Turbocharged Vs Supercharged - Part 4 [Skid Pan Battle]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ต.ค. 2016
- Which of our two boosted roadsters will win the skid pan challenge? today we find out.
Shop: www.mightycarmods.com/collecti...
Facebook: / mightycarmods
Forum: forums.mightycarmods.com
ManUP: manup.org.au
Check out the Australian Racers Driving Club and Sydney Motorsport Park here: www.sydneymotorsportpark.com.au/
Also something to note around Mighty Car Mods: we are normal guys and are not trained mechanics. We like to make interesting car mods and show you how we've gone about it, but we can't promise that anything we show you will work for your particular car, or that you won't harm yourself, someone else, your car or your warranty doing it. Please be safe, be responsible and unless you know what you're doing, do not fool around with very serious machinery just because you've seen us make it look so easy. Talk to a qualified mechanic if you are in any doubt. - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
![2SEXY Vs EVO [TRACK BATTLE]](/img/n.gif)
MCM: you'll see these cars again in the not too distant future
me: still waiting 3 years later
Cryxalis 4 years now lol
Me, too. I would like to see the turbocharged car taken to Nitro Dann to let him work his magic. I would like to see the evaluation of performance with the tune maximizing torque at the driveline limit, as Nitro Dann does.
@@SADDSADW-qn1vg going on 5 years now. :()
Over 5 years now 😂
6 years now.
Second car on the courses was faster, maybe they ran faster after learning the first time around.
This.
What a useless test, do the turbo after the supercharger for a 3rd run and it'll be quicker again
jay west I was thinking the exact same thing, maybe the should have done 3 runs in each car & adjusted for averages.
agreed though i bet they had time constraints with the rain and all
What I was thinking. They should've each done a second run per car.
Go to 18:40 and they talk about the fact that they get better as they learn the course after numerous runs so it's too hard to split them.
20:37 Look in the mirror. It's their 180SX.
ishootstuff oh, yes!
1:55
ishootstuff it's on the trailer I think it's gonna be the next video
i seent it!
Turboed Leo
Good eye. My vision isn't what it used to be since the brain surgery.
Next: do a turbo-supercharged mx5
metalkarim9 hell yes
metalkarim9 then a turbo, super and pro charged mx5.
anthony soto triple charged!
LMAO! Procharger is a type of supercharger
lol god damn idiots
Waiting on the Mount Akina test.
[Eurobeat Intensifies]
RUNNINGINTHE90S
***** Funny thing, I did have a "shit tier" street race (Skoda Octavia with 55 kw against Suzuki CX4 with 112 kw) with that song on... yes, it was awesome.
that song has become a meme to me x)
I genuinely like that song. Like, a couple of gigs of eurobeats in my car is a must have
That dent on the supercharged MX-5 wasn't there last video....
Guys look centrifugal superchargers are really just belt driven turbos the real difference needs to be seen between a conventional turbo and a roots or twin screw supercharger.
my thought too. excellent mopar thumbnail by the way.
Agreed. Nice twin screw ❤
Roots blowers are never going to match the efficiency of a turbocharger. They just suck too much power out of the crankshaft, OK for a drag car but fucked up for a street car.
stmounts I strongly disagree. A roots blower has much better low end and mid range which is ideal for a street car. You don't spend all your time at the top 10% of the rev range, so centrifugal is less desirable for the street.
@@Terruhcutta ...Sure, that would explain why 99% of street car manufacturers use turbos instead of Roots blowers, eh???
Truth is, turbos can be set up to provide full boost at low rpms and maintain that through the rev range via a wastegate. They are not always set up to come on at high rpm, only in race cars or after-market conversions by fan boys. So mid-range boost can be much higher.
Considering the low boost levels I would have liked to see a roots or screw type of blower vs. the turbo since they can make boost much earlier in the RPM range.
lmfao there is a raindrop in marty's gopro. and i was like, why did they blur the shifter XD
it may not have been a shifter.......
thats actually disturbing
driftingcris pls
The shifter was being a bit shifty you see...
TH-cam demanded that they blur the shifter because it was too phallic ....
incredible guys thank you for doing this comparison you should do top speed on these next
thanks for watching mate!
where does the Boost Caboose stand?
