Truth: Permanent Magnet Motor Using Magnetic Repulsion. Inventor's idea and what does really happen?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.พ. 2023
- Understand in an easy way why such a magnetic motor does not generate free energy and is no perpetual motion generator, so that you can easily explain it to others - using my gravity model method.
Roller that spin forever with free energy are still a very convincing power generator.
The magnets are arranged to drive the reel, making sustained spinning easy.
Just watch this video and you will understand for sure, why this great machine is not able to work.
Let's first look at the device itself. It consists of a rotatably mounted plastic cylinder in which magnets are set at regular intervals. f you look closely, the rows of magnets that are attached to the roller overlap. This is intended to allow or facilitate the transition from one magnetic loop to the next.
On the side of the reel is a stand with a very large magnet attached to it.
What happens when the very large magnet attached to the side is pushed closer to the roller?
Have a look.
--
#ywild - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D3 | Summer | ไม่อยากเหนื่อยวันเสาร์ ก็ต้องจัดเต็ม](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CbsHmoJXjvE/mqdefault.jpg)
Had a customer come into my store the other day explaining how he's solved perpetual motion to power his house, he just needs stronger magnets 😅 this video really cleared up exactly how it wouldn't work, thank you!
First: thank you and congratulations on the video, this is absolutely fantastic - the analogy of a gravity well for a magnetic field is really intuitive, at least for me.
But one thing: you forgot the magnets on the sides of the roller.
- they're only there for one period of the process
- perhaps their presence in conjunction with the large permanent magnet would be enough to provide this extra kick to get over that hump?
Hi Matt, glad you like it. Possibly you mean the copper coloured weights. These are just non magnetic weights because of the overlap on the other side. They put the Roller in balance. Thx for watching 🙂
Simple solution to that is an "hopper" on the wheel, wich pushes back the magnet from the rail, meanwhile inertia of the wheels movement turns the wheel (with no big magnet in the interacting distance from the rail) further and than the big magnet get returned (possibility to use a spring, or another self-return mechanism), and proceeds from the starting part of the rail, till it reaches almost the end and will get pushed back again. That will make the magnet "jump" over the area, where end and start of the rail reaches each other, and where (as in only part of the rail) is the movement stopped.
Hi Ultra, thx for your comment. I made a video about a principle of an motor you might mean. Magnetic perpetual motion motor, which is continuously powered by a tilting magnet mechanism.
th-cam.com/video/Gj6krP-1P3M/w-d-xo.html
This principle does not work either. The videos made about may be very convincing but the energy to remove or bring back the magnet out of or into the field of the others is much more than nothing. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild Ment something like this
th-cam.com/video/ux4qfizL0xg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=DlE6JhQNaLtyh05q
If you want free energy, its real easy, run an extension cord over to your neighbours out side outlet.
Hi Universe, great idea since they have no clue 😄. Thanks for watching.
Great simulation. Appreciate your good work👍
Hi David ,thank you. Glad you like it 🙂
I think that if you include a fly wheel in the rotor axe you will overcome the repulsion forces that are stopping the system, and the extra kinect energy may maintain and feed the rotation.
Hi YYY, thx for your comment. A fly wheel is a good method to store some energy for a while and hide the friction. But the fly wheel has to be powered by the system and there is not enough power in the system for starting its rotation. 🙂 thx for watching
Sehr gut beschrieben und auch für Laien verständlich. 👍
Hallo Sven, danke dir für das Lob. Ich tue mein Bestes. Thx for watching 🙂
A truly excellent visualization and explanation. Most impressed. FYI, another way to arrive at the same proof is to mathematically compute the magnetic force vectors at each position through the rotation, then take the differentials (ie. force gradients). They sum to _exactly zero_ which proves beyond doubt that this system will encounter a huge barrier force at the next rotational cycle around the diverging loop of magnets, and therefore will NOT continue to accelerate to produce free energy.... unfortunately !
Hi Rohan, thx for your comment. Yes, there is no perpetual imbalance possible in our world. Thx for watching 🙂
there is it
@@yWild wrong the elites posted this video to try to trick you because an east german guy figured this out with a similare model but this video has the stator part wrong but the rotar part correct actually besides the 4 magnets on the very outside . interesting how the elites put this out there. Notice that this video was not demonstrated by a human. wake up people. do you trust a video from a robot???????? ask me for the link of the east german guy and ill send it. they shut down his youtube video but he made another website with the same video they censored. this is undeniable proof for me that his device works besides the fact that i saw the video in real life work. I screen recorded it the minute i saw it. ur lucky i randomly sent this reply fyi
Very good video I'm very happy that your channel is becoming more and more popular meanwhile already 2.35 k subscribers and another little tip you can link your second channel in your description of the channel. Also, please always provide us with new videos 👍
Hi Arkonius, glad you like it. Thx for the hint. I hope there would be all people like you 👍🏻🙂 thx for watching
Well stated, robot.
This was great. I would like to see you discuss various designs of permanent magnet motors the same way. Are there any that get better results? Perhaps closer to '"self running" than this one? To be fair the design of this motor is not very good but as a first iteration or initial prototype, the lessons learned could be applied to the design of something better.
Hi Paul, thanks for your comment. Just watch some more videos on my channel. Thx for watching 🙂
Your explanation was wonderful and easy to understand. If free energy is discovered I believe it will not be through the mechanical process, I believe it will be through frequency. You say this universe is set to come back to balance, but in the micro universe vibration is as eternal as the universe itself, vibration is motion, motion can produce flux at resonate coupling, so it is possible in my opinion. Even if we could some how tap into the collective heartbeat of millions, or billions we would have endless energy from the human perspective.
