You only realise when you leave the religion how much lies you're told about the greatness of the sahaba, looking back at when I was a kid I was indoctrinated so much
@Swoosh Swish You won't have to be a closet Ex-Muslim for that much longer. It's becoming more widespread, far more widespread. In my home country of Kerala in India, it's a phenomenon.
@@paulthomas281 same thing in the arab countries .. a lot of ex-muslims here from Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Tunisia we have Communities on TH-cam and twitter and Facebook .. it's a worldwide phenomenon.
As an ex-muslim what bothers me is knowing all these and not being able to share them with my friends/family/in social media. Most of the people are unaware of all these disturbing things and the ones who know all these aren’t allowed to say these things or else they will get killed. It’s so frustrating.
Dear Akbar, you can always share that kind of hadith with other Muslims and your friends, just say it from the perspective of a believer who has some problem with this hadith. In that case, you are sure that no one can accuse you and tell you that you are Murtad or Kaffer etc. . You are planting a seed of doubt in others' minds, that in time could grow and become a powerful tree.
Sauda: Goes out to take a dump Umar: "Sauda! I can see you!" Sauda: "Mo, Umar won't let me take a crap in peace" Mo: "God allows you to take a dump, now let me finish my chicken dinner"
Yeah seriously! I just learned about this a few hours ago! (Sahih Bukhari 146) Sauda wife of Muhammad catches red-handed (or perhaps white-handed) my man Umar watching her do the real business, and Umar manages to talk his way out of it. Unless I'm mistaken, that story is one of the arguments for niqabs. These guys are too much. XD Speechcraft 100. (Hail Ishtar)
very recent ex-muslim here. i think something very interesting is to look back at my experiences (as a muslim) and realize things that i otherwise wouldn't have realized. in school we were taught about the companions of muhammad. umar was described as "strict", but in a good way. so he was portrayed to us as strong, courageous, even if he was strict it was for the good of islam, etc. i can't believe he was supposed to be our role model or something. another thing is i remember my teacher telling the class about killing apostates as a "strategy" of upholding islam. now i'm like... how did we not question that?! leaving islam, for me personally, it feels like the ending of a mystery novel. there were all these red herrings, characters with fake identities, there were hints, clues, or evidence i missed, embedded throughout the whole story. but only now do i see how much i overlooked. i still have much more to learn. but i'm looking forward to coming up with my own conclusions and analyzing what was once unquestionable.
@@ashleytheseeker8480 I think fear was the motivation given to me to remain. I found nothing romantic about izlame and left over 40 years ago. But, welcome to humanity 👍
Even Sunni sources which are inclined to be favourable toward him show him as being ignorant eg not knowing basic Masail like no restriction on mahr or rules about tayammun
The hatred of Umar may also have to do with the very invasion of Persia. He is accused of destroying Persian culture and so on. I remember watching a video where a religious representative in Iran said that Umar was worse than Alexander the Great because according to this person, Alexander the Great did not destroy Persian culture. Then, Shia Muslims have tried to present themselves as being different from Sunni
Building a big empire was in Umar's mind from the begining. That’s why he was working to raise a rough and tough emotionless male population. That’s the reason he was turning the society ultra conservative. I guesss he succeeded pretty good.
After reading about Islamic History, I think Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman knew that Muhammad was making up Allah and they were his partners in crime. However I think Ali was genuinely fooled by Muhammad like rest of the regular Arabs. He may have really thought Muhammad was prophet of Allah. Secondly I don't find character of Ali much repulsive by modern standards unlike Prophet and his other companions. He may had genuinely loved his 1st wife and children.
Yes, i agree with u, bro. In several occasions, Abu Bakr rejected Umar's proposal to compile the Quran. Abu Bakr and Zaid said it was not an order from Muhammad to compile the Quran.
It makes sense because when I was young they told me Ali was only a pre teen when Mo started to spread Islam. Mo also took care of Ali when his father was in poverty. So it wasn't hard for Mo to fool that kid
@@naira.carissa Ali took daughter of Yazdgerd the persian king whom arabs defeated as war booty.. She was a kid of 5 or 6 years of age.. I think her name was shahrbano.. So ali was not innocent
@@indicphilosopher8772 I was talking about him when he was a kid. I grew up reading the "disney version" of Islamic history, so I am pretty sure Ali was a kid when Mo first introduced Islam
@@saidrogerrm8896 Jesus was crucified, not killed by the sword. And He said: (Matthew 26:52) *_"Put your sword back in its place," Jesus said to him [Peter], "For all who draw the sword will die by the sword."_* To put it into perspective: (Sahih al-Bukhari 2818) *_Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Know that Paradise is under the shades of swords."_* I think these 2 teachings illustrate pretty well, the fundamental (opposing) differences between Christianity & Islam. Question is: *which one would you rather follow?*
@@naathnaath6377 Aaah, no? 😂 The "double-edged sword" is *Judgement* and the *Word of God* you genius! That whole passage is an allegoric hyperbole. _"He will be holding the sword in his teeth..."_ 😂😂 I don't mean to presume - but your conclusion wouldn't surprise if you are Muslim, tbh. I noticed Islam is a religion with a rather poorly developed abstract theology, or symbolic interpretation - in which things are taken *very literally.* And I'm sorry, but that is *not* spirituality.. That's a very childish understanding of spiritual matters.
Good topics. Also like how confident and clear you have become in your presentation from your first video on your coming out as exmoos. Keep up the good work, man.
Once again i'll say, when it comes to the stories and hadiths about the sahabis and what they had done. many muslims will say it was only the norm back then, now islam had been progressing and become better. When there are embarrassing and awful incidents involving the prophet or the sahabis, muslim will flip and said "that was just back then. now it's different." but when the topic about equality for women, homosexual, or even enforcement of hijab, muslim will be fixed on their stands and said that "the laws can never be changed for that. we must follow what had been stated on the quran or on the hadiths". the double standards..
