Holy crap this is such a bop compared to the new one I like the new one for the...uh...snappiness? It’s just really classy somehow, whereas this one is a bit frantic.
I like the drum in the background, idk why. It's just- I love 2005 versions they're just so "raw" I guess I'll say? I really love both versions of all of these songs, and it's somewhat refreshing to hear different versions that aren't specifically covers, just older versions/drafts. New and old, both great in their own ways.
i discovered the 2005 variants of these songs because i clicked on some download link for mmmm and the feeling of knowing it's the same song but so slightly off was so off putting. i even showed my sister who likes tally hall and she didnt notice the difference, i felt like i was in the twilight zone
I really like both versions, in the regular version they seem to be trying to hide a terrible meaning in a harmless song, but here it’s just very cruel and aggressive, masterpieces!
These were the og tally hall songs on youtube like 10 years ago. Older versions of greener, two wuv, ruler of everything, playing in the sand, uhhh and the whole marvins basically. The only remastered them, or i guess actually released the album from a legit stuido, a few years
imo I feel like the rerelease kinda nailed the atmosphere/intent of the lyrics while the original has way more character and soul, I like them both a lot
@@perfidiousprophet that's awesome!! i've p much finished mine (after listening and watching MANY live performances to see what Zubin does!) but it'd be cool to see urs
i think this one and the newer one are both really good. they both have something special about them! The newer one is more classy, less rock and roll and slower which is cool, whereas this one is faster and kind of rap-like and faster and frantic/desperate energetic. Both of them have there own vibe and feel and i can appreciate both of them
I like the newer version better I feel this one is too fast, almost like they were in a rush to sing it is one way to describe it Don’t get me wrong, this version is great too, I just like the newer one because of the way the music changes and how dramatic it sounds. You can kinda get a sense of each narrator’s personality, or at least I feel like that. With this one it feels like one person rather than multiple but that’s just an opinion of mine :)
just some things i notice here: voice isn't as deep honestly seems more faster pace or has kinda an extra beat a few extra oo-oo-oo's in the background at 0:42 to 0:51 1:36 to 1:39 the "going twice going thrice" kinda has an extra voice, idk how 2 explain 1:50 the background voice that said "dont shop around" is a lil quieter, along with a more noticeable guitar 2:10 the extra voice sounds a lil more robotic? idk if thats the word but ye
yknow I first came to this version of The Bidding not really liking it for how clunky and disjointed it is compared to the 2008 re-record. I've come to appreciate it way more not just for how aggressive and simple it feels, but also for just how RAW it is. It has so much more passion and feel than the 2008 version, and just feels like a silly band having silly fun. I love that so much
This may sound weird, but comparing this to the newer one, it gives Kids Bop energy in the first part. It’s all just a certain upbeat, it sorta loses that Kids Bop vibe later on.
Any physical release of MMMM after 2005 and before 2008 should have these versions, sadly I don't think you can officially purchase them digitally anymore
My theory is that each verse of this song presents a different guy trying to date . "I've been sleeping in a cardboard box Spending every dollar at the liquor shop And even though I know I haven't got a lot I'll try to give you love until the day you drop." (The Alcoholic guy) "I've been training like a Pavlov dog Let my independence out to take a hike All you got to do is activate my bell And I'll fetch you anything you like" (The needy, over giving guy/aka a Simp) "I've been in like a thousand times Dated every woman in the atmosphere I've been to every continent Broken all the hearts in every hemisphere And if I'm not the type of guy you like to circumvent Just remember not to love me when I disappear" (The player/Pick up artist) "I graduated at the top I like to take advantage of the bourgeoisie So if you have a fantasy of being a queen Maybe you should blow a couple bucks on me" (highly educated guys/CEO/ very wealthy and successful) At the end the "he's sold" at the end represents the "Mr. Right/perfect" man who is already taken.
is it just me or was there a slide whistle playing n the background at 0:59 when they say "SOLD!". ive checked every version of the bidding and there is no slide whistle. only an electric guitar.
Честно, я бы предпочла эту версию из-за ритма, скорости и общего настроя, мне нравится тут абсолютно всё, хоть убейте, но по моему мнению это гораздо круче.
Just a rerelease. If you're wanting some more Tally content, I suggest searching "We Think We're Playing in a Band," it's a tribute album which features covers by several people who worked on Tally Hall related content, such as Casey Shea and Courtney Flynn from the Good & Evil tour and Minimall who were featured in Joe's solo album Joe Hawley Joe Hawley.
i had to stop the video as soon as they started singing because ive heard the newer version so many times i thought i was having a stroke
lol
666 likes for you my fella!!
no cus same?!
i love this version and the pingry EP version more than the 2008 release
awesome
bom bom bom bom
Holy crap this is such a bop compared to the new one
I like the new one for the...uh...snappiness? It’s just really classy somehow, whereas this one is a bit frantic.