Thank you for the video, Though I had a thought.
Suppose you added a variable fly wheel? Springs to keep it tucked in, and as centrifugal force increase, weights shift outward. This should help the wheel pass the moment of magnetic resistance
Hi RedDragon, glad you like it. I just try to tell people that these devices are not able to work and explain a new way of thinking 🙂. Thx for watching.
@@yWildrather than complete free energy is the idea off these creations not too improve how we use electric and get more out off it...movement is energy and magnets can create movement so can they not be used for improvement in designs we may not have thought off yet...if you added metal powers or fragments too water could you not use magnets too make the water move due too the metal powders in the water n make a type off hydro energy or such ideas like this...thanks
' as centrifugal force increase, weights shift outward.'
When that happens, the 'weights shifting outward' slows the rotation and stops the centrifugal force from increasing and 'shifting them outward'.
You're essentially trying to pull yourself up by your own bootstraps. It doesn't make a gain, you simply stop yourself before you start. You're dependent on 'something keeping increasing to make something happen' while 'what's happening is slowing it down just as hard as it was increasing'. You can't make something change that stops the change from happening.
hi, thank you so much - it helps a lot in learning - for simulation of magnets what is the software you used? .. simulation looks awesome.
Hi Ans, glad you like it. I use blender for the animations. Thx for watching 🙂
Create a downhill trac with your 3d model then convert it to magnets and you fixed the problem. Try droping it on to this setup, spin up the wheel and its like skipping a stone on water, gaining momentum with each bounce
Hi Soul, thx for your comment. Do you think that it will also work in the gravitational model? If so, then you made it. 👍🏻🙂 thx for watching
Basically spreading out the magnets infinitly? Not possible on a cylinder with a non infinite circomference.
Yeah , but , can you put wire windings on the other side where the very large magnets on the outside are to actually generate usable electricity ?
Hi User, thanks for your comment. Yes, if the device would be able to work, it would always be able to get energy out of it. Thanks for watching.🙂
Schönes Video, sehr schön erklärt.
Danke für das Lob! Thx for watching 🙂
The universal law of energy conservation to which there exists no counter example makes the deception of free energy so absurd, but only the law of repetition can prevent people from falling into that free energy trap. Great demonstration!
Hi, thanks for your comment. Glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
Why can't the be a clock work mechanism that pulls the large magnet away at overlap and then pushing it closer after the overlap, skipping the strong part resetting the falling process from a higher point. Or use an electromagnet, and a physical push to start the process so as to only give energy to the electromagnet at intervals skipping the overlap, would this not create a free fall forever?
I'm glad you have a clear picture of what you are talking about😉😉😜😜😊😊😊😊
На основе Магнитной ёлочки.
Интересно, кто его изобрёл ?
Thx for your comment. Yes, that’s a great Christmas tree 😄. Thx for watching
@@yWild ...Здравствуйте. Я вам предложу изготовить очень простой Магнитный двигатель по моему проекту. Коротко изложу;
- Два неподвижных магнита статора в форме пластин, расположены параллельно, между ними есть расстояние, через которое проходит подвижный, цилиндрический магнит ротора. Сперва когда магнит ротора приближать к магнитам статора, пластины его притягивают, но когда они начинают отталкиваться, то магнит ротора должен остановится или уйти назад. Но этого не происходит, потому что пластины временно отклоняются в бок и возвращаются обратно ударяясь об пружины пропустив магнит ротора. как маятник . Так происходит со всеми магнитами по кругу ротора и ротор вращается с ускорением. Дополнительных сил для отклонения пластин не надо, всё происходит автоматически, благодаря силы гравитации и пружин.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
...Hello. I will propose to you to make a very simple Magnetic Motor according to my project. I will briefly state;
- Two fixed stator magnets in the form of plates, located in parallel, between them there is a distance through which the movable, cylindrical magnet of the rotor passes. At first, when the rotor magnet is brought closer to the stator magnets, the plates attract it, but when they start to repel, the rotor magnet must stop or go back. But this does not happen, because the plates temporarily deviate to the side and return back hitting the springs, missing the rotor magnet. like a pendulum. This happens with all the magnets around the rotor and the rotor rotates with acceleration. Additional forces are not needed to deflect the plates, everything happens automatically, thanks to the force of gravity and springs. (28.02.2023).
Hi, thanks for your proposal. How about making an short video of your actual state of the project, put it on TH-cam and post a link right here. It would prevent misunderstanding 🫣. But first, use my method of thinking about your device in order to the gravity model. Would it also work then? Thx for your comments 👍🏻🙂
Тиртха !
Exellent experiment. Congrats ♥️👏👏👏
Hi Muthuiah, thanks, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
Sir very very fine information of megnetik free enrgy 👍👍🇮🇳from:India
Hi Kanijb, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
I saw a video of this machine, but the difference was the main push magnet was lifted up by a cam. I thought was an interesting idea. Was probably run by a motor. Maybe an idea for you.
Thank you for your great videos.
