A lot of people shy away from speaking about the Mafia when retelling NY history. Even though the Mafia has a long history with the city. Nice retelling.
As a straight man and an aspiring writer, I fully support the LGBT community with open arms, and I had even written a script with the intention of not just subverting the "Bury Your Gays" trope but *_DESTROYING_* it, giving the script's LGBT couple an actual happy ending, live happily ever after type ending.
It's not a happily ever after if they're still being rightfully oppressed. Your script is only going to make temporary changes, not permanent ones. With that being said, opposition to the lgbt will only rise as we speak.
Oh my god, from the amount of comments I’ve seen on videos like these I expected while reading your comment you would say something like “I support LGBT *but*…” and you never did, you just expressed how you can empathize and support the community. So thanks for that :) it means a lot
ECS1126 videos about the LGBTQ community tend to have a larger proportion of dislikes than other videos. *Some people* dont like it when oppressed minorities are empowered by learning their history
There's a lot of underlying guilting in this video. Even though it's not what Ruddy wanted, the script sounded as if straight people were demons while LGBTQ people were saints.
People raised to wallow in ignorance, hatred of the different and rampant self-centeredness tend to hate facts. Why do you think these idiots keep shrieking "FAKE NEWSSSSS"?? Facts scare them, and when the ignorant are scared, they get angry.
Update: The original comment was when I came out as bisexual. As of less than a week ago, I came out to my mom for a second time, this time as a trans girl. It went more or less perfectly - she even gave me her old nail varnish - but it's obviously going to take some time for her to get used to referring to me in a new way. Every day I thank God that I ended up with her as my mom. There are so many horror stories I've seen of others' parents...
At first I was a little disappointed that it was so violent but then I remembered that in order for black people to have rights there was a war so this went pretty well actually
2:51 I can tell what character are they from if u don't know Ursula: Little Mermaid Scar: Lion King King Candy: Wreck it Ralph Him: Power Puff Girl James: Pokemon Jafar: Aladdin But idk who the last two, but comment if u know And Be proud if you're part of LBGTQ Edit: Thank you all for helping out, also I replaced Jesse with James, though i was surprised that the top left is Miss Trunchbull from Matilda
@@LucidFL In my opinion I don't think it is, as an example obviously for a cis white straight man shouldn't be proud of that because there has never been a period of history where a cis white straight man has been discriminated compared to any person of colour and any lgbtq folk. The whole premise of celebrating such minorities is to tell minorities that they should be proud of who they are instead of being discriminated for it and hoping to be a different gender, race etc. Just to avoid the hate. I feel that you would have a different opinion if you were a marginalised person.
0:35 As an Anglican, I'd like to note that while Abrahamic religions have historically taken a negative view of LGBT people, contemporary biblical scholarship casts a new light on many of the verses that have been used to justify this bigotry, and there are a growing number of churches & synagogues that accept LGBT people for who they are. For example, the verse from Leviticus mentioned in the video has historically been seen as a blanket condemnation of being gay, but when placed in its historical context can be understood to refer to activites as part of a ritual connected to idolatory.
@@lukeh2556 all christian churches that are liberal fail. The anglicans are the most liberal so are the fastest declining. Others like lutherans, catholics, methodists and other fan liberal churches are racing to the bottom. But real christian churches like the baptists aren't. Coincidence?
this made me immensely happy. thank you so much. especially for all the flags at the end. it means alot to me and everyone else to see representation like this. especially on academia TH-cam :')
Hindsight and history is on the side of the LGBT movement. Those who reject it will be remember as no better as the people who yelled at Ruby Bridges when she tried to go to school.
If you don't want riots to happen then get rid of what caused them in the first place instead of complaining about destroyed property that the government and rich people can easily pay off if they weren't so damn greedy.
EJ 's Hotlaps I cant believe I missed it!!! I’m so annoyed! I was running on overdrive to get the video finished for this weekend! Whoops! Happy Pride!!! :D
the mafia wasn't always a complete force for evil, they were loyal to money first but they figured out that catering to minorities was gonna make a lot of money so they are often found in the histories of these groups
It's not the LGBTQ+ part that matters, it's the people part. And as long as people have to fight to be who they are, we need videos like this to remind us we need to protect people. Not "them", not "they", not "those people", because there are just people. All the rest should be irrelevant.