+Mighty Car Mods i think you guys should do some little mods to the supercharged miata to even up the power and then go to the drag strip or race track cheers :)
Since the cars have almost equal power and they are the same apart from that top speed (which is limited by gearing) should be the same. I don't think it would prove anything.
And rev limiter.... :)
Thanks guys for making those episodes they really gonna help me out, thanks again for hard work and honest discussion and feedback, good luck mates.
Having made a few videos myself recently I can barely guess how much time and work has gone into making this series! Thank you so much for doing it - really enjoying it and learning lots of new thing :)
Keep up the good work!
Greetings from Germany ;)
You guys should bring the cars on a drag strip and do two laps of a race track.
Steve 30x agreed
You know they're gonna do an episode at the drag strip. Then an episode on a road coarse. Then an episode about street driving. Bet they'll drag this out as long as possible.
+Ryan Billy I hope they do.
Steve 30x Turbo will win at drag strip. Depends how tight the road course is. Turbo will will win at high speed with sweeping corners but supercharger will be advantageous in short technical corners.
They have the same suspension and tires, go to 9:33 and Marty says exactly that.
Why not have the best of both worlds? why not Twincharge a miata?
iHelmster They should get a third MX-5 for that..... I'm definitely watching that
hell yeh
iHelmster might as well just a v8 in at that point
iHelmster genus
Kingdom Of Mog nah twincharing is more entertaining
This video is classic, guys who love cars having fun. They're doing everything me and my mates would do in that situation. Keep up the great work guys!!
You guys should bring back: Lend Us A Ride because I loved that series!
YES MCM VIDEO!!! ** starts taking off pants**
Shika Racing hahaha wtf! You guys have a good channel!
started my car , im going to watch it on my maaaad dashboard ipad install
Lol season 2 reference
I think the go to woe needs a different launch setting, I mean a person to signal go. The person who honks three times is in an advantage versus the other.
podboi825 It doesn't matter, it's the distance that counts.
doesn't matter. outcome is based on distance covered by both cars.
It doesn't matter who starts first because only distance from 0-60-0 matter
These videos have been so interesting. I know that more trials plus different drivers etc could change the results, but coming from a perspective of a driver that is decent but not a professional, this really says a lot about the 2 types of boost. On a further note, speaking as some one who is newly into cars, I'd say that working on and learning with the supercharger is easier on entry level. Very cool that you guys are doing this!
Glimpses of the Green Re-bought 180 there on the back of the track on a trailer gives us hope to see it shine again. Awesome video and quite happy with the results.
I'd argue that some of difference in the motorkhana (autocross for the US peeps) times could have just been the difference in being the 2nd lap around the track no? more familiarity with the course definitely will change times.
Kept watching, you guys mentioned this too. Good video as usual!
T-WRX Definitely, they did the long course test right by switching which car each of them used first. For the short course though they messed up by both taking the same car first. It gave the supercharged car an advantage by having a practice run with the turbo car first. Of course they could have run the course several times each off camera but when doing a test you should still try to take as many variables out as possible. Still entertaining as hell though. good job MCM!
T-WRX ..
😡😡T-WRX 👅
That was exactly what I was thinking while I was watching..
The best is high compression ratio NA. Lol.
You have given all of us happiness in many different ways 8)The both of you have brought me out of the hardest time of my life personally, and prolly a bunch of others. Thank you for all the hard work and diligence you have both put into making McM. i have been watching McM for years and plan on continuing doing so. Yall keep doing yourselves and dont play into b/s (you obviously know this) eventually the boh of ya will be the next, and most Unicorn Top Gear of all time ! Thank you Marty and Moog. From the top to the bottom 8)
So much great stuff from you guys!! This makes me want to buy and build both versions of the MX5!
You guys need another one thats super and turbo charged one. Yes it is possible
Owen Dodman Twin charged!!!
thay would be cool
that
Owen Dodman yes it's possible and yes it's stupid.
Ryan Rohauer you get the advantages of both
i think if you would have done the motor kahna one starting with the turbo car then the other starting with the supercharged car would have made for a better test given the lap you might have been learning the course. still good though mates, cheers.
never mind, you did it in the 2nd one, my apologies.
and we slow drove them a bit to get used to it
Mighty Car Mods wow can't believe you replied, huge fan of you guys. Love your videos, you guys make me laugh so hard, thanks mates.
