T-Rex vs Spinosaurus Fight Simulation | 3D Face-Off In-Depth Analysis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ค. 2024
- This is perhaps the most debated dino match up ever. Will the T-Rex successfully defend its crown as the true apex predator of all time? Or will the Spinosaurus come in and change things? This video will cover all offensive aspects of these two dinosaurs and enter the data into a combat simulator where both of these creatures will battle it out in a fight to the death! Make sure to watch till the end to find out who will be the victor.
Spino Poster - gojicenter.creator-spring.com...
T-Rex Poster - gojicenter.creator-spring.com...
Credits:
Jack Blackburn - Special thanks to one of our most helpful Patrons for helping us source tons of info on the Spino and Rex, and helping us debunk some Spino Myths.
Charles Nye - Follow his page @thepaintpaddock on Instagram. Special thanks for his help with finding certain metrics and info on both T-Rex and Spino as well as Paleo art to help us build these 3D characters.
KingKong19100 -
/ kingkong19100
Big thanks for helping us with animating, and sourcing all of our 3D turntable animations and high resolution artwork.
MI5TR - / @mi5tr641
Rigging and Animation Supervisor
Steve Reeve - GojiCenter's legendary voice over artist.
Joe Dezmo - Creative Director of GojiCenter, storyboarding, UI Editing.
Chapters
00:00 - Intro
00:48 - Corporal Builds
3:13 - Locomotion
5:36 - Stability
6:25 - Intelligence
8:15 - Bite Effectiveness
10:52 - Auxiliary Weapons
12:55 - Weaknesses
14:09 - Recap
14:42 - The fight
17:20 - The Aftermath
#Trexvsspinosaurus - บันเทิง
To support this channel and help fund more 3d animated fights please consider checking out our Merch Store or supporting us through Patreon.com/gojicenter! or you can at the very least subscribe and leave a like!
Sorry for the Chaos that happened in live chat Goji Center.
I only have one word for the 3d models: Magnificent.
We can't to expect more 3d models you have in store for us so support the channel guys
I'm excited
@@alistairdiren5790 What happened?
I love how much you've grown from just doing fight showcasing to now having actual simulations I just absolutely love it
I hope they don't permanently give up on the "Which fighter wins in which category?" thing though.
Omg ty so much
Awesome fight!👍🏼 I hope you guys do more of these, especially with the Kaiju.
My favorite video
@@dangelojones2224 i like the kaiju but perfer it like this
As a spino fan I'm happy with this result, because most channels will just outright insult the spinosaurus and say it would be destroyed by the trex anywhere but here, you have respect and love for both the dinosaurs and took a look at their strengths and weakness fairly, and the winner was based off of the terrane the fight was taking place. In conclusion fantastic video, from my perspective you showed respect to, both dinosaurs and their fanbases
It all depends on the environment. If the battle is near the water or in a swampy area, the Spino would drown the T-rex. However, on land the T-rex just has too strong of a bite to contend with.
@@Historian474 exactly!!
Yeah in most cases we spinosaurus fans know that spino was not built to hunt large dinos and mostly lived its whole life eating fish and have more than 50% of it losing to trex but then some Trex fans are just disrespectful as fuck and says" trex will destroy spinosaurus ass. Trex will eat spinosaurus for dinner. " Its just obnoxious as fvck
The Spinosaurus is my favorite dino (very interesting and unique) but it isn't made to fight a dinosaur its size head-on.
That's like making a gharial fight a crocodile, the crocodile obviously wins because its way of feeding involves brawling with big prey and other crocs, while gharials fish.
@@gigachad6885 I mostly agree but it came in conflict with carcharodontosaurus which is of relative size. Not saying they fought all the time just that I had conflict with other animals besides itself in a similar weight class.
It’s a shame this didn’t get more views, the effort and studying out into this video is insane and literally on a documentaries level. Please don’t be discouraged by the performance on this video Goji Centre your fans love it so make more.
Yeah, it just wasn't that.. accurate. If the spino was actually 10 tons, its legs would have been thicker, the bones on its legs were actually quite thin and the muscles were quite lacking. There was no research to back up the "research" that the spino were 10tons. The video was also clearly biased on spino. The T-Rex, was actually 10-11tons. You can do your own research if you don't believe.
Also a spinos max weight was 6-7 tons. While T-Rex is 8-10
@@jlordbundang I’m well aware of the research it’s just most palaeontology is speculation. Also randomly changes.
@@jlordbundang no spinosaurus 7-8 tons and t.rex 10 tons
@@jlordbundang no bro spino could have reached 10 tones
This is by far one of the coolest T.rex vs. Spinosaurus battle videos i've seen . I love how both dinosaurs where both presented as strong and almost equal . I've learned a lot from this too .
Yes but yo mama 😮
@@ThePunisher-si8exbro what?
@@Naked_grandma some internet beef son, nothing to see here
To me, one of the most underrated details of the fight simulation is how the first few minutes consist of the two dinosaurs trying to intimidate each other into retreating. They don't immediately charge at each other to rip out each other's throats, because, well, even massive theropod dinosaurs have strong self-preservation instincts! They size each other up first, like every large animal does. The T-Rex roars and tries to make itself as tall as possible, while the Spino rears up like a bear and flashes its super cool claws!
Overall, this fight simulation is EASILY the most convincing and realistic dinosaur confrontation I've ever seen -- the Jurassic World final battle is entertaining to me, but it's obviously unrealistic, and I'll take gritty realism over flashy spectacle any day. Goji Center, you've done awesome work making videos that are both entertaining and SHOCKINGLY educational!