@@euskara2068 I am so happy your spelling is as wrong as your sense of real morality. Or would you rather indulge in your true calling of killing anyone who's different from you, Herr Standartenfuhrer Uncle?
Fantastic video! Quick thing I noticed though at 10:15 was with the Pansexual flag. It seems to be missing the blue at the bottom. At first I thought this pink/yellow/white flag was an older pansexual flag (since the current pink/yellow/blue flag became prominent in the 2010s) but I couldn't find anything online about this. I think you might have forgot to finish coloring the flag in! Amazing video btw! Love your history videos since 2014, and thank you so much for covering this topic!
Spoonseria - SpennyTheSpoon yup! I forgot the blue! I was too busy getting the rest right that this final one slipped past me! At a glance, they all looked finished! :/
Okay, so here's the problem. The culture has created (as it seems) only two sides. Those who complain all the time and whine about being oppressed, and those who hate them and speak violence against them. It does have to be this way, so called "christians" on both sides have not obeyed the laws of Christ. So, we have two sides at war, so now what? We look at true Christians, who know and love the gospel, and spread true love. What does this mean? Loving your neighbor, truly, means bringing them close to Jesus, and showing them how to repent, turn away from temptations. We do this, and it's peaceful, and kind, loving, and if we are turned away, then we'll go on to others.
This is very well done! I’ve been working on a research paper the past 5 weeks about the gay right movement. Looks like I’m using a lot of the same sources you did. I like the small details in this. Such as the article titles in the village voice newspaper.
Thank you for creating and sharing I am always amazed that the changes in society and in the hearts of man" that I have lived to see ( keeping in mind a,ll the while how much more remains to be done )
I don't know how to feel about the riots because I'm Demisexual (Don't feel sexual attraction to anyone unless I've gotten to know them) which is part of the LGBTQIA+ community, but I also like the police and I'm aware that the police were corrupt back then.
I am going to get torn apart for this, but do people agree that there is a difference between biological sex and gender? I think there is as most people are born with certain characteristics defining them as male or female, not to mention what we understand of chromosomes. In my opinion, gender is more social and allows for an expanded range of what one may identify as.
Many people are defining gender more like a personality thing rather than a scientific thing. I'm sorry, but your biological sex will never change. It may not determine who you are, but it does determine what you are (male/female)
@@TheSteam02 no one said you could change it tho,trans woman are woman in the sense of gender but when talking about sex everyone whos educated on the subject will tell you they are biologically male as in sex
@@fleecejohnsonbandit man that's really homophobic and mean and I don't know your religious beliefs but that doesn't mean you can say something like that unless you are talking about horrible people like murderers then in that case carry on
I myself am a Christian and sure the bible isn't supportive but I like to think of any LGBTQ interactions as not what God intended but he still loves his children
Homosexuality wasn't really accepted at any point though. In ancient Greece it would depend if you were a top or bottom, if you were the sub/bottom you would be no difference from a woman back then so not that good, and Greece among many European countries, wasn't one single defined country. You had Athens, Sparta, Ithaca, Macedonia, Crete etc. Sp while one state may be "okay" eith homosexuality, another would might kill you. And in the medieval ages you said that it would also be okay but again, not really. In the medieval ages (along with ancient Greece) it usually wouldn't be an open consenting religion between two adults, it would more often than not be a young pre-teens castrated boy being used by a king, lord, priest etc. For most of history, homosexuality wasn't accepted and if it was, it wouldn't be the same as it is now and there would still be alot of "rules" that would decide if it was okay.
I live in Malaysia (The countries who have laws against the LGBTQ community there and I am not personally and I am a muslim I on paper I dont support it because its religion and I still believe in it but I know other people in secret must be terrified to confess here
Lesbian trans woman here and I loved this video, great job. It's somewhat depressing though how the same norms that were protested against at the Stonewall Riots are still preventing you from telling the whole story on TH-cam.
What he depicted here is historically accurate and does not insert fictional activities and myth such as a trans woman throwing the first brick/glass to start it.
