@@angie-tm7qg what the hell are you on about? You need to think your comments through, otherwise they come out weird like yours did. I gave you criticism and you’re telling me to get a life. Like do you start every argument out as toxic?
I actually love this concept because I give 5 stars so easily but to books so different from one another sometimes it confuses even me. It’s really cool to see you make the distinction between 6 star reads, solid 5 stars, books you’s change the rating of and books you just don’t feel the same about anymore. Really cool video!! 💗💗💗
Good video! I just purchased three books! 👍🏼 📚 I see a lot of negativity towards Colleen, yet her books seem to have “initiated/started” reading for many. It’s alright to “grow out of” particular authors, but IMO some just jump on supposed “cool” train. Sort of reminds me of something similar that happened to one of my favorite artists.
sara's in her consistency era, and i'm here for it!! there are literally some really great books within the five stars! also, i think we could have all guessed where magnolia parks was going even before clicking on the video💕
To anybody watching this who’s enjoyed colleen hoover, because it’s on trend to dislike her books, there’s nothing wrong with enjoying them if you do! She’s not my top author, but I’ve loved so many of her books! I feel so many people are jumping on the hating her books bandwagon! There’s no right or wrong with what authors you enjoy / don’t enjoy, do you!❤ That being said, I enjoyed the video as always Sara and completely respect your opinion on it ❤️
@@KeyondraHarris From what I’ve heard her son SA’d someone and she defended him, which is pretty crappy especially considering one of her most popular books is about *not* defending that kind of thing
@@etlthornburgh ehhh, i wonder when that happened bcus "it ends with us" its almost like she wanted readers to feel remorse for the rapist... i also got that vibe from Hopeless too. She always makes the rapists sound like these perfect ppl that just made this "little" mistake.
@@KeyondraHarris I needa reread It Ends With Us tbh because I read it when I was just starting my “booktok” portion of reading and I didn’t get many of those vibes at the time but looking back yeah that honestly makes sense. I liked Ryle for a long time in the book up to a certain point but I know people who still defended him even after reading the whole thing which is… concerning
I’d love to see someone read the UK version of AGGGTM after reading the US one, because there are a lot of changes in it (setting changes, language changes and some sections are missing completely). Also I am so excited for the show and I have never felt excitement for a book adaptation than I have with this book!
you should do a blind date with a book thing, sometimes they have them at barnes and noble and other places have them and it would be cool to see you pick some out and read them!
I would LOVE to see you make a video re-reading Colleen Hoover books. Especially since you have no idea what you would think of them now. I’m so curious!
It's so funny because for someone who never read any romance or in that general genre I started with CoHo books I Saw it ends with us at an airport lol and decided to pick it up, but after reading Emily Henry, Anna Huang, Taylor Jenkins Reid, and Abby Jimenez I realized I just like them way more. I don't like any CoHo books anymore besides Verity because Verity messed up my mind reading it in 24 hours.
