Both games are great, but I liked GTA San Andreas because of the large size of the city and the presence of cities, villages, rural places and forests, and there is a lot of content in the game after completing the story, such as you can be a taxi driver, paramedic, policeman or firefighter. Being a truck driver or a construction worker and being able to get into a gang war and being able to buy houses and go with your gangsters or go to the gym and do a lot of things in the world of San Andreas, unlike GTA 4, you can't do anything Other than just touring. The open world and eating in restaurants, playing bowling, or just hanging out with one of your friends, but GTA 4 offered excellent physics in everything. I don't hate GTA 4, but I prefer GTA San Andreas because of the great content in the world
Liberty City is a city. San Andreas is a state. To me it was obvious that (in 2008, even with the newer console gen...) LC won't be as big as SA. However GTA 4 probably has more (or at least equally as much) interiors and HD Era LC are as big as 3D Era San Andreas' three cities combined.
San andreas was so big i could feel when we change environment and get into the forest, it was amazing, but I hated when you fall off a cliff and have to swim for 10min just to get to nearest shore
If I could add one feature from GTA SA to IV would be the ability to buy more safehouses, it really feels like a chore to have only 3 saving spots in such a large city
TLAD desperately needed more safehouses. Once finishing the game you're left with one very out of the way place to go to just to save the game. TBOGT needed more as well but at least Luis' one was a bit more central.
in GTA SA has the character of a young person who always wants to try new things while in GTA 4 has the character of an older and more mature person who wants to enjoy life as a normal person in general
GTA IV didn't have enough time to bring in the variety, because they only had 4 years. They could either make a new physics engine or create environments. GTA VI is doing both so look how long it's taking to release.
@thanu they all used the same physics engine. It was just the question of adding new texture packs. That's why their animations are so similar. As a result of using the same physics engine, these games started their developments before their respective predecessors were even completed. So it's not like Vice City only had one year or San Andreas had only two years, they had a little more time than that. On the other hand, the hands of GTA IV's developers were tied until the new physics engine was created. All they could do was wait till it was done, only then they could start working.
excuse me but did you just say gta 4 has VARIETY? LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL no it doesn't and as for detail, in my opinion that doesn't matter at all in games, MOVIES maybe, but not games
@@Guesty1337CJ Can Work As Taxi Driver He Can Work As Ambulance Driver 😂😂😂😂😂He Can Work As Fire Man 😂😂😂😂😂He Can Work As Police Officer 😂😂😂😂He Can Work As 😂😂😂😂😂😂Sexy Girls Seller😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂He Can Do 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Drugs Deal😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂But Your G***ay Niko Can't 😂😂😂😂😂These Features are Not In GTA 5 Too LMAO 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I played both games while GTA San Andreas has a lot more features that are missing in GTA 4 , it's undeniable that GTA 4 has better graphics and way better physics.Both games have their ups and downs but I'd personally choose the San Andreas because there are a lot more things to do while in GTA 4 you're mainly stuck in a city that gets boring after a while.
Back then the complaints included: boring, sluggish, greyed out, depressing, downgraded, tonnes of content removed, abilities removed, monotonous friend activities, no progression or reason to, worst mission varety in the franchise, no property or even garages, multiplayer where people kept killing you at the airport, less cool cars, less guns, etc etc... Now in 2024 it's a 10/10 masterpiece, and potentially the greatest game ever made lol.
gta 4 definitely feels like a downgrade compared to sa but still a good game. always bothered me how you couldn't even fly a plane in gta 4 or get some good weapons like a minigun or a flamethrower but i still like gta 4.
@@elprimokyle1102nah. It aged poorly. It Has great radio stations and 80s Vibe but Holy Hell - the controls and gameplay itself aged poorly. Map is very small with nothing to do aside from Story and Vice City's story is nothing special either
@@Prince.Shoaib-back2YT I don't really agree but whatever works for you man. I mean I'm not being biased or anything, gta 5 was not only the first one I played but my very first experience with the series and for a while I loved it but after playing IV,san andreas and others it feels like 5 turned into a massive parody of it self especially with the microtransactions. we're honestly fortunate they didn't milk these two as much as they could have. (Not even bringing up "definitive" edition)
Tbf Tbogt did add a lot of things that GTA 4 needed like Tanks, Parachutes, more weapons, more mini games, though I agree In terms of features and map SA was better.
Talk about their feats, in the past / before the game storyline Niko did more than CJ as he was a soldier but in the game storyline CJ did way more than Niko as he broke into Area 69, killed a countless in a various areas not only in one city, etc.
@@cardenasr.2898that’s why they went back for game play in GTAV Many of these people forget that GTA4 was not as critically acclaimed. Many people were mad at a lot of the features
@@TeamCraftable2004 Bro, Gta SA is more well known compared to Half Life 2. Gta SA was the best Grand Theft Auto game by Rockstar on that era. Everyone loved it and played it everytime. It had all the possibilities and features you can think of. You'll never get bored. You can roam around the whole 3 big cities and a desert area in the map. Also Area 69 and steal the jetpack. Ride in the jetpack and what not?
GTA 4 had amazing driving and i thought Niko was a better character as he was through war and hearing his war stories is sad but it shows that Niko doesn't want to be a violent person
GTA 4 has better graphics but it's just too polished and the story was kind of bland. GTA SA was huge ranging from cities to countryside, mountains, deserts and there was much greater variety. From hood to flying jets, and lots of offroad cars that didn't all have big rims.
Gta 4's story was so dark and emotional. But Gta SA beats it because it had fun, action, dark and emotions. There was not so much dark and emotion but it still had. Fun and action was more on SA.
6:58 My hats off to you. You managed to get an accident in every situations at the same time 😂👍 Edit: You said in the video that "It would be nice to have multiple cities in GTA 6 (7:54) I think the leaks confirm that there will be more than one city. (That's what I heard, let's hope so 🤞)
You mean Port Gellhorn? It's a small town not a city. It's similar to the Blaine County in GTA V you can't necessarily call it a city because it's basically just the rural outskirts.
