@@normannjnj it's all on her mind I swear. There are moments where her voice transports to another eras. I'm not denying her voice maturing with age, but her flexibility and the way she dodges some notes is all on her mind
I would really love to see her make records like this again. she’s had years and years of successful pop radio hits, now it’s time to get back to that soul that started it all on those first two records❤️❤️
It’s not like it was then. She was apart of a golden age that hadn’t yet had the internet or social media. No one could just sell 30 million records anymore.
She's so competitive... She really tries to give people their money's worth, again and again for decades. Consistency and longevity are attributes of greatness. Thank you Mariah ❤️
I grew up listening to Mariah, young Mariah. Back then, we all were young and strong! I have aged, all of us have, too, Mariah has, too! This performance brought tears to my eyes, I just remembered mom, being at home, listening to Mariah on the radio. Thank you Mariah for every single lyric you have shared with us. The sentiment you transmit is simply unique. God bless you.
Her tone on those lower notes are so good. I was just listening to a live version from the 90s and she does this part with a rounder/fuller sound now 2:36
I think so. Normally when she lipsynchs, the volume of the lipped parts would sound thinner or lighter in tone, unlike the live parts which often sound fuller and raspy similar to her speaking tone.
No disrespect, but no she does not. Her voice is so beat up now. She can’t hold notes, she’s very breathy, changed the keys because she no longer can hit high notes with ease. I love her music very much but she isn’t the same vocally.
@@mrdanielaiello I agree but she has some peaks in her voice in recent performances.. she’s been singing with nodules since childhood and as she ages so does her voice from drinking and childbirth but I think if she underwent vocal training for the current state of her voice she could please her fans and she has to sing in lower keys that aren’t so demanding
@@justinsenior8264 perfectly said! 2020 alone prove Mariah still has it. She was on fire every performance. She needs to get a vocal coach that helps her sing around her nodules while preserving her voice. Rest and stop touring so damn much.
What I will always appreciate about her artsy is her ability to always create a new melody or vocal line when her voice isn’t doing what she wants these notes to changes are everything
I ❤ me some MC. Her vocal approach to her songs are a treat when you know the original and understand where the adjustments are. This live version is really good.
There you are holding her hand I am lost Dying to understand Didn't I cherish you right Don't you know you were my life Even though I try I can't let go Something in your eyes Captured my soul And every night I see you in my dreams You're all I know I can't let go Just cast aside You don't even know I'm alive You just walk on by Don't care to see me cry And here I am Still holding on I can't accept My world is gone, no no Even though I try I can't let go Something in your eyes Captured my soul And every night I see you in my dreams You're all I know I can't let go Do you even realize the sorrow I have inside Everyday of my life Do you know the way it feels When all you have just dies I try and try to deny that I need you But still you remain on my mind No I just can't get you out of my mind I never can say goodbye 'Cause every night I see you in my dreams You're all I know I can't let you go Even though I try I can't let go, of something I need so badly You're all I know I can't let go
Ive never heard The live version of ' Without You " with outro" Butterfly " " Without You * was originally released in 1993 during my highschool years, thank you for posting this ❤
Why did she not sing this song live for so many years? We never got to hear it live in music box or daydream era. Why did she not sing it at the Proctors concert for the DVD? One of her best ballads.
She touched my heart. She still got it I was waiting for the whistle and I'm happy she still can do it after all these years. I remembered when that song came out I kept that song on repeat lol
Mariah, it’s you but not you. You have been my life. Live your true life. Be true to yourself way above your expectations, other’s expectations, and your ego. Please, you’ve got this talent. Share your authentic self.
I created my own hell To fix it. I knew exactly what I would go through to fix World and human problems. That's what a divine god warrior angel king leader does. Go through hell and pain and all demons and darkness life can bring when Satan interferes But no more my job is Complete my law and life of happiness begins with you all
Yes it is, you can tell because it isn't as high anymore and less airy as well. Probably the few high notes she can continue to sing (and not just hit), the whole song was arranged for her to not go into the high ones, I guess she left them for the climax. Sounded great anyway.
Comeback here after listening to her 2024 performance and I miss 2019-20riah🥹
Her recent 2024 vocals are much healthier than before
@@britneyfan9270 idk. She sounds really bad these days lmao
@@mofuryan can you name the performance lol cause maybe you're thinking of 2022
this lower key arrangement is everything. Mariah mastered that haunting soulful sultry genre of music she PRODUCED.
The language of FACTS!!
I’ve been searching for her live performances of this song, but there is something special about this one. Definitely my favorite.
I feel this is the worst. Arsenio hall and unplugged were way better
@@tripe9719 Age. She's not 23 years old anymore.
I guess no one can keep his/her voice as same as 30 years ago, she's still marvelous 💖
@@tripe9719 u definitely don’t understand. It’s the best for me too
you need to watch her performance of this song on soul train! to me it was the best.