Hi Doc, thanks for your comment. Yes there are some variations of these machines out there. I took the design from an very professional guy with high skills in building different devices 🙂. Thx for watching
A very nice video with laborious and excellent simulations! There is another simple argument, that these constructions don't work. If there is only one single magnet on the rotor, it will not run, since torques due to magnetic repulsion (or attraction) will be the same clockwise and anti-clockwise. And the effects of several magnets simply add up. Thus, if you have n magnets on the rotor and none of them delivers a resulting torque in one direction, n times zero gives zero.
It is more difficult with constructions which suggest, that the master magnet should be withdrawn temporarily to achieve a continuous spin. If this is done by external means you can achieve a continuous spin, but this movement needs an input of energy. And attempts to get this energy from the rotation fail, since the rotational energy is not bigger than the energy needed for moving the master magnet. For those competent in physics of course conservation of energy is the simplest explanation which refutes all possible designs of magnet motors. Unfortunately those who are free energy addicts don't trust laws of physics ...
Hi Heinzpg, glad you like it. Thx for your detailed comment. Thx for watching 🙂
Not agreeing or disagreeing that it can be done with some more formulaic design, but the fact that this energy, while not totally "free", would significantly reduce the cost of fuel which big brother does not want. Hence why the shut down Tesla. It's not even big enough of a push for the whole "conservationist convention party"to jump on board with lol. Probably could use 1/10 the fuel consumption in combination with this type design
u trust the conclusions of an fake video instead of real life demonstrations. no wonder our surface world is so primitive still. so frustrating all these sheeple. I really hope ur response is not a real human. so dissapointing
@@raymondsilva5440 Since this design can not deliver any energy at all, it would also not reduce fuel consumption. The majority of countries has to buy fuel from other countries. They would be quite happy to find an alternative to oil products. But magnet motors are no alternative. And by the way: Tesla was not shut down. Teslas project which was no longer financed by P. Morgan was not about free energy, it was about the transfer of electrical energy through the air without wires. The energy itself would have been a conventional one, produced from oil, coal and water. Not free at all.
Brilliant explanation and a brilliant animation. You guys make TH-cam great. Thank you for all your time and effort.
Hi Bill, glad you like it. Thank you for watching 😃
What about 4 of these side by side inline.... so that, while one point needs to go up hill, the other 3 are pushing it down hill.
Hi Ryan, thanks for your comment. Make a video about and let’s see. Possibly you found the one piece 😄. Thx for watching 🙂
A mechanism must pull the repulser magnet away from the barrel where the fields overlap, then it will work. It is also possible to conceive of a counter weight that overcomes the barrier.
Hi Lynn, thx for your comment. Thanks for watching 🙂
You can use magnets of different diameters and capacities to overcome the barrier.
Hi, thx for your comment. Yes, this is a good idea, but think about the perpetual imbalance. The ball has to roll down the slope forever. Only a different configuration of magnets is not able to establish this. What do you think? Thx for watching 🙂
I think it works with another type of magnet, electric, graduated in strength, and the point of the peak of attraction must remain like an arrow. Once it reaches the top, the electricity is cut off from the previous magnet and increases in the next magnet, with the presence of a discharge and suction of the magnetic field with laser beams, thus it continues to increase to infinity.
Thanks, I liked your video. However in the last few words while you were saying that it wasn't possible, I envisioned how it can be possible.
Not to contradict you, because I see that you have a great point to be said, however as an artist and inventor, I saw another dimension involved which could actually facilitate a continuous movement even though you prove that you can't.
But this doesent say your wrong, it just says I believe I know how to over come the issues you pointed out,
Once again, thank you, peace be on your house.
Hi C.Kilby, glad you like it. Thx for your comment. I don’t say, that it is impossible and I appreciate your comment. 😀 All I tell is that it is not possible this way because there is no infinite imbalance in our universe soo far I can see. There may be other ways to build an so called perpetual motor which take their power from hidden places. Thx for watching 🙂
Posso colocar um link de um gerador usando esse princípio que está sendo comercializado para sua avaliação.
Hi Rodolfo, your welcome. Post the link if you like 🙂. Thx for your comments.
What if you used the weight of the ball and gravity to make up for the overlap? Or maybe a spring that kicks the ball forward using the gravity of the ball dropping and compressing the spring causing it to lift enough to compensate for the strong energy?
Hi J, thx for your comment. Interesting thought. 🙂 I tried to make a Loop ramp work some years with the help of gravity, link ahead, but the power consumed to get back to the starting point was higher as the outcome. 😬
th-cam.com/video/iNODsSAjJ8Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=VP14UeLoHVxc6V8x
So the ball just sticks a the position of highest attraction.
This one was one of my first videos to this topic 🫣
th-cam.com/video/nRJUePA1eb8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=CzQGoRp7EbGI7aRi
Thx for watching 🙂
Informative, thank you.
Hi Ronald, glad you like it, thx for watching 🙂
🙏🏼🇧🇷👍
Recém inscrito.
Muito obrigado pela oportunidade de aprender com seus vídeos pragmáticos.
Obs: Joule thief circuito mostrando eletromagnetismo e elétrons em 3D. 🥺
Glad you like it, Rodolfo. Thx for watching 🙂
Absolutely RIGHT !
Finally someone made sense of it all, there is no such free energy 😊
Hi Monaim, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
you're wrong, this is the best design, all that he forgot is a magnet pusher, it pushes the magnet away when the hump comes, then returns the magnet after the bump.
@@TerryDavisMediaexactly. Just like a cam lobe.