Actually Jurassic World Dominion had some realism in it's Giganotosaurus vs Tyrannosaurus Rex fights because even in the end they sized each other up and tried to scare one another off
@@DevoteeofThunor I agree that was probably the most realistic outcome in a dinosaur movie. one dinosaur walks away the other is grateful for it. no such thing as being a coward in the animal kingdom as any injury to either large size predator could result in a double death in the long run.
Yes, I agree with this comment and the replies, I can’t really think of another battle in the Jurassic Universe where two apex predators had a non-lethal fight and then went their separate ways.
Why do you think that the Jurassic World fight scene is worse than this?
Trex: roars
Spino: escapes into the water cause he eats fish and doesn't care about the trex.
I like how to you clarify that animals don't always fight to the death. I always feel like there's a question that's never really explored in analysis. Would they even fight if they met? Probably not most of time.
A spino and T-rex despite both being large theropods, occupied different niches, hunted different prey. They would have no need to fight for territory or food like hyenas and lions or wolves and bears do. A desperate Trex probably would hunt a spino from time to time, and the spino might want to protect its river from a rex looking to drink, but other than that they probably would ignore each other and mind their own business.
Next there's the risk-reward factor. Could Trex kill a spino or vice-versa? yes, but would it worth it? You can't just heal up from a clawed out eye, broken jaw, or fractured tail and any of these injuries would hamper either one from hunting in the future. Neither creature is going to go down quietly and both would probably know it.
The most realistic fight is spino putting rex where he belongs, nobody dies. Just a short realistic animal turf war
Rex: *drinking*
Spino: Dude get off my lawn
Rex: Or what?
Spino: *turns to its side to look bigger* don't underestimate me
Rex: ...fine, you win this round, weird croc
well considering the rex hunted trikes and maybe ankylosaur
a hungry rex would try to hunt a spino albeit a LAST OPTION cuz a rex would know a spino is another predator and its size as well
Yep, fights would be rare, especially serious ones, but they could still take place on occasion.
@@markangelogarcia2584 yeah, but only clueless Juvie rexes would try to hunt an ankylosaur. Because after they fight one
*they never forget it*
This was a marvelous, well-researched, and well-executed battle scenario! It’s amazing how far the structural research on these two dinosaurs has come since JP3, with Spinosaurus in particular. This presentation looks so realistic and adapted to its environment. I have always loved the battle series on this channel, and I am overwhelmed with excitement at the prospect of seeing more simulated battles in the future, particularly on a titanic scale with the Kaiju/Titans!
well everyone that sais that Rex would destroy Spino in a second is not true. It would hold up quite a bit.
@@giggsi1006 maybe but trex would win
@@pierre-samuelroux9364 in the end it would
I gotta say, for your very first fully animated episode of Battle Face-off, it’s not bad at all! Whoever animated this deserves praise. There was a bit of janky movements and the models sometimes looked off with their limbs in some moments, but otherwise it felt like a real confrontation between two animals.
The analysis was enjoyable, spot on, and delivered good trivia and was presented very well. I like both of these dinosaurs, and it’s nice to see both being portrayed well here.
I do hope you’ll be able to make more animated episodes. I’ll consider being a Patron as well to help fund more animated episodes.
Great episode overall, Goji Center!
It will be cool to see their improvements on 3d animating.
Cool comment
Do you mean Patreon? It's because your spelling is wrong
@@Pandope616 it's not wrong because you become a patron on patreon
agreed, the dinos seemed a bit floaty but otherwise this was phenomenal! Loved all the details they gave each model to reflect all the most up to date info.
without a doubt, this battle needed an analysis
Yeah
It didn't. Its complete mismatch
Lmao this is satire rite
@@DocAllo it wasn't a mismatch it is 2 of most true matches ever because goji center wasn't biased at all so I can see this happening in real life if they ever meet.
@@stellercrystaldragon7457 hahaha. Ur both biased here
What I love most about this is that it has the respect and realistic outlook to admit that the fight could go either way, instead of outright determining that only one would win 100% of the time. Very well done!
which is stupid. a fully grown t rex would always destroy a spinosaurus. it was simply way more muscular and heavy and had an insanely powerful bite theres just no way a spinosaurus would beat it if both were aware and fully grown
@@bearzdlc2172 They both have there own advantages, for example, Spino has strong arms and more agile, better biting grip and more stuff.
Absolutely astonishing work, good job to the team !
I like how this fight takes into consideration that either rex or spino could have a strong chance of winning depending on where the fight is happening (for example the spinosaurus having the upper hand in a aquatic environment) as well as clarifying that a fight to the death wouldn't be a common occurrence
Yep that was actually a cool detail they added. In real life most encounters/ face offs between predators rarely result in death because they're aware of what is in danger. Whether it be their life immediately or their ability to hunt which would lead to their death later.
Not just in water, but near it as well. A swamp, floodplain, tropical wetland, etc. would give the Spino a major advantage
@@compatriot852 how?
@@thanos7942 a rex is pure muscle its almost like trying to waddle with jeans on in ankle or knee deep water. so swamps, tropical wetlands have lots of ankle/knee deep water with will slow a rex trying to run at full speed.
@@abimaelreyes7134 Most dinosaurs including Rex were very capable in water and could even swim really well.
T.rex vs Spinosaurus is a classic prehistoric match-up! It's equivalent to the Tiger vs Lion debate in the Paleo community! Jurassic Park sure stirred things up in JP3 😅 I just wish we could've seen the Spinosaurus in Jurassic World Dominion 🦖 👍
Ikr lol honestly
Ikr
More like tiger vs gator
LoL T Rex vs Spinosaurus is more likely Tiger vs gharial.