Man, I was there that night. A moment I'll never forget. Wonderful voice and concert.
Lucky u
Whew! That “my soul” at 2:16 sounded just like 90s mariah. I wish she didn’t hold back that much and would be more confident! She never lost it!
Man your tone deaf!
It sounds exactly like that!!
OMG!! I say the same thing!! She’s lost her confidence and I just wish she get that back. She still has it
@@normannjnj it's all on her mind I swear. There are moments where her voice transports to another eras. I'm not denying her voice maturing with age, but her flexibility and the way she dodges some notes is all on her mind
I would really love to see her make records like this again. she’s had years and years of successful pop radio hits, now it’s time to get back to that soul that started it all on those first two records❤️❤️
It’s not like it was then. She was apart of a golden age that hadn’t yet had the internet or social media. No one could just sell 30 million records anymore.
She’s always had soulful records after this. You’re obviously not a real fan if you think the soul & conviction has left her music
@@capcomfighter13 her music went downhill when she went urban. The adult contemporary stuff like this is her best work.
She’s been singing soul you’re just not listening
@@jaydel3 you mean “Black” because wtf is “urban”?
She's so competitive...
She really tries to give people their money's worth, again and again for decades.
Consistency and longevity are attributes of greatness.
Thank you Mariah ❤️
I grew up listening to Mariah, young Mariah. Back then, we all were young and strong! I have aged, all of us have, too, Mariah has, too! This performance brought tears to my eyes, I just remembered mom, being at home, listening to Mariah on the radio. Thank you Mariah for every single lyric you have shared with us. The sentiment you transmit is simply unique. God bless you.
Her tone on those lower notes are so good. I was just listening to a live version from the 90s and she does this part with a rounder/fuller sound now 2:36
Obsessed with see u in my dream x2 at 3:14
Her mind 😭😭
Who is still listening to this on 2024!? 🥰
One of my favorite songs from Mariah!!!!👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Yasss I am, it's 11:19 pm September 1 2024. ❤
I am 😊😮❤
3:15 - rock and roll hall of fame induction for that alone
30 years and still gives me all the chills ❤️👏👏👏
she has the special touch that makes every song special!
I'm crying, I don't know how to expalin. Mariah has te power to change music into sentiments.
Wow those raw vocals😍😍🚀
Yeah she did awesome ❤
One of my favorite performances of this song. Im living for the rasp & belts! N i love when she improvises 😍💙🦋 2021
Agreed
I still prefer the buttery 1991 tone but it's quite obvious Mariah didn't lose her voice and all the other made up crap!!
Totally live and totally beautiful ❤❤❤❤❤
100% live
I think so. Normally when she lipsynchs, the volume of the lipped parts would sound thinner or lighter in tone, unlike the live parts which often sound fuller and raspy similar to her speaking tone.
@@giocaliguia8370 exactly
Mariah, if you ever see this: you still got it and more! Love you!
So I prefer this to the studio version 🥺😍
She still got it .... yasssss Mariah
Girl stop lying. This vocal performance was a train 🚂. wreck.
@@shannonbegood587 stfu bc after 30 yrs in the industry she probably can sing better than u even on a bad day
No disrespect, but no she does not. Her voice is so beat up now. She can’t hold notes, she’s very breathy, changed the keys because she no longer can hit high notes with ease. I love her music very much but she isn’t the same vocally.
@@mrdanielaiello I agree but she has some peaks in her voice in recent performances.. she’s been singing with nodules since childhood and as she ages so does her voice from drinking and childbirth but I think if she underwent vocal training for the current state of her voice she could please her fans and she has to sing in lower keys that aren’t so demanding
@@justinsenior8264 perfectly said! 2020 alone prove Mariah still has it. She was on fire every performance. She needs to get a vocal coach that helps her sing around her nodules while preserving her voice. Rest and stop touring so damn much.
2:38 so much more fullness to that low note than in her prime.
and its a full tone lowered too
Great ear!
@@westanmariahI didn’t even think about that! Good point.
What I will always appreciate about her artsy is her ability to always create a new melody or vocal line when her voice isn’t doing what she wants these notes to changes are everything
I ❤ me some MC. Her vocal approach to her songs are a treat when you know the original and understand where the adjustments are. This live version is really good.
Wow. Surprised she went for it at the end. She's given us so much and more and for so long! Thank you Mariah.
The end whistle reminds me of the opening in Dreamlover
Miss her LIVE performances like this
Still so resonant!!!
Queen Mariah!!!❤️❤️❤️
And the whistle at the end is sooooo perfect omg!!!!
I wonder if she still sees him in her dreams after all these years..