This random video that was suggested by yt gave me an idea. Couldn't you just create a magnetic field, shaped like a neutral 3d corridor for the big magnet rod there where the 2 V shaped magnets come together. Because you could create any 3d shaped magnetic field with a lot of little magnets, right? With each small magnet producing its own magnetic field, which falls off with distance and by combining many magnets, you can sculpt complex overall field shapes. You would probably need computer optimization algorithms who determines specific magnet arrangements and strengths to best approximate a desired target field. As the solution in this video by overlapping magnets in v shapes looks too simplistic to get that effect. Or am I thinking too simplistic?
Hi Kazakz, thanks for your comment. I don’t know if this will work, but keep in mind, that magnetic field lines always bound to their own magnet and not to the cluster. So there will be many field lines off attracting and repelling magnetic fields. It will not be so homogeneous as you may think. But I think it is worth a try. 🙂 let me know your progress if you like. Thanks for watching.🙂
Excellent understand-ology 👍 . I wonder how mercury might act. With or without electricity??
Hi Tina, glad you like it. In my opinion, Mercury wouldn’t have any influence or being influenced. This assembly is not suitable for it. Thx for watching 🙂
My bad, you missed a part where you can prove it fails. When the roller moves the magnets in the roller gains momentum while after completion of a revolution the momentum of the magnets over come the magnetic pole's repelling strength when the magnets which are closer ( ie the magnets at the starting point) . Also the original design is not the way you show. While the wheel spin one full revolution, the non rotating magnet is moved a little far from the revolution having the magnets for an instant, then back on its original position to maintain the constant push.
Hi Sesha, thanks for your comment. I’m sorry if I missed to tell some details. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild it's alright bro. Take care
I have seen many variations of the callaway v gate. In fact I have one of my very own in mind to some day build. All of these have 1 flaw. That is that they will de gauss itself eventually. Even the very best of designs will de gauss itself within a few short months. There is no way around this! Further there is no free energy. It takes energy to make these modern magnets, lots of it in fact! It was however nice you noting the magnetics/gravity and how similar they are in action.
Hi William, thanks for your comment. You are blessed if you have seen a working device like this. I don’t think that there is any constellation of magnets which allows to take the moving magnet over the sticky point. The power to do that is far more than the energy is received by the magnet ramp. 🙂 thanks for watching.
HEY do u think you could use ferrofluid in a motor or as a motor?
Hi Newb, thanks for your question. I just don’t have a clue how to use ferrofluid to make a Moto working better. Fluid is when it comes to friction not the best idea to use. Thanks for watching.🙂
perfekt Illustratet and taech - but when you are looped - and you make the static Magnet to repulse - like a E- Motor with a loop platine to give hime the right impulse - how is the Impule Energie lower or higher then the Output - plaese test it.
Hi Peter, thanks for your comment. I fear that such an impulse is exactly the amount of power that is not available to overcome the overlap. But an great idea, nevertheless. Thx for watching 🙂
How about More Mass and Circumference of the Wheel to overcome the initial resistance and thereby using Centrifugal Force as well.
In addition, the wider the circumference the longer the throw of magnets to offset the initial resistance in the run. 🤔
Hi DG, thx for your comment. More mass will slow down the process because of the higher inertia. The principle still stays the same. It would not work either. Thx for watching 🙂
The threshold of repulsion can be easily overcome if, at the moment of completion of the revolution, the main magnet is mechanically moved away, and when the threshold is overcome, it is returned back. In this case, the force spent on the shift will be almost equal to 0
Hi, thanks for your comment. Yes it’s possible to overcome the point of highest magnetic repulsion by moving the magnet away, but it needs power to bring it back. In addition it is more power to invest than your get back. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild I wrote that it would take practically no energy to move the magnet
@@yWild according to the principle of operation of the valve of the internal combustion engine
I think it works with another type of magnet, electric, graduated in strength, and the point of the peak of attraction must remain like an arrow. Once it reaches the top, the electricity is cut off from the previous magnet and increases in the next magnet, with the presence of a discharge and suction of the magnetic field with laser beams, thus it continues to increase to infinity.
the space boot of the 1960's allowed a astronaut to simply lift his heel up and it would mechanically nullify the magnetic s, then when coming back down on the heel would reapply the force without anything but mechanics. the implications are mind boggling.
Hi, thanks for your comment. Thx for watching 🙂
Posso colocar um link de um vídeo Russo que mostra movimento contínuo pra sua avaliação.
Hi Rodolfo, thx for your comment. Yes for sure, you can post the link. I would be glad to have an eye on it. I don’t say, that it is impossible to build something great, I’m just telling that the machines on TH-cam mostly not able to work. Thx for watching 🙂
Boa noite, gostaria de ver tbm
Would it be possible to pulse energy to make it go over the "hill" and continue it's roll again?
Hi Freu, thx for your comment. Good idea. Yes it’s possible to do so. The amount of energy to do so is equal to the friction and other energy loss. The goal to build an energy producing machine would be missed but it would be nice to watch it run. 🙂 thx for watching
if you put a small motor to make a movement of the big magnet back and front , and after the ignition power the small motor from the movement of the weel it will be infinite?
Hi Howto, thanks for your question. Great idea to overcome the magnetic maximum but the efforts to move the magnet in and out into the lower magnetic influence every time will be high enough to come to a standstill, nevertheless. Thx for watching 🙂
Need to create a timing curve. Advance the stationary magnet a couple degrees it turns.
