Auburn Gymnast KNEE DISLOCATION | Doctor Explains
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 มิ.ย. 2024
- Auburn gymnast Samantha Cerio suffered bilateral knee dislocations during a recent competition.
In this video we'll review the biomechanics of landing and explain part of why this happened, plus we'll review the important nerves and blood vessels in the knee that us doctors worry about with a leg fracture or knee dislocation.
No graphic content is shown in this video and i do not show the injury clip.
Other knee dislocation videos i've discussed:
Shaun Livingston
• WORST NBA Injury EVER?...
Zach Miller
• Why He Almost LOST HIS...
McKenzie Milton
• WORST College Football...
TWITTER:
b_sutterer?lang=en
DISCLAIMER: I have not treated or evaluated the athlete discussed in this video. Content not to be taken as medical advice. Opinions represent those of myself and not my employer - กีฬา
You tell me more information than the media when an athlete gets injured
That's the goal 👍
@Richardbubkus411 he's genuinely very good at this compared to most of his peers who release info on sports injuries. Not just media pundits.
The media is extremely scientifically challenged
Not a bad thing. The media aren't doctors.
He kinda is the media, isn't he?
That was a gut wrenching injury I wish her a speedy recovery
What you mean gut wrenching?
Big A have you never heard of that phrase before or something
No
just saw it. it was definitely shocking. i haven't seen it in gymnastics but other sports with hyper-extensions. tough girl for not screaming.
Blackman Whitesuit she didn’t scream?
As a sport science student, these vids have been invaluable, keep up the great work 👌🏻
How so
017474 Just know what the damn word means and it won't be an issue 😂😂
017474 If you truly believe that, then what's your problem with them trying to sound smart? Why can't they do that if it means the same shit?
@@Bhasker7474 they actually don't mean the same thing, similar but not the same. Valuable= having a great deal of value, while invaluable= value beyond estimation.
This is the stuff of NIGHTMARES I hope she recovers well
Nowadays I hurt my knees if I even just miss a step on the stairs #oldman
I thought you are jon snow
you too?
Godfrey Tavera why do people keep thinking I look like him 😂
Central District yeah 😢
My dad missed a step on the stairs and tore both of his quads, but it was in 2k16 so he’s aight now
I argued my friends up and down why this wasn’t a leg break but knee dislocations with ligament tears, that you for this information! Absolutely love your content!
Thank you for tackling this topic and doing her justice by not showing the entire video again. I saw she had an excellent support system during recovery 💕
As a future PT and a sports fan I appreciate you so much
We wish you luck in finishing your course.
David Margaryan good luck with studies man
Skip Bayless thinks Lebrons groin tear isn't a good excuse for the failed season. I am ready to hear your thoughts, Dr. Guy.
It’s extremely hard to see such a talented and smart young lady that’s got such an amazing future ahead of her, I pray this doesn’t effect her the rest of her life. I hope she has a full recovery without lasting problems.
Did she recover?
Wow. Ur fast with these uploads, i was literally just watching it
I looked it up after Charles Barkley’s shoutout then watched a couple of different videos I come back and he uploaded.
I cringe so hard for her! I can't even imagine the pain. Great explanation of what happened.
I broke my tibia in a. Car accident and was in an immense amount of pain I can only imagine how painful this was for here with it being both sides. Praying for a quick and painless recovery.
Thank you Brian for finally explaining to me why a knee dislocation is truly an EMERGENCY !
Thank you so much for not showing clips or pictures right off the bat or without warning.
I and I imagine some others also are hyper sensitive to any injuries.
For me personnally it creates intense anxiety, even moderate anxiety through verbal description.
It's difficult.
Thank you SO MUCH for this awesome video explaining the knee! I had bilateral knee replacement in 2017 (arthritis) and am doing great, but I wasn't an "athlete" but love your explanation of the knee and how everything funtions. Thank you!
Soon you'll be collaborating with some sports channel. Very thorough explanation on this particular injury. Prayers up for Samantha!
I love the way you explain the diagnosis of injuries especially in sports
He only does sports injuries...
What would be the emergency response/treatment to this?
I'm hugging my knee as I watch the original video.
Nathan Hung amputation of both legs
Ice now, heat later
Tell them to walk it off
@Uncle Jemima in case of no open fracture, stabilize the joint, check for pulse below the knee to see if there is an arterial injury as the doc says. If no pulse, emergency surgery at the hospital. If there is a pulse, there will be X-rays, imaging and then surgery to repair the tears in the knee ligaments that were hurt. This girl won't be able to stand on her feet for 1-2 months. Then slowly resume to normal function through therapy.
newsflash, this girl is going to have pain in the knees for the rest of her life most likely.
@@M4nimal What is going to cause the pain? Is something in here knees damaged permanently and will never heal?
