Yeah, not that I feel old but it's weird that I watched this in theatres (like I was old enough almost 20 years ago to actually see this in theatres). God bless everyone.
If the Spinosaurus and Roberta (the T.Rex) ever do meet, I think they'll just pass each other and won't fight at all. This'll symbolize how people should move on from it.
I'm worried people are going to be too persistent regarding the rematch anyhow. Its understandable why they want it, but I feel like what's done is done.
@@mystic_bat8442 Problem is that Horner is actually wrong about that lmao. As a great of a paleontologist he is, the T-Rex is built as an apex predator, and has had clear evidence that it hunts.
@@mystic_bat8442 At this point, tho, even Horner himself has stopped believing the Scavenger theory (He's said so himself). He only bring it up to troll other Paleontologists. But, yeah. The dude hates Tyrannosaurus. Not sure why tho
@@VelociraptorsOfSkyrim In reality, the T-Rex was a really successful hunter and was indeed a killer. Often killing each other or other “apex” predators in their area. The T-Rex would have truly killed the Spinosaurus if he had followed the facts rather than his feelings on the creature -_- He should have used a Carnotaurus or the Ceratosaurus for a more accurate depiction of the events. Then again, Jurassic Park/World doesn’t follow logic and reality. Everyone knows the Spinosaurus was a hybrid. The Indominus, Indoraptor, and dinosaurs even being a thing are enough. And the movie T-Rex broke bones by shaking rather than simply biting like a real T-Rex.
I wonder why they still used him as the paleontology consultant for Jurassic films... As much as his claims regarding Tyrannosaurus, he might have the right idea about Stygimoloch being a juvie stage of Pachycephalosaurus
Whilst i do think that the whole backlash against this fight got blown way too out of proportion, this whole trend of having the fan-favorite thing being killed by a new "cooler" version is hella stupid and needs to stop cause it literally never works. It didn't work when they replaced Optimus Prime with Rodimus Prime, didn't work with the Spino, and also didn't work with the new Dalek Paradigm on Doctor Who It always backfires
Also Predator and then Terminator, its just so damn overused and lazy to just make em bigger and beefier and kill the original shamefully every damn time. Its like they have no sense of loyalty to stick with it.
And this has alsp happened in between companys and thier main franchises protagonist where they make one look cooler to make the competition look outdated for example. Mickey Mouse vs Bugs bunny. Marvel and DC Mario vs Sonic
Regarding Doctor Who: The idea was good. The new pure Daleks destroying the old impure ones makes a lot of sense. Even the way it happens was pretty well written. What made it suck was the design of the new Daleks.
i mean i didn't watch the things you mentioned in your comment besides jp3, but i way prefer the spino over the T-rex and also liked watching the spino defeating the T-rex
*chad hybrid spinosaurus* Chad: Killed T-Rex on his prime Hás ability to fast heal Could resistence alot of guns make life live hell of humans and raptors Vs *Virgin indominus rex* Virgin Bullet prove skin Camo easy mod Talks in dinosuar dna mostly killed granny rexy *Sorry about the joke*
Its clear from the film what they were trying to do. This fight is kind of like how wrestling promotions work. if you have a new guy coming in and you want to show that this new guy needs to be taken seriously to the audience you have one of your establish stars put them "over" by losing. That basically what happened The Spino was the new guy into the franchise and they wanted him to be a big threat. So they establish if early on by having the T-Rex take the loss, to basically tell the audience. This new guy is a big deal. Just a story telling deceive, don't know why people get so upset.
Its because lots of people were attached to Tyrannosaurus rex the most. I was a year old around the time of Jurassic Park 3, which was 2001. I didnt have a reaction much, as it was the movie that got me into Jurassic Park in the first place.
Cause it could've worked had they not have the fight at all. Showing the Spino brutally wreck an airplane in seconds with it's arms and bulky body. The rex vs spino fight doesn't add anything to the plot at all other than the directors wanting to jack themselves off in front of the old fans.
@@TheGhost-rp3ko its one of the only carnivore fights in the series and the best scene in JP3. It's just 1 trex that died and ppl act like they went extinct. It lost. And a rex wouldve lost again in JW if Blue hadn't saved the day. In wildlife lions get killed by hyenas sometimes. Despite being the kinf of the jungle they still get wrecked from time to time. Ppl need to get over it. The tyrannosaurus can be killed by a larger carnivore especially an intelligent hybrid like Indominus.
I think you’re totally right, Klayton. I mean, if you actually look at the fight in the film, they’re roughly the same size. I’m with you though, the fight never really bothered me personally, I know they wanted to focus on a new threat for the movie, and I was excited to see a new big bad. Spinosaurus wasn’t a super well known animal either, back then, so to see a new fairly unknown dinosaur in JP was really exciting, at least for me. I loved the T. Rex, but we had a lot of it the previous two films, I’m glad they went in a little different direction. That all being said though, yes, I think the way they handled to fight could’ve been a little more respectful to the Rex and the fans. The fight was pretty abrupt, the Spino basically shows up and kills the Rex. So I definitely get some of the anger from fans. Had they made the fighter a little longer, and a little more balanced, and even, Idk, made the fight a draw, or have the Rex give the Spino a serious wound.. I think that would’ve gone a long way as far as fans were concerned.
A little late but I totally agree what you said. 20 years ago I was upset too but I got over it for two reasons: One the writers wanted to introduce the new "Big bad" and went better introduction than the clap the previous big bad. Still salty but I understand. Plus spinosaurus is clearly larger and longer than jp3 T-Rex. You would think in nature size matters a lot sometimes more than smarts and agility. Plus there was a moment when the T-Rex left himself wide open for the spinosaurus to deliver a lethal counter. So again I'm still salty by how abrupt the fight was I can accept it because the Rex left himself open and the spinosaurus is clearly larger and stronger.
Spinosaurus: "I was the only one to kill a T-rex not raptors, not humans, and damn sure not that Indominus Rex, ME!!!!!! and do i get any recognition for it? NO!!!!! They just put me as a skeleton just for the T-rex to run through, to hell wit em!!!!!" Bartender: alright Spiny i think you had a lil too much to drink........
The Rex vs Spino fight is the LEAST problematic part of that movie. I actually was shocked and went "damn, if THAT THING took down a Rex, God help the poor people on that island."
@@leongaming9834 Jack Horner, a paleontologist who had a retarded theory that Tyrannosaurus was primarily a scavenger, was a consultant for JP3. It's very possible his biased views on Trex may have influenced the direction of the film.
I'd actually be fine with a rematch, but it SHOULDN'T be a 30 second fight and instead an actual epic showdown. I also am hesitant of the Spinosaurus biting the dust; but if it already got enough screentime in JW Dominion, I'm fine with it dying
Yeah but it doesn’t feel the same like when the T. rex killed the Carno or the Raptors. Think about this what if u were a Carno fanboy and u where really angry that the T Rex killed the Carno so easily without a fight. Then in JWD a Carno just destroys a T Rex skeleton and roars. Wouldn’t it be more satisfying and vengeful for a Carno to kill a T Rex with a awesome fight? P.S. I am not a Carno Fanboy I am just using this as an example
@@jaimepennington1120 but logically a trex would destroy a carno with a single bite. However a spinosaurus beating a trex in 30 seconds is full of bull because the trex is the icon of jurassic park. That's what made fans mad.
And by easily you mean that the Spino animatronic breaking the T Rex animatronic before thw battle really began? Honestly if they went into deeper lore at the time of the Spino being a hybrid (which would most likely give it am edge) and gave us an actual fight and not a one-sided slaughter, I almost guarantee that no matter who would of won, it would have been a great moment of the series.
To me, I don’t really think a rematch between the T.Rex and Spinosaurus is really necessary, cause I feel like Jurassic World already made up for that by having the T.Rex break through the Spinosaurus skeleton and fight the Indominus Rex.
And there are spinosaurus fans so if they do a rematch they’re going to have to make the tea Rex win because then the tea Rex fans will get even more mad but then the spinosaurus fans will be mad it’s just a never ending cycle of pain for everyone
@@primebg1467 yes. Because that's totally a valid reason for the spino to lose. Being qaudrupedal. What is supposed to be your point here? A triceratops would steam roll a T. Rex in real life. Just like most quadrupedal dinosaurs would from the rexes time.
@@primebg1467 and there is no way the spino could walk on all 4's since its wrists would snap. And it can't flatten it's hands because it's a therapod. All therapods hands aren't functional except for hunting and stabbing fish.
I have the official "behind-the-scenes" version of that poster! In Canada, Burger King was giving them out when JP3 first came out. I still wouldn't have the JP3 fight any other way. Rexy's comeback in JW was so great, partly BECAUSE of how the T-Rex was used in JP3! Fans wanted better for the T-Rex, and we got it! If the fight in JP3 was different, we might not have the epic JW fight today!
I love this perspective. When it looked like Queen Rexy was gonna bite it in JW a lot of people (myself included) were thinking “Oh fuck not again” Likewise the Spino skeleton smash wouldn’t have had as much impact were it not used as a Fuck-you to JP3, at best it would be a nod to the museum display getting destroyed in the original JP movie
Honestly seems like splitting hairs for those who insist the T.rex was "way smaller". The Spinosaurus was also downsized in the size chart and a 37 foot long T.rex is only going to be marginally smaller than a 40 foot one of comparable build. Klayton's right on the money here.
Nah. The JP3 Spinosaurus was of intended size (different from the real one). Its been given 43'9 all the way to 46 feet because the maquette has a curved tail vs the CGI's straightened tail.
I always thought of it as Rexy being at the peak of her size or unnaturally large because she was well fed and kept on its own. The Sorna rexes were just more "naturally grown" in about the same size range as the living rex
@@kennethsatria6607 That's not always how natural size works with wild animals. Often heights and lengths between captive and wild animals are comparable, but weights will vary.
I just think the creators of JP3 wanted to make a new dinosaur look bigger and badder for a new generation of jurqssic park fans than the same ole trex
I've been on that size chart for years now. It's legit (at least Spino, T-Rex and Raptor). The maquette Tyrannosaurus (yes, that includes Rexy) is meant to represent the theoretical full scale of an over 36 feet long and almost 15 feet tall animal. Angry fans have accused those dimensions to be that of a subadult because they choose not to see Spino being intended as "Bigger than T-Rex" Edit: I know of the 40+ foot listing of T.Rex but I take that as in-universe visual approximacy. Believe me, before I learned of JP1 Rex's real size I also was sold on it being 40 feet long. The chart doesn't do its size justice.