Faut il vraiment que vous ecoutiez aux paroles d'une chimére qui ne vit qu'en critiquant les légendes qui ont fondé la civilisation ? Car oui, misérables et gueux sont ceux qui comme cette chimére (héla Ouardi) ne vivent que par la critique de personnes dont le déstin et les accomplissements légendaires ont faconnés leur légende et avec elle l'histoire d'une civilisation qui aura été le phare de l'humanité pendant des siécles... Cette chimére est soit stupide et cancre, soi de mauvaise fois car celui qui fait de l'histoire et qui se veut objectif n'écoute pas ces discussions de plateau a deux balles ou seuls les misérables trouvent plaisir a tenter de salir les honneurs des grands, celui qui se veut objectif et de bonne foi analyse les faits, des faits encrés dans l'histoire, voici des faits : Le caliphat Rashidun c'est : - Une expansion qui a partir de deux villages du hejaz aura conqueri tout les térritoires des portes de l'inde aux portes du maroc en seulement 14 ans et avec des moyens trés faibles, cela en ecrasant littéralement les deux empires les plus puissants de ce temps qui bien qu'ayant pérdurés des siécles se sont vus balayés en seulement 4 ans par des bédouins. - Une armée qui avec seulement 13 000 hommes (bédouins non formés) initialement en 632 et ayant atteint un maximum de 80 000 hommes en 636 ( mais cela aprés le gros des batailles ) a balayé deux empires dotés si on somme leur forces de 500 000 soldats en 4 années ( avec les batailles descisives d'al qadissiya et yarmouk qui se sont déroulées en 636) , source wikipedia : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_the_Sasanian_Empire en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_army en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashidun_army Cela bien sur sachant que ces 13 000 bédouins ne s'étaient jamais préparés a des guerre de grande ampleur, étaient faiblement equipés et manquaient d'éxpérience contrairement a quelques 500 000 hommes de l'autre coté. - Un passage de deux villages a un empire s'étandant de l'inde aux portes du maroc et ayant écrasé deux empires millénaires ayant prés de 50 fois plus de soldats et de moyens et cela avec peu de pertes. - Un ratio incroyable de batailles gagnées/pérdues, 97% de victoires de batailles : 75 et plus victoires, 3 défaites (retraites ) , toutes en désavantage numérique allant de deux fois plus a prés de 15 fois plus comme dans la bataille de Yarmouk. - Toutes les batailles du caliphat Rashidun se sont déroulées en territoir hostile ce qui constituait un grand désavantage (établissement d'administrations, routes de ravitaillement...) Une vidéo montrant la rapidité de l'éxpansion : th-cam.com/video/AvFl6UBZLv4/w-d-xo.html une autre du meme type mais plus en détail : th-cam.com/video/5XjiY3tQ038/w-d-xo.html Et enfin pour celui qui se veut vraiment objectif et historien, je lui propose ce documentaire neutre d'une chaine anglosaxone "kings and generals" qui rapporte des faits historiques sur l'éxpansion des rashidun et cela avec ennormenement de détails sur les batailles, les successions, c'est un documentaire d'une ennorme qualité fait pour des personnes qui analysent des FAITS... th-cam.com/video/r2cEIDZwG5M/w-d-xo.html Ce sera tout. Une fois de plus je vous demande sincérement de ne pas vous laissez emporter par des paroles de chiméres subjéctives comme le bateau se fait emporter par les vents d'une tempête, analysez des FAITS, étudiez l'histoire comme des historiens avec des analyses et des faits basés et non par le biais de plateaux/salons ou des misérables gueux ne font que bavarder et critiquer des légendes ayant forgé l'histoire, car un tel comportement ne revient qu'aux misérables qui ne sachant rien faire et étant de mauvaise fois iintérieurement se décident de jeter leur dépourvu sur des héros devant lequels ils ne réprésentent pas le poid d'une miétte. Sur cela je vous souhaite le bien et la bonne guidée.
Excellent work! Abdullah. This is just plain insanity. This is the unraveling of the senselessness of Islam let alone the focus on Umar. The mentality surrounding this is beyond sad.
Slapping your daughter because she wants to jump off the 10 storey building? You sure that will stop her from jumping Dr Naik? I'm sure if an irrational person got slapped, they'll be more irrational. How can he be a doctor again?
The way you rationalize through the logic of these dogma to discredit the integrity of these beliefs reminds me of the line of thought I was too afraid to ponder as a young child (a young child..of like 10). Thankfully, with age comes reason. And with reason - we do better
This is great content! It's becoming clear to me that surah 66 is enough to disprove islam. It's so obviously undivine even if you only look at the quran verses with no context, but when the backstories are added ... oh man. And the Umar interference gave this sordid affair yet another dimension.
This has to do with the occupation of Persia. I remember watching a TH-cam video with a religious representative in Iran saying that Peter the Great was better because he did not destroy Persian culture. that's what this person said. and remember there were many uprisings in Persia against the caliphate according to what I have read
Faut il vraiment que vous ecoutiez aux paroles d'une chimére qui ne vit qu'en critiquant les légendes qui ont fondé la civilisation ? Car oui, misérables et gueux sont ceux qui comme cette chimére (héla Ouardi) ne vivent que par la critique de personnes dont le déstin et les accomplissements légendaires ont faconnés leur légende et avec elle l'histoire d'une civilisation qui aura été le phare de l'humanité pendant des siécles... Cette chimére est soit stupide et cancre, soi de mauvaise fois car celui qui fait de l'histoire et qui se veut objectif n'écoute pas ces discussions de plateau a deux balles ou seuls les misérables trouvent plaisir a tenter de salir les honneurs des grands, celui qui se veut objectif et de bonne foi analyse les faits, des faits encrés dans l'histoire, voici des faits : Le caliphat Rashidun c'est : - Une expansion qui a partir de deux villages du hejaz aura conqueri tout les térritoires des portes de l'inde aux portes du maroc en seulement 14 ans et avec des moyens trés faibles, cela en ecrasant littéralement les deux empires les plus puissants de ce temps qui bien qu'ayant pérdurés des siécles se sont vus balayés en seulement 4 ans par des bédouins. - Une armée qui avec seulement 13 000 hommes (bédouins non formés) initialement en 632 et ayant atteint un maximum de 80 000 hommes en 636 ( mais cela aprés le gros des batailles ) a balayé deux empires dotés si on somme leur forces de 500 000 soldats en 4 années ( avec les batailles descisives d'al qadissiya et yarmouk qui se sont déroulées en 636) , source wikipedia : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_the_Sasanian_Empire en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_army en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashidun_army Cela bien sur sachant que ces 13 000 bédouins ne s'étaient jamais préparés a des guerre de grande ampleur, étaient faiblement equipés et manquaient d'éxpérience contrairement a quelques 500 000 hommes de l'autre coté. - Un passage de deux villages a un empire s'étandant de l'inde aux portes du maroc et ayant écrasé deux empires millénaires ayant prés de 50 fois plus de soldats et de moyens et cela avec peu de pertes. - Un ratio incroyable de batailles gagnées/pérdues, 97% de victoires de batailles : 75 et plus victoires, 3 défaites (retraites ) , toutes en désavantage numérique allant de deux fois plus a prés de 15 fois plus comme dans la bataille de Yarmouk. - Toutes les batailles du caliphat Rashidun se sont déroulées en territoir hostile ce qui constituait un grand désavantage (établissement d'administrations, routes de ravitaillement...) Une vidéo montrant la rapidité de l'éxpansion : th-cam.com/video/AvFl6UBZLv4/w-d-xo.html une autre du meme type mais plus en détail : th-cam.com/video/5XjiY3tQ038/w-d-xo.html Et enfin pour celui qui se veut vraiment objectif et historien, je lui propose ce documentaire neutre d'une chaine anglosaxone "kings and generals" qui rapporte des faits historiques sur l'éxpansion des rashidun et cela avec ennormenement de détails sur les batailles, les successions, c'est un documentaire d'une ennorme qualité fait pour des personnes qui analysent des FAITS... th-cam.com/video/r2cEIDZwG5M/w-d-xo.html Ce sera tout. Une fois de plus je vous demande sincérement de ne pas vous laissez emporter par des paroles de chiméres subjéctives comme le bateau se fait emporter par les vents d'une tempête, analysez des FAITS, étudiez l'histoire comme des historiens avec des analyses et des faits basés et non par le biais de plateaux/salons ou des misérables gueux ne font que bavarder et critiquer des légendes ayant forgé l'histoire, car un tel comportement ne revient qu'aux misérables qui ne sachant rien faire et étant de mauvaise fois iintérieurement se décident de jeter leur dépourvu sur des héros devant lequels ils ne réprésentent pas le poid d'une miétte. Sur cela je vous souhaite le bien et la bonne guidée.