@@Shouta1933 bruh just because a game has good graphics doesn't mean it's realistic, take saints row for example, good graphics but besides that nothing obeys the laws of physics and makes no sense meanwhile GTA 4 is so realistic that games that come out today don't even reach its level of detail and realism
GTA IV is more like a quality over quantity type of game. limited features, less options, fewer weapons, smaller map etc but all that what we have in the game are brilliantly done and have excellent quality, so much effort and details into them
@@PolishGod1234definitely not on the level of gta iv. Like he said, most of the things that were done in gta iv were done better with more realism. It sucks how rockstar had to sacrifice so much for this game but it’s still a masterpiece that goes without saying
@@Lancehendrix813 not really. Most things were both cut and dumped down in GTA IV - stuff like customisation, restaurants, weapon and vechicle variety, mission variety were heavily nerfed in GTA IV. San Andreas is a better game. IV might have superior graphics and physics, but San Andreas is more of a complete package. Oh and The radio stations in SA are far superior to those in IV
@@PolishGod1234 bruh u casual gamer gta 4's physics can slap gta sa one hand i dont even count graphics and gameplay details gta 4 was the best gta ever created to this day
@@c4nnyiyim169 I don't care about physics. I care more about content and entertainment. SA offers far more stuff to do than IV and also San Andreas Has more variety (especialy in missions). In majority of ways GTA IV was a downgrade from San Andreas
hmm they 2 were great. Gta san andreas is better than them for its time but normally i think gta 5 and gta 4 upgrade many san andreas weaknesses like graphics, physics and more. But yeah i can agree gta san andreas has better side activites and rpg elements.
@@Gentleman.. in terms of gameplay it is the best GTA (opinion) and map is bigger than san andreas and los santos in gta 5 is as big as all the 3 cities in san andreas. so gta 5 map better too. the only part they could have improved was the story and alot of people say that is why gta 5 sucks. however gta 5 is a good game and my second most fav gta .
Gta san Andreas is a masterpiece, it has all those things which a Gta fan like me wants like great Storyline, great adventure, Awesome graphics, several Missions and side Missions, lots of Vehicles like different bikes and cars, Air Vehicles like Jets, helicopter, Aeroplane, Jetpack etc, option for haircut, Eating animation etc and our lovely protagonist Cj, swimming mechanism is also very good, I have not played Gta 4 or 5 but I don't wont to play also, because i love to play Gta san Andreas game, this my favorite game, because this 18yrs old game has made our childhood Awesome and far better from Gta 4 and Gta 5
@@johnnysinners9857 bro Gta san Andreas has many features which are missing in Gta 4 so i don't want to play Gta 4 or Gta 5, I'm soo happy with Gta san Andreas
Imagine a gta san Andreas remake with same features and storyline but with gta 5 graphics and gta 4 physics or maybe just put the gta san Andreas features in gta 6 and it would be awesome
@@drCox12 no thanks, RD2 is fine but taking its physics would ruin what made SA fun as I don't care personally for Realism (which is also why I much prefer Red Dead 1 over 2)
You'd be correct. I went to play it again on Series X and got bored half way through. Dont know if I'll finish it. Just don't care much and east coast stuff doesn't appeal to me much
GTA 4 is better in graphics and physics or the cellphone feature but GTA San Andreas is far better in gameplay features with the ability to reply on npc comments, car customizations (car parts, more colors, nitro, hydraulics) , player customizations (bodyweight, hair, beard, tattoo, more clothing styles, fighting styles, girlfriends, cheats, more weapons, more activities like marathons or gym, bigger map, more vehicles for land, water, or air, more houses, can enter npc house, racing either from stadium or street, public service missions like paramedic, firefighter, taxi driver, policeman, trucker, a pimp driver, and even a robber lmao) I wouldn't compare the story since both stories are the best
Well technically you can parachute in gta 4. Just not in the original version. Bcs its also 2 addon Packs you could buy and in gta tbogt you can parachute.
San Andreas was just way better, cars were better, car customization had more options, weight mechanics, haircuts, tattoos, bigger map, story, music, etc. only thing gta4 got better was graphics, and physics. Tbogt was better tho
Both Niko and CJ are great, but thing is most of Niko's achievement like war vet stat are off screen and only puropse of it is finding Darko, otherwise he is no saint, he like all GTA protagonist does anything for money oike kidnapping Gracie, killing the hobest charitable Lawyer offering jobs who wanted to expose Francis's corruption and more. We only get to play a part of Niko's ready made life. But with CJ he starts as a gangster who returns home. We help him really se the rank. We train him kn gyms learn different move sets beating gym masters (ls boxing, sf kung fu, lv mma), can give him hair cut, tatyoes , different cloth shops and from a busta he went to show bravery in yhe Green Saber when Sweet tells him to save himself CJ bravely says "I ain't running out on my brother, yo Ballas I am taking you down, I am taking you all down!" And he bravely surrender hinself. From there he rises again having his garage, cadino, air field, mandion CJ grows from a gangster to a rich and powerful businessman who outsmarted a mob biss like Salvatore Leon pulling a brilliant tactical casino heist (gta 3 and LCS shows how powerful Salvatore is) and eventually brings down traitor Big Smoke and the corruot CRASH cops and expands the GSF homies with better weapons taking over Ballas and Vagos territory. By the end of the fame CJ is a rich and powerful business man and the co leader of SA's most powerful gang the GSF. CJ feels like a son you raise, you never get that feeling with any other GTA protagonists. Feature wise SA is unmatched six different cloth stores (ny fav isvthe biker iacket in Victim), diverse mao 3 cities, a desert and countruside, parachuting from mounth chilliad, completing burglary side mission gives you infinity stamina (you xan even tob gang houses and they fight you back, you can soray and choaknthem its fun), stealth mechanics gone in 4, daying GFs give reward like dating cop Barbara in the desert gives the special cool cop outfit and you never lose weaponsvwhen arrested again, seeing inmates fight each other to death visiting jails, driving traibs, jetpacking everywhere, playting pool in the bar, buying properties all over SA and the list goes on and on . For is a great GTA game but all thigs considered GTA SA is the greatest GTA game ever, and consider the fact ut xane out in 2004!
You can find some prop flowers in game and use it as throwable you know what mean gta 4 can pick random items so don't worry about useless weapons such as flower etc if it wasn't rockstar helicopters won't be a thing too the graphics jump is way higher than sa / physics
In GTA San Andreas there is other use of the flowers: you can give it to your girlfriends, with whom you also can have uncensored sex (Hot Coffe mod). In GTA SA you can start a fire, then help the firemen with your extinguisher. There are trucking sidemissions, stadiums, schools, casino games, triathlon, basketball, mountain bike downhill, ... GTA San Andreas has much more features than what this video mentions. GTA 4 was/is a huge disappointment.
