Over The Rainbow outtake
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 เม.ย. 2009
- outtake from The Wizard of Oz in which Dorothy is locked in the Wicked Witch's castle.
YTube won't let me change the license in the settings, so I am specifying it here in plaintext...this work is under a CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 (Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported) license
See: creativecommons.org/licenses/...
OR...if it suits your needs as a individual/NGO, I also authorize it under the following:
Peer-Production License (p2pfoundation.net/Peer_Product...) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![Judy Garland - Over The Rainbow - Command Performance - 1943 [BEST QUALITY!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Yq7_ec0JAFU/mqdefault.jpg)
In fact, it was said to have made the whole cast AND crew break down in tears.
It's possible, but these were professionals, and would have carried on with retakes.
She knee Hollywood had no soul. Judy was real.
I would have broken down into tear to when ever I watch the wizard of oz at the end of the movie I cry as well the only movie I cry to is the wizard of oz just hearing her cry
Nah they probably just hit her
@@kyleelonergan4474 Wrong.
Oh God, I wanna give her a hug and tell her it's all gonna be okay.
Who doesn't? :(
It is heartbreaking!
Oh god why did she have to go so soon but yet this world didn't deserve her
She's just acting.
They say Margaret Hamilton was her closest friend on the set. I think even the Wicked Witch may have been moved to tears watching this.
Judy got along with everybody, actually. She was a very gregarious young lady.
@@MaskedMan66 why do i always see you replying on wizard of oz videos?
@@catlover4891 I dunno; just lucky, I guess. ;-)
@@MaskedMan66 maybe :), but do you just really like wizard of oz?
@@catlover4891 Oz in general; I've read all 40 books and written articles on them (which I've collected into a book I hope to get published), and I've seen most movie versions of Oz and been in the stage version of the MGM musical as the Cowardly Lion. I'm also a fan of Judy Garland and nearly everyone else in the film.
you can imagine her thinking, daddy, please come back, i miss you. to make those tears come :( So sad to hear little Judy crying like that
Her daddy was three years gone by then, and while I don't doubt she still missed him terribly, we can't be sure that thinking of him was her motivation for her performance. Far more likely that she was just a dang good actress.
Fuck. I know I have a heart, because it's breaking.
Even at 17, she was too astounding an actress to be believed. Had this been included in the final cut, I think to this very day we would all be so terrified and upset by what you can hear even in this a straight-to-camera vocal performance as to feel the need to jump straight into (or through) the screen and rescue her ourselves. Mind-boggling, given the conditions of filming, as has been pointed out. And then "take 3"? Good Lord ... they wanted MORE? Inimitable.
She was 16, but yes.
She could have done that all day; she was a brilliant performer who loved to perform.
Oh my gosh, if they kept this in the movie, it would have made the whole thing so much sadder.
It's in the stage version of the musical.
'possibly why they didn't...
What's sadder is that she was abused by the workers of this film.🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭
@@Kennadiejadexoxo No, she was not. Stop spreading this kak.
@@Kennadiejadexoxo No, she wasn't. In the first place, as the lead performer, the workers had zero authority over her. But they also had no reason to dislike her.
When she's says I'm frightened I genuinely believe her! She was remarkable Judy!
In showbiz, she was what you call a "triple threat": that is, she was equally brilliant at singing, dancing, and acting.
@@MaskedMan66 I work in the theatre so I know. She was a fantastic artist.
@@1993MN I'm in theater too; as a matter of fact, I just got news of auditions for, of all things, "Wizard!"
It’s because she was! She was being abused on set. Look it up.
@@2nd-place yes they were ABUSING her😢😭😭🥺🥺
Judy just had such an air of vulnerability about her, I don't think she ever felt loved or wanted, if only she knew how much she meant to her fans. R.I.P. Judy an amazing lady...
Everybody on the movie loved her, and she loved them.
R.A.S.
Judy knew how much her fans adored her. When you walk out on stage and your fans are standing and screaming and applauding so hard their hands burning, I think she got the message. When your audience doesn't want you to stop, you might get that message too. Judy wasn't stupid, she was extremely intelligent. The audience always let's you know. At least they always let Judy know.
