Does the Quran Support Domestic Abuse? Verse
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ส.ค. 2017
- In our series, controversial issues related to women, we’ll explore this topic further. Does the Quran support domestic abuse? Do we need to rethink this issue from an Islamic lens? We sit down and talk to Dr. Shabir Ally to learn more.
___
Please SUBSCRIBE to SUPPORT the show!
Questions: www.QuranSpeaks.com/Contact
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Twitter : / quran_speaks
God I really hate the comment sections on these videos, they’re never informant and usually just negative and make u disgusted by people’s ignorance.
The Quran is often misunderstood and misinterpreted by some Muslims and Non-Muslim and many verses are misquoted. No matter what was done against you, if you forgive and leave those affairs to Allah (SWT), it is better for you and Allah (SWT) will reward you, don't worry! It is easy to hurt someone, but it is far better to love and follow the guidance of Allah (SWT) and all his Prophets (PBUT), and his last Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). In the Quran, Allah (SWT) teaches love and not hate. The same goes for Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) teachings. Thank you Dr. Shabir Ally for your explanation filled with wisdom.
He just said a whole lot of nothing
If my husband even so much attempt to raise a hand at me I will change , he will not wake from his sleep
But prostitutes don't become prostitutes because they like it, they become prostitutes because they need to. Why would we punish them with house arrest or corporal punishment, instead of helping them meaningfully? The clients are those who should be punished for taking advantage of poor vulnerable women.
I like the reform attempt and hope it continues but it's kind of sophomoric to think that for 1400 years all Muslim scholars and communities got the understanding of this verse wrong but this one man in Canada (who would ridicule such teachings) got it right. It's better to admit what the Quran is teaching (to physically discipline wives if need be) and say that we are better than that teaching so we'll reinterpret this verse. All and all I'm happy that Islam is starting to reform. It's about time.
But why has a woman listen to her husband? Where do they talk about what should the woman do when the husband doesn't listen to her?
why do so many translations still use the word husbands then? wives are also used. Maybe it's time for a better translation?
I feel so sorry for Muslim women
But still this question is still haunting me! Why even put to touch her in any kind of way. And that would be for all generations not only the old… this the one thing I can’t swallow and makes me question…. Because I don’t feel like God belittles the woman to the point that if she doesn’t listen to him, he can beat her as the last solution…. I just don’t feel it comes from God Almighty!
But again in the Quran it says: "And live with them (the woman) in kindness" (
I really appreciate the conversational style of these videos and the quality of questions asked by the Sister. Thank you all for your time and effort.
Context is a good thing to observe.. that was enlightening Dr. Ally thank you.
i saw a person writing a comment below a book of the seerah of our prohet muhammad saw and he had no knowlegde about this verse like me so i checked the sura and verse 34 and was very disappointed at the beginning too so i started researching and found your video - thank you very much for the explanation and may Allah swa be with you
i dont understand why the Quran would need specificity on it saying “Husbands” & “wives” even when you take out husband & wife isn’t it speaking “in general” ?? like regardless of if it says husband or doesnt, it says women.
Verse 4:34 is crystal clear in what is says. DO we need explanations to lessen it's severity?
'Beat their wives'....!????? Honestly....!? Justify this in modern day and age!
It "if you fear dissencion between the two send an arbitrator". This clearly shows that the only time you send an arbitrator is in times when there is a wrong judgement. (Example; when a man beats an "innocent" wife)
Learned something new today
May Allah grant Dr Shabbir Ali the greatest paradise and grant him long life he is the most humble of the Muslim scholars and can interprate the Qur'an and the verses logically unlike these extremist scholars with Thier ignorant claims !!