i think a lot to do with it is that people loved them at the beginning of their journey, but after reading more they realised those books do not align with their preferences anymore
@@leah-ko6wjyeah, like im grateful Colleen pretty much got me into reading but looking back, her books weren't great. They felt very easy and not very complex?? if that makes sense? I definitely wouldn't enjoy one of hers now after reading other and much better booksm
@@elyse5639 i feel like thats the case with a lot of new readers, and a phase i had myself when i was younger, however, i have “matured” as a reader in the books i read and my taste, which leads me to not enjoy her books as much anymore (my coho phase was when i was 12/13, which i know, bad, however it is the way her books are marketed. but this is why i said matured, not trying to imply anything)
I love this video idea! However I would have swapped the negative undertone of the "old me" section for the label "new reader." Those books tend to start many people's reading journey and they are so special because of that. Would I rate the 'Uglies' series by SW a 5 star read now like I did nearly 15 years ago? Maybe not, but it's still a 5 star read because of the 100s of dystopian fantasy books it both inspired in the genre and led me to read (and eventually write) personally 🥰
Looove this video concept. Definitely took a screenshot so I can remember to read some of these books! Some of my other 5 star reads: Lessons in Chemistry (6-star), the Maid (5-star), Daughter of the Pirate King duology (5-star), By Any Other Name (comfort read)
I like that the last tier was, this was the old me, because it doesn't speak down to the old you, it respects that you felt that way at the time even if things have changes since then
I also when I was starting to get into books I didn’t know where to get recommendations from so I searched on the web and it basically said Collen Hoover it ends with us and that was In the popular books section and I just started reading it 😅 ( I definitely relate to you Sara ❤)
I’m almost halfway through magnolia parks and I still can’t imagine me forgiving a cheater but we shall see lol! ❤I’m not a picky reader and even love toxic boys but not cheaters so I’m interested to see if my mind will change by the end of book 1
Sara my sister really really loves your earings so so much and you're looking too pretty in spectacles you are my inspiration and I wish you have a amazing day💖💫🤗
Currently in a hotel and driving home. I have to go from Florida to Canada, where I live. I was in the car for 13 hours. Now I am in a hotel and I get this.❤
me getting mad that you put the shatter me series in the valid 5 stars and didn't inject it into your veins, but then remmembering that everyone can have their opinion:
The rain congratulates us when we kiss; or are the angels watering our scalps? The raindrops braid our hair into their twists as mouths dismantle; mouth from mouth dismounts. Indoors it seems we've come from somewhere else; some separate world is still inside our hair. How different does a person in Love sound? their words which dress a wounded atmosphere. Isn’t it beautiful how soulmates are? how magic puppeteers their chance to meet How feeble folds the raptor’s wings. Our arms; throughout a kissing on a rainy street. How could we prove such bonds were made before? a couple feeling like they’ve kissed before. ( a sonnet that i wrote today about soulmates)
I'm glad someone else feels the same way about Every Summer After. I read it after binging all of The Summer I Turned Pretty trilogy and I DNF'd it in the first 50 pages because it felt too much like a franken-novel of TSITP and L&OW
I don't love Colleen Hoover, but I definitely am not on the hate bandwagon for her. But usually I don't love her books (November 9 is my most hated book. I do not hate any book more than that one. It wins the hate contest) HOWEVER, I knew I wanted to read Confess because it seemed the most interesting (it was out of stock everywhere when I wanted it so I read some of the others) but anyway, I finally read it and loved it because it was what I wanted. So it is a 5 star for me. So that's a long explanation for me to say that it's okay to like or love some of her books 😅
only 5 minutes into the video but patiently waiting for you to talk about magnolia parks and have them overtake the "inject this into my veins tier" bc literally same
Hi Sara I am a new subscriber and i just wanted to say every single one of your videos has made my life SO much better!!! I am trying to become a booktuber one day and man if im half as good as you i‘ll be satisfied YOU ARE SO AMAZING!!! tysmmmm for your content! 🤩❤
Sara’s videos are just pure comfort. She has the most comforting voice.
She should fr do a “rereading my olddddd five star reads”
THE WAY MOTHER IS FEEDING US!!!!!❤
FRRR I LOVE ITT
🤨📸
Did. You actualy read what you commented? Please for the love of god try again
@@bruhda7469 get a life, try again😂
@@angie-tm7qg what the hell are you on about? You need to think your comments through, otherwise they come out weird like yours did. I gave you criticism and you’re telling me to get a life. Like do you start every argument out as toxic?