Terry Smith Depression can make you believe that everyone hates you even when you’re a lovely person. I hope she still knew her fans loved her despite all the crap she was putting up with mentally.
I think she might just know now
@@Baniiize It was nothing to do with depression; Judy was a brilliant actress, and she was acting sad.
Wow sums it up allright. I assumed it was missing her father, but whatever caused those heart-wrenching tears, she amazingly remained on pitch..which breaks my heart even more..all that innate talent.
She'd lost her father three years previous, but might have called on that grief to fuel her tears. Then again, she was just that brilliant a natural actress; one of those gifted few who can cry on cue.
I remember a good eight years ago, I was diagnosed with depression...I would watch Wizard of Oz to cheer me up...but watching how they would've had the reprise of Over The Rainbow made me shed tears unceasingly...and it still does today... :'(
Makes you want to take her and give her a big hug and comfort her.
This is so hard to hear even though she was acting. You do just want to hug her. I am not surprised if she made the rest of the cast and crew cry.
She was the only member of the cast on set at the time.
@@MaskedMan66 maybe they saw the scene they film with Judy
@@josephcalrow2586 I doubt the actors watched the rushes; they were usually filming.
Venting raw emotion isn’t “acting”. One can tell Judy is revealing a profound emotional experience in the moment. Acting an emotional response requires the ability to feel the emotion and convey it in a controlled way, contained within the framework of what a director requires for a particular scene. In this short clip Judy is evidently straying from what the director wanted; after it he is heard saying “take three”. Judy was a phenomenal performer but at times she succumbed to her emotions and it would just be too extreme. Audiences require that actors have a modicum of self-control when it comes to performing, otherwise it can make for uncomfortable viewing. In your comment you start off by saying this clip was “..so hard to hear..”, which is probably why the director didn’t use it in the final cut of the film.
poor girl, I just want to hug her.
THAT's heart wrenching!!!! The Wizard of Oz is THE best movie EVER!!!! I have always and will always love this...It's my favorite movie EVER!!!
Mine too. :-)
This is really her crying. 💜😪 Bless her heart. I want to hug her.
Some performers can do that.
this just makes me want to cry....her voice was absolutely beautiful
Judy was a beauty and a great actress
what a talent...BLESS HER HEART...
Wow, that just blew me away! What a talent Judy was.
Oh my God! This is so emotionally amazing! Just incredible that she could sing and cry like that! Imagine- if they had left this in- how we'd all be cry babies at this point in the movie!
This was a beautiful scene. It supports the fact that when she returns in Kansas, she realizes that that's where she truly belongs. Maybe that place that she's been chasing, "somewhere over the rainbow", isn't all she hoped it would be.
This was during the scene where she was locked up, right? How can she sound great as she sings, yet cry at the same time? I'm her age, and I can't do that! That girl was talented.
She was a showbiz pro since toddlerhood. She had a natural gift; Jack Haley once said that she was "born to brilliance."
We are all her age, and it has always been like this throughout the ages_ I am Twenty-One years old now_ but I'm sure that I will be seventeen forever in my heart, 4 years ago to me seems like a century right now.
And she thought she couldn't act!!! ❤️
When did she think that?
I couldn't listen to the whole thing without tearing up. Just amazing.
But it showed the raw power she had in this scene that would make almost anyone cry. And I agree with the guy with the earlier comment that this scene should stay in the movie.
oh my gosh. how sad, and beautiful! that girl was a genius.
It's never been said one way or the other, but I strongly suspect that she was a genuine prodigy. Stories from the "Wizard" set speak of her fellow performers being amazed by just how talented she was, as well as whipsmart. She learned three new words every day and could recite lines and poetry after hearing them once.
I heard a recording of her saying she could read up to 9 pages of script just ONE TIME and remember every word. I’ve read where lots of her co-actors were stunned by her brilliance. In the movie The Harvey Girls, she watched the opening number, which involved at least 60 or 70 singers, dancers, and actors doing that long first number--watched it just ONE time with her double doing her part--and was able to do it in just one take! It was the “Atchison, Topeka, and the Santa Fe” number. She was an incredible genius along with her unbelievable talent.
