According to him before chatrapati everything was good there was no hindu -Muslim then tell me why chatrapati had to establish swaraj atleast so called historian should use logic before talking and don't understand why BBC has got any other good experience historian or is there any agenda
Tyavel garib pasun aaj Maharashtra richest state ye india by gdp ye serve Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj ani shahu phule aani ambedkaran chya shikvani mule jai shivrai jai maharashtra 🚩
@@unknownno-up1is मला बोलायच आहे की आपण शाळेत हिंदी शिकतो... त्याचा पूढे जाऊन शून्य वापर होतो..... म्हणून लिपीच शिक्षण द्यायला हवे.... direct lipi change keli tr khup jhol hoel so halu halu karav lagel....
खूप छान माहिती.. फक्त दोन गोष्टी सुचवतो. शिवचरित्राचे नाव शिवभारत नाही. त्याला शिवचरित्रच म्हणावे. दुसरे म्हणजे दख्खन एवजी महाराष्ट्र म्हणावे कारण शिवचरित्रातही आपल्या लोकांनी महाराष्ट्रच म्हटलेय.
Dear Friends, When Maharaja Shivaji was living in Visapur fort, Sihangargh and near by Lonavala, Karjat and if you traveled you will see lots of Buddhist caves, I wonder why any Historian hasn’t put any information. What was Maharaja Shivaji connection with those are he doesn’t know any caves.
दादाच्या सांगणे वरून अस दिसतय की महाराजांच्या अगोदर महाराष्ट्र खूपच सुजलाम सुफलाम होता, हिंदू मुस्लिम गुण्या गोविंदाने नांदत होते...भारीच ना....काय बोलतोय हां दाद्या.....कमाल आहे...
I'm so surprised to see Mr. Manu Pillai speaking Marathi, Aapli Ivory Thrones pasun te False Allies paryant sagle vachlet, Asech aaple kaam chalu thevave👍
बीबीसी मराठीला कोणी शुद्ध आणि स्वच्छ मराठीत बोलणारा मराठी इतिहासकार मिळाला नाही का शिवपूर्व कालाबद्दल बोलायला. हे सद्गृहस्थ भलेही इतिहासाचे खूप ज्ञानी असतील पण ते तीस ते चाळीस टक्के इंग्रजीमिश्रित मराठीत बोलत होते.मग बीबीसी मराठी ही फक्त नावापुरतीच मराठी आहे असे समजायचे का?
As Shivaji Maharaja was leaving at Visapur, Shinhagargh, and Lonavala and Pune area and mostly there are Buddhist caves, I those caves were quite ancient. I wonder no Historian has written about that caves, was there any connections with Buddhist caves of Maharaja Shivaji?
@@anid805 yes we are very much know that Maharaja was Hindu Samrat. We respect very highly for that. No doubt at all. My just query regarding History. Wasn’t caves in that time, when maharaja was leaving at there. All the caves. Ajanta, Ellora, Karle, Bhaje. In Dapoli some places. So what was scene that time.
Are rashtrakutas ,satvahanas, shilaras, gajapati, rajputs, siddhis, myanmar king he shivaji maharaj chya pahile che rulers hote tyani maharashtra war rule kela hota yacha tar naav ghya nuste Moghals Navte
I know where it is going when he starts the references where it said Nizam married to hindu and then he said Nizam are half marathas .... systemic history dakhvat apala hetu sadhya karat ahe
there are so much great historian available in maharasthra and why BBC is giving so much emphasis on equality yes there are few facts that malik ambars governances was good ,ibrahim adilshaha never descirminates between hindus and muslim but apart from that all rulers tried to distroy hinduism rather than this nation. dont give fake picture guys be aware from such videos you can read the books of Va. si. bendre, babasaheb purandare jadunath sarkar you get the real idea..