@@euskara2068 So do I. I mean, gay people shouldn't have had to riot for humans rights that they should have had in the first place. But that's what happens under rampid homophobia
The Black Cat Tavern is an LGBT historic site located in the Silver Lake neighborhood of Los Angeles, California. In 1967, it was the site of one of the first demonstrations in the United States protesting police brutality against LGBT people, preceding the Stonewall riots by over two years.
The Russian revolution during Lenin time also gave rights to the LGBT community decriminalizing homosexuality entirely. Problem is his successors is hated that idea
@@sanmarino8605 ^ it’s still not completely normalized yet. As well as for me the majority of America is very religious so schools are too scared to teach it to students
@@drelezar7745 ya but who knows a little over 60% of Americans support LGBTQ RIGHTS but still very religious country but who knows where it will be the same in a few decades with religion on a fast decline in the states
@@DocLeQuack In the sense that it was "technically" legal, but the state still persecuted people who didn't align with the N.Korean way of life. It's funny because many communist countries decriminalised homosexuality, since the only argument against it was based in religion (they were atheist).
Not 100% sure but this is how I understand it: Sexuality is a spectrum, and to include every label would be impossible without an acronym five miles long. The best solution is '+' to remain inclusive to everyone
There are many more sexualities and gender expressions. For example Intersex, or asexuality. So sometimes is written as LGBTQIA. And there are even more possibilities (Pansexual, Allies, 2 Spirited, etc). So the + is just so symbolise that there are more and not just LGBTQ People. Sometimes the term GRSM (gender, romantic and sexual minorities) is used to describe the LGBTQ+ community. I hope that this term catches on as it is all inclusive and not "unusable" long.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 89 | คู่เอก "ยอดไอคิว vs คิริลล์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z3vYkHJ_5Ig/mqdefault.jpg)
"Didn't even want hand holding."
There is an anime degeneracy joke in there.
@@AmyRovin-ie2jr it is
What the Stonewall Riot shows is that people being oppressed can only go so far before they push back against the ones doing the oppressing
Say that about the 73 other countries which saw that failed.
A lot of people shy away from speaking about the Mafia when retelling NY history. Even though the Mafia has a long history with the city. Nice retelling.
And across the river in NJ too
I just think its amazing mafias are still relevant today. Like in sicily, they took advantage of covid medical supplies
Yeah so much of it should be known you can't get rid of it
@@giovannicervantes2053 what's the song at the beginning?
@@Sharko-tk7ij idk
I only recently learnt about Stonewall after being out bi for a year. Can't believe they don't teach it at school
I hope someday they will teach about it in our schools.
They teach it in my history class but a quote from my history teach “ I can’t speak for how hard life is lgbtq+ but I can help stop oppression”
Same, I had now idea what our forefathers had to go through just to be themselves
Modern schooling is very far from being modern at all
@@deehoover777 funny how drunk history teaches me more than school
nice jab at J.K Rowling lmao
@@puppet1-170 thanks!
It isn't too much to ask for to be able to love who you want to love. Mad respect to all of the people who fought for freedom during the protests.
If love is love then you support incestM
@@PennGaming kinda suspicious that that's the first thing you thought of
@@abby5779 not really
@@PennGaming ur connecting incest to a sexuality…. time to reflect
It’s more complicated than you think
Are seriously telling me Fat Tony is an actual Italian mobster?!
When you oppress people, don't be surprised when they rebel or riot.
A surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one!
Iurie Pripa Ahh, the negotiator!
General Kenobi!
You are a bold one.
Took me way too long to spot the Palpatine quote!
Hello there!
Not in the LGBT community myself, but I do support it completely.
did anybody ask?
that's your problem
@@micahistory no that's your problem
@@LucidFL Not really. Just making a statement.
@@micahistory wouldn't really call it a problem
Wow, history lesson we didn't realize we needed. And during Pride Month. Well done sir.
beautiful and amazing video as always!!!!
As a straight man and an aspiring writer, I fully support the LGBT community with open arms, and I had even written a script with the intention of not just subverting the "Bury Your Gays" trope but *_DESTROYING_* it, giving the script's LGBT couple an actual happy ending, live happily ever after type ending.