Anyone who dont offer his wife to the messenger of Allah can,t be a muslim for real.If the prophet loves a woman its obligatory for her husband to divorce her immediately donate her to Rasoolullah and find beautiful hoors alongwith pure wine in jannah as much as he wants.
Bruh, When I was a Muslim I didn't know his history but I wanted to be like him cuz our names bruh I'm glad I don't wanna in hell be even an inch like him😭😭
many things i find out every day - 3 months i left - and it gets crazy every day - the most crazy part is that i still do my prayers, so my family does not find out - all this is crazy - this is crazy
I wonder if these two hadiths at the beginning wouldn't instantly have made me deeply question Islam if I were a muslim. I mean, I get it, the religion claims that Muhammad is the prophet of god. You sure somehow have to accept this silly claim if you want to be in the game, but Umar is just a guy like everyone else. There is no way that saying "there is no Angel in heaven that does not respect Umar" is not a clear statement from nepotism which would make Muhammad a liar who makes stuff up in his and his family's favor.
Hey Abdullah please remember he is a medical doctor. The problem is you have more reason and logic to share than this guy will ever gather in 500 lifetimes (while being a medical doctor).
It goes to show how ancient the devil is that a lot of demonic foolishness was taking place for a long time. But it's coming to an end not long from now.
I didn't get it this time; but oftentimes I do get islamic ads looking for funding to build masjids before his videos ... I hate to watch them when they do come up and they drive me crazy; but I do watch them as the ads supposedly help Abdullah Sameer.
Sorry if you already know this but the ads have to do with what you watch and as far as I can tell, since ex-Mulim and Muslim both fall under the general category of Islam, so long as you watch Islam related videos, you will get Islam related ads! It is somewhat absurd to experience, but it's important to remember that the content creator has no control over which ads you see. Good health to you!
If you respectfully enjoy wine (the flavor, the aroma, the mouth feel, and the alcohol) then the benefit is NOT just from the grapes. If you are addicted, you should definitely avoid alcohol because at that point it is harmful to you and those around you. Same is true if you are weak and can't control yourself. Otherwise there's no reason not to enjoy that isn't stupidstition! 🍷
non-muslim, ex muslim please don't fall into his trap. What he is saying is isn't true at all. He left Islam maybe. He is picking the lame, unverified narrations out of his bigotry and to calm his soul, heart that he did something good by becoming an ex-muslim. Also please verify the authenticity of narrations by yourself. Every Muslim admire Omar R.A . Even Christians and jews at that time admired Omar R.A. that's why Omar was handed over the Palestine (holy place of major religion) by the Christians without shedding single drop of blood. Christians writers wrote "had Omar R.A lived for another decade, Islam would have conquered the whole World" . Omar laws are still intact in some parts of the world, these laws are called Omar Laws(as He R.A introduced them first). How can you deny the greatness of Omar R.A even if you are non-muslim. If you admire Alexander who burnt down cities, raped women, killed children then don't be a bigot or hypocrite and deny the greatness of Omar R.A.
Yes, only pick sahih narrations before judging... sunnah.com/bukhari/64/182 sunnah.com/muslim/4/299 sunnah.com/bukhari/67/130 sunnah.com/muslim/49/6 sunnah.com/bukhari/6/9 sunnah.com/bukhari:6812 sunnah.com/bukhari/86/25 sunnah.com/bukhari/88/5 sunnah.com/muslim:1668a sunnah.com/bukhari/51/26 sunnah.com/bukhari/44/6 sunnah.com/bukhari/87/53 sunnah.com/muslim:651c sunnah.com/bukhari:233 sunnah.com/bukhari/64/381 sunnah.com/muslim/39/16 sunnah.com/muslim/54/105 sunnah.com/muslim/50/60 sunnah.com/muslim/50/58 sunnah.com/muslim/29/45 sunnah.com/muslim/32/79 sunnah.com/urn/1268350 sunnah.com/muslim:1668a sunnah.com/bukhari/51/26 sunnah.com/bukhari/44/6 and about THREE HUNDREDS more like that...
Greatness of Omar is no different from the greatness of Alexander, the greatness of Rome, the greatness of Genghis Khan, the greatness of the Victorian empire or the greatness of USSR. Just another glory dictatorship in the ripples of time.
The fact that she was sent to Umar was because she was already given in marriage. In Islam no man can be alone with a woman who is not closely related to him.
Oh Omar, he who contributed to the Quran, alongside Allah (aka Mohammed)! How dare Mohammed challenge “Mankind and the Jinn To Produce the Like of This Qur'an” when HE clearly wrote (at least) three parts of the Quran based upon suggestions from Omar!!? It is reported by Annas, the Omar bin Al Khatab said: “My almighty agreed with me in three things: (First), I said, 'Oh Allah's Apostle, I wish if [you would] take as your place of worship the place where Abraham did [have his] place to pray. It so came, the Divine Inspiration: (Qur'an 2:125) And take you (Muslims) the place of Abraham as a place of prayer.' (Second), And I said to the Prophet, to the prophet of Allah, 'Good and bad ones talk to your wives, therefore order them to veil themselves!' So Allah sent down the concerning the veiling of the women (Qur’an 24:31). (Third), the wives of the Prophet made a coalition against the Prophet, and I said to them, 'Maybe if his, the lord of the Prophet, divorced you, (all the wives) and exchange you with better wives than you.' So the verse revealed (Qur’an 66:5) the same as I had said.” You can see the same story in Sahih Al-Bukhari (Book 8, Hadith 395).
I am William James, the one who send you information regarding the question no Muslim Apologists can answer, I want to give you more details but you keep ignoring me.
@@FriendlyExmuslim I am not talking about doing the video, I am talking about information which is more details. I want to keep on sending you information and more details regarding the topic. Can I do that brother.
I realize this wasnt the message of the entire video but I'd like to put here that I disagree with the statement that all relationships between husband & wife must have arguements to be healthy. I would never argue with the love of my life.
Asking for money or "causing pain" is equivalent to jumping off from a 10 storeyed building 😳😮????? Looks like logic has taken a *total* leave of absence from this man 🤦🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️.
The man who was executed in his own home by Umar's sword - the sentence was inevitable from the beginning; no reaching for a measured verdict based on reason and merits. Law based on a contract entered into before you were born: breach of which is sin of disobedience. This is what believers enslave inferiors and their own unworthy selves by, Animals too and women are separately created -wombs are our weapons, said Yasser Araffat. Former muslim women rid themselves of modesty segregationist dress codes and the blameless whiteness of Mary the virgin who gave birth to a sinless child; must deal with pychological trauma to impossibly achieve living fully and completely in dignity and freedom. Interfaith connivance - ubiiquitous visibility and presence of Morality dress is in denial of brutality of hatred of unbelief, and that human rights are the legal expression of life A code of: hate what Alah hates, love what Allah loves. is lifted from:'Jesus is my master'- war on infidels; the man's pride and arrogance is in party with Iblis. He would have sympathy with infidels - teach falsely intercession for them.
before a calamity befall isreal (in the past), they were surrounded by people who had the culture of worshipping idols. does it mean then its good and acceptable for the isreal to worship idols then? obviously not. what in the earth even is the argument of: people were doing it back then, thus its right back then but not now
Hi sameer, in regards to what zakir naik said "anyone who does not love allah and his prophet more than their own life is not muslim." Could you please explain taqqiya with respect to above? Isn't taqiyya means deceive others and suggests to not disclose your true faith if your life is under threat? If you could explain?
hey murtad....why islam is always in ur mind....it was ur past...just move ahead....why r u being like remembering ur ex wife instead of stick to ur present wife. You should not complain about ur ex wife if u have left it.