Marties first lap in the turbocharged car was still clearly sloppier and Moogs there was only a tiny difference, I think that was more or less a tie. Maybe next time do it twice each and average it, even if you only show one of them? (I know youtube stats say viewers drop off after 10-15 minutes generally).
Ramie Harris
Been watching you guys for years and it just gets better!!!!!!!!!
Thank you for doing these tests on a track!! Amazing to see the differences in all tests. Goes to show that if you decide what you want to use your car for then build to suit, you'll get the best result rather than just doing what everyone says you should do. Personally, the way I drive I can see myself supercharging my Mazda 6 (except it costs more than the car itself). Can't wait to see the "spirited driving" real-world test. Also, yes we all saw the 180 sitting on the trailer, you sneaks!
anyone notice the dent on the front left panel of the black one
Marty went on too much electric space wizards when he tried to bog it....
Anyone notice that engine off to the right....
Anyone notice Taytay on a flat bed in the back.
It's the mark of a reversing Peugeot enthusiast... I had the same on my mk1.
Anyone notice they are actually using different tyres??!
That flat 6 sitting there still has me drooling. I have an EZ36 in my tribecca with over 360,000 miles on it. Original motor it's TOUGH!!
That was a bloody great series, well done fellas!
Hope this isn't the end of the series. Loved every second of it!
superchargers for circuit and rally, turbos for highway pulls and for having a lot of fun
Did you guys do some practice runs on the course before you did your timed laps? You always started with the Turbocharged MX-5 on each of the sessions. I'd hate to think that the reason you were quicker on the Supercharged MX-5 is due to familiarity with the track.
These guy are notorious for terrible experimentation practices. Never involves a control, and like you said, they started with the same car twice. Never ran averages.
did you even finish watching the video before commenting? because the supercharged one went first in the second circuit....
notorious amongst who. you're literally making stuff up.
I was thinking the same thing. There are some serious methodological flaws in their experiments. In the motorkhana tests, the car that went 2nd won every time; they should've noticed something was up when in the long course the turbo beat the super then the super beat the turbo... I guess they did kind of mention this though, but they really only mentioned this in passed.
Amazing you guys got this done, and you're with Roadkill at the moment! Some Hard Working Aussies right there!
You guys have come a long way very inspiring
Hey gents, it's been a while since this video, but I was wondering if you've had the chance to get both of these cars on the open road to compare how they drive in normal circumstances?
What a series guys!!!!!!! Now what you've to do is a supercharged VW beetle, and compare it to miss daisy!! hahahaha that would be MAAAAAD. I really enjoy al of your vids guys! Saludos desde bolivia! (south america)
just got a chrome cast and its so weird seeing you guys on my TV. but I LOVE it
I really love this little series, and these Miatas are so clean and sick! Both of them!
yo the 240 was at the skid pan. Cant wait for the video
I was trying to sleep but I saw this notification. Y U DO DIS
such a sick video guys, love this kind of experiment!!!!
Great editing work !
10:20 where did that massive dent came from?
next time take into account the fact that red paint gives your car at least 53 extra horsepower
Long time subscriber, thought it was about time to contribute and thank you for the awesome videos so I bought a CHOPPED FLAG :D Mad.
@Mighty Car Mods each has its benefits and we love both at Good-Win Racing. The Rotrex supercharger is, without a doubt, the easiest for folks to bolt on and survive full on track use. Is it as fast as a turbo in a straight line? No, but for the purists, the throttle response of the Rotrex is hard to beat. I've beat on mine relentlessly for almost 2 years now and couldn't be happier.
you can see the 180sx in the back hopefully there's an episode coming up
I love the NB Miata. Personally it looks the best
I Have one
@@samuelherman4859 do you daily drive it? Looking at getting one for myself.
@@MaxSpeedMike I have an nb miata and daily drive it. And I love it. I'm 6'2" and fit in it just fine as well.
MaxSpeed you mean people buy them not to daily drive?
Mk2 bumper is best looking but 2.5's are more functional due to seats fog lights etc. I've had both.
Can't wait to see drag race! I would like to also see a 2 lap race as well!!!
I subbed a long time ago when you guys probs just hit 50k now I come back to this and you've hit 2M congrats guys and keep up the great work
So which will be gutted for Twincharger MX-5?
this is making me strongly consider building a 200whp rotrex setup.
used rotrex kits are floating around, albeit rare
Brilliant insight into both, very entertaining‼️
I know this is old,but I love it. when you guys do videos like this.