I could not agree more
couldn’t agree any more abbacchio :D
You're right Abbacchio
@Mairead O'Connor AKA Mo Hello. I see you also appreciate good songs. And good... Series...
I agree fellow donut friend
i think the reason this is more "boppy" is because it's (pretty sure) in swing rythm, and the drums sound jazzier.
The later release of the song is in the same light swing rhythm, but the faster speed and extra drums just make it much more pronounced in this one
This version is so much more aggressive and I love that
yea
yea
yea
yea
yea
I like the drum in the background, idk why. It's just- I love 2005 versions they're just so "raw" I guess I'll say? I really love both versions of all of these songs, and it's somewhat refreshing to hear different versions that aren't specifically covers, just older versions/drafts. New and old, both great in their own ways.
try the pingry ep ones
they are GREAT
@@SpilledSprite They are!! thanks for the recommendation
@@shnoly23 No problem! :)
*so, yah like it raw, eh?*
@@EyeSky420 yes it is, "fat text" user.
the 2005 versions of the MMMM songs feel like the rerelease in a fever dream and i kinda like it better
i discovered the 2005 variants of these songs because i clicked on some download link for mmmm and the feeling of knowing it's the same song but so slightly off was so off putting. i even showed my sister who likes tally hall and she didnt notice the difference, i felt like i was in the twilight zone
@@AIIied.Mastercomputer so you were *out in the twilight* right?
this song is a tally hall refrence (they say MMMM at the beginning and MMMM is their first album (real))
no way
Technically complete demos would be there first album and party boobytrap would be there first ep
@@CatOnVenus183 fair enough
😧😧😧😧😧😧😧😧😧😧😧
The mixing is better on the re-release, but the "I'll promise..." part on this one sounds much heavier and cooler.
Agreed. I prefer the 2008 version's first half, but damn I love the second half on this one way more.
1:42 I don’t know how to explain how this sounds other then it sounds like an English opening for an anime from the early 2000’s
i hear it too lol
Guitar and drumset
one of those Disney channel shows
@@thedeliveryboy1123 that too
it sounds like this song is a punk rock song for me.
I love this version much more than the other, very catchy and enthusiastic.
the fuck i wouldnt have blocked you on discord back then if i had known you liked tally hall lmfao
@@BoyusGoyus lmaoo
@@honey-snap now add me or i will replace everything in your house with an exact replica of itself
@@Sylvan531 ditto
This song feels more like it's a cover from a movie soundtrack
I really like both versions, in the regular version they seem to be trying to hide a terrible meaning in a harmless song, but here it’s just very cruel and aggressive, masterpieces!
I'm going to tell my kids this was weezer
As you should 🙏
is it not?
Gonna tell my kids this was gorrilaz
It was part of the red/yellow/green/blue/grey album I think
Ruler of sweaters
Woa. Didn’t even know they had two versions. I’m a fake fan lmao.
theres 3 i think
These were the og tally hall songs on youtube like 10 years ago. Older versions of greener, two wuv, ruler of everything, playing in the sand, uhhh and the whole marvins basically. The only remastered them, or i guess actually released the album from a legit stuido, a few years
you don’t have to know every single version of every song to be a true fan!
no such thing as a fake fan! enjoy what you know!
@@phoneyogurt all of you are fake fans smh
you're only a true fan if you
1. have spinning blades
2. blow air
3. actually work as intended
imo I feel like the rerelease kinda nailed the atmosphere/intent of the lyrics while the original has way more character and soul, I like them both a lot
I totally agree!
Sounds like the bidding. Incredible!
It do be
It IS The Bidding.
@@devlindecker sounds just like it
@@emdicadrian huh
sir calm down i can hear the passive aggressiveness
@@emdicadrian I bet you're so fucking special for being an old tally hall fan. good on you, fucker
The Bassline is hella rad
definitely! i'm tryna make it into a tab for myself lol
@@noromantichero I'm making one, too :0
@@perfidiousprophet that's awesome!! i've p much finished mine (after listening and watching MANY live performances to see what Zubin does!) but it'd be cool to see urs
@@noromantichero hey, that's really cool :0 I'm learning mine by ear. Do you plan on posting the tabs anywhere?
can someone hand them tabs over? i’m a little stupid to find them out myself
i think this one and the newer one are both really good. they both have something special about them! The newer one is more classy, less rock and roll and slower which is cool, whereas this one is faster and kind of rap-like and faster and frantic/desperate energetic. Both of them have there own vibe and feel and i can appreciate both of them
That part at 1:41 tho
That part definitely goes a lot better with this version
i wholeheartedly agree bestie !