Your prophet died and left a bunch of ex wives, but Allah told all believers to not marry anything of his wife. Why couldn’t he let his ex wife go? Why keep them in bondage
Why in your channel have advertisement to ask for donation to build mosque in the State ...do you think you can do something to get rid of this ad on your channel ...I find it really annoying to hear about it
I understand why you left islam because you were only taught nonsense and study nonsense all your life lol Therefore you left the nonsense that you taught were islam whereas it was just nonsense and now you are educating people against that same nonsense .
@@gloriascientiae7435 man only the sheep who just follow what they have heard believe in that . How come I don't believe in that . They are million of Muslim who don't believe in that . And by the way how can this kind of teaching make even senses. If a person is really searching for truth they will find it on their own instead of relying on people . Reason why releigon is failing because we are not looking inward but looking in books
@harishkumar india imagine someone travelled trough a route and get to hea destination, now you wanting to go to the same place you ask the person for guidance to which he reply if you follow this way you will reach your destination but if you want also you can do as I did and find your way on your own untill you reach to where you going but at the end since everybody is looking for an easy way out they will follow his way and get to the destination but the experience is not the same as the one who travelled trough pain, and confusion that he went trough reason why the quran says Do the people think that they will be left to say, "We believe" and they will not be tried? We certainly tested those before them. And ˹in this way˺ Allah will clearly distinguish between those who are truthful and those who are liars So I say to you the quran is just a book of guidance to those who want to use it and also it is a book of jikr reminding you that which you already know about, cause whatever in in the quran is already been said by the people of the past . Nothing is new, the only difference is the time and the people to which it was revealed that time . I'm not here expecting each one to be a Muslim or a christian or Hindu or budhist. You have to find out yourself what you are more in alignment with instead of relying with label. There have been many previous wise person's that came before us, people who spent their time meditating days and night just like Jesus , muhammad , budhas, lao-tzu , Osho, sadhguru , so on and so forth . These people are teaching the same thing that all other previous wise people taught . So again instead of painting fingers at other book or faith why don't you look within yourself and work on the evil that is harboring within your heart like envy jealousy hatred lust etc....
Thanks for creating this video, to all the muslims who are feeling angry, you have all the rights to do so, not on the video creator but the authors of buqari & sahi muslim who made up these stories, let me correct she married to Mohammad ibn e Jaffer e tayar and her elder sister zainab married to Abdullah ibne Jaffer tayar these bastards made up the stories, these made up story to justify the rule of rushideen is what ruined the islamic religion, & what made me and any other religions observer leave the religion
You only realise when you leave the religion how much lies you're told about the greatness of the sahaba, looking back at when I was a kid I was indoctrinated so much
@Swoosh Swish You won't have to be a closet Ex-Muslim for that much longer. It's becoming more widespread, far more widespread. In my home country of Kerala in India, it's a phenomenon.
@@paulthomas281 same thing in the arab countries .. a lot of ex-muslims here from Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Tunisia we have Communities on TH-cam and twitter and Facebook .. it's a worldwide phenomenon.
@Tiberian Sun I act a skeptic Muslim here lol 😆
Learn teach and spread his word. Save others
@CHEANG HAN BIN Moe Aaaah, that is *so true.* And very wise saying. Did you come up with it?
As an ex-muslim what bothers me is knowing all these and not being able to share them with my friends/family/in social media. Most of the people are unaware of all these disturbing things and the ones who know all these aren’t allowed to say these things or else they will get killed. It’s so frustrating.
This event has been confirmed by lots of molvis including Molana Ishaq Madani ,the righteous one.Watch his reply on this matter.
It actually happened in all of abrahamic religion. Something is weird about this arabic religion.
Dear Akbar, you can always share that kind of hadith with other Muslims and your friends, just say it from the perspective of a believer who has some problem with this hadith. In that case, you are sure that no one can accuse you and tell you that you are Murtad or Kaffer etc. . You are planting a seed of doubt in others' minds, that in time could grow and become a powerful tree.
I am exactly in the same position, unable to share my knowledge with other Muslims, relatives and colleagues. I have been asked to shut up 😩
Agree 100%.
Sauda: Goes out to take a dump
Umar: "Sauda! I can see you!"
Sauda: "Mo, Umar won't let me take a crap in peace"
Mo: "God allows you to take a dump, now let me finish my chicken dinner"
That creepy fucker really stalked his friends litersl wives...
Yeah seriously! I just learned about this a few hours ago! (Sahih Bukhari 146) Sauda wife of Muhammad catches red-handed (or perhaps white-handed) my man Umar watching her do the real business, and Umar manages to talk his way out of it. Unless I'm mistaken, that story is one of the arguments for niqabs. These guys are too much. XD Speechcraft 100.
(Hail Ishtar)
🤣
very recent ex-muslim here. i think something very interesting is to look back at my experiences (as a muslim) and realize things that i otherwise wouldn't have realized.
in school we were taught about the companions of muhammad. umar was described as "strict", but in a good way. so he was portrayed to us as strong, courageous, even if he was strict it was for the good of islam, etc. i can't believe he was supposed to be our role model or something.
another thing is i remember my teacher telling the class about killing apostates as a "strategy" of upholding islam. now i'm like... how did we not question that?!
leaving islam, for me personally, it feels like the ending of a mystery novel. there were all these red herrings, characters with fake identities, there were hints, clues, or evidence i missed, embedded throughout the whole story. but only now do i see how much i overlooked.
i still have much more to learn. but i'm looking forward to coming up with my own conclusions and analyzing what was once unquestionable.
Please look into shia islam
Well written. As an apostate (discreetly) since 1977, I had the same thoughts.
Yeah it's all romanticized. As I got older I realized this was utter chaos. 😳
@@ashleytheseeker8480 I think fear was the motivation given to me to remain. I found nothing romantic about izlame and left over 40 years ago. But, welcome to humanity 👍
@@dasaadz :(
A much needed expose on Umar who his own Islamic sources portray as quite the hot head.
Even Sunni sources which are inclined to be favourable toward him show him as being ignorant eg not knowing basic Masail like no restriction on mahr or rules about tayammun
@@ma55382uk is it possible that sunni being so strict bc of him?
The hatred of Umar may also have to do with the very invasion of Persia. He is accused of destroying Persian culture and so on. I remember watching a video where a religious representative in Iran said that Umar was worse than Alexander the Great because according to this person, Alexander the Great did not destroy Persian culture. Then, Shia Muslims have tried to present themselves as being different from Sunni
He's not wrong. Alexander pursued a form of Greco-Persian cultural synthesis and largely left the Persian administration intact.
Persians were hardcore sunnis before becoming Shia in the safavid era. The Shia heartlands were throroughly arab.
Umar was Muhammad "best friend". That's why.
Umar did beat up a slave for wearing Hijab. Although Hijab is only for free Muslim woman not for slave.
Ali was better
@@sullyqureshi676 Ali was justice
but majority prefered omar and muiywa
@@sullyqureshi676not much better, he was the same
What do you think of Imam Hussain?
Building a big empire was in Umar's mind from the begining. That’s why he was working to raise a rough and tough emotionless male population. That’s the reason he was turning the society ultra conservative. I guesss he succeeded pretty good.
