2:32 Is incredible because the "Mr Moon voice" goes out and you can hear Joe I see it like whoever the kid is asking what the sky is, is changing his voice so the kid sees it as the moon But he's not the moon, he's someone whos trying to explain the kid what life is and giving them a much more innocent and pretty perspective
It feels like you just took a fresh batch of cookies out of the oven. It's perfect, and you couldn't do any better with it. However that's probably how the band felt but also kinda how I feel if that makes sense
The 2008 seems to be a bit more polished than this one. They re-recorded the drums for the 2008 version. This version has some delay effect on the vocals in the beginning while the 2008 version does not. Rob’s and Zubin’s harmony vocals are a bit louder than the 2008 version as well. Mr. Moon’s doubles tracked vocals are panned both on the left and right each. Just some differences I’ve noticed.
I hope tally hall makes a deluxe version of Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum with the 2005 and 2008 versions of the album. I'd buy that on the spot.
@@Pokedude1110 marvins was not rereleased, it was only repressed on vinyl and other physical media. + what single? just a friend? (which was recorded in 2009 iirc)
I love you Joe Hawley, you didnt just gave me the beautiful Hawaii Part II album but also this equally beautiful song. May the universe bless your soul ❤️
I always thought of both versions of this song of a nursery rhyme. Sung to kids. Maybe a teacher getting too carried away singing about nature and it's qualities.
I've been playing the two side by side for a few minutes now trying to find out if they're the same. I don't think they are? Drums sound different, vocals sound layered differently.
Ok, found something. Compare the 2:40 part, the "Well I think you return to obscure" bit, on this to the album/Amazon version. The left channel is completely low and the right channel is completely high on this one, but they're panned less and blended a bit on Amazon. Also, listening to just the left channel/bass voice alone is an EXPERIENCE.
One time, I tried to sing About spring and a storm But you know How it goes Blah blah blah blah Blah blah blah blah Blah All along Won't you please stop complaining I'm playing a song But all the rain comes down the same Falling to from where it came On the ground then back around Up in the sky I wish you could have heard the music When the clouds growled overhead I finally felt enthusiastic I finally felt alive Blah blah blah blah Blah blah blah blah Blah So you said Would it please you to listen To thunder instead Man the rain came down that day And it drained my soul away And I wondered why I even Bothered to try Mr. Moon (yeah?) Tell us about the sky The sky is deep and dark and eternally high Many people think that's where you go when you die Do you? Well, I think you return to obscure Or wherever you were Before you were But I won't let you lose yourself In the rain We have so much left to sing There's a storm for every spring All you see and you and me Became from a star You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star You're a star Yes, you are Silent explosive and Silent explosive and Silent explosive and Silent explosive and Create until nothing is left to create and The universe bursts with an overworked sigh then Pretend to pretend to re-crown the creation and Sing the same thing 'til the clouds start to cry and then Over and over and over again and then Over and over and Never again
Song actually makes me think of a bitter-sweet relationship. I never realized how happy i made her and i never forgot how much i let her down too. I have too much empathy for my logic.
I have a feeling this song is about two people the narrator and another guy. The narrator tries to make the other guy listen but fails the first time, then has to tell the other guy buy yelling or being aggressive. With him repeating blablablablablablabla. Like the other person is mocking the narrator, then telling the other guy to stop complaining about him talking. Then resorting to aggressively telling him to listen. "Would it please you to listen, to thunder instead." Basically meaning the other guy would listen if he said it by screaming or having an aggressive tone. It's sad how true this is and how it applies to situations IRL like consent and stuff
@@Fentdawg420 lmao this PanzerDragon dude is a really racist confederate that my friend met in a discord server a month or two ago. i just thought it was really funny that i ran into him on the comments of a random tally hall video sdjkghs
If you listen to the Mr. moon part, in which he explains what he thinks the sky is, with headphones on, you can hear the treble and bass vocals split
Omg yea
That's all the vocals
Kinda wish they left that part on the remastered version tbh, that was great
@@skelly1004 pretty sure they did
@@Kuriboh1008 no they didnt cuz you cant hear the split. the vocals are just layered on top of each other on both sides, but it isnt split.
This version sounds a bit more remastered, like I'm in the room with the band. Such a calming and joyful song.
Dont you dare ruin my song I'll be so sad
Please?
Aero Aux wait what?
Aero Aux what??
jesus what happened in here?
