This is their 9th appearance in Immortal Songs 2 but I'm still amazed at how they are able to deliver different yet unique performances. Also, they show improvement every performance. I personally love how they harmonize while Moonbyul raps and their four-part harmonization.
no one is reacting to moon joining in the vocal harmonies .... legit made me scream ...... its so clear that shes adding her voice to it .... it was full before but its thicker now ....OMG I LOVE THIS
Esra Turgut Wheein nin vokal tekniği grup içindeki en iyisi. Keşke Moonbyul da rap yerine vokaline ağırlık verse. Diğer üçü kadar güçlü olmasa da güzel bir sesi var. Bu arada Lee Haeri Immortal Song performanslarını izlemiştim önceden. That Only is My World favorim.Davichi yi dinlerim ama Mamamoo kadar fanı değilim.
Esra Turgut Doğumgünüm 23 Ağustos. Bazı yerlerde Başak veya Aslan olarak geçiyor. Ama daha çok Başak gibiyim sanırım. Mamamoo ve Davichi dışındaki dinlediğim diğer kız grupları Red Velvet,Spica,BlackPink. Erkek gruplarından ise BTS, B1A4,Big Bang,BTOB ve Mamamoo nun kardeş grubu Vromance.
Esra Turgut BTOB yi Mamamoo sayesinde tanıdım. İkisinin beraber Special Stage i vardı. Birbirlerinin şarkılarını coverlamışlardı. Vokallerini çok iyi bulup sevmiştim.K-Pop u yeni dinlemeye başladım. Mamamoo ilk grubum olduğu için onların yeri ben de ayrı. Her albümlerini aldım - pahalı olsada-. Aslında bu da ilk yorumumdu benim. Normalde sadece beğenirdim ama içimden yazmak geldi.
Cathy Tran she knows hot to play with our emotion....when its a sad song...shes like gonna cry when she sing...and when its a sexy song...her expression different...really like her charisma tho
How many times has Mamamoo been on IS2? Eleven? Twelve? What is the most ANY other idol act has appeared on IS2? Once? Twice? Why? Because Mamamoo IS AWESOME!
There is something that has been bothering me, as real moomoo's we know that moonbyul has a really good singing voice. But come on guys she enjoys rapping it's moonbyul's passion. Please stop assuming and feeling bad for her because she 'doesn't have singing lines' , she is not a rapper for nothing, she loves what she does and so do I. I love this performance, I love mamamoo and I wouldn't want to change a thing.
+J Blanco I'm not sure that's quite right. I understood that she auditioned as a singer, but they needed a rapper, so... I've heard several times that she finds it difficult to stand around for a long time doing nothing until her rap comes up (where she's the center of everyone's attention). I'm pretty sure she would very much like to sing more than just the epic harmonies she's a part of. Love and Hate (my jam!) and Paint Me are starting to turn this around.
This is the first time they change their 'formula' and have Solar to open the song (it's usually the maknaes who did). I have to say, it's really nice to hear her lower register (I don't see anyone commenting on this). Wheein, as usual, balancing the performance while Hwasa adds that unique vocal of hers with full emotion that makes me teary. Moonbyul... I know that people will always have a mixed opinion about her rap in ballad songs, but what's great from her rap in this: it's emotional, 'poetic', even. I even thought that her part must be a love confession or something similar... which is somewhat true when I read the translation. It's just like the first time I listened to Love Story of A Girl where I felt that her rap was misplaced and didn't match with the song - but it gets better and better as I listened to it more and read the lyrics. Mamamoo, you've done a great job! Thanks for giving us another great performance here in IS2 :)
Great comment! Sometimes when Moonbyul is rapping emotionally and the other three are trying to sing over her and she persists with her rap it can be the highlight of the song.