@@tnb4509 44 feet is Rexy's size from 22 years of nonstop growth (Jurassic World onwards). Definitely based on reptiles' tendency to grow throughout their lives. Edit: I just realized. Since Spielberg had the tendency to upscale his dinos for more wow factor, maybe the JP Rexes were 40 feet in universe. They just give the 37-foot animatronics more close-up to fulfill this illusion.
@@tnb4509 Maybe or maybe not. It depends on whether Spinosaurus will come out of Universal's creature purgatory, let alone get an official size chart. Well, if he does appear, there is a chance that the producers will acknowledge the real-life Spinosaurus length of 50 feet.
@@paolopasaol9700 hey i know this is VERY late. But if you see this mind telling where you got that information that the maquet was scaled to a 36 ft long animal?
As a kid in 2001, I never saw the issue with the Spino. When Alan said it was something bigger than the Rex, I just took into consideration that there are dinosaurs bigger and worse than the T.Rex. I never got upset that it killed the mascot for the franchise as a result.
Uh, guys, Tyrannosaurus would have crushed Spinosaurus rather easily in real life. THAT's the problem with the battle. But, that aside, don't forget the other, perhaps the main issue: you don't build up this epic confrontation between 2 badasses to get people into the theater, then, cheat them with a few seconds of one killing the other with hardly a struggle.
Great video on the T. rex that got terminated from Jurassic Park III. I know how you feel about the T. rex vs Spinosaurus fight in Jurassic Park III but I was very disappointed with the fight as well because Jack Horner made the Spinosaurus more powerful than the Rex in Jurassic Park III. If anything, it’s all Jack Horner’s fault for this chaotic mess of the Spinosaurus and T. rex fight. Great video Klayton Fioriti and as always, Take It Easy and Life Finds A Way.
@@aryshandono3249 Horner hates T.Rex because he's a fan of duckbilled dinosaurs but he kept finding T.Rex fossils instead of duckbills. And he's also sick and tired of how overrated T.Rex is, so he dedicated his whole life to trolling paleontologists and dino fans alike with the scavenger theory, a theory that not even he believes, he just hates T.Rex THAT much. XD
@@cintronproductions9430 Well, can't blame him. T-Rex was the apex predator of North America in the Late Cretaceous and pretty well known thanks to how abundant its remains are :3 But I'm starting to think while it has not yet appeared in that many films (but plenty in video games), Spinosaurus has also become somewhat overrated
Wow! Early comment! I just wanted to say that you’re the best and have helped me fuel my interest in Jurassic Park and because of you I’m reading all of Michael Crichton’s books. Thank you Klayton!
4:49 that Rex came out of nowhere! I would love to see a scene like that in Dominion, where someone is tranqing a dino and another passes by at the worst moment. Great video though!
I'm a 2000s kid and I have to admit the JP franchise was one of my favorites growing up,I had the box with all of the movies 1-3 collectors edition with the wooden doors as the cover.😁😄
I always thought that the DVD size chart was made to further show how bigger the Spino is rather than making a retcon of sorts to appease fans. That being said, what always caught my attention was the moment when the Rex almost steps on Alan. You can see his foot is smaller than that of the female Rex from TLW (whose foot almost crushed Carter completely). This makes me wonder if the female Rexes ("Rexy" and "Doe") are actually bigger than males. Anyway, the fight scene in JP3 never bothered me. I liked they chose another species as the main predator, and the Spino was a cool choice that added more variety to the franchise.
Resizing the T-Rex has to be the most accurate accident the JP Franchise ever did. As of now, the most recent estimations of the Spinosaurus (the biggest specimen, MSNM V4047) is still smaller compared to the likes of Sue and Scotty
@@ahahaha6228 Look up Sue and Scotty's latest size and mass estimates and compare it with the biggest confirmed Spino's (MSNM V4047) latest estimates (as close to 2020 as possible. You'll see what I'm talking about.
Three things: 1. Horner most likely made the spino win because he hates T-rexs (yes he has said that publicly) 2. Theres no point in arguing because the two would have never fought in the first place (and even if they did there is a probability of Rex wining, because it is better built to fight other dinosaurs, not because its a t-rex) 3.(This was said by someone else) But I think it would be nice if the trex and spino met and didn't fight, it would symbolize that people need to move on. If the spino dies it should be to humans, not the T-rex.
I remember watching the tv spots of jp3 & my jaw dropped like "the t.rex actually dies?!". The whole fight did angered me as a kid ( a little bit now as an adult ). Don't get me wrong spinosaurus is a cool dinosaur , but t.rex will always be #1 imo.
I am very excited to see how Jurassic World: Dominion turns out. I hope to see a very compelling story line, great performances from both the actors and the Dinosaurs (CGI and animatronic), and I hope to have a thrilling time watching it in general.
Why not Acrocanthosaurus? At least its moderate height spine would make it look a little bit different. Plus, that dinosaur hasn't appeared in any film, me thinks
@@aryshandono3249 i would love to see a proper Acrocanthosaurus in a film or series get respect and love it is actually believed that the spines were holding muscles together and added bulk to the animal in other words in an accurate Acrocanthosaur we would mot see any exposed spine at all, no more than in normal vertebrates like bison. The Acrocanthosaurus was a very large and powerfully built animal, it is shown this way in JW Evolution demonstrating a much bulkier body and build to it.
So glad this channel exists, klayton (imo at least) is on the same level as star wars theory in terms of passion and care for a franchise and the fans. Happy to have stumbled upon this to highten my knowledge on one of my favorite franchises.
Size chart Rex in pre-production looks about the same size as the DVD release. I think the perceived difference is just the power of suggestion because the Rex has the sub-adult label on it and the Ankylosaurus is between the Rex and Spino in the DVD release (unlike the pre-production chart which is less spaced out and has a Galli or something between them, but close enough that the Rex is right on the Spino’s tail), making it more difficult to tell. Edit: also you can tell they’ve only applied the label and kept the size the same if you compare the size to the Para. In both images the Rex is slightly larger than it.
Firstly, I love your videos. Secondly I have to point out it wasn't remotely how as you suggested with the Star Wars analogy. Everyone acts like it killed off "THE" T. Rex, but it killed "A" T. Rex. A rex we've never seen before. I would understand somewhat if it killed Rexy but it was a random one. You're right about the Rex being an adult though. That was always the intention. Spino was just supposed to be a very powerful animal and that's all there is to it. He made for a very entertaining dinosaur and since JP3 he has remained on my top spot of favourite dino in the franchise. They did a great job with him and the film was good fun. He didn't replace the T. Rex like everyone suggests, he just kills a random one. Admittedly the fight wasn't as good as it should have been but that's because the Spino animatronic destroyed the rex animatronic, so they had no choice but to do it in CGI due to scheduling.
I always thought that the T-Rex in JW3 was a fully grown adult and that the Spino won the fight because of its hands allowing it to grab the Rex and break its neck. The Spino did get bitten on the neck but, since it was described as a "super predator", InGen must've designed it to have greater resistance to damage. I only became aware of the controversy surrounding the Rex vs Spino fight about 6 years ago. The size chart thing comes across as damage control.
@@Black_Wolf1357 it's not. They have came out and said it's not fully grown, but I'm pretty sure it was meant to be fully grown when the scene was shot. Just excuses to keep people happy. Or semi happy.
@@eglorious-yt it's confirmed fully grown, they never mentioned or listed not fully grown once, only fans said it as an excuse and not only that but it's also confirmed and canon that the spinosaurus is more ferocious and more nastier than the trexes on sorna, so saying the trex not fully grown wouldn't make sense.
@@Black_Wolf1357 I have seen otherwise. Maybe I am wrong. Will have to check again, but I remember somewhere some official Jp3 thing said for it to not be fully grown. Look I 100% agree with you. I think it's really stupid. I think people should move on seeing as the next 3 films basically licked the Trex's ass.
@@eglorious-yt I never heard any interviews or commentaries or behind the scenes or Twitter or Instagram etc. not once it was ever mentioned not fully grown, it's listed full grown bull trex on the last script and also on the jp3 Novel that was made a year after the film.
To be honest I don’t care for the outcome of that fight, I just remember seeing that scene for the first time and thinking that the spinosaurus was awesome
That would be a bad idea. Rexy in her prime vs the jp3 spino is more fair cuz rexy will just get killed off by that behemoth due to rexy being very old to fight
I agree, the Trex was fully grown and I Support the Spinosaurus. #TeamSpinosaurus, I just wish that it returned in Dominion and fought the Giga with the T-rex....
I seriously just don't get why this scene caused such a big stink. It was a cool fight, the spino really was bigger than the rex (its not a fictional character like Godzilla) and one rex going down doesn't mean that they would lose that matchup every time.
Huh. I always went with the whole '"JP3 T-Rex is a subadult' theory for a long time. As always, you've done a good job of giving me stuff to think about. :) And personally, the 'Spino vs. T-Rex' fight scene NEVER rubbed me the wrong way even when I was 10 years old and saw "JP3" on the big screen for the first time, mainly because I'm a *paleontology* fan as well as a "JP/JW" fan, so I can respect and like Spinosaurus for the *animal* that it is. The fact that some "Jurassic" fans out there haven't gotten over that one "JP3" scene is what bothers me, NOT the scene itself. It's like 'LET IT GO, PEOPLE! It's just a *MOVIE!'* Sheesh. I really don't understand why some people take films like the "JP/JW" or "Star Wars" films so seriously. It's THAT kind of attitude that, *IMO,* RUINED the "Star Wars" sequel trilogy (which I personally feel are *OK, ENJOYABLE* films). Of course, this is just me talking.
I think your theory is solid. After all, JP3 was hastily put together mid production so I can believe that the outcome was no different. I also believe that they should've gone for the epic climatic style they were advertising for the fight so it would add more to mystery of the Spino and at least give the t rex a chance to go down fighting. Oh well, no point in crying over spilled milk.
Actually Klayton, after the release of JP3, every kid in my school LOVED the Spinosaurus including me. It was a cooler and more dominant dinosaur. We even said it's like a real life Godzilla since it can swim lol.