After reading about Islamic History, I think Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman knew that Muhammad was making up Allah and they were his partners in crime.
However I think Ali was genuinely fooled by Muhammad like rest of the regular Arabs. He may have really thought Muhammad was prophet of Allah.
Secondly I don't find character of Ali much repulsive by modern standards unlike Prophet and his other companions. He may had genuinely loved his 1st wife and children.
Yes, i agree with u, bro.
In several occasions, Abu Bakr rejected Umar's proposal to compile the Quran. Abu Bakr and Zaid said it was not an order from Muhammad to compile the Quran.
It makes sense because when I was young they told me Ali was only a pre teen when Mo started to spread Islam. Mo also took care of Ali when his father was in poverty. So it wasn't hard for Mo to fool that kid
@@naira.carissa
Ali took daughter of Yazdgerd the persian king whom arabs defeated as war booty.. She was a kid of 5 or 6 years of age.. I think her name was shahrbano.. So ali was not innocent
@@indicphilosopher8772 Ali WAS innocent, but he got brainwashed
@@indicphilosopher8772 I was talking about him when he was a kid. I grew up reading the "disney version" of Islamic history, so I am pretty sure Ali was a kid when Mo first introduced Islam
In a world of warlords, it’s all about fear of the sword.
BUT JESUS TOLD HOWEVER KILLS BY THE SWORD WILL BE KILLED BY THE SWORD THATS WHAT FINELY HAPENED TO HIM
Exactly.
@@saidrogerrm8896 Jesus was crucified, not killed by the sword. And He said:
(Matthew 26:52)
*_"Put your sword back in its place," Jesus said to him [Peter], "For all who draw the sword will die by the sword."_*
To put it into perspective:
(Sahih al-Bukhari 2818)
*_Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Know that Paradise is under the shades of swords."_*
I think these 2 teachings illustrate pretty well, the fundamental (opposing) differences between Christianity & Islam. Question is: *which one would you rather follow?*
@@dyawr
When Jesus returns,he will be holding the sword in his teeth...
True or false .
In the Bible or not?
19:15 🤔
@@naathnaath6377 Aaah, no? 😂 The "double-edged sword" is *Judgement* and the *Word of God* you genius! That whole passage is an allegoric hyperbole.
_"He will be holding the sword in his teeth..."_ 😂😂
I don't mean to presume - but your conclusion wouldn't surprise if you are Muslim, tbh. I noticed Islam is a religion with a rather poorly developed abstract theology, or symbolic interpretation - in which things are taken *very literally.*
And I'm sorry, but that is *not* spirituality.. That's a very childish understanding of spiritual matters.
Good topics. Also like how confident and clear you have become in your presentation from your first video on your coming out as exmoos.
Keep up the good work, man.
I died at male Karen 🤣😂🤣
Once again i'll say, when it comes to the stories and hadiths about the sahabis and what they had done. many muslims will say it was only the norm back then, now islam had been progressing and become better. When there are embarrassing and awful incidents involving the prophet or the sahabis, muslim will flip and said "that was just back then. now it's different." but when the topic about equality for women, homosexual, or even enforcement of hijab, muslim will be fixed on their stands and said that "the laws can never be changed for that. we must follow what had been stated on the quran or on the hadiths". the double standards..
Faut il vraiment que vous ecoutiez aux paroles d'une chimére qui ne vit qu'en critiquant les légendes qui ont fondé la civilisation ? Car oui, misérables et gueux sont ceux qui comme cette chimére (héla Ouardi) ne vivent que par la critique de personnes dont le déstin et les accomplissements légendaires ont faconnés leur légende et avec elle l'histoire d'une civilisation qui aura été le phare de l'humanité pendant des siécles...
Cette chimére est soit stupide et cancre, soi de mauvaise fois car celui qui fait de l'histoire et qui se veut objectif n'écoute pas ces discussions de plateau a deux balles ou seuls les misérables trouvent plaisir a tenter de salir les honneurs des grands, celui qui se veut objectif et de bonne foi analyse les faits, des faits encrés dans l'histoire, voici des faits :
Le caliphat Rashidun c'est :
- Une expansion qui a partir de deux villages du hejaz aura conqueri tout les térritoires des portes de l'inde aux portes du maroc en seulement 14 ans et avec des moyens trés faibles, cela en ecrasant littéralement les deux empires les plus puissants de ce temps qui bien qu'ayant pérdurés des siécles se sont vus balayés en seulement 4 ans par des bédouins.
- Une armée qui avec seulement 13 000 hommes (bédouins non formés) initialement en 632 et ayant atteint un maximum de 80 000 hommes en 636 ( mais cela aprés le gros des batailles ) a balayé deux empires dotés si on somme leur forces de 500 000 soldats en 4 années ( avec les batailles descisives d'al qadissiya et yarmouk qui se sont déroulées en 636) , source wikipedia :
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_the_Sasanian_Empire
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_army
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashidun_army
Cela bien sur sachant que ces 13 000 bédouins ne s'étaient jamais préparés a des guerre de grande ampleur, étaient faiblement equipés et manquaient d'éxpérience contrairement a quelques 500 000 hommes de l'autre coté.
- Un passage de deux villages a un empire s'étandant de l'inde aux portes du maroc et ayant écrasé deux empires millénaires ayant prés de 50 fois plus de soldats et de moyens et cela avec peu de pertes.
- Un ratio incroyable de batailles gagnées/pérdues, 97% de victoires de batailles : 75 et plus victoires, 3 défaites (retraites ) , toutes en désavantage numérique allant de deux fois plus a prés de 15 fois plus comme dans la bataille de Yarmouk.
- Toutes les batailles du caliphat Rashidun se sont déroulées en territoir hostile ce qui constituait un grand désavantage (établissement d'administrations, routes de ravitaillement...)
Une vidéo montrant la rapidité de l'éxpansion :
th-cam.com/video/AvFl6UBZLv4/w-d-xo.html
une autre du meme type mais plus en détail :
th-cam.com/video/5XjiY3tQ038/w-d-xo.html
Et enfin pour celui qui se veut vraiment objectif et historien, je lui propose ce documentaire neutre d'une chaine anglosaxone "kings and generals" qui rapporte des faits historiques sur l'éxpansion des rashidun et cela avec ennormenement de détails sur les batailles, les successions, c'est un documentaire d'une ennorme qualité fait pour des personnes qui analysent des FAITS...
th-cam.com/video/r2cEIDZwG5M/w-d-xo.html
Ce sera tout. Une fois de plus je vous demande sincérement de ne pas vous laissez emporter par des paroles de chiméres subjéctives comme le bateau se fait emporter par les vents d'une tempête, analysez des FAITS, étudiez l'histoire comme des historiens avec des analyses et des faits basés et non par le biais de plateaux/salons ou des misérables gueux ne font que bavarder et critiquer des légendes ayant forgé l'histoire, car un tel comportement ne revient qu'aux misérables qui ne sachant rien faire et étant de mauvaise fois iintérieurement se décident de jeter leur dépourvu sur des héros devant lequels ils ne réprésentent pas le poid d'une miétte.
Sur cela je vous souhaite le bien et la bonne guidée.
Dang, I love how Abdullah is enjoying himself in these vids.
Probably my favourite ex-Muslim on YT.
Thanks!
Christian Prince just did a breakdown of Omar as well.