Moonbyul has nice vocals too, I feel always adding rap is such a waste! Personally I think rap is also unnecessary, but I guess some people like it. It does suit her image, especially if she has cool moves and smirks like she can 😍. It's a tough job to be a vocalist next to the likes of Celine Dion and Beyonce, but I think she can bring something nice to the mix (and still be cool 😎).
this isn't moonbyul's best rapping tbh... she sometimes seems to have issues with slower songs (i noticed this in their song Draw Draw and Draw) but she totally makes up for it with her harmonizing! solar and wheein's high notes and hwasa's soul are always precious
i always feel bad for moonbyul when they sing another singer's ballad song. as moonbyul fan, i want her to shine more in this kind of performance :" i hope she gain more confidence in singing in the future, because i know her voice is really good.
dinda melinda but compared before we can now actually her her voice in the harmonies. 😊 let's just wait moonbyul unnie might have some surprise in the future.
Love and Hate (Moonbyul's first solo on a Mamamoo album) is my jam! They just released Paint Me and there's no rapping--Moonbyul actually gets to sing some lines!
it was so hard to find the melody with this arrangement, i think they kept adding different instruments and everything didn't overlap as nicely. I still wish the guitar was the main, it sounded so good... their vocals definitely saved it though
rewatching all their performances in immortal songs again while waiting for next week (their 10th appearance) to come... ugh how will i survive from waiting...
Since you already talk about their singing, I just want to talk about Hwasa's outfit. She literally kills it, even she wore the long sleeve backwards 😍
This is beautiful❤ I love it so much but I couldn't help but feel that the rap was a little...out? My queens still slayed tho and I still wish Byulie will sing more when is she ever going to sing more???? Instead of rapping,she should've sang. I love their harmonization and their singing is amazing,even MoonByul's. Maybe she's too shy to sing😅
always proud of the girls, this show is their special stage which proves their quality, never seen any GB dare to perform as often as they do.. *kinda sick of music show chart and awards*
Their vocals never cease to amaze me! 😍 Love the fact that we can also hear Moonbyul in the harmonies as well! But I don't really feel that this song arrangement made the best of their abilities or their unique characters in my personal opinion (it seemed a bit fragmented). But overall, I don't mind if they won or not; they showed us yet another astonishing performance! 👏👏👏
as always, they're singing with passion, their harmonization are great. btw, I Love hwasa's hairstyle here, I wish wheein's bang get a lil bit longer. it would be nice if she has same hairstyle as monbyul.
not their best but considering their heavy promotion of delcacomanie at the time and other events and fan meetings plus prep for concert, they still gave a nice and pretty performance. it was one of those soothing and cleansing type feel of performances. during that time wheein was especially sick out of the 4. mamamoo fighting! rest well and please take care of yourself
I like Mamamoo but i dun really like when they do ballad at IS2. It's bcos it's really hard to insert rap in old songs that do not have rap in it.... moonbyul dun hv that much to do and the rap part will come out awkward. but that's just my opinion
Mamamoo kills it _AGAIN_ ! Is there a gg in Kpop today with better vocals than Mamamoo? Those harmonies just kill me! *Any one of them* could be the Main Singer of any girl group around today. So why hasn't the Radish Empire taken over the world yet?
what I'll say is that hwasa's vocal power was so 100% this time. she sounded air-y? maybe she wanted to match the song cause it's a slower song idk. the rap part was only weird at the beginning cause it clashed with the harmony. moonbyul adding to the harmony at the end tho made me happy cause I wanna hear her sing more. even with these little faults they still sounded good. solar and wheein were amazing as always.
Even though the rap seems misplaced, this perfomance still beautiful af, it's just we set the bar too high for Mamamoo. I think it was the song itself that doesn't do it for me.
I really wish to see Moonbyul sing more in their performances and not just rap and harmonize all the time. I hope she gains more confidence in singing solo parts quick. It's about time she should get recognized as a vocal too not just a rapper. Everyone, not just Moomoos, should know that Moonbyul could actually sing. Fighting Moonstar!!!👊🏼😘
personally it was not one of their Best performances.... solar's high notes helped pull this song through but moonbyul's rap in this song felt a bit misplaced in this.... that's just my unpopular opinion though... don't need no bashing
yep,, i think they didn't have enough preparation for the song,, just want to promote decalcomanie in IS2 this time, hope next time they will slay hard than ever
maybe they didnt have time to rearrange the song because of comeback preparations, they slayed this performance though :) i prefer them doing immortal sogs a lil bit after their comeback because then theyd be able to prepare more awesome performancesss
Nikita Kumari i love moonbyul and thats also one constructive criticism I want her to know. its not the rap feels misplaced but often she still lacks emotional feels to do rap in ballad songs... the only emotional rap ballad I liked from her is in I Miss You :(.