@@loveInvincible6400 it is still quite popular though. Have you seen how many people say their favorite dinosaur is Spino in many dinosaur fan communities? Or in Klayton's videos?
@@aryshandono3249 Doesn't matter. That fight with the T Rex is what hurt the Spinosaurus. Now that further research was made Jack Horner even had to admit he was wrong about the fight.
A frivolous children's movie will not determine the power of a greater creature, even if it defeats him in the movie, because that duck will not be able to raise its head in front of a T-Rex in the real world.
Hey guys in dominan there is gonna be spinosaurus also it's the jp3 spino is back and it's gonna be a full grown adult!!!! It's the same jp3 spino now in the dominian he is a full grown adult now!!!
Yeah, I’m with you. I...never really cared that much. The spinosaurus is one of my favorite dinosaurs in Jurassic Park, even if the movie it’s in is admittedly not a great movie. To me, the dinosaurs in Jurassic Park and Jurassic World have always really been more like slasher movie monsters than representations of actual animals. Case in point, why would the Rex in JP3 pursue a couple of tiny humans when it has a perfectly good meal right in front of it? As you’ve mentioned in some of your other videos, JP/JW don’t really run on real world logic. Which is fine, it’s way more fun watching people getting munched on than it would be watching a movie where the dinosaurs mostly just ignore us tiny, insignificant morsels. Though, on that note, I wish the film makers wouldn’t always fall back on the T-Rex and raptors. I get that they’re iconic, but...come on, there are other dinos out there.
ofc that size chart was changed cause of fans :D its complete bs. There is no way the T rex in movie is almost as small as ceratosaurus, there is no doubt it is a full grown or atleast adult T rex, the unused Buck animatronic puppet supports it aswell as you pointed out. Btw that Vader comparison was on point, i can just imagine how Star Wars fans would react if Kylo Ren slapped Vader that easily :D
The only logical reason I can see as to why the spino in the third film won is be cuz it’s a genetically modified spino compared to a natural one and is more heavily built.
I'm sure the reason they use the bull-rexx animatronic was to save money. The behind the scenes of JP3 was a huge mess through most of that production. Their budget was probably screwed up as well. Using a previously built prop, stage, or animatronic is a good way to save money. Especially when it's one that big. Having it lose to the spinosaurus makes sense story wise as well. They were trying to establish this new dinosaur as not just a new threat but that there was seriously something wrong with it. It turning out to be some kind of hybrid that we find on the Masrani site makes it winning make sense. It also just shows nature at work. Sometimes the local big bad carnivore can still get its butt kicked by something else. The way nature works. T-rex was having a bad day.
People need to let go of the whole spino vs rex controversy. For real. That movie happened, that fight happened, it's done. If fans keep focusing on something that's two decades old, and if they keep asking for a rematch, they will prevent the franchise from moving forward. I personally would not mind seeing the spino in Dominion, but I honestly pray to God that the writers don't have it fight a rex.
If tvtropes is anything to go by, it seems like it has been a standard norm for these two. Not that I want that either... tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SpinosaurusVersusTRex
@@aryshandono3249 I know it has been done everywhere outside the franchise since jp3. It's because fans look for the justice they think they deserve. Still, I don't mind seeing the rematch there, or even in jp videogames for that matter, AS LONG as it isn't used in Dominion.
@@JulianTorres-lh5du Warpath is probably the media we get to see these two fighting each other for the first time. Both T-Rex and Spino (albeit in old reconstruction) are playable in that game. First time we see Spinosaurus in Jurassic franchise too We kinda do need another Jurassic fighting game that is not on mobile me thinks
@@aryshandono3249 totally agree with you. A fighting game would be neat. Also, there is an official jp arcade game from 2015 that does feature the rematch. Klayton did a video on it a while ago. It's a short scene, but it's still a rematch. I think that and seeing rexy destroy the spino skeleton in jw should be enough. The writers have been trying to find ways to say they're sorry for jp3 ever since it came out in 2001. We as fans should know when to stop bugging them.
Wow, I'm impressed, I did not think the Jurassic Park cannon was large enough to provide enough material for a youtuber to derive a living from it, good work.
To add to what you said at 6:42 , in the scene where the group finds the rex and then the fight itself, the rex seems to change sizes as well. When Grant starts running and the rex comes out from behind its kill, it looks like Grant would almost reach the belly but then when they show it coming around the trees to see the spino, it looks a lot bigger. There is a margin for error because of the camera angle and distance but it's something that always stood out to me.
It's like a lion fighting a tiger, apex predators will fight, and unfortunately not always the ones we want to win, win. But as Malcom said, "Life finds a way." I love both animals, and will always. Great vid man, I agree
Im not even sure that a paleontologically accurate t rex would win against a paleontologically accurate Spino, but they wouldn't fight anyway. Depends on behavior we don't know
@@theraptorore1785 "Im not even sure that a paleontologically accurate t rex would win against a paleontologically accurate Spino" - Dude! Scotty, the biggest T-Rex outweighs the biggest Spino MSNM V4047 by almost a couple of tonnes despite the latter being 6 feet longer, but 4 feet shorter.
@@theraptorore1785 That's not true. Spino's biteforce is nothing compared to a rexs. Spino might've claws but that's not gonna be enough. And it's tail muscle? Eh, what would it do with that? Slap the rex in its face? Not gonna work. As much as I love spino, a realistic spino stands no chance against a realistic rex. In the movie, the spino only won because it's literally a hybrid- it's not accurate at all, anddd because of some plot armor.
@@alacazarthedragon2952 you are absolutely right, but I'm talking about the modern day Spino model's tail with the fins, it needs a lot of muscle to swim, so it could be used for fighting. And as for bite force, you are wrong because we don't know Spino's bite force and if it lived and competed with other crocodilians, then yes it's bite force would be more powerful
The first time I seen the fight back in 01 I was shocked, but I got over it during that same viewing because the Spino was so cool for the rest of the movie. Next time I seen it I didn’t even care. Spino was in my top 10 favorite dinos of all time that have been discovered even if it’s because of the movie form.
When I saw that movie I actually liked the spino as a kid instantly. I thought it had a cool roar and design. I like the T. rex, but Spino is neat also.
There's no way a long, slim-jawed, fine-toothed predator like Spinosaurus would have anything like the bone crushing power of a T-Rex bite. If they'd fought, the spino would have been defeated or killed quickly
@@cnarylmaz998 so snoke was introduced as the new big bad of the new sw trilogy. He was hyped up to be a sort of new palpatine style puppet master pulling strings from the shadows. Then rian Johnson comes along and shouts "yeet!" and the next thing you know, snoke has been unceremoniously killed off, in an almost embarrassing fashion, by kylo ren. It's incredibly stupid. The final movie adds insult to injury by revealing that snoke, this big bad puppet master, was nothing more than a clone created by palpatine-who, for all intents and purposes, was DEAD. It was so hilariously dumb. That reveal, is very similar to the spino coming out of nowhere and dunking on the rex
It's sad when the Rex dies fighting Spino but I do like Spino and at least it wasn't Rexy even Rexy would know not to mess with Spino and it's actually interesting to see different meat eating dinosaurs that are less popular in the spotlight for once The Land Before Time movie series did that in their sequel movies. There's also a Spinosaurus in The Land Before Time Wisdom of Friends and he looked really cool and very similar to Jurassic Park Spino.
It's not the length, it's the other dimensions like width, height, mass, etc... In real life, a 43 Feet T-Rex is almost 2000kg heavier than a 46 Feet Spino. Rexes are the thiccest bois among land carnivores.
@@waffeltruffel6199 nope it didn't weight that much the thing you said " According to Ibrahim " yeah he said but did he actually confirmed that it was 12 tons
I never gave two shits about that T rex fight. I always just thought "this is the movie with the spino." And I appreciated the fact that JP3 was willing to try something new.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, I never want to see a rematch. All it will do is add more fuel to the fire of the most ridiculous controversy in the entire fandom. If it happens in Dominion it will feel so petty and just leave the whole thing bitter.
Ye same I don’t rlly want to see another rematch , the reason why spino won in jp3 is just that he was more heavily built.that’s it idk why ppl have to be so mad about.
I’m amazed that there is still so much behind the scenes knowledge not many of us were aware of from the Original Trilogy! This is why I love coming to binge watch Klayton’s videos! :)
8:56 someone who finally talks objectively! Well said Klayton, I mean seems pretty obvious. And I love both animals, both in real and Jp universe. Cmon we're now adult and go over this story easily 😃
I just rewatched Jurassic Park 3 the other day. I never understood the theory of the subadult T.rex, if you watch the movie it’s obvious that the Rex was a full grown adult. What I do believe however is that this particular Rex has no correlation with the family we see in TLW, I do not believe it was the Buck from 1997, being that the color was completely different, and it surely wasn’t the infant, in 4 years he wouldn’t be anywhere near an adult or subadult.
Honestly the backlash wouldn't have been so bad if the fight was the climax of the film and not right when they get on the f*cking Island!!! The first movie and especially the Lost World had build up to a T-Rex's reveal lots of it but this movie it's so quick like BOOM there are on the island BOOM spinosaurus BOOM t-rex BOOM fight BOOM Rex dead cut to Alan Grant punching Mr Kirby in the face. Not to mention no one even talks about it! I mean Alan Grant talks about what dinosaur was chasing them like "oh it was the spinosaurus Ingen made something that wasn't on the list" but he never brings it up again. He's never like "Oh sh*t this thing just took out a motherf*king T-Rex maybe we should be concerned about that" but nope. It's just "oh it's a Spinosaurus something Ingen wasn't supposed to make okay next scene"......like what???!!!!! I think the most we get about the fight is that Eric mentioned that T-Rex piss attracts the spinosaurus so it's hinting that he actually hunts Rex's. But other than that no one even mentions it or talks about it! Like you could edit that whole scene out of the movie and nothing would really change. Edit: Sorry this is long. Also if they bring back Spinosaurus it wouldn't be a good idea to have it in the film just to kill it off. Spinosaurus has amassed a lot of fans over the years and I don't think you want to piss them off it will just start the fight all over again. I mean that would literally start ww3 and if you think I'm kidding look at 2020 would it really shock you at this point?