Excellent work! Abdullah. This is just plain insanity. This is the unraveling of the senselessness of Islam let alone the focus on Umar. The mentality surrounding this is beyond sad.
Slapping your daughter because she wants to jump off the 10 storey building? You sure that will stop her from jumping Dr Naik? I'm sure if an irrational person got slapped, they'll be more irrational. How can he be a doctor again?
SEE HOW BACKWARDS THIS ZAKIR IS .SLAP YOU DAUGHTER WHEN SHE WOULD JUMP OF A TOWER ????????????????? ONBELIEVEBLE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Seriously that would piss me off even more 😂😂
you surprise me every time with these serious contents 👍👍👍😚❤
Zakir naik makes me cringe like no one else.
The way you rationalize through the logic of these dogma to discredit the integrity of these beliefs reminds me of the line of thought I was too afraid to ponder as a young child (a young child..of like 10). Thankfully, with age comes reason. And with reason - we do better
The male Karen had me rolling 😂😂😂😂
This is great content! It's becoming clear to me that surah 66 is enough to disprove islam. It's so obviously undivine even if you only look at the quran verses with no context, but when the backstories are added ... oh man. And the Umar interference gave this sordid affair yet another dimension.
An evil leader will only attract other evil leaders. Just look around the world and we will see this trend is universal
There are no historical records for all four caliphs.
But surely they were living in that famous trade centre called Mecca!
@@Basaljet or that famous trade centre called Petra! Mecca in the Hejaz is a later "holy city" in Islamic history, but Muslims don't know this.
You need to start such video by defining "good".
Because Islam clearly has different definitions for even human rights (Cairo declaration).
In islam good is haram and bad is halal
@@JackSmith-qi2sl Pretty sure it's backwards.
I mean I'm yet to see "haram" labelled meat at the market.
Unless you're being sarcastic, then agreed...
@@el_killorcure haram labelled meat is just meat that isn’t labelled halal
@@JackSmith-qi2sl Like kosher labelled meat?
@@el_killorcure i think in islam kosher counts as halal
Yes,Umar,s statement on prophets wives problem has been mentioned by Urdu speaking preachers exactly what you told .
Allah's revelation actually Muhammad inventions...in many occasions in Sahih hadeeth.. Muhammad protect himself with the so called revelation...
Watch "Lady of Heaven" as an intro to the scoundrel that is Omar.
If people copy the ways of the Sahaba today they would be criminals
Exactly!!
This has to do with the occupation of Persia. I remember watching a TH-cam video with a religious representative in Iran saying that Peter the Great was better because he did not destroy Persian culture. that's what this person said. and remember there were many uprisings in Persia against the caliphate according to what I have read
It would be quire hard for the Russian emperor from the 17th century to destroy the Persian culture ;)
Don't forget his Umar's loving & generous Pact with the Christians of Syria and Palestine.
Maybe you read the whitewashed pact of Omar 😃😃😃
@@peteroye1216
Everything is whitewashed for you.. Dont play victim
@@indicphilosopher8772 okay. Maybe it was blackwashed then 😂😂😂
Don't need to play victim, unlike you folks that shout Islamophobia all around.
@@peteroye1216
Islamophobia is necessary when islam is hell bent on denying all other faiths as wrong..
@@peteroye1216
Did you know Mohammad called black people RAISINHEADS..
I am not joking..
These stories are so messed up. Thanks mr. Sameer.
if i say these things to my family or friends they think i am blaspheming. (most of muslims have no idea who is teaching them spiritual stuff.)
It's still a mystery on why umar followed muhammad, and umar seemed to love him and abu bakr so much, he also seemed to believe in the whole BS.
Keep up the good work Abdullah
how could i beleive so many years that Umar was the greatest companion - finding out daily that Islam is a collection of horror stories
Is he even really real or a literary device invented by the Abassids?
Neither Muhammad.
We shall never know and for all practical purposes it's irrelevant. After all, perhaps Jesus is also fictional.
Yeah he was real lol
I only know this bc his bloodline exists today
@@diabloakland yeah right and he had no surviving children so how does that work
Male karen best description of him. He even told his daughter that she isn’t pretty than Aisha.
Medical dakter has a good sense of imagination to mislead others.
No he wasn’t. He was a devil.
Faut il vraiment que vous ecoutiez aux paroles d'une chimére qui ne vit qu'en critiquant les légendes qui ont fondé la civilisation ? Car oui, misérables et gueux sont ceux qui comme cette chimére (héla Ouardi) ne vivent que par la critique de personnes dont le déstin et les accomplissements légendaires ont faconnés leur légende et avec elle l'histoire d'une civilisation qui aura été le phare de l'humanité pendant des siécles...
Cette chimére est soit stupide et cancre, soi de mauvaise fois car celui qui fait de l'histoire et qui se veut objectif n'écoute pas ces discussions de plateau a deux balles ou seuls les misérables trouvent plaisir a tenter de salir les honneurs des grands, celui qui se veut objectif et de bonne foi analyse les faits, des faits encrés dans l'histoire, voici des faits :
Le caliphat Rashidun c'est :
- Une expansion qui a partir de deux villages du hejaz aura conqueri tout les térritoires des portes de l'inde aux portes du maroc en seulement 14 ans et avec des moyens trés faibles, cela en ecrasant littéralement les deux empires les plus puissants de ce temps qui bien qu'ayant pérdurés des siécles se sont vus balayés en seulement 4 ans par des bédouins.
- Une armée qui avec seulement 13 000 hommes (bédouins non formés) initialement en 632 et ayant atteint un maximum de 80 000 hommes en 636 ( mais cela aprés le gros des batailles ) a balayé deux empires dotés si on somme leur forces de 500 000 soldats en 4 années ( avec les batailles descisives d'al qadissiya et yarmouk qui se sont déroulées en 636) , source wikipedia :
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_the_Sasanian_Empire
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_army
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashidun_army
Cela bien sur sachant que ces 13 000 bédouins ne s'étaient jamais préparés a des guerre de grande ampleur, étaient faiblement equipés et manquaient d'éxpérience contrairement a quelques 500 000 hommes de l'autre coté.
- Un passage de deux villages a un empire s'étandant de l'inde aux portes du maroc et ayant écrasé deux empires millénaires ayant prés de 50 fois plus de soldats et de moyens et cela avec peu de pertes.
- Un ratio incroyable de batailles gagnées/pérdues, 97% de victoires de batailles : 75 et plus victoires, 3 défaites (retraites ) , toutes en désavantage numérique allant de deux fois plus a prés de 15 fois plus comme dans la bataille de Yarmouk.
- Toutes les batailles du caliphat Rashidun se sont déroulées en territoir hostile ce qui constituait un grand désavantage (établissement d'administrations, routes de ravitaillement...)
Une vidéo montrant la rapidité de l'éxpansion :
th-cam.com/video/AvFl6UBZLv4/w-d-xo.html
une autre du meme type mais plus en détail :
th-cam.com/video/5XjiY3tQ038/w-d-xo.html
Et enfin pour celui qui se veut vraiment objectif et historien, je lui propose ce documentaire neutre d'une chaine anglosaxone "kings and generals" qui rapporte des faits historiques sur l'éxpansion des rashidun et cela avec ennormenement de détails sur les batailles, les successions, c'est un documentaire d'une ennorme qualité fait pour des personnes qui analysent des FAITS...
th-cam.com/video/r2cEIDZwG5M/w-d-xo.html
Ce sera tout. Une fois de plus je vous demande sincérement de ne pas vous laissez emporter par des paroles de chiméres subjéctives comme le bateau se fait emporter par les vents d'une tempête, analysez des FAITS, étudiez l'histoire comme des historiens avec des analyses et des faits basés et non par le biais de plateaux/salons ou des misérables gueux ne font que bavarder et critiquer des légendes ayant forgé l'histoire, car un tel comportement ne revient qu'aux misérables qui ne sachant rien faire et étant de mauvaise fois iintérieurement se décident de jeter leur dépourvu sur des héros devant lequels ils ne réprésentent pas le poid d'une miétte.