![[Unreleased] SOLE's ＂Always by my side＂ ♬](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ep97cuUoe1E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Kbs world] 불후의명곡 - 마마무, ´두메산골´ 가을밤엔 역시 발라드.20151031](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pXdvBy_4dxo/mqdefault.jpg)
아 너무 잘한다 괜히 마마무 마마무 하는게 아니라구여 내 가수 맘무 사랑하누
와 이 노래 좋은거 알고있었지만 몰입해서 다시 보게 되니까 새삼 좋은거 다시 느끼게 된다...역시 믿고듣는 마마무
ㄹㅇ 마마무는 성대 보험 하나씩 들어놔야된다...
너무잘한다 진짜 목소리도 너무 좋고 화음도 너무좋고 마마무만의 무대 케미도 너무 좋다
This is their 9th appearance in Immortal Songs 2 but I'm still amazed at how they are able to deliver different yet unique performances. Also, they show improvement every performance. I personally love how they harmonize while Moonbyul raps and their four-part harmonization.
no one is reacting to moon joining in the vocal harmonies .... legit made me scream ...... its so clear that shes adding her voice to it .... it was full before but its thicker now ....OMG I LOVE THIS
that's because she's been doing it since debut LOL
I love Mamamoo espicially Whee in.One of the talented groups in K-pop.
Esra Turgut Wheein nin vokal tekniği grup içindeki en iyisi. Keşke Moonbyul da rap yerine vokaline ağırlık verse. Diğer üçü kadar güçlü olmasa da güzel bir sesi var. Bu arada Lee Haeri Immortal Song performanslarını izlemiştim önceden. That Only is My World favorim.Davichi yi dinlerim ama Mamamoo kadar fanı değilim.
Esra Turgut Doğumgünüm 23 Ağustos. Bazı yerlerde Başak veya Aslan olarak geçiyor. Ama daha çok Başak gibiyim sanırım. Mamamoo ve Davichi dışındaki dinlediğim diğer kız grupları Red Velvet,Spica,BlackPink. Erkek gruplarından ise BTS, B1A4,Big Bang,BTOB ve Mamamoo nun kardeş grubu Vromance.
Esra Turgut BTOB yi Mamamoo sayesinde tanıdım. İkisinin beraber Special Stage i vardı. Birbirlerinin şarkılarını coverlamışlardı. Vokallerini çok iyi bulup sevmiştim.K-Pop u yeni dinlemeye başladım. Mamamoo ilk grubum olduğu için onların yeri ben de ayrı. Her albümlerini aldım - pahalı olsada-. Aslında bu da ilk yorumumdu benim. Normalde sadece beğenirdim ama içimden yazmak geldi.
Wheein is just a big ball of awesome!
진짜 휘인님 노래 너무 잘부른다....
3:25 휘인이 “달려갈래요~” 하면서 손 제스처하는 거.. 너무 좋다!!!😍😘
역시 마마무 노래는 언제나 소름 돋을정도로 멋지다👍👍👍👍
뭔가 이때 마마무 그립다..
이 노래 슬퍼잉...ㅠ
I absolutely love Solar and Wheein's harmonization. It's just something special.
one of the better things in life ;)
angel line....that's why they called each other their pillar
솔라 목소리 너무 청아하면서도 힘 있어서 좋다
Solar's voice is not only clear but also powerful. I love her voice 👍👍
wheein's note at 3.39 was the highlight of the song for me :)
휘인 음색 취향저격♡
1:02 홀로 이밤지샐때 이부분 완전 소름돋았다... 너무좋아
이세상에 존재할수있는 가창력인건가요 ;;;;;; 볼때마다 감탄;;;;;;;;
Hwasa's emotion in her singing is so strong
Cathy Tran she knows hot to play with our emotion....when its a sad song...shes like gonna cry when she sing...and when its a sexy song...her expression different...really like her charisma tho
awesome stage presence
The girl's reaction at 4:03 tho. Don't worry you're not alone.
always love them on immortal songs... Solar's high notes though 😍😍😍😍
How many times has Mamamoo been on IS2? Eleven? Twelve?