Wow because a nijam or adilshahi king colluded with maratha against mughals rule they became good people abd though it was known that saying maratha were so called saviours of india and hindus was incomplete truth now there are proofs that busts the myths abd people havd been udihg half baked conclusion for their eelfish gains than any real good
@@pranilbhilare7610 yes but dakshin wouldn't make sense. dakshin would refer to the whole of the south. The Deccan doesn't include TN, Kerala, most of Andhra and many parts of southern Karnataka and the western ghats
महाराष्ट्र ना अगोदरचा, ना नंतर चा
महाराष्ट्र होता सुखी तेव्हाच जेव्हा होता जाणता राजा 🙏🙏🙏
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
Over hotay as nahi vatat nahi
@@kk59596 kay chukicha aahe hyat ....maharaj hote mhanun apn aahot
सातवाहनांच्या काळातील महाराष्ट्र म्हणजे इतिहासातील सुवर्णकाळ.
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
how so?
छ्त्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांनी हिंदुस्थानला स्वर्ग बनविले.🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
I love it when rational history researchers give talks
We would like to hear/ watch series from Mr Pillai, he is very intelligent and scholar.
नक्कीच :)
According to him before chatrapati everything was good there was no hindu -Muslim then tell me why chatrapati had to establish swaraj atleast so called historian should use logic before talking and don't understand why BBC has got any other good experience historian or is there any agenda
Maharashtra he south indiaa cha part aahe....Jay Maharashtra..Jay Marathi
Tyavel garib pasun aaj Maharashtra richest state ye india by gdp ye serve Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj ani shahu phule aani ambedkaran chya shikvani mule jai shivrai jai maharashtra 🚩
Jai ShivBhim
भक्तांना हा इतिहास समजणार नाही..अभ्यास आणि वाचन यापासून ते खूप दूर आहेत....
यांना खूप समजत्या बरंय....हाहा हाहा
Shivaji maharajani Abdulanchi changli jiravali hoti 😁😁😁🚩
Tumhi swatah ithihas vacha tumhala kay yete kay pan khota ithihas sangta tumhi lok
तुर्रक सैन्यात असल्यास जय कैसा?
निजाम पुत्रांना खूप समजतोय इतिहास .
आगे बढो निजामपुत्र
Very informative. Please continue as a series.
Jay shivaray
दैवीय अवतार होते माझे राजे
अखंड किर्तीमान श्री श्रीमान छत्रपती शिवाजीमहाराज
Historian explaination is very interesting, please do more videos with him
छान माहिती दिली हे माहिती हवी यापुढील पिढींना.. धन्यवाद..
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
महाराजांच्या काळात मोडी स्क्रिप्ट वापरली जात असे अणि आपण देवनागरी वापरतो
आपली सर्वात मोठी चुकी.... हिंदी काढून त्या ठिकाणी मोडी लिपी च शिक्षण द्यायला हवे..
देवगिरी नाही देवनागरी
Modi wapas ana pahije 💪 Dusri script gheun apan khup chuki keli.
Mala watt modi script vina reshechi hoti mhanje aksharanvar resha nahi.
@@RS-zh1vc hindi nahi bhava ti devnagari script ahe
@@unknownno-up1is मला बोलायच आहे की आपण शाळेत हिंदी शिकतो... त्याचा पूढे जाऊन शून्य वापर होतो..... म्हणून लिपीच शिक्षण द्यायला हवे.... direct lipi change keli tr khup jhol hoel so halu halu karav lagel....
Manu Pillai... You beauty. We want more of Manu Pillai. His research seems to be thorough and his opinions seem to be fact based and not biased !
खूप छान माहिती.. फक्त दोन गोष्टी सुचवतो.
शिवचरित्राचे नाव शिवभारत नाही. त्याला शिवचरित्रच म्हणावे. दुसरे म्हणजे दख्खन एवजी महाराष्ट्र म्हणावे कारण शिवचरित्रातही आपल्या लोकांनी महाराष्ट्रच म्हटलेय.
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
@@ShivswarajyaOrganisation मराठा तितुका मेळवावा, महाराष्ट्रधर्म वाढवावा!!
खूप छान माहिती, साविस्तर वाचण्यासाठी यावर एखादं पुस्तक आहे का?
🙏👍
छत्रपति शिवाजी महाराज की जय 🚩🚩
Very knowledgeable
Dear Friends, When Maharaja Shivaji was living in Visapur fort, Sihangargh and near by Lonavala, Karjat and if you traveled you will see lots of Buddhist caves, I wonder why any Historian hasn’t put any information. What was Maharaja Shivaji connection with those are he doesn’t know any caves.