One of my favorite tally hall songs, it feels like a strange nursery rhyme with the moon part
i mean well they did write songs for disney
@@viyetch what😭😭
Tally Hall wrote songs for Disney via Happy Monster Band
And now Rob works for Disney jr
2:32 Is incredible because the "Mr Moon voice" goes out and you can hear Joe
I see it like whoever the kid is asking what the sky is, is changing his voice so the kid sees it as the moon
But he's not the moon, he's someone whos trying to explain the kid what life is and giving them a much more innocent and pretty perspective
Is it just me or does this one sound _crisp_
it kinda does
It feels like you just took a fresh batch of cookies out of the oven. It's perfect, and you couldn't do any better with it. However that's probably how the band felt but also kinda how I feel if that makes sense
The 2008 seems to be a bit more polished than this one. They re-recorded the drums for the 2008 version. This version has some delay effect on the vocals in the beginning while the 2008 version does not. Rob’s and Zubin’s harmony vocals are a bit louder than the 2008 version as well. Mr. Moon’s doubles tracked vocals are panned both on the left and right each. Just some differences I’ve noticed.
That’s a good way to describe 2008 over all: a bit more polished than 2005
rob said this is the first ever tally hall version of this song
(just adding on to what you said)
Everyone seems to neglect the slight echo/doubling in parts of this
Cormorant Colors it’s part of the reason why I enjoy the song :)
Michael Alexander I like it too. People who talk about the difference between this and the album version never talk about it ;-;
Sometimes a try to sign ***pssht***
Glad I found this version. Definitely one of my favorite tally hall songs, and this one sounds more organic
This scratches the itch in my brain
Mr Moon may be time itself, the character from Ruler of Everything. A wise, friendly being. Just don't take advantage of it.
interesting
Holy shit, that's a great theory.
Yeah, same type of voice too
always thought it was a guy called moon-face from The faraway tree.
My headcanon is MMMM is a connected universe itself just like Hawaii part II. Probably not true AT ALL lmao but I want to believe it
I hope tally hall makes a deluxe version of Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum with the 2005 and 2008 versions of the album. I'd buy that on the spot.
they’re not doin anything anymore lmao
@@jmo_real they literally rereleased Marvin's a few months ago with a new single
@@Pokedude1110 marvins was not rereleased, it was only repressed on vinyl and other physical media. + what single? just a friend? (which was recorded in 2009 iirc)
@@daeskiz4031 it's technically a rerelease, since it has more songs than 2008, and the fact it's getting a re-press for the first time in 13 years
@@Pokedude1110 what songs were added that aren’t on the 2008 version?
The subtle lyric changes in this song between the demo is incredible ❤
no way I found the person who comments on every tally hall related post 😱
All that sounds different is the drums and guitar wasnt as loud, regardless still my favorite Tally Hall song
Nick Fioravanti honestly i cant say which I prefer
Joe sounds like he’s running out of air too
I love you Joe Hawley, you didnt just gave me the beautiful Hawaii Part II album but also this equally beautiful song. May the universe bless your soul ❤️
yikes
Me when my idol is a groomer:
Aged well
_"Should we tell him?"_
Zoinks!
wow, the sing barely changed but yet, the song sounds so different
Category: Gaming
WHATS UP GAMERS WELCOME TO ANOTHER MINECRAFT LETSPLAY
@@user-gz2hy2wu5g when's episode 2?
Still waiting
@@user-gz2hy2wu5g we're both waiting for episode 2. please release it.
@@user-gz2hy2wu5g Dude it's been 8 months, where episode 2? :/
It’s beautiful. I think I like this one more than the official release.
Edit: changed original to official release
"The original" refering to the one released later?
@@ltloxa1159 sorry I’m dumb
I always thought of both versions of this song of a nursery rhyme. Sung to kids. Maybe a teacher getting too carried away singing about nature and it's qualities.
I’m glad this is the Amazon music version
I've been playing the two side by side for a few minutes now trying to find out if they're the same. I don't think they are? Drums sound different, vocals sound layered differently.
Ok, found something. Compare the 2:40 part, the "Well I think you return to obscure" bit, on this to the album/Amazon version. The left channel is completely low and the right channel is completely high on this one, but they're panned less and blended a bit on Amazon.