Hi Warren, thx for your comment. It’s an principle which is not able to work, that’s the problem. I try to describe the flaws. Thx for watching 🙂
And why then would not a pulsed electro magnet be usefull here to remove the dip when it begins to affect the rooller and come back on once its past the point of the dip and add to that the rooller be a heavy flywheel that would add to the forward motion of the rooller. I think that if multiple methods are used in conjunction this would work to produce electricity and overunity could be possible
Hi Ron, thx for your comment. Yes, it’s a good thought, using an additional electric magnet.
Watch this: th-cam.com/video/jYsRonUeRTM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=-tOu7fkSO6HxyXek
But it would not work anyway, because the energy harvested might be too small for the electric magnet. Thx for watching. 🙂
there are a lot of videos out there that is spreading false information, thank you for explaining and demonstrating the facts about magnets and how they work
Hi User, glad you like it 👍🏻🙂 thx for watching
that is logical and ingenious at the same time.
Hi Petty, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
That is an outstanding analysis of the magnetic fields! I would love to see where the hidden power source was in the original model.
Hi Dave, glad you like it. Yes, some of the videos are so well made, that it’s extremely difficult to tell how they made it work. Thx for watching 🙂
I think it works with another type of magnet, electric, graduated in strength, and the point of the peak of attraction must remain like an arrow. Once it reaches the top, the electricity is cut off from the previous magnet and increases in the next magnet, with the presence of a discharge and suction of the magnetic field with laser beams, thus it continues to increase to infinity.
Hi C., thanks for your comment. Yes, with the help of eclectic power we get it to do the job. Thx for watching 🙂
congratulations you just invented the electric motor, I would patent that quick
Brilliant video some of the communication on this topic I have seen!!
What happens if you introduce a Golden Mean (or at least a contracting) loop the loop at the bottom of the run just before the rise :)
The contracting/non symetrical angle of the loop the loop introduces centripedal accelleration for free.
Hi, glad you like it. I’m sorry, because of the reason, that the motor is just an mind game and an simulation, there might be any action to tune the performance not very useful. Thx for watching 🙂
The title should be "Free Energy Generator Debunked" (or exposed).
Otherwise it smells of "clickbait". The word "revealed" suggests it works and you are explaining how the miraculous device found a way around fundamental physics & thermodynamics. Many people are mislead by suggestive headlines and jump to unwarranted conclusions when they don't read or can't understand the content of the video.
TH-cam is plagued with simple amateur DIY contraptions claiming to be free energy devices, but are actually faked with power sources hidden or simulated by editing tricks.
Similar wind & hydro generator hoaxes & failures are fictitiously presented, often as impossibly more than 100% efficient in converting mechanical energy to electrical.
Many simply impress viewers with easily achieved high voltage shown on a meter, but ignore the fact that amperage was inefficiently sacrificed to get a higher voltage. The actual power produced must be measured and reported as the product of voltage AND amperage.
It's directly analogous to being impressed by a 20,000 RPM diesel engine claim when semitruck diesels run under 3,000 RPM.
What isn't explained is that RPM is meaningless without also knowing how much torque is rotating at that RPM. A tiny model airplane engine is a diesel engine that achieves very high RPM, but of course has very little torque and is not comparable to a truck engine in horsepower.
In actuality a generator does not create power at all; it merely converts some other type of energy (usually mechanically extracted from flowing water, wind or a fuel burning engine) into electrical energy.
The conversion is never 100% efficient, and even if it was, it could only convert and preserve the small amount of electricity necessary to keep itself wastelessly running, but not any excess that could be drawn off for any other purpose without it quickly coming to a halt.
No machine is perfectly frictionless or never wastes some energy as heat, stray magnetic fields, electrical resistance in wires, even in air resistace of moving parts, viscosity of lubricants (even as a residual limit to otherwise reducing friction).
Even energy wasted in vibrating surrunding air (noise) is enough to keep a machine under a theoretical 100% efficiency in converting one type of power to another.
A continuous input of energy is unavoidable per the principle in physics of 'conservation of energy'.
A great deal of remedial education is needed to battle the greedy hucksters peddling fantasy & antiscience by monetizing hoaxes aimed at the insufficiently science-educated public.
This video should emphasize the fundamental principles that are violated by ALL purported 'free energy' or 'overunity' devices.
I don't want to ignore the educational value of the "thought experiment" analyzed in this video, but I think it could be very much more valuable if it also taught the fundamentals to the curious kids that need to be inoculated againt all the pervasive disinformation on TH-cam.
In this case it leads them to believe the conspiracy theory that "free energy" is more than just possible, but is technology being greedily "suppressed" by some impossibly powerful, unified, impenetrable, secret cabal of world dominators.
What if the first couple of magnets were attached in such a way that they move in a specific way as they turn so that when it comes back around the “jump out of the gravity well isn’t so high?” But they would still need to return somehow so they still create the torque. 🤔
Hi JWY, thx for your comment. If you try to tilt some magnets to bring them out of the magnetic field of the others. Please watch my video for this topic 🙂
th-cam.com/video/Gj6krP-1P3M/w-d-xo.htmlsi=pb606-9ZItYDO7Y1
Thx for watching
I'm trying to join 20 disc magnets (no hole) opposing. Coin size. I'm trying take but it's proving difficult. Any suggestions? Thanks
A
Hi Toni, thanks for your comment. I may be able to tell something about your concept if you provide an link to an video or blueprint of your idea. Thx for watching 🙂
I want to believe that if something that simple existed, it would have been created. But all these great examples are using a bunch of multiple magnets and the balance between them.