Khup chhan mahiti dilit dada thanks
दादाच्या सांगणे वरून अस दिसतय की महाराजांच्या अगोदर महाराष्ट्र खूपच सुजलाम सुफलाम होता, हिंदू मुस्लिम गुण्या गोविंदाने नांदत होते...भारीच ना....काय बोलतोय हां दाद्या.....कमाल आहे...
Are pagal mansa tya veles sagle hinduch hote nantar tyanch dharm parivartan kel hindunvar atyachar kela aya bahinichi abru lutli tyach musalmannani
Purna aaiktar mitra, shivaji maharajanchya darbarat lihilelya pustakatun sangtoi toi! Ulta toh mhantoi ki maharajanchy aadhi khup vait paristiti hoti
nice information.
मराठी त बोला... शिवाजी महाराजांच्या आगोदर मराठेशाही होती त्याबद्दल सांग जय शिवराय
निषचया चा महामेरू .
मुजरा राजं
I'm so surprised to see Mr. Manu Pillai speaking Marathi, Aapli Ivory Thrones pasun te False Allies paryant sagle vachlet, Asech aaple kaam chalu thevave👍
Super
Kiti changle hote MUSLIM saltanat ani Hindu Saltanats 💛💚.I Love Adishahi sultan and CHA.Shivaji Maharaj UNITED Indian
Itihasa baddal mahiti milali aapan dili aaple dhanyawad
बीबीसी मराठीला कोणी शुद्ध आणि स्वच्छ मराठीत बोलणारा मराठी इतिहासकार मिळाला नाही का शिवपूर्व कालाबद्दल बोलायला. हे सद्गृहस्थ भलेही इतिहासाचे खूप ज्ञानी असतील पण ते तीस ते चाळीस टक्के इंग्रजीमिश्रित मराठीत बोलत होते.मग बीबीसी मराठी ही फक्त नावापुरतीच मराठी आहे असे समजायचे का?
Knowledge is important
very good information provided by mr pillai
Shivray Manje Maharshtra cha Pursharth ... Shivray Manje Maharshtra cha Abhimaan
Pls interview Vikram Sampath
सुरूवात फार चांगली सांगितले न्यचरली त्या मुळे शिवाजी महाराजांनी विचार केला आसेल
Please more videos from Mr. Pillai ….
As Shivaji Maharaja was leaving at Visapur, Shinhagargh, and Lonavala and Pune area and mostly there are Buddhist caves, I those caves were quite ancient. I wonder no Historian has written about that caves, was there any connections with Buddhist caves of Maharaja Shivaji?
No chhtrapati shivaji maharaj was Hindu king
@@anid805 yes we are very much know that Maharaja was Hindu Samrat. We respect very highly for that. No doubt at all. My just query regarding History. Wasn’t caves in that time, when maharaja was leaving at there. All the caves. Ajanta, Ellora, Karle, Bhaje. In Dapoli some places. So what was scene that time.
Good information....keep it up
Are you from Parner
Nice
अभ्यासपुर्ण मत.......👍
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
💯
पूर्ण मुलाखत दाखवा ना....किती छान व अभ्यासपूर्ण माहिती मिळाली.
Where is the sources of This history can you suggest
I understood ,why bramhin were not against the Mughals because they were slave of Muslim.
Malik amber was great military leader
Are rashtrakutas ,satvahanas, shilaras, gajapati, rajputs, siddhis, myanmar king he shivaji maharaj chya pahile che rulers hote tyani maharashtra war rule kela hota yacha tar naav ghya nuste Moghals Navte
बहुतेक साम्राज्य ही महाराष्ट्रात जन्माला आली आहेत तरीही त्याचे श्रेय बाहेरील लोक घेतात कारण आपण त्यांना उचलून घेतले नाही अजून.
Te 14 century chya aadhi whote..he 14 century Chya nantar cha santoy
@@samydicosta right
I know where it is going when he starts the references where it said Nizam married to hindu and then he said Nizam are half marathas .... systemic history dakhvat apala hetu sadhya karat ahe
shevti channel america cha ahe.. bharatat chaos karun bhartala kadhi grow na houn dena haach tyacha udhistha ahe.
Vidarbha is not Maharashtra.
History of maharashtra is not a history of vidarbha.
Seperate Vidarbha from Maharashtra.