I too also once jacked up my patella due to the daily jumping warmups i used to do on a hard surface. Luckily I'm fully healed and can now run and jump like before. But now that I now how easy it is permanently damage your knees, I now only do jogging (on grass) and have stopped hipping and sprinting. Now seeing the video of this girl and seeing your comment on permanent injuries has reinforced my view points about knees.
I love a intelligent explanation of things I don’t know about that I can understand. Thanks good video
Yay! I was just minding my business procrastinating for studying for my psych nursing final, saw some of the gymnast video on REACT, had to look it up, and then found this! Guess I learned something after all ;) thanks for reminding us about avascular necrosis and possible paralysis! Maybe I'm meant to be an ortho nurse haha...thanks for the educational video! I saw so many comments on the original video asking how this is possible to happen, and you explained very well! I'll subscribe!
As someone who has multiple partial dislocations per week, this is an excellent short explanation about the mechanisms behind sports-related knee dislocations.
Impressive!!! You were thoughtful and sensitive. And when most would have played the video a thousand, you were very tasteful in your video. Thank you
Thanks I intentionally didn't want to show it to try and be more tasteful .
Was definitely waiting on this video.
Damn, just seeing her injured like that just makes my heart stopped a second. Get well soon!
You're awesome doc! Injuries are a different approach to study anatomy and keep it interesting
Thanks!
I'm still nursing a low impact unilateral patellar dislocation and given what little force it took for my kneecap to end up on the outside of my leg, I often wonder in amazement how gymnasts can get away with the countless short landings and twists without MORE incidences of injury to the knee (but them, athletes are far more fit that I am and have better muscle/tendon support). It really was an unfortunate accident for Samantha Cerio and I hope she recovers well from it.
Great explanation! Thank you.
excellent description and explanation! thank you!
You bet! Thanks!
Great video. Keep up the great work.
Very informative, thank you!
Just discovered this channel today..very well done and great information..thanks very much..\m/
I was wondering if you were gonna do a vid about this injury 😎
OOF! hey doc, i’m back. this one is probably season ending too, huh??? ;) but no, really for the gymnast that’s incredibly sad (used to do gymnastics). as usual you did a great job explaining why this happened. knew you’d be on it!
This video was very educational. Thank you!
You're welcome!
A very satisfying explanation
Thank you for now showing video of the injury
**not*
Yes for NOT
Thanks doc! Sports fan from the Philippines
Very-very informative.
Is it messed up to look forward to these videos to see the doctor break down the injury?
I was doing one-legged bulgarian squats and my knee cracked at some point when I was pushing upwards at the beginning of the movement. From what I remember, the leg went no straight upwards, but a bit inwards. After that I got some stiffness in the knee and no immediate pain or swelling. My orthopedist diagnosed me with a somewhat (not severe) capsule tear. She also said it takes 4-6 weeks to heal and you cannot do much about it. My question is - what is this capsule tear? I am not sure what can be damaged in the knee this way. Occasional pain that I have been experiencing in the last 2.5 weeks is on the medial front side, around the point where the tibia and the femur connect. I would appreciate any information. Great channel!
Your soo informative, great video !!
Appreciate it!
That short clip almost made me vomit. It hurt still jump and land hyperextended, she did a double and landed hyperextended, bleh. Wishing her a speedy recovery though
Great Information.
Great work
This clip almost made me vomit, but I knew a video was coming on it
Did she recover?
Thank you doc!
Yo Brian thanks for not showing the injury in its entirety where's it's was paused at is stomach turning enough and the emphasis on the nerves and blood vessels that a lot of us don't consider in these cases.
hey there, I'm a bit of a late comer to this party, have you ever done one on Drew Brees' shoulder injury? I find it amazing how it was so well repaired that he was still able to win a superbowl after... Great Videos! Thanks!
Wowww!!!! I hope Cerio would be fine after that accident :( thank you for such educational video Doctor
Nice video, but would've liked to know more about what injuries / surgeries the gymnast actually experienced.
I broke my back and have nerve damage in my right leg. Its my sciatic nerve that is damaged. Half my buttock and leg muscle has wasted away. I've honestly gotten to the point that I don't wanna live much longer. I can walk but I'll probably never get any better. Life really sucks with a half paralyzed half numb leg.
Hi Brian. I love your videos, they’re very educational and the sports injury is such an interesting topic. I was wondering if you can do a video about one of Marco Reus Injuries.
I would be really interested if it was the one that kept him to pray te Euro 2016 or the one that kept him out of the World cup 2014. There are more info about all the soccer players injuries in the website called Transfermarket
Has there been a prognosis released for the gymnast? Thx.