@reiovn yeah, you're right there is less in game mechanics in gta 4, but it's not a disappointment, did you read the last part of my comment? I mentioned that graphics and physics are way higher than Gta sa. Gta 4 has the highest graphics in the world than any other game in 2008 it is was a strong game with strong game engine yet R☆ added a lot of functions in it that make gta sa look like a cartoon for example : you can sleep on bed watch TV in realistic way the table inside your home or the windows can be broken or thrown away the rocket launcher is very realistic. You can use the internet. You can drive a large ship called "Tug boat" you can play mini games like bowling 🎳 you have a phone. The fire physics are amazing. It has an online mode and much more ... I love GTA games, and each one has its own place. Gta 4 might not win in a death battle against gta sa, but it was amazing. It was because Gta 4 was reboot of Gta series; it's like this [2d universe]: gta , gta London 1961,gta London 1969.gta 2. [3d universe]: starts with gta 3 R☆ planned to call it gta 3d, but didn't Then Gta Vice City , Gta San Andreas Gta advance, Gta liberty city stories, Gta vice city stories. [HD universe] Gta 4 was a strong game that simulates physics like reflections,water,fire ,destruction, car physics, sun lights, and sun rays , lighting, glass physics, and most importantly character body ragdoll which means characters can be thrown in any direction and position unlike 3d universe gta games which uses animations. Then The dlcs:Gta 4 the lost and damn & Gta 4 the ballad of gay tony these 2 dlcs add a lot of vehicles, weapons and mechanics to gta 4. Gta China town wars and Gta 5 the legendary masterpiece which is now a days called trash because of online dlcs. I'm not sure about Gta 6; it might be a reboot Or it could be in HD universe.
Okay GTA IV fans need to stop comparing graphics over San Andreas gameplay there are literally alot of things to do in San Andreas so stop comparing graphics the fun in San Andreas is one of the best games I've played cuz there way to much things you could literally do
GTA 4 has actually two different states, Alderney and Liberty. With cities such as Alderney City, Liberty City (which is huge) and others in Alderney. Broker, Bohan, Dukes, Algonquin and Alderney also feel different. The nightlife in Algonquin, the poor neighborhoods of Bohan, Somewhat depressing Alderney, middle class Dukes and immigrant filled Broker.
people now a days only care about realism but they do not care about anything else, for example gta vc has no fall damage but it makes it more helpful during missions so you don't die easily
another thing is the only reason why gta sa is slightly better because of haircuts logic,parachutes, and big map, and no hate btw gta sa is a very good game
Whether you like it or not, GTA San Andreas is the greatest video game ever made. It's a fact. And the evidences are everywhere. There's no game that will beat it in all categories. Of course it will lose to graphics, physics or something else. But to beat it as a whole? Nope. There's not a single game that can do that. San Andreas is just the greatest masterpiece of the video game world.
Hardest decision in gaming, I swear I can't pick, gta 4 had the amazing story and amazing characters and their history like niko in the war and its driving and its attention to detail, While gta san andreas also had an amazing story, it wasn't the best after vertical bird, but the end of line makes up for it, the amount of things u can do in gta san andreas is insane, minigames, changing cloths, discovering the map, and the amazing amount of cars u can drive, and j had a lot of fun playing it as a kid just driving around the Map with a 4 star wanted level, nostilga, I dont have gta 4 nostilga cuz I never heard of it as a kid, playing it now, is just amazing, im always bored, gta 4 and gta 3, sa, vice city changes that, my dads laptop is old so he got a new one I have his, it can run gta 4 good with , 800x600 low texture resolution low water resolution no shadows or reflections it runs good and looks good somehow, red dead came to ps4 and ps5, and it's a 2010 game, maybe 2008 game is next, gta 4, if it releases it will look good play good and have amazing reflections and shadows, im buying that, but now I just gotta wait to get red dead 2 and try it.
I think gta 6 will be the best gta in the series and the greatest video game of all time it will be a combination of everything perfect physics,graphics,story,bigger map,more activities i cant wait!!!!!
Quality of quantity for GTA4 Depends what you'd rather, I guess. A more realistic game with better graphics and physics, or a game with lots of stuff to do other than missions. Tags, horseshoes/oysters, stunt jumps, gang wars, driving/flying school, weapon skill, gyms, tattoos, barber, clothes, car customisation, racing, video games, gambling, playing pool, girlfriends, firefighting/police/ambulance side missions. Different types of cars. GTA4 had bowling though. Nothing beats that. 😁
GTA San Andreas Vs GTA IV Story: GTA San Andreas Physics: GTA IV Graphics: GTA IV Characters: *Equal* OG: GTA San Andreas Map Development: GTA San Andreas Character Development: *Equal* Popularity / Sold Copies: GTA San Andreas Winner: (For me GTA San Andreas wins) *What do you think???*
Both games are great, but I liked GTA San Andreas because of the large size of the city and the presence of cities, villages, rural places and forests, and there is a lot of content in the game after completing the story, such as you can be a taxi driver, paramedic, policeman or firefighter. Being a truck driver or a construction worker and being able to get into a gang war and being able to buy houses and go with your gangsters or go to the gym and do a lot of things in the world of San Andreas, unlike GTA 4, you can't do anything Other than just touring. The open world and eating in restaurants, playing bowling, or just hanging out with one of your friends, but GTA 4 offered excellent physics in everything. I don't hate GTA 4, but I prefer GTA San Andreas because of the great content in the world
Lol this seemed dead map to me only size was Big.
👍👍
We can play in the police side and arrest/ kill criminals in GTA 4 as well..
The city?
@@Shap0o.PlayZz And that way the core gameplay never ends with possibility of driving and shooting missions forever;)
San Andreas is really big... a huge map. I wish Liberty City has a bigger scale.
You are right
Liberty City is a city.
San Andreas is a state.
To me it was obvious that (in 2008, even with the newer console gen...) LC won't be as big as SA.
However GTA 4 probably has more (or at least equally as much) interiors and HD Era LC are as big as 3D Era San Andreas' three cities combined.
