In Memoriam: Dan Dennett on Mortality, Life, and Existence
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 เม.ย. 2024
- I filmed a conversation about death shortly after he recovered from a life-threatening condition. In addition to discussing personal mortality, we talked about bereavement. I thought this time it would be appropriate to listen again to his wisdom-the wisdom of a great thinker and a dear friend. Big books, eloquent speaker, deep knowledge of science as well as philosophy, talented musician and sculptor, lived a full life, and died in harness. Leaves a huge gap in the world of intellect, Dan will miss you so much, so deeply.
--------------
Join Substack:
richarddawkins.substack.com/
Subscribe to Poetry of Reality Channel:
/ @poetryofreality
Follow:
Instagram: / the.poetry.of.reality
Twitter: / richarddawkins
Facebook: / richarddawkinsbooks
Reddit: / thepoetryofreality - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
The world is lesser without Hitchens and Dennet
But more if we keep them alive
I’m a Christian who’s spent many hours listening to dennets thoughts. The man was a intellectual titan. So jolly and positive too. You truly will be missed sir. Even by all of us
@brycemannn4847 The world needs more religious people like you. People need to hear and understand other people's world views instead of shutting everyone who doesn't agree with them out. Respect!
With the world being as it is, we need the 4 horsemen now more than ever. We need them to fight the proliferation of ignorance invading our shores. This is a terrible blow.
Not really.
The four horsemen was the greatest vid I have seen. Literally changed my life. We were so lucky to have lived.
What is it about?
@@cnccmiclarkecocreativemedi7284 Atheism
@@cnccmiclarkecocreativemedi7284 i think he is referring to a video Dan, Richard, Sam and Christopher made. Over 10 years ago now i imagine.
I remember watching that, i was sitting having stuffed myself with pizza, followed by a whole tub of ben n jerry, it brings back fond memories.
@@cnccmiclarkecocreativemedi7284 It was mostly a video with 4 atheists and how they try talking reason with religious people and how they get attacked by them. No matter how honest and respectful they are. It’s still on utube and you can check it out. Yes with Dan,…Richard Dawkins,Sam Harris and Hitcherson . They relate their personal experiences. I thought it would revolutionize the world, ….then trump and his Evangelicals came along.
Dan will live on in the minds of millions.
When I was suddenly bedridden in my early twenties, debilitated with severe pain and a mysterious illness that had no explanation or even prognosis, the person looking after me would place a laptop beside my bed each night and I would watch the conversation between Richard and Dan, again, and again, and again. The cosmic perspectives, the gratitude, and and the wonder expressed were a great consolation for me.
Two great minds. RIP Mr. Dennet
Sadly he doesn't rest in "peace", but he is burning in hell.
@@markusw.2690
Nope🤣
Not real my fellow ape!
@@markusw.2690😂 your delusional
@@oWiKeDx Which idol do you have in your avatar?
@@markusw.2690 kkkkk hell is like Alice in Wonderlands, the same shelf where there are gods, Angels, and talking snakes.
Thank you for this lovely tribute to Dan Dennett. R.I.P., Dan.
And a second of our four beloved horsemen has fallen. We have lost another great force for progress, logic, and humanity as a whole. Thank you internet for making his wisdom eternal.
Thank you for sharing those thoughts. I miss Hitchens, and now Dennet.
So sorry for your loss, dear Richard. What a wonderful tribute to a great man. I was struck by how scientific his approach to philosophy was, and I know he will be missed dearly.
His existence has made the world better. This should be the purpose of each human being passing through the life. Honours to you, Daniel Bennett!
I find Richard's voice so soothing and gentle. Very comforting. So seldom does he lose his cool or shift from his quiet, dignified, self-assured tenor. Perfect tone for eulogizing the mighty Dennett. Makes me feel a bit better... Just found out a personal friend passed yesterday to pile on the loss of Dennett. Happy to listen to these two greats at tuis moment.
❤
Yet so many want to label Dawkins as ‘strident’. Anything but that in my view.
@@NotalloldpeopleTheir definition of ‘strident’ is, “Frequently disagrees with my views in a logical and consistent manner”.
The billions to one probability that I exist at all is a marvel that’s lasted my lifetime. It brings such a sense of gratitude to all those before me and to the natural world of wonders of which I’m a part.
@@Notalloldpeople To be fair, he has changed over the years.
Thank you, I'm 82 and aware of life's passing in ways not as clear before. It's easy to be disappointed with the pain and injustice that humans bring with them. Was and ever shall be. Your conversation helped open a window to the broader view that being here is such an impossibility that do what must be done to recgonise the gift and be in awe.