What is the most ANY other idol act has appeared on IS2? Once? Twice?
Why? Because Mamamoo IS AWESOME!
There is something that has been bothering me, as real moomoo's we know that moonbyul has a really good singing voice. But come on guys she enjoys rapping it's moonbyul's passion. Please stop assuming and feeling bad for her because she 'doesn't have singing lines' , she is not a rapper for nothing, she loves what she does and so do I. I love this performance, I love mamamoo and I wouldn't want to change a thing.
+J Blanco I'm not sure that's quite right. I understood that she auditioned as a singer, but they needed a rapper, so...
I've heard several times that she finds it difficult to stand around for a long time doing nothing until her rap comes up (where she's the center of everyone's attention). I'm pretty sure she would very much like to sing more than just the epic harmonies she's a part of. Love and Hate (my jam!) and Paint Me are starting to turn this around.
im so happy i love them so much
queens
This is the first time they change their 'formula' and have Solar to open the song (it's usually the maknaes who did). I have to say, it's really nice to hear her lower register (I don't see anyone commenting on this). Wheein, as usual, balancing the performance while Hwasa adds that unique vocal of hers with full emotion that makes me teary. Moonbyul... I know that people will always have a mixed opinion about her rap in ballad songs, but what's great from her rap in this: it's emotional, 'poetic', even. I even thought that her part must be a love confession or something similar... which is somewhat true when I read the translation. It's just like the first time I listened to Love Story of A Girl where I felt that her rap was misplaced and didn't match with the song - but it gets better and better as I listened to it more and read the lyrics.
Mamamoo, you've done a great job! Thanks for giving us another great performance here in IS2 :)
Great comment!
Sometimes when Moonbyul is rapping emotionally and the other three are trying to sing over her and she persists with her rap it can be the highlight of the song.
Moonbyul has nice vocals too, I feel always adding rap is such a waste!
Personally I think rap is also unnecessary, but I guess some people like it. It does suit her image, especially if she has cool moves and smirks like she can 😍. It's a tough job to be a vocalist next to the likes of Celine Dion and Beyonce, but I think she can bring something nice to the mix (and still be cool 😎).
감수성 풍부한 뭉스타ㅏ.. 눈발ㄹ개진거바요오ㅠ 자도 이거보고 울엇디ㄴ..는...
웬만한 가수 보다 훨쎈 잘 부르네
화사 개멋짐~~~
wheiin....😍😍😍😍 moonbyul...😘😘😘😘 hwasa...😍😍😍😍😍😍😍solar😘😘😘😘....
Mamamoo ..fighting😍😍😍😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃
wheein
vocal line ❤👍
MAMAMOO AMAZING
solar and Wheein so high notes, WAWWWW...
LOVE U MAMAMOO
WHEEIN 💯%💖
2:45 내가 젤 조아하는 부분..... 그저 눈물뿐...😭
참 태양이네 위로되는목소리들
I just love every single one of their performances. Chills and emotions almost bursted out every time!
MAMAMOO harmony is the most beautiful thing in the world
Even you can hear Moonbyul's low vocie more often now
Solar sounds so good. Her range is 🔥
Wheein 😍😍😍
이게 바로 맘무마맘지
Mamamoo is extraordinary! They have the whole package! ♡♡♡♡
Mamamoo❤️ Solar 💋🙆🏻
Solar voice is like an angel 😍 (Like what we've been expected from Mamamoo 😏)
they sound like angels
yes coz they are an angels 😊
queens of immortal song
Dude, I found one I haven't seen yet! YES!
