Thule Cargo Box Comparison: Vector VS Motion XT VS Force XT
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ค. 2024
- Ad-free, no fluff, subtitled Thule Cargo Box comparison of Thule Vector, Motion XT and Force XT. We'll talk about what the boxes have in common and what features set them apart.
✔️ GOOD - Thule Force XT: www.rackattack.com/cargo-boxe...
✔️ BETTER - Thule Motion XT: www.rackattack.com/cargo-boxe...
✔️ BEST - Thule Vector: www.rackattack.com/cargo-boxe...
0:00 What the Thule Cargo Boxes have in common
2:32 Thule Vector
6:28 Thule Motion XT
8:09 Thule Force XT
9:34 Thule Vector - Reinforcement Bars
10:42 Cargo Box Belt Lines
12:15 Thule Motion XT and Force XT - Reinforcement Bars
13:04 Matt and Gloss Finish / Outro
Cargo Boxes are the ideal way to carry your gear, skis, and boards. Keep the inside of your car clean and clear without having to leave anything at home. All luggage boxes sold by Rack Attack are premium quality guaranteed to keep your gear safe and dry, no matter how far your destination.
🔗 Facebook: / rackattack
🔗 Instagram: / rackattack
🔗 Twitter: / rackattack
🔗 LinkedIn: / rack-attack
#CargoBox #Thule #RackAttack - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
🛒 More cargo boxes here: www.rackattack.com/cargo-boxes/
🏬 See it in action in one of our stores across North America: www.rackattack.com/stores/
Thanks guys for putting this out! I've been delaying my first cargo box purchase because the Vector M looked like what I wanted, but was so new that no one had an example to compare with in the store. Now we have some detailed video of it + a side-by-side comparison of it against some of their other older models. Well done!
An excellent comparison. Thank you for explaning the tubular reinforcement bars on each of the boxes.
..approximately 13:00
Great explanation of theses boxes
Very thorough. Thank you
Very welcome!
Hi, im planning to get the Thule Motion. Will the Thule Motion XXL fit my 2019 Toyota Sequoia?
very useful and informative, many thanks!
Thanks a lot for this great presentation of this boxes 👍
Hello. Thanks for the positive feedback!
Thanks for the nice comparison video. It is very helpful. I am interested in an XXL box and wondering about the choice between Force and Motion. I see your point about the larger beltline on the Motion, also the different lockingh systems and exterior finishes. My question is - do you recommend the Motion over the Force? Thanks.
Hello. Yes, if the added cost is budget friendly, than we'd recommend the Motion XT for the added upgrades. Thanks!
Hi, great video and very informative. Thanks! I already have the BMW bars on my car but I would like to buy the Thule force XT XL. Do you know if the bars are compatible with the box and the grip system. Struggling to find an answer and dont want to buy a new set. Thanks again.
Any box will fit on your crossbars, however some of the longer boxes can have a bit of hatch interference potentially. Measure from the open hatch to the middle of the front cross bar. With that measurement, we can let you know which boxes fit without hatch interference. In most cases the antenna is a bit flexible and can bend a bit if it is tall enough that it would contact the box. For the XL size you would need 50-52 inches.
Thanks for your great question!
Nice comparison, thanks!
Thanks for watching!
Thank you for the very thorough and helpful video. We need an XXL box, wanted your opinion between the Thule Motion XXL and Yakima skybox 21. Which would would you recommend? Need it for when we go skiing. Thanks for your help!
Hello. The Motion XT has a more upscale, gloss finish and very easy to use mounting hardware, the Skybox is has a very ridged construction, it's a bit heavier, the finish is textured, and scratch resistant. Thanks!
I plan to buy one within 10 days, thanks for the video. Will the motion xt xxl allow the the hatch to open fully or half way with a 2019 highlander ? Thank you.
We recommend the XL, here's our video showing the fit on the Highlander th-cam.com/video/B6ZLI-maAdY/w-d-xo.html
Glad to have found your channel. I have a 2021 Toyota Prius L Eco and wondering if Thule has rack that will fit or work on my car so I can buy one of this box? Thank you
Looks like both Thule (Evo Clamp) and Yakima (Baseline) have some cross bar systems for your Prius available. Please check the link below for a 2021 Prius. It won't matter too much which cross bars you choose as a Thule box will work on either/all.
www.rackattack.com/fit/toyota/prius/2021/
Thanks for your question!
Great explanation! Thanks!
all in one take, thank you for the information
You're welcome!