Deep ❤️
@@jacobplaylists yes
90s vibe omg
There you are holding her hand
I am lost
Dying to understand
Didn't I cherish you right
Don't you know you were my life
Even though I try I can't let go
Something in your eyes
Captured my soul
And every night I see you in my dreams
You're all I know
I can't let go
Just cast aside
You don't even know I'm alive
You just walk on by
Don't care to see me cry
And here I am
Still holding on
I can't accept
My world is gone, no no
Even though I try I can't let go
Something in your eyes
Captured my soul
And every night I see you in my dreams
You're all I know
I can't let go
Do you even realize the sorrow I have inside
Everyday of my life
Do you know the way it feels
When all you have just dies
I try and try to deny that I need you
But still you remain on my mind
No I just can't get you out of my mind
I never can say goodbye
'Cause every night
I see you in my dreams
You're all I know
I can't let you go
Even though I try
I can't let go, of something I need so badly
You're all I know
I can't let go
This whistle Is PERFECTION !!!
She was FEELING IT!
Baby I was waiting to see if she was going to hit that famous whistle and SHE DID! For those that say she lost it. No dahling lol
2:41 ALTO QUEEN!! DURING HER CAREER SHE SHOWED US EVERY OF VOICE TIPES, SOPRANO, MEZZO, ALTO!❤❤
I love u Mariah
MC, Goddess of all music, forever
Her greatest song by far...♥️
one of my fav’s song. ❤️❤️❤️
I love you. Sarang hae
The SOUL at 2:18 made me stop doing my makeup and look down at my phone and rewind! Touched my soul 🥺😍💕❤️
Great memory for her, after writing all of those songs she stills remembers what album and her it was😊, I’m sure sometimes she forgets. Love U MC!!
Considering a live performance, this is a great one according to her recent vocals. Many Thanks for sharing it this is a great moment.
I don't wanna cryとCan't let goでマライアにハマりました！
大人の音楽に憧れた13歳でした。
Ive never heard The live version of ' Without You " with outro" Butterfly " " Without You * was originally released in 1993 during my highschool years, thank you for posting this ❤
Yesss, Mariah! Legendary diva!👏👏👏👏👏👏
The improvises in this performance are so nice.. i keep revisiting this very often ❤️
This song deserves to be a number one record facts
you can say mariah voice is decline but you you cannot say that her whistle is gone coz it is still powerful like emotion era
Yas!! DARLING Slay it!
Perfect live
i never thought that she still got her whistle after decades and still even now...
Yess slay it mariah Carey
This is my favorite song 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
One of the greatest voices of all time
I love this song, and those background singers are smashing.
That intro tho 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽
Still got it girl!!! 🙌🏻💪🏻 my favorite song 😍
Why did she not sing this song live for so many years? We never got to hear it live in music box or daydream era. Why did she not sing it at the Proctors concert for the DVD? One of her best ballads.
2:17 “ my soooooouuuuuull …. “ 😮
Just a little bit different from the early 90s MTV Unplugged version . . .
😲
Just amazing! What a great performance
How beautiful,
I love her
INCREDIBLE 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Mind blowing!
Beautiful
She touched my heart. She still got it I was waiting for the whistle and I'm happy she still can do it after all these years. I remembered when that song came out I kept that song on repeat lol
Mariah, it’s you but not you. You have been my life. Live your true life. Be true to yourself way above your expectations, other’s expectations, and your ego. Please, you’ve got this talent. Share your authentic self.
Plz make a 90s album
How is nobody here talking about 3:15?
Loved that part.
One of best performance of this beauty song.
Greetinga from #Venezuela
Amazriah Carey
I love you BABY! Very beautiful song.
Bravo 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
La mejor artista de todos los tiempos , hermosa MARIAH !
Incredible
THE MUSIC CONASUIER CLASSIC MARIAH CAREY,WE ALL HAVE BEEN THERE PERIOD! 3:58 4:01
Amazing ❤️
I enjoy her background vocals
I love her ❤️
As antigas são as melhores
Sangin
F...YES!
Well done!!!
Perfection 🥰
Diva🎶🎵🎼🎧🎤
Unty Mariah is very good singger
I created my own hell
To fix it.
I knew exactly what I would go through to fix
World and human problems.
That's what a divine god warrior angel king leader does.
Go through hell and pain and all demons and darkness life can bring when Satan interferes
But no more my job is
Complete my law and life of happiness begins with you all
Perfect 💚💛🧡
🦋
Am crazy with voice
omg compare this performance to the 8th july one (butterfly returns) you can hear her vocal is brighter
Love you ❤️
احبك ميمي ❤
Que belleza ❤️
2:32
Wow
3:44 😍😍
She pretty
Still sounds good ❤️❤️❤️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐💫🤩🪴🌸🩸
this whistle is live?
Yes it is, you can tell because it isn't as high anymore and less airy as well. Probably the few high notes she can continue to sing (and not just hit), the whole song was arranged for her to not go into the high ones, I guess she left them for the climax. Sounded great anyway.