Good luck on writing your script and thank you for being an ally. 😄
It's not a happily ever after if they're still being rightfully oppressed.
Your script is only going to make temporary changes, not permanent ones. With that being said, opposition to the lgbt will only rise as we speak.
Oh my god, from the amount of comments I’ve seen on videos like these I expected while reading your comment you would say something like “I support LGBT *but*…” and you never did, you just expressed how you can empathize and support the community. So thanks for that :) it means a lot
I don't get the dislikes.
I guess people just hate facts
Every vid will have dislikes, no matter the topic
ECS1126 videos about the LGBTQ community tend to have a larger proportion of dislikes than other videos. *Some people* dont like it when oppressed minorities are empowered by learning their history
There's a lot more likes than dislikes, and I think there should be a greater emphasize in the amount of positivity in this comment section than hate.
There's a lot of underlying guilting in this video. Even though it's not what Ruddy wanted, the script sounded as if straight people were demons while LGBTQ people were saints.
People raised to wallow in ignorance, hatred of the different and rampant self-centeredness tend to hate facts. Why do you think these idiots keep shrieking "FAKE NEWSSSSS"?? Facts scare them, and when the ignorant are scared, they get angry.
Wow! This is super in-depth! Really appreciate the time that went into researching this, and I love your drawing style!!!
Thanks :)
I came out to my mom after we watched this video. It went perfectly.
Great video.
@Al Ease girlll stfu
Great for u
Holy smokes, thank the good lord kit went well.
So happy for you 🏳️🌈
Update: The original comment was when I came out as bisexual. As of less than a week ago, I came out to my mom for a second time, this time as a trans girl. It went more or less perfectly - she even gave me her old nail varnish - but it's obviously going to take some time for her to get used to referring to me in a new way.
Every day I thank God that I ended up with her as my mom. There are so many horror stories I've seen of others' parents...
i bet this comments section is gonna be just roses
I hope so. (Hopefully rainbow ones! 🏳️🌈)
@@historyarmyproductions Judging by the like to dislike ratio, it's probably not going to be. Unless Ruddy made a major mistake I didn't catch.
Ruddy's irish, isn't he? He's seen worse.
@@ddobrevs his major mistake was turning a history channel into a leftist propaganda channel
and it only took an hour for people like this to show up. what a shame
you dropped this 👑
Its so sad to see this many hate comments...
@Ducks yours dont. It should be an I insted of a U.
AWWWWWW. cry me a river
@@micahistory no. Also, forgot to go to 4chan?
@Ducks well you are a duck so i was expecting that.
It’s not hate if it’s an opinion
"Let us be judged by our leaders. Not our criminals."
- Harvey Milk
And my hero
Fun fact: The person who coined the term "feminism" was a utopian socialist and defended same sex marraige.
At first I was a little disappointed that it was so violent but then I remembered that in order for black people to have rights there was a war so this went pretty well actually
2:51 I can tell what character are they from if u don't know
Ursula: Little Mermaid
Scar: Lion King
King Candy: Wreck it Ralph
Him: Power Puff Girl
James: Pokemon
Jafar: Aladdin
But idk who the last two, but comment if u know
And Be proud if you're part of LBGTQ
Edit: Thank you all for helping out, also I replaced Jesse with James, though i was surprised that the top left is Miss Trunchbull from Matilda
I think that the person in the center is Governor Ratcliffe from Pocahontas.
I don't know who the last one is.
@Johann Hyena it’s James from Pokémon not Jesse from Pokémon
The one above scar and beside ursala is Ms Trunchbull from the movie and book, Matilda.
being proud of anything you cant control is beyond stupid
@@LucidFL In my opinion I don't think it is, as an example obviously for a cis white straight man shouldn't be proud of that because there has never been a period of history where a cis white straight man has been discriminated compared to any person of colour and any lgbtq folk. The whole premise of celebrating such minorities is to tell minorities that they should be proud of who they are instead of being discriminated for it and hoping to be a different gender, race etc. Just to avoid the hate. I feel that you would have a different opinion if you were a marginalised person.
0:35 As an Anglican, I'd like to note that while Abrahamic religions have historically taken a negative view of LGBT people, contemporary biblical scholarship casts a new light on many of the verses that have been used to justify this bigotry, and there are a growing number of churches & synagogues that accept LGBT people for who they are.