Hey Brian, I’ve been recently diagnosed with osgood schlatter disease, I heard it’s pretty common among sportsman
I’d like to hear your thoughts on that
I had it as a teenager in my right knee after a growth spurt. it was very painful at first, especially after hockey practice. Hopefully if you are active in sports it doesn’t affect you in the same way it affected me. Gods speed to you (P.S really good video idea too(
Pj Schiff Thanks. It does affect me unfortunately, I'm playing basketball for my uni. From my what I could find this disease usually affects teenagers like you said, though I'm 20 and I can't recall myself having growing spurt recently.
@@98nikson That's a really unique diagnosis for 20 years old. At my Uni, one of my friends had 2 growth spurts, one at 16 and another at 21.. Possible you could be in the process of undergoing a second. I hope Dr. Sutterer posts a vid on Osgood-Schlatter's so we can learn more.. Either way best of luck with OSD (Rest and ice were my two best friends).
So...official reports say posterior dislocated knee. I'm thinking PCL, popliteus, posterior horns and maybe LCL? What do you think?
I have Ehlers Danlos Syndrome so I have daily subluxations and dislocations. I have had both my knees operated on due to ligament damage
A little over a year ago I tore my meniscus and my ACL and it took a really long time to recover because I made it worse by continuing to do gymnastics when I knew I was hurt.
Great video Brian. Tighten your tie though!
Watched the video separately thanks! She shouldn't ask people not to watch!!
Tough recovery..makes my fx tib look minor.
Knee injuries are brutal, speaking from unfortunate experience. I had a lateral dislocation of my patella one time and it was not pretty. My kneecaps just naturally sit up higher than normal, so I’m just more susceptible to those kind of injuries if I’m not careful with lateral movement.
Wow that was soooooo fast 🔥
Can you do a video on Andrew bogut elbow injury?
Plz plz do one on osgood schlatter
I dislocated my knee cap about 11 years ago. As I've gotten older I can no longer run because my knees swell up really bad. Also, when I'm going down steps or on a down slope you can hear my knees crackle. Yes crackle just like the cereal. What should I do?? I swear knee straps when I work out but it still hurts.
I’m not a gymnast so I do not understand why the black pad belongs on the floor. If a gymnast is training on flat floor and then has to land on a surface 4 inches higher than level ground during competition, it could have contributed to the hyper extended knee position. All those ligaments are in their tightest position in full knee extension. I would be interested to see if there is increased injury rates due to the pad vs no pad. Thanks for the video!
I thought the same. The pad, in theory, could soften the landing but it could also throw off the timing by a second or two on the landing. The "feel" of a blind landing is very sensitive. I watched Sam in another video do this handspring pass with no problem at all, like she could do it in her sleep. Wonder if that pad affected her timing.
My daughter is on a competitive gymnastics team and you are correct that pad vs no pad does indeed change the timing and the position you need to be in to land correctly and safely. With that said, it is almost guaranteed that different venues have different sports equipment. Your home gym that you train in will not have the same equipment and in the same condition as your competitive venues - it’s luck of the draw. Most competitive events allow practice passes so that you can get a feel for the equipment and the timing and it is something this gymnast was definitely aware of as she has been preforming for quite some time. Unfortunately it does help contribute to injuries like these. I personally feel like it should be standard equipment across the board, no matter the competitive venue. It would at least remove one factor for injury! Wishing her a speedy recovery, this is what I envision happening when my little girl is on the floor, shewwww.
Alexandria Southwell thanks for the info, that was well explained :)
Hey Brian Im a young athlete, and everytime after i do some type of physical activity my shins hurt, i think i have shin splints but i dont want to keep playing if its a stress fracture and ultimately make it worse. Any thoughts?
Get an xray?
I have frequent patella dislocations so this hits close to home I hate my knees and not really am sure what to do from this point
You should do one on the lacerated kidney mystery injury Andrew luck sustained in 2015.
Or Chris Simms ruptured spleen
Dr Sutterer do you know what actual damage she sustained? And how it will affect her recovery?
(wishing her a full and speedy recovery.)
Not sure. She's graduating though and isn't competing in gymnastics anymore.
Hey! So I recently just injured my knee. I jumped and landed wrong on my left leg. I heard and felt like my knee popped but when i landed it popped back into place. It hurt when It happend but i was able to walk it off and stretch it. It got swollen but without any bruising the day after and its hard to bend fully. Its been 4/5 days now and I can walk on it more, its still swollen (no bruising still) but its still alil hard to fully bend. The front of my knee gets tight, the back of my knee and outside of my knee do also. Is this something serious (surgery needed) or will this eventually subside with more PT and RICE?
I hate the words "knee" and "dislocation" in the same sentence, it just makes me fall whenever I hear it😭
I hate every sentence that has "dislocation"
In it
@@ineedsomemilk6610, YES! I hate that word!
Which one of them nerves you spoke about caused Jaylon Smiths Drop foot. Also ca you do a video on Jaylon Smith and What Dr Cooper was able to do to enable him to play again.