I have a large Pioneer platform made by Rhino Racks on my truck and I was wondering if I can mount directly without any other accessories any of this cargo boxes in between the platforms channels. Thanks
The boxes are designed to sit on crossbars with lowered front and rear areas to hug the roof, this design will not work with flat platforms.
Great comparison. Seeing the box on the websites. Looks like the Vector is wider in the front and smaller in the back is that true? Do you recommend the vector against the motion? I do not see much improvement beside the padded and lights
Hello. The shapes will vary depending on the size but the Vector boxes are lower profile than the Motion and Force boxes. Vector buyers want the best, no compromise product regardless of practicality or economy. Thanks!
Would you recommend the alpine size if I want to haul more than just skis/snowboards? That will be the primary use but potentially camping supplies/etc. during other trips.
Hello. The low profile of the Alpine may limit the capacity for taller items. Unless the priority is the ultra sleek profile, the better choice may be standard boxes that can accommodate taller items. Thanks!
Will the Motion XT XL fit on a 2019 Tesla Model 3?
Xt or vector what you think? For my nissan versa note 2014 model
Thule Motion XT L Black Cargo Box bought mine today at Van Nuys Shop for my 2014 Subaru Outback in the shop they look huge but Jefry said once mounted it would be just the right size 👍
Hello. Yes, up close, they do look big but once mounted to the vehicle the right box will look proportionate. Thanks!
My question are
Do Thule use same key and lock for all they boxes?
Cause when I bought my motion xt- xl, that's what the sale associate took me that.
Thule offers a "One Key" system.
I would imagine the vector is the Quietest model Thule offers?
Really useful - thank you. Can you please advise the largest Force XT I could get for a 2022 Mazda CX-9 please?
Hello. The Force XT XL is the best proportional fit for the CX-9, however, roof positioning will vary depending on the roof rack system. We'd suggest a test fit at your nearest dealer: www.rackattack.com/stores/
Hardly discussed the Force XT. The video makes it appear to be the red headed step-child of the Thule line. No disrespect to the pitch man.
Great video. Which box would you use on a Mazda CX-50 (Thule force XT L or XL)? many thanks
Hello. The L would be the best proportional fit for the CX-50 roof line. Thanks!
Great comparison video--well done!! Currently have a Yakima Skybox 16 but it needs to be replaced (true story: was in San Diego and misjudged the ceiling height when going down into underground parking! Possibly the stupidest thing I have ever done driving, but who knows, maybe I can outdo it. Crunched it something fierce and put two cracks in it and jacked up the inner hinges, but with gorilla tape I have made do). I like Thule as it is about 6 lbs lighter, at least with the Motion, than the 16L Yakima Skybox. Paying more for the Thule, of course, but it seems well made.
We’ve all been there. In fact, that’s why I’m here😂🤦♂️
Hi I've got a 2019 Infiniti QX30, what is the largest size you would recommend for the motion and force? Don't want to buy one and ends up being too big
Hello. The 16 cubic foot is the smallest Motion or Force box and the largest that could fit the QX30. Thanks!
Thanks for the excelent explanation.
What THULE Cargo Box, for the SEAT Ateca 2017?
Thanks
Unfortunately in my 15 years of attacking racks I have never worked on a SEAT (Had to google) as they aren't sold in North America that I know of. However!
Any box will fit on your crossbars, however some of the longer boxes can have a bit of hatch interference. Measure from the open hatch to the middle of the front cross bar. With that measurement, we can let you know which boxes fit without hatch interference. In most cases the antenna is a bit flexible and can bend a bit if it is tall enough that it would contact the box.
@@rackattack Thanks so much!
So between the motion and vector, your paying an extra 1,000 for a light and liner?
Hello. The Vector is a completely unique design with Thule's most advanced molding techniques to optimize strength and aerodynamics. The Motion XT is still the more popular product as it delivers great performance at a much lower price. Thanks!
Hello, what roof box are compatible with Ford Focus 2023 hatchback? I can't find a configurator for Thule...
Hello. Sorry, but we do not have any fit listings for the 2023 Ford Focus. Please check back later for updates on our fit guide: www.rackattack.com/wizard/ In the past, we'd generally suggest a 16 cubic foot box to proportionally fit the Focus (on an approved roof rack). Thanks!
