being replaced if girls continue to be born. You make zero sense and are going based off of debunked claims. You NEED to start doing research instead of just refusing to. You’d be surprised to know that maybe…just maybe…trans people are once again people and sometimes you guys don’t even realize they’re near you. You’d be surprised how many people are genuinely surprised when I say I was born female. Suck it lmao
@@Blappyboop "A lot of them are" people? Jesus fucking Christ, dude. Are you a Nazi? Do you ever consider what you write before you post it? Imagine yourself saying the same thing about any other group. Jews? "A lot of them are". Cops? "A lot of them are". Christians? "A lot of them are". I would recommend that you examine your world view if you don't believe that every single human being is a person, plural; "people". Everyone is "people"; not "a lot of them".
Most of the criticism of Dylan is basically being mad she’s doing what most women do at around 10 to 16. Getting caught up in stupid or silly ideas of what it means to be a woman. Sometimes wrong ideas! We have no ducking clue either. We Spend a stupid amount of time figuring it out and being over blown versions of adult women. I find newly out transitioning women do the same. Their bodies are shifting, they’re awkward as they put on the trappings of womanhood while not being there physically. It’s better to sit back and let them settle before being too critical. Cuz like teenagers they’re full of hormones and changes and not really ready for nuance. Dylan is probably starting to settle down now. You can tell by her face filling out and softening that the hormones are doing their thing. It’s getting easier for her to “pass” and she probably feels less of the urge to Loudly define who she is as woman and go back to just, being a person who happens to be trans. Dylan isn’t Really an activist. They’re a public figure who got a lot of attention for being an awkward newly transitioning woman. I wish her luck on maintaining her career and getting away from the pearl clutchers. Her figuring out her version of womanhood doesn’t threaten mine.
FFS do you realize how misogynistic your statement is against actual women. "Dylan is basically being mad she’s doing what most women do at around 10 to 16. Getting caught up in stupid or silly ideas of what it means to be a woman." Women know what they are. You have no idea what they go through at that age, where do you get off calling them silly and stupid. What's wrong about this is, people like you and Dylan assume they know. You cant assume anything. It is the ultimate form of misogyny and appropriation. Just like how I can't assume that I know what being Chinese is like, a man cant assume they know what being a women is like. It is not as simple as just a hormones.
@@JohnDoe-ks9xx wait what lol we got an extra goofy here the free market don't care about a hateful pos thats the point of it being free every company will support lgbt otherwise they get canceled by most moral people thats only right or you like segregation and other evil ideas huh?
@@babyvaso3855orrect. I have traveled to 33 countries and lived in 7 and have seen real poverty. Americans have no clue what real poverty is. Americans who make $5 an hour are richer than ever before than most of the world.
hey I'm a trans person and I just want to say that she personally makes me uncomfortable when she calls herself a girl rather than a woman. I understand that she didn't have a girlhood but she cannot be in her girlhood because she is a grown woman. I would feel just as weird as a grown woman who is not trans said they are in girlhood.
Women can call ourselves whatever we want. We were born, raised and lived our entire lives as female. No matter how hard they try trans women will never experience this and their attempts to replicate common female experiences is honestly offensive and disrespectful to real women. Dress however you want just live as a regular person stop trying to live as a stereotype. It’s like someone being transracial Black and wearing full blackface, then only eating fried chicken and watermelon, speaking in AAV slang and dressing like a 2000s gangster with their pants down
Fact is you only use Dylan Mulvaney as a core example of the trans community? I don’t relate to her womanhood ideal whatsoever. A lot of us don’t neither do I claim I’m a real woman because I’m a trans woman. Two very different things. The way Dylan glamorises trans dumbs down the severity of gender dysphoria.
Wow, I'm usually not one that agrees with trans idealogy but it's so refreshing to see your POV and honestly, it's 100% a POV I can get behind. From my personal experience, most, if not all, trans people I've interacted with are quite extreme with their identity so it always ticked me the wrong way how they'd disenfranchise women by claiming womenhood.
@@insomniackiller1 I never claim I’m a real woman because that’s defeating the whole point of being a trans woman. Trans women need to own it instead of saying they are real women which is false. Which was the narrative in 2009 and on going until 2016 when trans politics started going haywire. And I don’t agree with all these words to describe biological women, like breast feeders etc it’s awful. There was such a thing as transfeminism but then trans women and trans activists started joining the new wave. And that’s ok, but isn’t it better to have your own movement?
The word "criticism" implies fhat she did something wrong worthy of, well, criticism. All she did was exist in this world and the "criticism" she just received was just plain old bigotry. You wouldn't call a racist rant about XYZ criticism, wouldn't you? Well, same shit here. All these fence sitting vocabulary usually attracts the wrong kind of people
Do you think letters can experience racism or is that just a bad example you used? You people have become so insane that I honestly can't tell the difference anymore...
We got em' You realize that he's obviously not fence sitting with all of what was said. I am trans myself, and found nothing wrong with what he said. People like you are the ones that make people think I'm gonna go postal for someone messing up on my pronouns. I don't care about my pronouns anyway. The fuck is the point? To have a label. Pretty sure I went through like a yearly lecture in school about how harmful putting so much stock into a label was. I swear to God if you aren't trans yourself you're an even bigger part of the problem.
Nothing wrong with voicing one's disapproval. Just like there's nothing wrong with a man who thinks he's a woman and vica versa.... Doesn't mean I have to agree or like that lifestyle
As a man who identifies as non binary, I have mixed feelings, but props to you for giving respect where respect is due, I don't think people should make being gay their entire personality
At least Dylan is maturing now. Dylan's statements from the early beginning of the "__ day of girhood" series had some terrible takes, such as "normalize the bulge" or Dylan sterotyping females like weak chicks who are always afraid of insects. I wish Dylan the best from diverging her content from making gender as the whole personality to more refreshing videos about what has got best out of herself.
I mean. There would be no platform of it wasn’t for being transgendered though…..we wouldn’t even know who this person is….so it’s hard to take it seriously if I’m honest.
Praising people for being calm under pressure can also be applied to Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini. It means nothing that he responded this way because a total sociopathic narcissist could do the exact same and that's who he is
I never cared if someone identifies as something else. For all I care you could identify as a plant. Just leave me out of it. Just like everyone can choose whatever they believe, let me have the same. I'm not going around yelling on the street or getting the media involved in my opinions. Just live and let live. Keep your opinions to yourselves.
Are you going to let others live when people are persecuting them? Or are you going to stand up for their right to exist? If you truly didn't care what people identify as, you'd be fighting for their rights
@@TroutBoneless as someone who truly does not care I absolutely am not going to fight for something. Just as they have their rights to identity as they want, others have the right not to agree. Sure violence is unnecessary, but wars have been fought over things that don't matter. It's human nature. All I'm saying is just let it be. Besides you have no idea on what point I stand. Because it shouldn't matter. My opinion is my own. Everyone else's should be also. The fact that you don't seem to understand that tells me your opinion on the subject.
Okay but here's the issue, there are people that are actively working to hurt and harm these people. Trans people are being attacked by not only bad people, but also the government. There are literally hundreds of antitrans bills being passed across the United States right now. By trying to remain unbiased you are allowing a minority group who is currently being attacked and having their lives ruined to be in danger. The least that people can do is say "people can identify as whatever they want, I don't care what people identify as. And they should be able to do that". This isn't just an opinion thing this is like a human rights issue. This would be like saying "I don't hate black people, I I think everybody should be allowed to live no matter what their skin color is. But don't get me involved in it, leave me alone and I'll leave you alone." During the civil Rights movement. Non-action equals siding with the oppressive side because only action can help these people.