T Rex vs Giganotosaurus fight is similar to Tiger vs Lion where T Rex is a tiger & Giga a lion
@@zebgiganotosaurus3704 I don't think you understand what he meant
As a long time t rex fan, this is the best video that has ever been made about what would happen in a fight to the death between these two. Hats off to you
Loved how it was in 3D, it made it so immersive and we were able to see properly what the bones that you talk about looked like.
Yes but yo mama more immersive. Imho 😮
I like it how you informed people that in real life confrontations both animals would still be alive after the battle since they are animals instead of blood thirsty monsters. I also love it how you researched and did well with the confrontation and what the animals had on their side, unlike bright side who doesn't know any better.
Thank you 🙏
Nature doesn't always work that way. Wolves make a point to kill coyotes and often very gruesome. Sometimes when bears confront each other it can end in fatalities. One of the leading causes of mortality for Yellowstone grizzlies are other grizzlies. Another example during the rut bull elk, moose, and buck deer will kill rivals. Self preservation is an instinct but sometimes other instincts overrule it.
@@jamess7576 i mean, yeah, i get what you're saying, but it isn't any better to portray dinosaurs as animals that would fight to the death constantly. but yeah, if they literally pull up on their territory, then it's probably a fight to the death.
This is just like a show I watched as a kid called Animal Face Off. What a blast from the past.
Yeah, I had nostalgia watching this video
Damn, you made me remember my favorite show from my childhood
My thoughts exactly! I used to love that show.
That was one of my favorite shows as a kid.
From what I've read T-Rex's were quite aggressive by nature. Mark's on their skulls suggest they fought with each other quite a bit and some even suggest they had cannibalistic tendencies. I doubt it would have squared up like in this vid, I think it would have just charged strait in knowing it would cause serious damage due to its bite force.
No a trex isn't smart that i thinks " hey my bite force is strong let me charge lol" no predatort animal wants to ever risk unnecessary dmg. It would most likely win but it would still be extremely cautious fighting another predator of similar size.
@@hanabal898 most predators avoid each other if they're equally matched unless there's a shortage of food and both are really hungry. They also tend to know their strengths and weaknesses well, which is essential for their survival.
@@williambuchanan77 exactly my point so the trex definitely wouldn't yolo rush another large predator like that.
@@hanabal898 the problem is we're debating a creature we're never going to encounter and it's psychology is really difficult to guess, but I do know they were quite aggressive towards each other.
@@williambuchanan77 they lived on different continents. And the behavior when it comes to predators can just be matched with predators from todays time, that really doesn't change the only predators that risk injury at times are huge pride or pack animals like lions or hyenas.
17:19 this animation is everything I need dinosaur movie fights to have, you done exactly what I wanted Gojicenter, good job to you and your group!
Quick note . Studying paleontology myself at the moment , you mentioned that a direct injury to the sail of a spinosaurus wouldn't be fatal and I am so glad you included that . There are suggestions that like modern day camels , the sail was a water storage for the spinosaurus, so while a direct injury wouldn't immediately kill the spinosaurus, it would hurt it . Great research by you guys
"Great research" while t.rex doesnt have lips and the fourth toes are show wrong
Spinosaurus also swims instead of wading
Ye but for a first time making a 3d simulation, it's pretty good . You can't know everything
Spino goes on all fours exactly like an indominus rex by breaking its knuckles
Camels store fat in their hump not water.
Loved this video,absolutely unbiased and accurate,and I like how you cleared up the myth of spinosaurus sail being vulnerable
Still though, the Spino fans (including me) do be sobbing right now
@@prehistoricfanboy101 why tho? They did said that spinosaurus wins on water,and majority of the earth was always covered in water .
@@rayyanahsan2628 Crap. That reply got dated in only several minutes xd
Didn't expect to see a familiar face.
@@prehistoricfanboy101 I like Spinosaurus much more than T.Rex, but I was still happy with this outcome, it didn’t make it seem like Spinosaurus would be a easy kill at all.
It's a bit off topic but I have watched your videos for some time and watched this channel grow and the effort put into each video is something worth acknowledging. Amazing job and as always a great video! Well done!!
I just discovered Goji Center and I love it. The guy sounds like he's narrated the coolest '90s toy commercial or an ESPN recap but he's saying everything in such a logical scientific way with studies to back it up
It's incredibly nice to have an unbias take on the 2 animals while debunking old myths and shutting up fan boys on each side. The work shown here was amazing truly, from the voice over to the animation and grahpics. Thank You Goji Center for finally putting an accurate simulation out there!
The fact is that Trex DESTROYS Spino. No fan buying just facts
@@thewidowskiss7675 *fan buying*
@@diamond_dude1063 nope, Trex literally destroys the Spino in everything minus being a better swimmer but Trex was able to defend itself against a Mosasaurus when swimming so a Spino is nothing. No “fan buying” just facts.
@@thewidowskiss7675 to be fair, t rex kinda stomps unless their underwater, if not i dont see any chances of spino winning
The spino and rex werent accurate at all, 10T spino more like 7.8T (biggest) rex was actually 11G at biggest.
Ya proved me wrong on what to expect. I originally said this battle has been done to death, but you guys made it interesting. That was cool man. Glad to see new studies mixed in and not to add the way either one could win in their element.
You are right.
But this battle has been done to the death
By the T.Rex in the video, that is
Oh btw, animations were pretty great! It's good to see you improving all the time! Keep up with the good job!
I adore this! No better words, really.