I’m absolutely so grateful that you’re posting so much!! 💕 adding these all to my goodreads
should i be doing homework? yes. will i watch sara’s video instead? absolutely 🥰
I actually love this concept because I give 5 stars so easily but to books so different from one another sometimes it confuses even me. It’s really cool to see you make the distinction between 6 star reads, solid 5 stars, books you’s change the rating of and books you just don’t feel the same about anymore. Really cool video!! 💗💗💗
THE COMFORTING PERSON AWARD GOES TO YOU !!!❤🌼✨
The fact that I just finished Scream and needed something wholesome to watch and Sara posted 💗💗
Good video! I just purchased three books! 👍🏼 📚
I see a lot of negativity towards Colleen, yet her books seem to have “initiated/started” reading for many. It’s alright to “grow out of” particular authors, but IMO some just jump on supposed “cool” train. Sort of reminds me of something similar that happened to one of my favorite artists.
sara's in her consistency era, and i'm here for it!!
there are literally some really great books within the five stars! also, i think we could have all guessed where magnolia parks was going even before clicking on the video💕
Yesss!! Loving the consistency Sara❤️❤️
i knew from the beginning that colleen hoover would be at the bottom LOL
Monotone is a good way to describe “if he had been with me” but like it was so good. It almost needed to be monotone to fit the story
21:37
To anybody watching this who’s enjoyed colleen hoover, because it’s on trend to dislike her books, there’s nothing wrong with enjoying them if you do! She’s not my top author, but I’ve loved so many of her books! I feel so many people are jumping on the hating her books bandwagon! There’s no right or wrong with what authors you enjoy / don’t enjoy, do you!❤
That being said, I enjoyed the video as always Sara and completely respect your opinion on it ❤️
she writes about and romanticises incest and abuse…
@@hannahd4vwhat actions?
@@KeyondraHarris From what I’ve heard her son SA’d someone and she defended him, which is pretty crappy especially considering one of her most popular books is about *not* defending that kind of thing
@@etlthornburgh ehhh, i wonder when that happened bcus "it ends with us" its almost like she wanted readers to feel remorse for the rapist... i also got that vibe from Hopeless too. She always makes the rapists sound like these perfect ppl that just made this "little" mistake.
@@KeyondraHarris I needa reread It Ends With Us tbh because I read it when I was just starting my “booktok” portion of reading and I didn’t get many of those vibes at the time but looking back yeah that honestly makes sense. I liked Ryle for a long time in the book up to a certain point but I know people who still defended him even after reading the whole thing which is… concerning
I’d love to see someone read the UK version of AGGGTM after reading the US one, because there are a lot of changes in it (setting changes, language changes and some sections are missing completely). Also I am so excited for the show and I have never felt excitement for a book adaptation than I have with this book!
we have the EXACT same thoughts on beach read 😭😭 put it in my veins but also so comforting
Whenever you post my day get immediately better!! Also your one of the prettiest people like ever 🤭
Powerless is definitely my fav too!!❤❤ in chestnut springs
the way only coho books are in the old me tier💀
You should do a video on re-reading the books that got you back into reading and compare your old opinions on them to your current ones!
this video is what i needed. your so pretty! i have a whole lot of five stars! but i’ve never tier ranked them. ilyyy
always a treat to get a notificaton from you sara 💜
you should do a blind date with a book thing, sometimes they have them at barnes and noble and other places have them and it would be cool to see you pick some out and read them!
I would LOVE to see you make a video re-reading Colleen Hoover books. Especially since you have no idea what you would think of them now. I’m so curious!
never stop talking abt mpu cos we love it!! i feel the same way abt the series esp the long way home. that book is special
We love a consistent book queen 🥰
as someone who’s been watching your videos since 2019 this was so funny seeing how much your opinions have changed and evolved😭💖
I am reading "Happy Place" now and am loving it!
Sara you are honestly my comfort person, I love you and your videos so much 💖
🤍🤍🤍🤍
It's so funny because for someone who never read any romance or in that general genre I started with CoHo books I Saw it ends with us at an airport lol and decided to pick it up, but after reading Emily Henry, Anna Huang, Taylor Jenkins Reid, and Abby Jimenez I realized I just like them way more. I don't like any CoHo books anymore besides Verity because Verity messed up my mind reading it in 24 hours.
Your videos honestly are the most comforting thing ❤
I agree with all the assessments of the books I’ve read.❤
Cracks me up that everyone loved coho until the hate started and then suddenly everyone changes their mind and don’t like her books anymore
100%!!!