Looks like the major difference between the Force and Motion are the locks and the front lip. Does that front lip on the Motion really make a difference? Is the lock on the Force any good? I'm trying to justify the extra $$ between the two
Hello. The Motion XT series has upgrades for convenience and appearance, both boxes will carry gear to the destination. The Force XT locks are dependable, the Motion front lip offers more overlap, however, the Force XT overlap is sufficiently secure. Thanks!
What do you put in these boxes? Is it for skis? Or other stuff too?
Originally they were designed for Ski's but as less and less people drove station wagons, space and storage became more of a priority. Now a days they do a little bit of both, best to know the longest length ski you may transport before buying a cargo Box. Don't forget to ask your tallest friend incase they wanna hitch a ride up the hill.
Just picked up a Toyota 2023 rav 4. What's the best size box? Hopefully beach chairs and carry on bags will fit. Planning a road trip for a famy of 4 and no longer have the space of a minivan, thx
Hello. The best proportionate size is the medium or 16 cubic foot. Thanks!
Would this fit over the ac unit of a Intech explorer travel trailer? Look for more ways to bring cargo.
Great question! I would usually recommend shifting the cargo box to one side of the roof to be next to the unit, but from pictures online the AC unit for the Intech Explorer appears to be centered in the roof. Since it most likely needs to sit above the AC unit, the fit would greatly depend on the rack system that would hold up the cargo box. At timestamp 9:06 you can see between the clamps on the bottom of the Force XT is flat, meaning it rests directly on the crossbars. The crossbars will need to sit above the AC unit enough so no vents are blocked, and so the cargo box doesn't heat up. I would recommend reaching out to your local Rack Attack store to speak to an installer about possible fitments: www.rackattack.com/stores/
Awesome!
Glad you think so!
can i use Vector M on my tesla model 3 ?
Hi Paul, can you tell me if the Thule Force XT XL will fits a 2015 Nissan Rogue? Thanks!
The Large, Force or Motion is a better fit: th-cam.com/video/_L4KtswtgjI/w-d-xo.html
@@rackattack Cheers!
I have Thule Force L , is it possible to install on 2021 model Y?
Any box will fit on your crossbars if you have them. However some of the longer boxes can have a bit of hatch interference. Measure from the open hatch to the middle of the front cross bar. With that measurement, we can let you know which boxes fit without hatch interference. In most cases the antenna is a bit flexible and can bend a bit if it is tall enough that it would contact the box. The Force L needs about 48 inches of clearance.
Hi I am planning to buy one in the next two week i live in houston texas i can come buy and get one from you in Austin over on a weekend if is possible i have a Tahoe 2019 i like to get the large one that i can fit on the tahoe, i like the one in the middle
We do stock these boxes at our Austin location which is open 10AM - 6PM Monday through Friday. We offer free installation on these boxes on approved crossbars. Please call prior to traveling to confirm, we do offer 24 hour holds on boxes.
Very interesting and informative.
Glad it was helpful!
The best thing Thule has done was to make the clamps easily removable because I keep breaking the ones in my old Atlantis.
Hello. Though the Atlantis was state-of-the-art in its time, Thule is always striving to improve the ease of use of there products. Thanks for commenting!
hey man maybe you could help. thule website doesnt give any results. im driving audi TT MK3. which box goes for my car? thank you. i was thinking having space for 2 skis on rack and another small box for wet stuff
Hello. No roof rack fits were found for your vehicle. Contact us to consider custom options: www.rackattack.com/stores/ Thanks
do these boxes make any noise when parked due to wind or anything? i use my vehicle as a camper, too and want to install one of these but am concerned that wind may cause too much noise on top of the roof when i sleep...thanks for the review!!
if you are concerned about that amount of noise.. do you also remain oblivious to the other sounds in nature such as birds and bugs making noise at night or just the artificial wind blocking noise non-nature related is the only thing that increases your annoyance levels?
This is the dumbest question i have heard.
You sleep during a tornado or something?
@@antdx316 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
@@Oakleyworld HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
@@Oakleyworld HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Great video.. any input on which Thule box would fit an 08 Volvo XC90?
Hello. The Motion XT XL would be the best fit. Thanks!
@@rackattack thank you so much!!
Useful video! I am seeking a model and size recommendations for a ‘16 BMW 3-Series wagon. Trying to avoid too much overhang over the windshield and avoiding contact with the tailgate.
For the motion xt xxl can add the lights inside the box like the vector or an accessory
It turns out you cannot add a light to the Thule Motion XT series. The Vector is the only Cargo Box that comes with a light inside.