I came here again since I am rewatching Ep. 13 of What's wrong with Secretary Kim, this song was played there. 역시 마마무 짱!!!
beautiful i cry everytime i love these girls! i love all their immortal songs performances!
this isn't moonbyul's best rapping tbh... she sometimes seems to have issues with slower songs (i noticed this in their song Draw Draw and Draw) but she totally makes up for it with her harmonizing! solar and wheein's high notes and hwasa's soul are always precious
Their harmonies are one of the better things in life
i always feel bad for moonbyul when they sing another singer's ballad song. as moonbyul fan, i want her to shine more in this kind of performance :" i hope she gain more confidence in singing in the future, because i know her voice is really good.
dinda melinda but compared before we can now actually her her voice in the harmonies. 😊 let's just wait moonbyul unnie might have some surprise in the future.
Love and Hate (Moonbyul's first solo on a Mamamoo album) is my jam!
They just released Paint Me and there's no rapping--Moonbyul actually gets to sing some lines!
Also, Moonbyul has some great solo videos! Be sure to check them out.
wheein is queen 💞💞💞💞
yong bae
it was so hard to find the melody with this arrangement, i think they kept adding different instruments and everything didn't overlap as nicely. I still wish the guitar was the main, it sounded so good... their vocals definitely saved it though
SOLAR'S BUILDING TO HER HIGH NOTE GAVE ME CHILLS!!!
😍😍😍 LOVE YOU SO MUCH MAMAMOO
이땐 다들 애기였는데 능숙하게 잘 불렀다
3:40 wheein's high note
2:46 세상은 외롭고 쓸쓸한데 ... 솔라&휘인 화음 들으니까 그 쓸쓸함이 사라지는 것 같다.. 너무 따뜻해...
i love all mamamoo's immortal song perfomance.... always slay...always amazing...never disapponted us... 💖💖
rewatching all their performances in immortal songs again while waiting for next week (their 10th appearance) to come... ugh how will i survive from waiting...
Since you already talk about their singing, I just want to talk about Hwasa's outfit. She literally kills it, even she wore the long sleeve backwards 😍
Look at that savage face my superbias made at 3:41. Her face was like : "Oh, this high note looks hard ? Meh, this is nothing.."
The emotions and harmonies in this performance are just awesome.
Tho this isn't my favorite Immortal Song performance of theirs, they improved so much! Especially Solar, I'm so proud of them :')
amazing as always.... i love all mamamoo's immortal song performace... my queens!!!!
This is beautiful❤ I love it so much but I couldn't help but feel that the rap was a little...out? My queens still slayed tho and I still wish Byulie will sing more when is she ever going to sing more???? Instead of rapping,she should've sang. I love their harmonization and their singing is amazing,even MoonByul's. Maybe she's too shy to sing😅
SX Harmony I believe she doesn't have a lot of confidence in her singing so she prefers to rap. She can sing though and has a pretty sweet voice
Yeah! I love to hear her sing!! If she would just have more confidence she could be a singer-rapper like hwasa😁
For sure!
I think her confidence and/or ability has grown the last few years, so maybe more Byulie vocals in the future?
3:56 I had eargasms listening to Solar's high note.
YOU CAN HEAR MOONBYUL IN THE HARMONIES VERY CLEARLY NOW IT SOUNDS SO COMPLETE
oh my, this gave me so much goosebumps~ Mamamoo are really something else♥
Hope solar is taking care of her health :( she went off pitch a ton in this performance on her upper belts
always proud of the girls, this show is their special stage which proves their quality, never seen any GB dare to perform as often as they do..
*kinda sick of music show chart and awards*
The song was all over the place but the vocals were amazing as always
Their vocals never cease to amaze me! 😍 Love the fact that we can also hear Moonbyul in the harmonies as well! But I don't really feel that this song arrangement made the best of their abilities or their unique characters in my personal opinion (it seemed a bit fragmented). But overall, I don't mind if they won or not; they showed us yet another astonishing performance! 👏👏👏
as always, they're singing with passion, their harmonization are great. btw, I
Love hwasa's hairstyle here, I wish wheein's bang get a lil bit longer. it would be nice if she has same hairstyle as monbyul.