@@MasonPayneJericho i agree with what u said
San andreas was so big i could feel when we change environment and get into the forest, it was amazing, but I hated when you fall off a cliff and have to swim for 10min just to get to nearest shore
@@titanus261 yeah i agree with u on that.
San Andreas was just legendary.
Bro it I only good in 5 aspects gta 4 is best game
Yes gta san andreas is good.
@@IrfanQureshi-o2u no
If I could add one feature from GTA SA to IV would be the ability to buy more safehouses, it really feels like a chore to have only 3 saving spots in such a large city
TLAD desperately needed more safehouses. Once finishing the game you're left with one very out of the way place to go to just to save the game.
TBOGT needed more as well but at least Luis' one was a bit more central.
Good point, toally agreed 👍
@@SkydrawnIV Johnny had to run around forever to reach the bed🤣
4 you mean
@@maxim196 I guess you're right, I wasn't counting PlayboyX's penthouse
Hands down San Andreas this game truly needs a proper remaster
I'd buy it again. Just release the original version from the ps2.
Sorry, modern R* are done with fun, imagination, pure freedom etc. It's all pretty details, realism and depression now.
in GTA SA has the character of a young person who always wants to try new things while in GTA 4 has the character of an older and more mature person who wants to enjoy life as a normal person in general
Well, gta sa was made at the end of ps2 life cycle and after 2 other 3d games whereas gta iv was made very early into the ps3 era
Okay then...let's go bowling 🎳
@thanu ya bruh it is a fact of average young blood and adults, GTA develop want to apply everyday life in the real life bruh
@thanu And GTA IV's story. Dont forget about it
are you high?
We can argue forever... But GTA IV had one legendary thing that San Andreas didn't have : ROMAN
"Can we finally go bowling cousin? You haven't been returned my calls in like 14 years."
BOWLING
Bruh, san andreas has big smoke, Thing gta 4 doesn't have
But we had......BIG SMOKE
A strange man calls and asks you to go bowling.
Gta san Andreas was more fun but gta 4 had incredible detail and variety. Both games were good and way ahead of its time.
not to mention IV’s incredible euphoria physics
GTA 4 had pretty good physics but i was disappointed that we couldn't even pilot any short of plane
GTA IV didn't have enough time to bring in the variety, because they only had 4 years. They could either make a new physics engine or create environments. GTA VI is doing both so look how long it's taking to release.
@thanu they all used the same physics engine. It was just the question of adding new texture packs. That's why their animations are so similar.
As a result of using the same physics engine, these games started their developments before their respective predecessors were even completed. So it's not like Vice City only had one year or San Andreas had only two years, they had a little more time than that.
On the other hand, the hands of GTA IV's developers were tied until the new physics engine was created. All they could do was wait till it was done, only then they could start working.
excuse me but did you just say gta 4 has VARIETY? LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL no it doesn't and as for detail, in my opinion that doesn't matter at all in games, MOVIES maybe, but not games
Niko can't swim underwater
Tommy cannot swim
Claude cannot talk
Cj cannot follow the damn train 🚂🚃😂😆
Cj cannot climb ladders too
@@Guesty1337 I know also he cannot be polite too 🤣
@@youcefbouziancj 🤣
And Micheal, Franklin, Trevor can't crouch/sit
@@Guesty1337CJ Can Work As Taxi Driver He Can Work As Ambulance Driver 😂😂😂😂😂He Can Work As Fire Man 😂😂😂😂😂He Can Work As Police Officer 😂😂😂😂He Can Work As 😂😂😂😂😂😂Sexy Girls Seller😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂He Can Do 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Drugs Deal😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂But Your G***ay Niko Can't 😂😂😂😂😂These Features are Not In GTA 5 Too LMAO 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Gta sa is released in 2004 and gta IV is released in 2008 yet gta sa still came out on top,imagine if gta sa was made in like, 2013-2020
Oh it would be the greatest game ever...shit was ahead of its time in 2004 with limited hardware
I miss old rockstar games
But I like both games 😌
Its not old its gold
@@ZiIdjian yes
@@raven679-m3i I agree 👍
@Kepler 186-F hi do I know you?
True. Every GTA is a masterpiece except the Defective Trilogy.
GTA 4: The Ballad of Gay Tony has parachutes
yeah
Yeah that's what I'm abt to say
And also tanks
The video is about the Original GTA IV anyways
Yeah
7:07 in San Andreas map there's also a huge part of countrysides, multiple terrains, mountains etc..
I played both games while GTA San Andreas has a lot more features that are missing in GTA 4 , it's undeniable that GTA 4 has better graphics and way better physics.Both games have their ups and downs but I'd personally choose the San Andreas because there are a lot more things to do while in GTA 4 you're mainly stuck in a city that gets boring after a while.
And this is why GTA IV was hated by many when it released.
Yeah but now the nostalgia has kicked in and everyone is bragging about how it’s “the best”
GTA IV Is still a very great game and there are valid arguments for why GTA VI is better than V but I'd say GTA V is better overall. @ZAPGAMERZ
Yea. I sold it after a month. The game felt limited jumping from San Andreas.
Back then the complaints included: boring, sluggish, greyed out, depressing, downgraded, tonnes of content removed, abilities removed, monotonous friend activities, no progression or reason to, worst mission varety in the franchise, no property or even garages, multiplayer where people kept killing you at the airport, less cool cars, less guns, etc etc...
Now in 2024 it's a 10/10 masterpiece, and potentially the greatest game ever made lol.
gta 4 definitely feels like a downgrade compared to sa but still a good game. always bothered me how you couldn't even fly a plane in gta 4 or get some good weapons like a minigun or a flamethrower but i still like gta 4.
CJ even can learn martial arts
Fax
if you watched gta 4 fighting animation you can see Niko already knew how to fight with alot aoff combination
Niko on the other hand already knows it. He's a war veteran.
@@alihanbaruk1590 Its because they used mocap on niko's fighting
@@VanillaV4 No, because hes a war veteran.