I liked that the Spino beat the T Rex. 1. It had the arms so it grabbing and twisting the t Rex's neck was believable. 2. After 2 movies of the t Rex being the "hero" of the films (which is just stupid to be honest) it was nice to see something new. 3. The fight was supposed to be longer, but the spino animatronic literally ripped the head off the t Rex one. Supposedly it was squirting hydraulic fluid like blood. I'd love to see the footage of that if any still exists. And since we have people complaining that the t Rex always comes out on top in these movies (5/6 of them now) maybe switching it up for once wasn't as bad as people seem to think.
actually, real spinosaurus can never beat T.rex in 1vs1 fight(especially in ground) But we need to remember that JP3 movie is so old and in that period, people thought spinosaurus is the biggest and strongest one.(well spino's length is the longest)
I don't believe there was a backlash against Spinosaurus winning or else it would have been a disliked dinosaur with low popularity. It's actually the opposite seeing as how Spinosaurus is rivaling Tyrannosaurus in terms of popularity in the fandom. Your highest viewed videos are regarding the Spinosaurus.
Dude, people were absolutely upset about Spinosaurus winning the fight, and it is what made it one of the most hated dinosaurs ever. Come on, don't be in this much denial.
I think the problem people really had with it was the huge amount of marketing put into it as well. If you go back and watch almost all the trailers have at least one shot of t rex and spino preparing to go at it. And this took up a large amount of the marketing. So to suddenly go from that to a less than 5 minute encounter that kills off the icon of the franchise not only insulted fans on the other two films it insulted casual people that paid for this hugely marketed aspect.
(Jeep turns a corner chasing a Spinosaurus and finds the Spinosaurus flanked by another Spinosaurus and several large carnivores) Spinosaurus: Everybody gangsta 'round here! Jeep Driver: Rough neighbourhood.... ACU in the back seat: Must go faster, must go faster....
No... that's if a *human* character appearing in the second half of the film, came in and killed the T Rex/Rexy with a pistol off screen and we next see the rex dead with other humans praising the hunter for their "Greatness".
Speaking from the heart here: Honestly, people just need to get over the spino killing the t-rex. In my opinion, the moment when the spino killed the rex is powerful. Why? Because it subverted our expectations. What did you expect them to do with the third film? Things had to change, and in my opinion it was done beautifully. Do I wish Jurassic Park 3 had been done better? Yes. Regardless, I'm still a fan of the film ,flaws and all. True fans understand that each film needs to be watched with a different state of mind. Jurassic Park 3 is a badass film, and I love it.
They could have easily just said the Rex was Elderly and maybe close to death anyway, like it would have the same effect without changing the size. Like it was mentioned the carcass it was eating seemed to be dead for a while, maybe it resorted to scavenging due to the fact it's no longer in its prime and would have trouble hunting
I never understood why people care so much, the T rex is just a dinosaur not the main character and whether its the spino or rex doesnt actually change the story at all. Ok one spino beat one rex whats the issue
My wife just watched jp3 for the first time last night and was highly disappointed with the fight scene. She was upset the trex lost. I saw this film in cinemas back on 01 and yeah still don't agree with them putting the spineosauras over
@@theminecraft2516 like that'll happen, what the rex takes a swipe at the galli and misses, tripping and breaking an ankle in the process, that's basically a death sentence
Better yet, why not have rex and spino fight something else and give the rex the finishing blow to whatever they were fighting, ending in the iconic rex roar
All of Jurassic park 3’s criticisms have nothing to do with the trex losing imo, if anything the spinosaurus was the best thing about the movie and it was better than he was the main dinosaur instead of the trex to show how powerful and deadly the spino was, plus the spinosaurus is one of the coolest dinosaurs that has ever existed and this is coming from a trex fan. The only criticisms I have with the spinosaurus are that the animatronic and cgi effects haven’t aged well.
I'm still mad about the fight.... Spinosaurus should have just shot the t rex.
Pog
The sino is better then that t-Rex but not better then rely
ME TO
I agree so stupid!
@@Jason-fs6jq No?
"it came out 20 years ago"
Thanks Klayton. I wanted to feel old today.
19 years ago
Yeah, not that I feel old but it's weird that I watched this in theatres (like I was old enough almost 20 years ago to actually see this in theatres).
God bless everyone.
@@kmhpranto8386 20 years
Dude I'm almost 20 now And I feel really old after this
Bro I remember seeing JP3 3 times in the theatre…time is crazy eh
If the Spinosaurus and Roberta (the T.Rex) ever do meet, I think they'll just pass each other and won't fight at all. This'll symbolize how people should move on from it.
I'm worried people are going to be too persistent regarding the rematch anyhow. Its understandable why they want it, but I feel like what's done is done.
the jp3 spinosaurus is the only spinosaurus and I think it's stupid to bring it back just to go extinct for a rematch, I agree no rematch.
@@Black_Wolf1357 it's what it is now. Apparently.
If people want it so bad, there's always Primal Carnage.
@@tyrantking3193 yea, but if there were 4 or 5 spino then I wouldn't care if 1 or 2 die just as long as they don't go extinct, same for the trex
@@Black_Wolf1357 I did love the dinosaur designs for JP3.
Buck T. rex: You Took... Everything from me...
Spinosaurus: I don’t even know who you are.
Buck T. rex: You will, boy...
“I understood that reference.”
- Captain America
"Ded" heavy weapons guy.
Lol IL love that
spinosaurus: *chuckles I'm in danger
me: DINOSAURS: Assemble
I heard that the reason why the spino killed The Rex was because it was horner's idea because he hated t-rexes
@@mystic_bat8442 Problem is that Horner is actually wrong about that lmao. As a great of a paleontologist he is, the T-Rex is built as an apex predator, and has had clear evidence that it hunts.
@@mystic_bat8442 At this point, tho, even Horner himself has stopped believing the Scavenger theory (He's said so himself). He only bring it up to troll other Paleontologists.
But, yeah. The dude hates Tyrannosaurus. Not sure why tho
@@VelociraptorsOfSkyrim In reality, the T-Rex was a really successful hunter and was indeed a killer. Often killing each other or other “apex” predators in their area. The T-Rex would have truly killed the Spinosaurus if he had followed the facts rather than his feelings on the creature -_- He should have used a Carnotaurus or the Ceratosaurus for a more accurate depiction of the events. Then again, Jurassic Park/World doesn’t follow logic and reality. Everyone knows the Spinosaurus was a hybrid. The Indominus, Indoraptor, and dinosaurs even being a thing are enough. And the movie T-Rex broke bones by shaking rather than simply biting like a real T-Rex.
I wonder why they still used him as the paleontology consultant for Jurassic films... As much as his claims regarding Tyrannosaurus, he might have the right idea about Stygimoloch being a juvie stage of Pachycephalosaurus
@Zulhazreen zulkifli I wish Robert T. Bakker, Paul Sereno, or Phillip Currie could have similar opportunities...
Whilst i do think that the whole backlash against this fight got blown way too out of proportion, this whole trend of having the fan-favorite thing being killed by a new "cooler" version is hella stupid and needs to stop cause it literally never works. It didn't work when they replaced Optimus Prime with Rodimus Prime, didn't work with the Spino, and also didn't work with the new Dalek Paradigm on Doctor Who
It always backfires
Also Predator and then Terminator, its just so damn overused and lazy to just make em bigger and beefier and kill the original shamefully every damn time. Its like they have no sense of loyalty to stick with it.
The indominis almost killed the T rex so there is also that.
And this has alsp happened in between companys and thier main franchises protagonist where they make one look cooler to make the competition look outdated for example.
Mickey Mouse vs Bugs bunny.
Marvel and DC
Mario vs Sonic
Regarding Doctor Who: The idea was good. The new pure Daleks destroying the old impure ones makes a lot of sense. Even the way it happens was pretty well written. What made it suck was the design of the new Daleks.
i mean i didn't watch the things you mentioned in your comment besides jp3, but i way prefer the spino over the T-rex and also liked watching the spino defeating the T-rex
Sud-Adult Tyrannosaurus: *exist*
JP3 Spinosaurus: *It's Free Real Estate*
Hmmm
**Sub adult**
He wasn't sub-adult, this is the dumbest mith ever created
So even tho it's smaller than the other 6 Tyrannosaurs,it isn't a Sud-Adult?
*chad hybrid spinosaurus*
Chad:
Killed T-Rex on his prime
Hás ability to fast heal
Could resistence alot of guns
make life live hell of humans and raptors
Vs
*Virgin indominus rex*
Virgin
Bullet prove skin
Camo
easy mod
Talks in dinosuar dna
mostly killed granny rexy
*Sorry about the joke*
Its clear from the film what they were trying to do. This fight is kind of like how wrestling promotions work. if you have a new guy coming in and you want to show that this new guy needs to be taken seriously to the audience you have one of your establish stars put them "over" by losing. That basically what happened The Spino was the new guy into the franchise and they wanted him to be a big threat. So they establish if early on by having the T-Rex take the loss, to basically tell the audience. This new guy is a big deal. Just a story telling deceive, don't know why people get so upset.
Its because lots of people were attached to Tyrannosaurus rex the most.
I was a year old around the time of Jurassic Park 3, which was 2001. I didnt have a reaction much, as it was the movie that got me into Jurassic Park in the first place.
Cause it could've worked had they not have the fight at all. Showing the Spino brutally wreck an airplane in seconds with it's arms and bulky body.
The rex vs spino fight doesn't add anything to the plot at all other than the directors wanting to jack themselves off in front of the old fans.
@@TheGhost-rp3ko its one of the only carnivore fights in the series and the best scene in JP3. It's just 1 trex that died and ppl act like they went extinct. It lost. And a rex wouldve lost again in JW if Blue hadn't saved the day. In wildlife lions get killed by hyenas sometimes. Despite being the kinf of the jungle they still get wrecked from time to time. Ppl need to get over it. The tyrannosaurus can be killed by a larger carnivore especially an intelligent hybrid like Indominus.
@@bantuboi3131 Believe whatever the hell ya want, I'm not changing my mind
@@TheGhost-rp3ko you're clearly 15 yo fanboy.
