Thank you. I get the reaction. And yes, from the first time I heard this, it was like a 'goodbye' to Avi, a loving one. He tweeted when they released it that he loved them all deeply. And it's Scott when, at that point in the song he looks at the camera and sings, "I just came to say goodbye' that always gets me.
Karen Brown I felt the same way. I still cry every time I watch this, and it hurts, but I'm putting ptx first and viewing reactions from my favorites. I feel like the members of PTX have very sad hearts😔, but they would never say it as it might hurt Avi. And I keep thinking "The Trio sounds great!" but it's PTX ! Kevin is so crucial to the GROUP. just weird having him off screen when they're doing a "couch" video. #PTXforever
AWE! Rob, this is why I love your reactions. That is exactly how I felt when I heard the song! Keep doing what you do because you are such a beautiful soul!
oh gosh now I'M crying again. This reaction was me but like 10x more composed since I was a Wreck™ your commentary was short, but deeply appropriate... all we can hear when Kevin plays his cello is Avi... and knowing the friendship between Kevin and Avi makes it even harder. The song choice is perfect, and you can't help but see it as a metaphor for Avi leaving. And it beautiful, but devastating. I cry every time I hear it.
Hugs to you Rob, I am crying with you. I felt the exact same way. Scotts voice especially is so very much from his heart. They all did a beautiful job, Beyonce put an ache in my heart tho. 💚
I'm with you Rob. Sara Barilles called it on the sing off. There will always be sickness, and time away from your family and the ones you love, but you guys (PTX) are worth it. Much love J.
What you saw on BGT was Calum Scott. His label wasn’t being cooperative, so he got rights to sing the song and produced it. It was the #1 song in the UK that summer!
I cried right along with you Rob, I don't like to see you cry, it makes me cry, but there was a bass voice hidden in there, i heard a fifth voice, not sure if it was Avi's last song or if they found someone just for that song but there was a bass voice hidden in there.
Okay, see this song did not make me cry when i first saw it or the multiple times afterwards. Then here you come with your reaction and that tear rolling out at the very end... now we both need hugs!!
♡♡♡ Rob. you are me when I first heard this. the cello was a fitting stand in for Avi, and that cello solo bit was heartbreaking due to the delivery & the omitted lyrics: "so far away, but still so near / the lights go out, the music dies." #PTXForever
I looked at the eclipse...that's why my eyes are watering, I'm not crying!!! Ok...you caught me. The feels were the same for me as well with the cello as Avi and they look so sad but also saying good bye. You ALWAYS make my heart BREAK when you cry! HUGS! #MeatandPotatoesFOREVER #PTXForever indeed!
I cried too when I watched this cover at first time. And I'm always about to cry when I watch it. Rob, you make your reaction videos with your soul and it's just great.
I cry everytime I hear this and I hear Avi in the Cello. I can't help it. PTX may not have meant this as a goodbye to Avi, but it has all the feels, especially for the Pentaholics. I am looking forward to the next chapters for all of them...and have my tickets for the Christmas concert in Chicago. ALSO...was SO EXCITED.....in my local Target was Kirstin's album. I bought three to give to friends.
OMG! When I saw this cover for the first time didn't cry at all, but I just did it now watching your reaction. Men, I really miss Avi :( Anyway, love your videos so much ❤
Rob good to see you its been a long time for me . We all mis Avi I share your feelings and glad to know how much we love him . Thank you so much for reaction
Hi, Rob. I've been watching for this one. I knew you'd do it when you were ready. All I can say is thanks for your unabashed ability to let us in on your feelings, and offer you all the virtual huggles you want.
🔷🔷Rob, you are so in tune with your 😥emotions which makes you a great 😇man. Are you 💎married or have a girlfriend? If not, I'm single and would ❤love to get to know you better.
Thank you. I get the reaction. And yes, from the first time I heard this, it was like a 'goodbye' to Avi, a loving one. He tweeted when they released it that he loved them all deeply. And it's Scott when, at that point in the song he looks at the camera and sings, "I just came to say goodbye' that always gets me.
Karen Brown Ugh, me too on the goodbye part. Scott looked so sad.
Karen Brown I felt the same way. I still cry every time I watch this, and it hurts, but I'm putting ptx first and viewing reactions from my favorites. I feel like the members of PTX have very sad hearts😔, but they would never say it as it might hurt Avi. And I keep thinking "The Trio sounds great!" but it's PTX ! Kevin is so crucial to the GROUP. just weird having him off screen when they're doing a "couch" video. #PTXforever
Okay, when you said "Kevin playing the cello, all heard was Avi" I completely lost it, I just want to give you a big hug. Love ya Rob.