@@rackattack thanks for the fast reply that stinks. But hope an accessory comes around or may look to put a battery and sticky tape.
I am new to cargo roof racks and I am looking to purchase one, but a question I have is are the boxes tall enough to fit a large suitcase? Or even the smaller single person (maybe carry on suit cases) And what's the maximum weight that can safely be stored in the boxes?
Hello. Most boxes are rated to carry 110 pounds, some up to 165 and here's an 18 cubic foot box with five standard carry-on size luggage pieces with room to spare: th-cam.com/video/VBzFtv_k_iw/w-d-xo.html Thanks!
How to remove strap with the power click grip?
Which strap are you referring to? If would like some specific assist reach out to our team at 1-888-301-1527
Stupid question,
I love my Car wash membership. Is it advisable to take a Thule Cargo box through the car wash?
Ford Fusion Sport...
Hey Larry, you should never take the cargo box through the car wash, it will be damaged. On that note, the crossbars on your vehicle, if removable, should also be removed for the car wash as taking them through voids warranty and will not be covered if damaged. Hope this helps!
This is somewhat related. What happened to their Hyper line?
The Hyper is discontinued. We may see a replacement for the Hyper in the future as this could fill in the price point between the Motion XT and the Vector. Nothing is official or even rumored at this time though.
Wish you could display every single kind and size at once with big poster boards on cubic feet and key features on big lettering. Without having separate notes it is hard to follow all Thule cargo box reviews, not just yoursz
Wow, is there a rack outfitter in colorado?
Hi Bruce! Rack Outfitters recently joined the Rack Attack family, and we have a few locations in Colorado. You can find our list here: www.rackattack.com/stores/
What size box do you recommend for a 2021 Honda Pilot?
Hello. The best proportional fit for the Pilot is the XL or 18 cubic foot box, here's the exact fit: th-cam.com/video/vBg4xhEnDTg/w-d-xo.html
My last Thule box failed at slide of mounting hardware… Thule wasn’t able to help me repair it but gave me discount code for another purchase…
Hello. Glad to hear of Thule's support after the product issue. Thanks!
Do you have a store in LA where I can go look at all your Thules?
We do not, however, Rack Attack has locations in LA: www.rackattack.com/store/los-angeles/
@@rackattack Van Nuys too am looking to go there this afternoon
Can a stroller fit the vector???
213gixxer Potentially, but you’d want to do a test fit to confirm.
Are there any boxes with rubber gaskets around the perimeter to really keep the moisture out?
Hello. None of them have rubber gaskets, instead the lid and base overlap to keep water and dust out. Thanks for checking!
@@rackattack Thank you!
Thanks
Thank you for your time, and comment!
Does the Motion XT Alpine have the tubular support bars underneath? You only mentioned the L, XL, and XXL but didn't say if the alpine had them or not.
Hello. Yes, the Motion XT Alpine also has the tubular steel support bars underneath. Thanks!
Any idea why the slide lock would jam and not open
Hello. If the box is loaded with too much weight at the ends it could bind the lock linkage. With help, push upward on the front and rear to relive the stress, then try the lock again. Thanks!
That vector is sweet but that price woo
Hello. Yes, the Vector has every advanced feature from Thule's best engineers and designers, fortunately, the less expensive Motion XT shares many of the same features. Thanks!
Will any of these fit bicycle wheels laying flat?
Hello. There should be room to fit road bike wheels and possible even larger MTB wheels, however, we definitely recommend a test fit, just visit one of our dealers to confirm: www.rackattack.com/stores/ Thanks!
A video explaining all the diagrams in the instructions would be nice.
Hello. Thanks, good suggestion.
aren't there four power grips? two on each side to pinch the roof bars? why do I only see one?
Vector has all four Power Grips preinstalled, the Motion XT and Force XT are shipped with the hardware included but not preinstalled.
hi , do you have a roof box that you can fix on suction cup i can't put a roof bar on my car ? (Thule vector )
Hello. We'd suggest matching up the vehicle with a Thule roof rack to support the Thule Vector, check our vehicle fit guide for the latest fit and pricing information: www.rackattack.com/wizard/ also, you may check with an expert at one of our stores near you: www.rackattack.com/stores/ Thanks!