Trust in Christ, or it's all for nothing!!
"Trust in christ, or its all for nothing" is just a stupid and indeed a condescending statement.
I'll take the risk of thinking for myself, rather then jumping on the ideas of a religion. And should I die and find out that i stand before some pearly gate, then I trust that whatever diety is there, would have more respect for someone who followed his/hers own convictions, then someone who simply jumped onboard for either fear of punishment or for a divine reward.
Take care #keithrelyea7997, and know I had more less the same experience 🥰
@@annettewatson3706 Thor or bust, baby! Bring the hammer! 🔨
Today is my birthday (1979-04-25). And that is NOT a bitter sweet irony consindering that Sir Dawkins once wrote “We are going to die, and that makes us the lucky ones. Most people are never going to die because they are never going to be born. The potential people who could have been here in my place but who will in fact never see the light of day outnumber the sand grains of Arabia. Certainly those unborn ghosts include greater poets than Keats, scientists greater than Newton. We know this because the set of possible people allowed by our DNA so massively exceeds the set of actual people. In the teeth of these stupefying odds it is you and I, in our ordinariness, that are here.We privileged few, who won the lottery of birth against all odds, how dare we whine at our inevitable return to that prior state from which the vast majority have never stirred?”
So Sir Dennett was also among the lucky ones. And he did great. Thank you.
the unborn are never considered people or persons by atheists.
What nonsense, "Most people are never going to die because they are never going to be born". Who cares about that which is not and cannot be. No wonder religions begin.
What you say is indeed the take-away message from this excellent, most genuine, short discussion between these two great thinkers. A quick search suggests that the book contemplated by them at the end, perhaps 'Hymns of the Universe', didn't materialise. Anyway, happy birthday for yesterday. You had the good fortune to be born 1 month and two days before me. Stay well.
Great sentiments, but simply not true. If we properly follow the logic relating to our existence, we have to take it for granted that we exist, and the totality of events that transpired to produce our existence to begin with, also implicitly-obviated 'others' from existing altogether. Even further, science clearly says that 'all of existence' actually occurs ONLY inside our own brain which itself functions according to the laws of physics; that's actually where all of the 'action in the universe' is...just physical matter which is on the move. The entire universe is actually just inside of our individual, little brain, and nowhere else whatsoever at all. Just one more thing that scientists inevitably evade with their thinking...a hypocrisy they engage in all of the time.
Sir Dawkins?
Such a loss. Daniel Dennett truly was a great philosopher. The legacy of ideas he has left will be appreciated even more with years.
He died on April 19th, 2024. I was scrolling through youtube that day & saw a video from Aron Ra (a science communicator) saying that Daniel Dennett just died & that's how I found out. RIP Daniel Dennett❤️
That's exactly how I found out as well. Hell of a guy he was.
I first saw it on Pangburn and then I saw Arons video pop up
Yep me too. Such a shame he's gone.
Dead is illusion anyways or eternal peace in void or is there eternal suffering aaaaaaaaa cannot wait i will be there too... I am so used to death it feels like illusion to me i feel nothing ... not to meant to be insensitive i am in 10/10 pain lol 8 years 24/7
@@gofai274I’m sorry to hear that you are in constant pain. I hope you are able to find peace.
4 horsemen down to 2. But the only thing they ever spelled the apocalypse for was ignorance and savagery. Thank you Dan. You will be missed.
his death hit me way more than I'm used to when it comes to people with whom I'm in a "parasocial" relationship. the image that comes to mind is that of an incredibly bright light having faded away. one of the best philosophers of mind that have ever lived. his work will live on.
Well said. I found a video of him giving a lecture in early 2023 where he was talking about the problems he was working on. So, yes his work will live on, but it’s desperately sad that we don’t get to read the next Dennett book. I’m glad he got his memoir done-I’ve got it on my shelf. Haven’t read it just yet, but will soon. But to think he was working on a successor to ‘From Bacteria to Bach and Back’ and we’ll never get to see it is so sad. Just feels like we lost a dear friend.
On a happier note, I am really excited for Richard Dawkins’s forthcoming book. He has been doing memoirs and children’s books in recent years and I’d kind of assumed he wouldn’t be doing any more serious science books in the vein of ‘The Selfish Gene,’ or ‘Ancestors Tale’. But it sounds like ‘Genetic Book of the Dead’ is in that lineage. Really excited to read it!