I think you’re totally right, Klayton. I mean, if you actually look at the fight in the film, they’re roughly the same size. I’m with you though, the fight never really bothered me personally, I know they wanted to focus on a new threat for the movie, and I was excited to see a new big bad. Spinosaurus wasn’t a super well known animal either, back then, so to see a new fairly unknown dinosaur in JP was really exciting, at least for me. I loved the T. Rex, but we had a lot of it the previous two films, I’m glad they went in a little different direction.
That all being said though, yes, I think the way they handled to fight could’ve been a little more respectful to the Rex and the fans. The fight was pretty abrupt, the Spino basically shows up and kills the Rex. So I definitely get some of the anger from fans. Had they made the fighter a little longer, and a little more balanced, and even, Idk, made the fight a draw, or have the Rex give the Spino a serious wound.. I think that would’ve gone a long way as far as fans were concerned.
A little late but I totally agree what you said. 20 years ago I was upset too but I got over it for two reasons:
One the writers wanted to introduce the new "Big bad" and went better introduction than the clap the previous big bad.
Still salty but I understand.
Plus spinosaurus is clearly larger and longer than jp3 T-Rex.
You would think in nature size matters a lot sometimes more than smarts and agility.
Plus there was a moment when the T-Rex left himself wide open for the spinosaurus to deliver a lethal counter.
So again I'm still salty by how abrupt the fight was I can accept it because the Rex left himself open and the spinosaurus is clearly larger and stronger.
And et was also ths first big carnivor fight in the franchiss
Hey, at least *that T Rex* wasn't our Old Girl, Rexy. Now that, would have been over the top upsetting for sure.
Spinosaurus: "I was the only one to kill a T-rex not raptors, not humans, and damn sure not that Indominus Rex, ME!!!!!! and do i get any recognition for it? NO!!!!! They just put me as a skeleton just for the T-rex to run through, to hell wit em!!!!!"
Bartender: alright Spiny i think you had a lil too much to drink........
Spinosaurus: NO!! I HAB-HABINT DRINKN *hic* ENOUGH!!! GIMME MORE!!!
Crocoduck: Come, my breathren. Join us in our sanctuary.
Wasn’t there a comic like this
The Rex vs Spino fight is the LEAST problematic part of that movie. I actually was shocked and went "damn, if THAT THING took down a Rex, God help the poor people on that island."
The only reason the fight bothers me was that Horner used it to prop up his pet theory
Exactly that was the only reason it happened.. he hates T Rex and the buffoon Joe Johnston believed every word he said.. its absolutely bullshit
The what now?
@@leongaming9834 Jack Horner, a paleontologist who had a retarded theory that Tyrannosaurus was primarily a scavenger, was a consultant for JP3. It's very possible his biased views on Trex may have influenced the direction of the film.
A rematch would feel super forced, they already symbolized a rematch in World by having Rexy destroy the Spinosaurus skeleton.
K
I'd actually be fine with a rematch, but it SHOULDN'T be a 30 second fight and instead an actual epic showdown. I also am hesitant of the Spinosaurus biting the dust; but if it already got enough screentime in JW Dominion, I'm fine with it dying
Yeah but it doesn’t feel the same like when the T. rex killed the Carno or the Raptors. Think about this what if u were a Carno fanboy and u where really angry that the T Rex killed the Carno so easily without a fight. Then in JWD a Carno just destroys a T Rex skeleton and roars. Wouldn’t it be more satisfying and vengeful for a Carno to kill a T Rex with a awesome fight?
P.S. I am not a Carno Fanboy I am just using this as an example
@@jaimepennington1120 but logically a trex would destroy a carno with a single bite. However a spinosaurus beating a trex in 30 seconds is full of bull because the trex is the icon of jurassic park. That's what made fans mad.
@@alpha7even928 rexy is the icon while every other trex is not.
It's called "the Worf effect." It's a lazy way to show how "strong" a new bad guy is by having them easily beat another known strong character.
Nice to see someone else that reads stuff on TVtropes.
Is that true? I gotta google that shit
And by easily you mean that the Spino animatronic breaking the T Rex animatronic before thw battle really began?
Honestly if they went into deeper lore at the time of the Spino being a hybrid (which would most likely give it am edge) and gave us an actual fight and not a one-sided slaughter, I almost guarantee that no matter who would of won, it would have been a great moment of the series.
@@zendzend5107 or they could've cut away from the fight after a while and leave it up to the audience to decide who won
this explains why I didn't really care about it..... I was numb from DBZ always using it
When I first saw JP 3 I thought the idea of another predatory dinosaur that was even bigger and badder than the T-Rex was pretty cool
It was, the story just wasn’t that good
It was, just not executed well
@@warbeast787 Executed better than Rexy vs Indominus Rex
Bigger but not as much of a monster as Tyrannosaurus is
@@Espartanica how so?
To me, I don’t really think a rematch between the T.Rex and Spinosaurus is really necessary, cause I feel like Jurassic World already made up for that by having the T.Rex break through the Spinosaurus skeleton and fight the Indominus Rex.
Or there is always Primal Carnage if people keep asking. Made peace with it.
And there are spinosaurus fans so if they do a rematch they’re going to have to make the tea Rex win because then the tea Rex fans will get even more mad but then the spinosaurus fans will be mad it’s just a never ending cycle of pain for everyone
@@theearthkingdom7537 to them, it seems like dinosaurs are Pokemon
@Jurassic Hero That would probably I make almost everyone happy because there would be no real winner
@@theearthkingdom7537 Ah yes the tea rex the return of the cups. Its T-rex btw
T-Rex: “Hello, my name is Inigo Montoya, you killed my father, prepare to die.”
Spino: (runs away)
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I was wondering if someone would make a Princess Bride reference! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That is probably how it would have happened in real life.
@Paul McCartney V2 Wtf in reality the spino would lose because they found the right Standing position And its quadrupedal
@@primebg1467 yes. Because that's totally a valid reason for the spino to lose. Being qaudrupedal. What is supposed to be your point here? A triceratops would steam roll a T. Rex in real life. Just like most quadrupedal dinosaurs would from the rexes time.
@@primebg1467 and there is no way the spino could walk on all 4's since its wrists would snap. And it can't flatten it's hands because it's a therapod. All therapods hands aren't functional except for hunting and stabbing fish.
I have the official "behind-the-scenes" version of that poster! In Canada, Burger King was giving them out when JP3 first came out.
I still wouldn't have the JP3 fight any other way. Rexy's comeback in JW was so great, partly BECAUSE of how the T-Rex was used in JP3! Fans wanted better for the T-Rex, and we got it! If the fight in JP3 was different, we might not have the epic JW fight today!
Not to mention I-rex was closest to Spino we can get (bigger; forearms) but worse.
I love this perspective. When it looked like Queen Rexy was gonna bite it in JW a lot of people (myself included) were thinking “Oh fuck not again”
Likewise the Spino skeleton smash wouldn’t have had as much impact were it not used as a Fuck-you to JP3, at best it would be a nod to the museum display getting destroyed in the original JP movie
I am not angry for the fight
@@MrCliffda3rd exactly rexy beat the i rex which sorry but if the indoumous saw the jp3 spino the I rex would absolutely destroy it
@@iamaidansmith7542 when did rexy beat i rex?
JP3 had more serious problems than debating on the T-Rex size.
What if we get a rexy/spino team up
Yea it has way more problems than the fight
Yeah. The Trex was smaller than the Triceratops(Which was way too big.)
@@jurassicking101.4 There wasn’t even a Triceratops in JP3 though
@@waffleboi9584 What are u saying? The Triceratops was there in the beginning when they characters were flying over Sorna. It only made a cameo.
Honestly seems like splitting hairs for those who insist the T.rex was "way smaller". The Spinosaurus was also downsized in the size chart and a 37 foot long T.rex is only going to be marginally smaller than a 40 foot one of comparable build. Klayton's right on the money here.
less than 1m
Nah. The JP3 Spinosaurus was of intended size (different from the real one). Its been given 43'9 all the way to 46 feet because the maquette has a curved tail vs the CGI's straightened tail.
I always thought of it as Rexy being at the peak of her size or unnaturally large because she was well fed and kept on its own.
The Sorna rexes were just more "naturally grown" in about the same size range as the living rex
@@kennethsatria6607 That's not always how natural size works with wild animals. Often heights and lengths between captive and wild animals are comparable, but weights will vary.
I just think the creators of JP3 wanted to make a new dinosaur look bigger and badder for a new generation of jurqssic park fans than the same ole trex
I've been on that size chart for years now. It's legit (at least Spino, T-Rex and Raptor).
The maquette Tyrannosaurus (yes, that includes Rexy) is meant to represent the theoretical full scale of an over 36 feet long and almost 15 feet tall animal. Angry fans have accused those dimensions to be that of a subadult because they choose not to see Spino being intended as "Bigger than T-Rex"
Edit: I know of the 40+ foot listing of T.Rex but I take that as in-universe visual approximacy. Believe me, before I learned of JP1 Rex's real size I also was sold on it being 40 feet long. The chart doesn't do its size justice.
@@tnb4509 44 feet is Rexy's size from 22 years of nonstop growth (Jurassic World onwards). Definitely based on reptiles' tendency to grow throughout their lives.
Edit: I just realized. Since Spielberg had the tendency to upscale his dinos for more wow factor, maybe the JP Rexes were 40 feet in universe. They just give the 37-foot animatronics more close-up to fulfill this illusion.
@@tnb4509 Maybe or maybe not. It depends on whether Spinosaurus will come out of Universal's creature purgatory, let alone get an official size chart.
Well, if he does appear, there is a chance that the producers will acknowledge the real-life Spinosaurus length of 50 feet.
@@paolopasaol9700 hey i know this is VERY late. But if you see this mind telling where you got that information that the maquet was scaled to a 36 ft long animal?
As a kid in 2001, I never saw the issue with the Spino. When Alan said it was something bigger than the Rex, I just took into consideration that there are dinosaurs bigger and worse than the T.Rex. I never got upset that it killed the mascot for the franchise as a result.
DINOBOYXYZ the Rex on Nublar is the same one in Jurassic world!
@DINOBOYXYZ it's not the same trex from the lost world, it's just another adult trex.