@@rackattack many thanks for your quick response it's for a Maserati Quattroporte V can you help me for the link ( model ) what advice do you have for the Thule Vector ?
www.thule.com/fr-fr/cargo-carrier/car-top-carrier
my choice is for the Thule Vector ! I'm going to buy the Thule Vector and I'm going to drop it off at my body shop who will paint it in the colours of my car I want it for this summer the length of the car is 5052 mm large 2.00 meters 1895 mm
give me the link exactly for this car , I don't see a rack to support the Roof thank a lot .
@@rackattack ??? I ask you a question , please ;
@@patrickXWAY Hello. Because there is no stock fit for the vehicle, we'd suggest considering a custom fit, for this it is necessary to consult directly with an in-store rack specialist. Please find the store nearest to you here: www.rackattack.com/stores/ Thanks!
@@rackattack merci 👍I'm French I'm live in France
For a toyota pruis any recommendations anyone?
It will depend on the year and bars you have on your Prius, generally I recommend any of the Thule L or Yakima 16 cubic foot boxes for a vehicle like yours.
I’ve had all three it’s kind of like what looks best on your car and how much are you willing to pay. They all work great.
Hello. Yes, good input. Thanks!
Why are you lying?
@@davedavid0 Why are you acusing him of lying?
@TheGrundigg it's been a year since that was posted. Why are you defending a liar?
@@davedavid0 It's been 49 minutes since my comment, why are you saying I am defending him?
Can you mount a Thule Motion XT cargo box on a Yakima rack using Corebar or Jetstream crossbars
NO
@@salvadorcampos3840 Actually you can, I just purchased a Thule Motion XT XL and mounted it on a Yakima rack using jetstream crossbars and it works perfectly.
Long term durability? What do i need that for? Am i rolling my car over?
Too bad Thule never released a bigger Vector
Only Medium and no Large or Xtra Large and definitely no XXtra Large
Hello. Yes, the Vector is a speciality box and very low profile, the Motion XT and Force XT are offered in larger volume sizes to suit a wider range of users. Thanks!
The VECTOR is the L or the ALPINE?
Hello, The Vector is offered in an "M" or Alpine, this video is featuring the "M". Thanks!
What about speed?
Up to 140 km/h
@@aeshuva thank you
and for higher speed?
@@aeshuva That is wrong, it is 130 km/h.
trip width the fe ski pals luggage hassle concern not emergency equipment and nutrition included ; done
911 are these cases waterproof??
213gixxer They are considered weather resistant.
Dude said frontal
I'm surprised they are still using cheap locks these days.
Hello. The Thule One-Key System is used throughout the Thule product line. The system provides a strong theft deterrent and is comparable the other rack manufactures' lock systems. In a high risk environments, we'd suggest unloading the gear, eg: overnight motel stays. Thanks!
Not 'toolee' but 'toolah'.'
Hello. Good point, yes, you'll find that Thule is commonly pronounced "toolah" in Europe but it is commonly pronounced "toolee" in North America. Thanks!
@@rackattack You're welcome! I hope you didn't take offense!
@@esdet105 No offense taken, thanks for commenting.
Tuly? Has everyone in my life been pronouncing the name of this brand wrong my entire life? You say it Tuly and not Thool? huh...
yes, that would be the correct enunciation. Thule = (THEW-lee)
Stay away from Thule products. They don’t answer warranties or call you back. I’ve been waiting over a month to resolve my defective Upride bike racks. I’m going to continue on social media until they are out of business.
Choose another company.
Hello. Presenting the warranty claim with a clear explanation of the defect along with photos can go a long way to have a claim resolved, here's their warranty page for a through explanation of what's covered: www.thule.com/en-us/about-thule/warranty
Same terrible latching systems from decades ago I see.
Hello. Thanks for the comment. Thule has had great success with these boxes in markets around the world. Sorry to hear of the latch issue.
Way too long and off point. Clean and concise is needed. 1). Start with PRICE. 2). Then tell us what you get at each price point. 3). Cubic Ft? Really. People want to know how long, wide and tall they are. 4). Which fit best on which vehicle. 5). Then get into ease of use. The video is taking way too much time talking about features that are self evident. Again, tie downs, led lights, etc. all good to know… once I know what the price is!
Hello. Each model is offered in multiple sizes all at different prices which change over time. Current price comparisons would be best found on our website: www.rackattack.com/cargo-boxes/ We do have over 70 videos showing boxes on specific vehicle which many find useful. Here's our cargo carrier playlist (124 videos): th-cam.com/play/PLOSKwRzMz8xzrtUnNN3BAwRh-dnjcYo3b.html Thanks for commenting!
Such outdated ugly designs!