Ranking Every Red Dead Redemption 2 Ending
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- Buy Red Dead Redemption 2: amzn.to/45wD9Bm
NONE OF THIS FOOTAGE IS MY OWN. From Jaosns Video Game Source and Scerebro PSNU
Today, I am going to rank every Red Dead Redemption 2 ending in a tierlist, starting from the worst endings, and going all the way to the best endings.
This is just my opinion, so put yours in the comments and let's debate! - เกม
Arthur getting shot in the skull is very brutal, but realistic as Micah would want revenge.
micah just walking off doesn't really fit his character
I honestly prefer high honor, go for money. Dutch and Micah being on level ground during their confrontation is much better and feels more personal. The help John ending is also a bit to cinematic and perfect for me, the go back ending feels much more real and brutal. It could have made more sense with some tweaks though.
The fire surrounding micah and arthur is also badass tbh
i just love how badass low honor and going for the money is, it was a bad ending but it was just really intense and i loved it
I actually liked low honor go for money. Getting literally backstabbed by Micah fits chapter 6 I think. Getting shot point blank in the face is just too “straight to the point” & sucks.
For me high honor Arthur going “back for the money” feels more like revenge than him actually wanting the money because as he’s running back to camp he’s beckoning Dutch and Micah
He didn't want the money he was gonna give it to john
I think Go for the Money High Honor is not only my favorite, but also canon. Hear me out.
1. It’s the only ending where we scar Micah’s eye, leaving him a permanent reminder of Arthur’s existence. And if it’s the only ending that does this, i have a feeling it was intentional. It also explains how Sadie snuck up on him in American Venom, since she comes up from his blind spot. Micah’s Aim also was better in 1899, like how he headshotted the guy who killed Sean in Rhodes in an instant, notice in 1907 he suddenly can’t hit John when he’s right in front of him?
2. Going for the money would actually help John more. Who will the pinkertons follow, the one guy getting away from them, or the guy shouting charging straight back to camp? Obvious answer. It’ll keep the pinkertons off John’s back.
3. Also, what was Arthur going to buy with the money at that point, a coffin? It’s too late, he’s gonna die soon anyway. So he might as well throw what little time he has left at keeping the pinkertons off John’s back, and hopefully by some miracle Arthur survives all of this, he can get the money to John and his family, since they actually have lives ahead of them.
4. I also feel like Arthur really gets it through Dutch’s skull that Micah is the rat. That’s just a matter of opinion though, but still, i feel like the way Dutch just doesn’t even say anything, stares at Micah for a bit, and just walks off in shame does it. I also think Micah would’ve cared more about getting the money than killing Arthur. Stabbing him would make it quick, so letting him slowly wither away to TB was preferable.
5. In the Help John endings, i also wonder how the hell does Charles find Arthur’s body on some random cliff far from camp? It makes more sense for him to go to the camp’s aftermath, and find Arthur’s body lying in the middle.
6. It’s also my favorite since the fight seems more realistic to me. Like a guy with TB who was jumped, got punched in the face and thrown off a cliff beats a healthy man hand to hand. To me it made more sense for the fight to be undetermined since Arthur i imagine is way stronger than Micah in a fight, but i refuse to believe a dying man could beat a healthy man in a fist fight. So it’s really just a draw since Dutch interrupts. Also, the camp being on fire in the background is almost like a reflection of the Gang over time. Slowly dying out.
These are my reasons why Go for the Money High Honor is my favorite, and i believe is canon. I can see why people picked Help John first though, i did too. And Arthur dies the way he wanted, on a cliff watching the sunset (although it was really sunrise, but close enough, corpses can’t be choosers).
yep, to anybody whos boutta comment ‘I ain’t readin allat!’ read it, i beg you, its interesting and worth reading unless you have the attention span of a toddler
@@_imnotgoodatnames_ lol exactly, that's the reason TH-cam Shorts and TikTok exist, cause everyone has a goldfish's attention span and can only handle a minute long video, cause apparently hearing in depth explanations of things are "too long." Clearly nobody reads books anymore.
@@_imnotgoodatnames_I ain’t reading allat (I red allat😢)
I find find those reasons pretty good and solid man!! I agree !! Unfortunately l helped John,then fought Micah and then he shot me 😢.I didn't know that the honour system was gonna play a role for the finale. Though Arthur dies no matter what so l guess people prefer to see him die in different scenarios.