Cool video! Your results are similar to my liking with control ability. I want to supercharge my 93 Vdub Corrado, and I have heard putting turbo on the VR6 is wild powerful but out of control with front wheel drive! Thanks for the video!
Also. find a Corrado and do a series of building it ;)
I'm supercharging my mk3 vr. Easier to daily & less maintenance
Tyler Krieger
Rad! My Rado has an VR out of a MKIII Jetta. Pretty peppy stock, but i would like that extra push.
I spot the 180sx in the background ;)
That looked like so much fun. I'd love to drive either one.
you guys deserve everything good in life, keep up what your doing! id love to see a rotary build or a nice v8 grip build! come to florida if you ever get a chance id love to meet you guys
I think both you guys should do a episode with out your hats on
You guys should try building a twincharged car (turbo and supercharged)
Very interesting to see! Thanks MCM!! ❤️
This is so cool. You guys are awesome for doing this series. You should put both supercharger and turbo in one of the cars just for fun before you get rid of them.
W00t?! Aside from the new MX-5 designed together with Alfa Romeo, that model is the nicest looking one. How can these guys claim it's ugly?
I used to think they are ugly but now I quite like them I'd actually like to have one preferably supercharged.
The abarth should have been aborted.
~NB owner
ND > NC, NA > NB
I always thought of it this way; The driver isn't looking at the outside of the car when he's driving it. Ugly or not, the car drives great.
NA is best ;)
how much you wanna bet you gonna get shit cuz the black mx5 has a dent behind the passenger side headlight
BeMad4M3 and on the drivers side rear quarter
BeMad4M3 Weight Reduction
How does crushing a panel equal weight reduction...? That's some haggard garage logic right there.
atlanticimports Exactly. It's a joke buddy
It's on the driver side you dummy lol.
Hey Moog and Marty, have been watching your stuff since day dot and absolutely love the casual way you provide information. Have recently got into circuit driving in the last year and would really love to see the part 5 on the circuit as i think it would be very informative and i'm sure many other viewers would too, just wondering do you still have these two beasts and if so would part 5 be a possibility? Also love the license plate on the red mx5 "mx5 l0w". Cheers for all the great vids so far and hope to see many more.
Awesome video, loved the Tay-Tay cameo.
Whats with the fender dent on the black one? Has that always been there?
NO
Comes that way from the factory. Unique trademark of Mazda.
You should've run the motorkhana more than once in both cars! It's obvious that supercharged car is faster if you learn the track layout in the turbo car.
love your show guys.
You guys were also great on the Man Up series on ABC!
Wanna buy my 1994 Taurus SHO?
No thank you
Nathaniel Kubaile oml
Nathaniel Kubaile you got fucking destroyed bro.
don't even think the dump wants it
Nathaniel Kubaile I had 2 94 shos loved them
id say choose a smaller turbo to spin up more quickly.
i still wonder how there is no aftermarket kit or ready to use turbo that is kept spinning or accelerated electronically somehow nowadays with so many cars turbocharged to safe fuel. Sounds like an alternative to twinscroll turbos.
Some ALS System that does not require to rest the engine at high rpm.
DxCBuG I know this is an old comment, but there are some VW Group cars (Audi SQ7 etc) that use a dedicated 48V system to power anti roll bars as well as spooling the turbo earlier
You guys did an amazing job on the comparison tests. You should do a quarter drag.
i love how you guys do a snack at the end. it's not car related, but its a nice end to the video. cheers!
Skid pan? Skid pad, like concrete pad... least here in 'Murica at least. I don't get you 'Strailians.
its skid pan in UK but we all still know what each other means so its all good to me.
jamielm skid pad in every magazines worldwide so adapt got dammit lol ;)
Skid pads/pans are usually wet test tracks to test how a car handles lateral acceleration or how fast you're able to drive the car in its smallest radius without spinning out.