If you're using only 2 magnets, and the push is strong enough what would happen? The system would balance at some point with the magnet on the rotor being on the opposite side of the static magnet ?
Hi 1Iomi, thx for your question. Yes, I think it would go like you said. It tends to balance. And balance mostly is a standstill 🫣.
Thx for watching 🙂
É essa parte do magnetismo que ninguém consegue quebrar a barreira, obrigado pelo excelente conteúdo
Hi Digranni, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
The threshold of repulsion can be easily overcome if, at the moment of completion of the revolution, the main magnet is mechanically moved away, and when the threshold is overcome, it is returned back. In this case, the force spent on the shift will be almost equal to 0
It actually can work. It just misses one component there. :) the door is shut. You got to open the door for it to work. 😉 Im not gonna say anything else. If you will not build it, then in time I will. In time as if I get enough resources.
Hi Mik, thanks for your comment. Yes, do it. I gladly will admit to be wrong if you are successful! Good luck 🙂. Thx for watching
@@yWild you are not wrong actually. You are about 90% done with this motor. You just got to open the door so that the "ball" can get through and not falling back. I love that you showed that 3d model way with the climb and why it will not work at this state. But there is tech out there that can neutralise that stoppage force. Its like you need to add fuel to otto motor for it to start working. Otherwise the pistons can move, but there is no energy to move em. You need to...... open the door. :)
Hi Mik, glad you like the 3D animations. I soo strongly would like to open the door, but I don’t know how. If you are able to do so, be my guest 🙂. Thx for watching
@@yWild you are good at animations... maybe I need you... can we speak in private?
Hi Mik, I will provide an email address soon but actually I’m on an trip and haven’t access to the credentials 🤪.
Good job buddy!👏👏👏
💪
Hi, thx for your comment. Glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
IS IT APPLLIED PHYSICALLY ?
Hi Swan, thanks for your comment. Try it out using the gravity model. If it is possible in this context, it will be possible in reality. Thx for watching 🙂
Good work
Make motor for placing parallel magnets array but Rotter secuse or inword small diameter then out side from center where magnets. Stationery magnet placed in grooving then r
Hi Rizwan, thanks for your comment. This machine is not able to work. If you like to know why, just watch the video till the end 🤗. Thx for watching
Brilliant for another example of free energy. I see envious haters in here.
Hi Relic, thx for your comment. Yes it’s an design that looks like it is able to run perpetual, but if you look closer, it’s an magnetic ramp. Magnetic ramps cannot do the job. Unfortunately. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild not fast enough or enough torque? Maybe good enough for a smaller use. In our free energy 5d world ✨
well, try maglev bearing flywheel, then make a minor modification to make it push, 90 degree flip then spring back to maglev mode. maglev/push alteration modes
Hi, thanks for your comment. Great ideas, but I just want to show why perpetual motion motors are not able to work. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild is God? do you consider newtons laws as perpetual motion (no energy added or removed, from a system, always at same energy level)
@@yWild well thats not a proof then
Hi Jkauppa, thanks for your comments. Yes, Newton is great but most people need something more tangible to follow what’s happening. So I do the switch from magnetic force to gravity force. And yes, this is not really a scientific proof but if you think about, you will see the permanent imbalance thing. That’s simple to understand without scientific understanding. Thx for watching 🙂👍🏻
@@yWild you either do it scientifically, not rely on "peoples understanding", dont cross over when suitable, lol
What if you connect a nonmagnetic wieght inside the roller ,at the point where it's stop???
Hi DIY, thx for your comment. The idea is good, but it will just slow down the effect because of the higher inertia. It will not make a difference, I fear. Thx for watching 🙂
I developed a magnet motor that produces usable torque and RPM and can easily drive a generator. A much different design than this. But it actually works. It has minimal moving parts and can be made in any size needed. My biggest problem is intellectual property protection. Yes it is so simple to build anyone can do it on their coffee table in a few hours.
Hi John, thanks for your comment. Glad to hear that. When will you produce it in an industrial way? Our world energy problem is solved, if I understood right, right? 👍🏻 😄 thanks for watching.
@@yWild that's the problem. It is so simple to build. It's very easy to steal. Not sure how to get it public without getting ripped off
Hi John, I understand your problem. I would start to write down the design, and bring it to the patent office.
On the other hand, you can publish it with a donation model. Then you don’t would be a billionaire, but you would change the world.
If you publish it for free, and ask for some donation, many people would give you some money if it really works for them.
🙂
If you share it for free, the good news is that no one has any reason to hurt you. I personally do not think that anyone thinks this way.
@@yWild yeah but having world changing technology... Be nice to go from living in poverty public housing to at least a home of my own
Супер спасибо большое за информацию 👍👍😀👍 интересная идея 👍👍😀👍👍😀👍👍😀👍👍😀👍👍😀👍👍😀👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Hi Roman, glad you like it, thanks for watching 🙂
I've long wanted to see someone review or debunk the theory behind a v-track motor, but this video sadly misrepresents it. The stator magnet is never static, instead, these motors have it moving up and down at the rail connection to prevent the exact issue you are describing.
it does work but you have to offset the axle yours is in the cntre and thats why it stops you need to make axle offset slightly thats it.