I feel like I'm watching Jurassic fight club again, everything is so well researched and explained, then shown. I hope you all keep going 🎉❤
Kiddies thinking this would be an easy win for the T.rex are going to be in for a surprise. The biggest part for this video I enjoy so much, along the magnificent hard work on the animation, voicing, and graphics, is to help the GojiCenter team debunk many myths, which to me makes these fun Vs videos a perfect and underused medium to educate others about these lesser known details. Some people I think get very emotional comparing the T.rex to the other gigantic theropods, defensive of the dinosaur they grew up with. But nature wasn't about making one animal better than the other. It's about natural selection formulating life to the conditions presented to them in that time and place. And when one wants to compare such life in a way like this, respecting one animal isn't dissing another. It's a common misconception, especially with how emotional some get, liking any big theropod but the T.rex means you hate ol'Tyrant. Untrue for me, much as I like to point out the power of others.
To anyone who gets really upset when the possibility of a T.rex losing in a fight with another animal, which sounds more impressive? A confrontation that the largest predator a whole continent has ever seen was going to win by default? Or that same mighty beast being put into situation where it has the chance to win a dangerous battle with a worthy foe who's dangerous enough to go toe-to-toe with the Tyrant King?
Tyrannosaurus rex was an awesome animal, but it wasn't off in a league of its own with all others as weak chaff below it. And that to me makes the times it pulls a win in these comparisons all the more impressive. A combination of skill, build, weaponry, and defense to allow a well earned victory. Hail to the Tyrant King, and Hail to the Spined Pharaoh.
-Jack Blackburn, Paleontological educator for Museum of Dinosaurs and Ancient Cultures
Hey Jack! Amazing analysis! Could not have said it better myself haha. Glad to have worked on a project that you also worked on yourself!
Eh doesn't matter Ankylosaurus can kill both
@@deinocheirusthebestduck5447 Technically any Dino can kill another, if it’s give the right circumstances.
Peoples do what you describe only because every single "bigger than t.rex" theropod always was pushed forward exactly as a league on its own with the "chaff" t.rex below it.
It isn't the Rex fans that started this ridiculous pee-pee size contest, they simply responded in tune at worst and at best they simply wanted to put forward the fact that the rex was no chaff and the "insert new megatheropod" wasnt a league of its own as it was mostly done.
Nobody in its rigth mind would think any megatheropod would steamroll any other contender, and that includes rex fans in their rigth mind.
As for rex fanboys...they aren't doing anything different than any Spino or Charcharodontopsaurid fanboy...with the plus that even while still fanboys they aren't among the one who threw the first stone.
Also as scientifically "sad" as the phenomenon can be, it is a *fact* that Jurassic Park has a VERY heavy influence in fueling fanboyism, and that particular franchise has so far *always* had the rex act like the chaff you describe.
I consider paleontology and JP as two completely separated entities with only loose ties, but that being said it is still a shame that cinematographically speaking the icon of the franchise is always the jobber for other megatheropods up until the very end of the Hexalogy.
It would be wrong even if it was a full fantasy movie about dragons.
@@stringedmouse7695 very true... well said
I was hoping for a battle analysis of Giganotosaurus vs Spinosaurus, this should still be fun though
Spino lived in an area with a relative of giganotosaurus.
@@rexyjp1237 True, although they probably would rarely fight since the spino and carcharodontosaurus had different niches.
@@MistikCo would have small confrontation from time to time tho when the Charca goes to the river to drink where a Spinosaurus might have made it it's home.
That's exactly what i was about to write. Also Indominus Rex vs one of these two should be done.
Did anyone know Giganotosaurus brain size was of a banana?
This is the very best video about dinos i've ever seen. You realy had a truly remarkable investigation about every single aspects in both dinos. Well done sir.
I'm literally crying because of this wonderful educated fight demonstration . 🥺 You really do a awesome job and I love your videos! ❤️
This was… extremely fun to watch! I applaud you guys for using fossil evidence and accurate reconstructions in this battle, instead of using JP’s designs. Great work!
Is jp's design really that bad?
@@randombadchannel8700 Not at all. It’s iconic in it’s own right, but if you wanted to conduct a fight analysis like this one, using a decades-old movie isn’t really the smartest idea
@@seabass1428 Sorry i realized now that you meant Jurassic Park 🤦i think you were originaly refering to the One that was published on nature
@@randombadchannel8700 no
Just innacurate
The only advantage spino really has is its claws and its mouth made for grabbing fish which has good grip but not strong enough to break the Rex's neck JP3 style.
Good grip for fish, as for claws, well assuming the scientific accurate spino is tall enough to even reach and slash its claws without tipping over at the T-rex, then I guess its aight.
And if the trex can land a single blow to the spinos back he's dead
Thinking about the structure in spinosaurus teeth it can make the T. rex bleed by biting his neck and slashing his torso, neck, body
@@V1ncenz010 doubt
@@dom9300 my theory is that it sink a bit deep when grappling the rex. I belive it would stand up to attack the rex since it’s claws are made for killing. Different for the therizino
have to say, love the scientifically accurate (at least currently) models. Specially the spinosaurus. I think people are way past the monster like look from JP3 (Which I will admit, is sick, but only for a movie) but some people take the design way too far creatively, some even going as far as making the spinosaurus look like a Giant duck.
JP3 was Jack Horner the nonces anti-Trex fantasy that even he admitted he was wrong about and the “Spino” in it was nothing like a spino.
You guys should try doing more of these in the future. This video alone is making the dino loving fanatic in me screaming in excitement. And i would love to see more of these in the future.
I love how the simulation makes us know that the t-Rex noticed the danger of the spino’s arm and it was the highest priority to take out the arm before anything else
Thanks so much to everybody involved on this project! Again this was a huge honor to work on and it turned out fantastic!