Sur cela je vous souhaite le bien et la bonne guidée.
Anyone who dont offer his wife to the messenger of Allah can,t be a muslim for real.If the prophet loves a woman its obligatory for her husband to divorce her immediately donate her to Rasoolullah and find beautiful hoors alongwith pure wine in jannah as much as he wants.
But the poor wives get nothing only used old men who are whoring around.
Bruh, When I was a Muslim I didn't know his history but I wanted to be like him cuz our names bruh I'm glad I don't wanna in hell be even an inch like him😭😭
Zakeir naik and his likes is a big problem
It's like Muhammed was George Bush while Umar was Dick Cheney. Islam is the worst kind of MLM
many things i find out every day - 3 months i left - and it gets crazy every day - the most crazy part is that i still do my prayers, so my family does not find out - all this is crazy - this is crazy
You are the definition of munafiq, by islamic standard
I wonder if these two hadiths at the beginning wouldn't instantly have made me deeply question Islam if I were a muslim. I mean, I get it, the religion claims that Muhammad is the prophet of god. You sure somehow have to accept this silly claim if you want to be in the game, but Umar is just a guy like everyone else. There is no way that saying "there is no Angel in heaven that does not respect Umar" is not a clear statement from nepotism which would make Muhammad a liar who makes stuff up in his and his family's favor.
Hey Abdullah please remember he is a medical doctor.
The problem is you have more reason and logic to share than this guy will ever gather in 500 lifetimes (while being a medical doctor).
Really reminds me of ‘Animal Farm’.
Go read about omar in the book of Michael H. Hart
Why was the FIRST Arabic reference to Muhammad: sixty years after his traditional death date!
1:50 horrifying, creepy man! He would have had a knock on the door from the police in a civilised, moral society.
ZAKiR naik does not let people respond
I liked mostly hear from the ex Muslims the real story of prophet Muhammad
Thanks for the support.
AND DID OMAR NOT BURIED HIS GIRL ALIVE ?????????????
was he muslim or not when he did that
answer is no
Oh... interesting...
Having lost upper and lower teeth, grandpa Mohd felt convenient to satisfy his 12 wives and 67 concubines with his fluffy mouth🤭
Things are only good or bad in relation to a moral standard. I might find them offensive, but that is just my moral standard.
It goes to show how ancient the devil is that a lot of demonic foolishness was taking place for a long time. But it's coming to an end not long from now.
Oh brother ...
Apparently there is an islamic ad just before ya video
I didn't get it this time; but oftentimes I do get islamic ads looking for funding to build masjids before his videos ... I hate to watch them when they do come up and they drive me crazy; but I do watch them as the ads supposedly help Abdullah Sameer.
Sorry if you already know this but the ads have to do with what you watch and as far as I can tell, since ex-Mulim and Muslim both fall under the general category of Islam, so long as you watch Islam related videos, you will get Islam related ads!
It is somewhat absurd to experience, but it's important to remember that the content creator has no control over which ads you see.
Good health to you!
The benefits of drinking wine isn't in the alcohol, its in the grapes.
One of your five a day
If you respectfully enjoy wine (the flavor, the aroma, the mouth feel, and the alcohol) then the benefit is NOT just from the grapes.
If you are addicted, you should definitely avoid alcohol because at that point it is harmful to you and those around you.
Same is true if you are weak and can't control yourself.
Otherwise there's no reason not to enjoy that isn't stupidstition! 🍷
Omar is the real god.
If he can dictate to a prophet, you must be right😁
non-muslim, ex muslim please don't fall into his trap. What he is saying is isn't true at all. He left Islam maybe. He is picking the lame, unverified narrations out of his bigotry and to calm his soul, heart that he did something good by becoming an ex-muslim. Also please verify the authenticity of narrations by yourself.
Every Muslim admire Omar R.A . Even Christians and jews at that time admired Omar R.A. that's why Omar was handed over the Palestine (holy place of major religion) by the Christians without shedding single drop of blood. Christians writers wrote "had Omar R.A lived for another decade, Islam would have conquered the whole World" . Omar laws are still intact in some parts of the world, these laws are called Omar Laws(as He R.A introduced them first). How can you deny the greatness of Omar R.A even if you are non-muslim. If you admire Alexander who burnt down cities, raped women, killed children then don't be a bigot or hypocrite and deny the greatness of Omar R.A.
BullS#it
Yes, only pick sahih narrations before judging...
sunnah.com/bukhari/64/182
sunnah.com/muslim/4/299
sunnah.com/bukhari/67/130
sunnah.com/muslim/49/6
sunnah.com/bukhari/6/9
sunnah.com/bukhari:6812
sunnah.com/bukhari/86/25
sunnah.com/bukhari/88/5
sunnah.com/muslim:1668a
sunnah.com/bukhari/51/26
sunnah.com/bukhari/44/6
sunnah.com/bukhari/87/53
sunnah.com/muslim:651c
sunnah.com/bukhari:233
sunnah.com/bukhari/64/381
sunnah.com/muslim/39/16
sunnah.com/muslim/54/105
sunnah.com/muslim/50/60
sunnah.com/muslim/50/58
sunnah.com/muslim/29/45
sunnah.com/muslim/32/79
sunnah.com/urn/1268350
sunnah.com/muslim:1668a
sunnah.com/bukhari/51/26
sunnah.com/bukhari/44/6
and about THREE HUNDREDS more like that...
Greatness of Omar is no different from the greatness of Alexander, the greatness of Rome, the greatness of Genghis Khan, the greatness of the Victorian empire or the greatness of USSR. Just another glory dictatorship in the ripples of time.
@@mdug7224 why is it no different? reason?
@@faheemmirza6741 empires initially built on violence and subjugation and ruled by oppression and fear.
I think Zakir Naik is one of the best stand up comedians on the delusional circuit.
Can't believe that this nonsense has become "Ad-Deen' or a way of life in Islam.
Could you do a video on uthman the third caliph
A.Sameer !Could you showthe hadith about Umar had sex during fasting and got fatwah from Ali on that ?
Unfortunately there were no railway tracks in the desert. At least they could have gone behind the train.
The fact that she was sent to Umar was because she was already given in marriage. In Islam no man can be alone with a woman who is not closely related to him.
Oh Omar, he who contributed to the Quran, alongside Allah (aka Mohammed)!
How dare Mohammed challenge “Mankind and the Jinn To Produce the Like of This Qur'an” when HE clearly wrote (at least) three parts of the Quran based upon suggestions from Omar!!?
It is reported by Annas, the Omar bin Al Khatab said: “My almighty agreed with me in three things:
(First), I said, 'Oh Allah's Apostle, I wish if [you would] take as your place of worship the place where Abraham did [have his] place to pray. It so came, the Divine Inspiration: (Qur'an 2:125) And take you (Muslims) the place of Abraham as a place of prayer.'