Also, listening to just the left channel/bass voice alone is an EXPERIENCE.
this song just breaks me for some reason. i don’t know why
This song brings me so hope in my life, I don't know why but the lyrics and instruments give me so much happiness
One time, I tried to sing
About spring and a storm
But you know
How it goes
Blah blah blah blah
Blah blah blah blah
Blah
All along
Won't you please stop complaining
I'm playing a song
But all the rain comes down the same
Falling to from where it came
On the ground then back around
Up in the sky
I wish you could have heard the music
When the clouds growled overhead
I finally felt enthusiastic
I finally felt alive
Blah blah blah blah
Blah blah blah blah
Blah
So you said
Would it please you to listen
To thunder instead
Man the rain came down that day
And it drained my soul away
And I wondered why I even
Bothered to try
Mr. Moon (yeah?)
Tell us about the sky
The sky is deep and dark and eternally high
Many people think that's where you go when you die
Do you?
Well, I think you return to obscure
Or wherever you were
Before you were
But I won't let you lose yourself
In the rain
We have so much left to sing
There's a storm for every spring
All you see and you and me
Became from a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
You're a star
Yes, you are
Silent explosive and
Silent explosive and
Silent explosive and
Silent explosive and
Create until nothing is left to create and
The universe bursts with an overworked sigh then
Pretend to pretend to re-crown the creation and
Sing the same thing 'til the clouds start to cry and then
Over and over and over again and then
Over and over and
Never again
Hey I know this might sound strange but thanks Jenny truly thanks for putting this up
BANGERS ONLY
BANGERS
@@viyetch omg it tally hal
@@shrimpypyeah ok
The drums are much rougher in this version but I’m surprised at how little else is changed really
0:00 to 4:43 is fire
i love these versions so much more compared to the 2008 versions
Song actually makes me think of a bitter-sweet relationship. I never realized how happy i made her and i never forgot how much i let her down too. I have too much empathy for my logic.
this is my favorite song even still
OMG WITH HEADPHONES ITS SO GOOD 😍😍😍
"Mr. Moon" aged well
I can't stop thinking of the rizzed up moon meme
I’m glad I don’t know what this means
i genuinely misread 2005 Version as GOOD Version
Because it is
I just realized why it sounded different 😭
i think i like this a bit more than the 2008 version tbh
Yes.
Thanks
Haven’t heard this song in a minute
because it’s been 2 years since you commented this i’m bringing you back to this song again 2 years later with this reply… your welcome
SPOON
WHAT A FAMCY SPOOK THEYLL SAY!
This feels c r i s p
Why does this sound better?
Probably because it sounds less edited
you alive?
@@A_Profilewhat does bro want from him
@@tobyisawesome to know is man is alive 5 years later
hi jenny ^.^
Hi Kayla :)
Mister Moon! Tell us about the Sky!
The sky is deep, dark and eternally high...
Many people think that's where you go when you die...
@@rockstarbonett886 do you?
@@cheerio4000 Well I think you return to obscure
Or wherever you were, before you were
But I won't let you loose yourself in the rain
@@rockstarbonett886 We have so much left to sing
@@pancakes4795 There's a storm for every spring
I think I prefer the studio one tbh
Honestly I like them both I can’t decide, this one sounds more like a carnival
so pretty :D
Just came back from the demo(s) and I forgot they changed the key :(
This version sounds like McDonald's sprite
i smell acapella
@💙 Niah 💙 bananas and rain
5
4
3
2
1
0
I have a feeling this song is about two people the narrator and another guy. The narrator tries to make the other guy listen but fails the first time, then has to tell the other guy buy yelling or being aggressive. With him repeating blablablablablablabla. Like the other person is mocking the narrator, then telling the other guy to stop complaining about him talking. Then resorting to aggressively telling him to listen. "Would it please you to listen, to thunder instead." Basically meaning the other guy would listen if he said it by screaming or having an aggressive tone. It's sad how true this is and how it applies to situations IRL like consent and stuff
Literaly the same.
the drums aren't as loud and it sounds mellower. more balanced.
Oof lmao don't pay attention to the deleted comment if you saw it. Thought I was on the demo version.
Woah crazy! you're the racist confederate that said that N-word and denied genocide! small world, isn't it? From Ford's Discord, right?
@@maybesmusic223 what
@@Fentdawg420 lmao this PanzerDragon dude is a really racist confederate that my friend met in a discord server a month or two ago. i just thought it was really funny that i ran into him on the comments of a random tally hall video sdjkghs
i miss her
It's OK bro
Who is her 👁️👄👁️
Just came back from the demo(s) and I forgot they changed the key :(