That space between Kevin and the trio just killed me. 😢 It was beautiful but seemed incomplete without Avi.
It was the same for me 😭 The cello solo was Avi's solo. Very emotional. ❤
"kevin was playing the cello but all i heard was avi" HARD SAME 😢
AWE! Rob, this is why I love your reactions. That is exactly how I felt when I heard the song! Keep doing what you do because you are such a beautiful soul!
Thank you, sweet Kassandra♥
We hear Avi in Kevin's cello, too.
I think this was a great way to honor Avi.
*hugs* to you Rob... i feel the same way. i cried my eyes out. by the way: love the bright shirt! it looks great on you!
thank you ♥
It's okay Rob I'm over here crying with you 😭😭😭😭 #PTXForever
oh gosh now I'M crying again. This reaction was me but like 10x more composed since I was a Wreck™
your commentary was short, but deeply appropriate... all we can hear when Kevin plays his cello is Avi... and knowing the friendship between Kevin and Avi makes it even harder. The song choice is perfect, and you can't help but see it as a metaphor for Avi leaving. And it beautiful, but devastating. I cry every time I hear it.
No one was prepared for this one Rob. It shatters my heart everytime i watch it 💔💔
I just wanna hug you when beautiful songs make you cry. /hugs!
Ditto!
ALittleGamer 71 same
Awwww I just wanna run in and give you a hug when I saw you cry
Thanks for sharing your reaction. We all heard Avi. It is a beautiful video and I hope someday I can watch it without crying, too.
You said it all with that final hashtag. #PTXForever, indeed.
Watching you get teary-eyed, got ME teary-eyed. Thank you so much for such a real reaction!
Kevin playing the cello all I heard was Avi. You killed me. Thought I had the song under control but apparently not. Sigh.
I feel you, all I could hear when Kevin played was Avi too. That was beautifully done!
Hugs to you Rob, I am crying with you. I felt the exact same way. Scotts voice especially is so very much from his heart. They all did a beautiful job, Beyonce put an ache in my heart tho. 💚
I'm with you Rob. Sara Barilles called it on the sing off. There will always be sickness, and time away from your family and the ones you love, but you guys (PTX) are worth it. Much love J.
Awwee!!! *hugs* This is why we love you. Couldn't agree more that the cello *was* Avi, and no one could portray that better than Kevin.
Am a bit of an emotional mess here. "Kevin playing the cello, all I heard was Avi." ❤️ Rob
Im
Totally
Not
Crying
😭😭😭😭
What you saw on BGT was Calum Scott. His label wasn’t being cooperative, so he got rights to sing the song and produced it. It was the #1 song in the UK that summer!
I cried right along with you Rob, I don't like to see you cry, it makes me cry, but there was a bass voice hidden in there, i heard a fifth voice, not sure if it was Avi's last song or if they found someone just for that song but there was a bass voice hidden in there.
No! How dare you make me cry! #PTXForever
Okay, see this song did not make me cry when i first saw it or the multiple times afterwards. Then here you come with your reaction and that tear rolling out at the very end... now we both need hugs!!
Im not crying, is raining inside my eyes... 😂 😢
Greetings from Argentina Rob!
You can just break my heart 💖
♡♡♡ Rob. you are me when I first heard this. the cello was a fitting stand in for Avi, and that cello solo bit was heartbreaking due to the delivery & the omitted lyrics: "so far away, but still so near / the lights go out, the music dies." #PTXForever
I started tearing up just from your thumbnail! And your last comment had me bawling...I agree 100%! #ptxforever
Came home from school, decided to watch this video, ended up sobbing like a maniac... I miss Avi **cries**
This is the only video I've ever cried while watching...💖
I feel you so much, Rob. I kept expecting Avi to come in, but alas.
I looked at the eclipse...that's why my eyes are watering, I'm not crying!!! Ok...you caught me. The feels were the same for me as well with the cello as Avi and they look so sad but also saying good bye. You ALWAYS make my heart BREAK when you cry! HUGS! #MeatandPotatoesFOREVER #PTXForever indeed!
Watching with you made me cry...and I heard Avi in the cello too!
Yet another beautiful song and beautiful reaction.