All trans people want to do is live and let live. Why do we have to be outspoken and political? Because politicians and gamer podcasters make us that way by trying to eradicate us.
Massive miss from you bro. You made it seem like she did something wrong even though bud light reached out to her and she accepted the offer for money and to speak about her story. Because you said it was refreshing that she would make less gender related content and more artistic talent content, this implies that you believe it was "refreshing" that the transphobia towards her, because that was the criticism after all, changed the content she makes now
Yeah, ppl need to listen to Buck Angel and Marcus Dib before they call this Dylan ass-hat a “woman”. He’s just not. He’s not “trans”, he’s just a gay man, and he should stick with that. Even if you perceive one thing he says as positive, his actions and speeches and videos tell a very different story. He likes to get all “positive” and humble after he’s received backlash for insulting women, such as falling down in his “hiking heels” bc he was scared of a bug, and giggling like an idiot. Ppl think he’s “harmless”, but claiming to break free of “gender roles” and of gender itself, while simultaneously reinforcing the worst stereotypes about women, getting famous for it, and using his influence to encourage ppl to allow their children to go further with transitioning than he ever will (bc he’s a dude and doesn’t actually want to be a woman) is dangerous, it’s narcissistic, and it’s manipulative. I’ve got nothing for him. He can act humble and empathetic at key moments in order to shame his detractors all he wants, but his words and behaviors the other 99% of the time renders any attempt at appearing sincere, reasonable, and mature meaningless.
Hello as a gay man i really appreciate your acceptance but you must understand she hasnt really done anything wrong other then be herself the fact shes getting criticized shows we have alot further to grow as humans as we've always been on a sexual spectrum and we should know and accept that
Wow. I find myself not-giving-a-fuck about people whom are simply seeking personal happiness. That's (whatever) god's will. Even God himself. Almost all have forgotten, "Judge not, lest ye be judged yourself. " I have NO issue on trans folk. Do your want. Don't expect ME to conform to anything. You are you. Live that. Your life, not mine. BL just bought into an unrequited dream, based on sponsorship alone. Hard card, but they asked to hit.
Why was the name Yahuah taken out of the scriptures over 7000x? It’s simple- so that you wouldn’t know it. For “everyone who calls on the Name of יהוה shall be saved.” Romiyim (Romans) 10:13 ‘And it shall be that everyone who calls on the Name of יהוה shall be saved.’ Ma`asei (Acts) 2:21 Pour out Your wrath on the nations Who have not known You, And on reigns that have not called on Your Name. Tehillim (Psalms) 79:6 Help us, O Elohim of our deliverance, For the sake of the esteem of Your Name. And deliver us, and cover over our sins, For Your Name’s sake! Tehillim (Psalms) 79:9 I can keep posting scripture about how Important Yahuah and Yahusha Ha Mashiac name is. you see those who don’t call a this name is cursed, those who call there is salvation and deliverance and blessings. Name in Hebrew is shêm, shame; a primitive word [perhaps rather from H7760 through the idea of definite and conspicuous position; compare H8064]; an appellation, as a mark or memorial of individuality; by implication honor, authority, character:-+ base, (in-) fame(-ous), named(-d), renown, report. a name is a Mark, authority, and character of a person. The reason this is important because Yahuahs name encompasses his whole character through the scriptures. And a different name encompasses another character. Another Mark if you will. lord, god and jesus are not innocent translations. in TS 2009 ISR explanatory notes it explains making these changes transgresses the command not to bring Yahuahs name to naught, and not to add to the Word, and not to have another mighty one against Yahuahs face. -the name lord can be traced to the Roman house-diety , and further back to the name of an Etruscan sovereign, Larth. In antiquity sovereigns were -the name god developed from a Germanic god wodenaz-gudenaz-guden-god. -the name jesus can be traced to the diety of healing in Greek culture. iasous a female healing diety. look at the scripture below the Greeks likened there deity’s to the Hebrews when they saw the power at work. And when the crowds saw what Sha’ul had done, they lifted up their voices, saying in Lukaonian, “The mighty ones have become like men and come down to us!” And they called Barnaḇa Zeus, and Sha’ul Hermes, since he was the chief speaker. And the priest of Zeus, being in front of their city, brought oxen and wreaths to the gates, and wished to offer with the crowds. And when the emissaries Barnaḇa and Sha’ul heard this, they tore their garments and ran in among the crowd, crying out Ma`asei (Acts) 14:11-14 I pray this information helps you as you seek the truth and continue to research these matters.
I haven't followed Dylan Mulvaney and I didn't know who she was until I heard about the bud light controversy so I can only speak for myself. I rarely spend my whole day thinking about my gender or how I feel about it. I do have a channel but my content is mostly about things i do and like in life. And bit of science and fixing my car, because it could help people that need to fix the same car I have. I think she could have a balance content. But in the end is up for her to decide what content she puts on her channel. And as trans person I would say that not every trans person need to have a channel where they talk about femmininity or unicorns and rainbows.
I disagree. The problem with these so called oppressed groups are into victimization and being treated as special interest group with extra laws protecting them. They aren't asking to treated by content of their character, but based on their identity. 60 years ago a man had a speech he had a dream. Which moved Americans support civil rights. Whoever advocates socialism with govt power are dishonest and grifters.
The thing is transgender people arent treated as a special interest group and as far as I know there are no extra laws protecting them (but you can cite some if there are), in fact transgender people are typically left out of laws protecting certain groups from different abuses and there have been over 550 proposed anti transgender bills so far this year🤷
Hes literally on the verge of losing his shtick. Patronizing womanhood and making a mockery of it has literally made him a millionaire. That livelihood is being threatened so he's shifting gears. Theres no talent no artistic expression to behold and there's certainly no maturity or conscientious approach he's trying to make here. He's simply trying to save his income stream. And if being oppressed gets me paid millions tell me where to sign.
She is an adult, she responded to literal harassment campaigns by thousands of people, death threats, threats on her safety in a very calm and mature way that I don't think most people could. Why would you respond during the large heat of this whole controversy, when you didn't do anything wrong? She was approached by Bud light for a sponsorship, and then took the sponsorship. People got triggered because they are sensitive little snowflakes and can't deal with the fact that trans people exist and they like beer. This would be no different than boycotting a beer because they got a black person to do a sponsored segment. Don't be a transphobe, get better Josh
@@justamf82 actually no, she is trans. Have you ever actually communicated with like real trans people? Just like had like a mature discussion trying to understand other people? Because you know that scientifically there are medical differences between trans people and cis people right? There have been brain scans done that show that many many MTF trans people actually have brains more similar to cis females than cis males. Not to mention there are also over 40 ways to be classified as intersex. Gender is not this hard binary that we thought it was for so long. There are so many other creatures in nature that don't live by a hard sexual binary, and we are figuring out that humans are one of those creatures. There's no reason to be hateful to trans people and think that you know more than them. Are you a scientist? Are you a biologist? Are you trans? How many trans people have you interacted with in a way that wasn't just being mean to them? You literally have no idea what you were talking about. Transphobic people always try and use science or common sense, when in fact those things are disagreeing with you. You are wrong not only scientifically but also morally. Why do you get to choose and say what someone is? What gives you the authority that you are better than them? Because you're not
This is called backpedaling. He gained notoriety through the gender politics and now that he’s amassed a large following, he’s going to begin doing what he’s wanted to do all along, whatever that may entail.