For example, the verse from Leviticus mentioned in the video has historically been seen as a blanket condemnation of being gay, but when placed in its historical context can be understood to refer to activites as part of a ritual connected to idolatory.
Of course nowadays thankfully some religions are accepting!
It meant to condem perverts, that passage in leviticus
yes that's why your fake anglican church is the fastest dying church in the world. You become accepting of sin and you reap the benefits
@@micahistory yeah because the rest of Christianity has been doing so much better /s
@@lukeh2556 all christian churches that are liberal fail. The anglicans are the most liberal so are the fastest declining. Others like lutherans, catholics, methodists and other fan liberal churches are racing to the bottom. But real christian churches like the baptists aren't. Coincidence?
I call stonewall: "the gay Alamo"
you posted this twice? You good?
@@clinger5520 I'm pretty sure it's a glitch I've seen it before on other videos
@@dekuboidonut4552 Happens to me quite often.
"55 days ate Gaying" is a better title
It’s the gay Lexington and concord
thanks John, this was very good and informative
this made me immensely happy. thank you so much. especially for all the flags at the end. it means alot to me and everyone else to see representation like this. especially on academia TH-cam :')
go to hell, where you belong.
@@fleecejohnsonbandit yes 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
@@sapphogrove5242 Hitchens said hell is where all the interesting people are going anyway. Cheers from a Massachusetts atheist.
Hindsight and history is on the side of the LGBT movement. Those who reject it will be remember as no better as the people who yelled at Ruby Bridges when she tried to go to school.
Dark irony: that Stonewall and the 20th century Battle of the Bogside happened the same year still freaks me out. Should it?
Thank you for covering such an important topic and not ignoring it to avoid criticism from homophobes and bigots.
🤡🤡🤡
@@julien.s2002 Wut.
@@brodown64 he hates gay people , I saw him in another comment.
@@julien.s2002 woah that's sad
@@julien.s2002 You're the only clown here in thise section
PLEASE, MAKE A VIDEO ABOUT THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR!!! 🇪🇸
I second this
I third this, I don’t know nearly enough about that period of Spanish history
Yes
I fourth this
I fifth this this would probably be very interesting.
If you don't want riots to happen then get rid of what caused them in the first place instead of complaining about destroyed property that the government and rich people can easily pay off if they weren't so damn greedy.
Looks like Miss Trunchbull from the movie Matilda was one of the villains I see here.
My grandpa and his husband met at the stonewall inn and both were in the riots
Oooooo my god thats sooo cuuuteeee
cute
what an unholy family
@@sapphoschild3019 you have a really twisted mind
@@johnappleseed3428 this is exactly what causes people to be sent to hell
Never knew the mafia were somehow involved... Also did u run out of blue with the pan flag?
EJ 's Hotlaps I cant believe I missed it!!! I’m so annoyed! I was running on overdrive to get the video finished for this weekend! Whoops! Happy Pride!!! :D
@@JohnDRuddyMannyMan im unsubscribing, you fell to a new low
@@fleecejohnsonbandit What? What low did he fall to?
@@fleecejohnsonbandit bit rude it was an honest mistake
the mafia wasn't always a complete force for evil, they were loyal to money first but they figured out that catering to minorities was gonna make a lot of money so they are often found in the histories of these groups
Did you do the seven years war? Pretty sure you didn't and it will be great to have you make a video about it !
@Jhonny Auditore inb4 It's been 7 years since he started doing this content. It would be quite ironic and funny
I second this.
Please don't forget the +. It's really important that everyone who identifies outside of straight cisgendered 'norms'.
Not as bad as my great grandmother who calls it LGB.
It's not the LGBTQ+ part that matters, it's the people part. And as long as people have to fight to be who they are, we need videos like this to remind us we need to protect people. Not "them", not "they", not "those people", because there are just people. All the rest should be irrelevant.
Thank you for saying should
True but as history has shown, things come slowly and often one at a time, I wish it were faster.