First, the Hitch. Now Dan Dennet. The world is a better place because of them. Thank you, Professor Dawkins for sharing this and for your generosity through your writings and your work. I look forward to the anthology “Hymns To The Universe”
Thank you Richard. You are a great man.
*were
@@panty_sniffer69 RD is not dead.
@@larskragh-hvidberg1593 fuck I thought he's talking about dd
@@larskragh-hvidberg1593 Did I say he was? I’m thanking RD for a great tribute to Dan.
I don’t often say it, but thank goodness for TH-cam.
It is an immense honour to be living in the same age of these legends. Mr. Dan Dennett's death is a great lose for humanity. He will live in our memories, till the end.
Indeed a great man in all respects. We will miss him in a positive way and be grateful for having him in our lives.
I'm saddened deeply that I may now at best only ever see two of the four horseman live. 😥
I feel fortunate that I got to meet Dennett at a book signing & watched him deliver a lecture later that day. Let’s vow to catch the other 2 if the opportunity arises.
Yup Richard is doing a tour of the US/UK later this year. I immediately booked a ticket after watching this video
@@yippeeyo thanks for letting me know. I’ll have to drive 6 hours to catch the closest one in DC
[The mind is the effect, not the cause.]-(Dan Dennett)
May the earth rest lightly on you
I been reading Daniel Dennett since 1989 when I entered Jr College. I had to take a philosophy class and my Christian faith was challenged. I still remember , I hated the guy, but I read some of his books. 1984. Elbow Room The intentional stance, Darwin evolution Intution pumps , and so many others competing his belief in free will. Wow, I read his new book I’ve Been thinking , he did so much. What a teacher. I also read. Determine by Robert Saposky He also made me think, but I referred back to the Elbow room 1984. Great book. Frank. Downey California 😅
He was a lovely man and a deep thinker. We were lucky to have him.
Thank you, Professor Dawkins! I love Dan Dennet so much that even after I've absorbed all the information I can from all that's out there on TH-cam, I still plug one of his lectures up at bed time just to fall asleep to his soothing voice.
Very nice touch to remember him with this conversation about life and gratefulness and meaning. RIP Dan…we didnt know each other but Im happy to have known _you_ a little bit…thanks for all the thoughts ❤️ Both of you
What a good chat between two great brains.
Didn’t know Dan died. This is such a loss but let’s celebrate his work and legacy. Read his books and listen to his lectures, debates and interviews! Take notes, review them, contemplate on them, learn more, always enquire, doubt and question everything! Share with others!!
Embrace science not partially but fully! Science is the light ☀️🖖🏼📚🧬✨ And make the best realistically possible effort to contribute to civilisation!
Such a joy to hear you and Daniel discuss the privilege of life and being in such awe of life and the capacity to love! Thank you Richard! Love in the universe to Daniel Dennett 💕
Atheism helped me control my senses, Some times disbelieving can be a strong antidote against the balance between insanity and balancing my thoughts and ideas. It made me realize that it's not that I have a soul but I am that being no mere less important than my soul. Now I don't believe in my soul but my own being alive and well. I still believe and also pray in meditation, and it has helped me in many ways. I am grateful that we have the existence of atheism. Thank you!💚
RIP Dan Dennett, great thinker. Thank you Richard Dawkins for sharing this.
Such a beautiful conversation. No strive , no assumptions, just discussion of what is . Thanks for sharing
Such a great loss to humanity.
His message remains immortal. More and more people will follow his footsteps, I am positive about that.
Thank you Mr. Dennett. We'll miss you.
I really feel for Professor Dawkins, the loss of his dearest friend and fellow Horseman.
I dread the day we lose him also, it’s too much to bear !😢😢😢
Thank you Dan Dennett, so much.
A void that cannot be filled. RIP Dan Dennett.
So much heart in your words and quotes Mr Dawkins.Thank you.Like Mr Dennett you are cherished.
Fantastic video. I'm sending my thanks to both of you. Hope your here in the next many decades 😊
Richard, I hope that you stay healthy and accompany us for a long time to come! ❤
Thank you so much for sharing this with us
It was wonderful to watch this conversation again, and be reminded of what a great, intelligent, gentle man he was. Richard always knows just how to express the absolute wonder of life and the universe with his soft, eloquent and comforting voice.
Fantastic conversation, so profound. As my mother leaves this world, I have watched this over & over. Many thanks to you both for the inspiring words.