I literally just looked through the comment section to make sure someone said this...skid pan...what are they doing frying up the cars real quick
same... somebody had to mention it, it was driving me crazy hearing skid pan, wasn't sure if it was intentional or verbal typo lol
is that the 180 in the background i see? at 3:50
i do believe that is the 180 on the back of there van...
yea i saw tay tay as well, i wonder what they were doing with it
The only thing a 180SX can do on a skidpan. MAD DORIFTOS
Yo this channel is as funny as informative ! Keep up with these awesome vids
Amazing show, as always!!!!!! :D
so are you no longer supported by Just Car Insurance?
+Shiho Miyazaki the commercial with the mod max they made is dope for super cheap auto. if yiu havent check out mcmtv2
***** rennoc gnal yes, I saw the commercial they filmed for supercheap auto, but they've been with just car for ages now.
Like the "Building" episodes more than those "Challenge" episodes.
Fantastic comparison
Love the bikes in the background!
It'd bolster your motor khana test if you alternate which vehicle the driver drives first. For example, Marty drives the turbo miata first and then the supercharged; Moog drives the supercharged miata first then drives the turbo miata next
Still enjoying the comparison. It's a great idea
They did that the second time.
Whoa Why Did You Just Remove The Harness Video??
Jack Williams / TympanicCoast72 ikr, wtf
I knew i saw them upload, wanted to watch it and now it's gone, WHY????
Came here looking for this. I started it and then waited till i made dinner, came back, and its friggin gone. what gives?
Jack Williams / TympanicCoast72 I was at school when it disappeared. What's wrong with youtube
There was an issue with the harness that they fitted. It was right for Marty but not adjusted properly for Moog so they took down the video as it wasn't appropriate to show after they decided that it wasn't safe (as in not safe to wear an ill fitting harness). They felt it gave the wrong message.
They are redoing it and it will be back up once they have fixed the issue.
Follow them on the Faceballs to get updated info and explanations like this. :)
this is great! I just bought an NA miata and I was trying to figure out whether to go turbo, supercharger, or Na.
cant wait to see them on the track and would love to see the same thing done on like v6's or straight 6's
20:40 180 sx nuggets in the background on the left , who knows what's preparing with the mx5 and the 180
Are you guys purposefully leaving out POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT SUPERCHARGERS? You're using a centrifugal supercharger. If you wanted to test a PROPER supercharger, you should have done a positive displacement supercharger (Eaton or Twin Screw). The centrifugal superchargers are almost a hybrid between a supercharger and turbo.
The positive displacement (PD) supercharger is the best type of supercharger. That is why ALL car manufacturers that make supercharged cars use them, NOT centrifugal superchargers. PD superchargers make FULL BOOST as low as 1800rpm, and continue to make it to redline. And they have instant throttle response. In a turbo car, if you're off the throttle at 4000rpm, then jump back on throttle, you have to wait to build boost. In a PD supercharged car, the boost hits the instant you hit the throttle.
I understand there may not have been a PD supercharger available for the Miata, but I do have to say this comparison (which I still loved) is like playing a professional football team against a college team.
I know what you mean, and there are supercharger kits with Eaton type superchargers for the Miata. Fast Forward makes one, for instance. The TVS900.
I would imagine the same could be said for turbo tech tho so perhaps the anology is just using a white ball or a red ball
Zolen Boogaerts my exact thought
U can have 3 turbos on your car, that covers all the power band, or you can twincharger. why choose one system when you can have both? there are even cars that spin the turbo electronically first.
Sacatolas Moreira are you can have both Twin screw SC for low rpms and have a turbo for high rpms
Makes me even more excited for my build.
Want the powertrain out of a FPV F6 Typhoon too go into my 1993 Ford Falcon XG.
Mcm dropped a new video as I was watching this one. I’m gonna have to stick it out for the skids
5:30 AM in the UK
5:30 PM in NZ
6:66 AM in Hell
did anyone see the 180sx in the background on a truck
i'm a big fan on this channel and this test is awesome. I have an mx-5 i've love to boost so this comparison is great! one of the advantages of the turbo is variable boost though so i feel like keeping both cars on 10 psi is a missed opportunity.
Really digging all of the band t-shirts moog has been wearing.
@20:40 is that moogs 180 on the truck in the background?
Is that Tay Tay i spy in the back ground at 2:32 maybe next video???
great job , appreciate your hard work 🤗🤗
Excellent job gentlemen! I reckon your choice of forced induction depends on what you're driving requirements are. After your review I can see the strengths and drawbacks to both. Cheers!