Get this man the likes he deserves for the work he contributed to this video.
Thank you for contributing to this masterpiece
Wait did u do the animation
Oh wait you animated it?
@@statictv6284 I think he is I’m like 90 % sure
Actually the spino weights 7 tons not 10 tons
Great video!! I really enjoy it :) Thanks to all who made it!!
Outside of some minor jank, this looked amazing. I especially loved the sheer attention to scientific accuracy(aside from the roaring, which even than sounded much more like bellows and other more reptilian sounds compared to say, JP) that was put into this, especially the lack of shrink-wrapping and pronated wrists. The little disclaimer before the fight began that such fights would rarely end in death is such a nice touch that shows that these people actually care about the subjects being shown and understand that they are actual animals, not just movie monsters.
Sorry to break it to you but roaring could happen because no one has ever seen these animals alive and we only know what we can deduce from fossils etc which absolutely doesn't make scientists right automatically who claim dinosaurs couldn't roar
@@DevoteeofThunor it's still un realistic that they have mammalian sounds
@@DevoteeofThunor Roaring require a larynx, which we've seen absolutely no evidence for in theropod dinosaurs.
@@c.d.rstudios4691 maybe so but again to make definitive claims requires definitive proof
@@matthewadams1674 you maybe right but claims always require proof not scientific guessing
This was great. I was expecting the classic "spino can't even move on land and is just free food for rex" but here it had the advantage until it got overwhelmed by the rex problem solving. Great video!
I would be curious to find out if this would still be the same outcome since we don't fully know the cognitive abilities of the Spino, we don't know how intelligent or how well it's brain was developed for problem solving or thinking skills and such. We do know it was capable of such things, especially when it can tell it has an advantage in the water against other creatures or when it comes to ranged fights for example, but also taking into account that it has incredible timing and precision since it usually hunts fish, something that takes huge amounts of skill to be able to pull off if it does it regularly. So i would be very curious to know if the outcome could alter if it turns out that the Spino was a lot more intelligent then what was originally thought and or researched.
This is without mentioned the other factors that we aren't well aware of when it comes to the Spino since it's still one of the most unknown creatures yet when it comes to it's information overall, they are still trying to figure out this creature every year and it only gets more impressive and stronger.
@@raionshishi8290 Probably the same outcome I mean we could get more intelligent but Rex still has the edge in bite force and weight
@@darkeatermidir6452 But in his video he makes it very clear that Spinosaurus's bone density gives it a ton extra weight on Tyrannosaurus, meaning it's actually heavier than the T-Rex! But yeah, Tyrannosaurus has the superior bite force, that's not disputed at all!
By far one of the best videos you've ever done! I have an idea for you! Spinosaurus vs Giganotosaurus!
This is actually very accurate and not some random jp kids saying spino can kill tyrannosaurus
The CGI fired at this film is frying my eyes with glory. Such a delight to see the astonishing models and animations to have such effort put in to. Also this is the most accurate the outcome would be especially the burning of the obsolete myths! Great job Goji centre
Keeping in mind that Spinosaurus did live along side the Charcharodontosaurus (I know they're different animals with different features even if they have other similarities, but Spinosaurus would have to be decent enough at fighting off would-be attackers to be successful for so long).
All in all, excellent video...
Not just carcharodontosaurus,but many other abelisaurids and huge 10m crocs (not talking about sarco)
Spino probably didn’t compete with carchar often if even at all. Both served totally different niches which is why they managed to coexist
The two animals would have met very rarely, because Spino lived in the water, and hunted different prey. In a real life scenario, the Spino wouldn't have bothered with the Charcharodontosaurus, and it certainly wouldn't have fought it off from a carcass for example.
@@liampleurodon8831 Theropods fighting wouldn’t be common as well. They would probably threaten each other and leaving afterwards
@@CAPTAiNC I know
I love how you guys took time and effort out of your days to make this wonderful video. The animations are high quality too. I love it! Also y’all should do Giganotosaurus vs T. rex or Giganotosaurus vs Spinosaurus to see who would really win those fights.
What a awesome comparison of two of the most amazing predators of our planet.I root for the toughness off the T Rex,but the spino can’t be denied,especially with those claws. I think it could be a draw at any fight ,but we will never know. Well done!
In addition, the crocodile type snout full of teeth would have to end up being felt at some point. For 3 encounters, at least one of these is won by a Spinosaur . (?)
Yes we do.Paleontologists say rex wins
This fight was a lot closer than I expected
This was a very fair, well researched, and quite detailed video. Nice to see it without any bias.
You and your crew should be proud for a job well done.
It had 1 flaw. The trex not being able to run is outdated and was proven wrong by paleontologist David Hone.
@@lactoseandintolerant7601 yes but I’m pretty sure most ppl don’t know about that I’ve never heard that name until today so my guess is most ppl don’t know about this
The spinosaurus arm's are kinda too long
@@deinocheirusthebestduck5447 they aren’t though spinosaurus had massive arms not tryin to be a Spino Stan but I’m just sayin
@@V3vo-.- yeah but still
you know after watching the Monster Face Off Trailer I would consider this a Monster Face Off Episode.. More like Episode 0. Keep on the GOOD WORK GOJI! 😎👍🏽
Hugely educational and highly recommended. Awesome video!!!! Go Rex!