@DINOBOYXYZ the JP2 trex is way more aggressive than rexy which leaves me to believe it would've taken down spino despite it's sheer size
Uh, guys, Tyrannosaurus would have crushed Spinosaurus rather easily in real life. THAT's the problem with the battle. But, that aside, don't forget the other, perhaps the main issue: you don't build up this epic confrontation between 2 badasses to get people into the theater, then, cheat them with a few seconds of one killing the other with hardly a struggle.
In other words, the fight was over almost as soon as it started and we're sitting there, "that's it? THAT'S IT????"
Great video on the T. rex that got terminated from Jurassic Park III.
I know how you feel about the T. rex vs Spinosaurus fight in Jurassic Park III but I was very disappointed with the fight as well because Jack Horner made the Spinosaurus more powerful than the Rex in Jurassic Park III.
If anything, it’s all Jack Horner’s fault for this chaotic mess of the Spinosaurus and T. rex fight.
Great video Klayton Fioriti and as always, Take It Easy and Life Finds A Way.
Mmm-hmm.
Well... Jack Horner seems like not a T-Rex biggest fan. He's a believer that it's a scavenger, not an active hunter from what I read
@@aryshandono3249 Horner hates T.Rex because he's a fan of duckbilled dinosaurs but he kept finding T.Rex fossils instead of duckbills. And he's also sick and tired of how overrated T.Rex is, so he dedicated his whole life to trolling paleontologists and dino fans alike with the scavenger theory, a theory that not even he believes, he just hates T.Rex THAT much. XD
@@cintronproductions9430 Well, can't blame him. T-Rex was the apex predator of North America in the Late Cretaceous and pretty well known thanks to how abundant its remains are :3
But I'm starting to think while it has not yet appeared in that many films (but plenty in video games), Spinosaurus has also become somewhat overrated
@@aryshandono3249 maybe but Rex, giga and even carno are more popular than spino back then.
Wow! Early comment! I just wanted to say that you’re the best and have helped me fuel my interest in Jurassic Park and because of you I’m reading all of Michael Crichton’s books. Thank you Klayton!
4:49 that Rex came out of nowhere! I would love to see a scene like that in Dominion, where someone is tranqing a dino and another passes by at the worst moment.
Great video though!
Yup that was very cinematic and that person was so screwed
My man Klayton over here reopening old wounds.
I'm a 2000s kid and I have to admit the JP franchise was one of my favorites growing up,I had the box with all of the movies 1-3 collectors edition with the wooden doors as the cover.😁😄
I always thought that the DVD size chart was made to further show how bigger the Spino is rather than making a retcon of sorts to appease fans.
That being said, what always caught my attention was the moment when the Rex almost steps on Alan. You can see his foot is smaller than that of the female Rex from TLW (whose foot almost crushed Carter completely). This makes me wonder if the female Rexes ("Rexy" and "Doe") are actually bigger than males.
Anyway, the fight scene in JP3 never bothered me. I liked they chose another species as the main predator, and the Spino was a cool choice that added more variety to the franchise.
Spino is best
Yes, in the book version of the jurassic park movies, specifcally the lost world, the females are stated to be bigger than the males
Resizing the T-Rex has to be the most accurate accident the JP Franchise ever did. As of now, the most recent estimations of the Spinosaurus (the biggest specimen, MSNM V4047) is still smaller compared to the likes of Sue and Scotty
Could you link the paper you found that info from?
@@ahahaha6228 Look up Sue and Scotty's latest size and mass estimates and compare it with the biggest confirmed Spino's (MSNM V4047) latest estimates (as close to 2020 as possible. You'll see what I'm talking about.
Three things:
1. Horner most likely made the spino win because he hates T-rexs (yes he has said that publicly)
2. Theres no point in arguing because the two would have never fought in the first place (and even if they did there is a probability of Rex wining, because it is better built to fight other dinosaurs, not because its a t-rex)
3.(This was said by someone else) But I think it would be nice if the trex and spino met and didn't fight, it would symbolize that people need to move on. If the spino dies it should be to humans, not the T-rex.
I remember watching the tv spots of jp3 & my jaw dropped like "the t.rex actually dies?!". The whole fight did angered me as a kid ( a little bit now as an adult ). Don't get me wrong spinosaurus is a cool dinosaur , but t.rex will always be #1 imo.
Of course it is. The T-Rex is extremely overrated, so a ton of people are gonna have it #1.
Spinosaurus is #1 for sure for me.
I am very excited to see how Jurassic World: Dominion turns out. I hope to see a very compelling story line, great performances from both the actors and the Dinosaurs (CGI and animatronic), and I hope to have a thrilling time watching it in general.
Well... that didn't happen.
7:05 Oh my god you shot that Spino right in the eye! Ouch!
Considering that alot of people love Spinosaurus And Trex it wouldn't be fair that a rematch would be in Domion. Plus my Mom loves Spinosaurus.
I want the Giganotosaurus since it's the last member of the Big 3.
It would look very similar to the Indominus honestly
@@joyhagerty6455 true but it won't be a fake dinosaurs at least
Why not Acrocanthosaurus? At least its moderate height spine would make it look a little bit different. Plus, that dinosaur hasn't appeared in any film, me thinks
@@aryshandono3249 i would love to see a proper Acrocanthosaurus in a film or series get respect and love it is actually believed that the spines were holding muscles together and added bulk to the animal in other words in an accurate Acrocanthosaur we would mot see any exposed spine at all, no more than in normal vertebrates like bison. The Acrocanthosaurus was a very large and powerfully built animal, it is shown this way in JW Evolution demonstrating a much bulkier body and build to it.
@@smokebomb7889 they are all fake dinosaurs every single dinosaurs in JP/JW is a hybrid
So glad this channel exists, klayton (imo at least) is on the same level as star wars theory in terms of passion and care for a franchise and the fans. Happy to have stumbled upon this to highten my knowledge on one of my favorite franchises.
Size chart Rex in pre-production looks about the same size as the DVD release. I think the perceived difference is just the power of suggestion because the Rex has the sub-adult label on it and the Ankylosaurus is between the Rex and Spino in the DVD release (unlike the pre-production chart which is less spaced out and has a Galli or something between them, but close enough that the Rex is right on the Spino’s tail), making it more difficult to tell.
Edit: also you can tell they’ve only applied the label and kept the size the same if you compare the size to the Para. In both images the Rex is slightly larger than it.
Firstly, I love your videos. Secondly I have to point out it wasn't remotely how as you suggested with the Star Wars analogy. Everyone acts like it killed off "THE" T. Rex, but it killed "A" T. Rex. A rex we've never seen before. I would understand somewhat if it killed Rexy but it was a random one. You're right about the Rex being an adult though. That was always the intention. Spino was just supposed to be a very powerful animal and that's all there is to it. He made for a very entertaining dinosaur and since JP3 he has remained on my top spot of favourite dino in the franchise. They did a great job with him and the film was good fun. He didn't replace the T. Rex like everyone suggests, he just kills a random one. Admittedly the fight wasn't as good as it should have been but that's because the Spino animatronic destroyed the rex animatronic, so they had no choice but to do it in CGI due to scheduling.
I always thought that the T-Rex in JW3 was a fully grown adult and that the Spino won the fight because of its hands allowing it to grab the Rex and break its neck. The Spino did get bitten on the neck but, since it was described as a "super predator", InGen must've designed it to have greater resistance to damage.
I only became aware of the controversy surrounding the Rex vs Spino fight about 6 years ago. The size chart thing comes across as damage control.
the trex in jp3 is adult
@@Black_Wolf1357 it's not. They have came out and said it's not fully grown, but I'm pretty sure it was meant to be fully grown when the scene was shot. Just excuses to keep people happy. Or semi happy.
@@eglorious-yt it's confirmed fully grown, they never mentioned or listed not fully grown once, only fans said it as an excuse and not only that but it's also confirmed and canon that the spinosaurus is more ferocious and more nastier than the trexes on sorna, so saying the trex not fully grown wouldn't make sense.
@@Black_Wolf1357 I have seen otherwise. Maybe I am wrong. Will have to check again, but I remember somewhere some official Jp3 thing said for it to not be fully grown. Look I 100% agree with you. I think it's really stupid. I think people should move on seeing as the next 3 films basically licked the Trex's ass.
@@eglorious-yt I never heard any interviews or commentaries or behind the scenes or Twitter or Instagram etc. not once it was ever mentioned not fully grown, it's listed full grown bull trex on the last script and also on the jp3 Novel that was made a year after the film.
I remember the backlash. I thought it was kinda badass that a new dinosaur (the Spino) got to take the throne temporarily.
To be honest I don’t care for the outcome of that fight, I just remember seeing that scene for the first time and thinking that the spinosaurus was awesome
Yes it really is
In my opinion the Spin-off in JP 3 is bigger than the JP 3 bull, Buck, and Doe but is slightly smaller than Rexy.
The Spino
@@worldsworsthost7016 your right
I totally agree with you, but I still want to see Rexy vs Spinosaurus in Jurassic World Dominion 😂😂😂
With blue
@Fxa no
with or without it in the movie its completely fine with me
That would be a bad idea. Rexy in her prime vs the jp3 spino is more fair cuz rexy will just get killed off by that behemoth due to rexy being very old to fight
@@hanna2510 wtf really you know in jp3 when the t rex bit the spinos neck it should've been destroyed oh and the spino age's faster
I agree, the Trex was fully grown and I Support the Spinosaurus. #TeamSpinosaurus, I just wish that it returned in Dominion and fought the Giga with the T-rex....
I seriously just don't get why this scene caused such a big stink. It was a cool fight, the spino really was bigger than the rex (its not a fictional character like Godzilla) and one rex going down doesn't mean that they would lose that matchup every time.
EXACTLY!!! And I believe it just sends a message that the Spinosaurus should be feared as much as the Trex
I may be biased because I saw JP3 first, but the Spino defeating T.Rex never affected how I loved it just as much.
Huh. I always went with the whole '"JP3 T-Rex is a subadult' theory for a long time. As always, you've done a good job of giving me stuff to think about. :) And personally, the 'Spino vs. T-Rex' fight scene NEVER rubbed me the wrong way even when I was 10 years old and saw "JP3" on the big screen for the first time, mainly because I'm a *paleontology* fan as well as a "JP/JW" fan, so I can respect and like Spinosaurus for the *animal* that it is. The fact that some "Jurassic" fans out there haven't gotten over that one "JP3" scene is what bothers me, NOT the scene itself. It's like 'LET IT GO, PEOPLE! It's just a *MOVIE!'*
Sheesh. I really don't understand why some people take films like the "JP/JW" or "Star Wars" films so seriously. It's THAT kind of attitude that, *IMO,* RUINED the "Star Wars" sequel trilogy (which I personally feel are *OK, ENJOYABLE* films). Of course, this is just me talking.