Bitter news, indeed. I probably owe my exposure to Dennett (as well as Hitchens and Dawkins) to Verle Muhrer, philosophy teacher at Penn Valley Community College,l Kansas City. I am forever grateful for that, and for the great works Dan Dennett leaves behind. As author Joe Hill wrote: “It’s quite common to enter a library and find yourself in communication with the dead. The best minds of generations long gone crowd every bookshelf. They wait there to be noticed, to be addressed, and to reply in turn. In the library the dead meet the living on collegial terms as a matter of course, every day. “ (Full Throttle, “Late Returns”, p. 204)
In this manner, in this the only true life after death, I hope future generations meet in conversation with Daniel Dennett.
Great quote. People can achieve life after death through the literature and art they created. Dan Dennett is alive in his books and videos. John Lennon is alive in his music and movies. Judy Garland is young and alive when you watch the Wizard of Oz.
My best tribute to Dan (and previously for Hitch) is the space on my shelves for several of his books that I’d bought in his lifetime and have enjoyed reading - and likely not for the last time.
Yep. I have a pretty solid Dennett shelf. Not the complete set…I’m missing a couple. But I’ll get there.
Many a restless night have been calmed by Richard's comforting logic and absolute reason. He helps me find peace.
This conversation about life and death is the best of the treasure of grief wisdom I have harvested over the years of losing my family. Thank you Richard and Dan!
What a thoughtful and beautiful tribute to Dan Dennet. Thank you Richard for this and all the work you've done for humanity so far.
Thank you for producing and sharing this wonderful video!
I was waiting for this.....and it was just as profound as I'd hoped. Thank you Richard for providing it, and thank you Dan, your like does not come along very often. We will miss you.
I'm lucky to have you, Richard.
If no one had ever shown kindness or love to me and had I no ability or chance to learn and gain knowledge then I have no doubt I would be a poor excuse of a man.
I have done good things thanks to those good things that some had done for me long ago....
And centuries from now, long after my name is forgotten, some of the good things people find themselves doing will stem all the way back to the good things I did for some now, which stemmed from the good things some did for me back then.
This is my meaning. ❤
Rest In Peace Dan Dennet
How can he rest in peace? That saying needs to go.
@@JesyB2023explain to us, please!
@@kristijanakristijanic To rest in peace implies life after death.
Lol. You atheists are so creepy.
@@JesyB2023how can you rest when your dead. And how can there be peace, when there’s no existence Agree with you 100%
Such a good one for me. Thank you both
Thank you Sir, for sharing this video with us. 🙏
In a world that seems increasingly full of people who dwell in self-pity and always seeking 'happiness' through excessive accumulative of materials. this is an absolute delight. Two gentlemen who are not just great intellectuals but also full of appreciation stemming from their intelligence, empathy and sincere kindness. This was such a beautiful video post to have discovered. Beauty, love and empathy exist in sadness, loss and grief, just as much as joy, discovery and friendship. All emotions define us and have their place in every life. I hope millions can learn from this approach and attitude to our lives and those of others.
Thank you for this lovely tribute
Thank you for sharing those special moments with Dan, Peace, and Love and again thank you for the many happy memories with a intellectual giant.
Thank you for such a touching tribute
Thanks Richard for all the great content you share, but especially at this time for sharing these documented moments with Dan Dennet.
Time to read all the works of DD that I haven't already.
Sorry for your loss, Richard. Thank you, Dan 🙏🏼
Hitchen, Richard, Dan & Sam have been heros of mine for many years. Sending my love and immense respect ❤
I've uploaded a lot of Dan Dennet's wisdom to my necktop. He has augmented my life significantly.
I just finished "I've been thinking". Such a treasure. Thanks for this video. I will miss Dan Dennett. I am so sad at his passing. His books have been inspirational for me.
Rest in Peace Mr Dennett, your contributions to the field of Philosophy have been a great inspiration to myself and many. And thank you Mr Dawkins for this excellent video
The 2 Greatest Exponents of Critical thinking, Rational and reasoning in understanding science both by philosophical and Truthful search in the Beauty and Grandeur of our Universe..Thank you Sir Richard and Mr Daniel Dennett...unforgettable Forever...❤❤❤
Just fantastic and deeply moving.
there he goes and shares my favourite poem...all time favorite... no wonder I worship and follow these guys religously!...
Thank you 🙏🏼 ❤
That was beautiful. I’m sorry for your and everybody’s loss. RIP Mr Dennet 🙏🏻🌹💫
Love your beautiful mind. A world treasure. Thanks Dan for sharing your humility and intelligent.