I usually don't pay attention or care about the lgbtq community but this made me have another level of respect for them
And pervasion
@@euskara2068 I am so happy your spelling is as wrong as your sense of real morality. Or would you rather indulge in your true calling of killing anyone who's different from you, Herr Standartenfuhrer Uncle?
Thank you! Having videos on LGBTQ+ history is absolutely amazing.
This is great and I'm so happy you made this video, thank you.
When I saw the title, I thought it was about riots about Stonewall Jackson dying from friendly fire
Would have been funny if it was
Fantastic video! Quick thing I noticed though at 10:15 was with the Pansexual flag. It seems to be missing the blue at the bottom. At first I thought this pink/yellow/white flag was an older pansexual flag (since the current pink/yellow/blue flag became prominent in the 2010s) but I couldn't find anything online about this. I think you might have forgot to finish coloring the flag in!
Amazing video btw! Love your history videos since 2014, and thank you so much for covering this topic!
Spoonseria - SpennyTheSpoon yup! I forgot the blue! I was too busy getting the rest right that this final one slipped past me! At a glance, they all looked finished! :/
@@JohnDRuddyMannyMan No worries! Great video regardless
we dont need a lecture about satanic symbols, ok?
@@fleecejohnsonbandit xD
@@fleecejohnsonbandit "satanic symbols"😂 I didn't know that kind of homophobia still existed in the west.
We fought then. We fight now. 🏳️🌈
Hopefully one day you wont have to fight, stay safe and strong.
Ja
We’ll rally round the inn,we’ll rally once again.
🏳️🌈🚫
@@julien.s2002 no
the way we had an entire unit on the 1960s in school yet never learned about this
Damn the world is so screwed up people have to riot just to love who they love
Awesome video man, progress will not be stopped!
you call this progress? you want satanic forces to take over the world?
Yes, and let’s hope more groups will also see more acceptance.
Today on Manny Man does History: More exmaples of teh US being afraid to actually talk about horrible things they've done in the past!!
Any gaes here in the comments section?
You bet. 🏳️🌈
Pansexual here.
Get some gay flags here
IRISH-RUSSIAN DRAKE absolutely
bisexual here B)
Had no idea this happened. Its time to learn.
Always great to educate yourself and learn important events
Okay, so here's the problem. The culture has created (as it seems) only two sides. Those who complain all the time and whine about being oppressed, and those who hate them and speak violence against them. It does have to be this way, so called "christians" on both sides have not obeyed the laws of Christ. So, we have two sides at war, so now what? We look at true Christians, who know and love the gospel, and spread true love. What does this mean? Loving your neighbor, truly, means bringing them close to Jesus, and showing them how to repent, turn away from temptations. We do this, and it's peaceful, and kind, loving, and if we are turned away, then we'll go on to others.
Except there are no true Christians, only those who think their interpretation of the religion is true.
Can you do the civil rights movement next
Looks like he listened to you
This is very well done! I’ve been working on a research paper the past 5 weeks about the gay right movement. Looks like I’m using a lot of the same sources you did. I like the small details in this. Such as the article titles in the village voice newspaper.
Holy shit, I didn’t realize this channel was so fucking cool. Absolutely amazing content, keep it up
Thank you for creating and sharing I am always amazed that the changes in society and in the hearts of man" that I have lived to see ( keeping in mind a,ll the while how much more remains to be done )
i love you my lgbtq brothers and sisters and i am going to fight with you until the day that i die.
And we will fight with our other minority brethern
@@ruairiodonohoe2533 Why so you can get greater political autonomy? gtfo of here with that nonsense. 🤣
we march united under the arc of the rainbow till all are able to live their lives
Seeing various characters from different media in 2:54 in your own art style is pretty nice to see, you should do some more or that in more videos.
I know this has nothing to do with the video's topic, but you should do a video on the Chinese Civil War. It has a very fascinating history.
Yes, that would be a interesting video, a gay non Asian fan
THE ORIGINS ARE FROM COMPTONS CAFE IN SF....
I don't know how to feel about the riots because I'm Demisexual (Don't feel sexual attraction to anyone unless I've gotten to know them) which is part of the LGBTQIA+ community, but I also like the police and I'm aware that the police were corrupt back then.