Thinking the same thing!
i think a lot to do with it is that people loved them at the beginning of their journey, but after reading more they realised those books do not align with their preferences anymore
@@leah-ko6wjyeah, like im grateful Colleen pretty much got me into reading but looking back, her books weren't great. They felt very easy and not very complex?? if that makes sense? I definitely wouldn't enjoy one of hers now after reading other and much better booksm
@@elyse5639 i feel like thats the case with a lot of new readers, and a phase i had myself when i was younger, however, i have “matured” as a reader in the books i read and my taste, which leads me to not enjoy her books as much anymore (my coho phase was when i was 12/13, which i know, bad, however it is the way her books are marketed. but this is why i said matured, not trying to imply anything)
I love this video idea! However I would have swapped the negative undertone of the "old me" section for the label "new reader." Those books tend to start many people's reading journey and they are so special because of that. Would I rate the 'Uglies' series by SW a 5 star read now like I did nearly 15 years ago? Maybe not, but it's still a 5 star read because of the 100s of dystopian fantasy books it both inspired in the genre and led me to read (and eventually write) personally 🥰
Ur so right! I love that wording better
I've been studying the whole afternoon and having an amazing video to watch is the best thing🩵
Also, this glasses are the cutest:)
I'm currently in a book slump and the way you are obsessed with Magnolia Parks makes me want to read it lol
Looove this video concept. Definitely took a screenshot so I can remember to read some of these books! Some of my other 5 star reads: Lessons in Chemistry (6-star), the Maid (5-star), Daughter of the Pirate King duology (5-star), By Any Other Name (comfort read)
Watching your videos is so comforting🥰
Man, I wish I had this many 5 stars!😭
She has more five stars than book I have read.
You know its a great day when bestie sara uploads
I was just thinking about youu! I am so happy you posted!! I love u! 💕 💗
i will never get sick of you talking about the books you love 💕
I like that the last tier was, this was the old me, because it doesn't speak down to the old you, it respects that you felt that way at the time even if things have changes since then
I love that the book girlies are posting so much!
I read the Shadow & Bone Series before Six of Crows and it still took me some time to get into Six of Crows. But Crooked Kingdom was just...😍
I also when I was starting to get into books I didn’t know where to get recommendations from so I searched on the web and it basically said Collen Hoover it ends with us and that was In the popular books section and I just started reading it 😅 ( I definitely relate to you Sara ❤)
Omg now I know which books I HAVE to add to my tbr
The way I ate this video up omg. I'm so excited.
The consistency yes!!!! 🫶🫶
Yes yes yes! I’ve been waitin’ for this one, turn it up!🤩
Jeez. Another upload from one of my fave booktubers! My day's complete, fr ❤
your videos bring me sm joy
Using this to find my next five star books ❤
this video idea is so creative!!! i loved every second 🫶🏻✨
THANK YOU FOR ALL THE CONTENT SARA AHHH
Omg Sara the glasses look sooooo good on you !!!
omg thank u
me clicking on this vid knowing damn well i’m gonna add every single book to my goodreads
I saw you went to see 5sos the other day! I'm seeing them in in 16 days in Texas, I hope you had so much fun!! I'm very excited. 🥰
IT WAS SO FUN!!!!!!
brb writing all of ur 5 stars down so i can read all of the ones i havent yet😌🤪
Literally doing the same😂😂😂
If he had been with me and the Hawthorne legacy are the ones I have read and they are so good.
Love you Sara, thanks for posting :)
i literally trust u with all of the books you liked (my whole bookshelf is filled with ur recs)
OBSESSED with your videos! 🫶🏻
I CANT AGREE MORE WITH MAGNOLIA PARKS!!!!! and not much people understand that feeling and its frustrating that i cant discuss with anyone ughhh
loved the video bestie!