Beautiful heartfelt performance once again for Inmortal Song
not their best but considering their heavy promotion of delcacomanie at the time and other events and fan meetings plus prep for concert, they still gave a nice and pretty performance. it was one of those soothing and cleansing type feel of performances. during that time wheein was especially sick out of the 4. mamamoo fighting! rest well and please take care of yourself
They made me cry everytime they performed
how is it possible that hwasa still looks good with literally a shirt worn backwards?!
I like the beginning. Solar...
I like Mamamoo but i dun really like when they do ballad at IS2. It's bcos it's really hard to insert rap in old songs that do not have rap in it.... moonbyul dun hv that much to do and the rap part will come out awkward. but that's just my opinion
mha she needs more singing parts
They just released Paint Me and there's no rapping--Moonbyul sings several lines. What took them so long?
Mamamoo kills it _AGAIN_ ! Is there a gg in Kpop today with better vocals than Mamamoo? Those harmonies just kill me!
*Any one of them* could be the Main Singer of any girl group around today.
So why hasn't the Radish Empire taken over the world yet?
they released the new mv great job Moomoos for reaching view target! * confetti cannons * I love my fandom waaaaah!
I don't know if I should cry because I can clearly hear Byul harmonizing or because Solar high notes made me see the highly mighty lights
what I'll say is that hwasa's vocal power was so 100% this time. she sounded air-y? maybe she wanted to match the song cause it's a slower song idk. the rap part was only weird at the beginning cause it clashed with the harmony. moonbyul adding to the harmony at the end tho made me happy cause I wanna hear her sing more. even with these little faults they still sounded good. solar and wheein were amazing as always.
mamamoo = peefect match
I cried..
Hwasa is wearing a shirt backwards..... that's all I wanna say
Pd: I love them! Damn!!
Even though the rap seems misplaced, this perfomance still beautiful af, it's just we set the bar too high for Mamamoo. I think it was the song itself that doesn't do it for me.
this is what i call real talent
fuck i cant stop crying
GOOSEBUMPS ALL OVER MY BODY.
thanks 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Even though I can't understand a thing, I'm crying. Because of the emotions.
I really wish to see Moonbyul sing more in their performances and not just rap and harmonize all the time. I hope she gains more confidence in singing solo parts quick. It's about time she should get recognized as a vocal too not just a rapper. Everyone, not just Moomoos, should know that Moonbyul could actually sing. Fighting Moonstar!!!👊🏼😘
good perfomance my queens 😍
YOU CAN HEAR MOONBYUL'S VOICE SO CLEARLY WHEN SHE SINGS ALONG IM CHDBEICJOV
another beautiful performance but I agree with those who think that Moonbyul's rap sounded out of place in the song
personally it was not one of their Best performances.... solar's high notes helped pull this song through but moonbyul's rap in this song felt a bit misplaced in this.... that's just my unpopular opinion though... don't need no bashing
I feel the same and I'm a big mamamoo trash but still love their performance
yep,, i think they didn't have enough preparation for the song,, just want to promote decalcomanie in IS2 this time, hope next time they will slay hard than ever
maybe they didnt have time to rearrange the song because of comeback preparations, they slayed this performance though :) i prefer them doing immortal sogs a lil bit after their comeback because then theyd be able to prepare more awesome performancesss
I know right cause they has so much work to carry maybe no enough time to prepare
Nikita Kumari i love moonbyul and thats also one constructive criticism I want her to know. its not the rap feels misplaced but often she still lacks emotional feels to do rap in ballad songs... the only emotional rap ballad I liked from her is in I Miss You :(.
At first they have no attention because the korean said they ugly even they're talent but with me they're most beautiful girls
😍💞
Wheein fooled me thought she was Bomi in the thumbnail 😅
Feeda H they have the same bangs style! Hahaha.. and both rock it.
😍😍
😍❤️❤️❤️