I love the concept. Especially after seeing these two in Jurassic Park. Everyone likes to think who would win, just like pairing a tiger verse a lion. But in reality, these two would never fight. Aside from the obvious time discrepancy. Dinosaurs weren't blood thirsty monsters that attack everything in sight. They ate when they needed to eat, and fought when they needed to fight. Most studies conclude that trexs were scavengers, and usually roamed in pairs or even small packs. And although territory fighting is a thing among animals, most tend to fight among themselves rather than other animals so long as those animals don't encroach on their resources. Spinos on the other hand ate mostly fish, but they would hunt prey on land from time to time. They were most likely solitary creatures that only ever came together to mate. So Trexs already have an advantage of outnumbering in most cases. However in a one on one situation? They'd most likely just scurry away from one another. There would be no point in killing each other for food as the risk/reward would be far too great when there are many other food sources nearby. Hunters don't usually hunt other hunters. They hunt weaker, easy prey. At the slightest sight of injury, flight instinct would kick in for self preservation and they'd skedaddle. So unless a one shot miracle blow hit at the start, or one was starving and not getting this meal meant death, neither would die from the encounter and life would go on.
That is true but we're doing this fight for fun!
True. I compare it to a Hippo vs a rhino for the most part.
Both creatures are large and know how dangerous they can be so most confrontations end with the rhino running away to a safer area to avoid confrontation from a territorial Hippo
A healed hadrosaur tail with a T rex tooth embedded in it demonstrated the T rex was not purely a scavenger. Although carrion would have been an easy meal, the T rex, like carnivores today, probably targeted the most vulnerable among prey-the sick, injured, young, and unaware. Hadrosaurs probably lived in herds for protection. One probably strayed too far and paid the price, though not with its life until it was fossilized.
@Pastry Yes, edmontosaurus was a hadrosaur, so fits with the theory t rex hunted similar prey. Triceratops was like a very large and dangerous cow. Huge size, strength, and horns were a concern and healthy adults likely had no natural predators. T rex targeted the sick, injured, or young triceratops or those caught by surprise. Triceratops preferred a more solitary lifestyle, only getting together to raise young or mate. Bone beds of triceratops herds were not found. So an individual would be easy to sneak up on but if it was aware of you and kept its horns toward you, then it was not worth fighting.
Wrong...most if not all studies conclude that T. Rex was indeed NOT an obligate scavenger. What would it scavenge? Animals that died of disease or old age, how often would that have to happen to sustain an animal as large and as abundant as Tyrannosaurus Rex.
There's also no evidence of other large predators coexisting with the Rex and obligate scavengers (such as vultures today) are highly dependent on other predators to take down prey. This animal more than likely functioned like any other predator...going for the young, the old, the sick and the weak.
Watching the live chat sure was fun. Great analysis! Even though Spino's weight estimates have lowered to 5-7 tons due to its thinner frame, this was probably the most accurate depiction of Tyrannosaurus vs. Spinosaurus to date! Props to you, GojiCenter!
Spinosaurus is currently 7.1 tons & T rex 10.5 tons
The weight were high estimates (accounting for density and other factors) which is why we added a note underneath with more conservative estimates, Thank you for the kind words and yes the chat was really entertaining!
Indeed. It has been confirmed that it's bone density has been researched more in depth along side Baryonyx that it was able to be more semi aquatic then what we've previously thought. That would mean it's weight would also increase tremendously.
Usually semi or fully aquatic animals tend to get heavier than fully terrestrial animals.
Thank you for putting this new study in this video 👍🏽
@@GojiCenter there really aren't any high estimates now. The largest spinosaurus aegypticaus tho has fragmentary remains has fixed weight of 6.8t, maybe borderline to 7.1t. On the other hand, the largest trex specimen which is far more complete has weight of 10.6t, maybe even 11t if we are going off by paleop reconstruction.
Plus spinosaurus was shown in the video striking alot with its arms, but in reality it wont effectively reach the trex with them. They weren't that big and had natural position streamlined with the body making them unable to be swang effectively.
IMO rex will win in both land and water with little difficulty, but ur vid was still better than other spino vs rex vids.
Hey, I was one of the advisors on this. It seems that most Spinosaurus estimates actually low balled the weight. We do know from one study that the neotype more or less had the same proportions as a fully grown adult at the age it died at, meaning it can be used with mathematical scaling to figure out a rough approximation of how big the adults were. Using square cubed law, 8 to 10 tons was quite feasible, with some higher estimates also being produced but we decided to scale those back for the sake of being conservative. One of the reasons Tyrannosaurus looks so big in regards to the skeleton that is it's got a very wide chest, but you should also remember a large portion of that chest is going to be made up of a lot of air chambers because it is closely related to birds.
A fight that’s been done based on your analysis, great work, imagine this with a kajui face off
Bro you editing is flawless
My money is on Kong...
My bet's on anguirus.
My money is on Ghidorah.
What the heck are you doing here dangerville
This is a Dino video not a kaiju video?
My bets on hedorah
I would love to see more of these in the future, like T-Rex vs Giga or Spino vs Giga. Great work, loved the in depth analysis and including recent studies. My friends and I had a debate recently and came up with the same conclusions for terrestrial and aquatic combat between the two.
T-Rex vs Giga is already a thing you
Wow. I learned a lot.....this totally answered all of my comparison questions. Thanks!
Just saying, Deadliest Warrior - Dino Edition is badass. Keep up the good work !