Honestly the reason i listen to this song. it's so satisfying.
The 2005 versions of these songs makes me want to buy both versions
life advice: do
BHORGEWAZZE BUTTON 1:19
Thank you random stranger
This is my favourite version of this song. I'm glad someone uploaded it to TH-cam. Thanks!
TheDiMono No problem! And remember to support Tally Hall itunes.apple.com/us/artist/tally-hall/id121984328
@@JennyYesac I don't have iTunes, I use Android
@@kaijoswilman same
@@kaijoswilman they're on Spotify as well
@@darthrader1068 they're on spotify
This sounds like if The Bidding was released on Good & Evil
the bidding 2005 my beloved
sooo true
hello fellow the bidding 2005 version enjoyers!
hii :D
Hey there
hey
Yo.
Wassup
I like the newer version better
I feel this one is too fast, almost like they were in a rush to sing it is one way to describe it
Don’t get me wrong, this version is great too, I just like the newer one because of the way the music changes and how dramatic it sounds. You can kinda get a sense of each narrator’s personality, or at least I feel like that. With this one it feels like one person rather than multiple
but that’s just an opinion of mine :)
69 likes, yea dude.
yearlingbore 260 i’m sorry i ruined it 😔😔
twinkle twinkle dislike
@@twinkletwinkle7734 lol
@@zoftell519 no then it will be 68 lol
If the final version is like a rich person auction, this is like one of those fast speaking auctions with how aggressive this version is.
oh thank goodness he pronounced bell correctly
i really thought they said bill everytime in the new one
the way joe says bourgeoisie (like every other version) sends me into orbit
Me slowly introducing a rap fan to tally hall with this
This version is so much better than the rerelease! They took the tempo down a few clicks and the song lost all its energy. Thanks for uploading!
I’m pretty sure the energy comes from the different drums in this version
What madman convinced them not to use this version on the album?
Atlantic Records did. This version was recorded and released for the album in 2005, then rerecorded for Atlantic in 2008.
i prefer the humming in this version if I’m being honest. Also, the keyboard or whatever at 0:42 goes absolutely BONKERS!!!
I'm more here to look at the album cover and DANG has it changed.
the actual 2005 art looks closer
This was a placeholder there is real art for the 2005 Version
this one is so much better
when the fuck did i write this
i don’t have an opinion
just some things i notice here:
voice isn't as deep
honestly seems more faster pace or has kinda an extra beat
a few extra oo-oo-oo's in the background at 0:42 to 0:51
1:36 to 1:39 the "going twice going thrice" kinda has an extra voice, idk how 2 explain
1:50 the background voice that said "dont shop around" is a lil quieter, along with a more noticeable guitar
2:10 the extra voice sounds a lil more robotic? idk if thats the word but ye
Why is this one better 😭 (if the chorus was the 2008 ver it would be perfect)
yknow I first came to this version of The Bidding not really liking it for how clunky and disjointed it is compared to the 2008 re-record. I've come to appreciate it way more not just for how aggressive and simple it feels, but also for just how RAW it is. It has so much more passion and feel than the 2008 version, and just feels like a silly band having silly fun. I love that so much
I LOVE THIS VERSION ITS SO AGGRESSIVE AND CLUNKY IM SO INLOVE
I believe in the bidding 2005 supremacy
same
same
same
same
same
Unpopular opinion: The Pingry EP version is the best version of The Bidding.
Unpopular opinion: I gotta say, the 2005 version of the album sounds better than the 2008 version.
So I was drawing and this comes on and I automatically assume it’s a nightcore and if it was I would have cried
drunk mr moon in the back 😩😩 he makes me act up 😳😳
reminder that you posted this‼️‼️ 😊😊😊
@@cinnarollinq i hate you
@@cinnarollinq WHO WAS I EVEN TALKING ABOUT
This may sound weird, but comparing this to the newer one, it gives Kids Bop energy in the first part. It’s all just a certain upbeat, it sorta loses that Kids Bop vibe later on.
Wow this felt like it was screaming in my face 👁👄👁
Not necessarily in a bad way I was just wearing headphones and it scared me a bit lol
i was jaming to mMMmMmmMm then the singing started and I FUCKING JUMPED
Joe says Bourgeoisie faster :(
why is 1:02-1:26 so gender in this version
2005 versions are so aggresive i love it
Scout if he could sing
Can't un-hear that now.