Hi Jedi, thanks for your comment. Maybe there is a way to make that motor work as desired but it will not implementable by using some magnets in a tricky setup for sure. Try thinking in my gravitational model way. Thx for watching 🙂
But can’t you just add a counter weight that pulls downwards with gravity on the wheel at the point of slowing. Or even place a small magnet the runs along the z axis downward at that point you can run a simple gear that moves a ground magnet out of the way once the point of resistance is past. It’s convoluted and it would require a counter weight on the opposite end or simply have to deal with the wheel being imbalanced which technically it already is which also did not factor in to your model that the weight and mass of the wheel is imbalanced in such a way that gravity and momentum pul hardest against that point also many versions of this I see actually use a electromagnetic disconnect on that transition point. My question has always been can the rpm increase to the point where the energy needed to power a small electro magnet is smaller then the electricity generated by an attatched flywheel and generator. I never see these with proper flywheels.
Also a simple gearing system attached to a chain could retract the magnet at the moment of highest resistance. You could have a pair of gears with teeth only on a small portion attached to a gear correlated to the 360 degrees of travel. It would pull the magnet out for that brief moment than push it back. This is just one example I can think of many that would do the trick.
I think the greatest question or operative problem is not the transition period but if the rest of the slope is capable of powering anything at all besides it’s own momentum if it can run a chain and spin a flywheel I am not convinced that this idea is one hundred percent worthless. As you showed pushing the operating magnet forward starts the action, than surely creating a mechanism to remove it at the right moment should solve the problem provided the movement is enough to spin a flywheel. Even using spring or a gravity battery for insertion and removal of the operative magnet should make it possible. All of my doubts are in weather or not the magnets have any spare power to move anything but the plastic wheel they are mounted on.
Thx for your detailed comment. Thx for watching 🙂
And yet, whenever anybody makes a real version (me included), they function for quite a while until the permanent magnets loose coherence and stop projecting their fields. It's better to think of these things as batteries instead of generators.
Hi Gabriel, thanks for your comment. I apologise, but I don’t think so. I believe that they don’t start working whatever you do. Except using forbidden power sources 🙂. Yes, it’s better to think of a new type of power generators. Thx for watching 🙂
Why you add some weight to rotating shaft and give it a little rotating speed to over come repulsion
It should keep spinning
Hi Chirtan, thanks for your comment. I just got the idea for the roller from Daniels inventions, an TH-cam which built this machine with an power source attached. But out there are many of these motors which look like they are really working. So I reveal the truth. Thx for watching 🙂
Very nice free energy project
Hi Raj, thanks for your comment. I try to show that this kind of free energy is not possible. Thx for watching 🙂
I think it can be possible if the magnets can be turned off (cancelled out) at the right timing maybe with timing advance/retard.
Hi Jumah, thanks for your comment. I made a video about turning the magnet, th-cam.com/video/Gj6krP-1P3M/w-d-xo.html . The power to invest to remove a magnet from the system or to insert a magnet back into the system is too much for perpetual motion. Tilting the magnet needs also too much energy. Thx for watching 🙂
Make a video over graph probability of free potential difference energy forever
Hi Anil, thanks for your comment. I just don’t know what free potential you think of. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild as we ⌚know their are some magnetic⌚👀 field switch🔄 which are making magnetic field⌚ on🕉️ and🌌 off
So just by twisting the magnetic⌚ field⌚ we can leverage the maximum force with minimum energy⚡⚡⚡
🤔💫⚡️💥🫣🤪🥳😎
que topzera gostei dessa forma é incrivel
Hi Os, glad you like it, thx for watching 🙂
Excellent 👍
Hi Mr Ad, glad you like it 🙂. Thx for watching
Why cant magnetic shielding be used as it gets to the closer point of the gate?
Hi Benjamin, thx for your comment. Magnetic shielding is not able to do the job because it is magnetic itself. For more information watch my video th-cam.com/video/oQ36wQJUYq4/w-d-xo.html . Thx for watching 🙂
@yWild hypothetically, if I put something like this on a bike, where the pedaling would contribute to the movement of the wheel, would it actually speed up the bike??
Cos magnetic shield not eliminates magnetic field. It can change/compress it, so no chance that it can be usefull here.
@@benjaminfoley919 No it would not, pedaling would speed up the bike the magnets would add nothing except increased mass to accelerate therefore slowing the wheel down
Dein Magnetteil sieht toll aus, aber wie du selbst weißt ............... funktioniert das Teil nur so lange , wie du am Anfang Kraft ( wie auch immer ) überträgst. So lange bis die Kraft verbraucht ist.
Hi Peter, thanks for your comment. Glad you like it. Yes it’s not able to work perpetual. In this video I try to show why these devices are not working. Thx for watching 🙂
Ok felicitări ❤❤
Hi Toader, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
you're right on this one.
Hi Samba, thx for your comment. Great that I made it 😃. Thx for watching 🙂
sir, if we make production of this motor, can we sell it from India?
Hi Jackwhite, thanks for your comment. This motor is just an simulation for demonstration and I try to tell people, that these devices are not able to work. In this video I show why they don’t do the job, because many people believe in perpetual motion motors. Thx for your offer, but I apologise, I don’t want to sell devices which do not work. Thx for watching 🙂
Who knows what about side magnets and center bolts from both sides? Looks like permanent magnets and inductor of coil
Hi Theodor, thx for your comment. Because it’s only an simulation to show the principle, it’s not necessary 🙂. Thx for watching
Im shure that dont matter in simulation, but in case trying to build it in real life and get "unstopable" machine they needed to fake free energy.