Notoriety can be a one sided street. Nothing dylan did I woukd describe as notorious. Many people hate those that are gender non conforming. Says more about then amd their insecurities than dylan
I don't think this is inherently wrong. There are cases, like politicians, where backpedaling is indeed very damaging, because it results in changes to society that do not align with what the majority wanted. However, for something like influencers, I would say it's completely fair game. If you amass a following through your gender, like Dylan, and then switch your content to something different, I would say it's an indication of talent if your brand survives the switch, since you're veering to something different from what your base audience would expect. As a matter of fact, I would say this kind of backpedalling can sometimes be beneficial ; a content creator veering away from politicized content in a period where they aren't comfortable being a political icon is a good thing. Nobody who doesn't want to be involved in politics should be forced to.
I personally don’t like the way Dylan stereotypes woman. But I don’t hate him. I don’t like several things he does or what he claims he is. I appreciate the way he’s handling this whole thing tho. I don’t agree with his politics or his beliefs. But he’s being mature about this at least, so I can respect him for that.
No it doesn't, it states. If your parents are American citizens, then you're an American citizen Representative amounts are based on state population People who commit treason aren't allowed to run for any office And debts picked up from fighting rebellions can't be questioned and that the US has no obligation of paying pensions to those fought in a rebellion against the state or that occurred due to the lost of slaves.
@@cockmqn how is any of this relevant to the point I made? The purpose and spirit of the 14th Amendment was, yes, to outline citizenship, but also by virtue of that to explicitly state that all citizens are equally protected under the law. Nobody gets special rights, which is what a "protected class" ostensibly grants. The existence of a "protected class" - in any respect - is the equivalent of saying "all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others". In practice, it explicitly prevents open criticism of a designated group of people, which is antithetical to the entire concept of the 14th Amendment as a whole.
I have my irks about Dylan but at the same time Dylan does not deserve the hate. And they keep riding on it to the point they would essentially be driving a person to suicide... They are hypocrites and they do not live the love they say they have.
Dylan is literally a troll and you can hear the inauthenticity whenever he speaks, but everyone wants to latch onto him and make him an icon because they’re brainwashed but I think he’s really sitting back and either laughing about it or freaking out because he’s gone too far to go back.
@Trout (the) Boneless what if the person who wrote the comment identifies as a female? Or just not a dude.... ur a bot stupid aren't u..... plus it isn't too far of a stretch as their name is literally olivia
Although your point is valid, to not see his behavior for what it is-purely pathological manipulation-rather devalues said point and him. He's made his money and created a brand, so he no longer finds it necessary to be a spectical for the mere sake of narcissistic attention. He gets no respect from me. He'll say anything to be relevant and liked.
Mulvaney is hated because de did mockery of women. She openly said extremely misogynistic phrases and pretended being a dumb bimbo as if that's the same as womanhood... It seems that she decided to left that extremely cringy phase, and I'm happy for that. But let's don't pretend her critics are irrational or hate her because of her transness or because she did a commercial or won some prices...she was hated before that. Those things only increased the fuel.
My problem with dylan is first he isnt opressed opressed people arent millionaires sry but he mocks women all women its like when people get upset over black face which i get makes sense while thats what dylan does to women acts like a little girl and is just totally disrespectful.
She's part of an oppressed group, would you say that black people aren't oppressed because there are black rich people? That's not how it works, she has become more popular despite her oppression. There are literally hundreds of antitrans bills being passed across the US right now, that are actively designed to harm and ruin the lives of trans people. If the government actively trying to make your life worse isn't oppression then what is? She is a woman, there's nothing wrong with being trans. What is wrong is being transphobic. How in the world can you compare black face to being trans, that's fucking disgusting? Blackface was a tool used by an oppressive class to humiliate and take advantage of black people. Trans people are an oppressed class who are literally born in the wrong body. And this is backed up by science, there's been significantly more studies on sexual dimorphism in the human body over the past couple decades. Did you know that one in 40 people are actually born intersex? We do not live as a perfect binary sexual species, it's just not true. Lots of brain scans done of trans people show that their brains are actually more similar to the gender they identify as in the gender they were born as. How do you know her experience when you aren't her? How many trans people have you genuinely tried to have a real constructive conversation with? How can you say that you know their struggle or what they've went through when you refuse to even see them as people? Also very gross of you, and obviously white woman by your profile picture to try and use the oppression of black people as an argument for transphobia. You need to take a step back and look at your life dude, because you are not a good person
@@reedoken6143 lgbt (you forgot the qia+) is a cult, not a community. And illegal aliens deserve to be oppressed, they're literally invading criminals. It's what the borders of all countries are supposed to be for until liberals take control of them...
Does noone not recognize how purely mysogynistic it is for a man to believe he can become or is a woman? And if gender truly is a spectrum why are there only 2 choices when they go for reassignment surgery? That people cant or dont see the irony in these things baffles me. The problem with dylan is that his gender identity is the only thing he has going for him. Hes been an attention seeker his entire life with acting and singing but none of that brought him/her the accolades he sought out so he decided to go thru his days of girlhood. And the fact that more women arent offended by his parody of what he believes women are supposed to be like shocks me. Im sorry but im not one that believes feeding someones mental illness is a good thing for them.
I’m pretty neutral to the matter of gender debate that being said Ive spoken to people who support Dylan and this is what I’ve gathered. from a supporters point of view its not a man in the first place since they believe their genuinely “stuck” in a man’s body. Secondly there *are* more than two choices in gender reassignment surgery but only trans men and trans women are interested in getting it, any other gender doesn’t want to change their sex. And the thing about Dylan being an attention seeker is that you don’t really lose anything from buying into it .
The problem is people like Dylan aren’t the oppressed ones, they are the oppressors. They have a whole month in celebration of them. They force people to adhere to their ideology, and if they don’t there’s a chance of being thrown in prison. If anyone speaks out about this, they are instantly canceled.
False. You will not be imprisoned for being a bigot towards them. They are oppressed by being told they shouldn't exist and literally have millions boycotted against a single person just being who they are without hurting anyone else.
@@RedFezLad Actually in Canada, it is now against the law to misgender someone and you can be thrown into jail for not following that sort of ideology. While it is not a law in the US yet, there have been instances where people have been thrown into jail just for calling someone the wrong pronouns. Also the boycott shows how the oppressed class feels when an insane ideology is forced unto them. People are finally starting to wake up and fighting back against the LGBTQ mafia.
The infamous "they" that haunts us all... "they" do not ALL believe these things. They are not all even really Trans.. Someone should not be calling you a Nazi because you disagree with something. But it does make you people just as much the hypocrites. You are not just disagreeing with something someone believes. You are disagreeing with their existence, no matter how much you try to downplay it. If you are Christian and someone disagrees with you thats one thing. But thinking you should not exist is the same damn thing..
@@singularitybound Incorrect. Most people don’t blame the trans person, but blame the perverts that sold them a lie. We don’t think that they shouldn’t exist, we pity them and their mistake to trust someone who wanted to make a quick buck. That being said, it would not matter so much to people if they weren’t having an entire ideology shoved in their faces. The beliefs of the minority are being forcibly pushed on the majority and that is making a lot of people angry.
the "controversy" surrounding Dylan Mulvaney is people being absolutey toxic about her identity. Trans people care about things other than gender- we always have. Its important to our community to see representation (even as far as advertizing goes, which is a soulless endeavor imo), but trans people have always cared about things that have nothing to do with their gender. The "criticism" of Dylan Mulvaney is absolutely unwarranted and hateful garbage.