@@elizabethdacosta5601 Sounds like a prodigy to me! She also liked to learn three new words every day. Ray Bolger was quite blown away by her brilliance.
I had never heard this before!!! That was quite a job she was doing there!Wow!
I'll bet a lot of that was from the grief that she was not allowed to have when her father died... they made her keep working, as if she had no feelings. And her horrible mother immediately got up with the neighbor right after her husband's funeral. Lorna's book talks about this.
Ethel, Judy's mother had apparently been "seeing" this man well before Frank became ill. There was an undercurrent about Frank Gumm being bisexual, if not closeted "Gay." But it was in very bad taste to go out with that man the same day as her husband's funeral.
I would imagine that Judy managed to get her grief out sometime in the three years between her father's death and the production of "Wizard."
@@RayPointerChannel Assuming she did.
I would really have like this moment to be in the film. OK, maybe it was too considered too intense for such a light-hearted movie, but I think this is exactly what the movie needed. A moment of seriousness and bared emotion. It's a perfect contrast to how light and colorful the rest of the movie is, and really gets the point across.
There are several moments of "seriousness and bared emotion."
Oh god, Judy, don't cry!! I can't handle ittttt
Dang... I just got chills all over and teared up from that. It's like 2 minutes, but so incredibly heart-breaking... They definitely should've kept that one!
It is such a shame that Victor Fleming (the director of ''The Wizard of Oz'') and/or Mervin Leroy (the film's producer) mindbogglingly either failed to film the moment in the scene in the Wicked Witch of the West's castle when Judy Garland speaks the alternate lyrics to the song ''Over The Rainbow'' through her tears or deleted it from the final version of the film, because if they had filmed that moment or left it in the film and not deleted it, it would have elevated the film to an even greater level in movie history than the already phenomenal level it currently occupies and that moment in that scene would be regarded as one of the greatest moments in movie history alongside Bogart's ''Louis, I think this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship'' moment at the end of the movie ''Casablanca'' or Gable's ''Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn'' moment at the end of the movie ''Gone With The Wind''.
There were a lot of scenes discarded, many from the first two weeks of shooting under the direction of Richard Thorpe before he was taken off the film. It is possible that this may have been one of those scenes that was discarded. Also, there were sequences filmed at the start of production where the costumes were not that good. The concept of Dorothy was over-dressed as the early production stills show. To date, none of the footage from the first two weeks of production has surfaced, also there are numerous audio outtakes, such as this one.
@@RayPointerChannel This would not be one of Thorpe's scenes, because that was when Judy was in a blonde wig.
I don't think the decision was either LeRoy's or Fleming's.
@Sunshiny day in April What who was "afraid" of? Her tears in other parts of the movie were real.
I believe there is a famous line in the film. " Toto I don't think we're in Kansas anymore". Don't know if it's exact, but, it's close.
Wowsercopter...... She can sing and cry at the time !!! Now that's awesome talent right there . Not " acting cry " but REAL crying .
It's the same thing with some gifted individuals, of whom Judy was one.
Incredible! I really wish that they would have kept that in....just...wow.
Jesus that’s hard to listen to, I just about started crying myself.
He knows.
If they had left this in, she would've won that best actress award hands down- I'm not a huge Judy Garland person however much I love the Wizard of Oz but this was just... so raaaaww bravo.
She did win an Academy Award for Wizard, even without this.
R.I.P. Judy Garland 🌈🌪️👠👠🏠
this would have made everyone cry... wow....
0:06 R.I.P Thomas Martins & Eddie Carroll.....(Sad Sighs)
After hearing this, I wanted to comfort her.
That means she did her job! :-)
@TheChrissy473 I have read many bios on her life I am rereading one at the moment. I met Sid Luft in 1997 at the judy festival in Grand Rapids, Minnesota. we had a wonderful time talking over having drinks.Im a huge Garland fan from way back & Im only42 yrs old. I know she is this huge Iconic figure but people forget she was Human being and a classy lady with great gifts but people took advantage of her and shemade some mistakes. Im tired of hearing about her addictions. Judy was a Lady.