7:25, I saw that and the Rex looks like it's the same size as Spinosaurus, minus the sail.
Pretty sure the Spino has slightly longer jaws and slightly longer neck to.
I think your theory is solid. After all, JP3 was hastily put together mid production so I can believe that the outcome was no different. I also believe that they should've gone for the epic climatic style they were advertising for the fight so it would add more to mystery of the Spino and at least give the t rex a chance to go down fighting. Oh well, no point in crying over spilled milk.
What if the milk is so delicious and expensive? 😂
Actually Klayton, after the release of JP3, every kid in my school LOVED the Spinosaurus including me. It was a cooler and more dominant dinosaur. We even said it's like a real life Godzilla since it can swim lol.
Years later the Spinosaurus lost it's popularity and now people hate it.
@@loveInvincible6400 it is still quite popular though. Have you seen how many people say their favorite dinosaur is Spino in many dinosaur fan communities? Or in Klayton's videos?
@@aryshandono3249 Doesn't matter. That fight with the T Rex is what hurt the Spinosaurus. Now that further research was made Jack Horner even had to admit he was wrong about the fight.
@@loveInvincible6400 the spinosaurus in jp3 is the 3rd most popular dinosaur in Jurassic franchise, more popular than indominus Rex.
@@loveInvincible6400 No that fight was what catapulted it into stardom. Ever since Spinosaurus has been an incredibly popular dinosaur like wtf lmao
A frivolous children's movie will not determine the power of a greater creature, even if it defeats him in the movie, because that duck will not be able to raise its head in front of a T-Rex in the real world.
When i was a kid in JP3 times, i liked Spinosaurus because it over threw a King. A ******* King of all kinds of tyrants!
I loved the Spinosaurus because of its unique design, the fact that it fought a trex was an awesome bonus
The JP3 Spinosaurus design is better than its real-life counterpart tbh
Hey guys in dominan there is gonna be spinosaurus also it's the jp3 spino is back and it's gonna be a full grown adult!!!! It's the same jp3 spino now in the dominian he is a full grown adult now!!!
@@apexpredator5721 really
@@kiryuthedragonwarrior2746it's 90% sure
Yeah, I’m with you. I...never really cared that much. The spinosaurus is one of my favorite dinosaurs in Jurassic Park, even if the movie it’s in is admittedly not a great movie. To me, the dinosaurs in Jurassic Park and Jurassic World have always really been more like slasher movie monsters than representations of actual animals. Case in point, why would the Rex in JP3 pursue a couple of tiny humans when it has a perfectly good meal right in front of it? As you’ve mentioned in some of your other videos, JP/JW don’t really run on real world logic. Which is fine, it’s way more fun watching people getting munched on than it would be watching a movie where the dinosaurs mostly just ignore us tiny, insignificant morsels. Though, on that note, I wish the film makers wouldn’t always fall back on the T-Rex and raptors. I get that they’re iconic, but...come on, there are other dinos out there.
ofc that size chart was changed cause of fans :D its complete bs. There is no way the T rex in movie is almost as small as ceratosaurus, there is no doubt it is a full grown or atleast adult T rex, the unused Buck animatronic puppet supports it aswell as you pointed out.
Btw that Vader comparison was on point, i can just imagine how Star Wars fans would react if Kylo Ren slapped Vader that easily :D
but the difference is vader is like rexy, not buck or doe or bull.
I swear I would be super pissed if Kylo beat Vader I also don’t think kylo could last 5 seconds in a fight with vader
@@Black_Wolf1357 rexy would crush the spino and so would most t rexs
The only logical reason I can see as to why the spino in the third film won is be cuz it’s a genetically modified spino compared to a natural one and is more heavily built.
@@applesaucelord368 no Dino beats rexy that’s rule
I'm sure the reason they use the bull-rexx animatronic was to save money. The behind the scenes of JP3 was a huge mess through most of that production. Their budget was probably screwed up as well. Using a previously built prop, stage, or animatronic is a good way to save money. Especially when it's one that big. Having it lose to the spinosaurus makes sense story wise as well. They were trying to establish this new dinosaur as not just a new threat but that there was seriously something wrong with it. It turning out to be some kind of hybrid that we find on the Masrani site makes it winning make sense. It also just shows nature at work. Sometimes the local big bad carnivore can still get its butt kicked by something else. The way nature works. T-rex was having a bad day.
People need to let go of the whole spino vs rex controversy. For real. That movie happened, that fight happened, it's done. If fans keep focusing on something that's two decades old, and if they keep asking for a rematch, they will prevent the franchise from moving forward. I personally would not mind seeing the spino in Dominion, but I honestly pray to God that the writers don't have it fight a rex.
If tvtropes is anything to go by, it seems like it has been a standard norm for these two. Not that I want that either...
tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SpinosaurusVersusTRex
@@aryshandono3249 I know it has been done everywhere outside the franchise since jp3. It's because fans look for the justice they think they deserve. Still, I don't mind seeing the rematch there, or even in jp videogames for that matter, AS LONG as it isn't used in Dominion.
@@JulianTorres-lh5du Warpath is probably the media we get to see these two fighting each other for the first time. Both T-Rex and Spino (albeit in old reconstruction) are playable in that game. First time we see Spinosaurus in Jurassic franchise too
We kinda do need another Jurassic fighting game that is not on mobile me thinks
@@aryshandono3249 totally agree with you. A fighting game would be neat. Also, there is an official jp arcade game from 2015 that does feature the rematch. Klayton did a video on it a while ago. It's a short scene, but it's still a rematch. I think that and seeing rexy destroy the spino skeleton in jw should be enough. The writers have been trying to find ways to say they're sorry for jp3 ever since it came out in 2001. We as fans should know when to stop bugging them.
Wow, I'm impressed, I did not think the Jurassic Park cannon was large enough to provide enough material for a youtuber to derive a living from it, good work.
I just want the Spino to make an appearance! Such a beautiful looking dinosaur!
To add to what you said at 6:42 , in the scene where the group finds the rex and then the fight itself, the rex seems to change sizes as well. When Grant starts running and the rex comes out from behind its kill, it looks like Grant would almost reach the belly but then when they show it coming around the trees to see the spino, it looks a lot bigger. There is a margin for error because of the camera angle and distance but it's something that always stood out to me.
It's like a lion fighting a tiger, apex predators will fight, and unfortunately not always the ones we want to win, win. But as Malcom said, "Life finds a way." I love both animals, and will always. Great vid man, I agree
Im not even sure that a paleontologically accurate t rex would win against a paleontologically accurate Spino, but they wouldn't fight anyway. Depends on behavior we don't know
@@theraptorore1785 "Im not even sure that a paleontologically accurate t rex would win against a paleontologically accurate Spino" - Dude! Scotty, the biggest T-Rex outweighs the biggest Spino MSNM V4047 by almost a couple of tonnes despite the latter being 6 feet longer, but 4 feet shorter.
@@mstr293 but think about the spinos tail muscle, and it's jaw strength, I love t rex but spinos better equipped for battle
@@theraptorore1785 That's not true. Spino's biteforce is nothing compared to a rexs. Spino might've claws but that's not gonna be enough. And it's tail muscle? Eh, what would it do with that? Slap the rex in its face? Not gonna work. As much as I love spino, a realistic spino stands no chance against a realistic rex. In the movie, the spino only won because it's literally a hybrid- it's not accurate at all, anddd because of some plot armor.
@@alacazarthedragon2952 you are absolutely right, but I'm talking about the modern day Spino model's tail with the fins, it needs a lot of muscle to swim, so it could be used for fighting. And as for bite force, you are wrong because we don't know Spino's bite force and if it lived and competed with other crocodilians, then yes it's bite force would be more powerful
The first time I seen the fight back in 01 I was shocked, but I got over it during that same viewing because the Spino was so cool for the rest of the movie. Next time I seen it I didn’t even care. Spino was in my top 10 favorite dinos of all time that have been discovered even if it’s because of the movie form.
Was I one of the only kids that liked the Spinosaurus over the T-rex?
I hate to break it to you, but a lot of people do. But since when did you actually like Spinosaurus though?
When I saw that movie I actually liked the spino as a kid instantly. I thought it had a cool roar and design.
I like the T. rex, but Spino is neat also.
@@CandyApples4ever same, that movie hooked me on Spino.
@@CARBONHAWK1
It’s a crocodile with a giant spiky fan on its back. Of course I’d love it haha
37 feet is still average for a T. rex. Not every T. Rex is 45 feet long.
Spino won bcoz of plot armour
There's no way a long, slim-jawed, fine-toothed predator like Spinosaurus would have anything like the bone crushing power of a T-Rex bite. If they'd fought, the spino would have been defeated or killed quickly
You basically explained snoke from the sequel trilogies and why his "arc" sucks
I don't want to sound like an idout but... I don't get it can you explain?
@@cnarylmaz998 so snoke was introduced as the new big bad of the new sw trilogy. He was hyped up to be a sort of new palpatine style puppet master pulling strings from the shadows.
Then rian Johnson comes along and shouts "yeet!" and the next thing you know, snoke has been unceremoniously killed off, in an almost embarrassing fashion, by kylo ren. It's incredibly stupid.
The final movie adds insult to injury by revealing that snoke, this big bad puppet master, was nothing more than a clone created by palpatine-who, for all intents and purposes, was DEAD. It was so hilariously dumb. That reveal, is very similar to the spino coming out of nowhere and dunking on the rex
It's sad when the Rex dies fighting Spino but I do like Spino and at least it wasn't Rexy even Rexy would know not to mess with Spino and it's actually interesting to see different meat eating dinosaurs that are less popular in the spotlight for once The Land Before Time movie series did that in their sequel movies.
There's also a Spinosaurus in The Land Before Time Wisdom of Friends and he looked really cool and very similar to Jurassic Park Spino.
Spinosaurus: 43ft.
“Sub-Adult”: 37ft.