Dylan just switched to his male state while recording that: logical, understanding and little to no emotions. I don’t want to watch the full video but it’s actually refreshing as you already said
Everything Dylan Mulvaney will ever do is all about gender he is literally the epitome of gender politics and ideology. It's impossible to be trans and not be involved in gender politics the moment someone gets trans surgery they become permanently inbeded in gender ideology and gender politics they literally become a walking controversy Dylan Mulvaney is pushing a woke gender ideology it doesn't matter how calm and collected he is he will always be known as the poster boy of gender ideology and gender politics how do you think transheuser Busch ended up in this situation because wokism a huge part of wokism is eugenics gender politics and gender ideology.
Insanity. All I do is go to work, spend time with my loved ones and friends, and nurture a musical hobby. Who I am doesn't change anything. I don't force some stupid ideology just by existing.
@@RSJ420 isn't it wierd how true it is though? Like to "affirm" your identity you trap yourself in gender politics forever when "affirming" is ment to free you or something
Dude your mask make me want to chew two packs of gum at once nonstop
Trans ppl are not nonsense, they’re real
They are people, theyre just not as they claim.
@Joe-pc3hs you have a bioessentalist world veiw. If you don't know what that means you don't have the requisite philosophical, sociological, psych, or bio knowledge to participate in conversations about sex, gender, or trans people. I'm begging you and every other random internet troll to just read a single book, Just one book before talking. Stop listening to political pundents say trans people believe and taking their word as gospel, if you're illiterate at least have an open and honest conversation with a trans person before you make claims about their claims.
Meanwhile on Facebook, there's a lot of "moral crusaders" who will lash out regardless of how nice the situation just because she's a trans person. How noble.
"criticism"
What did she do that was worthy of criticism? Should she be ashamed of making a TikTok with a bud light can?
H. I.m
So you're just going to ignore the fact that Dylan will be genetically male, not just now but long after he's dead? Dude, DNA is a thing, and it really fu*ks up your whole worldview. Maybe change????
My guy that's a guy, Don't feed into it's delusions
@imash3p him wake up
@@justagamethrower you say it. That’s disgusting, man. That’s a human being.
And we say “she” because she asks us to. If you want to choose to be a jerk, that’s your legal right, but you should evaluate that choice, because it isn’t a very good one.
“use your oppression to your advantage to grow whatever you can as virtue” dawg WHAT😭😭😭😭
Lol riiiightttt . He does call himself anti prophet so if the shoe fits
What's the issue?
Ikr. Like this guy is so dumb and sheep thinkers jus flock to him. He’s like lgbt but NOT lgbt. He’s right wing thinker but NOT EXACTLY like bro ok. Just cut the bs😂
Yeah, classic advice of "use your weakness and turn it into a strength"
The word ‘criticism’ implies that Dylan did something problematic. All they did was do a beer commercial.
Exactly. The issue is..my beer can't advertise with people who are unlike me.
I 100% agree, people were really upset that she got a can with her face on it. And they thought that Bud light was going to start forcing them to buy beer cans with her face, but Bud light literally sends a can with someone's face on it to everyone who joins their marketing campaigns? People will just take any excuse to be bigoted and transphobic. All of this "criticism"comes from bigoted transphobes who just want to complain that trans people exist. They are legitimately disgusted by the fact that a trans person has to do with a beer brand that they identify with. They are so sensitive and triggered that the mere existence of a trans person sends them into a flurry of hatred
So making a mockery of women and using "woman face" and doing days of GIRL hood and not womanhood and taking millions from brand deals as soon as you say you're a woman because you couldn't get clout as a man isn't problematic? I have no issues with trans adults. Dylan is not trans. He is a money hungry attention seeker
@@Nachofleas The entire point of her content was to show her journey of being trans. She is trans, she did not plan to become popular it just happened. If someone came to you because you were making content, and offered you brand deals of course you would take those brand deals because that's how life works. You need money to survive, and if your content is meaningful to trans people going through similar situations as you, and you can make that your full-time job then that's a good thing. You are being transphobic, first of all misgendering someone on purpose is pretty gross. Claiming that just because she makes money off of her content doesn't make her trans makes no sense. Because she was making this content well before she got popular just to share her life and her journey.
It isn’t wrong ro say criticism tho. Because there was.
He didn’t say it, but I think I figured out what he thinks. You know she didn’t do anything WRONG, right?
He*
@@roscoejones374 she** Dylan is a girl.
He*
He*
she**
Exactly the vast majority of people don’t really about gender. We just care about wtf you produce for society. There’s nothing more annoying that some that’s unproductive to society.
preach. ceos, landlords, and shareholders are the worst
@@reedoken6143 that's not what the people who hire them think.
@@reedoken6143 or rent from them.
Unless you're so repulsive that you have to use gender as an "in". There's no redemption in something so deceitful and wasteful.
@@rockerdude83 it doesn't bother you that the person you pay rent to is profiting off of your need for housing without contributing anything themselves?
It’s almost like……trans people are people
Then what do you think they are? Monekys?
@@MikoWhackingEi people act like trans people are subhuman
@@ParBar17I mean a lot of them are. I would say men who try to get into women’s spaces where they are extremely vulnerable is pretty scummy
@@Blappyboop do you think ppl are like Marching into women’s houses and saying they’re replacing them?
Can you explain to me how they’re replacing cis women if the amount of women in the world doesn’t go down? Who’s being replaced if girls continue to be born.
You make zero sense and are going based off of debunked claims.
You NEED to start doing research instead of just refusing to. You’d be surprised to know that maybe…just maybe…trans people are once again people and sometimes you guys don’t even realize they’re near you.
You’d be surprised how many people are genuinely surprised when I say I was born female.
Suck it lmao
@@Blappyboop "A lot of them are" people? Jesus fucking Christ, dude. Are you a Nazi? Do you ever consider what you write before you post it? Imagine yourself saying the same thing about any other group.
Jews? "A lot of them are".
Cops? "A lot of them are".
Christians? "A lot of them are".
I would recommend that you examine your world view if you don't believe that every single human being is a person, plural; "people". Everyone is "people"; not "a lot of them".
How can I contact you MJ Kuwait 🇰🇼.
I think he wears the mask because he's secretly a clone of Ryan Reynolds🤔
Most of the criticism of Dylan is basically being mad she’s doing what most women do at around 10 to 16. Getting caught up in stupid or silly ideas of what it means to be a woman. Sometimes wrong ideas!
We have no ducking clue either. We
Spend a stupid amount of time figuring it out and being over blown versions of adult women.
I find newly out transitioning women do the same. Their bodies are shifting, they’re awkward as they put on the trappings of womanhood while not being there physically.
It’s better to sit back and let them settle before being too critical. Cuz like teenagers they’re full of hormones and changes and not really ready for nuance.
Dylan is probably starting to settle down now. You can tell by her face filling out and softening that the hormones are doing their thing. It’s getting easier for her to “pass” and she probably feels less of the urge to Loudly define who she is as woman and go back to just, being a person who happens to be trans.
Dylan isn’t Really an activist. They’re a public figure who got a lot of attention for being an awkward newly transitioning woman.
I wish her luck on maintaining her career and getting away from the pearl clutchers.