The police are still just as corrupt now
@@Rejoice. Well that’s your opinion and I acknowledge it but I don’t agree with it.
@@zeusthewolfsky While not being true for 100% of police, some are corrupt.
Wow the past Was REALLY not woke
who knew
Micahistory 2 hahahahaha
@@unclesam5230 hey nice to see you here
Micahistory 2 get back to discord pls
@@unclesam5230 He'll be there in a minute. He lost his hood somewhere and wandered into this comment section.
I have a cousin whos trans and gay and I identify as straight ally.
I am going to get torn apart for this, but do people agree that there is a difference between biological sex and gender? I think there is as most people are born with certain characteristics defining them as male or female, not to mention what we understand of chromosomes. In my opinion, gender is more social and allows for an expanded range of what one may identify as.
Many people are defining gender more like a personality thing rather than a scientific thing. I'm sorry, but your biological sex will never change. It may not determine who you are, but it does determine what you are (male/female)
Gender iirc is somewhat social but is also determined by one’s neurobiology. Google ‘gender dysphoria.’
@@TheSteam02 no one said you could change it tho,trans woman are woman in the sense of gender but when talking about sex everyone whos educated on the subject will tell you they are biologically male as in sex
@Jazzy yeah dw,that was months ago,i changed my opinion and now i think trans woman are more female then male since sex also has a biological spectrum
Great video Manny! Well made and educational.
forgot to mention tchaikovsky
everyone should just leet everyone like/be whatever they want
no. satanic monsters should notbe allowed to stay on earth
@@fleecejohnsonbandit man that's really homophobic and mean and I don't know your religious beliefs but that doesn't mean you can say something like that unless you are talking about horrible people like murderers then in that case carry on
@@thatperson1009 oh shut up
I myself am a Christian and sure the bible isn't supportive but I like to think of any LGBTQ interactions as not what God intended but he still loves his children
@@thatperson1009 they are atheists. isn't atheism a sin, professor?
Ha thanks for calling out J.K. Rowling.
Homosexuality wasn't really accepted at any point though. In ancient Greece it would depend if you were a top or bottom, if you were the sub/bottom you would be no difference from a woman back then so not that good, and Greece among many European countries, wasn't one single defined country. You had Athens, Sparta, Ithaca, Macedonia, Crete etc. Sp while one state may be "okay" eith homosexuality, another would might kill you. And in the medieval ages you said that it would also be okay but again, not really. In the medieval ages (along with ancient Greece) it usually wouldn't be an open consenting religion between two adults, it would more often than not be a young pre-teens castrated boy being used by a king, lord, priest etc. For most of history, homosexuality wasn't accepted and if it was, it wouldn't be the same as it is now and there would still be alot of "rules" that would decide if it was okay.
I’m not saying that it was legal, but it went through waves of being tolerated.
In ancient greece it did not matter if you were top or bottom your thinking of rome which is why caesar got memed on for banging a foreign king
The Manny Man Comes Back!
PatchesRips He’s in the video!
This video really expanded my view on the history of the LGBTQ rights. Thanks! :)
Great video. Cheers
Thank you, it's an important part of history
the important part of the downfall of humanity that will happen unless the enemies of god are vanquished and sent to hell
@@fleecejohnsonbandit If you're speaking about LGBTQ, most of LGBTQ+ people don't believe in anything.
They must be very delusional to think poorly someone for there Choices
To think a people should oppressed for being themselves the are free beings to do as they want
1:36, Alaska and Hawaii weren’t states yet
Correct. But they were territories.
Another great video, thank you John.
Thanks so much for taking the research for this video seriously, it really shows.
You might as well do the George Floyd riots.
Rodney King first
Someday, hopefully we learn a little this time
Except no, that's not a historical event.
@@TrocaTheNero It will be in a few months maybe.
I live in Malaysia (The countries who have laws against the LGBTQ community there and I am not personally and I am a muslim I on paper I dont support it because its religion and I still believe in it but I know other people in secret must be terrified to confess here
An upload what a pleasant suprise
Great video Jon. So in depth just like al your other videos. Keep up the good work!
I would joke about what year this took place, but this is probably not a good time to do so
i mean really besides "gay 69 hehe" what material is there?