This really shows Garland's acting chops even as a very young person. I mean crying and singing like that, done by a bad actress it would have been silly and dumb, but done by Garland it's beautiful, innocent, heartfelt and just really damn good!!
There are a few things in the way Dorothy is written that would have suffered in the hands of a lesser actress-- the last line in the movie, for instance-- but Judy made them real!
When I think about what she went through in the shooting of the movie and the tragic future she will experience. It breaks my heart even more :(
Please don't believe the lies about her being bullied, starved, drugged, forced to smoke, sexually assaulted, raped, or any of that kak. The truth is that she was excited to be working on the movie, and she made friends of the entire cast and crew.
I heard this, several years ago, I thought then - and still do - it was one of the most powerful, deep "performances" (doesn't really seem right to call it that... it's just too real) I'd ever heard.
Unfortunately at that time it would have been too heavy to include. Wasn't until years later when this kind of depth and anything tongue-in-cheek or "lighter" in overall context were acceptable in the same package. The contrast was just to stark, though some of us are more open to it now.
Wow. That was so sad. I teared up listening to this.
Kat
That reprise is so emotional to listen to. Even in her later live performance career, Judy would actually cry while singing the song LIVE in her concerts.
There will never be another versatile entertainer like the great Judy Garland. Always and forever that young girl from Kansas. It always breaks my heart how she was treated in real life by the real life Wicked Witch of the West..... her mother and the entire board at MGM..... they were the ones who got her on those drugs. We lost her too soon. She would have been over 100 today.
Which drugs do you think you mean?
Watch "Meet me in St Louis", then you'll SEE just what an amazing actress she was!
You can see that in any of her movies. :-)
@@MaskedMan66 i see you again! do you have a crush on judy garland or something?
@@catlover4891 Like over a billion people who have seen her movies, most particularly "Wizard," I unabashedly say that I love her very much.
@@MaskedMan66 oh haha, well are you creepy about it? lol.
@@catlover4891 No, up front and perfectly reasonable.
Damn, the scene in the movie has always made me cry, but this... WOW. Judy was amazing, even then.
Even then? She was always amazing, since toddlerhood.
This is so sad, they should have kept it in
Totally loved the clip.
Goosebumps
I really think this would've added a lot to the movie! I wish they would've kept it in...
As much as I admire Shirley Temple (who they first wanted to do The Wizard of Oz) nobody could top Judy's acting and singing, and it's for the best that she was the one they eventually decided on for Dorothy.
Nothing eventual about it; Mervyn LeRoy always intended for Judy to play Dorothy.
Wow...I am in tears listening to this. Oh how I wish it didn't end up on the cutting room floor!
At least we have this. :-)
I actually cried - and I rarely do cry at this sort of thing.
Wow, this is so believable. Amazing acting on Garlands part.
We love Judy Garland for ever she'll be always remembered❤❤😂
Very emotional moment 😢
This made me cry! "I'm frightened!" TT^TT
Aw. That's too sad. I wanna hug her.
im already crying
wow i did not know that was suppose to happen during in the witch's castle scene. awesome
Yup, a reprise of "Over the Rainbow," except that now, she's singing about Kansas.
this was cut simpy because the scene was "to much of a downer , slowed the picture way to much and frightened children even more, the crew was cryig while this was being shot and personally I wish they would have left it in the movie it adds a depth and beauty to the song as ONLY Judy could do and give..
Children would not have been frightened by this, just feeling sad for Dorothy.
She actually DID get a "Special Oscar" for "best Juvenile Performance" that year, If I properly recall, it was presented to her by Walt Disney
Mickey presented her with miniature Oscar. Spencers Tracy was furious that Judy didn't get nominated for best Actress. There were 8 women nominated that year, and he felt that Judy should have been one of them. When he was asked whose place Judy should have taken, he said Greer Garson. Her roll in Goodbye Mr. Chips was a supporting part at best.
It was presented to her by Mickey Rooney.
Poor Bowsan Brownwich Lane Titchfield PO14 4NZ will be very much sadly missed RIP😭😥😢🥺😿
This scene should've been in the movie and that could make the whole audiences, and casts cry, but then they just deleted it
May she rest in peace Judy garland❤❤
Wow, that was raw emotional fortitude.