Her figuring out her version of womanhood doesn’t threaten mine.
he* try again
@@justamf82 And what’s your excuse for acting like a petulant preteen who yells, “Gross!” whenever they encounter something they don’t understand?
He*
FFS do you realize how misogynistic your statement is against actual women. "Dylan is basically being mad she’s doing what most women do at around 10 to 16. Getting caught up in stupid or silly ideas of what it means to be a woman." Women know what they are. You have no idea what they go through at that age, where do you get off calling them silly and stupid. What's wrong about this is, people like you and Dylan assume they know. You cant assume anything. It is the ultimate form of misogyny and appropriation. Just like how I can't assume that I know what being Chinese is like, a man cant assume they know what being a women is like. It is not as simple as just a hormones.
Except that’s not a man
It's all part of them using us to collapse the market.
Accurate
@@patientlywatching7775 you look like an incel
Lol goofys that say they are going to boycott the stuff should just starve
@@tenouttatendoes3843 so people aren't allowed to vote with their wallets? Tell me you hate the free market without telling me 😂
@@JohnDoe-ks9xx wait what lol we got an extra goofy here the free market don't care about a hateful pos thats the point of it being free every company will support lgbt otherwise they get canceled by most moral people thats only right or you like segregation and other evil ideas huh?
Plot twist you are actually Dylan behind that dope mask of yours lol
Voice is too deep.
Both are men, so might be.
I can still see Dylan's mustache lmao
In 90% of the countries around the world? 😂
Yeah, the poorest people in America are still wealthier than the super super majority of people in this world.
@@babyvaso3855orrect.
I have traveled to 33 countries and lived in 7 and have seen real poverty. Americans have no clue what real poverty is.
Americans who make $5 an hour are richer than ever before than most of the world.
Are you phillpe de Franco ?
hey I'm a trans person and I just want to say that she personally makes me uncomfortable when she calls herself a girl rather than a woman. I understand that she didn't have a girlhood but she cannot be in her girlhood because she is a grown woman. I would feel just as weird as a grown woman who is not trans said they are in girlhood.
Snap out of your delusion
Women can call ourselves whatever we want. We were born, raised and lived our entire lives as female. No matter how hard they try trans women will never experience this and their attempts to replicate common female experiences is honestly offensive and disrespectful to real women. Dress however you want just live as a regular person stop trying to live as a stereotype. It’s like someone being transracial Black and wearing full blackface, then only eating fried chicken and watermelon, speaking in AAV slang and dressing like a 2000s gangster with their pants down
@@chedisalhi2382 touch grass instead of being hateful online
@@chedisalhi2382grow up
He*
Fact is you only use Dylan Mulvaney as a core example of the trans community? I don’t relate to her womanhood ideal whatsoever. A lot of us don’t neither do I claim I’m a real woman because I’m a trans woman. Two very different things. The way Dylan glamorises trans dumbs down the severity of gender dysphoria.
Wow, I'm usually not one that agrees with trans idealogy but it's so refreshing to see your POV and honestly, it's 100% a POV I can get behind. From my personal experience, most, if not all, trans people I've interacted with are quite extreme with their identity so it always ticked me the wrong way how they'd disenfranchise women by claiming womenhood.
@@insomniackiller1 I never claim I’m a real woman because that’s defeating the whole point of being a trans woman. Trans women need to own it instead of saying they are real women which is false. Which was the narrative in 2009 and on going until 2016 when trans politics started going haywire. And I don’t agree with all these words to describe biological women, like breast feeders etc it’s awful. There was such a thing as transfeminism but then trans women and trans activists started joining the new wave. And that’s ok, but isn’t it better to have your own movement?
That dude is a spook (D.M). He uses an @CAA email addy. CAA 🐇🕳
Do u have another platform ??? Where are your views!!
Me asking the same thing bc like tf
Yeah I wonder that too. Im new at this channel and as a non native speaker I'm stunned by his choice of idioms and vocabulary.
@@lalita9041 lol man you kids a simple. I remember the days when TH-camrs earned your subscription by making videos lingers then 2 minutes lmao
Who is Dylan Mulvaney?
It's a dude who think he's a woman and expects the world to accept it as a fact. Basically a slap in the face of every biological woman.
Is it really hot or are you Columbian?
If you hadn't put the mask on first you would have seen that you left at least two shirt buttons loose. Be more careful please.
The word "criticism" implies fhat she did something wrong worthy of, well, criticism. All she did was exist in this world and the "criticism" she just received was just plain old bigotry. You wouldn't call a racist rant about XYZ criticism, wouldn't you? Well, same shit here.
All these fence sitting vocabulary usually attracts the wrong kind of people
Do you think letters can experience racism or is that just a bad example you used? You people have become so insane that I honestly can't tell the difference anymore...
We got em'
You realize that he's obviously not fence sitting with all of what was said.
I am trans myself, and found nothing wrong with what he said.
People like you are the ones that make people think I'm gonna go postal for someone messing up on my pronouns. I don't care about my pronouns anyway. The fuck is the point? To have a label. Pretty sure I went through like a yearly lecture in school about how harmful putting so much stock into a label was.
I swear to God if you aren't trans yourself you're an even bigger part of the problem.
Yes had the exact same thought, it imples she did something wrong by just existing!
Preferences aren’t bigotry you twitter philosopher
Nothing wrong with voicing one's disapproval. Just like there's nothing wrong with a man who thinks he's a woman and vica versa.... Doesn't mean I have to agree or like that lifestyle
I'll wait till that content comes out ☠️
I watched a few videos and I like your general message...but why don't you button up your shirt my guy? lol
How did you get all those Dentyne Ice gum pieces?
Your lack is or cringe btw.
That dude is crazy
This dude looks like Pelosi on a bad day 😂
I think she’s cute.
You shouldn’t really insult people for their appearance though. Not a kind thing to do. Be better.
I personally don't think Dylan mulvaney is an artist I think if they were they be pushing more artistic abilities and not trans
As a man who identifies as non binary, I have mixed feelings, but props to you for giving respect where respect is due, I don't think people should make being gay their entire personality
@@Stradinaz_Dragon799 fr like please have any other hobby 😭
@@clintonsmith3953 I do have other hobbies. Drawing, playing games, writing stories. I just do this once in a while. Sorry if I scared you a little…
@@Stradinaz_Dragon799 what no I was just agreeing with you
@@clintonsmith3953 ohhh sorry I get confused easier than most people
Dylan isn’t even gay wtf are you on about?
I can see his mustache.
Oppressed? How much money did he make from that commercial?
Yo, do you not have chest hair? 😂 It looks very nice.
At least Dylan is maturing now. Dylan's statements from the early beginning of the "__ day of girhood" series had some terrible takes, such as "normalize the bulge" or Dylan sterotyping females like weak chicks who are always afraid of insects. I wish Dylan the best from diverging her content from making gender as the whole personality to more refreshing videos about what has got best out of herself.
He's a man tho
@@readysoldier6799Yup..!
Normalize the bulge!!!
And god forbid a woman fears bugs wtf
He is known for hamming-and-cheesing it up like Jack McFarland (Will & Grace)
I mean. There would be no platform of it wasn’t for being transgendered though…..we wouldn’t even know who this person is….so it’s hard to take it seriously if I’m honest.
I wouldn't know who she was if people didn't screech out over a 1 minute video on her channel with a beer can.
Didn't pan out so well for the dude. Did it dude?