Tbh SA is the best out of all GTA games
Gta vice city is better
@@elprimokyle1102 it lacks the map interaction. It's map is kinda small and SA map had more diverse ecosystem with regards to the various cities
@@elprimokyle1102nah. It aged poorly. It Has great radio stations and 80s Vibe but Holy Hell - the controls and gameplay itself aged poorly. Map is very small with nothing to do aside from Story and Vice City's story is nothing special either
Gta 5 : hold my beer
Flavour of gta SA is unforgettable, game like this will never be created again sadly 😪
This is going to make a lot of GTA 4 fanboys mad
Its much better tho u guys play only gta 5
@HeavyGunner278 🤓
@Toxic Madman tf 😂 this yo face reveal: 👶? Hahaha ur probably in elementary school
@Toxic Madman gta 4 is older than you hahaha
@HeavyGunner278 u mad? 🤓🤓🤓🤓
You can parachute in GTA IV for sure if you have TBoGT, parachuting was re-introduced there
You can also use tanks In gta 4 the ballad of gay tony
That's why GTA San Andreas is my favourite game of all time ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Comparing gta 4 and san andreas is like comparing mgs3 to bioshock, seriously though I love both and prefer the two over V
@@Prince.Shoaib-back2YT I don't really agree but whatever works for you man.
I mean I'm not being biased or anything, gta 5 was not only the first one I played but my very first experience with the series and for a while I loved it but after playing IV,san andreas and others it feels like 5 turned into a massive parody of it self especially with the microtransactions. we're honestly fortunate they didn't milk these two as much as they could have. (Not even bringing up "definitive" edition)
@@Prince.Shoaib-back2YT bro mery pas laptop hp processer 2.10 ghz 4 gb ram gta 4 chaly gi window 7 hy
@@MCT461 yes
@@Killer-hy9lyI don’t remember GTA V has micro transactions? Like what bro? GTA Online?
@@AkimM751 exactly, like their shark cash card system.
Tbf Tbogt did add a lot of things that GTA 4 needed like Tanks, Parachutes, more weapons, more mini games, though I agree In terms of features and map SA was better.
03:06 In fairness, the parachute is present in GTA IV The Ballad Of Gay Tony.
he missed the point 🤷🏻♂️
It's about original
You talk about GTA tbogt we talking about GTA 4
It's in TBOGT, but the parachute is not present in gta 4
GTA San Andreas is the GOAT game!
So basically cj can do what ever he wants
Other gta protagonist can't do much shit
Cj is daddy😂😂
Talk about their feats, in the past / before the game storyline Niko did more than CJ as he was a soldier but in the game storyline CJ did way more than Niko as he broke into Area 69, killed a countless in a various areas not only in one city, etc.
@@Zygothknightlord dude CJ has more feats than niko his game has the most cheats out of all gta games
@@impackmusiq5236 bro eso no es canon los trucos niko en un combate haría mierda a cj
his ability to do whatever he wants to do is also somewhat canon in the story
That's why we love GTA San Andreas 😍🥰😎❤️💚
I don't
@@Pablitho_ okay kid I have a dog like you
Because you are kid
@@KING-es5mu kids love Minecraft game just like you and man loves GTA game just like me
@@prashant.6135 I like all gta games 😐
There are parachutes in TBoGT which basically belongs to GTA 4
yeah, he missed the point 🤷🏻♂️
we don't talk about that
Video is about original
TBOGT feels a lot like GTA San Andreas to me, with the outlandish missions and humor
@@cardenasr.2898that’s why they went back for game play in GTAV
Many of these people forget that GTA4 was not as critically acclaimed. Many people were mad at a lot of the features
Kids: tHe GrApHiCs ArE bAd In sA
Lol 😂🤣
Graphics doesn't matter. We only enjoy playing the game, GTA San Andreas loses in Graphics and Physics. But is better in everything
:|
Yeah, the graphics sucks
You cant even enter a taxi as a passenger in san andreas
GTA San Andreas is one of the best games ever made in the gaming history, It took the world of gaming into a whole new level
I agree.
All 3d gtas are awesome, sadly the new ones even if well made have lost that feel, i Hope 6 turns out well
No half life 2 is
@@TeamCraftable2004 Nah
@@TeamCraftable2004 Bro, Gta SA is more well known compared to Half Life 2. Gta SA was the best Grand Theft Auto game by Rockstar on that era. Everyone loved it and played it everytime. It had all the possibilities and features you can think of. You'll never get bored. You can roam around the whole 3 big cities and a desert area in the map. Also Area 69 and steal the jetpack. Ride in the jetpack and what not?
Should I Drop out of Highschool to become the greatest Artist alive❓ 🤷♂️🔥🚀
Yea
Do it
No stay in school mf your gonna need it
It’s a bot
Huh?
They both the two best games
imagine them combined into a single game 💀
That's true, also GTA SA Has mamy good activities, gym, martial art school, driving school, you could buy condoes, manage a gang, fight for terytories
You can't do that in other gta games
@@MatysegibMztarHTFSAeven u can play with ur friends 2 player at the same time 😢on ps2
U could search it
GTA 4 had amazing driving and i thought Niko was a better character as he was through war and hearing his war stories is sad but it shows that Niko doesn't want to be a violent person
I thought you gonna mention the "many object is throwable" in GTA IV
Useless feature
@@omareltayar102 but fun to use sometimes
@@omareltayar102 Using flowers as a weapon is also useless. It doesn’t matter if it’s useless, just have fun.
@@omareltayar102 No, it's good. It's a nice feature. I like it. Also you can push people which you cannot in Gta 5.
@@nullnull8310 CJ's flowers can destroy cars. Even blow up tanks.
6:44 i think Rockstar didn't want players to use airplanes so they cannot recreate the 911 incident. But hey, atleast you can still use a helicopter
It was the size of the map basically
You don't need planes when the map is too small though
That would have made gta iv godly
No, 911 happened before the GTA SA. And the GTA SA has safety features against recreating it.
6:19 I wasn't expecting that mario jump sound effect. Lmao
GTA 4 has better graphics but it's just too polished and the story was kind of bland. GTA SA was huge ranging from cities to countryside, mountains, deserts and there was much greater variety. From hood to flying jets, and lots of offroad cars that didn't all have big rims.
the story was bland? bro you ain't never played gta 4 before 💀
Bland story? Lol what
A bland story would be an overstatement
Gta 4's story was so dark and emotional. But Gta SA beats it because it had fun, action, dark and emotions. There was not so much dark and emotion but it still had. Fun and action was more on SA.