Hi Theodor, yes, but it is a try to make people understand why these devices are not able to work. Thx for your comments. 🙂
So in the roller Weights have been added to overcome the imbalance of the forces involved, lol.
Hi Jackal, the additional weights are mend to create a balance for the overlap on the opposite side. But with or without, both systems are not able to do the free energy job. Thx for watching 🙂
Beatiful 👍
Hi, thanks for your comment. Glad you like it 🙂
How long it will take when magnet will lose 1% of strengh 100Years or sooner or later?
Hi Jozef, thx for your question. I have to admit that I have no clue how long it takes. Nevertheless is the working principle independent from this, as long as the reduction is going on similar to all magnets together. Thx for watching 🙂
But are there sales and distribution?
Hi Paul, thanks for your comment. Because the concept is not working it’s not recommendable to sell such a device. I try to show the people why these perpetual motion devices are not able to do the job. Thx for watching 🙂
Because an infinitely long line of dominos would topple forever, that means some kind of continuous chain reaction motion must be possible
Hi William, thanks for your comment. Yes, if there is someone who quickly picks up the domino bricks and puts them back😄. Thx for watching
Quantum infinity is it spining
Hi Physics, thx for watching 🙂
Hello, I'm from Brazil and I preferred to post in Portuguese (Brazilian) due to possible limitations of the "Google" translation.
Não se deve entender um "motor" ou "movimento" gerado por imãs como sendo "moto-perpétuo", "energia livre", ou qualçquer coisa desse tipo porque não é.
É preciso considerar que os imãs foram "produzidos" de alguma forma, e trazem sua energia para o sistema. O movimento desejado não é partir do nada. Está sendo introduzida energia no sistema sim, da mesma forma que combustível é introduzido num motor a combustão interna para acionar um gerador.
Quanto ao problema dos imãs se anularem em determinado momento, talvez trabalhando em unipolarização do campo (tem estudos nesse sentido) e/ou usando isolantes (já existem materiais que fazem isso parcialmente) o resultado seja outro.
Ainda que não se consiga resultado favorável, é necessário excluir "motores magnéticos com imãs" do conceito moto-perpétuo. E isso é conceitual.
Poderá não funcionar por outros motivos, não por ser moto-contínuo, coisa que de fato não é.
Entendo que uma vez solucionado o problema do "auto-freio", a questão é se o movimento gerado é capaz de gerar outros imãs e sobrar alguma energia.
Em todo caso, não é moto-contínuo.
Hi Clovis, thx for your comment. You are right. That’s the idea behind my videos. I try to give people a view to the invisible magnetic field and its effects. So they might understand that there is no magic perpetual motion inside. Thx for watching 🙂
Could you sell me one? I loved having one for my electrical projects
Hi Olivier, thanks for your question. I just do CGI for demonstration to explain people why these devices are not really work. Thx for watching 🙂
The mass of intersected magnets helps to overcome the repulsion via gravity of earth
Hi Randomizer, thx for your comment. Maybe this is a way, but over here th-cam.com/video/nRJUePA1eb8/w-d-xo.html , th-cam.com/video/iNODsSAjJ8Y/w-d-xo.html I tried out with the helping hand of gravity. Did not work. Thx for watching 🙂
There was one model where the magnet was lifted for that jump.
Hi KittenKatja, thx for your comment. Maybe, but to bring the magnet back into the magnetic field power is required. In addition to establish the movement and the friction, inertia… It might be more power to invest, than you get out. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild I didn't know gravity is a power.
A lot of work for animation but very good explanation.
Hi, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
What about people who use bismuth in 'overunity' devices to block the magnetic field...
Hi Sodium, thx for your question. I don’t know what the difference of bismuth is, but it is influenced by magnetism so far as I know. Thx for watching 🙂
@@yWild yes it's the most diamagnetic element. You can do some tricks to get some unusual magnetic field geometries but nothing revolutionary as far as I can tell
@@yWild you can levitate magnets in a similar way to pyrolytic graphite
Amazing...
Hi Enam, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
Sick infinity is a perpetual motion machine
Hi Physics, thanks for your comment. If it would work, you would be right 🙂. Thx for watching
IVE DONE THIS YEARS AGO. THE PROBLEM WITH ALL THESE MOTOR ATTEMPTS IS WHAT IS MISSING IN THEIR DESIGN. THEY NEED A CAM TO CHANGE THE MAG POSITIONS. JUST LIKE A GAS MOTOR. THAT WHY THEIRS DOESNT WORK AND MINE DOES. AND IT ALLOWS YOU TO SET THE TIMING AND THE TORQUE IS FAR BEYOND WHAT THEIR DESIGNS PRODUCE. ALL THOSE MOTORS CAN DO IS SPIN. BARELY
Hi Alex, thanks for your comment. I’ve made an similar experience. Thx for watching 🙂
Perfeito
Hi Valdeci, glad you like it. Thx for watching 🙂
It is not what the Muamar Magnetic Mouter showed to us .
Simulater is one thing , reality is other one.
There is free energy so. The Max Plank Diagram or Black Corps radiation show us that any piece of matter absorbs and emites particles of photons and other types .
Just we find a way to aligne this particles flows in one direction that we have energy.
We are not in zero kelvin. We are at 25 °C then , there is many radiations that surround us.
Hi Derick, thx for your comment. Yes, we are not at zero Kelvin and I am not able to tell what will happen if we were. Thx for watching 🙂