Praising people for being calm under pressure can also be applied to Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini. It means nothing that he responded this way because a total sociopathic narcissist could do the exact same and that's who he is
I never cared if someone identifies as something else.
For all I care you could identify as a plant.
Just leave me out of it.
Just like everyone can choose whatever they believe, let me have the same.
I'm not going around yelling on the street or getting the media involved in my opinions.
Just live and let live.
Keep your opinions to yourselves.
Are you going to let others live when people are persecuting them?
Or are you going to stand up for their right to exist?
If you truly didn't care what people identify as, you'd be fighting for their rights
@@TroutBoneless as someone who truly does not care I absolutely am not going to fight for something.
Just as they have their rights to identity as they want, others have the right not to agree.
Sure violence is unnecessary, but wars have been fought over things that don't matter. It's human nature.
All I'm saying is just let it be.
Besides you have no idea on what point I stand. Because it shouldn't matter.
My opinion is my own. Everyone else's should be also.
The fact that you don't seem to understand that tells me your opinion on the subject.
Okay but here's the issue, there are people that are actively working to hurt and harm these people. Trans people are being attacked by not only bad people, but also the government. There are literally hundreds of antitrans bills being passed across the United States right now. By trying to remain unbiased you are allowing a minority group who is currently being attacked and having their lives ruined to be in danger. The least that people can do is say "people can identify as whatever they want, I don't care what people identify as. And they should be able to do that". This isn't just an opinion thing this is like a human rights issue. This would be like saying "I don't hate black people, I I think everybody should be allowed to live no matter what their skin color is. But don't get me involved in it, leave me alone and I'll leave you alone." During the civil Rights movement. Non-action equals siding with the oppressive side because only action can help these people.
All trans people want to do is live and let live. Why do we have to be outspoken and political? Because politicians and gamer podcasters make us that way by trying to eradicate us.
@@AudreysKitchen so that's why the a-z community need an entire month? Tv shows about drag queens?
Have rainbow sleeves on my frikkin coffee cup?
Massive miss from you bro. You made it seem like she did something wrong even though bud light reached out to her and she accepted the offer for money and to speak about her story. Because you said it was refreshing that she would make less gender related content and more artistic talent content, this implies that you believe it was "refreshing" that the transphobia towards her, because that was the criticism after all, changed the content she makes now
Matur Suksma
Yeah, ppl need to listen to Buck Angel and Marcus Dib before they call this Dylan ass-hat a “woman”. He’s just not. He’s not “trans”, he’s just a gay man, and he should stick with that. Even if you perceive one thing he says as positive, his actions and speeches and videos tell a very different story. He likes to get all “positive” and humble after he’s received backlash for insulting women, such as falling down in his “hiking heels” bc he was scared of a bug, and giggling like an idiot. Ppl think he’s “harmless”, but claiming to break free of “gender roles” and of gender itself, while simultaneously reinforcing the worst stereotypes about women, getting famous for it, and using his influence to encourage ppl to allow their children to go further with transitioning than he ever will (bc he’s a dude and doesn’t actually want to be a woman) is dangerous, it’s narcissistic, and it’s manipulative. I’ve got nothing for him. He can act humble and empathetic at key moments in order to shame his detractors all he wants, but his words and behaviors the other 99% of the time renders any attempt at appearing sincere, reasonable, and mature meaningless.
Hello as a gay man i really appreciate your acceptance but you must understand she hasnt really done anything wrong other then be herself the fact shes getting criticized shows we have alot further to grow as humans as we've always been on a sexual spectrum and we should know and accept that
He/Him/Himself*
CAPITALISM
Just an aside: I love your shirt.
Dylan Mulvaney also walk into women bathroom calmly.
I love your content. You make so much sense. You’d make an excellent coach or therapist.
Yes! This is what Dr. King always said, but he was talking about race. It should also apply to pretty much everything
Wow.
I find myself not-giving-a-fuck about people whom are simply seeking personal happiness. That's (whatever) god's will.
Even God himself.
Almost all have forgotten, "Judge not, lest ye be judged yourself. "
I have NO issue on trans folk. Do your want. Don't expect ME to conform to anything. You are you. Live that. Your life, not mine.
BL just bought into an unrequited dream, based on sponsorship alone. Hard card, but they asked to hit.
I mean a stopped clock is right twice a day
You need to sell these masks
This is unfortunate
So true
Why was the name Yahuah taken out of the scriptures over 7000x?
It’s simple- so that you wouldn’t know it.
For “everyone who calls on the Name of יהוה shall be saved.”
Romiyim (Romans) 10:13
‘And it shall be that everyone who calls on the Name of יהוה shall be saved.’
Ma`asei (Acts) 2:21
Pour out Your wrath on the nations Who have not known You, And on reigns that have not called on Your Name.
Tehillim (Psalms) 79:6
Help us, O Elohim of our deliverance, For the sake of the esteem of Your Name. And deliver us, and cover over our sins, For Your Name’s sake!
Tehillim (Psalms) 79:9
I can keep posting scripture about how Important Yahuah and Yahusha Ha Mashiac name is. you see those who don’t call a this name is cursed, those who call there is salvation and deliverance and blessings.
Name in Hebrew is
shêm, shame; a primitive word [perhaps rather from H7760 through the idea of definite and conspicuous position; compare H8064]; an appellation, as a mark or memorial of individuality; by implication honor, authority, character:-+ base, (in-) fame(-ous), named(-d), renown, report.
a name is a Mark, authority, and character of a person. The reason this is important because Yahuahs name encompasses his whole character through the scriptures. And a different name encompasses another character. Another Mark if you will.
lord, god and jesus are not innocent translations.
in TS 2009 ISR explanatory notes it explains
making these changes transgresses the command not to bring Yahuahs name to naught, and not to add to the Word, and not to have another mighty one against Yahuahs face.
-the name lord can be traced to the Roman house-diety , and further back to the name of an Etruscan sovereign, Larth. In antiquity sovereigns were
-the name god developed from a Germanic god wodenaz-gudenaz-guden-god.
-the name jesus can be traced to the diety of healing in Greek culture. iasous a female healing diety.
look at the scripture below the Greeks likened there deity’s to the Hebrews when they saw the power at work.
And when the crowds saw what Sha’ul had done, they lifted up their voices, saying in Lukaonian, “The mighty ones have become like men and come down to us!” And they called Barnaḇa Zeus, and Sha’ul Hermes, since he was the chief speaker. And the priest of Zeus, being in front of their city, brought oxen and wreaths to the gates, and wished to offer with the crowds. And when the emissaries Barnaḇa and Sha’ul heard this, they tore their garments and ran in among the crowd, crying out
Ma`asei (Acts) 14:11-14
I pray this information helps you as you seek the truth and continue to research these matters.
😴 Yawn.
bro how does this have anything to do with the video?
I haven't followed Dylan Mulvaney and I didn't know who she was until I heard about the bud light controversy so I can only speak for myself. I rarely spend my whole day thinking about my gender or how I feel about it. I do have a channel but my content is mostly about things i do and like in life. And bit of science and fixing my car, because it could help people that need to fix the same car I have. I think she could have a balance content. But in the end is up for her to decide what content she puts on her channel. And as trans person I would say that not every trans person need to have a channel where they talk about femmininity or unicorns and rainbows.
*he
I disagree. The problem with these so called oppressed groups are into victimization and being treated as special interest group with extra laws protecting them. They aren't asking to treated by content of their character, but based on their identity. 60 years ago a man had a speech he had a dream. Which moved Americans support civil rights. Whoever advocates socialism with govt power are dishonest and grifters.