Now that I think about it, this version of the Bidding would go very well with Expiration Date
Where can I get this version of the album
Any physical release of MMMM after 2005 and before 2008 should have these versions, sadly I don't think you can officially purchase them digitally anymore
I got it on my old comp and old ipod
Damnnn... this is really different! I love it!
Both are great but this has some rawness to it that I love.
This version sounds like a homeless guy shouting at you and the 2008 release sounds like a gentleman flirting
bourgwazee
ah yes the superior version
My theory is that each verse of this song presents a different guy trying to date .
"I've been sleeping in a cardboard box
Spending every dollar at the liquor shop
And even though I know I haven't got a lot
I'll try to give you love until the day you drop."
(The Alcoholic guy)
"I've been training like a Pavlov dog
Let my independence out to take a hike
All you got to do is activate my bell
And I'll fetch you anything you like"
(The needy, over giving guy/aka a Simp)
"I've been in like a thousand times
Dated every woman in the atmosphere
I've been to every continent
Broken all the hearts in every hemisphere
And if I'm not the type of guy you like to circumvent
Just remember not to love me when I disappear" (The player/Pick up artist)
"I graduated at the top
I like to take advantage of the bourgeoisie
So if you have a fantasy of being a queen
Maybe you should blow a couple bucks on me" (highly educated guys/CEO/ very wealthy and successful)
At the end the "he's sold" at the end represents the "Mr. Right/perfect" man who is already taken.
i think "he's sold" just means they finally sold someone
WHY DOES IT HIT SO KUCH HARDER LIKE
is it just me or was there a slide whistle playing n the background at 0:59 when they say "SOLD!". ive checked every version of the bidding and there is no slide whistle. only an electric guitar.
I've heard the remastered version so many times that when I heard the baseline I'm like hey that's from the new version
this version is actually good, the 2008 version feels unfinished
its so loud and aggressive but in a good way?? This is lovely!! Ofc I still love the "finished"(?) one, but this is so unique!!!!
im throwing up this is so good i dont think i can listen to 2008 the same again
Why the old ones bop harder?? ;-;
very angry sounding i like it
Most of the 2005 versions are like 10x better lmao
Честно, я бы предпочла эту версию из-за ритма, скорости и общего настроя, мне нравится тут абсолютно всё, хоть убейте, но по моему мнению это гораздо круче.
this version is super cool but i love the guitar part at the end way too much that’s in the newer one
I prefer this one, anyone know if the 2021 rerelease is a rerecording or just a rerelease?
Just a rerelease. If you're wanting some more Tally content, I suggest searching "We Think We're Playing in a Band," it's a tribute album which features covers by several people who worked on Tally Hall related content, such as Casey Shea and Courtney Flynn from the Good & Evil tour and Minimall who were featured in Joe's solo album Joe Hawley Joe Hawley.
The 2021 rerelease is just the 2008 version with Just A Friend added, it’s 100% official and worth it
this version feels more dramatic and i like that
1:16 favorite part nobody can change my mind
samee
I think chonny jash was inspired by this song
Waah, that's really cool beat. Wish they kept it
I like the new one better but I do appreciate the buhs that come through better and the more guttural voice at some parts.
I love how aggressive this one is.. and thw bum-bum-bum at the background at start is adding a good tone
0 dislikes lets go
I honestly like this version better
This is so much better than the modern version somehow wtf
I WASNT EXPECTING THIS TO GO SO HARD
OH HI THERREEE
@@Sylvemations_THTSHP_13A-
The instrumental at 0:51 reminds me of the Inbetweeners, I can't be the only one who thinks this
Y’all are crazy, as much as I like it, this version is NOT better
It feels so sped up
This verson is like listening to the final version while having an anxiety attack
Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
my second cousin told me that he heard this on tiktok once and i murdered him. disposed of the body in a place nobody will ever find
/s
This one is so much harder, the extra compression adds so much to the drums in the verses too
tally hall
Nah, playboi carti
This feels less empty(?) than the older one
Holy shit THIS SLAPS
i love this version so much oh my god
More bouncy then the other one
I like this ver better because its more energetic and bold. I like speedcore and breakcore by the way lol, calm stuff bores me.
this version is faster and played a half step lower than the released version, i believe. i honestly wish this version got produced!
Wah wah
wah wah
This one is so much better. It’s cowardly to not like the intensity.
You owe me a beer
can i see your passport
This song gives me anxiety
I like both versions
0.75 speed
my thoughts exactly