Bro is purposely making people pissed by saying "Bland Story" 💀
Sanadreas is simply better. There are so much things you can do. It's very fun to play.
I didn't know there was tear gas in GTA SA
Bro didn't finish the game 💀
@@nee_gur Fr😭😭😭
Niko casually holding rpg underwater
6:58 My hats off to you. You managed to get an accident in every situations at the same time 😂👍
Edit: You said in the video that "It would be nice to have multiple cities in GTA 6 (7:54)
I think the leaks confirm that there will be more than one city. (That's what I heard, let's hope so 🤞)
You mean Port Gellhorn? It's a small town not a city. It's similar to the Blaine County in GTA V you can't necessarily call it a city because it's basically just the rural outskirts.
My favorite rocket star games are
1 gta 5
2 gta san
3 gta 4
4 gta vice city
Who are agree to me
Gta san andreas is better than gta 5
For me GTA 4 is the best game in the series
I only don’t like GTA 4 the same as GTA 5 because of graphic
@@Shouta1933 who cares about graphics bro if you care about the graphics you are out of your mind
@@therizzler0609 I just like how games are realistic bro
@@Shouta1933 bruh just because a game has good graphics doesn't mean it's realistic, take saints row for example, good graphics but besides that nothing obeys the laws of physics and makes no sense meanwhile GTA 4 is so realistic that games that come out today don't even reach its level of detail and realism
@@therizzler0609 so why play game, drive a car irl.... Games are supposed to be fun, realism doesn't always make it better
I just hope gta 6 can add every single feature from gta sa maybe even more
4:57 Lamar be like : yee-yee a$s haircut you got 😂😂😂😜😜
GTA IV is more like a quality over quantity type of game. limited features, less options, fewer weapons, smaller map etc but all that what we have in the game are brilliantly done and have excellent quality, so much effort and details into them
GTA SA is both quality and Quantity
@@PolishGod1234definitely not on the level of gta iv. Like he said, most of the things that were done in gta iv were done better with more realism. It sucks how rockstar had to sacrifice so much for this game but it’s still a masterpiece that goes without saying
@@Lancehendrix813 not really. Most things were both cut and dumped down in GTA IV - stuff like customisation, restaurants, weapon and vechicle variety, mission variety were heavily nerfed in GTA IV.
San Andreas is a better game. IV might have superior graphics and physics, but San Andreas is more of a complete package. Oh and The radio stations in SA are far superior to those in IV
@@PolishGod1234 bruh u casual gamer gta 4's physics can slap gta sa one hand i dont even count graphics and gameplay details gta 4 was the best gta ever created to this day
@@c4nnyiyim169 I don't care about physics. I care more about content and entertainment. SA offers far more stuff to do than IV and also San Andreas Has more variety (especialy in missions). In majority of ways GTA IV was a downgrade from San Andreas
GTA 4 has the best Subway trains in GTA series.
GTA Fans : please make GTA 4 & 5 great
Rockstar : we missed the part where that's our problem
Gta 4 was great. You just didn't appreciate it being a fanboi
hmm they 2 were great. Gta san andreas is better than them for its time but normally i think gta 5 and gta 4 upgrade many san andreas weaknesses like graphics, physics and more. But yeah i can agree gta san andreas has better side activites and rpg elements.
What's the problem in gta 5?
I can understand about Online
But game is a masterpiece
@@Gentleman.. in terms of gameplay it is the best GTA (opinion) and map is bigger than san andreas and los santos in gta 5 is as big as all the 3 cities in san andreas. so gta 5 map better too. the only part they could have improved was the story and alot of people say that is why gta 5 sucks. however gta 5 is a good game and my second most fav gta .
@@gamingandmapping2281 Story doesn't entirely sks if people complain about killing Micheal or Trevor than they have a option to save them both
GTA 4 does have parachutes but only for Lewis Lopez in TBOGT
Gta san Andreas is a masterpiece, it has all those things which a Gta fan like me wants like great Storyline, great adventure, Awesome graphics, several Missions and side Missions, lots of Vehicles like different bikes and cars, Air Vehicles like Jets, helicopter, Aeroplane, Jetpack etc, option for haircut, Eating animation etc and our lovely protagonist Cj, swimming mechanism is also very good, I have not played Gta 4 or 5 but I don't wont to play also, because i love to play Gta san Andreas game, this my favorite game, because this 18yrs old game has made our childhood Awesome and far better from Gta 4 and Gta 5
idk, maybe the only thing barely better is the story seems kinda biased LOL
but havent played of gta 4, Now I know why you said that
@@johnnysinners9857 bro Gta san Andreas has many features which are missing in Gta 4 so i don't want to play Gta 4 or Gta 5, I'm soo happy with Gta san Andreas
@@rajatkumar-vc2ze Graphics, physics and realism makes it up for those shit
i think all gta games have their pros and cons
gta san andreas has best customization gta 4 has best physics and story and gta 5 has best graphics
greetings from Indonesia from the island of Bali I like your Chanel the problem is that your Chanel is good about GTA games
Imagine a gta san Andreas remake with same features and storyline but with gta 5 graphics and gta 4 physics or maybe just put the gta san Andreas features in gta 6 and it would be awesome
Imagine a San Andreas remake with Alan Wake II graphics and RDR2 physics.
@@drCox12 no thanks, RD2 is fine but taking its physics would ruin what made SA fun as I don't care personally for Realism (which is also why I much prefer Red Dead 1 over 2)
Damn seems like gta 4 has not much to offer other than story
You'd be correct. I went to play it again on Series X and got bored half way through. Dont know if I'll finish it. Just don't care much and east coast stuff doesn't appeal to me much
Wrong, it has the best fighting and physics out of the whole franchise
GTA IV was one of those games that blew me away by how graphically better and more realistic it was compared to its predecessor.
But then many things that were gr8 in san andreas wasn’t there in gta iv!