Aaaaawww hugs Rob 💕 it was certainly an emotional performance
I cried too when I watched this cover at first time. And I'm always about to cry when I watch it. Rob, you make your reaction videos with your soul and it's just great.
Thank you ♥
Awwww Rob, big hugs..
#PTXFOREVER
Lots of tears for me too! Beautiful song. #PTXForever
I cry everytime I hear this and I hear Avi in the Cello. I can't help it.
PTX may not have meant this as a goodbye to Avi, but it has all the feels, especially for the Pentaholics.
I am looking forward to the next chapters for all of them...and have my tickets for the Christmas concert in Chicago. ALSO...was SO EXCITED.....in my local Target was Kirstin's album. I bought three to give to friends.
As I said in the past video. I love your reactions. I like to think they're singing this to Avi. I like making myself sad 😭
It's okay rob, I also feel you. I also cried when I watch it😭😭😭
OMG! When I saw this cover for the first time didn't cry at all, but I just did it now watching your reaction. Men, I really miss Avi :(
Anyway, love your videos so much ❤
Rob good to see you its been a long time for me . We all mis Avi I share your feelings and glad to know how much we love him . Thank you so much for reaction
Avi was my favorite. #PTXForever #BiggerThanWeEverDreamed
This is why you’re my favorite reactor. You have such heart. Thank you.
Exactly, Rob, exactly...
This is all of us Rob...!
Rob you are such a beautiful person. I really love you xo
You are such a sweet man. #PTXForever indeed. Hugs to you!
You are by far my favorite react channel that I have ever seen. You are so genuine and heart felt. Keep being you 💖
I had the exact same reaction. And while watching this video, I started to cry all over again. *(wipes tears and hugs Rob)*
Made me tear again ❤️ #PTXForever
I was waiting for this. You have reacted as I did. I'm an Avi girl, though I love them all. Thank you for being true to you. lovely man xx
Rob I am so with you. All I heard was Avi
PTXforever
Bless your sweet heart! I was tearing up with you.💜
It's a beautiful cover for sure!
You're such a good person and I love your reactions cause it's pure emotions out there.... You're an angel ❤
such a beautiful song...
Hi, Rob. I've been watching for this one. I knew you'd do it when you were ready. All I can say is thanks for your unabashed ability to let us in on your feelings, and offer you all the virtual huggles you want.
When you're up to it, check out the ptx hunger games that Zack Archer put together. Last I saw, you were injured, but still alive and kicking.
I've been anticipating your reaction and I loved it as usual!
You have an incredible heart and you share it so openly. Your emotion is palpable. Beautiful reaction, as always. 💗
Awe Rob.. I cried with you.. I love your reactions! Thank you
Awee Rob! C'mere **hugs**
Awwwwwww breaks my heart.
Beautiful reaction! X
rob i totes had the same reaction. now you made me cry again lol hugs #ptxforever
I'm not ready for your tears in this. Because, reasons.
Love ❤️ your reactions and I miss Avi #Ptxforever
I'm crying with you 😢
Oh Rob. I know it’s so sad. You are so so sweet
I cry with you every time. I hope to give you a big hug in person at Pentacon. Then we can cry together.
Omg yeah....this arrangement is beautiful but I totally agree; fact that Avi is not there? That's very sad. 😢
#PTXForever😭😭😭😔😔😔😔😔😭😔😭😔😭😔😭😔😭😔
Ahh ending with #PTXForever?!! Always! 😡😢 ❤
Love you ❤
Aww, Rob! Same 😢😢 (i love you)
Crying
I cried when I watch the video🙁🙁🙁😔😔😔
Love ❤️ you
Still, feeling the pain of missing Avi...
Rob, do you want react to "Sleep" by Eric Whitacre?
awwwwww rob
Can you make a reaction to avi kaplan vocal range?
❤️😢
Aw Rob, gimme a hug! Also, can you react to BTS Fire or Dope?
almost forgot to ask you if you can react to Ptx hunger games by Zach archer? you are in it!!
Oh dear! This was a sad one 😔
Rob I understand. That's all I can say. J.
God you're so cute omg
Dimash kudaibergen react please
So sad that Avi is gone". Matt is great, but he’s not Avi
Great Video! if you got a second stop by our channel and check out one of our videos. We're releasing our First album Sept 8th.
🔷🔷Rob, you are so in tune with your 😥emotions which makes you a great 😇man. Are you 💎married or have a girlfriend? If not, I'm single and would ❤love to get to know you better.