Usually the common peroneal nerve. It is a branch off the sciatic nerve
Oh man, that fall was horrifying to watch before hearing what could be wrong. I hope the damage wasn’t too bad for her.
There is another doctor who does similar content. His name is Dr. Antonio Webb. I think it would be cool to have both of you collaborate on some videos together.
Yea I just saw he started doing this a week or so ago and has followed suit with a lot of what I cover. I guess imitation is the sincerest form of flattery!
Brian Sutterer MD Sue that bastard!!!
Can it also happen in elbow? With an hiperextended elbow?
Can you do Anderson Silva's leg break?
I am curious about Alex Smith's, injury, but maybe he already has a vid on that
Yes! I would like to see that too!
I have a similar injury to my left leg but from a trip and fall I was hurt in 2017 and still have to use a wheelchair and walker can you help me with a few questions so that I can try to have a normal life again how can I contact you my doctor is an idiot and I feel i should be walking by now I have two boys that want me normal again so that we can do the things we did before
I can't help but wonder what could be done to prevent these types of unfortunate injuries in future athletes. This some how seems to be preventable to me. Was she warmed up and moving? Is it possible to construct a safer landing area or is there a technique issue here from her training that built up layers of damage that subsequently led to this freak injury.... ?
Richard H not landing like that
@@Jman3881_ this is a particularly funny way to answer a question in middle school - but from an adults perspective a total waste of time. Clearly it is a bad landing. How do you prevent an injury from a bad landing was my thought process however.
Richard H it’s called not hyperextending your legs when landing. Obviously she landed wrong. It’s common sense. If you land badly, your body is going to hurt. You can’t prevent your body from breaking when you do something wrong.
@@Jman3881_ actually we have been finding ways to prevent these things from happening for several decades now. Thinking it's impossible to prevent injuries is exactly the kind of thought process that should be avoided.
Richard H I mean if you watched the video you can clearly see when she lands her knees are stiff which causes all the force to impact that joint.
She pulled the ol’ double Livingston
PKIce you wrong for that 😭
PKIce her legs turned into flamingo legs
Who else got excrutiating pain on the knees while watching this video?
Also, do you have a video about theories on why do our body feel pain when watching someone getting injured i.e.videos? My body hurts too much when watching videos like these, and you co uld consider I'm "average" in health. Common back and knee pain from someone that does heavy work. But mostly relaxed.
So, the artery was intact unlike the Zach Miller situation?
Hey Doc... I think you could have shown the film of the performance. Her routine shows the power and force her knees had to endure. For all the pain she endured it would be good to give the viewers an opportunity to see her skill.. and why her competitive fire contributed to this injury. Let sister shine a little bit
I was actually trying to be respectful by not showing the full clip and the actual dislocation :/
@@BrianSuttererMD I respect that. You're doing a good job keep it up
So we should worry about the Blood supply and nerves more than the flashy names of the media (ACL, etc) for overall function after the injury. What about high function athletes? Will ligament damage lead to the possibility of reduced function for sports, or is it still only the nerve/blood supply we should be worried about?
How much does it cost this knee apparatus? Where can I find it?
Hey doc, I’m a runner and my knees and lcl tendons hurt a lot. What should I do?
Need to go to a doc and make sure that's what it actually is and then follow their plan. Sorry but I have no way of telling you what to do over a TH-cam comment
WOW. YOUR PAIN IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ENTERTAINING AND FUNNY. THANK YOU FOR BREAKING BOTH KNEES SO I COULD WATCH IT A HUNDRED TIMES AND RETWEET TO MY 15K FOLLOWERS WHILE LAUGHING AT YOUR MISERY.
Right when I heard "Popliteal fossa", my brain instantly remembered Bears TE Zach Miller, who suffered a left knee dislocation back in 2017 and he did tear his popliteal artery. You already know this since you did a video on that. Here's Dr. Sutterer's video if anyone else wants to see him discuss that injury: th-cam.com/video/zBr5IFpfUbk/w-d-xo.html
This literally happened to me last Saturday
Do lienen injury?
Could you do a video on the Harry Kane injury from today
What happened?
@@officeaddict33 Looks like he messed up his ankle but no specifics have been released yet
Why do my knees bend a little more that other ppls?
Damn homie you didn't waste no time uploading did you?
I honestly want to see a episode on figure skaters, Seeing as I am one.
Bet she got a standing ovation
Zach Miller type beat
Can you do mcdavids injury?
I've been following it but I don't think we have the MRI update do we?
dr Suter vs dr mike boxing match please!
Here I’m screaming in pain when I think there is no more steps and the step of the stairs randomly buckles my knee and I go to the ground screaming for 911 and pain killers thinking I’ll never walk anymore and I’ll never run. But then I hear STFU! Then I get up and walk off like it never happened