But 5 and San Andreas are better
San Andreas is better than 4 and 5
@@MatysegibMztarHTFSA no
@@MatysegibMztarHTFSA😂😂😂
GTA 4 is better in graphics and physics or the cellphone feature but GTA San Andreas is far better in gameplay features with the ability to reply on npc comments, car customizations (car parts, more colors, nitro, hydraulics) , player customizations (bodyweight, hair, beard, tattoo, more clothing styles, fighting styles, girlfriends, cheats, more weapons, more activities like marathons or gym, bigger map, more vehicles for land, water, or air, more houses, can enter npc house, racing either from stadium or street, public service missions like paramedic, firefighter, taxi driver, policeman, trucker, a pimp driver, and even a robber lmao) I wouldn't compare the story since both stories are the best
Well technically you can parachute in gta 4. Just not in the original version. Bcs its also 2 addon Packs you could buy and in gta tbogt you can parachute.
"All you had to do was catch the damn train, CJ"
You know the game is great when its about a family returning home
San Andreas was just way better, cars were better, car customization had more options, weight mechanics, haircuts, tattoos, bigger map, story, music, etc. only thing gta4 got better was graphics, and physics. Tbogt was better tho
You like a DLC about a gay man better than the main game and Lost and Damned, wow you people really are gay
San Andreas is the best GTA game.
Both Niko and CJ are great, but thing is most of Niko's achievement like war vet stat are off screen and only puropse of it is finding Darko, otherwise he is no saint, he like all GTA protagonist does anything for money oike kidnapping Gracie, killing the hobest charitable Lawyer offering jobs who wanted to expose Francis's corruption and more. We only get to play a part of Niko's ready made life. But with CJ he starts as a gangster who returns home. We help him really se the rank. We train him kn gyms learn different move sets beating gym masters (ls boxing, sf kung fu, lv mma), can give him hair cut, tatyoes , different cloth shops and from a busta he went to show bravery in yhe Green Saber when Sweet tells him to save himself CJ bravely says "I ain't running out on my brother, yo Ballas I am taking you down, I am taking you all down!" And he bravely surrender hinself. From there he rises again having his garage, cadino, air field, mandion CJ grows from a gangster to a rich and powerful businessman who outsmarted a mob biss like Salvatore Leon pulling a brilliant tactical casino heist (gta 3 and LCS shows how powerful Salvatore is) and eventually brings down traitor Big Smoke and the corruot CRASH cops and expands the GSF homies with better weapons taking over Ballas and Vagos territory. By the end of the fame CJ is a rich and powerful business man and the co leader of SA's most powerful gang the GSF. CJ feels like a son you raise, you never get that feeling with any other GTA protagonists.
Feature wise SA is unmatched six different cloth stores (ny fav isvthe biker iacket in Victim), diverse mao 3 cities, a desert and countruside, parachuting from mounth chilliad, completing burglary side mission gives you infinity stamina (you xan even tob gang houses and they fight you back, you can soray and choaknthem its fun), stealth mechanics gone in 4, daying GFs give reward like dating cop Barbara in the desert gives the special cool cop outfit and you never lose weaponsvwhen arrested again, seeing inmates fight each other to death visiting jails, driving traibs, jetpacking everywhere, playting pool in the bar, buying properties all over SA and the list goes on and on .
For is a great GTA game but all thigs considered GTA SA is the greatest GTA game ever, and consider the fact ut xane out in 2004!
honestly both are masterpieces buy my personal favorite is SA
GTA : SAN ANDREAS
cars could be cleaned
when driven into water
The carwash was in san andreas but got removed due to some ps2 limitations
gta 4 still better
@@johnnysinners9857 nah, gta 3 is better
@@mr.buttler1649 Gta 4 > gta 3 and gta sa
@@johnnysinners9857 Better in what
San Andreas was/is the G.O.A.T
I played GTA San Andreas for 7 years, did it 100% 3 times, I started to play GTA IV this year.
I prefer GTA IV
Just 3 times? Well, if you had explored every inch of SA map, you wouldn't say that you prefer GTA 4...
So you downgraded and you prefer GTAIV? blasphemy, absolute blasphemy.
I always liked San Andreas more than IV, sure Gta iv has a good story and physics but free roam is just boring
You can find some prop flowers in game and use it as throwable you know what mean gta 4 can pick random items so don't worry about useless weapons such as flower etc if it wasn't rockstar helicopters won't be a thing too the graphics jump is way higher than sa / physics
In GTA San Andreas there is other use of the flowers: you can give it to your girlfriends, with whom you also can have uncensored sex (Hot Coffe mod). In GTA SA you can start a fire, then help the firemen with your extinguisher. There are trucking sidemissions, stadiums, schools, casino games, triathlon, basketball, mountain bike downhill, ... GTA San Andreas has much more features than what this video mentions. GTA 4 was/is a huge disappointment.
@reiovn yeah, you're right there is less in game mechanics in gta 4, but it's not a
disappointment, did you read the last part of my comment? I mentioned that graphics and physics are way higher than Gta sa. Gta 4 has the highest graphics in the world than any other game in 2008 it is was a strong game with strong game engine yet R☆ added a lot of functions in it that make gta sa look like a cartoon for example : you can sleep on bed watch TV in realistic way the table inside your home or the windows can be broken or thrown away the rocket launcher is very realistic. You can use the internet. You can drive a large ship called "Tug boat" you can play mini games like bowling 🎳 you have a phone. The fire physics are amazing. It has an online mode and much more ...
I love GTA games, and each one has its own place. Gta 4 might not win in a death battle against gta sa, but it was amazing. It was because Gta 4 was reboot of Gta series; it's like this
[2d universe]: gta , gta London 1961,gta London 1969.gta 2.
[3d universe]: starts with gta 3 R☆ planned to call it gta 3d, but didn't
Then Gta Vice City , Gta San Andreas
Gta advance, Gta liberty city stories,
Gta vice city stories.
[HD universe] Gta 4 was a strong game that simulates physics like reflections,water,fire ,destruction, car physics, sun lights, and sun rays , lighting, glass physics, and most importantly character body ragdoll which means characters can be thrown in any direction and position unlike 3d universe gta games which uses animations. Then
The dlcs:Gta 4 the lost and damn & Gta 4 the ballad of gay tony these 2 dlcs add a lot of vehicles, weapons and mechanics to gta 4. Gta China town wars and Gta 5 the legendary masterpiece which is now a days called trash because of online dlcs. I'm not sure about Gta 6; it might be a reboot
Or it could be in HD universe.