Rest in peace, Mr. Dennett. It was such a pleasure to hear your debates and your presentations.
I’m frustrated he isn’t being celebrated more 😢
Same. Its been oddly quiet since he died it feels like it should have made a far bigger splash.
Jennifer Ouellette (wife of Sean Carroll) has a wonderful obituary for Dan at ArsTechnica.
Unfortunately, modern humanity reserves its celebrity celebrations to the likes of Kardashians and Lil Kim. Someone who actually makes a difference in the world is ignored by the masses. Sad testimonial about our species.
@@earthlingsunited2663 agree
RIP Dan Dennett. This is the first I heard of it. You were apart of my atheist journey.
He said gratitude is a wonderful human emotion. I agree and am grateful to know who these amazing men are. Those who don’t, are truly missing out.
So much wisdom and knowledge between these two friends.
Beautiful discussion.
As Dawkins once noted, we are fortunate to be alive, given the countless potential people who will never exist. We won the lottery of birth, and Dennett was among the lucky ones, achieving great things. Thank you.
Although I'm not an atheist (generally agnostic but occasionally swaying towards certain forms of theism), there is no denying what an intellectual powerhouse Daniel Dennett was. I have a tremendous level of respect for his work and his contributions to the field of psychology. Some of the most exciting moments in my psychology bachelor's degree revolved around Dennett's theories. His work is incredibly thought-provoking, coming from an individual who led a battle in freeing the world of ignorance. Regardless of whether he managed to persuade me into embracing atheism, I will always be a major fan of his work and am incredibly saddened by this loss.
What a thoroughly decent and respectful comment. I hope you find solace in whatever beliefs you finally embrace.
@@tonygarrett7214 Thank you! I greatly appreciate the kind words and wish you the best in all future endeavors.
I have been a Richard Dawkins fan since the 1980’s when he was in TV programmes at time of The Selfish Gene. Christmas lectures in 1990’s. I have read most of his books,lately as audiobooks narrated by the man himself. He has enriched my life and continues to do so, hopefully for many years.
What a wonderful tribute.
Rest in peace Mr dennett, a total pleasure listening to your wonderful ideas and work!
I must say, when I was just a quasi believer, to have an outlet thanking God and giving gratitude was very fulfilling. I’m glad Mr. Dennett was in my life. Reflecting on the process of how we came to be, can be even more fulfilling than giving gratitude to God. I appreciate Richard’s insight.
Thank you both of you two gentlemen for calming my anxiety towards the inevitability of death
I just heard the news. I guess it's about time I read one of his books. At least.
Thank you Daniel❤
Really sad to learn that he is gone. I'm mid re-reading his Consciousness Explained. Brilliant and illuminating work!
Beautiful lines at the end.
I feel the loss of Dan as a deep pain even while I rejoice in having enjoyed him for so many years. We are all so fortunate to have had him, and I recommend his last book "I have been thinking ..." to all so you may get his picture of his great life.
"Religions have depended on the relative isolation and ignorance of their flocks, forever and this is all breaking down" Thank you so much Dan, for doin so much to break that down!
Beautiful words in Memory of Daniel Dennet
Love you Richard ❤
Sorry for you loss Richard. Stay strong, we need people who illuminate the world and you're amongst the best who do.
Sorry for your loss.
On my last day (not long now) I can say I have loved and been loved by, wonderful people. Nothing I've done, nowhere I've been, nothing I've owned, nothing can compare with that. It is my role to make the best life I can while I'm here, then move on and leave room and resources for those that come after me. I am not afraid of being dead, I just hope not to suffer too much in the process of getting there.
Brilliant man. Sad to lose him. But we were so fortunate to have had him and he can live on in his written words. I think Christopher Hitchens said of Shakespeare, he is immortal in the works he left behind!
Down to two horsemen. Dan Dennett what a scholar and a beautiful mind!
If each of us is improbable individually, then the odds of meeting another equally improbable who shares profound insight is exponentially more unlikely.
Awe- that joy of wonder but also that grief of loss, that moment and feeling that doesn’t come when we diligently seek it but which drops in unexpectedly and keeps us waiting for it to return. That’s what motivates us.
Who cares that life is finite? Everything is transient. Why should we be otherwise? To have the experience of awe- joy, grief, and compassion- that’s it. If one feels like that’s somehow inadequate, the problem is not out there in the universe.
So touching…♥️🥲 May your grieving be easy on you…🤗♥️
Sorry for your loss Richard
Wonderful.
Gr8!!!❤❤❤