I knew she was scared! But she was also so brave! This was what I needed to make the connection of pushing thru the fear, when I was a little girl. Why do we hide the truth from children?
She is rocks
1:26 - You can hear the director say "cut" and someone else call the take.
I’m frightened! I’m frightened and yet I’m frightened!
?
I heard well as she was crying and scared; "I'm frightened. I'm frightened, Auntie Em! I'm frightened!"
This is like finding GOLD! I was awe struck when i just heard this and so sad and did u hear the director say cut take 3? I mean she had to re do it again THAT IS WHAT YOU CALL A GENIUS! Too bad they didn't have this footage and added it into the film. as a special feature.
Wow.... That was depressing. 😢
Wow, and that was take 3?? What an actress to have so much emotion even after 2 takes.
She could have done twenty takes and still delivered the goods. In fact, it may have just got more intense.
Isn't she supposed to be crying. Because she's "frightened" in the movie.
WOW !! Amazing !
and why didn't they keep this?
This would have made the film better imo. It shows you how that even though she's doing all this stuff, she is SCARED. She just wants to go home. So how does she cope with that? she's trying to sing to make her self feel better, but in the back of her mind, she's thinking i'm scared. and that eventually comes to the front. the piano friggin melts your heart too doesn't it.
(this is just MY opinion. it's not for sure. lol)
I offered my guess posted above. But here another possibility. There were many other things cut for time. And it might have been felt that the reprise took up too much time, and the decision was to maintain the acting.
This is just Hollywood.
Aww rip u be over that rainhill happy and loved
I just want to say that outtake really scared me when I was 12
Judy Garland was full of brilliance. When I first saw this scene on dvd, it was hard for me to bare because it was too emotionally intense. That’s because when Judy did this life-and-death scene, she conveyed her emotions extremely well.
"Life-and-death?"
Wow! It's great ... but disturbing to listen to.
ouch, my heart just broke :(
@QuantumQuacks The only thing new about Avatar was the filming process and special effects. (Which I'll admit were pretty freaking amazing) The story has been used over and over already though. Pocahontas and Ferngully are two examples. Sure they don't involve aliens, but the premise is the same.
Don't get me wrong, I agree with what your saying, just not about Avatar.
I Think Dorothy Is Scared. She Wants To Go Home And I'm Scared Of Wicked Witch And I Feel Mad For Her Around The Scenes
?
Why did they had to take this part out? Now, I would understand cutting time for the movie, but this would have given Judy the Oscar if this was kept in the movie!
@chrissen1 She was emotional because of the scene she had to do. She was supposed to be acting scared because she was locked in the tower.
@ttmarlene ..Shes crying for the scene where she was locked in the witches castle. She was acting it wasn't for real.
woahhh. this is powerful.
Heartbreaking
I don't want to disagree with you, but I won't say that it's intense or disturbing, Id'e say it's sad. That's why this should'v been in the movie, it would've made it more emotional for viewers.
I think all the deleted scene was deserve to be in the film , so the story will have more emotion and depth to it .
So do I!
I thought the same thing while watching some of Judy's other movies.
In the tv biopic about her, they show Judy recording this song just after hearing about her father's death. I always thought that had to have been made up for dramatic effect, but maybe it wasn't. Does anyone know?
Her father died three years before _The Wizard of Oz_ went into production.
WOW !!!!!
@tokayhigh13 This movie is loved by males & females it's never been a "chick flick" Judy Garland's Career spanned over 4 decades she died @ 47yrs old in 1969. Men,women, str8 &gay loved her work. It's a shame that some man or woman who's str8 has to worry about being labled Gay if they like her. Her music touched hearts & souls. If you like this movie then check out her other films & her 1961 Carnegie Hall double CD which spent 13 weeks at the top of the charts & another 83 weeks on the charts.
@tayqueenb she's havin a party! can't you hear all the people in the background havin fun! of course she's cryin' ! don't you remember the scene with the crystal ball where she said "i'm scared aunty em"? wasn't she crying then? voila! a light comes on! you're right! she is crying! : 0 argh!
Poor Bowsan Brownwich Lane Titchfield PO14 4NZ RIP😭😢😥🥺😿