(Second), And I said to the Prophet, to the prophet of Allah, 'Good and bad ones talk to your wives, therefore order them to veil themselves!' So Allah sent down the concerning the veiling of the women (Qur’an 24:31).
(Third), the wives of the Prophet made a coalition against the Prophet, and I said to them, 'Maybe if his, the lord of the Prophet, divorced you, (all the wives) and exchange you with better wives than you.' So the verse revealed (Qur’an 66:5) the same as I had said.”
You can see the same story in Sahih Al-Bukhari (Book 8, Hadith 395).
Shia islam has all the answers brother
indeed
I am William James, the one who send you information regarding the question no Muslim Apologists can answer, I want to give you more details but you keep ignoring me.
Not ignoring you. I just didn't get a chance to start on the video yet. It will take me some time as I have a big backlog
Send it to the muslims. Why must you lean on others?
@@FriendlyExmuslim I am not talking about doing the video, I am talking about information which is more details. I want to keep on sending you information and more details regarding the topic. Can I do that brother.
@@ernestschroeder9762 whenever I ask Muslims that question they are never able to give my a answer. They just say yes but no answers at all.
@@bigfan2452 there's no point in asking any one else to pose those questions then. What new information do you have?
You only need to look at the people who take him as a role model to know if he's a good man or not.
P.s: he's not
I am sure the most number of likes for this video will come from Shia. I being a one have liked it. Umar par LANAT LOL
May I ask why are you still stuck in that religion? shiaism is equally nonsense albeit less violent.
omar deserved to be highlighted .|
but its unfair to blame prophet muhammed
@@travelleryu wrong shia islam is the real islam
I realize this wasnt the message of the entire video but I'd like to put here that I disagree with the statement that all relationships between husband & wife must have arguements to be healthy. I would never argue with the love of my life.
When i watch the apostate prophet video 'the origin of the hijab' i already know this guy kinda fishy
im not gonna lie, but you missed out on soo much stuff on Umar ibn al khattab...
There's no proof that the 4 ''rightly guided'' caliphs existed.
All sounds like Use and Abuse.
Im feeling sad for all cruelty men did and still do to wimen. 🙏🙏🙏
This guy is intelligent he on point🙏💯
Short answer: No.
Why is Allah revealing quranic verses to satisfy Umar when hes not a prophet?.
Because Allah does not exist, only Muhammad invented Allah to his crazy mind.
@@ordinarylife2343 wrong
And the woman crying at the funeral?
Asking for money or "causing pain" is equivalent to jumping off from a 10 storeyed building 😳😮????? Looks like logic has taken a *total* leave of absence from this man 🤦🏽♂️🤷🏽♂️.
OMAR stands for On My Ass RRRRRRRRRR....
The man who was executed in his own home by Umar's sword - the sentence was inevitable from the beginning; no reaching for a measured verdict based on reason and merits. Law based on a contract entered into before you were born: breach of which is sin of disobedience. This is what believers enslave inferiors and their own unworthy selves by, Animals too and women are separately created -wombs are our weapons, said Yasser Araffat.
Former muslim women rid themselves of modesty segregationist dress codes and the blameless whiteness of Mary the virgin who gave birth to a sinless child; must deal with pychological trauma to impossibly achieve living fully and completely in dignity and freedom. Interfaith connivance - ubiiquitous visibility and presence of Morality dress is in denial of brutality of hatred of unbelief, and that human rights are the legal expression of life
A code of: hate what Alah hates, love what Allah loves. is lifted from:'Jesus is my master'- war on infidels; the man's pride and arrogance is in party with Iblis. He would have sympathy with infidels - teach falsely intercession for them.
before a calamity befall isreal (in the past), they were surrounded by people who had the culture of worshipping idols. does it mean then its good and acceptable for the isreal to worship idols then? obviously not.
what in the earth even is the argument of: people were doing it back then, thus its right back then but not now
Amin.
bro all these hadiths aren’t authentic😂
Hi sameer, in regards to what zakir naik said "anyone who does not love allah and his prophet more than their own life is not muslim." Could you please explain taqqiya with respect to above? Isn't taqiyya means deceive others and suggests to not disclose your true faith if your life is under threat? If you could explain?
TLDL: Not really
Nice video but i couldn't see the Hadiths clearly... Maybe it's my phone problem...
Why wouldn't shias hate this guy...
we do
hey murtad....why islam is always in ur mind....it was ur past...just move ahead....why r u being like remembering ur ex wife instead of stick to ur present wife. You should not complain about ur ex wife if u have left it.
Your prophet died and left a bunch of ex wives, but Allah told all believers to not marry anything of his wife. Why couldn’t he let his ex wife go? Why keep them in bondage
Why in your channel have advertisement to ask for donation to build mosque in the State ...do you think you can do something to get rid of this ad on your channel ...I find it really annoying to hear about it
I don't think he has any control over his commercials
hahaha
Listen to his usual mocking tone.
He is paid to do so.
What was umars status was he a khaliph when he married to that poor girl
Who are you to judge?
You are only quoting part of the story.
I understand why you left islam because you were only taught nonsense and study nonsense all your life lol
Therefore you left the nonsense that you taught were islam whereas it was just nonsense and now you are educating people against that same nonsense .
Dude. This is stuff believed by muslims all over the world.
@@gloriascientiae7435 man only the sheep who just follow what they have heard believe in that .
How come I don't believe in that .
They are million of Muslim who don't believe in that .
And by the way how can this kind of teaching make even senses. If a person is really searching for truth they will find it on their own instead of relying on people . Reason why releigon is failing because we are not looking inward but looking in books
@harishkumar india imagine someone travelled trough a route and get to hea destination, now you wanting to go to the same place you ask the person for guidance to which he reply if you follow this way you will reach your destination but if you want also you can do as I did and find your way on your own untill you reach to where you going but at the end since everybody is looking for an easy way out they will follow his way and get to the destination but the experience is not the same as the one who travelled trough pain, and confusion that he went trough reason why the quran says
Do the people think that they will be left to say, "We believe" and they will not be tried?
We certainly tested those before them. And ˹in this way˺ Allah will clearly distinguish between those who are truthful and those who are liars
So I say to you the quran is just a book of guidance to those who want to use it and also it is a book of jikr reminding you that which you already know about, cause whatever in in the quran is already been said by the people of the past .
Nothing is new, the only difference is the time and the people to which it was revealed that time .
I'm not here expecting each one to be a Muslim or a christian or Hindu or budhist.
You have to find out yourself what you are more in alignment with instead of relying with label.
There have been many previous wise person's that came before us, people who spent their time meditating days and night just like Jesus , muhammad , budhas, lao-tzu , Osho, sadhguru , so on and so forth .
These people are teaching the same thing that all other previous wise people taught .
So again instead of painting fingers at other book or faith why don't you look within yourself and work on the evil that is harboring within your heart like envy jealousy hatred lust etc....
Thanks for creating this video, to all the muslims who are feeling angry, you have all the rights to do so, not on the video creator but the authors of buqari & sahi muslim who made up these stories, let me correct she married to Mohammad ibn e Jaffer e tayar and her elder sister zainab married to Abdullah ibne Jaffer tayar these bastards made up the stories, these made up story to justify the rule of rushideen is what ruined the islamic religion, & what made me and any other religions observer leave the religion