You obviously have zero idea what you are talking about
Is it not oppression when the government tries to make your existence illegal?
@@TroutBoneless who's existence is the govt trying to erase? Specifically who.
@@joshhigdon4951 Transgender people
The thing is transgender people arent treated as a special interest group and as far as I know there are no extra laws protecting them (but you can cite some if there are), in fact transgender people are typically left out of laws protecting certain groups from different abuses and there have been over 550 proposed anti transgender bills so far this year🤷
Hes literally on the verge of losing his shtick. Patronizing womanhood and making a mockery of it has literally made him a millionaire. That livelihood is being threatened so he's shifting gears. Theres no talent no artistic expression to behold and there's certainly no maturity or conscientious approach he's trying to make here. He's simply trying to save his income stream. And if being oppressed gets me paid millions tell me where to sign.
Funny another example of a dude even thinking like a woman better than a woman. I do think his content should be age restricted hate me if you want
Dylan could have been doing this the whole time, except he just acted like a court jester fool for 3 years and made fun of women.
You're so based dude, subscribed
He is not an adult. He is an attention seeking actor. He didnt wait to think on his response. He waited until he knew what he was allowed to say.
fact’s
She is an adult, she responded to literal harassment campaigns by thousands of people, death threats, threats on her safety in a very calm and mature way that I don't think most people could. Why would you respond during the large heat of this whole controversy, when you didn't do anything wrong? She was approached by Bud light for a sponsorship, and then took the sponsorship. People got triggered because they are sensitive little snowflakes and can't deal with the fact that trans people exist and they like beer. This would be no different than boycotting a beer because they got a black person to do a sponsored segment. Don't be a transphobe, get better Josh
Probably he finally realized that the majority of population still see him as what he is a man lol so he got tired of appropriating women.
She is a woman, no reason to be transphobic
@@the7569 lol 😂 he is a man appropriating women.
@@the7569no he’s not in YOUR fantasy he’s a woman but in reality he’s a man
@@justamf82 actually no, she is trans. Have you ever actually communicated with like real trans people? Just like had like a mature discussion trying to understand other people? Because you know that scientifically there are medical differences between trans people and cis people right? There have been brain scans done that show that many many MTF trans people actually have brains more similar to cis females than cis males. Not to mention there are also over 40 ways to be classified as intersex. Gender is not this hard binary that we thought it was for so long. There are so many other creatures in nature that don't live by a hard sexual binary, and we are figuring out that humans are one of those creatures. There's no reason to be hateful to trans people and think that you know more than them. Are you a scientist? Are you a biologist? Are you trans? How many trans people have you interacted with in a way that wasn't just being mean to them? You literally have no idea what you were talking about. Transphobic people always try and use science or common sense, when in fact those things are disagreeing with you. You are wrong not only scientifically but also morally. Why do you get to choose and say what someone is? What gives you the authority that you are better than them? Because you're not
This is called backpedaling. He gained notoriety through the gender politics and now that he’s amassed a large following, he’s going to begin doing what he’s wanted to do all along, whatever that may entail.
Notoriety can be a one sided street. Nothing dylan did I woukd describe as notorious. Many people hate those that are gender non conforming. Says more about then amd their insecurities than dylan
@@amyh9512 you just said a whole lot of nothing and did not address my original point.
@TGCid01 there's no hardened rule about what is immune from critique.
@@amyh9512 more babble
I don't think this is inherently wrong. There are cases, like politicians, where backpedaling is indeed very damaging, because it results in changes to society that do not align with what the majority wanted.
However, for something like influencers, I would say it's completely fair game. If you amass a following through your gender, like Dylan, and then switch your content to something different, I would say it's an indication of talent if your brand survives the switch, since you're veering to something different from what your base audience would expect.
As a matter of fact, I would say this kind of backpedalling can sometimes be beneficial ; a content creator veering away from politicized content in a period where they aren't comfortable being a political icon is a good thing. Nobody who doesn't want to be involved in politics should be forced to.
Theyre not opressed, theyre the opressor
delusional
Oh yeah I'm being oppressed by trans people left and right 🙄 seriously what the hell are you talking about?!
@@arcsballss how
@@arcsballss Its always the ones with drawings on their pfp who say dumb stuff
trans community is definitely not the oppressor...
I personally don’t like the way Dylan stereotypes woman. But I don’t hate him. I don’t like several things he does or what he claims he is. I appreciate the way he’s handling this whole thing tho. I don’t agree with his politics or his beliefs. But he’s being mature about this at least, so I can respect him for that.
The 14th Amendment explicitly prevents the concept or creation of a "protected class".
Thought you might like to mention this at some point.
No it doesn't, it states. If your parents are American citizens, then you're an American citizen
Representative amounts are based on state population
People who commit treason aren't allowed to run for any office
And debts picked up from fighting rebellions can't be questioned and that the US has no obligation of paying pensions to those fought in a rebellion against the state or that occurred due to the lost of slaves.
@@cockmqn how is any of this relevant to the point I made?
The purpose and spirit of the 14th Amendment was, yes, to outline citizenship, but also by virtue of that to explicitly state that all citizens are equally protected under the law.
Nobody gets special rights, which is what a "protected class" ostensibly grants. The existence of a "protected class" - in any respect - is the equivalent of saying "all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others". In practice, it explicitly prevents open criticism of a designated group of people, which is antithetical to the entire concept of the 14th Amendment as a whole.
@@RighteousJ that's what the 14th amendment is
just manipulation to keep you on their tail
Hoodwinked
I have my irks about Dylan but at the same time Dylan does not deserve the hate. And they keep riding on it to the point they would essentially be driving a person to suicide... They are hypocrites and they do not live the love they say they have.
Nobody here talking about love bro😂if you say we don’t have it then ok? Bravo😂
You’re unaware of the evil behind this dude, and him creating content targeted at children. Don’t be evil
You've been deceived.
Dylan is literally a troll and you can hear the inauthenticity whenever he speaks, but everyone wants to latch onto him and make him an icon because they’re brainwashed but I think he’s really sitting back and either laughing about it or freaking out because he’s gone too far to go back.
How do you know?
SHE
Her*
Hey man, do you insist on being a jerk, my dude?
Your the troll here your existence is just to hate we don't need you, your brainwashed
@Trout (the) Boneless what if the person who wrote the comment identifies as a female? Or just not a dude.... ur a bot stupid aren't u..... plus it isn't too far of a stretch as their name is literally olivia
Although your point is valid, to not see his behavior for what it is-purely pathological manipulation-rather devalues said point and him. He's made his money and created a brand, so he no longer finds it necessary to be a spectical for the mere sake of narcissistic attention. He gets no respect from me. He'll say anything to be relevant and liked.
Mulvaney is hated because de did mockery of women. She openly said extremely misogynistic phrases and pretended being a dumb bimbo as if that's the same as womanhood...
It seems that she decided to left that extremely cringy phase, and I'm happy for that. But let's don't pretend her critics are irrational or hate her because of her transness or because she did a commercial or won some prices...she was hated before that. Those things only increased the fuel.
He*
Being a woman is not an idea in a man's head, however different from male norms he may be. He will never be a she
Oppressed class? Your one of those people. prove the oppression
My problem with dylan is first he isnt opressed opressed people arent millionaires sry but he mocks women all women its like when people get upset over black face which i get makes sense while thats what dylan does to women acts like a little girl and is just totally disrespectful.