Noti gang
Do the 1921 Tulsa race massacre
Call it for what it is. A Tulsa Genocide.
@@filipinordabest and with airplanes
What is a woman?
Trans woman also have a female brain, do some research if you are going to comment on a topic.
Lesbian trans woman here and I loved this video, great job. It's somewhat depressing though how the same norms that were protested against at the Stonewall Riots are still preventing you from telling the whole story on TH-cam.
What did he not get to tell?
What he depicted here is historically accurate and does not insert fictional activities and myth such as a trans woman throwing the first brick/glass to start it.
what if the stonewall riots naver happened
I wish it didn’t
I'm waitn for alernat history hub btw
@@euskara2068 So do I.
I mean, gay people shouldn't have had to riot for humans rights that they should have had in the first place.
But that's what happens under rampid homophobia
@@M_W_L_F yeah but since homophobia is a thing, I’m glad they did happen because someone actually did something about it.
Switzerland in September will be holding a vote on gay marriage. Fingers crossed we win and win big.
The Black Cat Tavern is an LGBT historic site located in the Silver Lake neighborhood of Los Angeles, California. In 1967, it was the site of one of the first demonstrations in the United States protesting police brutality against LGBT people, preceding the Stonewall riots by over two years.
10:03 I couldn’t help but notice you didn’t include China in that map....
LGBT people have limited rights in China and are looked down upon a lot in Chinese society, but it’s not illegal to be LGBT in China.
Not being murdered or imprisoned by the state is a start
The Russian revolution during Lenin time also gave rights to the LGBT community decriminalizing homosexuality entirely.
Problem is his successors is hated that idea
Why haven’t I been taught any of this?
Because it's not important
@@anti-loganpaul7827 ok
Idk probably because it's kinda awkward to teach in school because lots of pll are still homophobic:/
@@sanmarino8605 ^ it’s still not completely normalized yet. As well as for me the majority of America is very religious so schools are too scared to teach it to students
@@drelezar7745 ya but who knows a little over 60% of Americans support LGBTQ RIGHTS but still very religious country but who knows where it will be the same in a few decades with religion on a fast decline in the states
I recommend the Warsaw uprising
Uprising by sabaton intensifying
So glad you covered this! As an asexual I think that stonewall has a lot of misinformation surrounding it and someone finally covered it properly!
Manny man is one of the many great people who make animations or drawings making history more easy to swallow.
Omg agender was the second flag to appear *happy agender noises*
loving the j.k rowling slander keep it up bestie
1969. Nice one LGBT community. Unfortunately TH-cam sensors gay content creators so this video won’t receive many views.
Good
10:03 North Korea
I don’t think so
Homosexuality and trans people are legal in North Korea, but there are still problems since most of the population has conservative views.
@@sgs3054 actually, there is a law where you cannot openly show your sexual orientation, which includes straight people aswell.
SGS I am sorry are you telling me NK was more ok with the LGBTQ community before the US?
@@DocLeQuack In the sense that it was "technically" legal, but the state still persecuted people who didn't align with the N.Korean way of life.
It's funny because many communist countries decriminalised homosexuality, since the only argument against it was based in religion (they were atheist).
3:24 And we all know where that lead us...
What's the "+" For in the LGBTQ?
And more
@@osomister Usually that means allys, or people of colour, if you believe in intersectionalism.
Not 100% sure but this is how I understand it:
Sexuality is a spectrum, and to include every label would be impossible without an acronym five miles long. The best solution is '+' to remain inclusive to everyone
There are many more sexualities and gender expressions. For example Intersex, or asexuality. So sometimes is written as LGBTQIA. And there are even more possibilities (Pansexual, Allies, 2 Spirited, etc). So the + is just so symbolise that there are more and not just LGBTQ People.
Sometimes the term GRSM (gender, romantic and sexual minorities) is used to describe the LGBTQ+ community. I hope that this term catches on as it is all inclusive and not "unusable" long.
It’s a bit like rounding Pi down to 3.14
why is there an Irish flag at 9:52 ?
Are we a pride flag now?
I think I'm missing something
It’s a picture showing the Marriage Equality Referendum in Ireland.
Separate note: That building was a fire hazard
True