Yeah I agree except for the fist fight part. Like what? If Arthur isn’t strong enough to beat Micah hand to hand in your opinion, then it would be a million times easier for Micah to kill him with an actual weapon in hand, especially given how weak Arthur would be (meaning he is both less durable and his reflexes are impacted)
High Honor “Save John” ending seems like the best and most canon ending to me.
overrated boring ending
@@theinfamoustucobet bet bet bet
@@theinfamoustucoyour pfp explains allot lmao
Does “bet bet bet bet” mean u agree or not?
Means I think you are a men liker. Maybe an mw2 word that sounds similar to baguette.@@Gingersnap_Adventures
Love your videos, keep it up
Imo low honor go for money is the best ending, when Arthur is talking to duch he says that Micach is the worst and he is worse than colm and dutch hated him, and when he says "you let him damn us all dutch" you can see dutch's face and the realisation on what he did.
When dutch goes away micah sees that arthur won and as he tries to make dutch stay you can hear his voice is starting to crack and he isnt acting so tough after all
also the music when dutch walks away is epic
Low honour go for the money maybe be the technical worst because it’s least redemption out of all, but it’s by far the best based on purely what happens in it
low honor go for money is best cuz it suits micah’s closure with arthur. you actually get dialogue and also micahs a good character
low honor go back for the money is the best directed, acted and scored scene in the game.
Can you rank every character by evilness
bro that clickbait ass thumbnail almost made me come to your house
I prefer the low honor go back for the money over the low honor help john and high honor go back for money.
Canonically it doesnt make much sense, but the dialogue, acting and score when dutch realises his mistakes is fantastic
To me its
1. High honor help john
2. Low honor go back for money
3. High honor go back for money
4. Low honor help John
I always hate that the low honor go back for the money ending doesn't let you leave a scar on Micah's eye, that makes way more sense with a brutal Arthur but Rockstar really wants you to get your redemption and go high honor.
you can scar him high honor go for money
For me IMO the canon ending should be Arthur putting a scar on Micah's eye, then Micah shooting Arthur in the end.
Nooooo, its better seeing arthur rest in his final moments instead of getting shot
My favorite ending is high honor Arthur go back for the money just simply, because while you smoke, it does get to live another 89-ish years he still loses an eye so in the end, I think in this ending Arthur Kinda, got a little bit of revenge
Imo I feel like going back for the money would only make sense if you’re doing a low honor playthrough. Doing it with high honor just seems way too out of character for Arthur.
Low honour, save john is more realistic imo
arthur getting shot is the best one live by the gun die by the gun
Like swanson said "you lived like a warrior you'll die like a warrior"
I don’t like that this video against my expectations spoiled me for the other endings of rdr2.
Do rdr1 best missions
Wait I’m confused I went back for money but also did American venom?
You always do american venom, its like the final ending.
After doing one of the 4 main endings of course
The guy didnt really explain it clearly
@@Azact yea thanks 🙏
Low Honour, go for the money at 5? L
What would you put at 5?
@@ooooothatsshit158 high honour, go for the money
@@therealmcbong8446why
@@FDav-kl3wwmakes no sense
I finished this masterpiece approximately 1 week ago and at the beginning of the game I was randomly playing I was helping people from time to time I was caring for honor and I was still stucked right below high honor and then I pushed hard to get high honor and finally got it around %50 and I went to the island with high honor and then as soon as I got back to saint denis from the island I got the low honor again and I was literally depressed like arthur through that time Hosea and Lenny died we lost everything etc. and I just could not be good anymore I could not care for honor I accidently hit someone with horse and ofc entire saint denis police was up to kill me and I turned this game into GTA screen of 7 years old kid and then I killed the stranger of stranger mission I killed someone who got trapped and then I got TB and I regret a little bit then I tried to go back to high honor I was right below and I was calm bc I thought Arthur was gonna stay alive until %100 so I can increase my honor and then when I was right below the high honor at around %70 Micah shot me in head… I regret, I am sorry, I was shocked at that moment but still this story of Arthur fits with me he was unlucky like me this is literally the ending fits with me 🤷🏼♂️
Take a shot everytime this guy says canon. You'll be dead by the end of the video
Who let bro cook 🤦♂️
3rd comment
1. High Honour, help john
2. Low honour, go for the money
3. Low honour, help john
4. High honour, go for the money (by far the worst)
what an awful list
1. American Venom
2. High honor, money
3. High honor, John
4. low honor, money
5. Low honor, John
High honor go for the money is easily the worst ending. The final speech is just rushed compared to the others
it’s pretty much just revenge before you die