चल बे
🤣🤣 हो माहीत आहे तुम्हा काही विदर्भियांना हिंदी जवळची वाटते मराठी पेक्षा म्हणून ही थेर आहे तुमची.
हे भैय्या पैदास विदर्भ महाराष्ट्रापासून वेगळे करू पाहत आहे पण एकच लक्षात ठेवा तुमच्या आईला दुसऱ्यांदा जनावे लागेल .तुमच्याकडून नाही होणार
there are so much great historian available in maharasthra and why BBC is giving so much emphasis on equality yes there are few facts that malik ambars governances was good ,ibrahim adilshaha never descirminates between hindus and muslim but apart from that all rulers tried to distroy hinduism rather than this nation. dont give fake picture guys be aware from such videos you can read the books of Va. si. bendre, babasaheb purandare jadunath sarkar you get the real idea..
Agdi barobar!
Tyanchya minister cha ullekh brahman. Tyanchya baykancha ullekh kartana marathi.
Brahmanvad
महाराजांचा इतिहास सांगायला लागलाय सर मराठीत बोलला तर खूप छान वाटले असते
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
इंग्लिश भाषेचा वापर थोडा कमी केला असता तर बर झाल असत
छत्रपती शिवाजी महाराजांचे स्वप्न हा अखंड भारत पुन्हा व्हावा | नक्की पाहा🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
th-cam.com/video/6e-kq4bQwWA/w-d-xo.html
Ata bharamman hindu gulam banly maratha
शिवभारत मोडी लिपीत आहे कि देवनागरीत आहे? जर ते देवनागरीत असेल तर ते शिवाजी महाराजांच्या काळात लिहिले आहे खोटे आहे
Shivbharat sanskrut madhe aahe
Wow because a nijam or adilshahi king colluded with maratha against mughals rule they became good people abd though it was known that saying maratha were so called saviours of india and hindus was incomplete truth now there are proofs that busts the myths abd people havd been udihg half baked conclusion for their eelfish gains than any real good
Raja che 350 fort Smart kara Vikas kara
Some of points you said are wrong..
English subtitles?
Tevha sagade midun Rahat hoty
Ata marathe bharamman gulam jhaly ahy
Ani marathyancha dharm fakt muslim cha virodh karny ahy
Mag musalmanala dokyavar gheun nachaych ka landyanni itke varsh amchya aya bahinichi abru lutli ani hindunna convert kel
निज़ामशाही चांगली होती
Deccan नाही दख्खन
He mhanje asa jhale ki
'India nahi bharat'
Well, Dakkhan is derived from Dakshin. So its Dakshin, not Deccan or Dakkhan.
@@pranilbhilare7610 correct
Deccan he British historians ni dakkhan sathi use karayche
@@pranilbhilare7610 yes but dakshin wouldn't make sense. dakshin would refer to the whole of the south. The Deccan doesn't include TN, Kerala, most of Andhra and many parts of southern Karnataka and the western ghats
He is saying wrong information Adilsha was from shia muslim community
साहेब आवाज काही नाही
Maharaja peksha sultan cha jast explanation ahe
Shivaji maharaj.....first and most banned language like Arabic and Persian...!! Shivaji maharaj support sanskrit and marathi..!!
खूप छान त्यांचे बायको वेळी बनवा बनवी आठवला 😂😂😂
Kunachich baaju n gheta maandleli history
अरे मित्रा मराठी कमी आणि इंग्लिश मध्ये जास्त बोलतोयस
मनू पिल्लाई हे मूळचे केरळचे आहेत आणि जेवढी मराठी बोलतायत ती चांगलीचीच बोलतायत
Nuste mughals rulers navte
मराठी व्यवस्थित बोलायला शिक आधी ....
He kalaylach have
th-cam.com/video/2-AbFQzkohc/w-d-xo.html
एक दा बघाच
Manni Pillai ? Marathi yete ? 😳😳😳😳😳😳
Tyacha balpan Punyat gela. Toh Punyachya Fergusson college madhe shikla ahe.
Maharaj Sisodia Vanshi Kshatriya hote ki Shudra hote????
Kshatriya!
Tumhi mahiti kahich dili nahi...phakt goal goal firavon kahihi bolat aahat
Wrong history aahe
Nice