Okay GTA IV fans need to stop comparing graphics over San Andreas gameplay there are literally alot of things to do in San Andreas so stop comparing graphics the fun in San Andreas is one of the best games I've played cuz there way to much things you could literally do
I played both and I love them and I can't say which one is better but graphics and physics were way more better in GTA IV
No shit ps3 vs ps2
@@THEK1NGSCLAN😂
GTA 4's episodes do actually have parachutes, atleast TLAD has them
EDIT: TLAD doesn't have parachutes, but TBoGT does
GTA 4 features can be used to upgrade the GTA SAN ANDREAS experience
Gta san andrease better 😂😂😂 100% dont argue gta iv players. Only bad thing gta san andrease has graphics
GTA 4 has actually two different states, Alderney and Liberty. With cities such as Alderney City, Liberty City (which is huge) and others in Alderney. Broker, Bohan, Dukes, Algonquin and Alderney also feel different. The nightlife in Algonquin, the poor neighborhoods of Bohan, Somewhat depressing Alderney, middle class Dukes and immigrant filled Broker.
Gta sa is better and goat game 😈💯👍👍👍
FACTS
Yo
@@SPECTRASTORM hello
Hi guys hows the life going
Hope you get one brother
I wish Gta sa had
“Cousin, let’s go bowling”
It has more activities than the boring bowling only in gta 4
people now a days only care about realism but they do not care about anything else, for example gta vc has no fall damage but it makes it more helpful during missions so you don't die easily
another thing is the only reason why gta sa is slightly better because of haircuts logic,parachutes, and big map, and no hate btw gta sa is a very good game
To be honest. San Andreas has the best storyline of all Rockstar game!
Red dead redeptiom 2 has the Best storyline of all rockstar games
Lmaoo it litterally have the worst storyline in all Rockstars Game what u smokin
@@hayman75 such a pity I feel for you
@@hayman75 🤡
Every Gta game is unique we cant argue even Gta 3 is unique
Gta 3 started this shit you can't mention them without bringing up 3...3 laid the groundwork
Whether you like it or not, GTA San Andreas is the greatest video game ever made. It's a fact. And the evidences are everywhere. There's no game that will beat it in all categories. Of course it will lose to graphics, physics or something else. But to beat it as a whole? Nope. There's not a single game that can do that. San Andreas is just the greatest masterpiece of the video game world.
Gta vice city is better!
@@ForbiddenAqui32729 gta 3.5 lol not vc 😂 vice city had nothing
@@bigsmoke5814 small smoke
@@bigsmoke5814 big smell
Rdr2 has entered the chat
Both of them got the same score on a test but got different questions correct.
These comparison videos just make hate between these gta fanbase, so please y'all should stop declaring war in the comments
@Floating boat hi
You are Right
@@FloatSamples710 ahh yes you can swim underwater in gta sa, wayy better than gta 4
Yea main thing is both games are made by Rockstar so enjoy
lmao that's not a flower at 8:43, it's called bouquet 🤣
Hardest decision in gaming, I swear I can't pick, gta 4 had the amazing story and amazing characters and their history like niko in the war and its driving and its attention to detail,
While gta san andreas also had an amazing story, it wasn't the best after vertical bird, but the end of line makes up for it, the amount of things u can do in gta san andreas is insane, minigames, changing cloths, discovering the map, and the amazing amount of cars u can drive, and j had a lot of fun playing it as a kid just driving around the Map with a 4 star wanted level, nostilga, I dont have gta 4 nostilga cuz I never heard of it as a kid, playing it now, is just amazing, im always bored, gta 4 and gta 3, sa, vice city changes that, my dads laptop is old so he got a new one I have his, it can run gta 4 good with , 800x600 low texture resolution low water resolution no shadows or reflections it runs good and looks good somehow, red dead came to ps4 and ps5, and it's a 2010 game, maybe 2008 game is next, gta 4, if it releases it will look good play good and have amazing reflections and shadows, im buying that, but now I just gotta wait to get red dead 2 and try it.
I think gta 6 will be the best gta in the series and the greatest video game of all time it will be a combination of everything perfect physics,graphics,story,bigger map,more activities i cant wait!!!!!
3:50 ahhhh Niko's fall so satisfying 😂
Every gta is better at something than other gtas. I have huge hopes for gta6.
All the differences have to do with missions, the things in GTA SA that u can do that u can't in GTA IV are specifically for certain missions
Nikai: "Hay CJ can borrow some things Don't worry you don't have to chase a train to find them"?
Old is gold 😎
Both games are perfect
Gta san andreas is better.
Quality of quantity for GTA4
Depends what you'd rather, I guess. A more realistic game with better graphics and physics, or a game with lots of stuff to do other than missions.
Tags, horseshoes/oysters, stunt jumps, gang wars, driving/flying school, weapon skill, gyms, tattoos, barber, clothes, car customisation, racing, video games, gambling, playing pool, girlfriends, firefighting/police/ambulance side missions. Different types of cars.
GTA4 had bowling though. Nothing beats that. 😁
GTA San Andreas Vs GTA IV
Story: GTA San Andreas
Physics: GTA IV
Graphics: GTA IV
Characters: *Equal*
OG: GTA San Andreas
Map Development: GTA San Andreas
Character Development: *Equal*
Popularity / Sold Copies: GTA San Andreas
Winner: (For me GTA San Andreas wins) *What do you think???*
story is for gta iv
@𝕋𝕖𝕩𝕥 𝕄𝕖 𝕆𝕟 𝕋𝕖𝕝𝕖𝕘𝕣𝕒𝕞 @Betaz_official oh hi I didn’t expect for me to get picked 😅
@@grassblockproduction6032 i respect your opinion but for me its mostly GTA San Andreas and most people agree on it but for me GTA 4 is a Close second
@@grassblockproduction6032 Gta san andreas story has more impact on people rather than Gta 4 when big smoke turned on Cj
@@Gentleman.. facts
gta4 is my favorite, but the arguments for why sa is better are valid.
My 1st truly open world game GTA San Andreas 😍
The only thing good in gta 4 is Realism, physics and story
You are goddamn right!!!
Only? man thats enough to be the best gta game Lol
@@johnnysinners9857 gta 6 she need realism physics map weapons first person third person graphics and more and this is the Best gta game 😎👍🏻
Gta sa is peak gta and gta4 is overrated mess, you can't buy house, can't own permanent cars and very less customization in general
Bro tryna do 911 with helicopter 🚁