THIS IS SO FUN I’m writing this down tysm
ily sara 🥰 ur videos make me so happy :D
We need a video of you rereading some of ur fav five star books.
or the ones that were the old her and rerank them
I’m almost halfway through magnolia parks and I still can’t imagine me forgiving a cheater but we shall see lol! ❤I’m not a picky reader and even love toxic boys but not cheaters so I’m interested to see if my mind will change by the end of book 1
Sara my sister really really loves your earings so so much and you're looking too pretty in spectacles you are my inspiration and I wish you have a amazing day💖💫🤗
Currently in a hotel and driving home. I have to go from Florida to Canada, where I live. I was in the car for 13 hours. Now I am in a hotel and I get this.❤
I think you should do a tier ranking of your least favourite/dnf’ed books!!! You can explain why you didn’t like them on different scales.
Watching this video after a tiring work day😭..Thank you Sara for being consistent and posting new videos❤
you should do a zoom reading seshion at some point where everyone can read together w you that would be ICONIC
Such a good idea! Love this.
i wake up to a sara carrolli notif. perfect way to start the day
i was bingeing your vlogs while this video was released 🥰🥰🥰
Sara you’ve convinced me to read the magnolia parks series and I’m so excited to start it
YAY!
WHAT A GREAT VIDEO IDEA
Thank you for making vids i really enjoy them ❤
This was fab idea. I feel like doing this for my own 5 stars. ❤
me getting mad that you put the shatter me series in the valid 5 stars and didn't inject it into your veins, but then remmembering that everyone can have their opinion:
hiiiiii Sara!! can’t wait to watch this video 🫶🏼🫶🏼
You could tier rank all the thrillers/fantasy you’ve read
Omg now have to add some book to to tbr
The rain congratulates us when we kiss;
or are the angels watering our scalps?
The raindrops braid our hair into their twists
as mouths dismantle; mouth from mouth dismounts.
Indoors it seems we've come from somewhere else;
some separate world is still inside our hair.
How different does a person in Love sound?
their words which dress a wounded atmosphere.
Isn’t it beautiful how soulmates are?
how magic puppeteers their chance to meet
How feeble folds the raptor’s wings. Our arms;
throughout a kissing on a rainy street.
How could we prove such bonds were made before?
a couple feeling like they’ve kissed before.
( a sonnet that i wrote today about soulmates)
the fact that the old me tier is fully colleen hoover😭😭
I'm currently reading Daisy Haites and I just don't want the series to end
I'm glad someone else feels the same way about Every Summer After. I read it after binging all of The Summer I Turned Pretty trilogy and I DNF'd it in the first 50 pages because it felt too much like a franken-novel of TSITP and L&OW
about to start the chestnut springs series thanks to you!!!
love a good tier ranking 💞
Its like Christmas morning when she posts ngl
i love you sara thank you for this💖💖💖💖💖💖
I don't love Colleen Hoover, but I definitely am not on the hate bandwagon for her. But usually I don't love her books (November 9 is my most hated book. I do not hate any book more than that one. It wins the hate contest) HOWEVER, I knew I wanted to read Confess because it seemed the most interesting (it was out of stock everywhere when I wanted it so I read some of the others) but anyway, I finally read it and loved it because it was what I wanted. So it is a 5 star for me.
So that's a long explanation for me to say that it's okay to like or love some of her books 😅
Truly posting content when I need it the most 🫶🩷
Reading by a thread soon I’m excited ❤❤
You look so good with glasses 🥺💜
only 5 minutes into the video but patiently waiting for you to talk about magnolia parks and have them overtake the "inject this into my veins tier" bc literally same
u get it
Video after video? Miss girl is slaying the upload game rn 🫶🫶
gonna take a wildddddd guess…magnolia parks may possibly end up in “inject this into my veins”😅
Hi Sara I am a new subscriber and i just wanted to say every single one of your videos has made my life SO much better!!! I am trying to become a booktuber one day and man if im half as good as you i‘ll be satisfied YOU ARE SO AMAZING!!! tysmmmm for your content! 🤩❤
omg that is so kind thank you! do it!!!
😍😍✨@@SaraCarrolli tysm i definitely will try
so valid for beach read will die for them