*There isn't a more iconic dinosaur than the T Rex, even people who don't know the differences between herbivore and carnivore know all about the Tyrannosaurus Rex. And when you see her up close, feel her gaze... you understand why the T Rex was the ruler of the Cretaceous period - Claire Dearing, Jurassic World Evolution series*
*Okay, even I have to admit that this next dinosaur is impressive. The Spinosaurus is perhaps the largest carnivores. Of course, I'll never get close enough to one to see for myself - Cabot Finch, Jurassic World Evolution series*
I know the Jurassic franchise isn't accurate, but I love how the creators of this film making the T Rex and Spinosaurus was a *SAVAGE* dinosaurs in my Jurassic Franchise list
Nah man Trex is The most Imfamous dinosaur
@ᴇᴅʏ_🐻 those would be runner ups, I would also throw in Stegosaurus, Ankylosaurus, Allosaurus even Spinosaurus as well
But T. Rex is definitely number 1 in terms of popularity and pop culture influence
aww c'mon clair she had a decent glaze, look at sue isn't her eyes beautiful, it is the eye of an animal not a tyrant, it just hunts, feels the same way other we feels but with 2x or 4x scopes and a nose of a dog
@ᴇᴅʏ_🐻 Even though it's not a dinosaur Plesiosaurus is also well known
Wow, excellent analysis, Goji!
I especially love how you debunked most of the myths surrounding these ancient world wonders. Maybe for another fight simulation, do megalodon vs Livyatan!
Funnily enough these two co-existed, so it probably did happen during the Miocene period!
Imo livyatan but if u think meg wins then i respect it
A very even fight, honestly could go either way I think
I would think the megalodon would win,it wasn’t as smart but definitely had the stronger bite force and was most likely faster since it doesn’t have solid bones and and be more agile
even fight but goes to livyatan because of muscularity
This is my fav channel for vs at the moment damn I love how well you guys do data
Another wonderful analysis. My one nitpick is that it devoted a couple minutes to the scenario that the Trex won, but gave less than 30 seconds to show the Spino’s scenario. I would have preferred to see both play out in full.
Top 20 biggest megatheropods in August 2023 ( 90% accurate).
1. Giganotosaurus- 10.5 tonnes 🥇🏆
2. Tyrannosaurus Rex- 10.45 tonnes🥈
3. Deinocheirus- 8.41 tonnes🥉
4. Mapusaurus- 8.2 tonnes🏅
5. Spinosaurus- 7.84 tonnes🎖️
6. Sauroniops- 7.57 tonnes
7. Carcharodontosaurus- 7.49 tonnes
8. Tyrannotitan- 7.47 tonnes
9. Bahariasaurus- 7.14 tonnes
10. Saurophaganax- 6.74 tonnes
11. Megalosaurus ingens- 6.32 tonnes
12. Zhuchengtyrannus- 5.75 tonnes
13. Megalosauridae indet- 5.73 tonnes
14. Meraxes Gigas- 5.70 tonnes
15. Acrocanthosaurus- 5.70 tonnes
16. Torvosaurus- 5.51 tonnes
17. Therizinosaurus- 5.50 tonnes
18. Suchomimus- 5.40 tonnes
19. Prodeinodon- 5.40 tonnes
20. Tarbosaurus- 5.39 tonnes
@@SheshaZilla cool 👍
@@SheshaZilla2023 are you ok rex was heavier than giganotosaurus
@@SheshaZilla, the Rex was bigger than the Giga, the biggest carnivore dinosaur in fact, size is measured in mass and weight, the T-rex is bigger, it's massive, yes, even more than what you put and the Giga isn't that heavy at all
@@SheshaZillatrex is bigger than giga
An interesting fight to see would be JWD Giganotosaurus vs JP3 Spino. Both are immensely strong and have killed a Rex in under 30 seconds, would be cool to analyze who'd win in a fight between the two.
Thank you GojiCenter for bringing this fight to life.
The giga didn’t kill the rex but it was a trex killer
@@chili2663 in the prologue
I feel like a fight between the JWD Giga and the JP3 Spino should’ve happened in the final fight scene in JWD, the Theri shouldn’t have been in the final fight at all, and have the fight itself last at least 3 minutes, and to have both of them deal a decent amount of damage to each other, but to have the Giga get the upper hand on the Spino on the latter half of the battle, and knocking out the Spino without actually killing it, and then Rexy should’ve killed the Giga while it was trying to regain its energy after getting into that fight with the Spino, of course before the Giga and Spino fought, it would basically be the same fight between Rexy and the Giga in the actual movie where the Giga knocked out Rexy in that first fight. And anyways, After Rexy finishes off the Giga, Spino should get back up, but looking injured, Rexy and Spino both lock eyes, but decide the fight isn’t worth it, and Spino looks at Rexy as if to thank Rexy for killing the Giga that almost killed him, and Spino decides to walk away.
Trevorrow stated spino is stronger so giga loses.
@@lactoseandintolerant7601 He never stated anything as fact. He just said as of the moment the spino appears to be stronger as it's known as the "rex killer". The giga didn't kill Rexy but he beat rexy much easier and quicker than the spino did against a much smaller and weaker rex. Rexy would steamroll that jp3 rex
It’s great to see you guys finally doing battle simulations instead of the usual 2D animation style. This was pretty awesome to see both theropods fight in a more scientifically accurate way, that hopefully doesn’t spark any heated comments between T. rex and Spino fans…
I would love to see a discussion/vs video in detail comparing the JP t-rex versus the real life accurate t-rex. Full on size comparisons, jaw width, skull size, arm size and position, speed, strength, weight- everything. All the Jp raptors should get the same treatment too like with how their arms were basically clawed wings instead of prongnated hands. Please make this happen- and love this video so much with the lengths it went to to present us with an actual fight and put so much arguments to rest.
Thanks for clearing up this discussion for many people.
I hope in future we will see more prehistoric animals battle in your channel , thank u for this 😊
That’s the only reason i watch them😂😂 the dino vids are fire🔥
@@GUM356 facts
@@GUM356 same pinch 😁
@@GUM356 I love all their videos.