*she
Your comment shows that SHE is absolutely oppressed. You are actually denying her right to exist.
@@Johnspartan296he* wake up
@@TroutBonelesshe* wake up
She's part of an oppressed group, would you say that black people aren't oppressed because there are black rich people? That's not how it works, she has become more popular despite her oppression. There are literally hundreds of antitrans bills being passed across the US right now, that are actively designed to harm and ruin the lives of trans people. If the government actively trying to make your life worse isn't oppression then what is? She is a woman, there's nothing wrong with being trans. What is wrong is being transphobic. How in the world can you compare black face to being trans, that's fucking disgusting? Blackface was a tool used by an oppressive class to humiliate and take advantage of black people. Trans people are an oppressed class who are literally born in the wrong body. And this is backed up by science, there's been significantly more studies on sexual dimorphism in the human body over the past couple decades. Did you know that one in 40 people are actually born intersex? We do not live as a perfect binary sexual species, it's just not true. Lots of brain scans done of trans people show that their brains are actually more similar to the gender they identify as in the gender they were born as. How do you know her experience when you aren't her? How many trans people have you genuinely tried to have a real constructive conversation with? How can you say that you know their struggle or what they've went through when you refuse to even see them as people? Also very gross of you, and obviously white woman by your profile picture to try and use the oppression of black people as an argument for transphobia. You need to take a step back and look at your life dude, because you are not a good person
It's like his surgery is slowing reversing back to a man
Is looking very different lol
Nothing like a little sexism to help out
Hey! Wassup Andrew Tate? 😅
He’s nothing like Andrew Tate
That's what I did. I have a lifetime of oppression from Christianism, and I used my own benefit and grew from it.
...oh boy this guy is a shill.
Dillon is a mental mess...let's be honest
There’s not a single sole in todays society that’s oppressed if you live in the US
Poor people are because USA has the worst Healthcare system ever
??? POC, lgbtq community, undocumented immigrants, working class
@@reedoken6143
Them too ofcourse.
@@reedoken6143 yes, they aren't oppressed
@@reedoken6143 lgbt (you forgot the qia+) is a cult, not a community. And illegal aliens deserve to be oppressed, they're literally invading criminals. It's what the borders of all countries are supposed to be for until liberals take control of them...
He might have to change his name first.
She did change her name
@the7569 he try again
🤣
Dylan is now magically attracted to women...🙄 he's an insult to REAL women
@@imash3p 😄😄😄. Sorry if your feefees gor hurt.
Because real women are never attracted to women
You're able to see somebody point when he/she is on point. You're the king man.
He*
Ok but why is your shirt open like that? It’s distracting. Just stop.
Just don’t fucking look, simple
m
Does noone not recognize how purely mysogynistic it is for a man to believe he can become or is a woman? And if gender truly is a spectrum why are there only 2 choices when they go for reassignment surgery? That people cant or dont see the irony in these things baffles me. The problem with dylan is that his gender identity is the only thing he has going for him. Hes been an attention seeker his entire life with acting and singing but none of that brought him/her the accolades he sought out so he decided to go thru his days of girlhood. And the fact that more women arent offended by his parody of what he believes women are supposed to be like shocks me. Im sorry but im not one that believes feeding someones mental illness is a good thing for them.
I’m pretty neutral to the matter of gender debate that being said Ive spoken to people who support Dylan and this is what I’ve gathered. from a supporters point of view its not a man in the first place since they believe their genuinely “stuck” in a man’s body. Secondly there *are* more than two choices in gender reassignment surgery but only trans men and trans women are interested in getting it, any other gender doesn’t want to change their sex.
And the thing about Dylan being an attention seeker is that you don’t really lose anything from buying into it .
The problem is people like Dylan aren’t the oppressed ones, they are the oppressors. They have a whole month in celebration of them. They force people to adhere to their ideology, and if they don’t there’s a chance of being thrown in prison. If anyone speaks out about this, they are instantly canceled.
False. You will not be imprisoned for being a bigot towards them. They are oppressed by being told they shouldn't exist and literally have millions boycotted against a single person just being who they are without hurting anyone else.
@@RedFezLad Actually in Canada, it is now against the law to misgender someone and you can be thrown into jail for not following that sort of ideology. While it is not a law in the US yet, there have been instances where people have been thrown into jail just for calling someone the wrong pronouns. Also the boycott shows how the oppressed class feels when an insane ideology is forced unto them. People are finally starting to wake up and fighting back against the LGBTQ mafia.
The infamous "they" that haunts us all... "they" do not ALL believe these things. They are not all even really Trans.. Someone should not be calling you a Nazi because you disagree with something. But it does make you people just as much the hypocrites. You are not just disagreeing with something someone believes. You are disagreeing with their existence, no matter how much you try to downplay it. If you are Christian and someone disagrees with you thats one thing. But thinking you should not exist is the same damn thing..
@@singularitybound Incorrect. Most people don’t blame the trans person, but blame the perverts that sold them a lie. We don’t think that they shouldn’t exist, we pity them and their mistake to trust someone who wanted to make a quick buck. That being said, it would not matter so much to people if they weren’t having an entire ideology shoved in their faces. The beliefs of the minority are being forcibly pushed on the majority and that is making a lot of people angry.
No one is getting thrown in jail for missgendering someone. You just want to be a victim, when in reality gay and trans folk face persecution everyday
the "controversy" surrounding Dylan Mulvaney is people being absolutey toxic about her identity. Trans people care about things other than gender- we always have. Its important to our community to see representation (even as far as advertizing goes, which is a soulless endeavor imo), but trans people have always cared about things that have nothing to do with their gender. The "criticism" of Dylan Mulvaney is absolutely unwarranted and hateful garbage.
Dylan's entire schtick is gender.
Oppression doesn’t discriminate.
Dylan needs to take a trip to Saudi Arabia to visit some rooftops.
I agree w everything that u just said, tho if you want to be more credible/believable, better button up that shirt
Well, I'll respect her pronouns for that. I'm an individualiat. I dwcide ro respect people and be curious to them based on if they deserve it.
Dylan just switched to his male state while recording that: logical, understanding and little to no emotions. I don’t want to watch the full video but it’s actually refreshing as you already said
He's not oppressed,he's an actor!!
.....sorry but trans ainr bein oppress.
Everything Dylan Mulvaney will ever do is all about gender he is literally the epitome of gender politics and ideology. It's impossible to be trans and not be involved in gender politics the moment someone gets trans surgery they become permanently inbeded in gender ideology and gender politics they literally become a walking controversy Dylan Mulvaney is pushing a woke gender ideology it doesn't matter how calm and collected he is he will always be known as the poster boy of gender ideology and gender politics how do you think transheuser Busch ended up in this situation because wokism a huge part of wokism is eugenics gender politics and gender ideology.
To be fair blaire white is trans and she isn't woke but I suppose she still talks about gender quite a bit
@@arieltal222 well for the most part you did make my point
Insanity. All I do is go to work, spend time with my loved ones and friends, and nurture a musical hobby. Who I am doesn't change anything. I don't force some stupid ideology just by existing.
@@RSJ420 isn't it wierd how true it is though? Like to "affirm" your identity you trap yourself in gender politics forever when "affirming" is ment to free you or something
@@ziabasu4169 maybe you don't and thats great i respect you but there is people who claim to be trans who do and thats what people don't like