Fully Grown Bull: 40ft.
Me: Is 3-6 feet that much of a difference?
It's not the length, it's the other dimensions like width, height, mass, etc... In real life, a 43 Feet T-Rex is almost 2000kg heavier than a 46 Feet Spino. Rexes are the thiccest bois among land carnivores.
@@mstr293 the "new" Spino weight 12 tons according to Ibrahim. Spinosaurus were actually much heavier.
the trex in jp3 is also adult trex
@@waffeltruffel6199 nope it didn't weight that much the thing you said " According to Ibrahim " yeah he said but did he actually confirmed that it was 12 tons
So everyone jumps on the fact that the Rex is smaller? But no one notices that the spinosaurus is only 13 meters long in Jurassic park 3?.
There are bigger therapods but don't tell that to a trex jp fan. They lose it
Well screw them if they want to be sore about it, there are other dinos that are bigger and meaner than a trex
@Rancor has a Posse what about the giganasaurus?
I never gave two shits about that T rex fight. I always just thought "this is the movie with the spino." And I appreciated the fact that JP3 was willing to try something new.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, I never want to see a rematch. All it will do is add more fuel to the fire of the most ridiculous controversy in the entire fandom. If it happens in Dominion it will feel so petty and just leave the whole thing bitter.
There can't be a rematch because the T-Rex is dead.
When the T Rex encounters the Spino they should just pass each other
Ye same I don’t rlly want to see another rematch , the reason why spino won in jp3 is just that he was more heavily built.that’s it idk why ppl have to be so mad about.
@@giovannigiovanni.7220 it probably won’t because the Giga probably is gonna be the big bad in JW3
Honestly I'm tired of rexy. She should be killed by a triceratops in dominion or die naturally.
I’m amazed that there is still so much behind the scenes knowledge not many of us were aware of from the Original Trilogy! This is why I love coming to binge watch Klayton’s videos! :)
I wouldn't compare a Rex with Vader, one is a CHARACTER, the other is an ANIMAL.
Not all the Rexes are gonna win always
Finally, someone who thinks like me
When you said 20 years ago I flinched lol I remember seeing that film in theaters as a kid. Wow I’m old 🤣
8:56 someone who finally talks objectively! Well said Klayton, I mean seems pretty obvious. And I love both animals, both in real and Jp universe. Cmon we're now adult and go over this story easily 😃
I just rewatched Jurassic Park 3 the other day.
I never understood the theory of the subadult T.rex, if you watch the movie it’s obvious that the Rex was a full grown adult.
What I do believe however is that this particular Rex has no correlation with the family we see in TLW, I do not believe it was the Buck from 1997, being that the color was completely different, and it surely wasn’t the infant, in 4 years he wouldn’t be anywhere near an adult or subadult.
If they are redesigning the spinosaurus in Dominion they should add a crocodile tail to the Spinosaurus
And crocodile legs^^, because a Spinosaurus never had these T-Rex-like hind legs.
And a more crocodile shaped face!
Honestly the backlash wouldn't have been so bad if the fight was the climax of the film and not right when they get on the f*cking Island!!! The first movie and especially the Lost World had build up to a T-Rex's reveal lots of it but this movie it's so quick like BOOM there are on the island BOOM spinosaurus BOOM t-rex BOOM fight BOOM Rex dead cut to Alan Grant punching Mr Kirby in the face. Not to mention no one even talks about it! I mean Alan Grant talks about what dinosaur was chasing them like "oh it was the spinosaurus Ingen made something that wasn't on the list" but he never brings it up again. He's never like "Oh sh*t this thing just took out a motherf*king T-Rex maybe we should be concerned about that" but nope. It's just "oh it's a Spinosaurus something Ingen wasn't supposed to make okay next scene"......like what???!!!!! I think the most we get about the fight is that Eric mentioned that T-Rex piss attracts the spinosaurus so it's hinting that he actually hunts Rex's. But other than that no one even mentions it or talks about it! Like you could edit that whole scene out of the movie and nothing would really change.
Edit: Sorry this is long. Also if they bring back Spinosaurus it wouldn't be a good idea to have it in the film just to kill it off. Spinosaurus has amassed a lot of fans over the years and I don't think you want to piss them off it will just start the fight all over again. I mean that would literally start ww3 and if you think I'm kidding look at 2020 would it really shock you at this point?
I liked that the Spino beat the T Rex. 1. It had the arms so it grabbing and twisting the t Rex's neck was believable. 2. After 2 movies of the t Rex being the "hero" of the films (which is just stupid to be honest) it was nice to see something new. 3. The fight was supposed to be longer, but the spino animatronic literally ripped the head off the t Rex one. Supposedly it was squirting hydraulic fluid like blood. I'd love to see the footage of that if any still exists. And since we have people complaining that the t Rex always comes out on top in these movies (5/6 of them now) maybe switching it up for once wasn't as bad as people seem to think.
actually, real spinosaurus can never beat T.rex in 1vs1 fight(especially in ground)
But we need to remember that JP3 movie is so old and in that period, people thought spinosaurus is the biggest and strongest one.(well spino's length is the longest)
I don't believe there was a backlash against Spinosaurus winning or else it would have been a disliked dinosaur with low popularity. It's actually the opposite seeing as how Spinosaurus is rivaling Tyrannosaurus in terms of popularity in the fandom. Your highest viewed videos are regarding the Spinosaurus.
Dude, people were absolutely upset about Spinosaurus winning the fight, and it is what made it one of the most hated dinosaurs ever. Come on, don't be in this much denial.
I think the problem people really had with it was the huge amount of marketing put into it as well. If you go back and watch almost all the trailers have at least one shot of t rex and spino preparing to go at it. And this took up a large amount of the marketing. So to suddenly go from that to a less than 5 minute encounter that kills off the icon of the franchise not only insulted fans on the other two films it insulted casual people that paid for this hugely marketed aspect.
Why are people angry over T-Rex losing??!?
They didn't want spino to replace Jurassic parks mascot
THE SIXTH MAN 2 STARRING LEBRON JAMES & KOBE BRYANT right Rex is our true mascot not Spino.
i honestly never cared for the rex , i just liked watching the blood and gore
Why is it such a big deal, though? Who cares about mascots? Micheal Crichton never tried to have a “mascot dinosaur”
It's like start wars disney made rey made op cuz she's a woman or the original ben ten getting clapped easily by the newer been ten that's out
(Jeep turns a corner chasing a Spinosaurus and finds the Spinosaurus flanked by another Spinosaurus and several large carnivores)
Spinosaurus: Everybody gangsta 'round here!
Jeep Driver: Rough neighbourhood....
ACU in the back seat: Must go faster, must go faster....
If Spinosaurus doesn't come back for Dominion, I will never forgive the directors
The giga is coming
@@donotpluh I'd love to see that too!
@@therealronniej look at bestinslots latest video
@@donotpluh wow I'm stoked!
Hope the giga kills rexy
Spinosaurus: you picked the wrong house fool 2:41
I just see them as having to change it because the sizing is very off. I very much could see them doing that, especially because it was so quick
5:15 ->Best way to explain it. Imagine you’re a Star Wars fan.. and then they came out with “the last Jedi”. That’s how it felt.
No... that's if a *human* character appearing in the second half of the film, came in and killed the T Rex/Rexy with a pistol off screen and we next see the rex dead with other humans praising the hunter for their "Greatness".
@@zendzend5107 LOL exactly.
Speaking from the heart here: Honestly, people just need to get over the spino killing the t-rex. In my opinion, the moment when the spino killed the rex is powerful. Why? Because it subverted our expectations. What did you expect them to do with the third film? Things had to change, and in my opinion it was done beautifully. Do I wish Jurassic Park 3 had been done better? Yes. Regardless, I'm still a fan of the film ,flaws and all. True fans understand that each film needs to be watched with a different state of mind. Jurassic Park 3 is a badass film, and I love it.
They could have easily just said the Rex was Elderly and maybe close to death anyway, like it would have the same effect without changing the size.
Like it was mentioned the carcass it was eating seemed to be dead for a while, maybe it resorted to scavenging due to the fact it's no longer in its prime and would have trouble hunting
JP3, still causing controversy in the JP community after nearly 20 years. Lol
that´s the dream thou, amirite? :D
I never understood why people care so much, the T rex is just a dinosaur not the main character and whether its the spino or rex doesnt actually change the story at all. Ok one spino beat one rex whats the issue
I’d love to see a more naturally correct spino come Jw Dominion. Anyone else?
My wife just watched jp3 for the first time last night and was highly disappointed with the fight scene. She was upset the trex lost. I saw this film in cinemas back on 01 and yeah still don't agree with them putting the spineosauras over
Don't kid us Klay. If that fight happens in Dominion you're gonna shit your pants with all the rest of us😂
Why? Let the rex die to Giga
@@TheWererapter92 no not Rexy
@@TheWererapter92 YES, or better yet make the Trex die to a Gallimimus
@@theminecraft2516 like that'll happen, what the rex takes a swipe at the galli and misses, tripping and breaking an ankle in the process, that's basically a death sentence
Some part of me wondered if the smaller Rex was actually the kid from Jurassic park 2
I don't know why people want the T Rex and Spinosaurus to have a rematch. Actually, I'm okay with them not having a rematch.
There can't be a rematch, the T-Rex is dead.
@@giovannigiovanni.7220 With a new T Rex my guy
Better yet, why not have rex and spino fight something else and give the rex the finishing blow to whatever they were fighting, ending in the iconic rex roar
@@DillyBar-fg1mh Then it's not a rematch.
Yeah I agree with you here Klayton as it is common for directors and etc. to make excuses to try to quell backlash from fans
All of Jurassic park 3’s criticisms have nothing to do with the trex losing imo, if anything the spinosaurus was the best thing about the movie and it was better than he was the main dinosaur instead of the trex to show how powerful and deadly the spino was, plus the spinosaurus is one of the coolest dinosaurs that has ever existed and this is coming from a trex fan. The only criticisms I have with the spinosaurus are that the animatronic and cgi effects haven’t aged well.
The bird cage, boat sequence and raptor chase cgi effects surpass the original Jurassic Park.
The execution needs a lot of improvement
Morning klayton, I just woke up and when I seen you uploaded I clicked.
I really enjoy your content keep it up :]