They already made a Trike vs. Anky video.
Spinosaurus JP 3 be like:WTF!!!!is that the real version of me, why does my reality version look very cursed???
Bruh so true 😂😂😂😂😂
Life is unfair and the truth always hurts
Jp3 spino: wtf why is my tail like that?
What's goin on intelligence?
By the way sometimes life really sucks.
This is what I wanted to see, a fair and incredible fight, as well as detailed, it's like seeing Raiden and Armstrong face each other, the fight of these two kings is incredible.
Incredible analysis!
This is exactly what a modern animal/dinosaur face off documentary should look like.🙂👌🏾👍🏾
Watch Prehistoric Planet. It's not just about fights though. The CGI is absolutely unreal
@@sayansarkarz5414 I wish I could, but Apple TV cost too much.
@@miimemester123 I watch it for free bro😜. Using torrents
@@sayansarkarz5414 Torrents?
I GOT A WHOLE ALARM READY FOR TOMORROW FOR THIS
Oh wow this was awesome! Glad your starting to do some more dinosaur content nobody loves dinosaurs or The Jurassic park series more than me!
Not gonna lie I’m a Rex fan. And this is my first video I’ve seen of yours. I love this. Subbed
This is the best combat simulation ever! With an actual 3d sim of a scenario, what's bettter than that now?!
Interestingly enough Spinosaurus had other large theropods as it's contemporaries such as Carcharodontosaurus and Bahariasaurus.
It's always fascinating to imagine multiple big predators coexisting with each other and thanks to occupying different niches, competition as well as conflict between them would've been rare.
To be honest, big hunters living in the same habitat isn't that interesting.
The probability of they interacting its even worse than 10%
I wnat carcha vs spino
@@silvertiger1538 a carcha overkills a spino, theres even fossil proof that carcha's know that spinosaurus weakness was his spine
@@elcrakcultraporxchara3260 since charcha is my fav dino Tq. but I know that carcha woul win just wanna see how woul the fight look like
If I eat burgers, and you eat hot dogs, why would I fight you for a hot dog place when I have a completely working burger place
This is your best battle video.
Best goji centre video change my mind
This gives me mad “Animal Face Off” vibes and I love it.
Love how the environment can really change the outcome of each fight.
Thank u for making an actual true fight that's correct
I'm very impressed on how well and professional you've handled this fight. Most people would say that the T-Rex would absolutely destroy the Spinosaurus. I think this is pretty accurate that both dinos can win in their own advantageous habitat(Rexxy on land and Spino on water). But personally, I think one of them would runaway and the other would just let it be than go for the kill especially if their both injured.
That's because factually a T-rex would destroy it. Even in the water the T-rex was capable (Prehistoric Planet) since it spent time island hopping and had to be.
@@nuke2099 *pteranodon noise
@@philipjeffrey2926 the hell ptera in this??
@@pierre-samuelroux9364 what?
@@philipjeffrey2926you say petranodon noises when we talk about rex..
This video is exactly what Jurassic Fight Club should’ve been.
What it could’ve been
Finally, an accurate fair fight to end this debate. Amazing video and artwork 👍🏻
Keep up the good work
Finally you do this, it's so iconic
Yeah, that's about what I expected.
I was a bit worried this was gonna be deadliest warrior with animals, but a few minutes in your talking about anatomy reassured me otherwise, and you didn't end up disappointing!
Good job!
The animation is pretty cool for its first time, I've seen so many 3d-animations of other dinosaurs that just looked goofy and wobly, it just looks like jelly dinos.
I love your work Goji Center, keep at it, I would love to see 3D renditions of kaiju's like Gigan and Gamera.
This so cool and shows how everyone can succeed in the right situation
Those final fights were thrilling
This video is extremely right! This is how I believe it would go! One thing I saw was that the T. rex didn’t do anything to fight back in the water and just accepted its defeat.
No hate but what do you want it to do spino is a water Hunter
@@mmaandstuff7406 If he tried to bite, he could have injured the spinosaurus, having time to retreat
@@kharnivore4042 Yeah I guess but t rex would have trubble turning and mowing in water which the spino has no problem with doing spinosaurus could also scratch and bite rex from under the water
alternate title: two lizards with anger issues fight each other
That's basically 90% of every kaiju film in existence 😆
The literal only advantages I can see with our current knowledge of Tyrannosaurus Rex is the spinosaurus would be larger, but the rex would be VASTLY more powerful and more agile given its heritage. It would also be more intelligent again based upon its heritage. Spinosaurus most likely really didn't face off with carcharodontosaurus often due to having completely different niches in the ecosystem. They may have coexisted, but they didn't have to compete for food or water. And as a matter of fact, Tyrannosaurus is now known to be even larger and more powerful than even the mighty carnosaurs spinosaurus lived alongside. Spino fans will hate me, but the fact of the matter is, Tyrannosaurus Rex is the most dangerous land based predator of all time.
this is why I like gojicenter they make things as fair as possible and not just goes like "T-rex will win anywhere because it is the king".
These new CGI 3D models are awesome and game changing for the channel, I can't wait to see how their models improve in fluency.
Great job Goji on making the most up to date battle between these two
This video was incredible, I've watched it 3 times in the past 3 or so days. The animation was great, the analysis was satisfying, the music was great in the fight, and the ending analysis was great to hear especially that end statement.
Yeah can we please have another 3d battle, this is really cool and realistic
Love how they got more views than subscribers😂 loved the vid tho, really made me feel better after watching jp3❤